IDE Graduation Manual Master of Science Integrated Product Design Master of Science Design for Interaction Master of Science Strategic Product Design Faculty of Industrial Design Engineering Delft University of Technology August 2011 (to be laid down by Board of Examiners in first week of September) TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 1 of 31 Index 1 Introduction 4 2 Graduating at the Faculty of Industrial Design Engineering 2.1 Mission statement of the Faculty of Industrial Design Engineering 2.2 Three Master programmes 2.3 Preparation for Graduation: GPS Week 3 and the Return to Base day 2.4 The Graduation Project: the final piece of the Master‟s degree programme 2.5 Internal and external Graduation Projects 2.6 Admission requirements 2.7 Graduation Support Center 5 5 5 6 6 6 7 7 3 Procedures and rules 8 3.1 Finding a graduation subject and position 8 3.1.1 GPS Week 3 8 3.1.2 Return to Base 8 3.1.3 Graduation report database 9 3.1.4 Graduation subject requirements 9 3.1.5 Finding a graduation subject and position 10 3.1.6 Executing a Graduation Project abroad 10 3.2 Composing a Supervisory Team 10 3.2.1 Registering as a Graduating Student 11 3.3 The Graduation Assignment 12 3.3.1 Draft Graduation Assignment and Form for graduation assignment and study progress 12 3.3.2 Graduation Assignment 12 3.3.3 Formal approval of the Graduation Assignment 12 3.4 The Graduation Project 13 3.4.1 Finding a workplace 13 3.4.2 Agreement with external party 13 3.4.3 Milestones, meetings and work plan 14 3.4.4 Green-light meeting 14 3.4.5 Application for examination by the Chair 15 3.4.6 Administrative obligations for the student 16 3.4.7 Graduation Deliverables 17 4 Examination of the Graduation Project 4.1 Thesis 4.2 Preliminary mark 4.3 Public presentation 4.4 The MSc examination, final mark and cum laude 4.5 Evaluation 4.6 Awarding the degree 19 19 19 19 20 20 20 5 Entering into an agreement with an external party 5.1 General 5.2 BNO Regulations 5.3 Payment 5.4 Copyright 5.5 Models and prototypes 22 22 22 23 23 23 TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 2 of 31 5.6 5.7 5.8 Intellectual property rights, the Dutch Patents Act Liability Confidentiality 5.8.1 Confidentiality of Graduation Project results 5.8.2 Confidentiality of company information Appendix 1 Appendix 2 Appendix 3 TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department 24 24 25 25 25 27 28 30 Page 3 of 31 1 Introduction This IDE Graduation Manual provides information on the Graduation Project: the final project that completes each of the three Master programmes offered by the Faculty of Industrial Design Engineering (IDE) at Delft University of Technology (TU Delft): Integrated Product Design (IPD) Design for Interaction (DfI); Strategic Product Design (SPD) This Graduation Manual is meant for students and staff who are preparing for, or are involved in, the Graduation Project. In the case of an external Graduation Project, it can also be used as a source of information by the external company or organisation where an IDE student is carrying out the Graduation Project. This manual discusses the most relevant aspects of the Graduation Project, from the preparatory work to the procedures for awarding the Master‟s degree. Checklists and examples of a number of important documents required during the process are enclosed. Students who encounter problems finding a graduation project, or who encounter problems during the graduation project that cannot be solved in consultation with the guiding team members (the Supervisory Team), are urged to consult the Graduation Support Centre (§ 2.7). For a digital version of this document and all documents relevant for graduation, please consult the IDE student portal > IDE graduation. For information on this Graduation Manual, please contact TU Delft | Faculty IDE | Education & Student Affairs Department (Afdeling Onderwijs & Studentzaken O&S) | Landbergstraat 15 | 2628 CE Delft | E-mail: j.j.a.m.vaneijk@tudelft.nl TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 4 of 31 2 Graduating at the Faculty of Industrial Design Engineering This chapter provides information about the role of the Graduation Project within the Master programmes, the different types of graduation, the admission requirements and the Graduation Support Centre. 2.1 Mission statement of the Faculty of Industrial Design Engineering The field of industrial design engineering consists of all activities concerning methodical and creative innovation and the development of consumer goods, or parts thereof. The objectives of the Faculty of IDE are described in the mission statement (2004): Creating successful products people love to use. Our mission is to contribute to the knowledge, skills, methods and professional attitudes in the field of integrated product development. We aim to achieve this through education and research at an internationally recognised scientific level, as befits our status as part of Delft University of Technology. The Faculty of Industrial Design Engineering's concern is to study, innovate and improve the development of durable products and their related services for people, on the basis of the balanced interests of users, industry, society and the environment. 2.2 Three Master programmes The Faculty of IDE offers three Master programmes: Integrated Product Design (IPD); Design for Interaction (DfI); Strategic Product Design (SPD). There are three possible fields of specialisation within the IDE Master programmes: Master specialisation in Medisign (IPD and DfI Master‟s only); Master specialisation in Automotive (all three Master‟s programmes). Master specialisation in Retail Design (all three Master‟s programmes). In addition, it is possible to take a TU Delft Master annotation in the field of: Technology in Sustainable Development (all three Master‟s programmes); Entrepreneurship (all three Master‟s programmes). TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 5 of 31 2.3 Preparation for Graduation: GPS Week 3 and the Return to Base day To ensure a timely start on the Graduation Project the student will attend Generic and Professional Skills (GPS) Week 3 in the first week of the third semester which is about preparation for graduation (§ 3.1.1). During the remainder of the third semester students will search for a graduation project and start executing the project. In the beginning of the second quarter of the third semester all students will need to attend the Return To Base day (§ 3.1.2) 2.4 The Graduation Project: the final piece of the Master’s degree programme The Graduation Project is worth 33 ECTS credits, the equivalent of 22 weeks of study. 3 EC are allocated in the second quarter of the third semester and 30 EC are allocated in the fourth semester. The Graduation Project can be started in both the Autumn and Spring semester. The Graduation Project gives the student the opportunity to show that he/she is worthy of the academic title “Master of Science” and that he/she fulfils the requirements of the Master‟s degree programme. This implies that the student must demonstrate his/her knowledge and skills as an independent industrial design engineer to execute a complex project. The Graduation Project can be seen both as the culmination of the student‟s work and as an academic and personal learning experience. The emphasis is therefore not only on testing competencies, but also on the development of the student‟s knowledge, understanding and skills during the project. The Graduation Project is considered to be a stepping stone to a future professional career. A high level of independence is therefore expected from the student in the planning and execution of the assignment and in the acquisition of knowledge, understanding and skills. Study goals The student will acquire knowledge, understanding and skills at an academic Master‟s level with respect to independently planning and executing a design and/or research assignment. On completing the Graduation Project, the student will be able to: Plan, organise and execute a design or research project; Independently manage a design or research project; Cooperate with other professionals; Document and report the results of a design or research project (both in writing and orally); Acquire specific knowledge on the subject of a design or research project. 