Theory of Metal Cutting Dr.A.Suresh babu,Ph.D Asst.Professor College of Engineering,Guindy 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 1 UNIT I FUNDAMENTALS OF METAL CUTTING 10 Mechanics of orthogonal and oblique cuttingMechanics of chip formation-Types of chips produced in cutting- Cutting forces and powerTemperature in cutting-Tool life –numerical problems-Wear and failure-surface finish and integrity- Machine tools structures-Vibration and chatters in machining-machining economics Cutting tools steels, cobalt alloys, coated tools Diamond tools -Cutting fluids. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 2 Contents 1. Common processes, features of machining 2. geometry of single point tool and tool signature 3. concept of speed, feed and depth of cut 4. Temperature in cutting 5. Tool life 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 3 Mechanics of Metal Cutting Tool must be sharp (what do you mean by sharp? Relative velocity Interference Tool material shall be harder than the work piece material Physical Phenomenon in Machining Plastic flow Fracture Friction Heat Molecular diffusion Chatter 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU At extreme condition • Sticking friction at tip • Deformation at high strain and strain rate • Nascent surface exposed after deformation is very active 4 Objectives During Machining High Material Removal Rate (MRR) Good accuracy and Surface finish Long tool life Cost 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 5 Processing Parameters in Machining Machine Related Depth of cut Spindle speed Feed rate Cutter Related Material Geometry Mounting Workpiece Related Material (composition, homogeneity) Geometry (bar, block, casting etc.) Mounting 6/29/2019 Others – Cutting fluid type and application ASB, CEG,AU 6 Effects of Processing Parameters Cutting forces and Torques and power Tool temperature Frictional effects Work hardening Thermal softening Hot spots on the machined surface on tool face Built up edge Formation Chatter, noise and Vibrations 6/29/2019 Deflection and diameter variations Tool life Surface finish ASB, CEG,AU 7 Tool signature • The numerical code that describes all the key angles of a given cutting tool is called tool signature • Convenient way to specify tool angles by use of standardized abbreviated system is known as tool signature or tool nomenclature. The tool signature comprises of seven elements and is specified in different systems . Systems of description of tool geometry 1. Tool-in-Hand System 2. Machine Reference System - ASA system 3. Tool Reference Systems - Orthogonal Rake System - ORS 1. Tool-in-Hand System • There is no quantitative information, i.e., value of the angles. Tool signature • seven element defining the tool signature 2. Machine Reference System - ASA system • ASA ( American Standards Association) system ASA system • πR = Reference plane; plane perpendicular to the velocity vector • πX = Machine longitudinal plane; plane perpendicular to πR and taken in the direction of assumed longitudinal feed • πY = Machine Transverse plane; plane perpendicular to both πR and πX [This plane is taken in the direction of assumed cross feed] • The axes Xm, Ym and Zm are in the direction of longitudinal feed, cross feed and cutting velocity (vector) respectively. The main geometrical features and angles of single point tools in ASA systems Definition Rake angles • αs= side (axial rake: angle of inclination of the rake surface from the reference plane (πR) and measured on Machine Ref. Plane, πX. • αb= back rake: angle of inclination of the rake surface from the reference plane and measured on Machine Transverse plane, πY. Clearance angles: • θs= side relief angle: angle of inclination of the principal flank from the machined surface and measured on πX plane. • θ e = End relief angle: same as θs but measured on πY plane. Cutting angles: • Cs = side cutting edge angle: angle between the principal cutting edge (its projection on πR) and πY and measured on πR • Ce = end cutting edge angle: angle between the end cutting edge (its projection on πR) from πX and measured on πR Nose radius, r (in inch) • R = nose radius : curvature of the tool tip. It provides strengthening of the tool nose and better surface finish. Tool signature according to ASA system • Tool signature : αb- αs- θe - θs- Ce- Cs-R • Tool signature : 8 -14 - 6 – 6 - 6 – 15 -1 • This system does not indicate behaviour of tool in actual practice. the • Hence actual cutting condition include the side cutting edge (OR) principle cutting edge. 3.Orthogonal Rake System – ORS • Planes and axes of reference 3.Orthogonal Rake System – ORS • πR = Refernce plane perpendicular to the cutting velocity vector, V • πC = cutting plane; plane perpendicular to πR and taken along the principal cutting edge • πO = Orthogonal plane; plane perpendicular to both πR and πC and the axes; • Xo = along the line of intersection of πR and πO • Yo = along the line of intersection of πR and πC • Zo = along the velocity vector, i.e., normal to both Xo and Yo axes. The main geometrical angles used to express tool geometry in Orthogonal Rake System (ORS) 3.Orthogonal Rake System – ORS Rake angles • i= orthogonal rake: angle of inclination of the rake surface from Reference plane, πR and measured on the orthogonal plane, πo • α= inclination angle; angle between πC from the direction of assumed longitudinal feed [πX] and measured on πC Clearance angles • γ = orthogonal clearance of the principal flank: angle of inclination of the principal flank from πC and measured on πo • γ 1 = auxiliary orthogonal clearance: angle of inclination of the auxiliary flank from auxiliary cutting plane, πC’ and measured on auxiliary orthogonal plane, πo’ as indicated in Fig. Cutting angles • λ = principal cutting edge angle: angle between πC and the direction of assumed longitudinal feed or πX and measured on πR • Ce = auxiliary cutting angle: angle between πC’ and πX and measured on πR Nose radius, r (mm) • r = radius of curvature of tool tip Orthogonal Rake System (ORS) i –α – γ – γ1 – Ce –λ – R 0 –10–6 – 6 – 8 –75 –1 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 21 Effect of tool Elements Side cutting edge angle 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. End cutting edge angle Prevents interference as the 1. cutting tool enters the work material Enable the cutting tool to contact the work first behind the tip 2. Affects tool life and surface finish Can vary from 0o to 90o but the 3. satisfactory value is 15o to 30o Smaller angle will result in more contsct area , thinner chip and heat distribution Larger angle results in chatter , separate the work and tool 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU Prevents rubbing (or) drag between machined and non cutting part of the cutting edge 8o to 15o is satisfactory Too large angle cuts the material that supports the conduction of heat 22 Effect of tool Elements Back rake angle 1. 