Lead-Acid Battery I Bahtiar Yulianto May 2016 Lead Mining Process Lead Manufacturing Process Mining the ore Concentrating the ore Flotation Filtering Roasting the ore Blasting Refining Costing Pb contains several metal impurities such as Cu, Ag, Au, Zn, Sn, As, and Sb, which have to be removed. The final purification is carried out by electrolytic rafination using massive cast Pb anodes. This procedure yields a cathodic deposit with 99.99% Pb. It can be further purified electrochemically to obtain Pb with impurities level below 1 ppm. K Maksymiuk, J Stroka, and Z Galus, University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland Lead Minerals Lead (Pb) Mining in Indonesia Lead Mining in Indonesia DI. Aceh (K. Beureung, K. Isep, Pasir Putih, Lokop) Sumatera Utara (Bululaga, Nias, Sihajo, Nusa Bargot, Muara Soma, Ulu Aek Paneme Estella, Paguran Si Ayu, Bukit Pionggu, Malilir, G. Marisi, Sidingin) Sumatera Barat (Sumpu, Balung, Batang Bio, Bata Menjulur, Lubuk Selasih, S. Talang, S. Pagu, Bulangsi, Tepan, Mangani, G. Arum) Bengkulu (S. Ipuh Panjang, G. Batu bertulis, Aer Penejun, Aer Saleh, Aer Piatu, Aer Bagus, Tabak Tempilang, Aer Anget, Aer Limpure, Cepei, Aer Kidurung, Aer Loh, Muara Impu Tanah, Lebong Simpang, Lebong Donok, Lebong Sulit, Lebong Kandis, Simau, Tumbang Sawah) Sumatera Selatan (S. Tuboh, Aer Kukus, Aer Seri, Bukit Lajah, Kikim Besar) Lampung (Rajabasa, G. Rantai) Bangka Belitung (Tanjung Pandan, Membalong, Dendang, Gantung, Manggar, Kelapa Kampit) Banten (Cirotan, Cikotok, Panggarangan) Jawa Barat (G. Parang, G. Sawal, Tasikmalaya, Cianjur) Jawa Timur (Janglot, Dawuhan, Kedungpring, Tegalrejo, Domasan, Kalitelu, Kasinan, Brungkah, Batu Ulu) Kalimantan Barat (Mandoe, Bengkayang, S. Samarayak) Kalimantan Tengah (Sampit) Kalimantan Timur (S. Mara) Sulawesi Selatan (Sasak, Masupu, Bobohan) Nusa Tenggara Barat (Lentek Desa Rembitan) Nusa Tenggara Timur (Hulu W. Rango, Omesuri, Laibunggi, Ujung Selatan Bag. Barat P. Sumba, Worgilip-Prabur, Maikawada, Taneman, Kuneman, Mamenang, Pido, Taramen, Wakapsir) What is battery ? Battery does not store electricity, but rather it stores a series of chemical, through a chemical process electricity is produced. Basically, two different type of lead in an acid mixture react to produce an electrical pressure called voltage. This electrochemical reaction changes chemical energy to electrical energy and is the basis for all automotive batteries (Kevin R Sullivan, Professor of Automotive Technology Skyline College) The purpose of battery ? (Kevin R Sullivan, Professor of Automotive Technology Skyline College) The battery supplies electricity when the : ENGINE IS OFF Electricity from the battery is used to operate the lighting, accessories, or other electrical systems when the engine is not running ENGINE IS STARTING Electricity from the battery is used to operate the starter motor and to provide current for the ignition system during engine cranking. Starting the car is the battery’s most important function. ENGINE IS RUNNING Electricity from the battery may be needed to supplement the charging system when the vehicle’s electrical load requirements exceed the charging system’s ability to produce electricity. Both the battery and the alternator supply electricity when demand is high. Batteries Primary or Secondary (Kevin R Sullivan, Professor of Automotive Technology Skyline College) Primary Cell The chemical reaction totally destroy one of the metals after a period of time, primary cells can not be recharged. Small batteries such as flashlight and radio batteries are primary cell. Secondary Cell The metal plates and acid mixture change as the battery supplies voltage. As the battery drains the metal plates become similar and the acid strength weakens. This process is called discharging. By applying current to the battery in the reverse direction, the battery materials can be restored, thus recharging the battery. This