HIS 102 Notes Week 2 WORLD CIV II NOTES THE ENLIGHTENMENT To open your mind. To challenge old ways of thinking. Mid-1600’s- 1700’s Human’s ability to understand the world around them. People began to seek knowledge of their world outside of what the church told them. “Age of Reason” Humans could understand the world around them through o Observing human behavior o Scientific experimentation Humans ability to understand the world came through the grace of God. Only God could have created a being that could comprehend the world around them. Faith COULD go with reason. Some Enlightenment thinkers used “the Enlightenment” to bring them closer to God. Others used it as a way to pull away from religion, or more specifically to pull them out from under the control of established religious institutions. o Some thought that “now we have the ability to figure out things on our own.” o A wide range of thinkers, from diehard believers to diehard atheists. Deists: God created everything, gave things their start then stepped back and let things go. o Believe that God created but does not control the Universe. Everything AFTER creation occurs through randomness. Separation of Church & State: Central to the ideologies of the founding of the US o Not anti-religion (necessarily) o Religion should not be involved in Government. Religious leaders should not control politics. o Citizens should have the right to worship (or not worship) as they choose. o No state sponsored/ authorized religion. Immanuel Kant: Described the Enlightenment as: “humankind’s release from immaturity.” o Immaturity: the inability to think for one’s self. Page 1 of 9 HIS 102 Notes Week 2 Many were suspicious of older forms of government and older superstitions. Humanity has the ability to think for themselves, thus any system that seeks to subdue this is suspect. Religious leaders tended to be suspicious of Enlightenment thinkers and vice versa. Enlightenment affected many aspects of human life: o Religion/ Spirituality o Art o Economics o Politics Citizen’s rights… a concept originating in the Enlightenment. Humans have the right to have a say in how they are governed. Impact and contradictions The enlightenment coincided with the expansion of the Transatlantic Slave Trade. TST based on race. Humans are born with reason, and the intellectual ability to make their lives better. Vs. o It is ok to enslave one group of people because of their race. Practiced “Scientific racism” came up with so called scientific reasons why one race was superior (or inferior) to another. i.e. shape of their skulls, facial features, style of dress, culture etc. o The justifications were completely arbitrary and elaborate. Also completely made up and ridiculous. Historical context Pre-1500 slavery o Slaves were generally POW’s, debtors, etc., o Major slave routes all over the world, Came from Russia, Central Europe, India, and later Africa. o TST saw a boom in the slave trade. Slavery became central to the economies of the Americas in the 1600’s- 1800’s. The Caribbean, South America, and North America. Page 2 of 9 HIS 102 Notes Week 2 Slavery became a dominant factor in the economy because of agriculture: Sugar plantations and refining. Europe ill-suited for growing sugar. Portuguese explorers found islands, first off, the west coast of Africa and then in the Americas that were perfect for growing sugar. Colonization/ Slave trade/ sugar plantations went hand in hand. Sugar became the predominant crop in this time period. Sugar harvesting was dangerous… chopping sugarcane with machetes, axes, etc. At first the plantation owners thought that they could use native populations for labor, but disease and other factors weakened the natives and made them ill-suited to this purpose. So, they brought in Africans instead. 1500’s to 1860’s about 13 million Africans were displaced to provide slave labor to the TST. o Slavery in practice: slave ships would land in West-Africa, Native Africans would sell people to the Europeans. These slaves could be: Prisoners, No Class next Tuesday Criminals, (10 September 5, 2019) Enemy POW’s Etc. o Triangle trade Triangle shaped trade routes… o Middle Passage: Also see Django Unchained Video on YouTube: “Skull Scene” https://youtu.be/aQM4ebFILv4 Is the social contract designed to protect citizens from each other (Hobbes) or to protect citizens from a government that might take our rights away? (Locke) Shipping of African people to the Americas for the purpose of being slaves. Dehumanizing of African people, Stacked, and packed into ships to carry them to the Americas. Many died of suffocation, disease, and suicide on the trip to the Americas. Page 3 of 9 HIS 102 Notes Week 2 Treated as cargo, not people. Slave families were broken up, husbands going one way, wives another way. Slave mothers used as “wet nurses” even to the detriment and death of their own children. o There was also an abolitionist movement, particularly in England in in the North American colonies in the 1770s. Grounded