Mapping – PEOs to SOs Program Educational Objectives (PEOs) or “Unit Goals” 1) Students will achieve professional knowledge, skill and competence in their particular concentration in Engineering Technology. 2) Students will learn to communicate effectively in a professional environment. 3) Students will understand the ethical and societal impact of engineering practices. 4) Students will understand the need for professionalism in their respective field of employment or business. 5) Students will demonstrate job preparedness and specific background training in their respective concentration in Engineering Technology. ABET Student Outcomes (SOs) or “Measureable Outcomes” a. b. c. d. e. f. g. h. i. j. k. An ability to select and apply the knowledge, techniques, skills, and modern tools of the discipline to broadly-defined engineering technology activities; An ability to select and apply a knowledge of mathematics, science, engineering, and technology to engineering technology problems that require the application of principles and applied procedures or methodologies; An ability to conduct standard tests and measurements; to conduct, analyze, and interpret experiments; and to apply experimental results to improve processes; An ability to design systems, components, or processes for broadly-defined engineering technology problems appropriate to program educational objectives; An ability to function effectively as a member or leader on a technical team; An ability to identify, analyze, and solve broadly-defined engineering technology problems; An ability to apply written, oral, and graphical communication in both technical and non-technical environments; and an ability to identify and use appropriate technical literature; An understanding of the need for and an ability to engage in self-directed continuing professional development; An understanding of and a commitment to address professional and ethical responsibilities including a respect for diversity; A knowledge of the impact of engineering technology solutions in a societal and global context; and A commitment to quality, timeliness, and continuous improvement. SO[a] SO[b] SO[c] SO[d] SO[e] SO[f] SO[g] SO[h] SO[i] SO[j] SO[k] PEO1 X X X X PEO2 PEO3 PEO4 PEO5 X X X X X X X 1 Mappings – Courses to SOs Course 100 a 132 x b c d e x f g x h i x j k x x x x x x 202 x 205 212 x x 213 221 x x x x x x 225 x x x x x 226 x x x x x 231 x x x x 232 x x x x 234 x x 241 x x x x x 244 271 x x x x x x 283 x 305 320 x x 331 x x 332 x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x 336 353 355 357 x x 361 x x 363 x x 365 x 371 x x x x x x x x x x 2 Mappings – Courses to SOs cont… Course 375 a x b x c d 376 x 381 x x x x 385 x x 386 x x 434 x 435 x x x x j k x x x x x x x 446 x x x x x x x x x 441 443 x x X x x 448 i x x 436 445 h x x x 433 442 g x x 425 431 f x 390 410 e x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x 463 x 465 478 x x x 480 484 x x x 488 x 492 x 493 x 494 x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x 3 Rubrics for Assessing Student Outcomes Rubric AB – for assessing Student Outcomes [a] and [b]: a. b. An ability to select and apply the knowledge, techniques, skills, and modern tools of the discipline to broadly-defined engineering technology activities; An ability to select and apply a knowledge of mathematics, science, engineering, and technology to engineering technology problems that require the application of principles and applied procedures or methodologies; Computer Engineering 1. Student demonstrates an ability to select and apply scientific and mathematical knowledge, techniques, skills, and modern engineering tools to broadly defined technology activities; involving, for example, electronic devices, microprocessors, power electronics, microprocessors, etc. Construction Engineering Performance Criteria 1. Student demonstrates an ability to select and apply scientific and mathematical knowledge, techniques, skills, and modern engineering tools to broadly defined construction technology activities; involving, for example, construction materials and methods, and analysis of simple beams and trusses, etc. Below Expectations - 1 Student fails to solve typical problems in computer technology. Student fails to identify proper materials and methods, and/or solve typical problems in construction technology. Progressing to Criteria - 2 Meets Criteria - 3 Exceeds Criteria - 4 Score Student identifies typical problems, but struggles to identify and select proper scientific and mathematical tools to solve problems. Student correctly identifies typical problems, selects and applies basic scientific and mathematical tools, but makes minor mistakes during the process. Student establishes a clear pattern of correctly identifying, selecting and applying the necessary knowledge, techniques, and skills required to solve relevant problems in computer engineering technology. At least 70% of students in CpET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Student identifies typical problems, but struggles to identify and select proper scientific and mathematical tools to solve problems. Student correctly identifies typical problems, selects and applies basic scientific and mathematical tools, but makes minor mistakes during the process. Student establishes a clear pattern of correctly identifying, selecting and applying the necessary knowledge, techniques, and skills required to solve relevant problems in construction engineering technology. At least 70% of students in CET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). 