2.5 Internal and external Graduation Projects Internal Graduation Project: This is either a research project at one of the IDE Faculty‟s research groups, or a design project executed at the IDE Faculty. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 6 of 31 External Graduation Project: This is a Graduation Project at an industrial, commercial, government or semi-government body or research company outside TU Delft‟s IDE Faculty. 2.6 Admission requirements It is essential that the student meets the admission requirements before actually starting work on a Graduation Project. This is to ensure that the student has the requisite level of ability at the beginning of the project. During the execution of the Graduation Project, the student must be registered as a student of the Faculty of Industrial Design Engineering. Students may start the graduation project on condition that they have finished at least the complete first year of the MSc (60 EC). Students who started in September 2007 or before should (also) have finished their BSc degree. If a student starts the Graduation Project in his/her fourth semester it is strongly recommended to have finished all other courses in the MSc programme. (See also Article 9 of the Implementation Regulations, the appendix to the Teaching and Examination Regulations.) 2.7 Graduation Support Center The Graduation Support Center provides help, advice and expertise to students who are preparing or executing a graduation project. Students can for instance contact the Graduation Support Center if they have questions regarding study planning, contracts, patents or the graduation procedure. Apart from that, students can contact the Graduation Support Center if they have doubts whether their proposed graduation assignment is suitable for their MSc programme or whether the level and magnitude of the assignment is appropriate. Students who have problems finding a Graduation Project after attending GPS week 3, are also advised to contact the Graduation Support Center. During the fourth semester the Graduation Support Center functions as a help desk. Students who, during the Graduation Project, encounter problems that cannot be solved in consultation with the Supervisory Team, are urged to consult the Graduation Support Center (graduationsupport-io@tudelft.nl). TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 7 of 31 3 Procedures and rules This chapter describes the procedures and rules that need to be followed during the preparation phase of the Graduation Project and the Graduation Project itself. These include requirements for the graduation subject, rules concerning the formation of a Supervisory Team, rules regarding the approval of the Graduation Assignment and rules concerning the execution of the Graduation Project. A large number of people and departments are involved in these procedures and rules, each with their own specific obligations and concerns. In the end, however, the sole responsibility for the correct completion of the course and the project and compliance with all relevant regulations and procedures lies with the graduating student himself/herself. He/she alone is the project leader of his/her graduation process. 3.1 Finding a graduation subject and position The first step towards finding a suitable graduation subject and position is to register in Osiris for GPS week 3. (For the graduation project itself registration in Osiris is not necessary.) 3.1.1 GPS Week 3 The GPS week 3 takes place in the first week of the student‟s third semester. The objective of this week is to get the student started to find and develop a suitable graduation project; conform his/her interests and competences and acceptable for the examination board. During the week students will create a personal profile to know their interests and capabilities, they will gain information on how to write a project proposal of good quality and how to find a supervisory team. They will develop strategies to find a project and they will gain insight in the procedural aspects of finding and setting up a Graduation Project. During his/her third semester the student searches for a Graduation Project and starts working on the Graduation Project part-time (3 EC of the 33 EC of the graduation project are allocated in semester 3.) 3.1.2 Return to Base After having attended GPS week 3 the student is obligated to attend the Return to Base day, which takes place in the second week of the second quarter of the third semester. On this day students will discuss their progress regarding the acquisition of a suitable graduation subject and position. Furthermore they will be informed about new/actual information regarding graduation. The day also provides the student with an opportunity to learn from the experiences of others on how to search for a project and how to contact companies. The student will have to attend the Return to Base day every semester until his/her graduation project has been approved by the examination board. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 8 of 31 3.1.3 Graduation report database To obtain an idea of the possible range of projects, students can consult other, previous graduation reports: Full-content reports o Report numbers 1 – 1999 (1963 – 1998), hard copies: consult on request; apply to the O&S Department; o Report numbers 2000 – approx. 4000 (1998 – September 2009), hard copies: consult IDE depot Inzage Afstudeerverslagen, Room IO-1D-34. o Report numbers from approx. 4000 upwards (from September 2009), in online database: consult TU Delft Institutional Repository at http://repository.tudelft.nl/ Summaries only Report numbers 1818 – approx. 4000 (1998 – September 2009), in online database: consult the IDE Graduation Summaries Database at IDE Student portal > IDE graduation > Database of graduation reports. 3.1.4 Graduation subject requirements An IDE Graduation Project has to meet the following general requirements: o It must belong to the domain of industrial design engineering and be relevant to the mission of the IDE Faculty (see 2.1). o It must be feasible for a student with the knowledge, insights and skills acquired in his/her Master‟s degree programme. o It must have the potential to be a fitting culmination of an academic Master‟s programme, in terms of content and complexity, giving the student scope to demonstrate his/her competencies and qualities as a self-reliant, professional industrial design engineer. o A Graduation Assignment must offer the student the opportunity to show he/she masters the study goals of the Graduation Project (§ 2.4), being: Plan, organise and execute a design or research project; Independently manage a design or research project; Cooperate with other professionals; Document and report the results of a design or research project (both in writing and orally); Acquire specific knowledge on the subject of a design or research project. o In the case of a research project, the Graduation Project has to be related to the research portfolio of the IDE Faculty. The Graduation Project should be executed in English (see Article 7, Teaching and Examination Regulations). If there are reasons to deviate from this requirement, a substantiated request should be sent to the Board of Examiners by the Chair of the Supervisory Team. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 9 of 31 Students are permitted to work as a team with other students on a Graduation Project, provided that each student has an individual and clearly distinguishable task. In other words, it must be possible to assess each student on the basis of an individual assignment and an individual result. 