CAPITAL COST SHARE GUIDE SEPTEMBER 2016 Version 2.0 Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care Copies of this report can be obtained from Health Capital Investment Branch Tel: 416-212-0823 Fax: 416-326-5533 Table of Contents Introduction Capital Cost Share Guide for Hospitals 4 1 8 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 3 3.1 3.2 3.3 4 4.1 4.2 4.3 Capital Cost during Construction Pure Construction Costs Financing Costs during Construction Period – AFP Only Other Turnkey Costs – Project Co. DBFM Only Other – Ancillary Costs Related to Construction – Project Co.DBFM Only Other Transaction Costs during the Construction Period – DBFM Only Hospital Related Project Costs 8 17 18 18 18 19 Ancillary Costs Post Contract Contingency Allowance Furnishings and Equipment Infrastructure Ontario Costs – AFP only 19 27 28 28 Maintenance Costs – AFP Models Only 29 Financing Costs during the Operational Term Lifecycle Costs Other Transaction Costs during the Operational Term General Costs Commissioning Insurance Taxes 29 29 29 30 30 30 31 Appendix 1 33 Appendix 2 34 Appendix 3 35 Introduction Capital Cost Share Guide for Hospitals Hospital Capital Cost Share Policy: In June 2006, the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care announced its policy for revised hospital capital cost sharing. The 2006 policy applies to hospital projects granted approval to award a construction contract on or after April 1, 2006. The key components contained in the 2006 policy are as follows: The ministry will provide 90% funding for eligible construction/capital costs; The ministry will provide 100% funding for eligible planning, design, financing and transaction costs; The ministry will provide 100% funding for eligible new major radiation therapy equipment for hospitals with regional cancer centres; The ministry will provide 100% funding for eligible construction/capital costs for longer-term mental health, and mental health programs transferring from former provincial psychiatric hospitals; The ministry will provide a minor non-depreciable capital equipment allowance; Hospitals are responsible for all other costs associated with new furnishings and equipment and continue to be responsible for replacement equipment. Policies regarding the eligibility of items for ministry capital cost sharing did not change in 2006 and are identified in the Guide. Non-shareable costs are those that are ineligible for ministry capital funding, such as constructing a parking facility or renovating or constructing a gift or coffee shop which are revenue producing. While the eligibility for most cost items is addressed, you may request further clarifications regarding any specific cost from your senior consultant at the Health Capital Investment Branch. Note: Community Health Centres, Community Mental Health and Addictions agencies and long-term care supportive housing projects are eligible up to 100% capital cost sharing and there are some differences in policies for eligibility. Contact the Health Capital Investment Branch for further information. Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 4 How to Use the Guide: This Capital Cost Share Guide has been developed to assist the staff of the ministry’s Health Capital Investment Branch to develop Cost Share Agreements to inform ministry approvals during the planning and design stages of a capital project (particularly at pretender or pre-RFP), and to then assist hospitals to complete the Final Estimate of Cost form based on the results of the bidding process. Refer to Appendix 3 for a list of acronyms. There are four primary sections in the Guide 1. 2. 3. 4. Capital Costs During Construction – encompasses all hard construction costs Hospital Related Project Costs – encompasses all ancillary costs Maintenance Costs – applicable AFP Model projects only General Costs – those costs which apply in more than one section The Guide has been developed to align with both the Cost Share Agreement and Final Estimate of Cost forms. Use the Guide to determine the eligibility of any cost item and then reference the relevant table to determine the rate of ministry cost sharing; 100%, 90%, 0%, or a blended percentage. The following three tables outline the ministry’s cost share rates: Table 1. Hospital Program Type Cost Share Programs/Services Cost Share Eligible – associated with the following program elements: Acute Care 90% Rehabilitation (non-acute) 90% Complex Continuing Care (non-acute) Longer Term Mental Health (LTMH) & Mental Health programs transferring from former provincial psychiatric hospitals LTMH & Acute/Non-Acute Care Ineligible – includes revenue-generating, retail, research and associated costs (e.g. escalation, grossing factor, site development, HST pro rated eligible-ineligible) 90% 100% Blended rate* 0% *The blended rate should be specific to the project and determined using an acceptable utilization-based methodology Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 5 Table 2. 