4 Energy Engineering Industrial Engineering Mechanical Engineering 1. Student demonstrates an ability to select and apply scientific and mathematical knowledge, techniques, skills, and modern engineering tools to broadly defined energy technology activities; involving, for example, energy generating and energy consuming devices. 1. Student demonstrates an ability to select and apply scientific and mathematical knowledge, techniques, skills, and modern engineering tools to broadly defined industrial technology activities; such as manufacturing processes and systems, and management of technical organizations. 1. Student demonstrates an ability to select and apply scientific and mathematical knowledge, techniques, skills, and modern engineering tools to broadly defined mechanical engineering technology activities; for example, the principles of solid and fluid mechanics, machine design, thermodynamics, and heat transfer. Student fails to identify proper materials and methods, and/or solve typical problems in energy engineering technology. Student fails to identify proper materials and methods, and/or solve typical problems in industrial engineering. Student fails to identify proper materials and methods, and/or solve typical problems in mechanical engineering technology. Student identifies typical problems, but struggles to identify and select proper scientific and mathematical tools to solve problems. Student correctly identifies typical problems, selects and applies basic scientific and mathematical tools, but makes minor mistakes during the process. Student establishes a clear pattern of correctly identifying, selecting and applying the necessary knowledge, techniques, and skills required to solve relevant problems in energy engineering technology. At least 70% of students in EET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Student identifies typical problems, but struggles to identify and select proper scientific and mathematical tools to solve problems. Student correctly identifies typical problems, selects and applies basic scientific and mathematical tools, but makes minor mistakes during the process. Student establishes a clear pattern of correctly identifying, selecting and applying the necessary knowledge, techniques, and skills required to solve relevant problems in industrial engineering technology. At least 70% of students in IET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Student identifies typical problems, but struggles to identify and select proper scientific and mathematical tools to solve problems. Student correctly identifies typical problems, selects and applies basic scientific and mathematical tools, but makes minor mistakes during the process. Student establishes a clear pattern of correctly identifying, selecting and applying the necessary knowledge, techniques, and skills required to solve relevant problems in mechanical engineering technology. At least 70% of students in MET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). 5 Rubric C – for assessing Student Outcomes [c]: c. An ability to conduct standard tests and measurements; to conduct, analyze, and interpret experiments; and to apply experimental results to improve processes; Computer Engineering 2. Student demonstrates an ability to conduct standard tests and measurements; conduct, analyze and interpret experiments, and apply results to improve processes; for example, electrical measurements, electrical wiring codes and specifications, etc. Construction Engineering 2. Student demonstrates an ability to conduct standard tests and measurements; conduct, analyze and interpret experiments, and apply results to improve processes; for example, supervised field practice in the layout of construction projects, etc. Energy Engineering Performance Criteria 2. Student demonstrates an ability to conduct standard tests and measurements; conduct, analyze and interpret experiments, and apply results to improve processes; for example, material properties testing and measurement, and the limitations and failures of engineering materials in the energy industry, etc. Below Expectations - 1 Progressing to Criteria - 2 Meets Criteria - 3 Exceeds Criteria - 4 Score Student fails to follow correct experimental procedures, or make proper measurements, or analyze and interpret results, or apply results to improve processes. Student understands standard procedures and experimental conditions of tests, but displays difficulty in analyzing and interpreting data, and/or using results to improve processes. Student understands standard procedures and measurements, conducts experiments correctly, and analyzes and interprets data correctly most of the time, but occasionally fails to do so. Student displays a clear pattern of understanding procedures and tests, analyzes and interprets data confidently, and uses results obtained to