3.1.5 Finding a graduation subject and position There are different ways to find a graduation subject: o Students can find their own subjects and position. For example, this can be done by contacting companies where they would like to complete their graduation project and discussing possibilities. o Students can use the opportunities available through members of staff or IDE Company Days (IO Bedrijvenbeurs). o Students can consult IDE student portal > IDE graduation > Database of graduation opportunities. This is a web page where staff and external companies and organisations notify students of the subjects they have on offer. Note that the opportunities listed have not yet been formally approved by the faculty. o If a student does not have a graduation subject or position by the end of the third semester, the faculty will support the student in finding a subject and position. The student is required to contact the Graduation Support Centre (graduationsupport-io@tudelft.nl). If the faculty offers the student a graduation project and the student does not accept, it is his/her own responsibility if this delays graduation. 3.1.6 Executing a Graduation Project abroad If a student chooses to carry out his/her graduation project with an external party abroad, he/she is subject to the general rules for studying abroad in addition to the procedures and rules of this Graduation Manual. General preparations include attending to practical matters relating to foreign language and culture, accommodation, funding (DUO), insurance, vaccinations, visas and work permits, and scholarships if applicable. For information on these matters, see the relevant web pages on the IDE Student Portal. 3.2 Composing a Supervisory Team A student can contact a possible chair for a Supervisory Team: For orientation and acquaintance; When he/she has found a subject or project and is looking for guidance or advice; If he/she has yet to find a subject or project, but has a preference for a project within the area of specialisation of a specific member of IDE staff. General requirements of a Supervisory Team, applicable to all Master‟s programmes: The Team should cover the expertise in the fields of the graduation subject. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 10 of 31 Internal Graduation Project: The Supervisory Team should consist of two members of university staff (Chair and mentor), both qualified and authorised to assess the Graduation Project. For staff qualified to act as a chair and/or mentor, consult Blackboard or the IDE student portal > IDE graduation > Supervisors List IDE. External Graduation Project: The Supervisory Team consists of two members of university staff (Chair and mentor), both qualified and authorised to assess the Graduation Project, and one company mentor, representing the external party. This third, company mentor is not authorised to act as an examiner, but can function as an advisor; Besides the one company mentor it is possible to have an additional company advisor, his/her role must be purely advisory and he/she will not be part of the Supervisory Team. The Supervisory Team is organised by the student, in consultation with the Chair. Only the two members university staff on the Supervisory Team are mandated by the Board of Examiners to serve as examiners, not only of the Graduation Project but also of the student‟s Master‟s programme as a whole. A total of 60 hours per student is available for supervision of the Graduation Project. The Chair of the Supervisory Team must be a member of staff at the IDE faculty. Mentors may be members of staff from other TU Delft faculties or be affiliated to a Dutch university of a comparable level. The university mentor in the Supervisory Team must not be an employee (part-time or otherwise) of the company at which the Graduation Project is executed. If it is desirable to add a third member of the university‟s staff to the Supervisory Team, a request for approval has to be submitted to the Board of Examiners. On approval, this third member is also authorised to act as an examiner for the Graduation Project. As long as they provide proper motivation, students are free to consult or seek the involvement of experts other than the members of the Supervisory Team. Guidance or advice from university staff not related to IDE is possible, provided no fees are charged for the work. 3.2.1 Registering as a Graduating Student When the student has found a chair, his/her first obligation is to register in person as a graduating student at the departmental office of the Chair‟s department. During the Graduation Project, this office will take care of all administrative support services on behalf of the Chair and the graduating student. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 11 of 31 3.3 The Graduation Assignment In the third semester the student composes a draft Graduation Assignment. He/she will go on to complete the Graduation Assignment itself together with the Supervisory Team, and more specifically, the Chair of the Supervisory Team. The Graduation Assignment has to be formally approved by the Board of Examiners. 3.3.1 Draft Graduation Assignment and Form for graduation assignment and study progress The student starts with the formulation of a draft graduation assignment, preferably in consultation with the prospective Supervisory Team. After that, the student downloads the form for graduation assignment and study progress and fills in the information to be filled in by the student. This form can be found in appendix 3. 3.3.2 Graduation Assignment In mutual agreement with the Supervisory Team, the student then builds on the draft Graduation Assignment, developing it into a Graduation Assignment. The student includes a planning and indicates whether there is a part-time part (as for 3 EC of the graduation project are intended to be allocated in the third semester) and a fulltime part of the graduation project, or only a fulltime part. At this stage, the Chair checks whether the graduation subject meets the requirements stated in Section 3.1.4 and the BNO criteria (Appendix 5). Once the graduation assignment is approved by the Supervisory Team, the form for Graduation Assignment and study progress is signed by the Chair of the Supervisory Team. The student then hands it in at the departmental office. The departmental office marks the date on which the document is received and sends it to the O&S Shared Service Centre (SSC O&S). The SSC O&S checks the progress of the student and sends the document to the Board of Examiners for approval on content and admission requirements. The Board of Examiners meet every two weeks. Due to the possibility of rejection of the Graduation Assignment to the Board of Examiners, it is important to submit the document as soon as possible but in any case within 3 weeks of the start of the Graduation Project. 3.3.3 Formal approval of the Graduation Assignment The Board of Examiners evaluates the Graduation Assignment and the certificate, both on content and admission requirements. There are three possible outcomes: o The content of the Graduation Assignment is approved as a basis for a Graduation Project. This finalises the Graduation Assignment; TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 12 of 31 o The content of the Graduation Assignment is conditionally approved. This means that the Board of Examiners wants the Assignment to be amended in a particular way; o The content of the Graduation Assignment is rejected. In all cases the Board of Examiners‟ approval is given on condition that the student meets the formal admission requirements for starting the Graduation Project. These requirements are: - The student must have finished at least the complete first year of the MSc (60 EC). - Students who started in September 2007 or before should have (also) finished their BSc degree. The Board of Examiners‟ decision is written on the certificate. Next, the student and the Chair of the Supervisory Team (via the departmental office) will be informed of the Board of Examiners‟ decision. They receive a copy of the certificate, the original of which is filed with the Board of Examiners. 