Part 1: CAGE Analysis Crocs started out with the design of a revolutionary boat shoe in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Since 2002, The Crocs Company has continuously expanded throughout the world with manufacturing plants in the US, Mexico, Italy, and China. With such a large demand worldwide, the Crocs Company needs to reduce costs, and gain economies of scale. Thus, it has considered Uruguay as a candidate for Greenfield Investment. The Crocs company see’s Uruguay as an opportunity to cater to South America, in order to persistently strive towards its primary objective – “To become the global leader in sustainable lifestyle footwear, apparel and accessories whilst ensuring that the four pillars of the Ocean Minded brand – Quality, Authenticity, Responsibility and Community – resonate throughout our company, products, associates and actions.”1 Below is a CAGE Analysis to examine the opportunities and challenges of Uruguay. CAGE Analysis Dimensions Cultural Administrative Geographical Economical National Language: Spanish. -Portuñol (A mixture of Spanish and Portuguese) is spoken on the Brazilian Frontier2 Ethnicity: -European decent 93%, African decent 6%, Indigenous decent 0.4%, Asian Decent 0.4%.3 Religion: -Roman Catholic 66%, Protestant and other Christian 2%, Jewish Currency: Uruguayan Peso (UYU$) 12 Form of Government: Constitutional Republic13 -Uruguay traditionally leads indices of low corruption, good governance and democratic development.14 President: José Mujica (elected) 15 Foreign Affairs: -Joined the UN in 1945 and has been a member Size of Country: Population: 3, 316, 328 as of July 2012. Area: 176, 215 sq. km. Capital: Montevideo, with a population of approximately 1,633,000 people Geographic Landscape: -Southern South America, bordering the South Atlantic Ocean, between Argentina and Brazil 26 -Second Smallest Consumer Income: -The average monthly household income in Uruguay is $1,756 (US) or 34,329.60 Uruguayan Pesos. (Uruguay Economic Summary) Nominal GDP: -$50.91 billion (US) in the year 2011. (World Factbook 2011) Nominal GDP per Capita: -$15,100 (US) in the year 2011. (World Factbook) Country Description 1%, Non-professing or other 31%. 4 Culture: -Uruguayans have a strong sense of national identity and patriotism. -Culture is significantly influenced by the gaucho (cowboy) tradition. 5 -Music in this country is dominated by a love for the tango, which is known as the most passionate Latin dance. 6 -Travelers to Uruguay will find the locals nursing an obsession with football (soccer). -Colourful ponchos, straw hats, and brightly patterned scarves can be seen on Uruguayans strolling about on the street. 7 -People are frank and direct and maintain close distance when speaking 8 -Uruguay is a familyoriented country; children usually live at the parental home into of most of its specialized agencies16 -Member of World Trade Organization since 1995.17 -Member of the Latin American Integration Association (ALADI), a trade association that includes 10 South American countries plus Mexico and Cuba. 18 -Strong political and cultural ties with the countries of Europe and the Americas. - Bilateral relations with Argentina and Brazil have always been of particular importance.19 -Uruguay's international relations also reflect its drive to seek export markets and foreign investment. 20 Investing in Uruguay: -A decree passed in 2007 provides significant incentives to local and foreign investors. Domestic investment and Country in South America (after Suriname)27 -Rio de la Plata (River of Silver) flows into the Atlantic Ocean on the east coast of South America between Uruguay to the North and Argentina to the South. -Terrain consists mainly of plains and low hills, with 84% -Uruguay has no territories or dependencies. 28 Climate: -Located entirely within the same temperate zone, Uruguay has a fairly uniform climate throughout the nation. -The absence of mountains, which act as weather barriers, makes all locations vulnerable to high winds and rapid changes in weather as fronts or storms sweep across the country. -Uruguay’s average GDP Real Growth Rate: 5.7% in 2011 8.9% in 2010 32 Natural Resources: -Arable land, hydropower, minor, minerals, fish Human Resources: -Labour force in 2011 was 1.677 million. -Work force: agriculture --13%, industry--14%, services--73% 33 Infrastructure: -The nation has 8,983 kilometers of roads, almost all paved. -There are plans to build a combination passenger railway and underground subway system for Montevideo and its suburbs. -Uruguay and Argentina are constructing a 35kilometer bridge between Buenos Aires, Argentina, and Colonia, Uruguay. -Uruguay has 2,073 kilometers of railways, and 1,600 kilometers of their late twenties.9 -Well-educated population, strong universities and a significant tradition of both French and English language education.10 Social Class System: -Uruguay is a relatively egalitarian society with a large middle class. -Uruguay's upper class consists of ranchers, businessmen, and politicians. -The middle class includes professionals, white-collar workers, small businessmen, and medium-sized farmers. -The lower class consists of blue-collar workers, and domestic workers. 