2. Side rake angle Rake angles are three types, positive, zero (sometimes referred to as neutral) and negative Increase in the rake angle reduces the horsepower consumption per unit volume of the layer being removed 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Provides easier flow of chip May be ‘0’, ’-’ , ’+’ Large angle lower the cutting force and power Lesser angles leaves lesser material supports the cutting edge to conduct away the heat Practical rake angle a compromise between these two. Negative rake angle is used with carbide tools since they are having more chance to brittle and less shock resistance – 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 23 Effect of tool Elements Side relief angle End relief angle 1. 2. 3. 4. Avoid rubbing of work piece and tool Small angle given strength to tool increased values –cut more efficiently,reduced cutting forces Too large angle –weaken the cutting edge 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Avoid rubbing of work piece and tool 5o to 15o for general turning Small angle given strength to tool increased values –cut more efficiently,reduced cutting forces Too large angle –weaken the cutting edge Nose radius 6/29/2019 1. Tool life and surface finish 2. Varies from 0.4 to 1.6 mm 3. Too large lead to chatter ASB, CEG,AU 24 Difficulties in Machining Mechanics studies Several physical phenomenon such as plastic flow, fracture, friction, heat, molecular diffusion and chatter are involved. Some of them occur in extrême conditions Friction – sticking; deformation – high strain and strain rate; nascent surface exposed after deformation is very active causing diffusion The cutting zone is covered by chips and coolant. Typical machining is oblique, i.e., forces, torques and deflections exist in all 3 directions. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 25 Cutting Models Tool workpiece workpiece OBLIQUE GEOMETRY ORTHOGONAL GEOMETRY 6/29/2019 Tool ASB, CEG,AU 26 Difficulties in Machining Mechanics studies The typical machining operations are too short and the stock (depth and width of cut) keeps changing. Furthermore, velocity also may change along the cutting edge as well as over time. These changes further compound the difficulties to observe the process carefully. Orthogonal cutting experiments were developed to overcome these difficulties 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 27 Orthogonal cutting Pure orthagonal cutting 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 28 Pure Orthogonal Cutting Facing of thin pipe on a lathe with the cutting edge radial to the pipe. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 29 Oblique cutting Angle of deviation of chip Causes 1.Restricted cutting effect 2.Inclination angle(i≠0) 3.Tool nose radiusing 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 30 Characteristics of Orthogonal Cutting A wedge shaped tool is used Cutting edge is perpendicular to the direction of cut. In other words, cutting edge angle Ce = 90o and cutting edge inclination angle i=0 Uncut chip thickness to is constant along the cutting edge and with respect to time. Cutting edge is longer than the width of the blank and it extends on its both sides. Cutting velocity v is constant along the cutting edge and with respect to time 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 31 Orthogonal Cutting - Experiments Quick stopping devices to freeze the chip formation Cutting wax manually slowly so as to observe it Marking grids on the side of the work piece and study their deformation. Microscopic studies Photoelastic studies (tools made of transparent material such as persbex or resin (araldite); work piece is wax. Resulting fringe patterns are observed under polarized glasses. Observation using high speed cameras Force, torque and power measurements using dynamometers. Temp measurements 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 32 Mechanics of chip formation 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 33 Theories of Chip Formation Chip formation studies helps in understanding mechanics of metal cutting or physics of machining They lead to equations that describe the interdependence of the process parameters such as depth of cut, relative velocity, tool geometry etc. These relations help us in selecting optimal process parameters. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 34 Theories of Chip Formation – Theory of Tear A crack propagates ahead of the tool tip causing tearing similar to splitting wood [Reuleaux in 1900] 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 35 Theories of Chip Formation – Theory of Tear Against the traditional wisdom, the tool was observed to wear, not at the tip, but a little distance away from it. Therefore, this theory was subscribed by many researchers for a long time. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 36 Theories of Chip Formation – Theory of Tear Further studies attributed the wear away from the tip to the following: Chip velocity with respect to the tool is zero at the tip. The tip is protected by BUE. Temp is also high a little away from the tip due to the frictional heat. Subsequent studies proved the chip formation as shear and not tear. Thus the theory of tear was rejected. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 37 Theories of Chip Formation – Theory of Compression The tool compresses the material during machining. This was based on the observation that the chip length was shorter than the uncut chip length. Later it was established that this shortage in length corresponds to the increase chip thickness. Thus this theory too was wrong 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 38 Theories of Chip Formation – Theory of Shear The excessive compressive stress causes shear of the chip at an angle to the cutting direction [Mallock in 1881]. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 39 Theories of Chip Formation – Theory of Shear Mallock’s other contributions Emphasis on the influence of friction at chip-tool interface Studied the effect of cutting fluids Studied the influence of tool sharpness Studied chatter His observations on the above studies still hold good although he could not explain all of them at that time. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 40 Types of chips 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 41 Types of chips produced The type of chip produced depends geometry, and operating conditions. 6/29/2019 upon workpiece material, tool ASB, CEG,AU 42 Types of chips produced Built-up Edge A built-up edge (BUE),consisting of layers of material from the workpiece that are gradually deposited on the tool, may form at the tip of the tool during cutting. As it becomes larger, the BUE becomes unstable and eventually breaks up. Part of the BUE material is carried away by the tools side of the chip,the rest is deposited randomly on the workpiece surface. The process of BUE formation and destruction is repeated continuously during cutting operation unless measures are taken to eliminate it. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 43 Types of chips produced 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 44 Mechanics of Metal cutting The angle formed by the shear plane and the direction of the tool travel is called the shear angle Compressive deformation will cause it to be thicker and shorter than the layer of workpiece material removed The work required to deform this material usually accounts for the largest portion of forces and power involved in a metal removal operation The ratio of chip thickness, to the un-deformed chip thickness (effective feed rate) is called the chip thickness ratio. The lower the chip thickness ratio, the lower the force and heat, and the higher the efficiency of the operation 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 45 Shear angle 1.Tool is perfectly sharp and contacts the chip on its face only 2.The primary deformation takes place in a very thin zone adjacent to ab tc 3.There is no side flow of chip t0 Chip compression coefficient 1 tc k 1 r to Work r cos tan 1 r sin 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 46 Derive an expression for the shear angle in orthogonal cutting In terms of rake angle and chip thickness ratio? There fore t0 * l0 = tc * lc The out ward flow of the r =metal causes the Sinchip to be thicker after separation from the t = l = r tc lc From the triangle abc bc = Sin But bc = t0 r Cos = ratio 1 – rorab Sin ratio is the ratio of uncut chip thickness to the cut The chip thickness cutting ab = t0 ------ (1) Tan chip thickness. Sin From the triangle abd bd = Sin 90-() Tan = abr Cos When metal is cut there is no change in volume of the metal cut therefore 1 r SinAnd But Sin 90-() cos () bd= tc 0 0 parent metal. Metal prior toCos being Is much cut . Cos + longer Sin than Sin the chip which is removed. t0 x b0 x l0 =tc x bc x lc & ttccare angle chip thickness before and after cutting ab t0 shear Therewhere fore can(2)be shown from the above equation () lCos 0 & lc are length of chip before and after cut. From (1) and(2) b0 &tbc are = width Sinofcut before = r and after cut , b0 = bc =b 0 it is observed that b1 = b2 tc 6/29/2019 Cos () ASB, CEG,AU 47 Effect of shear angle tc t0 6/29/2019 α φ ASB, CEG,AU 48 Shear stress and shear strain Dis tan ce Sheared Shear strain, s Thickness of Zone α AC BD φ A Shear Shear stress stress,,ss 6/29/2019 B φ α Shear force Shear stress , s Shear Area B D A 90-α C Distance sheared 90-φ C Fs sinFs (tt00bb00/ sin ) Shear strain, s cot tan( ) ASB, CEG,AU 49 Velocity relationships Cutting speed: Velocity of the tool relative to the workpiece Shear velocity: velocity at which shearing takes place(i.e) velocity of the chip relative to the work Chip velocity: velocity of the chip up the face of the tool 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 50 Velocity relationships 90-(φ- α) VC VC α Vs Vs (φ-α) 90- α φ V V From sine rule(or) Lame’s theorem Vc Vs V sin cos cos( ) 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 51 Numerical problems Pg 14(my ref.) 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 52 Cutting forces and power 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 53 Cutting forces Cutting force determination is required for • Estimation of cutting power consumption, which also enables selection of the power source(s) during design of the machine tools • Structural design of the machine –fixture – tool system • Evaluation of role of the various machining parameters on cutting forces Process –Speed (V), feed (f or to), depth of cut (b), Tool —material and geometry, environment Cutting fluid • Study of behaviour and machinability characterization of the work materials • Condition monitoring of the cutting tools and machine tools. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 54 Cutting forces during turning The single point cutting tools being used for turning, shaping, planing, slotting, boring etc. are characterised by having only one cutting force during machining. But that force is resolved into two or three components for ease of analysis and exploitation. Fig. visualises how the single cutting force in turning is resolved into three components along the three orthogonal directions; X, Y and Z. These three components are: c Cutting force (Fc) acts in tangential direction. It is also called power component as it being acting along and being multiplied by cutting speed (V) decides cutting power consumption. c t r Feed Force (Ft) acts in the direction of feed (axial direction). Generally, this force is small in magnitude but is responsible for causing dimensional inaccuracy and vibration. Thrust Force (Fr): acts in radial direction. This force is least harmful and hence least significant. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 55 Cutting models Turning model 6/29/2019 Orthogonal model ASB, CEG,AU 56 Other force components • shear force(Fs): A force that attempts to cause the internal structure of a material to slide against itself. • Normal force(Fn): Force normal to the shear force • Friction force(Ff) Force resist the chip along the rake face of the tool • Normal reaction(N) Force normal to the frictional force Coefficient of friction, Ff N • Resultant force(R) forces Ff and N added vectorially and oriented at an angle β tan 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 57 Force Relationships R Ff β Fs N Fc R R 6/29/2019 Ft Fn ASB, CEG,AU 58 Merchants force analysis-Assumptions • • • • • Tool is perfectly sharp Chip doesn’t flow either side Depth of cut is constant Width of the tool is greater than of work piece Work moves relative the tool at uniform velocity • Continuous chips produced without any built up edge. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 59 Merchant circle β 6/29/2019 β ASB, CEG,AU 60 Force Relaionships G Fs A Fc αφ D Ft α K Fn E L αφ B O φ To find Fsf OC=OE+BD KL=AL-AK ∆OAE, AL=F ∆OAL, OE=FccCos Sin α φ ∆ABD,BD=FttSin ∆ABK,AK=F Cosφα therefore Fsf=Fc Sin Cosα+F φ-FttCos Sin φα Ff N J C To To find find FNn OC=OE+BD BC=AE-AD ∆OAL, ∆OAE, OL=F AE=Fcc Sin Cosφα ∆ABK,BK=F ∆ABD,AD=FttCos Sinαφ therefore therefore FFn=F =F Sin φ +Ft Cos αφ f ccCos α-Ft Sin Relation between FC, Ft, Fsf and N Fn 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 61 • Numerical problems? 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 62 Power and Energy Relationships Power=Force x Velocity 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 63 Power and Energy Relationships 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 64 Power and Energy Relationships E Es E f Total Specific Energy required per unit time E bt0V F bt0 Total specific Energy=Total Energy/Unit volume of material removal e c ef 6/29/2019 Ef bt 0V F f Vc bt 0V Ff r bt 0 Ff bt c es ASB, CEG,AU Es FV Fs cos s s bt 0V bt 0V bt 0 cos( ) 65 Temperature in cutting 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 66 Temperature in cutting-Effects Work piece • Affects the strength, hardness and wear resistance • Affects the properties of machined surface and its properties • Causing distortion of machine Tool 6/29/2019 Work piece • Poor dimensional control of work piece Machine tool ASB, CEG,AU 67 Factors affect the temperature pattern (temperature distribution) in cutting zone Feed Depth of cut Cutting speed Specific heat ,Thermal conductivity 6/29/2019 Type of cutting fluid Temperature pattern ASB, CEG,AU Chip tool Contact length 68 Heat Zones Shear Zone • More heat generated due to shearing action of tool • Heat carried by chip(90 to 95%) • Heat conducted by work piece(5 to 10%) Friction zone • Heat generated due to friction and also due to secondary deformation of the built up edge • Heat carried by chip(90 to 95%) • Heat conducted by work piece(5 to 10%) w/p tool contact zone • Heat is generated due to burnishing action of the tool • Minimum with fresh tool • Temperature increases with cutting time 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 69 Methods of Measuring Temperature Tc 6/29/2019 T W mC ASB, CEG,AU 70 Analytical calculation Assumptions 1. Orthogonal cutting of second kind 2. Effect of tool flank wear neglected 3. Entire heat supplied as reappear heat 4. Shear and friction energy distributed uniformly over the contact region 5. Thermal properties of tool and work are independent of working temperature 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 71 Analytical model T Ts T f Temperature rise due to shear Heat=mass x Temp.difference x sp.heat t0Vb0 (Ts T0 )C x 0.9 Es t0Vb0 (Ts T0 )C y Rearranging for Ts Ts Vc a chip tool contact length kg m 3 b x V m s 0.9 FsVs T0 t0bC V y a T K C J Kg o K Orthogonal model o 0.9( Fc cos Ft sin ) cos k W m Ts T0 (1) t0bC cos( ) K m2 s 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 72 Analytical model Temperature rise due to friction According to joggers solution temperature rise at the interface of sliding (insulated)with a conducting surface at constant velocity L Vt 2K W mK 0.754 q t k L where Thermal diffusivity, K k C m 2 s For our case, qf Ff Vc ab (2) and L Vc aC (3) 4k Only 90% heat goes to the chip tool interface and 10% to the tool Tf 0.754 0.9 q f a 6/29/2019 2k L (4) and T f ASB, CEG,AU 0.679 F f b Vc (5) akC 73 Analytical model Therefore chip tool interface temperature T Ts T f 0.679 F f 0.9( Fc cos Ft sin ) cos T T0 t0bC cos( ) b 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU Vc akC 74 Tool life 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 75 Machinability The ease with which a given material may be worked with a cutting tool under a set of cutting conditions is defined as The of the tool machinability Chip hardness Ease of chip disposal Cutting forces generated Heat generated Shear angle/chip thickness ratio Dimension stability of the work The quality of the Machined surface Specific power consumptio n Tool wear/tool life Quality of the machined surface The power consumption per unit volume of the material removed 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 76 Machinability index Relative to the machinability of the standard material Machinability of free cutting steel is arbitrary fixed as 100% Machinabil ityIndex Cutting speed of material for 20 minutes tool life x 100 Cutting speed of free cutting steel for 20 minutes tool life FCS-sulphur0.08-0.3,Phosporous, carbon 0.1 to 0.45 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 77 Tool Life The period during which a tool cuts satisfactorily is called its tool life Expressed in minutes Most widely used criteria for machinability 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 78 Measures for tool life Machine time Actual cutting time Average length of cut/tool edge Average volume of metal removed/cutting edge Average number of identical components/cutting edge Cutting speed for a standard value of machining time 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 79 Tool life Relationship by F.W.Taylor VT C n V-Cutting speed in m/min T-Tool life in minutes n- an exponent C-Machining constant(Depending on the cutting condition /work material) 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 80 Tool life -Materials 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 81 Modified Taylor’s Tool life equation VT d f C n x y Where, D and f are in mm V in m/min T in Minutes X and y must be determined for each cutting condition Note: For Constant tool life 1. F and d increased V should be decreased 2. Depending on the exponents , a reduction in the speed result in the increase in the volume of material removed because of increase in the depth of cut and feed rate. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 82 Numerical Problems? 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 83 Tool Wear and Failure 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 84 Temperature in Primary and Secondary Machining Regions 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 85 Cubic Boron Nitride Heat Control all the mechanisms of tool failure so tool life is limited only by abrasion wear 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 86 Tool Failure Mechanisms 1. Abrasive wear 2. Built-up edge • Rake surface • Flank surface 3. Thermal/mechanical cracking/chipping 4. Cratering 5. Thermal deformation 6. Chipping • • Mechanical Thermal expansion 7. Notching 8. Fracture 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 87 Wear a) Flank wear and crater wear in a cutting tool; b) View of the flank face of a turning tool, showing various wear patterns. c) View of the rake face of a turning tool, showing various wear patterns. d) Types of wear on a turning tool: 1. flank wear; 2. crater wear; 3. chipped cutting edge; 4. thermal cracking on rake face; 5. built-up edge; 6. catastrophic failure. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU Courtesy of Kennametal, Inc. 88 Comparison of Catastrophic and Progressive Failure Catastrophic Failure Caused by dynamic changes Intermittent cutting Ramping Sudden changes in tool load In-homogeneity (hard particles or voids) in the raw material Micro-cracks in tool during HT Temp gradient due to non-uniform coolant flow Progressive Wear Caused by gradual wear of the tool due to Adhesion, Abrasion Diffusion. Undesirable since Desirable since Tool is lost for ever The tool can be reused by Damage the part or injure the regrinding or indexing/ operator Changing the bit Unpredictable and hence Predictable and hence corrective corrective action is not possible action is possible Closed loop control system used to Time bound regrinding is suggested 6/29/2019 tool failure ASB, CEG,AU 89 prevent approach Comparison of Crater and Flank Wear Crater Wear Flank Wear Occurs on the rake face Highly sensitive to temperature Occurs on the flank face Not as much sensitive to temp as crater wear Undesirable wear Used as failure criteria for brittle tools such as WC and Al2O3 tools Most desirable wear Used as failure criteria for tough tools such as HSS 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 90 Locations of Tool Wear 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 91 6/29/2019 Rapid failure Constant Period Break In Period Abrasive Wear (Abrasion) Abrasive wear occurs as a result of the interaction between the workpiece and the cutting edge. The width of the wear land is determined by the amount of contact between the cutting edge and the workpiece. ASB, CEG,AU 92 Heat Related Tool Failure Mechanisms Cratering (Chemical Wear) The chemical properties of the tool-material and the affinity of the toolmaterial to the workpiece material determine the development of the crater wear mechanism Hardness of the tool-material does not have much affect on the process. The metallurgical relationship between the materials determines the amount of crater wear. Ex: Tungsten carbide and steel have an affinity to each other The mechanism is very temperature-dependent, making it greatest at high cutting speeds. Atomic interchange takes place with a two-way transfer of ferrite from the steel into the tool. Carbon also diffuses into the chip. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 93 Heat Related Tool Failure Mechanisms Built-up Edge (Adhesion) It occurs mainly at low machining temperatures on the chip face of the tool. It can take place with long chipping and short-chipping workpiece materials—steel and aluminum. This mechanism often leads to the formation of a built-up edge between the chip and edge. It is common for the build-up edge to shear off and then to reform. At certain temperature ranges, affinity between tool and workpiece material and the load from cutting forces combine to create the adhesion wear mechanism. Machining work-hardening materials, such as austenitic stainless steel, this wear mechanism can lead to rapid build-up at the depth of cut line resulting in notching as the failure mode. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 94 Heat Related Tool Failure Mechanisms Built-up Edge (Adhesion) Increased surface speeds, proper application of coolant, and tool coatings are effective control actions for built-up edge Thermal Cracking (Fatigue wear) Thermal cracking is a result of thermo mechanical actions Temperature fluctuations plus the loading and unloading of cutting forces lead to cracking and breaking of the cutting edge Carbide and ceramics are relatively poor conductors of heat which leads to fatigue wear Thermal Deformation As the cutting edge loses its hot hardness the forces created by the feed rate cause the cutting edge to deform 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 95 Mechanical Failure Mechanisms Chipping (Mechanical) Small chipping of tool material Cutting force should be less than shearing force. Chipping is larger on flank surface than on a face Rake Surface 6/29/2019 Flank Surface ASB, CEG,AU 96 Mechanical Failure Mechanisms Insert Fracture When the edge strength of an insert is exceeded by the forces of the cutting process the inevitable result is the catastrophic failure called fracture. Excessive flank wear land development, shock loading due to interrupted cutting, improper grade selection or improper insert size selection are the most frequently encountered causes of insert fracture 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 97 Heat Related Tool Failure Mechanisms Property Carbon and low to medium alloy steels H S S Cast Cobalt alloys Cemented carbide Coated carbide Ceramics Poly crystalline CBN Diamond Hot hardness Toughness Wear resistance Chipping resistance Cutting speed Thermal shock resistance Total material cost 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 98 Surface finish and integrity 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 99 Surface finish and integrity A PART SURFACE has two important aspects that must be defined and controlled. The first concerns the geometric irregularities of the surface. second concerns the metallurgical alterations of the surface and the surface layer. This second aspect has been termed surface integrity. Both surface finish and surface integrity must be defined, measured, and maintained within specified limits in the processing of any product. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 100 Surface Finish Surface finish is often the superposition of two effects: result of Ideal surface roughness: Due to tool geometry and feed rate Natural surface roughness: Due to irregularities in the cutting operation 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 101 Factors Surface finish is determined by many factors, which can be grouped in to 1.Geometric factors 2.Work material factors 3.Machine tool factors and vibration 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 102 1.Geometric factors High feeds produce more prominent marks on surface Most evident from rotating tool or workpiece Turning, boring, milling, reaming, grinding Tool geometry =SCEA, ECEA, Nose radius Feed marks due to tool geometry and tool advance per revolution Roughness, R, is proportional to feed for a given geometry 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 103 2.Work material factors • Build up edge cyclically forms and breaks away, particles are deposited on the newly generated work surface causes rough surface • Curling chip back to the work piece produce damage to the work surface. • Tearing of the work surface during chip formation when machining ductile material • Cracks in the work surface during discontinuous chip formation when machining brittle material. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 104 3.Vibration and machine tool factors • These factors related to the machine tool and operation set up. They include chatter and vibration in the machine tool, deflection fixturing and backlash in the feed mechanism. • These machine tool factors can be minimized or eliminated by –providing damping and adding stiffness –proper cutting speeds ( cutting speeds do not cause cyclical forces whose frequency approaches natural frequency of the machine tool) –reducing feeds and depth of cut –changing the cutter design to reduce forces 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 105 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 106 Surface finishes achieved in various Machining operations 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 107 Machine Tool Vibration •Chatter refers to vibration of tool and workpiece Produces undesirable finish Can also be damaging to tool life -May introduce shock loads •High frequency vibration can be frustrating •Low frequency vibration may be transmitted to other equipment 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 108 Types 1. Forced vibrations Usually caused by an oscillating force not directly related to the cutting process itself Transmission from other machines Unbalanced shafts, gears, motors 2. Self-excited vibrations Caused by instability in the cutting process itself Generally occurs at or near the natural frequency of vibration of the part 3. Regenerative chatter Generally occurs when cuts overlap or when subsequent cuts are taken after an initial one Thus chatter marks left by previous cut may induce a forced vibration of higher amplitude than previous cut 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 109 Machine Tool Vibration – Reduction • Can be minimized by – Increasing damping • Making natural frequency of system much less than frequency of the exciting force • Damping arises in: Material of the machine tool Frictional damping in bolted joints Viscous damping in lubricated interfaces Slideways, bearings, etc. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 110 STRUCTURE OF MACHINE TOOLS 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 111 Required performance 1. Strength 2. Stiffness 3. Rigidity 4. Provision to ensure relative location and alignment 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 112 Machine body • Basic structure of machine tool • Bed, column or upright or combination of both • Locating datum surfaces(guide ways) Must possess • Shape invariability along with strength • Producibility • Low material requirement • Low cost Depends upon • Proper selection of material and manufacturing process • Provision for static and dynamic rigidity • High wear resistance of guide ways 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 113 Stiffening devices 1.Parallel 2.Diagonal ribs Plate or Rib section • Superior compared to above Body • Strong in vertical direction An example of a • Less against torsional strainmachine-tool structure. The boxtype, one-piece Box section design with internal diagonal ribs • Best stiffness in torsion significantly • Withstand bending forces improves the stiffness of the machine. Source: Okuma • Easy to produce Machinery Works Tubular Section Ltd. • No internal corners 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 114 ii)Guide ways Guide way constrain the work or tool path in a definite way Requirements – Accuracy of travel – Durability – Rigidity Types of guide ways – Slide ways – Antifriction ways – Hydrostatic guide ways 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 115 Slideways Vee slide Flat ways Dovetail Cylindrical 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 116 Antifriction • • • • • Overcomes “slipstick” Roller or ball Higher cost Accurate working surfaces Used for precision machine tools 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 117 Hydrostatically lubricated ways • Pressurized oil • Pressurized air(0.3 to 0.5 N/mm2) • Less clearance(15 to 25 microns) is the requirement 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 118 Material for machine body and guide ways • Damping out vibrations • Wear resistant Integral unit Material -Grey cast iron 1.Any complex shape 2.Good machinability 3. Less cost 1. Large machining allowance 2. More time 3. Production defects 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 119 Material for machine body and guide ways Welded structures Material-Rolled steel 1. 2. 3. 4. Less cost Time saving Lightness Higher mechanical properties 1. Not sensitive to shock loads 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 120 Material for machine body and guide ways Material: Plastic 1. 2. 3. 4. 3. Antiscoring Low modulus of elasticity Anticorrosion Low coefficient of thermal conductivity Less friction Excellent wearing Tendency to swell qualities when absorb oil’ Material: Pads of zinc or of bronze 1. Good wear resistance 2. Expensive 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 121 iii)Spindle and spindle bearings Requirements Withstand forces Vibration-proof properties • Rotational accuracy •Affect accuracy •Essential high speed and high surface finish operation •Able to rotate at varying speeds •Reduced service life of bearings •Essential in relatively long longitudinal motion of spindles •Nose run out (radial and axial) •Rigidity •Wear resistance 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 122 Material for spindle Rigidity –young’s modulus (i)Medium carbon structural steel(C-45) • Heat treated (quenched and tempered) to 22-28 Rc Surface at 40-50 Rc • Induction hardening recommended for less distortion with high hardness ii)Low carbon case hardening steel • Carburization, quenching and tempered to 56-62 Rc • Nitriding, quenching and tempered is recommended for precision machine tools 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 123 Material for spindle iii) Manganese steel • Heavy machines • Heavy loads • Normalization or hardening , tempering to 28-35 Rc iv) Grey or nodular cast iron • Hollow spindles • Large diameter • Horizontal boring machines and other Bearings • Sliding contact bearing -Babbitt, Cast iron, Bronze, Nylon