improve technological processes. At least 70% of students in CpET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Student fails to follow correct experimental procedures, or make proper measurements, or analyze and interpret results, or apply results to improve processes. Student understands standard procedures and experimental conditions of tests, but displays difficulty in analyzing and interpreting data, and/or using results to improve processes. Student understands standard procedures and measurements, conducts experiments correctly, and analyzes and interprets data correctly most of the time, but occasionally commits minor errors in the process. Student displays a clear pattern of understanding procedures and tests, analyzes and interprets data confidently, and uses results obtained to improve technological processes. At least 70% of students in CET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Student fails to follow correct experimental procedures, or make proper measurements, or analyze and interpret results, or apply results to improve processes. Student understands standard procedures and experimental conditions of tests, but displays difficulty in analyzing and interpreting data, and/or using results to improve processes. Student understands standard procedures and measurements, conducts experiments correctly, and analyzes and interprets data correctly most of the time, but occasionally commits minor errors in the process. Student displays a clear pattern of understanding procedures and tests, analyzes and interprets data confidently, and uses results obtained to improve processes involving energy technology. At least 70% of students in EET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). 6 Mechanical Engineering Industrial Engineering 2. Student demonstrates an ability to conduct standard tests and measurements; conduct, analyze and interpret experiments, and apply results to improve processes; for example, the properties testing and characterization of industrial materials. 2. Student demonstrates an ability to conduct standard tests and measurements; conduct, analyze and interpret experiments, and apply results to improve processes; for example, advanced analyses of engineering materials. Student fails to follow correct experimental procedures, or make proper measurements, or analyze and interpret results, or apply results to improve processes. Student understands standard procedures and experimental conditions of tests, but displays difficulty in analyzing and interpreting data, and/or using results to improve processes. Student fails to follow correct experimental procedures, or make proper measurements, or analyze and interpret results, or apply results to improve processes. Student understands standard procedures and experimental conditions of tests, but displays difficulty in analyzing and interpreting data, and/or using results to improve processes. Student understands standard procedures and measurements, conducts experiments correctly, and analyzes and interprets data correctly most of the time, but occasionally commits minor errors in the process. Student understands standard procedures and measurements, conducts experiments correctly, and analyzes and interprets data correctly most of the time, but occasionally commits minor errors in the process. Student displays a clear pattern of understanding procedures and tests, analyzes and interprets data confidently, and uses results obtained to improve industrial technology processes. At least 70% of students in IET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Student displays a clear pattern of understanding procedures and tests, analyzes and interprets data confidently, and uses results obtained to improve processes involving mechanical engineering technology. At least 70% of students in MET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Rubric D – for assessing Student Outcomes [d]: d. An ability to design systems, components, or processes for broadly-defined engineering technology problems appropriate to program educational objectives; Computer Engineering Performance Criteria 3. Student demonstrates an ability to design systems, components, and processes for broadly defined problems appropriate to computer engineering technology, such as microcomputer based systems design, and control systems analysis and design. Below Expectations - 1 Student fails to understand the design process, or properly identify components and processes typical in computer engineering technology. Progressing to Criteria - 2 Meets Criteria - 3 Exceeds Criteria - 4 Score Student understands the concept of designing systems, components, and/or processes to a limited extent, and strives to achieve a firmer grasp of the subject matter. Student demonstrates an ability to design systems, components and/or processes relevant in computer engineering technology, but occasionally commits mistakes that display a lack of clarity in understanding. Student displays a clear and consistent knowledge of the design process, whether of systems, components, or processes in computer engineering technology. At least 70% of students in CpET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). 