process is called charging. Automotive lead acid batteries are secondary cells and can be recharged. Car Electrical System Market study by ENERSYS® Battery Classification Lead Acid Batteries Starting, Lighting, and Ignition (SLI) Motive Lead Acid (MLA) Stationary Lead Acid (SLA) Consumer automotive applications Heavy Duty vehicle applications Telecommunication applications Mining applications Data Communication applications Marine applications Utility applications Other applications Railroad applications Emergency Lighting applications Other automotive applications Other applications Lead Acid Battery Market : Market Segmentation (World 2001, source : Frost and Sullivan) Security applications Other applications VRLA Batteries Pure Lead Grid Standard Calcium Motive Lead Acid (MLA) Starting, Lighting, and Ignition (SLI) Stationary Lead Acid (SLA) Standard Antimony Standard Calcium Low Antimony Low Antimony Flooded Batteries Lead Acid Battery families of flooded and VRLA Batteries, grid alloys and application field Lead Acid Battery Manufacturing Process Lead Acid Battery Component MOLL Ion permeable and resistant to H2SO4, O2 and H2 attack Lead Acid Battery Standard - JIS Standard (Japanese Industrial Standards) JIS D5301-2006 - DIN Standard (Deutsches Institut für Normung", meaning "German institute for standardisation) DIN EN 50342-1 - SNI Standard (Standar Nasional Indonesia) SNI 0038:2009 - IEC (Electrical Characteristics) IEC 60095-1 : 2006 IEC 60095-2 : 2006 - GSO Standard (GCC Standardization Organization) GSO 35/2007 - SLS Standard (Sri Lanka Standard) SLS 1126 Part 1 : 2004 - SAE Standard (Society of Automotive Engineers) SAE J240 - EN Standard (European Standard) EN 61429 Starting Lighting Ignition (SLI) Lead Acid Battery Construction NGS INDOBATT INDUSTRI PERMAI Negative Pole/terminal Plate strap Positive Pole/terminal Dop Polypropylene Cover Polypropylene Container Fiber glass mat Micro porous Separator Lead Connector Negative Plate Pb Positive Plate PbO2 wrapped in separator Lead Acid Battery Construction Grid – Enveloping – Separator & Fiberglass mat Grid Enveloping Separator & glass mat Grid Casting Machine - Wirtz Wirtz Automotive Gravity Casting Machine Wirtz Continuous Grid Casting System Wirtz Continuous Grid Punching System For Positive Plates Grid and small part Center Lug Grid Side Lug Grid The battery capacity is increased because of the increase in surface area. More plate surface area means the battery can deliver more current LEAD ALLOY • • • • The grids makes an important part of the storage cell which act as support for the active materials of plates and conduct the electric current developed. It also plays an important role in maintaining uniform current distribution throughout the mass of the active material. Grids must be mechanically proof and positive grid must be corrosion proof (Petr Krivik & Petr Baca). Corrosion converts lead alloy to lead oxides with lower mechanical strength and conductivity. Grids are made from Lead Alloys (Pure Lead will be too soft), it is used PbCa or Pb-Sb with mixture of additives as Sn, Cd, Se, that improve corrosion resistance and make higher mechanical strength. Grid corrosion is highly increased Grid Casting Machine - Wirtz Grid Size Capacity Production Wirtz Automotive Gravity Casting Machine Trim Width: 4.250” (108mm) min to 6.735” (161mm) max Lug to lug: 7.375” (187mm) min to 13.625” (346mm) max Grid Thickness: 0.040” (1.02mm) min to 0.188” (4.77mm) max Speeds up to 18 casts per minute. One operator, (3) machines, up to 35,000 grids per (8) hour shift. Wirtz Continuous Grid Casting System Maximum Casting Width: Depends on Concast System. Grid Design: Per customers specifications Thickness: Per customer specifications (+/- 0.0125mm) Production speeds up to 75 feet per minute (23 meters per minute), dependent on alloy, grid design, thickness, and other parameters. Wirtz Continuous Grid Punching System