11 FDI, which have been traditionally low, increased significantly in recent years. 21 -FDI accounts for 5% of Uruguay’s GDP as of 2011 -FDI totaled US$2,528, 000,000 in 2011, and multiplied by eight in the last decade. 22 -There are no restrictions or limitations for foreign investors seeking to set up a local operation with respect to the kind of business form they are allowed to use. 23 Legal System: -Uruguay’s legal system is based on Spanish Civil Law. -Accepts the jurisdiction of the International Court of Justice, which settles legal disputes according to international law. 24 Labour Laws: -The limit of daily hours of work is eight hours -The working hours yearly high temperature is 28°C, with an average yearly low temperature of 6°. 29 Transportation: -Uruguay is served by 10 international airlines -Highways have surpassed railways as the principle means of conveyance of passengers and freight. -Montevideo is the major Uruguayan Port. 30 Time Difference: -Uruguay is 5 hours ahead of Colorado. (HQ) Physical Distance from Headquarters & Factories -US (HQ)à 9723 km -Mexicoà 8040 km -Italyà11,049 km -Chinaà19,442 km31 navigable waterways, which are used to transport small quantities of goods. -Uruguay has 65 airports, 15 of which have paved runways. 34 Industry: -Electronics, chemicals, food and beverages, petroleum and machine products. Major Markets: -Brazil 19.3% -China 14.2% -Argentina 6.8% -Germany 6% Major Suppliers: -Brazil 16.3% -China 15% -Argentina 13.4% -US 9.4%35 Exchange Rate: $1US = $19.62UYU36 Unemployment Rate: -6% in 2011. 37 applied is 48 weekly hours in the industry sector -The weekly rest is 24 hours and taken on Sunday. -Minimum daily wage is approximately $7 (US)25 Relative Importance LOW HIGH HIGH MEDIUM Business Challenges -The language barrier that is Spanish being Uruguay’s official language. Contracts and official documents will be written in Spanish. Spanish will be the first language of prospective employees. -People of Uruguay speak in a direct manner and in close proximity. An indirect US American will communicate very differently than a direct Uruguayan, this can pose challenges. 38 -American management will have to familiarize itself with 6-day workweeks. It may be challenging to keep workers motivated after constantly working long and tedious weeks. -The Spanish Civil law will be foreign to American management; the legislation may contradict that of the Law of the United States. -The susceptibility to high winds can be threatening to the condition of the factory, as well as transportation in and out. -The physical distance between Uruguay and the company’s headquarters in Colorado is not exactly proximate. This distance will be costly and pose challenges of it’s own. -The labour force is not very large, as Uruguay itself has a smaller population than the state of Colorado. -The Industry sector of Uruguay’s economy only makes up 14% of the work force. Crocs will have to attract a work force of which 73% are members of the service sector. -The future subway system connecting Montevideo and surrounding suburbs may encourage prospective employees to find work in the city. Business Opportunities -Crocs would only have to concern themselves with holidays celebrated by Christians. -The nation’s liking for bright, colourful, clothing will attract people (potential employees) to the company. -Uruguay’s significant tradition of English language education would benefit communication for Crocs’ American management. -Extreme emphasis on unity, loyalty, and respect for elderly (working together). -Follows the same form of government as the United States. -Uruguay presents an inviting business environment with low corruption, good governance, and democratic development. -Being a member of the WTO ensures that trade will flow as smoothly, predictably, and freely as possible. 39 -Being a member of ALADI enhances trade among South American countries, in pursuit of establishing a common market. The Uruguayan plant can distribute to numerous South American countries. -Uruguay evidently seeks Foreign Investment, through incentives like tax benefits, free zones and an attractive statutory framework. -Located in an ideal location between Brazil and Argentina, two of Crocs’ major markets. - Uruguay’s mass amounts of untouched land will offer many options pertaining to the location of the manufacturing plant. -Rio de la Plata is a valuable waterway with Buenos Aires just across the estuary from the Montevideo Port. -The presence of international airlines is crucial for enabling international business. Having ten international airlines is opportune. -A time difference of only five hours is certainly not overly problematic. -Crocs can take advantage of Uruguay’s dependable Hydroelectricity. The company can enjoy the fact that it’s environmentally sound as well as an efficient power source for the factory. -The well-established highway system is ideal for commute. -The future bridge linking Argentina and