7 Industrial Engineering Construction Engineering Energy Engineering 3. Student demonstrates an ability to design systems, components, and processes for broadly defined problems appropriate to energy engineering technology, for example, the design and analysis of energy conversion devices. 3. Student demonstrates an ability to design systems, components, and processes for broadly defined problems appropriate to industrial engineering technology, for example, the design and application of various auto identification technologies. Mechanical Engineering 3. Student demonstrates an ability to design systems, components, and processes for broadly defined problems appropriate to construction engineering technology, for example, the design and analysis of steel structures. 3. Student demonstrates an ability to design systems, components, and processes for broadly defined problems appropriate to mechanical engineering technology, such as the design and analysis of machine elements and mechanisms. Student fails to understand the design process, or properly identify components and processes typical in construction engineering technology. Student understands the concept of designing systems, components, and/or processes to a limited extent, and strives to achieve a firmer grasp of the subject matter. Student demonstrates an ability to design systems and components typical in construction engineering, but occasionally commits minor mistakes. Student fails to understand the design process, or properly identify components and processes typical in construction engineering technology. Student understands the concept of designing systems, components, and/or processes to a limited extent, and strives to achieve a firmer grasp of the subject matter. Student demonstrates an ability to design systems and components typical in energy technology, but occasionally commits minor mistakes. Student fails to understand the design process, or properly identify components and processes typical in industrial engineering technology. Student understands the concept of designing systems, components, and/or processes to a limited extent, and strives to achieve a firmer grasp of the subject matter. Student demonstrates an ability to design systems and components typical in industrial engineering, but occasionally commits minor mistakes. Student fails to understand the design process, or properly identify components and processes typical in mechanical engineering technology. Student understands the concept of designing systems, components, and/or processes to a limited extent, and strives to achieve a firmer grasp of the subject matter. Student demonstrates an ability to design systems and components typical in mechanical engineering technology, but occasionally commits minor mistakes. Student displays a clear and consistent knowledge of the design materials and processes used in construction technology. At least 70% of students in CET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Student displays a clear and consistent knowledge of the materials and processes used in energy technology. At least 70% of students in EET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Student displays a clear and consistent knowledge of the materials and processes used in industrial engineering technology. At least 70% of students in IET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Student displays a clear and consistent knowledge of the materials and processes used in mechanical engineering technology. At least 70% of students in MET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). 8 Rubric E – for assessing Student Outcomes [e]: e. ALL Concentrations Performance Criteria An ability to function effectively as a member or leader on a technical team; Below Expectations - 1 Student fails to function effectively as a member of a technical team Student functions as part of a technical team, but has difficulty in demonstrating effectiveness. Progressing to Criteria - 2 Student functions effectively as member of a technical team, but occasionally fails to maintain effectiveness. Meets Criteria - 3 Exceeds Criteria - 4 Student demonstrates a consistent pattern of effectiveness as part of a technical team. Student fails to function effectively as a member of a technical team Score At least 70% of students in CpET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Rubric F – for assessing Student Outcomes [f]: ALL Concentrations f. An ability to identify, analyze, and solve broadly-defined engineering technology problems; Performance Criteria Below Expectations - 1 Progressing to Criteria - 2 Meets Criteria - 3 Exceeds Criteria - 4 Score 1. Students demonstrate an ability to identify, analyze, and solve broadly-defined engineering technology problems. Student fails to identify, analyze, and solve broadly-defined engineering technology problems Student identifies typical problems, but struggles to identify and select proper tools to solve problems. Student correctly identifies typical problems, selects and applies basic tools, but makes minor mistakes during the process. Student establishes a clear pattern of correctly identifying, selecting and applying the necessary knowledge, techniques, and skills required to solve relevant problems. At least 70% of students in CpET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). 