in a moral argument Also, technological advances replaced the need for human labor with mechanized farming methods. In 1808 US and the UK banned the International Slave trade. However, slavery continued to exist into the 1860s in the US, and 1888 in Brazil. Brazil was the last nation in the West to ban slavery. Enlightenment Political Thinkers Thomas Hobbes: 1588-1679 (English) Wrote Leviathan in 1651. o Dealt with the concept of the “Social Contract” (An agreement between individuals and the government) Individuals agreed to give up some of their freedoms to a leader in exchange for that leader’s agreeing to protect their other rights. For example: We give up the right to walk directly to an airplane and get aboard to the government (through the TSA, etc.) in exchange for the protection that we have from being blown up when riding airplanes. o Hobbes saw this concept of “Social Contract.” As a necessity. o He saw humanity, in a natural state, were violent, cruel, solitary (noncommunal), and in chaos. Motivated entirely by self-interest. Altruistic actions that benefit the community is against human nature. This changed Page 4 of 9 HIS 102 Notes Week 2 when the first humans developed society and started forming the first social contracts. This was done out of selfinterest in order to protect each individual through mutual defense. o In Hobbes mind, social contracts are in place through studied self-interest for each citizen to further their own goals Social contracts gradually became more intricately involved and migrated higher up in social development This is the basis on which larger governments have formed. We have social contracts between our leaders to protect the rights/ interests of the citizens. o Humans agree to abide by laws in exchange for certain benefits that are in place due to having the government in place. o He believed in strong, absolute leaders. Leaders with total control to keep citizens in check. John Locke: 1632-1704 (English) o 1689 Second Treatise of Government. o Social Contract- to protect rights, lives, and property. o In a state of nature, humans by their very nature inherently understood that doing harm to another human was wrong. o Humans were not out of control or motivated purely by self-interest. o Humans came together to form communities to protect their rights to life, liberty, and property from outsiders. The (US) Declaration of Independance When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation. We hold these truths to be selfevident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.–That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, –That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness. Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly, all experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to Page 5 of 9 suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by HIS 102 Notes Week 2 o Locke believed that humans much more driven by communal concerns than Hobbes did. o “Consent of the Governed”: those being governed only because they allow, they consent to allow the government to have that power. Thus, citizens decide that the government has power and can also decide to take that power away. Locke believed that this right is inalienable. (“God given” and cannot be taken away.) John-Jacques Rousseau 1712-1778 (French) o In 1762 wrote, “the Social Contract” o He said that the best government was one decided by, Popular sovereignty, where the people have a direct say in how they are governed and in how their society operates. o The United States is not a democracy, but rather a republic where we elect people to make laws on our behalf. In a democracy we would directly make those decisions. o Popular sovereignty is the General Will according to Rousseau. In reality, not all citizens will understand how to best contribute to the general will. (They won’t have the mental capacity.) Thus, societies ran by the general will still need to have some sort of leader to guide things. Influences o Magna Carta (1215) Written by English Nobles: Not really poor or oppressed. They wanted a say in their government as people who had invested in their nation. o Enlightenment Social Contracts, Relationship between citizens and their government Purposes of government Revenue? Protection against foreign powers? What exactly is the government there for, and could we do without one? John Locke (heavily influential) Montesquieu 1689-1755 (French) Wrote about the concept of separation of powers. Page 6 of 9 HIS 102 Notes Week 2 Recognized that any one individual, or group of individuals who held too much power were hard to keep in check.: Thus, we have 3 branches of government in the US. American Revolution o “City Upon a Hill” Enlightenment ideals Sense of destiny, particularly British have a great influence colonists believed that they would establish on the US revolution, a model that the rest of the world would French revolution, as follow. well as the Haitian o The American