Uruguay will greatly expand trade between the two nations. -Brazil and Argentina are both enormous markets for Crocs, and are two of Uruguay’s top three trading partners. -The construction of the subway system could be advantageous for commuters depending on the location of the factory. -Uruguay and America have both accepted the jurisdiction of the ICJ, which can facilitate any potential legal dispute. -Legal weekly working hours are greater than in North America by 8 hours. -Having strong political and cultural ties with the Americas is promising for the American company. -The cost of labour is significantly less than the current minimum wage implemented the United States. Management Implications -The Crocs Company will be required to send management to Uruguay that is proficient in both the English and Spanish languages. -Management will undeniably be forced to adapt to South American communication protocols. South -With longer workweeks than those of North America, management must prioritize motivating employees in order to assure quality performance. Motivation may come in the form of intrinsic or extrinsic rewards. -With regards to legal -The investment will not be financially burdening, as the American dollar is nearly twenty times stronger than the Uruguayan peso. -The unemployed can apply for manufacturing positions at the factory, as these positions require little experience and training will be applied. -The vast geographic distance between Uruguay and Crocs’ headquarters in Colorado will require frequent virtual communication from both locations. Crocs will assume the costs of transporting management, and commodities between the -The small labour force implies that Crocs must advertise employment opportunities to fill necessary positions in the factory. -To make the investment worthwhile, Crocs should investigate potential franchisees, or carriers in the continent. America’s direct style of communication will initially bewilder Crocs’ North American Management. -The company should market itself to prospective employees with an emphasis on the brand’s use of bright colours. procedures, having an understanding of Spanish Civil Law regulations would be beneficial, however sharing an acceptance of the ICJ will certainly make legal transactions easier. -Uruguay’s membership in various trade organizations such as the WTO and ALADI will benefit commerce for the Crocs Company. two countries. -Looking to be the primary supplier to the Argentinian and Brazilian markets, management will need to arrange logistics among the countries. -Management must decide on a location for the factory that is favourable with regards to land and proximity. 1 Crocs (The United States of America: 2012) Crocs Company 2 Uruguay, (The United States of America: 2009) Every Culture. 3 Uruguay. (Washington, D.C, The United States of America: November 13, 2012) CIA World Factbook. 4 Uruguay. (Washington, D.C, The United States of America: November 13, 2012) CIA World Factbook. 5 Uruguayan Culture. (The United States of America: 2010) Adventure Life. 6 Uruguayan Culture. (The United States of America: 2010) Adventure Life. 7 Uruguay, (The United States of America: 2009) Every Culture. 8 Uruguay, (The United States of America: 2009) Every Culture. 9 Uruguay, (United States of America: 2009) Encyclopedia of the Nations 10 Canada and Uruguay Relations (Canada: October 2, 2012) The Government of Canada. 11 Hudson, Rex A. Uruguay: A Country Study (The United States of America: 1990) 12 The Uruguayan Peso. (The United States of America: November 25, 2012) Universal Currency Converter 13 Uruguay. (Washington, D.C, The United States of America: November 13, 2012) CIA World Factbook. -The construction of the subway system could factor into management’s decision pertaining to the factory’s location. 14 Canada and Uruguay Relations (Canada: October 2, 2012) The Government of Canada. 15 Uruguay. (Washington, D.C, The United States of America: November 13, 2012) CIA World Factbook. 16 Uruguay: Government (The United States of America: 2012) globalEDGE. 17 World Trade Organization (The United States of America: 2012) World Trade Organization. 18 Uruguay: Government (The United States of America: 2012) globalEDGE. 19 Hudson, Rex A. Uruguay: A Country Study (The United States of America: 1990) 20 Uruguay: Government (The United States of America: 2012) globalEDGE. 21 Foreign Direct Investment in Uruguay (Montevideo, Uruguay: April 2012) Uruguay XXI. 22 Foreign Direct Investment in Uruguay (Montevideo, Uruguay: April 2012) Uruguay XXI. 23 Duran Hareau, Andres Strategy. Uruguay: Foreign Investment Protection in Uruguay. 24 Uruguay: Government (The United States of America: 2012) globalEDGE 25 Uruguay Business Guide. (The United States of America: 2012) World Services Group 26 Uruguay. (Washington, D.C, The United States of America: November 13, 2012) CIA World Factbook. 27 Uruguay. (United States of America: November 1, 2005) About.com 28 Uruguay, (United States of America: 2009) Encyclopedia of the Nations. 