For Positive Plates – Conpunch CP-13200 Maximum Product Width: 11.81 in. (300mm) Grid Design: Per customers specifications Thickness: Per customer specifications Production speeds up to 250 stroked per minute, dependent on strip alloy, grid design, thickness, and other parameters. Gravity Casting Accessories Sodium Silicate 150 ml Water 5 liter X500 MOLD COAT 500 gram Mixing Acid Tank Expand the paste and giving it great porosity, supplies a necessary binding cement so the dry plate can be handled without loss of material SOVEMA Blade Type Mixer 1,000 KG Water Tank Act as lubricant producing lighter paste Lead Oxide Silo Grinding and surface oxidation to pure lead ingots Mixing Tank Pasting line Flash Drying Oven Mixing Positive Active Material Negative Active Material Lead Powder Lead Powder Durafloc Durafloc Water Water Sulfuric Acid Sulfuric Acid Barium Sulfate Sodium Lignosulfonate Expander Stearic Acid Lead Oxide Processes on the Pb/PbO2/PbSO4 electrode in H2SO4 solution Oxygen evolution at PbO2 electrode MIXING Ratio of H2SO4/Lead Oxide Alpha & Beta PbO It depends on H2SO4/LO ratio (LO is the oxidized lead powder), temperature, additives and time of mixing. It has been established that the paste is a non-equilibrium system consisting of crystalline basic lead sulfates and oxides, and amorphous sulfate-containing components. Depending on the temperature of preparation pastes with the following compositions are obtained : At to<60oC H2SO4/LO ratio up to 12%. The paste contains 3PbO.PbSO4.H2O (3BS) + tet-PbO + orthorhombic-PbO + Pb. Maximum content of 3BS is obtained at 10% H2SO4/LO. Over 8% H2SO4/LO ratio, mostly PbO.PbSO4 (1BS) is formed. At to>70oC H2SO4/LO ratio up to 7%. The paste contains 4PbO.PbSO4 (4BS) + tet-PbO + orthorhombic-PbO + Pb. Maximum content of 4BS is obtained at 6.5% H2SO4/LO. At beginning of mixing 3BS and orthorhombic-PbO are formed first. Then (3BS) + tet-PbO + orthorhombic-PbO react and 4BS is formed. 4BS nucleation is the slowest process. It depends strongly on temperature. In the presence of surface active additive(s) (expander(s)) 4BS and orthorhombic-PbO are not formed at all. H2SO4/LO ratio between 7% and 12%. The paste contains 3BS + 1BS + tet-PbO + orthorhomb-PbO. With time of stirring 3BS crystals grow up to 2-4 μm in size and 4BS ones reach sizes of up to 20-50 μm. PASTING - + Pasting Machine Basic lead sulfates are formed during this stage Chemical of active material resistant to H2SO4 solution Flash Drying Oven The evaporation of water gives a desirable porosity If too much water is evaporated during the rather short period of flash drying, cracks will occur in the material (R Wagner, MOLL Accu Elsevier 2009) PASTING PASTING 3BS was observed to be dominant when pasting was carried out at lower peak temperature (Int J Electrochem Sci Vol 6, 2011). The initial reaction of sulfuric acid with lead oxide (equation 1) leads to normal lead sulfate and heat evolution. Under the influence of excess lead oxide and water this is not stable, so converts into basic sulfate, either tribasic (2) or tetrabasic (3) according to PbO + H2SO4 ↔ PbSO4 + H2O (1) PbSO4 + 3PbO ↔ 3PbO.PbSO4 (2) PbSO4 + 4PbO ↔ 4PbO.PbSO4 (3) Tribasic sulfate is crystallized as small needles with high specific surface and formed, roughly speaking, below 70 oC. Tetrabasic sulfate forms more bulky crystals at temperatures above 70 oC. (Lead Acid Battery Formation Techniques – Digatron) CURING 3BS Vs 4BS (R Wagner, MOLL Accu Elsevier 2009) 3BS 4BS Shorter battery cycle life Crystal much larger therefore the formation is much more difficult and longer. It means that either lower initial capacity has to be accepted or significantly longer formation time is needed. Reacts relatively fast to lead sulfate Reacts at first mainly to 1BS and afterward some of it much more slowly to lead sulfate Higher Capacity It gives more robust crystalline structure which reduce the shedding of