Delrin • Hydrostatic bearings • Air bearing 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 124 Machining Economics 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 125 Machining Economics Graphs showing (a)cost per piece and (b)time per piece in machining. Note the optimum speeds for both cost and time. The range between the two is known as the high-efficiency machining range. Tool material 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 127 Desirable properties of tool material 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 128 Desirable properties of tool material Hot hardness – High hot hardness means higher speeds and feed rates (higher production rates and lower costs). Toughness and Impact strength – Tool does not chip or fracture Thermal shock resistance Wear resistance – Tool does not have to be replaced as often Chemical stability and inertness – To minimize adverse reactions 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 129 Development of Cutting Tool Materials 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 130 Characteristics of Tool Materials Property Carbon and low to mediu m alloy steels HSS Cast Cobalt alloys Cemente d carbide Coated carbide Ceramics Poly crystallin e CBN Diamond Depth of cut Light to medium Light to heavy Light to heavy Light to heavy Light to heavy Light to heavy Light to heavy Very light for single crystal Finish Obtainable Rough Rough Rough Good Good Very good Very good excellent Method of processing Wrought Wrought, cast, HIP, sintering Cast, HIP and sintering Cold pressing and sintering CVD Cold pressing and sintering High pressure and high temp. sintering High pressure and high temp sintering Fabrication Machini ng and grinding Machinin g and grinding Grinding Grinding Grinding Grinding Grinding and polishing Grinding and polishing 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 131 Factors affecting selection of Tool Materials Hardness and condition of the workpiece material Operations to be performed Amount of stock to be removed Accuracy and finish requirements Type, capability, and condition of the machine tool to be used Rigidity of the tool and workpiece 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 132 Factors affecting selection of Tool Materials Production requirements influencing the speeds and feeds selected Operating conditions such as cutting forces and temperatures Tool cost per part machined, including initial tool cost, grinding cost, tool life, frequency of regrinding or replacement, and labor cost—the most economical tool is not necessarily the one providing the longest life, or the one having the lowest initial cost 6/29/2019 No Tool Material Satisfies All These Criterion ASB, CEG,AU 133 High Speed Steel High alloy steel They are either molybdenum or tungsten based but necessarily contains 4% chromium M = Molybdenum T = Tungsten M >40 = Super HSS materials; capable of treating to high hardness 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 134 High Speed Steel Advantages of HSS Heat treated to high hardness within the range of Rc 63–68 M40 series of HSSs is normally capable of being hardened to Rc70, but a maximum of Rc68 is recommended to avoid brittleness HSSs also possess a high level of wear resistance HSS tools possess an adequate degree of impact toughness and are more capable of taking the shock loading of interrupted cuts than carbide tools When HSSs are in the annealed state they can be fabricated, hot worked, machined, ground, and the like, to produce the cutting tool shape Toughness in HSSs can be increased by adjusting the chemistry to a lower carbon level 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 135 High Speed Steel Limitations of HSS Tendency of the carbide to agglomerate in the centers of large ingots Improved properties and grindability are important advantages of powdered metal HSSs hardness of these materials falls off rapidly when machining temperatures exceed about 538–593°C use of lower cutting speeds than those used with carbides, ceramics 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 136 High Speed Steel Applications of HSS Most drills, reamers, taps, thread chasers, end mills, and gear Cutting tools are made from HSSs HSS tools are usually preferred for operations performed at low cutting speeds and on older, less Rigid, low-horsepower machine tools Powder metallurgy HSS Uniform structure with fine carbide particles and no segregation Lower in cost because of reduced material, labor, and machining costs, compared to those made from wrought materials Near net shape more design flexibility Applications : Milling cutters 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 137 Cemented Tungsten Carbide Most carbide grades are made up of tungsten carbide with a cobalt binder Advantages of WC Hardness of softest WC is higher than hardened steel High hot hardness Grades of WC Straight WC Co as a binder Best suited for material having abrasion as a primary tool wear e.g. cast iron, non ferrous materials, non metals Complex WC Comprises carbides : TiC, TaC, NbC with Co as a binder ferrous materials, non metals 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 138 Cemented Tungsten Carbide Tungsten carbide is extremely hard and offers the excellent resistance to abrasion wear The most significant benefit of TiC is a reduction in the tendency of the tool to fail by cratering. The most significant contribution of TaC is that it increases the hot hardness of the tool, which in turn reduces thermal deformation Effect of Co as a binder Co is more sensitive to heat, abrasion and welding The more cobalt present, the softer the tool, making it more sensitive to thermal deformation, abrasive wear and chip welding Cobalt is stronger than carbide. Therefore, more cobalt improves the tool strength and resistance to shock 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 139 Cemented Tungsten Carbide Classification system ISO classification number ranges from 05 to 50 : e.g. P20, K35, M40; 05 is most wear resistance whereas 50 is most fracture resistance Coated carbide tools is the most significant advance in cutting tool materials since the development of WC tooling Various single and multiple coatings of carbides and nitrides of titanium, hafnium, and zirconium and coatings of oxides of aluminum and zirconium, as well as improved substrates better suited for coating, have been developed to increase the range of applications for coated carbide inserts. 