29 Hudson, Rex A. Uruguay: A Country Study (The United States of America: 1990) 30 Uruguay, (United States of America: 2009) Encyclopedia of the Nations. 31 Google Maps 32 Uruguay. (Washington, D.C, The United States of America: November 13, 2012) CIA World Factbook. 33 Uruguay. (Washington, D.C, The United States of America: November 13, 2012) CIA World Factbook. 34 Uruguay, (United States of America: 2009) Encyclopedia of the Nations. 35 Uruguay. (Washington, D.C, The United States of America: November 13, 2012) CIA World Factbook. 36 The Uruguayan Peso. (The United States of America: November 25, 2012) Universal Currency Converter 37 Uruguay. (Washington, D.C, The United States of America: November 13, 2012) CIA World Factbook. 38 Anamaria. Indirect-Direct Communication Styles. (The United States of America: 2010) Culturally Teaching. 39 World Trade Organization (The United States of America: 2012) World Trade Organization. Final Discussion The Crocs Company has proved successful in globalizing their footwear products over the last decade. Crocs have continuously attracted an array of cultures worldwide based their comfort, style and reasonable price. With such a remarkable expansion into the South American market, Uruguay has proven to be a worthwhile candidate for a Greenfield investment in the continent. Ideally located in the center of Argentina and Brazil, constructing a factory in Uruguay would undoubtedly benefit two of Crocs’ major markets. Currently, South American countries have imported Crocs footwear from the company’s manufacturing plant in Mexico. Uruguay’s prime geographic location, and the nations appealing parameters regarding Foreign Direct Investment suggest that constructing a manufacturing plant within the country is advisable Naturally, Uruguayan culture differs greatly from that of North America. South America possesses a unique culture that has been influenced by a concoction of European, African, North American and Native cultures. Having originally been a colony of Spain, Spanish is the official language of Uruguay. Investing in Uruguay, Crocs would be required to employ management that is fluent in both Spanish and English in order to successfully conduct business in the country. Legal documents in Uruguay will be written in the Spanish language, and it will likely be the first language of prospective employees. Assuring that management is capable of communicating in the Spanish language is essential to effectively investing in Uruguay. American management will also need to adjust to the direct manner in which Uruguayans communicate. The people of South America have typically been known to speak in a direct fashion, as opposed to North Americans who generally communicate indirectly. At first, South Americans may come across as rude or insensitive, however it is important to recognize that this is merely a characteristic of their culture. Another characteristic of South American culture is a collective appreciation for bright colour. The Crocs Company has evidently marketed their products through the use of bright colours, which coincides with South American taste. Having an instinctive liking for bright colours may draw prospective employees to the Crocs Company. Based solely on cultural characteristics, I wouldn’t recommend that Crocs invest in Uruguay as the obstacles are overpowering. Uruguay’s civilization and societal structure stands out among South American countries. As a developing country, Uruguay is achieving remarkable economic growth, which can be attributed to the nation’s foreign relations. An initial appeal of the country is its use of a constitutional government; the same form of government observed in the United States. Having an understanding of a nation’s political system is important when looking to invest in that country, and using a parallel system will attract Crocs’ American management. Legal jurisdictions will also be facilitated favourably through the International Court of Justice. Having accepted this court, both nations will allow for legal disputes to be settled according to international law. Certainly, being a member of several trade organizations makes Uruguay an attractive candidate for Foreign Direct Investment. With organizations like the WTO, and ALADI reducing the cost of trade and regulating the exchange of goods, Uruguay’s membership is advantageous. The Uruguayan government evidently seeks Foreign Investment, and has been successful through the use of incentives like tax benefits. The relatively inexpensive labour in Uruguay is also an attractive feature worth considering. Judging by administrative characteristics alone, I would definitely recommend that Crocs invest. Uruguay’s significant increase of FDI over the past decade can be attributed to the nation’s administration! Situated nearly 10,000 kilometers south of Crocs’ headquarters, Uruguay is conveniently central to two of the company’s major markets. Over the years Argentina and Brazil have embraced Crocs footwear, and have imported the shoes from the company’s Mexican factory. Constructing a manufacturing plant in Uruguay would be ideal as it will significantly reduce freight