Revolution was started and driven revolution. by a group of wealthy intellectuals who did not like being controlled by a government under which they had no say. o Declaration of Independence: the announcement to the world that the citizens in the US intended to break away from the British government and establish a new government and a new nation. This was a radical move. That they would win and achieve this was by no means a surety. They were going against the world’s largest (at that time) Empire. To rebel against a monarchy in this way was unheard of. o Thomas Paine wrote a pamphlet called “Common Sense”. The cause of America is in great measure the cause of All Mankind.” o Eventually the Americans convince the British that the fight against the “Americans” was no longer worth it. The Americans will not give up. Time to count their losses and sign a treaty with the new government of the US. The efforts to control the North American colonies was no longer cost effective. The British Government would be better off spending their money elsewhere. In 1783, the British agreed to sign the “Treaty of Paris” which ended the US revolution and granted the new nation rights to all lands East of the Mississippi River. French Revolution o 1789 French economy bad. Spending a lot of money on wars Page 7 of 9 HIS 102 Notes Week 2 French aristocracy were heavily spending on luxury items and seen as highly wasteful. French government invested in the American Revolution, as they were traditional enemies of England. o Louis XVI & his wife, Marie Antoinette the leaders of France in a time when the economy was bad and as such received much of the blame for the situation in their country. They seemed to not care about the plight of their citizenry, engaged in wanton and unchecked spending in a time when the government couldn’t really afford it. o Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen A statement of what the inherent rights of what a French citizen should have. It delineated what rights a government should grant its citizens in the present and future. “Men are born free and remain free and equal in right.” o Enter the guillotine: Seen as a more “humane” method of execution (vs. hanging or firing squad). Marie Antoinette & Louis XVI were executed by this means. o Revolution quickly turned to chaos, violence, and terrorism. Leaders of the Revolution became paranoid. They had revolted and overturned the government, what would keep someone else from doing the same to them. o Maximillian Robespierre Committee of Public Safety. Arrest, torture of suspected enemies, and execution (by guillotine). “Reign of Terror” 1793-1794 Violence was used to swiftly crush anyone who might attempt to overthrow the new government. When the US started the first Republic, others were sure to follow. When France staged their Revolution and became so violent, it made Americans become wary and suspicious of any revolutions. This would affect America’s policies regarding other nations revolutions for a long time to come. The violence and terrorism committed by the Committee of Public Safety greatly disturbed the Americans. Page 8 of 9 HIS 102 Notes Week 2 The French Revolution is an example of the corrupting nature of power. (John Addams?) Haitian Revolution o A colony of France (on the Island of Hispaniola, shares island with the Dominican Republic) o Population of Haiti mostly slaves, growing sugar on vast plantations. o Haitian blacks believed that John Locke’s ideals should apply to them too! We have the God-given right to freedom. The inalienable right to Life, liberty, and property. At least the freemen of color. o Haiti consisted of: White French Plantation/Landowners (A minority) Free Men of Color (Mixed African and French Heritage) Some were landowners, and slave owners. Slaves (The majority of Haitians.) o Some wealthy landowning people of color in the 1790’s believed that they should have the right to self-governance. They wanted the right to vote and take part in the government like other “white” citizens. They considered themselves Frenchmen. They argued that they were not trying to overthrow slavery or the French government but were simply looking after their own rights. Julien Raimond and Vincent Oge (ohjay) While all of this was happening was a slave revolt began in Haiti. One primary thought of slave owners, “Why don’t they rise up and kill us?” Toussaint L’Ouverture: One of the primary leaders of the Slave Rebellion and then the Haitian War of Independence against France. Considered one of the Founding Fathers of Haiti. Died of Pneumonia in 1803. January 1st of 1804 Haiti declared a Free Republic by France. o Thus, Haiti became the 2nd Republic in the world. (1, a former British Colony, the other a former French Slave colony.) o Rather than be happy for Haiti, the US government remains suspicious of Haiti because Haiti has declared that they welcome any slaves from other nations to be free citizens there. This was a concern to US slave owners. Page 9 of 9