3.4 The Graduation Project Once the Graduation Project has officially been approved by the Board of Examiners the student continues the graduation project according to his/her planning. 3.4.1 Finding a workplace There are different ways to find a workplace in which to complete a Graduation Project: o In the case of an internal project, the student can apply for a workplace at the IDE Service Point. The Chair of the Supervisory Team has to approve this application; o If the student is carrying out an external project, normally his/her workplace will be at the premises of the relevant company or organisation. 3.4.2 Agreement with external party In the case of an external project, the student is strongly advised to operate on the basis of a Graduation Contract with the external party, signed before the start of the Graduation Project. A model contract is available for this purpose (see Appendix 6 and Section 5). If the company wants to use its own contract please contact the Graduation Support Center. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 13 of 31 3.4.3 Milestones, meetings and work plan The student writes a work plan, based on the Graduation Assignment. During the Graduation Project, a number of meetings need to be planned in which the student and the Supervisory Team discuss the progress of the project. It is usual to meet about every 4 to 6 weeks, depending on the dates set for the milestones. The Supervisory Team regards the student as “project leader” and “initiator” throughout the duration of the Graduation Project. The student prepares the agenda for each meeting and records the items discussed. For preparation of the meetings, the student sends the work to be discussed to the Supervisory Team approximately one week in advance. In principle, the student also is expected to chair the meetings. If the Graduation Project is to result in the production of a model or prototype, the student should make a timely agreement with facilities like the IDE Model Construction and Processing Lab (PMB). In view of the busy schedule, the standard education programme is given priority at the PMB. All agreements with the PMB should be made before the green-light meeting. 3.4.4 Green-light meeting The student plans a green-light meeting with the Supervisory Team at least six weeks before the expected graduation date. One week at the latest prior to the green-light meeting, the student is required to ask the SSC O&S for a “Declaration of accomplishment on Master‟s courses”, by filling in and submitting the form „request for SSC O&S Declaration on accomplishment master courses' to osa.io@tudelft.nl. The form can be found on the student portal: Student portal > IDE > Education > Graduating > General information > Download documents. This is a formal declaration prior to the green-light meeting which states whether or not the student has passed all compulsory courses and sufficient elective courses (at least 18 ECTS credits) to finish his/her studies. During the green-light meeting, the Chair ascertains the student‟s progress based on this declaration. The Supervisory Team will give the “green light” if it can be expected with reasonable certainty that the student will complete his/her Graduation Project within six weeks. A green light is not a guarantee that the student will pass the degree audit, but students who have obtained a green light at this stage seldom fail. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 14 of 31 The student will receive a green light to graduate within approximately 6 weeks on condition that: o all compulsory and elective courses of the Master‟s programme (except the Graduation Project itself) have been completed; the student must have obtained all – or more – of the 18 ECTS credit total for electives; the Chair checks this at the green-light meeting by referring to the SSC O&S declaration handed in by the student; o the progress and the standard of the Graduation Project are satisfactory; o the draft of the final thesis has been approved by the Supervisory Team. At the meeting, expectations with regard to the completion of the Graduation Project and preparation for the degree audit are discussed and recorded by the Chair. If the progress or standard of the project is deemed to be unsatisfactory, a new green-light meeting is scheduled, at which a new or improved draft of the final thesis must be presented. At the green-light meeting, a decision on whether or not to request an embargo on the graduation report has to be taken. For administrative reasons this decision cannot be taken at an earlier or a later date. In most cases, the company involved in an external project is the party to request for such an embargo, but this is not necessarily the case. The graduating student has to assure that such a request, if relevant, has been received within 10 working days of the green-light meeting by the IDE Director of Education, Landbergstraat 15, 2628 CE Delft, attn. Mrs M. von Morgen (see Sections 3.5.8 and 5.8 for further considerations on embargos and confidentiality matters). Another aspect of the green-light meeting is that the Chair, the mentor, the external party and the student determine the date and time of graduation, preferably identifying several options. This date should be one which is realistically attainable, as changing it is a time-consuming process for everyone involved. Immediately after the meeting, the Chair informs the departmental office whether the student has been given the green light. If so, he/she hands over the initialled SSC O&S Declaration to the office. He/she also informs the office as to whether an embargo will be requested and passes on the options for date and time for graduation. The office will look for and book a suitable graduation location and inform the student of this. 3.4.5 Application for examination by the Chair On receipt of the Chair‟s notifications following the green-light meeting, the departmental office will send the IDE Chair Examination Application Form (Aanvraag ingenieursexamen door chair) to the SSC O&S. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 15 of 31 On receipt of the IDE Chair Examination Application Form, the SSC O&S will send a letter („B0_IDE Graduation Deliverables_Letter to student‟) with appendices by regular mail to the student‟s study address, containing information and instructions regarding obligatory administrative steps the student has to take (see Sections 3.6.6 and 3.6.7). Next, on the basis of the SSC O&S Declaration produced earlier, the SSC O&S performs a last procedural check to see if the student meets all the requirements to obtain the Master‟s degree, i.e. whether the student has passed all courses (with the exception of the Graduation Project). The SSC O&S stamps and signs the IDE Chair Examination Application Form, together with the words “agreed” or “missing courses: …” and the form is then sent to the Board of Examiners for formal approval. The Board of Examiners will decide whether or not to formally approve graduation on the planned date by signing the form with “approved”, “approved, provided that …” or “not approved”. In the latter cases, reasons for the decision will be supplied. Within three weeks of the departmental office having sent the IDE Chair Examination Application Form to the SSC O&S, it will be informed of the Board of Examiners‟ decision. The office will then inform the Chair of the Supervisory Team and the student. 