100% Cost Share (e.g. AFP- related costs and planning costs) Component Eligible Cost Share 100% Ineligible 0% Table 3. New Furniture and Equipment (No Replacement F&E) Cost Share Programs/Services Cost Share Eligible – associated with the following elements: Cancer Radiation 100% Chronic Kidney Disease/ End Stage Renal Disease/ Dialysis Equipment Built In (In-Contract) LTMH 0% See Table 1 100% All other 0% Throughout the guide the appropriate table is referenced in the Cost Shareable column. Ancillary Costs: The Guide clarifies those ancillary costs for which percent-driven caps or maximum costs are imposed for ministry cost sharing. These ancillary costs are shareable only to a maximum amount based on a percentage of the total shareable construction costs defined as the sum of hard construction costs (including escalation), construction insurance costs, cash allowances and built-in equipment at Final Estimate of Cost. These costs represent the defined ‘hard construction’ cost throughout the Guide. Percent-driven caps for ancillary costs include: Cost Consultant Functional Programmer Prime Consultant Disbursements Project Management Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) Up to 0.5% 1% 8% for new construction; 10% for renovations and up to 11% for DBFM projects 10% of the Shareable Prime Consultant cost Where the defined construction cost is: < $50M = 3%; $50M-$75M = $1.5M; or > $75M = 2% 6 Post Contract Contingency Allowance: The ministry will share in a maximum post contract contingency allowance for unforeseeable items only of 3% of shareable defined construction costs for a new build or 5% for renovations or a combination of renovations and new construction. Minor Non-Depreciable Equipment Allowance: The ministry will fund a minor non-depreciable capital equipment allowance of 2% of shareable defined construction costs. Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 7 A. Hard Construction Costs – Refer to Table 1 1 Capital Cost during Construction 1.1 Pure Construction Costs A. Hard Construction Costs The ministry cost shares in all eligible construction costs including all material, labour and associated costs such as escalation, grossing factor, site development, and HST. Component Building Element Cost Shareable Table 1 Eligible Areas: Yes Programs & services support areas, infrastructure Yes Shelled space and partial fit-out to base building for revenue generating items/retail Yes Notes Defined as per the approved project scope. Applicable only to small areas related to ineligible items e.g. chapel/ceremonial space, retail, foundation offices etc. Base building includes maintaining the space for life safety and compliance with codes. Shelled space and partial fit-out to base building for insured diagnostic imaging services Yes Applicable only to small areas that are part of a development or redevelopment project. Shelled space and fit-out to base building for insured diagnostic imaging services Yes Applicable only to hospital sites whereby the service has been deemed necessary by an expert steering committee and where a business case substantiates such a request (e.g. PET-CT) Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 8 A. Hard Construction Costs – Refer to Table 1 Component Element Ineligible Areas: Cost Shareable Table 1 No Notes Separately identify the shell and fit up costs, as fit up costs are not eligible for cost share whereas the shell costs are eligible. When the footprint or an entire floor is affected by the ineligible area, the shell and associated gross up are also considered ineligible in addition to the fit up. Abatement Auditorium (non-academic) Chapel/ceremonial space (religious and cultural) Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) No Yes/No No In cases where the abatement of the property is of no future hospital use e.g. asbestos Requires Business Case or rationale to support cost share. Fit-out only. 9 A. Hard Construction Costs – Refer to Table 1 Component Building Element Ineligible Areas: Cost Shareable Table 1 No Claims – Delay Notes A request by a contractor for compensation above the tender amount for delays created by the hospital, labour disruptions, weather, etc. Claims are to be resolved between the hospital and the contractor with the advice of the Prime Consultant. Excessive design No Beyond best practice: over and above what is described in the Generic Output Specifications (GOS) Atria, curtain wall: up charge or premium related to design features beyond best practice. Finishes: Up charge or premium beyond best practice. Foundation offices No Gardens/Landscaping No In excess of approved Functional Program (FP) i.e. Therapeutic Garden within FP scope is eligible. See separate Site Development section. Labour Costs (hospital staff) No When hospital staff positions are utilized during regular working hours and not backfilled. LEED No Not eligible when constructed beyond a level that would achieve LEED Basic certification (certification costs not eligible). Yes The ministry’s 2008 GOS document establishes minimum performance requirements for each potential LEED mandatory Sustainability Measure. Costs related to meeting these minimum performance requirements will be supported by the ministry. Costs related to meet higher performance