9 Rubric G – for assessing Student Outcomes [g]: ALL Concentrations g. An ability to function effectively as a member or leader on a technical team; Performance Criteria Below Expectations - 1 Progressing to Criteria - 2 Meets Criteria - 3 Exceeds Criteria - 4 Score 1. Student demonstrates ability to effectively and clearly express thoughts in written and oral presentations. Student fails to effectively and clearly express thoughts in written and oral communications. Student expresses thoughts orally and/or in writing, but fails to make an effective presentation. Student expresses thoughts orally and in writing, but not in a consistently effective manner. Student demonstrates a consistent pattern of communicating effectively in both writing and speech. At least 70% of students in CpET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Rubric H – for assessing Student Outcomes [h]: h. An understanding of the need for and an ability to engage in self-directed continuing professional development; ALL Concentrations Performance Criteria 1. Students are encouraged to become members of professional societies in their respective areas. Examples of relevant professional societies are American Society for Materials, Society of Women Engineers, Society of Manufacturing Engineers, among several others. Below Expectations - 1 Progressing to Criteria - 2 Student fails to show any interest in joining and participating in any professional society activities. Student displays interest in joining one or more professional societies, and possibly participates in activities on campus, but eventually does not become a member and execute member responsibilities. Meets Criteria - 3 Student becomes a member of a professional society and participates in society activities. Exceeds Criteria - 4 Student becomes a member of one or more professional bodies, and actively participates in activities on a regular basis. Score At least 70% of students in CpET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). 10 Rubric I – for assessing Student Outcomes [i]: ALL Concentrations i. An understanding of and a commitment to address professional and ethical responsibilities including a respect for diversity; Performance Criteria Below Expectations - 1 1. Student demonstrates ability to address professional and ethical responsibilities, including a respect for diversity. Student fails to meet basic requirements of professionalism and ethical behavior. Progressing to Criteria - 2 Student strives to meet professional and ethical responsibilities. Meets Criteria - 3 Student meets the standards of professional and ethical behavior, but occasionally falls short. Exceeds Criteria - 4 Score Student demonstrates a consistent pattern of behavior demonstrating superior professional and ethical behavior. At least 70% of students in CpET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). Rubric J – for assessing Student Outcomes [j]: j. ALL Concentrations Performance Criteria Student will demonstrate knowledge of the impact of engineering technology solutions in a societal and global context A knowledge of the impact of engineering technology solutions in a societal and global context; Below Expectations - 1 Student fails to demonstrate either knowledge of standard engineering technology solutions Progressing to Criteria - 2 Student demonstrates knowledge of engineering technology solutions but cannot link them to either societal or global contexts Meets Criteria - 3 Exceeds Criteria - 4 Score Student demonstrates knowledge of engineering technology solutions but can only link them to either societal or global contexts, but not both Student demonstrates knowledge of engineering technology solutions and can link them to both societal and global contexts At least 70% of students in CpET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). 11 Rubric K – for assessing Student Outcomes [k]: ALL Concentrations k. A commitment to quality, timeliness, and continuous improvement. Performance Criteria Below Expectations - 1 Progressing to Criteria - 2 Meets Criteria - 3 Exceeds Criteria - 4 Score Student will demonstrate a commitment to quality of work and timeliness. Student fails to demonstrate either quality of work or timeliness or both. Student strives to deliver quality and maintain timeliness in professional activities, but has difficulty. Student displays the standard commitment to quality and timeliness, but is occasionally late or delivers less than acceptable work. Student demonstrates a steady and consistent pattern of quality and timeliness. At least 70% of students in CpET are expected to meet or exceed the criteria (Levels 3 and 4). 12 Sample Data Collection Table TEMPLATE When a Student Outcome is being assessment, the following data table must be populated with the details, findings, and use of results. Course: Number of Students: Student Outcome Semester: Number of Students who satisfied Rubric: Rubric Used: Methods of Assessment copy/paste example questions, assignments, etc in this table Findings and Detailed Performance Use of Results: 13