Author’s Name:_________________
Your name:_________________
Peer Assessment for Argumentation
Did the author:
INTRO:
 Have a hook?___________
 Background info?
 Clearly state their argument and claims? ________
Body 1:
 Restate claim 1? ________________
 Use 2 pieces of evidence to support their position?
__________
 Use RELEVANT evidence/support? ___________
 Introduce the evidence (give context, background, etc.) and
articles? ____________
 Explain what it means and why it matters?
_______________
Areas to improve:____________________________________
_________________________________________________
 Restate claim 2? ________________
 Use 2 pieces of evidence to support their position?
__________
 Use RELEVANT evidence/support? ___________
 Introduce the evidence (give context, background, etc.) and
articles? ____________
 Explain what it means and why it matters?
_______________
Areas to improve:____________________________________
_________________________________________________
3rd Body Paragraph:
HAVE A COUNTERARGUMENT? __________
HAVE A REBUTTAL? ____________
Did the rebuttal respond to the counter (was it related?)
__________________
Use at least 1 piece of evidence to support their position?
__________
 Use RELEVANT evidence/support? ___________
 Introduce the evidence (give context, background, etc.)?
____________
 Explain what it means and why it matters?
_______________
Areas to improve:____________________________________
_________________________________________________





Conclusion:
 Restate argument? _________
 Give a call to action or final thought that ties back to the
hook? ____________
Areas to improve:____________________________________
_________________________________________________
Comments:
Something they did well
_________________________________________________
_________________________________________________