positive material during cycling resulting in a better cycling performance. This is particularly important for positive plates with Lead – Calcium grid alloys. Crystal smaller therefore the formation is more easy and shorter Action to reduce 4BS : - Control process parameters of the curing process so that smaller 4BS crystals appear. - Add certain chemicals to the paste that would limit the growth of the 4BS crystal. - Using two step curing program (first step at 70 Deg C in just a few hours, second step at 50 Deg C High formation efficiency, Lead Dioxide content > 90% Low formation efficiency, Lead Dioxide content < 80% Mixed Formation efficiency than just 4BS Cycling performance than just 3BS Lead dioxide content < 90% Curing and Drying Controlled the temperature, humidity and duration of the process (R Wagner, MOLL Accu Elsevier 2009) Pallets with plates are placed in a high humidity chamber and left to cure at 35 ⁰C for 48-72 h. During the curing process, lead in the paste is oxidized, the basic lead sulfates re-crystallize and the plates are then dried to moisture content <0.5% (Pavlov 109). The amount of the basic sulfates depends on the paste recipe or more precisely on the amount of sulfuric acid added during mixing. The portion of 4BS depends on the temperature of the curing process. This compound will not appear as long as the temperature is kept below 70 ⁰C (R Wagner, MOLL Accu Elsevier 2009) • • • • • • • Curing and drying of plates for lead acid batteries can be managed to become tetra basic or tri basic lead sulfate depending on the process parameters (Dr Nitsche) Higher surface area would accelerate the process of acid diffusion into the plate and within it, thereby improving the high rate performance of battery (Int J Electrochem Sci Vol 6, 2011). The surface area (sq m/g) get reduced with increasing Acid/Oxide ratio (Lead Sulphates bulkier than PbO). The temperature is responsible for the composition of cured plates, such plates cured at high temperature (more than 70oC) resulting in mainly tetrabasic lead sulphate 4PbO. PbSO4 (4BS) behave markedly different to those cured at low temperature having only tribasic lead sulphate 3PbO. PbSO4. H2O (3BS)(11,12). The surfaces are of active material and depend on curing temperature, as the suitable temperature in curing process is around (56-65oC)(13) (Bakhtiar Kakil Hamad, R Wagner, MOLL Accu Elsevier 2009). While the reduction in surface area with increase in curing temperature can be attributed to the growth of 3BS/4BS. The higher Peak Temperature and Curing Temperature have shown a similar effect. 3BS yields higher capacity and 4BS provides higher cycle life. Paste morphology is looked at from view point of crystal type 4BS/3BS crystal growth specially its length (um), phase distribution and packing intensity. Temperature above 60 oC should be avoided in the production of positive plates i.e. paste preparation, curing and drying (Dr. Reiner Kiessling, Lead Acid Battery Formation Techniques) Composition of the cured material (R Wagner, MOLL Accu Elsevier 2009 ) : - Basic lead sulfates (3BS : 3PbO.PbSO4 or 4BS : 4PbO.PbSO4) - Lead Oxide (α-PbO) - Small percent of free lead (Pb) - Monobasic lead sulfate (1BS : PbO.PbSO4) - Lead Carbonate/Hydrocerussite (Pb3(CO3)2(OH)2) - β-PbO After curing and drying, parameter should be checked are : - Remaining free lead content - Moisture content - Lead carbonate - Density - Porosity - Pore size distribution - BET surface - Ratio 3BS and 4 BS CURING Detchko Pavlov Lead Acid Batteries Science and Technology CURING R Wagner, MOLL Accu Elsevier 2009 Characteristic data of the cured plate Crystal Size Crystal Structure (XRay) Pore Diameter (μm) BET Surface (m2g-1) High Large 4BS 6-11 0.3-0.4 Medium Large/Small 4BS + 3BS 0.7-0.8 0.9-1.0 Low Small 3BS 0.4-0.6 1.2-1.3 Curing Temperature BET : Brunauer Emmett and Teller CURING Detchko Pavlov Lead Acid Batteries Science and Technology