6/29/2019 C- Classification ISO- Classification C1 to C4 for Cast iron C5 to C8 for Steel P = Stainless Steel M = Steel K = Cast Iron ASB, CEG,AU 140 Ceramics Ceramics are primarily aluminum oxides Inconsistent and unsatisfactory results during initial periods of development Improvements : better control of microstructure (primarily in grain size refinement) and density, improved processing, the use of additives, the development of composite materials, and better grinding and edge preparation methods. Tools made from these materials are now stronger, more uniform, and higher in quality 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 141 Ceramics Types of ceramics Plain ceramics, which are highly pure (99 percent or more) and contain only minor amounts of secondary oxides (produced by powder metallurgy) Composite ceramics : are Al203-based materials containing 15–30 percent or more titanium carbide (TiC) and/or other alloying ingredients 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 142 Ceramics Advantages Increased productivity: Ceramic cutting tools are operated at higher cutting speeds than tungsten carbide tools Good hot hardness, low coefficient of friction, high wear resistance, chemical inertness, and low coefficient of thermal conductivity Most of the heat generated during cutting is carried away in the chips, resulting in less heat buildup in the workpiece, insert and tool holder Better size control by less tool wear Machining of many hard materials 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 143 Ceramics Limitations Brittle than carbides Less mechanical and thermal shock resistance Less interchangeability with the carbide tool holders Applications High speed machining of steel and cast iron requiring continuous machining Most suitable for machining of chemically active materials Face milling and turning applications 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 144 Single crystal and polycrystalline diamonds(PCD) Best suited for precision machining with very high surface finish and to increase productivity by reducing downtimes Diamond is the cubic crystalline form of carbon that is produced in various sizes under high heat and pressure. Natural, mined single-crystal stones of the industrial type used for cutting tools are cut (sawed, cleaved, or lapped) to produce the cutting-edge geometry required for the application. Advantages Hardest material known. Indentation hardness is five times than carbide. Extreme hardness and abrasion resistance can result retaining their cutting edges virtually unchanged throughout most of their useful lives Because of the diamond’s chemical inertness, low coefficient of friction, and smoothness, chips do not adhere to its surface or form built-up edges when nonferrous and nonmetallic materials are machined. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 145 Cubic Boron Nitride Super abrasive crystal that is second in hardness and abrasion resistance only to diamond CBN crystals are used most commonly in super abrasive wheels for precision grinding of steels and super alloys Advantages Greater heat resistance than diamond tools High level of chemical inertness Compacted CBN tools are suitable, unlike diamond tools, for the high speed machining of tool and alloy steels with hardness to Rc70, steel forgings and Ni-hard or chilled cast irons with hardness from Rc45–68, surface-hardened parts, and nickel or cobalt-based super alloys They have also been used successfully for machining powdered metals, plastics, and graphite. 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 146 Cutting fluids 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 147 Cutting fluids Cutting fluid is used to: 1. Reduce friction and wear 2. Cool the cutting zone 3. Reduce forces and energy consumption 4. Flush away the chips from the cutting zone 5. Protect the machined surface from environmental corrosion • Depending on the type of machining operation, a coolant, a lubricant, or both are used • Effectiveness of cutting fluids depends on type of machining operation, tool and workpiece materials and cutting speed 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 148 Cutting-fluid Action • Cutting fluid seep from the sides of the chip through the capillary action of the interlocking network of surface asperities in the interface • Discontinuous cutting operations have more straightforward mechanisms for lubricant application, but the tools are more susceptible to thermal shock 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 149 Effects of Cutting Fluids on Machining If no coolant, 1. Friction at the tool–chip interface will increase 2. The shear angle will decrease in accordance 3. The shear strain will increase 4. The chip will become thicker 5. A built-up edge is likely to form 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 150 Effects of Cutting Fluids on Machining As a result: 1. The shear energy in the primary zone will increase 2. The frictional energy in the secondary zone will increase 3. The total energy will increase 4. The temperature in the cutting zone will rise 5. Surface finish will to deteriorate and dimensional tolerances may be difficult to maintain 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 151 Types of Cutting Fluids 1. Oils - mineral, animal, vegetable, compounded, and synthetic oils, 2. Emulsions - a mixture of oil and water and additives 3. Semi synthetics - chemical emulsions containing little mineral oil 4. Synthetics - chemicals with additives 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 152 Methods of Cutting-fluid Application 4 basic methods: 1. Flooding 2. Mist 3. High-pressure systems 4. Through the cutting tool system 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 153 Selection of a cutting fluid 1. Workpiece material and machine tools 2. Biological considerations 3. Environment • Machine-tool operator is in close proximity to cutting fluids, thus health effects is a primary concern • Progress has been made in ensuring the safe use of cutting fluids • Recycling involves treatment of the fluids with various additives, agents, biocides, deodorizers and water treatment 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 154 Near-dry and Dry Machining • Near-dry cutting is the application of a fine mist of an air–fluid mixture containing a very small amount of cutting fluid • Dry machining is effective on steels, steel alloys, and cast irons, but not for aluminum alloys • One of the functions of a metal-cutting fluid is to flush chips from the cutting zone Cryogenic Machining • Using nitrogen or carbon dioxide as a coolant • The chips are more brittle and machinability is increased 6/29/2019 ASB, CEG,AU 155