3.4.6 Administrative obligations for the student On receipt of the letter (B0_IDE Graduation Deliverables_Letter to Student) from SSC O&S (sent immediately after a positive green-light decision), the student must immediately fill in and sign all appendices to the letter (see below for details) and deliver or send them without delay to the IDE Service Point, Landbergstraat 15, 2628 CE Delft: o B1_IDE Examination Application Form Student. On this form, the student declares to having fulfilled all legal and financial obligations; this will be checked by TU Delft‟s Central Student Administration (CSA). o B2_IDE Electives List. Only the electives which the student chooses to include in this list (minimum of 18 ECTS credits), will be recorded in his/her diploma supplement. This list will be checked by TU Delft‟s Shared Service Centre for Education & Student Affairs (SSC O&S). o If applicable: Attachment: B3_E_IDE Annotation Approval Form Entrepreneurship or B3_S_IDE Annotation Approval Form TiSD (Technology in Sustainable Development). o B4_IDE Inventory Graduation Models + Workplaces. In this document, the student indicates who owns his/her graduation prototype/model, if TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 16 of 31 any, and states the locations where he/she has executed his/her Graduation Project. Based on the documents submitted, the SSC O&S will check whether the student has fulfilled all legal and financial obligations. If all such requirements have been met, the SSC O&S will apply for the degree certificate and, if applicable, certificates for the Annotation Entrepreneurship or TiSD (Technology in Sustainable Development) to be produced. Furthermore, the diploma supplement will be produced and completed with the official list of marks, insofar as possible. Due to the time-consuming nature of all these administrative steps, it is absolutely necessary that the student submits the requested documents without delay. 3.4.7 Graduation Deliverables The student is required to hand in the hard copy graduation report plus appendices and a digital A1 poster (see for specifications below) to all members of the supervisory team, no later than two weeks before the graduation date (unless otherwise agreed upon by the members of the Supervisory Team). Also, no later than two weeks before the graduation date, the student has to upload the graduation deliverables (i.e. the graduation report plus appendices, see below) to the TU Delft Institutional Repository for Graduation Reports (hereafter referred to as “Delft Repository”) of the TU Delft Central Library. Delft Repository is an online database which contains the academic output of TU Delft. It is the primary digital location for public scientific research and education publications at TU Delft and contains full text as well as bibliographic or metadata. Delft Repository is part of a nationwide network of scientific repositories, coordinated by the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences (KNAW). The IDE Faculty decided to add its graduation reports to the Delft Repository from 1 September 2009. For the present, IDE graduation reports will only be accessible and visible from computers on the TU Delft campus. Apart from completing certain metadata (general information on the Graduation Project, including a summary with a maximum length of 1000 words), the student may upload a maximum of 10 files to the Delft Repository. Mandatory uploads are: a. The complete graduation report, preferably in PDF format. b. Indissoluble appendices to the graduation report, if any, preferably in PDF format. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 17 of 31 c. At least 2, at most 5 representative images from the graduation report. The images to be submitted are intended for publication by the IDE Faculty in bulletins or brochures. They should therefore be of high quality. The following guidelines apply: minimum dimensions 1240 x 860 pixels, RGB or CMYK, preferably in TIFF or JPEG format d. A digital poster (A1 size). If required, the IDE Faculty will use this digital poster to produce a physical poster for exhibition purposes. See the student portal for guidelines and a template: Student portal > IDE > Education > Graduating > General information > Download documents. Uploading graduation deliverables to the Delft Repository is mandatory, even if the thesis is to remain confidential for a designated period and an embargo has been requested or granted by the IDE Faculty. However, these confidential reports will not be accessible or visible for the duration of the embargo (normally 12 months), see Section 5.8. If an embargo applies, the student should send proof of a requested or granted embargo to afstudeerrepository-io@tudelft.nl before uploading his/her thesis. The graduating student is responsible for the content of his/her graduation report and appendices and for uploading these data to the Delft Repository. The IDE Education & Student Affairs Department O&S is responsible for carrying out a final check on the metadata and the deliverables. The Delft Repository Team at TU Delft Library is responsible for publication of the graduation report and appendices online. On the subject of copyright, submitting the thesis and appendices to Delft Repository implies that: o The author (the student) grants the TU Delft Library the licence to perpetually publish the full text of the thesis on the Delft Repository website; o The author retains the copyright to the thesis; o There are no obligations whatsoever which prevent the publication of the thesis on the Delft Repository website; o The author is responsible for all statements in the thesis. The Master‟s degree certificate will only be issued once the student has met all of the above-mentioned conditions. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 18 of 31 4 Examination of the Graduation Project The final examination procedure for graduation consists of assessing the thesis, determining a preliminary mark, a public presentation based on the thesis, the degree audit (determining the final mark and notice of distinction/cum laude), an evaluation meeting and awarding the diploma. This is the final phase of the Master‟s degree examination procedure; the administrative check on all other courses and constituent marks has, by this time, already been conducted and approved by the Board of Examiners. This final examination procedure therefore leads directly to the awarding of the MSc degree. 4.1 Thesis The thesis is a report of the Graduation Project and its results. It forms the most important basis for the assessment of the project. Students should realise that the thesis must meet the accepted academic standards as regards content, structure, scientific referencing and language. It should provide a good insight into the project in terms of objective, methods and results. 4.2 Preliminary mark The Supervisory Team establishes an indication of the mark for the Graduation Project prior to the presentation, based on the thesis, the digital A1 poster and the team‟s impression of the student during the project. (See the study goals for the criteria of assessment in §2.4).The company representative has no formal say in the decision on the mark. 4.3 Public presentation The public presentation gives the student the opportunity to present his/her Graduation Project to everyone involved and to family, friends and other interested individuals. The public presentation can have a modest influence on the final mark for the Graduation Project. Within a maximum of 45 minutes, the student will present the objective, methods, concepts and results of his/her project and will answer questions from the audience. The presentation, which must be given in English, is a compulsory part of the examination. The presentation is open to the public. If a company is involved in the Graduation Project and this company has requested for confidentiality, the Supervisory Team and the Education Board take a decision as to the public nature of the presentation and/or disclosure or non-disclosure of certain data and/or project results. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 19 of 31 The public presentation is held at TU Delft, preferably at the IDE Faculty. Any request to hold the presentation elsewhere will be decided on by the Education Board. 4.4 The MSc examination, final mark and cum laude If the Graduation Project is executed to the satisfaction of the Supervisory Team, the student meets all the requirements of the MSc examination. Next, in a 15minute session attended only by the Supervisory Team, the members affiliated with TU Delft determine the final mark. They also decide on whether they see grounds to award the cum laude distinction. In order to do so, the examiners consult a record of all the marks that the student has attained throughout the Master‟s programme. The distinction of cum laude is an honour which the examiners can award when the examinee has shown exceptional competence, this being reflected in: The Graduation Project being awarded a 9 (out of 10) or higher; The weighed average mark for the other educational units of the degree programme being at least 7.5 (out of 10)1; The length of study not exceeding 2.5 years, excluding the overshoot allowed by law, or the period for which the examinee receives a contribution from the university‟s auditor fund. Exceptions regarding the cum laude distinction can be made by the Board of Examiners (see Article 33 of the MSc Rules & Guidelines from the Board of Examiners for details). 4.5 Evaluation After having examined the student‟s Master‟s programme, the Supervisory Team and the student together evaluate the project for a maximum of 30 minutes. In this final meeting, both the team and the student can obtain a clearer perspective on the strengths and weaknesses of the work performed. 4.6 Awarding the degree Provided that the Supervisory Team has reached a positive assessment, the degree certificate, which is signed by the Chair of the Board of Examiners, is awarded immediately. This usually takes place in the room where the public presentation was held, in the presence of the audience. The Chair of the Supervisory Team will announce the assessment, award the degree certificate and will typically take the opportunity to address a few well-chosen personal words to the newly pronounced Master of Science. In order to have full legal status, the certificate also has to be signed by the student, on both sides. 1 Students who start their MSc programme after January 1st 2013 will need to have a weighed average mark for the other educational units of the degree programme of at least 8.0 (out of 10). TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 20 of 31 In the case of a cum laude distinction, a special certificate has to be drawn up later. The standard certificate is awarded immediately to be later replaced by the cum laude certificate once it is ready. Within two weeks of the examination, the mark for the Graduation Project will be added to the official list of marks on the diploma supplement by the SSC O&S. It will be signed by the Chair of the Board of Examiners and sent to the new Master of Science (MSc) as a supplement to his/her degree certificate. After graduation, the thesis will immediately be available in the online Delft Repository for further use. See Section 5.8 for the procedure in cases where one of the parties involved (e.g. the company) objects to the immediate public display of the thesis and has requested an embargo which has been approved by the Director of Education. Graduation timetable (4 slots per day) Slot 1 Slot 2 Slot 3 Slot 4 Section 4.3 Section 4.4 Section 4.5 Section 4.6 Presentation & questions from audience Determination of final mark and cum laude*) Evaluation of the graduation with student Awarding the degree certificate End of ceremony 08:45 10:45 13:45 15:45 09:30 11:30 14:30 16:30 09:45 11:45 14:45 16:45 10:15 12:15 15:15 17:15 10:30 12:30 15:30 17:30 *) Meeting with Supervisory Team members only. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 21 of 31 5 Entering into an agreement with an external party 5.1 General In the case of an external Graduation Project, it is strongly advisable to operate on the basis of a Graduation Contract. A model contract is available for this purpose (see Appendix 6). This is a contract between the Graduating Student and the Company where the student completes his/her project. Neither TU Delft nor the Faculty of Industrial Design Engineering is party to the agreement between the Graduating Student and the Company. However, regardless of any provision made between the Graduating Student and the Company, the university will, in accordance with its tasks and objectives as laid down by law, execute its full rights regarding use and publication of the results of the Graduation Project (i.e. for its own educational and research activities and for its own promotional and publicity purposes), taking into account the interests of all parties involved. Furthermore, the university shall enter into an agreement with the Graduating Student and/or Company in the event that one or more employees of the university claim partial rights to the invention, patent and/or matters of exploitation relating to the Graduation Project. To protect the interests of the faculty when entering into the Graduation Contract, the Graduating Student and the Company shall assume the general principles and the interests of the faculty as stated in Appendix I, which forms an inextricable part of the Graduation Contract. This also guarantees that, conversely, the Graduating Student and/or the Company shall enter into an agreement with the university in the event that one or more employees of the university claim partial rights to the invention, patent and/or matters of exploitation relating to the Graduation Project. It is important that all parties involved realise the special situation of a student as a graduate at a company. The learning situation is the primary objective of the project, and the benefit to the working situation at the Company is derived from this. The Graduating Student therefore has the obligation towards the faculty to achieve results that meet academic standards, as well as the requirements for obtaining the Master‟s degree. Towards the company, the Graduating Student has the obligation to put genuine effort into the project and to execute the assignment to the fullest of his/her abilities. 5.2 BNO Regulations The IDE Faculty complies with the Arrangement Relationship between Education and Professional Practices (“Omgangsregeling Onderwijs – Beroepspraktijk 1997”) formulated with the Association of Dutch Designers (BNO). This agreement was TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 22 of 31 created to promote the relationship between education, business, the student and the profession. It states that educational objectives are primary with respect to a workplace assignment and prevents unfair competition and corruption of the market. 5.3 Payment Payment of the Graduating Student usually comprises a fixed allowance per month for Graduation Projects, determined by the Company. If the Company has no fixed regulations, the Graduating Student and the Company can discuss a reasonable fee. The IDE Faculty will not intervene in this discussion. The faculty discourages Graduating Students from executing a Graduation Project either without any compensation or if they are offered a full salary. The former could give the impression that the faculty provides free designers, while the latter could give the impression that the company is entitled to demand tangible results, while the Graduating Student‟s only commitment is to put reasonable effort into the project. During the project, extra costs for models or prototypes, the thesis, the presentation, travelling expenses and even housing expenses may occur as a direct result of the Company‟s involvement in the Graduation Project. It is the responsibility of the Company to reimburse these costs to the faculty and/or Graduating Student. Unwillingness to do so on the part of the Company could jeopardise the progress or results of the project. 