levels are not supported. Yes DBFM projects are eligible to design to LEED Silver (certification costs not eligible) (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 10 A. Hard Construction Costs – Refer to Table 1 Component Building Design Scope Contingency Element Cost Shareable Table 1 Ineligible Areas: Notes See separate Parking section. Parking Research No Revenue generating/ retail area fit-up No For example: Retail – pharmacy, food areas (excludes hospital sponsored cafeteria), gift shop. Shelled space for future programs/services No May be retroactively cost shared at the time of program approval and fit-out of the shelled space. Yes An allowance which is carried within the cost estimate. This allowance is intended to inform the adequacy of construction costing data through the various stages of the design process, when all items which may impact cost estimates are not identified or known. Design Scope Contingency to be carried in the cost estimates based on the applicable percentage of the defined hard construction cost based on the Class of estimate as follows: Class “D” at 20% (Stages 1 & 2 Early Planning) Class “C” at 15% (Stage 3.1 Schematic Design) Class “B” at 10% (Stage 3.2 Design Development) Class “A” at 5% (Stage 4.1 Pre-tender estimate) Escalation Yes On eligible hard construction costs from time of estimate to anticipated date of construction. Included in Total Project Cost during design and planning stages only. This cost may or may not be fully realized in the bid. Grossing Factor Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) Yes For those projects where an entire floor(s) is own funds the grossing factor needs to be separated out and is non-shareable. 11 B. B. Non-Building Hard Construction Costs – Refer to Table 1 Non-Building Hard Construction Costs Component Communications Element Cost Shareable Table 1 Notes Voice/Data, infrastructure, cabling, computer rooms and closets Yes Conduit and cabling terminating outside of walls and conduit risers. Includes cabling and antennae for wireless communication, racks, and program tie-ins such as nurse call systems. Excludes devices, servers, etc. Decanting / Phasing & Logistics IT Infrastructure Yes Parking Temporary relocation during construction. Decommissioning Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) Includes physical relocation of existing IT infrastructure and connections to data sources using external incremental IT resources. See separate Parking section. Yes If renovations, and/or off site lease/leasehold improvements support the approved project. Yes Eligible costs include those to moth-ball the building, securing it to prevent unauthorized entry, manage risk of fire, etc. No Costs associated with preparing a property for future sale are not eligible for cost sharing. Should there be an exceptional circumstance in which net proceeds from the sale of property are not adequate to cover the cost, a business case can be submitted outlining a decommissioning plan for ministry consideration. 12 B. Non-Building Hard Construction Costs – Refer to Table 1 Component Element Demolition Cost Shareable Table 1 Notes Yes Costs are eligible only if demolition of a building is required to accommodate approved new construction. No Hospitals are expected to fund demolition from the proceeds of the sale of property. Should there be an exceptional circumstance in which net proceeds from the sale of property are not adequate to cover the cost, a business case outlining a disposal plan can be submitted for ministry consideration. If the business case is accepted the costs, determined after deducting the proceeds from the sale of the land, would be shared according to Table 1. Facility Maintenance Costs No Does not form part of the Capital Project cost as it is an operating expense. Refer to Bulletin Parking Above ground new parking structure No On grade parking (surface) No E.g. asphalt, booths, gravel, meters, heaters, etc. Permanent relocation surface parking Yes Replacement of existing parking which has to be permanently relocated, to accommodate or support the eligible construction. Site development below asphalt Yes Work to the asphalt level (below the asphalt) is eligible for cost sharing. The cost consultant should separate out the cost of surfacing the parking area from the Site Development Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 13 B. Non-Building Hard Construction Costs – Refer to Table 1 Component Parking Element Temporary surface parking during eligible construction Cost Shareable Table 1 Yes Notes To support relocation or decanting of parking for eligible construction. Includes: asphalt, lighting, heaters Underground new parking structure No Underground parking facilities/structure to support eligible program/service areas on floors above. Yes Portion of footings and special conditions e.g. dewatering, shoring and temporary shoring during demolition if needed. st 1 floor excavation to support the clinical floors/building. Site Development Gardens – Therapeutic Yes Scope as per approved Functional Program. Gardens – Water features, furnishing, public art No Beyond the scope of the Functional Program. Heliport (new/relocated) Yes New – based on Business Case Relocated – to accommodate the construction project. Landscaping on site Yes To support site plan approval (walkways, ground cover, shade trees around building access, storm water management, etc). No Landscaping to support own funds or in excess of that required for site plan approval e.g. civic squares. On site – Connection to existing services (tie-ins) Yes Includes: roads, water mains, storm and sanitary sewers, storm water ponds, hydro distribution etc. On site – To be transferred post construction No Worked on land owned by the hospital during the project, but knowingly to be transferred to the city / municipality after the project work is complete. Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 14 B. Non-Building Hard Construction Costs – Refer to Table 1 Component Site Development Element Cost Shareable Table 1 Notes Off site – Bringing services to the hospital site No Bringing services to the hospital site is the financial responsibility of the utility provider. E.g. bringing the sewer system to the site is ineligible. Off-site work also includes roadwork, civil work, landscaping, sidewalk, as well as utilities. Parking – Below asphalt See separate Parking section. Remediation Yes Removal of contaminated soil. Road transferred post construction No Road transferred to other party post construction. Yes For eligible areas only. Wayfinding / Signage Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 15 C. Cash Allowances Component Element Cash Allowance(s) Cost Shareable Table 1 Yes Notes Provide list and rationale for each item. For a scope that cannot be defined by a set of contract documents (See Bulletin on Cash Allowances, Change Orders, and Post Contract Contingency Allowance). Amount carried within the tender package for specifically identified purposes (e.g. hardware allowance, asbestos abatement, site conditions, replacing hidden infrastructure exposed during construction, etc.). Not to be used in place of Post Contract Contingency Allowance Abatement – asbestos or mould (renovations/ demolition) D. Yes Can be included in the hard construction cost. Includes the removal of hazardous materials and remediation efforts. Must be for either renovation or demolition of existing building(s) required for eligible projects. Equipment Built In – See Furniture & Equipment Section Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 16 E. Risk Component Risk (Adjustment on Construction Costs) Element Cost Shareable Table 1 Notes Risk Transfer Yes Costs associated with the transfer of risk in the AFP model. Design/Scope Risk Yes Carried in early stage budgets (MP, FP) to cover risk of additions to scope by the client as the project is developed. Market Yes Carried to cover construction market risk during a period of high utilization of construction industry capacity, which impacts competitiveness, availability of bidders, and construction pricing. Location Yes Carried to cover risk of higher construction pricing for large institutional projects in smaller markets at a distance from major population centres. Own Funds No These costs may or may not be fully realized in the bid. 1.2 Financing Costs during Construction Period – AFP Only Component Financing costs Element Cost Shareable Table 2 Notes Shareable items Yes See section 1.5 Non-shareable items No Related to all Own Funds components. Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 17 1.3 Other Turnkey Costs – Project Co. DBFM Only Component Element Cost Shareable Notes Table 1 Monitoring of Equipment Relocation Moving of equipment E.g. Diagnostic, Supply, Processing & Distribution, Monitoring Transition Costs Yes During project only – subsequently part of operating. Yes May be included under construction related cost. Yes Physical move costs, education and training associated with the approved project conducted by Project Co. during the project. Subsequent moves and training are part of operating. 1.4 Other – Ancillary Costs Related to Construction – Project Co.DBFM Only Component Element Building Permit Fee Equipment Allowance Cost Shareable Table 1 Notes Yes Project Co. procured Loose Furniture & Equipment See separate Furniture & Equipment section Other consultant costs Yes Associated with design and construction. Project Co Design Fees Yes Includes disbursements, cost consultant & HST rebate 1.5 Other Transaction Costs during the Construction Period – DBFM Only Component Element Cost Shareable Table 2 Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) Costs SPV, trustee & agent fees, finance co., technical advisor, management fees, honoraria Yes Notes Design and Bid Fee Yes Paid by Project Co. to other qualified but unsuccessful proponents. Independent Certifier Costs Yes Commissioning agent independent from the general contractor or Project Co. Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 18 A. Percent Driven Costs – Refer to Table 2 2 Hospital Related Project Costs 2.1 Ancillary Costs A. The ministry cost shares in all eligible planning and design costs. Select ancillary costs are capped at a set percentage of a defined Shareable sum. While ancillary costs are estimated during the early planning stages, the actual eligibility is determined on a line by line basis at pre-tender/Request for Proposal (RFP). If existing staff are used to fill any consultant or management position to support the Capital Redevelopment Project during regular working hours the HSP is required to backfill the individual’s previous position for the expenses to be eligible. Percent-Driven Costs Percent driven costs shareable to a maximum amount are based upon a percentage of the total shareable sum of the following: hard construction costs including escalation; construction insurance costs; cash allowances; and built-in equipment The HSP’s cost consultant must provide the percent breakdown of renovated to new space to determine the calculation for the Prime Consultant cap. Component Element Construction Monitor See Project Management Yes Cost Consultant/ Quantity Surveyor Functional Programmer Notes Cost Shareable Table 2 Up to 0.5% Independent from the Prime Consultant. Includes: Process Redesign consultant for standardization and food services, materials management consultant, and Master Program. Yes Up to 1% Independent consultant retained by the hospital to develop a Functional Program. Includes Operational Day costs. Minor Non – Depreciable Equipment Allowance Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) Yes 2% Allowance and applicable to eligible items <$5000. An audited financial statement of these articles will be required at time of settlement. 19 A. Percent Driven Costs – Refer to Table 2 Component Element Post Contract Contingency Allowance Prime Consultant Notes Cost Shareable Table 2 See Post Contract Contingency Allowance Section 2.2 Includes: Architect (to include interior design, lighting and value engineering in basic service), Structural Engineer, Mechanical Engineer (to include cold storage and refrigeration in basic service), Electrical Engineering Consultant. Yes Note: Defined construction cost adjusted to remove any embedded sales tax prior to application of the ministry cap for Prime Consultant only. Up to 8% for new construction 10% for renovations and 11% for DBFM (10% + 1% contingency based on rationale) To plan, design, and prepare contract documents and tenders and administer the contract throughout construction. Prime Consultant Disbursement (s) Project Management Includes: Construction Monitor, Moving & Occupancy Planner, and Scheduling consultant Yes Up to 10% of the shareable Prime Consultant Cost. Yes Where the defined construction cost is: <$50M = 3% >$50M but <$75M = $1.5M >$75M = 2% Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 20 Non Percent-Driven Costs – Refer to Table 2 B.1 Non Percent-Driven Costs – Note this section contains two parts B. B.1 – Non Percent-Driven Costs – Costs primarily during planning and design and are cost shared under Table 2. B.2 – Non Percent-Driven Costs – Costs primarily during construction and are cost shared under Table 1. B.1 Non Percent-Driven Costs – Refer to Table 2 Blended rates apply for renovation and new construction combination projects. The HSP cost consultant must provide the percent breakdown in renovated to new space. Component Element Cost Shareable Notes Table 2 Consultants Abatement/Asbestos Yes e.g. indoor environmental Acoustics Yes Business case/rationale required. Aviation Yes Civil Engineer Yes Greenfield/Brownfield site development e.g. storm water management etc. Code Yes Ontario Building Code and Ontario Fire Code To facilitate design and costs associated with code requirements. Colour Yes Where indicated for specialized programs to support or enhance care e.g. paediatrics, palliative care, psychogeriatrics Commissioning See Commissioning section Electrical Engineer See Prime Consultant Elevator Yes Energy Management Yes Environmental Yes Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) e.g. air quality, assessments, geotechnical, hazardous materials, soil, noise, etc. 21 B.1 Non Percent-Driven Costs – Refer to Table 2 Component Consultants Element Equipment Notes Cost Shareable Table 2 Yes Programming, develop clinical and technical criteria, and procurement specifications. In-contract base building furniture and equipment are ineligible. Financial Yes For AFP financing and procurement Food Services Yes Includes study of food delivery options and kitchen layout, equipment, servery layout including refrigeration. Excludes third party providing food services to the hospital for profit/revenue generating. Hardware Yes Health and Safety Yes Only if an in-house resource is not available. Infection Prevention and Control Yes Only if an in-house resource is not available. Information Technology and Communication Systems Yes Only if an in-house resource is not available. Green/Brownfield – includes system planning and specification development. Interior Design No Included in architect’s basic services Laboratory Design Yes Land Survey Yes During design phase only. See section 2 B.2 for during construction. No For the purpose of land purchase. Landscaping/Horticultural Yes Required for municipal site plan application and to support therapeutic gardens. Legal Yes For preparation of contract documents only. Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 22 B.1 Non Percent-Driven Costs – Refer to Table 2 Component Consultants Element Lighting Design Notes Cost Shareable Table 2 No Included in architect’s and electrical engineer’s basic services Yes Local Share / PCOP No Maintenance Planning Yes Where indicated for specialized programs to support or enhance care. To ensure all new building systems are functioning as planned and that building system personnel are trained in the use of all systems. See Commissioning section Master Plan (Architect/Planner) Yes Outside of Prime Consultant cap as the scope is for longer term planning. Eligible for cost sharing every 10 years. Master Program Yes Materials Management Outside of Functional Programmer cap as the scope is for longer term planning. See Functional Programmer Procurement advice (specifications) should be included in the equipment consultant costs. Mechanical Engineer Medical gas See Prime Consultant Yes Occupancy planner/ Moving See Project Management Operational Commissioning See Commissioning section Peer Review Yes Process Redesign Roof See Functional Programmer Yes Scheduling Security Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) Only if required under ministry direction. For testing, inspection, and facilitating design and inspection. See Project Management Yes 23 B.1 Non Percent-Driven Costs – Refer to Table 2 Component Consultants Element Cost Shareable Table 2 Structural Engineer Notes See Prime Consultant Traffic Yes Includes Local (on-site) and External consultants. Transition Management Yes If used prior to construction start. See section 2B.2 for during construction. Also see Commissioning Urban/Municipal Planner Yes Value Engineering No Included in basic services of architect and engineers to bring building costs down if project is over budget. Where the Prime Consultant cap is exceeded and there is significant value engineering required beyond the control of the Prime Consultant team the ministry will consider cost sharing. Project Related Waste Management/ Handling No If there are exceptional circumstances where it is outside of the Prime Consultant a rationale is required. Wayfinding/signage Yes If used prior to construction start. Abandoned Planning Costs / Sunk Costs Yes For design/planning/project management or other work previously approved and undertaken in accordance with specific ministry written approvals for a project to progress from one capital stage to another, which no longer contributes to the current ministry approved capital project. Auditing Yes Eligible only for projects with a TPC of >$50M with a $100,000 maximum. Energy Management Feasibility Study / Building Condition Feasibility Study Yes LEED/Environment – eligible if not already included in the Business Case or Master Plan expenses. Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 24 B.1 Non Percent-Driven Costs – Refer to Table 2 Component Project Related Element Post-occupancy evaluation Notes Cost Shareable Table 2 Yes For new Greenfield/Brownfield hospitals. New construction approved based on rationale. Room mock-up Yes Soil Testing Yes To inform design. Site testing to measure vibrations or monitor for potential risks to the site and surrounding neighbourhoods. Surveys (pre-design) Yes As-built drawings and/or surveys at the outset of design where adequate drawings or surveys do not exist. Testing and Inspection Yes Consultant and services costs in addition to Prime Consultant fees or contractor’s price. B.2 Non Percent-Driven Costs – Refer to Table 1 Blended rates apply for renovation and new construction combination projects. The HSP cost consultant must provide the percent breakdown in renovated to new space. Component Consultants Element Cost Shareable Table 1 Notes Campaign/Fundraising No Equipment Procurement Yes Equipment Coordinator Yes Furniture Planning and coordination Yes Land Survey Yes During construction only. See above section for during design. No For the purpose of land purchase. Yes The process consultant used to bring the building into use after construction start only. Operational Commissioning Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) Only during the project. 25 B.2 Non Percent-Driven Costs – Refer to Table 1 Component Element Cost Shareable Table 1 Notes Consultants Transition Management Yes If used post construction start. See section above for costs incurred prior to construction. Project Related Arbitration and Adjudication Yes This allowance/provision may be required occasionally when multiple contractors are simultaneously on site and disputes arise. Building Information Management System Yes Additions to existing buildings may require upgrade and expansion of the existing Building Automated Controls (BAC). Includes education and training software for HSP staff for BAC. Building Permit Yes Commissioning See Commissioning section Decanting/Phasing & Logistics Yes See Decanting section 1.1 B Decommissioning Yes See Decommissioning section 1.1 B Demolition Permit Yes See Demolition Section 1.1 B Development Levies Yes Mandatory regional and municipal fees. Insurance Yes See Insurance section Modelling – Software modelling for building system functionality and energy performance Yes Only energy consumption (LEED) modelling to Silver is eligible as a separate cost (e.g. Building Information Modelling/BIM) Moving Relocation Yes Conducted by the HSP for move of patients and support services, equipment and re-installation of existing equipment. Security Services Yes Eligible if additional security is required beyond what is specified in the construction contract. The hospital must provide a business case. Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 26 B.2 Non Percent-Driven Costs – Refer to Table 1 Component Project Related Element Notes Cost Shareable Table 1 Site Plan Application Yes Testing and Inspection Yes During construction only. Wayfinding/signage Yes Actual signs post design and planning. If it is included in the General Contract, show as part of construction costs. 2.2 Post Contract Contingency Allowance Component Post Contract Contingency Allowance Element Cost Shareable Table 1 Unforeseeable change orders (may include orders issued by rd 3 party / local authorities) Yes Notes 5% for renovations or a combination of renovations and new construction 3% for new construction (Greenfield or brownfield) See Bulletins on Change Orders, Cash Allowances, and Post Contract Contingency Allowances. Hospitals must carry Post Contract Contingency allowance on, at a minimum, eligible construction until; Settlement for Traditional Substantial performance/ settlement for AFP Hospital must advise ministry as soon as a significant unforeseeable condition is identified and obtain ministry review and advice/agreement on eligibility. Unforeseen Change Orders No Owner Driven Change Orders No Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) Resulting from design/coordination errors and omissions 27 2.3 Furnishings and Equipment Component Element Minor Non – Depreciable Equipment Allowance New Equipment Notes Cost Shareable Table 3 See Percent driven costs section (2A) Cancer (Major Radiation) Yes For new major radiation equipment for hospitals with regional cancer centres (See Appendix 2) If included a detailed list must be provided. Chronic Kidney Disease/ End Stage Renal Disease/ Dialysis Equipment Built In (Incontract) No New dialysis equipment is eligible for cost sharing by the ministry through the operational budget. Yes Exceptions – Reverse Osmosis (RO) system and Central Dialysate Delivery System included in Built-in Equipment. Yes All construction costs need to be reviewed for the inclusion of loose furnishings and equipment. See Equipment Matrix in Appendix 1 A detailed list must be provided. Equipment Allowance Equipment Not Built In No LTMH Yes All other No Not built in No Only for Project Co. procured Loose F&E for DBFM projects. No To be included in Local Share Plan only, not to be included in the TPC. Replacement Equipment A detailed list must be provided. 2.4 Infrastructure Ontario Costs – AFP only Component Element Cost Shareable Table 2 Transaction Costs Yes OIPC Project Costs Yes Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) Notes 28 3 Maintenance Costs – AFP Models Only 3.1 Financing Costs during the Operational Term Component Financing Element Shareable Notes Cost Shareable Table 1 Yes If the hospital is fully paying its local share (own funds + hospital share) at substantial completion, the financing cost during the operational term is fully funded by the ministry. If the hospital is not fully paying its local share at substantial completion, the hospital will have to assume a share of the financing cost during the operational term. The cost sharing of the long-term financing will consider the amount of local share that the hospital is paying at substantial completion versus the amount of local share that it is financing through the deal. Non-Shareable No Own funds 3.2 Lifecycle Costs Component Element Notes Cost Shareable Table 1 Life cycle Shareable Yes Associated with replacing building components over the life of the building. Non-shareable No Own Funds 3.3 Other Transaction Costs during the Operational Term Component Element Cost Shareable Table 1 Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) Costs SPV, trustee & agent fees, finance co., technical advisor, management fees, honoraria Yes Base Relevant Insurance Costs Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) Notes Yes 29 4 General Costs 4.1 Commissioning Component Element Cost Shareable Notes Table 1 Commissioning rd Independent Certifier - 3 party commissioning agent agreed to by hospital and Project Co. or hospital staff only if positions are backfilled. Yes Independent from general contractor or Project Co. Focuses on mechanical, electrical and specialty systems to ensure that performance of equipment and systems are improved & meets performance requirements (defined in contract docs) See Ancillary section as well. Yes Process of bringing a building into use e.g. occupancy, furniture and equipment (delivery, installation, testing and acceptance) and includes move of patients, material and staff. Type Cost Shareable Table 1 Notes Project Co. / General Contractor Bid Bonds Errors and Omissions Performance Bonds Material and Labour Bonds Liability Yes - Mandatory Included in the bid Health Service Provider Liability Operational & during Construction (Transition Management) 4.2 Insurance Carrier Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) Yes - Optional Conditional based on advice of the insurance advisor/internal liability carriers 30 4.3 Taxes Component Element Cost Shareable Notes Table 1 HST Please note that HST should not be added to allowance(s) and risk(s) as it is calculated on the sum of the estimated construction costs 83% rebate on Federal taxes HST Federal Tax 5% HST Federal Rebate 83% HST Provincial Tax 8% HST Provincial Rebate 87% GST Tax 5% Rebate 83% Combination projects 87% rebate on Provincial taxes For projects with both HST and GST expenses, costs will be assessed based on prevailing tax structure at the time when costs of individual project components were incurred. Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 31 December 15th, 2006 Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 32 Appendix 1 * Building Systems (Built In) include Structure (Building Envelope), Supply of air (HVAC), supply of water (plumbing) supply of electricity (lights) and life safety and IT that supports the building Systems (Building Controls). Equipment Matrix Revised August 2011 90% /100% Eligible Hospital Building* Systems (Built In) Regulatory Compliant (OBC, CSA) Substantial Completion (Operating Hospital) Hospital Equipment Systems (Not Built Examples HVAC Equipment IT Infrastructure (Cables) - Building Plumbing Fixtures Medical Gases Headwalls (for Medical gases) Service Columns in lieu of Headwalls (for Building Systems in ICU / treatment / procedure areas) o May be in the form of an articulating arm Procedural Lights Built-in Fume Hoods, sterilizers, refrigerators 0% Ineligible Examples Patient Lifting Device Examples Examples In) Patient Lift Tracks Ceiling Mounts for Articulating Arms IT Infrastructure (Cables) – Communication Therapeutic Bath Tubs (CCC / Rehab / Maternal) Signage Walk-in Refrigerators Reverse Osmosis (RO) Water Systems (Dialysis) Nurse Call / Patient Wandering Systems Millwork / Casework for fixed cabinetry Millwork / Casework / Modular equivalent for communication stations Building System Equipment Diagnostic Imaging: CT Scanner / MRI IT - Computers, Phones, Data Hubs CCTV / Monitors Additional Articulating Arms (in addition to Service Columns if specified) Blanket Warmers Portable Fume Hoods Portable Sterilizers Portable HEPA Filters Utility / Supply Carts Moveable Casework in lieu of utility carts / storage cabinets Appliances (refrigerators, microwaves) Ice Machines Systems Furniture for Administrative Functions Window Coverings Operational Equipment Note: Hospital may include Furniture and Equipment under “Built In” equipment however Ministry Cost Share policy still applies. If the F & E is not eligible to be included as an infrastructure cost, the costs are not eligible for cost share unless the project is LTMH. If the project is LTMH only new eligible F & E is eligible. Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 33 Appendix 2 Major Radiation Capital – Ministry Funding Position (based on 2005/06 Cancer Care Ontario standards for technology) ITEM Current Ministry Position Linear Accelerators Linear Accelerator Therapy Unit (LINAC) To be funded at 100% Image Guided Radiation Therapy capability ( 1per 3 units) To be funded at 100% CR System (Req'd in existing Centres with older technologies) To be funded at 100% Stereotactic Capability ( Not req'd in all Centres) To be funded at 100% Radiation Clinical Information System (Network) To be funded at 100% Superficial OR Ortho voltage Unit To be funded at 100% High Dose Rate Brachytherapy HDR Treatment Planning module To be funded at 100% HDR Brachytherapy Unit To be funded at 100% HDR Imaging To be funded at 100% Treatment Planning and Treatment Delivery CT Simulator (incl. 2 workstations) To be funded at 100% Treatment Planning System To be funded at 100% Other Costs Associated with a new Radiation Treatment Centre Hardware, Software, Licenses directly related to equipment installation and operation Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) To be funded at 100% 34 Appendix 3 Acronyms AFP Alternate Financing and Procurement BF Build Finance (AFP Model) BFM Build Finance Maintain (AFP Model) CO Change Order DBFM Design Build Finance Maintain (AFP Model) DAA Development Accountability Agreement FP Functional Program GOS Generic Output Specifications GPC Guaranteed Price Contract HSP Health Service Provider LEED Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design LTMH Longer Term Mental Health MP Master Program/Master Plan PDC Project Design Compliance PCOP Post construction operating plan RFP Request for Proposals SPV Special Purpose Vehicle TPC Total Project Cost Capital Cost Share Guide (September 2016) 35 © 2012 Queen’s Printer for Ontario