costs, and save Crocs money in the long run. The nation’s abundant supply of unoccupied land represents the options pertaining to the factory’s location. Rio de la Plata, the estuary located south of Uruguay, will serve as a valuable means of transportation to Argentina. Though the five-hour time difference may hinder communication between Uruguay’s factory and Crocs’ corporate office, the nation’s geographical location is prime. With remarkable technology accessible at minimal costs, communication should never prevent an international business pursuit. Based solely on geographical characteristics, the Crocs Company should invest in Uruguay. Uruguay has experienced steady economic growth over the last decade. This is fascinating seeing as the World Financial Crisis has taken a negative toll on most economies. Uruguay managed to avoid a recession altogether and maintain a positive growth rate. The nation’s recent economic success can greatly be attributed to Foreign Investment, however an astonishing 96% of the population is employed. The Labour Force of Uruguay is quite small, at approximately half of the nation’s population. The level of infrastructure in Uruguay is impressive and improving. With thousands of kilometers between highways, waterways, and railways, there is no shortage of transport in Uruguay. Constructing a bridge connecting Uruguay and Argentina will surely increase direct trade between the countries, and lessen freight costs. The bridge will prove itself valuable, as Argentina is one of Uruguay’s top three trading partners. The American dollar being much stronger than the Uruguayan peso will make operations relatively inexpensive in comparison to those in North America. To make the investment worthwhile, I would encourage the Crocs Company to investigate expansion into alternate retail stores. The economic conditions of Uruguay suggest that Crocs should invest in the country. Having thoroughly weighed the opportunities and challenges posed by the Foreign Direct Investment, I am confident with my recommendation that the Crocs Company invest in Uruguay. Though cultural characteristics make investing seem unfavourable, Greenfield Investments are easier to implement standard culture and procedure. When considering the execution of a Greenfield Investment, I believe that a nation’s administrative and geographical characteristics should be carefully analyzed. Uruguay’s ideal central location, and attractive political environment make the expansion indeed worthwhile. References 1) Uruguay. (Washington, D.C, The United States of America: November 13, 2012) CIA World Factbook. https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/uy.html (November 21, 2012) 2) Uruguayan Culture. (The United States of America: 2010) Adventure Life. http://www.adventure-life.com/articles/Uruguary-culture-565/ (November 20, 2012) 3) Uruguay, (The United States of America: 2009) Every Culture. http://www.everyculture.com/To-Z/Uruguay.html#b (November 20, 2012) 4) Canada and Uruguay Relations (Canada: October 2, 2012) The Government of Canada. http://www.canadainternational.gc.ca/uruguay/bilateral_relations_bilaterales/canada-uruguay.aspx?menu_id=7&view=d (November 21, 2012) 5) Uruguay: Government (The United States of America: 2012) globalEDGE. https://globaledge.msu.edu/Countries/Uruguay/government (November, 19 2012) 6) Hudson, Rex A. Uruguay: A Country Study (The United States of America: 1990) http://countrystudies.us/uruguay/ (November 24, 2012). 7) Foreign Direct Investment in Uruguay (Montevideo, Uruguay: April 2012) Uruguay XXI. http://www.uruguayxxi.gub.uy/wpcontent/uploads/2012/04/FDI-in-Uruguay-April-2012-URUGUAY-XXI-.pdf (November 22, 2012) 8) Duran Hareau, Andres Strategy. Uruguay: Foreign Investment Protection in Uruguay. (October 4, 2007) Mondaq. http://www.mondaq.com/article.asp?articleid=52896 (November 24, 2012) 9) The Uruguayan Peso. (The United States of America: November 25, 2012) Universal Currency Converter. http://www.xe.com/currency/uyu-uruguayan-peso (November 26, 2012) 10) Uruguay Business Guide. (The United States of America: 2012) World Services Group http://www.worldservicesgroup.com/countries.asp?c=uy&country=Uruguay (November 24, 2012) 11) Uruguay. (United States of America: November 1, 2005) About.com. http://www.advertiseonabout.com/about-us/ (November 21, 2012) 12) Uruguay, (United States of America: 2009) Encyclopedia of the Nations. http://www.nationsencyclopedia.com/Americas/Uruguay.html (November 23, 2012) 13) Uruguay Economic Summary. (Montevideo, Uruguay: May 2012) http://photos.state.gov/libraries/uruguay/19452/pdfs/UYEconSummaryMay2012.pdf (November 23, 2012) 14) Anamaria. Indirect-Direct Communication Styles. (The United States of America: 2010) Culturally Teaching. http://culturallyteaching.com/2010/02/17/indirect-direct-communication-styles/ (November 23, 2012) 15) Crocs (The United States of America: 2012) Crocs Company http://company.crocs.com (November 23, 2012) 16) World Trade Organization (The United States of America: 2012) World Trade Organization http://www.wto.org (November 24, 2012)