5.4 Copyright The copyright of the thesis and any drawings, models and prototypes relating to it belong to the true creator of the work. The crucial argument regarding copyright is whether the work is original and new. In general, ideas or methods do not have copyright protection in themselves. The Copyright Act protects against the publishing and copying of the work and comes into force when the work is created. Registration of the work is not necessary, nor is use of the copyright symbol. However the author is strongly advised to put his/her name on the work. In the case of a Graduation Project, the copyright generally belongs to the Graduating Student. However, in light of the crucial arguments stated above, the university may also claim the copyright (see Section 5.1). If the Graduating Student is operating as an employee for the Company or carrying out paid employment for the Company, the Company may be entitled to claim the copyright. 5.5 Models and prototypes The Uniform Benelux Designs and Models Law protects certain models (threedimensional shapes) or drawings (two-dimensional shapes) of “creations with a TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 23 of 31 practical use” with a new appearance against copying. To claim this protection, the model or drawing should be registered at the Benelux Designs Office (Benelux-Modellenbureau) in The Hague. The rights of the model or drawing belong to the sponsor of the designer. In a Graduation Project this means that the model or prototype belongs to the Company or to the faculty (in the case of an internal project). Prototypes or models which are paid for by the Company are the property of the Company. Prototypes or models built at the faculty‟s expense are the property of the faculty; these can usually be sold to the company at the production costs. 5.6 Intellectual property rights, the Dutch Patents Act In general, the right to use the results of the Graduation Project (i.e. an invention or discovery) for commercial purposes, belongs to the sponsor of the Graduation Assignment, being the company or – in the case of an internal project – the faculty. Such rights are known as intellectual property rights (IPR). It is possible to make alternative arrangements on the basis of a written agreement between parties. For example, IPR can be allocated to the Graduating Student or to the faculty. The Dutch Patents Act (Rijksoctrooiwet 1995) stipulates that, when requesting a patent, the true inventor‟s name should be mentioned on the application form and that this true inventor can request financial compensation for the loss of title or rights to the patent. This means that if a patent is applied for on the basis of work done by a Graduating Student during a Graduation Project, the application should always include the name of the Graduating Student. If the application is submitted by an external company, it may be appropriate to name the university and faculty as co-inventor. If applicable, both the Graduating Student and the faculty can request financial compensation for the loss of title or rights to the patent. The Uniform Benelux Designs and Models Law and the Dutch Patents Act (Rijksoctrooiwet 1995) both require the work to be new; in other words it cannot have been made public before applying for protection. Since part of the graduation ceremony is open to the public, any patent request must be filed prior to the graduation date. Another solution in such cases, would be to ask the audience to sign a confidentiality statement. 5.7 Liability The IDE Faculty and TU Delft are not liable for any damage caused by the Graduating Student at the Company. The Graduating Student is responsible for ascertaining how liability between the Graduating Student and Company is regulated. Legal liability and health insurance are also part of this aspect. In some cases the Graduating Student can be insured through the Company. The Graduating Student and the IDE Faculty cannot be held responsible for damage or TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 24 of 31 injury that results from the Company‟s use of the results of the Graduation Project. 5.8 Confidentiality Matters of confidentiality and secrecy may involve both confidential Graduation Project results and confidential company information. 5.8.1 Confidentiality of Graduation Project results In principle, the results of the Graduation Project (as set out in the thesis) should be publicly accessible because the university is an institute subsidized by the government. Only on serious grounds and by way of exception may the IDE Faculty decide to keep these results confidential for a limited period. It may be the case that, while the Graduation Project results may be made public, the Company objects to the thesis being made accessible immediately. In that case, the company may ask the IDE Faculty to grant an embargo on publication. Such a request needs to be substantiated. This embargo, once validated, holds for a maximum of one year and results in a „company thesis‟, which is not publicly displayed in the Delft Repository during this period. If the Company considers a longer embargo to be necessary, the period can be prolonged for a maximum of another one year. In such a case the Graduate (having obtained the title of Master) will be contacted by the Company to create a second version of the thesis: an „external thesis‟. It is reasonable that the Company will reimburse the costs made by the former Graduating Student for creating such second version. The external thesis will then be made publicly accessible through the Delft Repository. Also the external thesis must have be approved by the Board of Examiners. Please note: the Graduating Student and the IDE Faculty are also allowed to request an embargo on publishing the results of the graduation work. 5.8.2 Confidentiality of company information The Supervisory Team, other faculty employees involved (if any) and the Graduating Student will treat with the utmost confidentiality all information from the Company with which they have become acquainted during the Graduation Project and in respect of which they have been explicitly informed of the need for secrecy. This obligation of confidentiality shall be observed for a period to be determined, with a maximum period of five years. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 25 of 31 In cases where the Graduating Student is asked by the Company to sign a statement of confidentiality (e.g. in order to keep company‟s production details secret), it should be clear that this statement does not affect the Supervisory Team‟s right to have access at all times to all information required to monitor the progress and assess the result of the Graduation Project. In certain cases, it may be desirable for faculty employees involved in the project to also sign a statement of confidentiality explicitly concerning company information. Confidential company information that is relevant to assessing the process and the result of the project can be added to the thesis in a separate appendix which is only available to the Supervisory Team. If this solution is not workable because the issue of confidentiality affects the entire project, then the project should be deemed unsuitable for a Graduating Student and reformulated in such a way that it can result in a project thesis which may be made public. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 26 of 31 Appendix 1 Checklist for the Chair of the Supervisory Team Prior to the start of the Graduation Project □ Together with the student, discuss and elaborate on the draft Graduation Assignment in order to arrive at a Graduation Assignment. Check whether the graduation subject requirements detailed in Section 3.1.4 and the BNO criteria have been met; □ Discuss and establish the choice of mentors with the student. In the case of an internal research project, one member of the Supervisory Team should be involved in current research. In the case of an external project, agree on expectations in relation to the company and confirm who will be the company mentor (one only); □ As soon as possible but at least three weeks of the start of the project, approve the Graduation Assignment by signing the „form for graduation assignment and study progress‟, and submit the document to your departmental office. The office will send it on to the SSC O&S to check the progress of the student, the SSC O&S will then send the document to the Board of Examiners for formal approval. The green-light meeting □ Check and initial the SSC O&S Declaration of Accomplishment on Master‟s Courses in order to judge student‟s permission to graduate. The student must have finished all courses of the Master‟s programme, including the accumulation of 18 EC credits for electives; □ Make sure a draft of the final thesis is available for approval; □ Explain to the company, if appropriate, the details on the faculty‟s policy on matters of publication, disclosure, confidentiality and embargo; □ During this green-light meeting, ensure that the company (or other relevant parties) decide whether or not to request an embargo – this decision cannot be taken at an earlier or a later date; □ Explain to the company, if appropriate, the details and procedures regarding graduation. Graduation administrative obligations, deliverables □ Immediately after the green-light meeting, agree – together with the student, the mentors and your departmental office – on the date, time and place for graduation; □ Make sure the departmental office applies for the graduation examination to the SSCO&S by sending the IDE Chair Examination Application Form □ Remind the student that hard copies of the final thesis and/or a CD ROM should be sent to each member of the Supervisory Team on time (two weeks before the graduation date unless otherwise agreed upon by the members of the Supervisory Team). Examination and evaluation □ Explain to those involved the procedure of the final examination. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 27 of 31 Appendix 2 Checklist for the Graduating Student General □ As the Graduating Student, you must be aware that you bear sole responsibility for ensuring the correct completion of the programme and project, and for compliance with all relevant regulations and procedures. You are the project leader of your graduation process, regardless of the specific obligations of the people and departments involved in the procedures; □ Make copies of documents delivered or sent for your own records. Approvement of the graduation assignment □ Produce a draft Graduation Assignment, preferably in consultation with the prospective Supervisory Team □ Discuss and elaborate on the draft graduation assignment with the Chair, to arrive at the Graduation Assignment itself. Have the Chair sign the Graduation Assignment for approval; □ Discuss and establish the choice of mentors with the Chair.; □ Make sure you meet the formal admission requirements of the graduation project. □ Prior to the start of the Graduation Project, offer the company involved, if appropriate, a copy of the IDE Graduation Model Contract. Enter into an agreement with the company; □ Check that, within three weeks of the start of the process, the signed form for graduation assignment and study progress is sent for formal approval to the Board of Examiners by the Chair‟s departmental office. The Graduation Project □ If necessary, make an appointment with the IDE Model Construction and Processing Lab (PMB) in plenty of time and in any case before the green-light meeting; □ Prior to the green-light meeting, finish all MSc courses and the 18 of ECTS credits for Master‟s electives; The green-light meeting □ Ask the SSC O&S for a certified Declaration of Accomplishment on Master‟s Courses. □ Hand over the SSC O&S Declaration to the Chair to prove that you have permission to graduate; □ Make sure a draft of your final thesis is available for approval by the Supervisory Team; □ Make sure that a decision is taken during the green-light meeting on whether or not to request an embargo – this decision cannot be taken at an earlier or a later date; Graduation administrative obligations, deliverables □ Immediately after the green-light meeting, agree on the date, time and place for graduation, together with the Chair, the mentors and the departmental office; □ Act on the instructions that you will receive by letter from SSC O&S, i.e. immediately fulfil all administrative obligations and upload the Graduation Deliverables to the Delft Repository at least 2 weeks before graduation; □ Supply the deliverables to the members of the Supervisory Team on time (two weeks before the graduation date unless otherwise agreed upon by the members of the Supervisory Team). After examination □ Make sure that your registration as a TU Delft student is cancelled on time. You can take care of this on the StudieLink website (www.studielink.nl); TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 28 of 31 □ If you are entitled to a reimbursement of university fees, apply for this via the TU Delft Central Student Administration, Jaffalaan 9, 2628 BX Delft. TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 29 of 31 Appendix 3 Format Graduation Assignment incl. the form ‘study progress’ To be filled in by the student Name student Student number Address Zip- code, City Telephone E-mail address Bachelor’s □ IDE Bachelor‟s □ TU Delft non-IDE BSc □ HBO Bachelor‟s □ Univ. BSc, non TU Delft □ Foreign Bachelor‟s ………………………………………………………………………….. ………………………………………………………………………….. ………………………………………………………………………….. ………………………………………………………………………….. ………………………………………………………………………….. ………………………………………………………………………….. Start at IDE …………….. (year) Start at TU Delft ………….. (year) Master’s □ IPD □ DfI □ SPD □ Individual programme2: l…………………………. Specialisation □ Medisign □ Advanced Automotive Design □ Retail Design Annotation □ Techn. in Sustainable Design □ Entrepreneurship To be filled in by the Shared Service Centre O&S after the approval of the assignment by the chair 1. Check study progress Bachelor‟s degree: Yes 1. Missing 1st year Master‟s courses 1. ……………………………………. 2. ……………………………………. 3. ……………………………………. No 4. ……………………………………… 5. ……………………………………… 6. ……………………………………… Master‟s electives, no. of EC credits accumulated: ……………….. Name: Date: ….. / ….. / 20….. Signature: 2. Formal approval Graduation Assignment by the Board of Examiners Approval of the content of the Grad. Assignment: Procedural approval: To be filled in by the Board of Examiners Approved Approved Not Approved Not Approved Comments: Name: 2 Date: ….. / ….. / 20….. Signature: Fill in: Title of the individual programme and date of approval programme TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 30 of 31 Format Graduation Assignment General information Title of Graduation Project: …………………………………………………………………………………… Chair of Supervisory Team: …………………………………………………………………………………… Department / Research Group: …………………………………………………………………………………… Supervisory Team Mentor: …………………………………………………………………………………… Department / Research Group: …………………………………………………………………………………… Company name: …………………………………………………………………………………… Country: …………………………………………………………………………………… Company Mentor: …………………………………………………………………………………… Start date: …………………………………………………………………………………… End date: …………………………………………………………………………………… Content graduation project Introduction: Problem definition: Assignment: Results: Planning: Approval …………………………… Date of approval …………………………………………………………………………………… Signature of Chair of Supervisory Team TU Delft / IDE / O&S Department Page 31 of 31