1 Chapter 11 Output Stages EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik Operational Amplifier Circuit Components 2 1. Ch 7: Current Mirrors and Biasing 2. Ch 9: Frequency Response 3. Ch 8: Active-Loaded Differential Pair 4. Ch 10: Feedback 5. Ch 11: Output Stages EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik Learning Objectives 3 1) The classification of amplifier output stages on the basis of the fraction of the cycle of an input sine wave during which the transistor conducts. 2) Analysis and design of a variety of output-stage types ranging from the simple but power-inefficient emitter follower class (class A) to the popular push-pull class AB circuit in both bipolar and CMOS technologies. 3) Thermal considerations in the design and fabrication of highoutput power circuits. 4) Useful and interesting circuit techniques employed in the design of power amplifiers. 5) Optional: special types of MOS transistors optimized for high-power applications. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 4 Introduction One important aspect of an amplifier is output resistance This affects its ability to deliver a load without loss of gain (or significant loss) Large signals are of interest and small-signal models cannot be applied Total harmonic distortion is good measure of linearity of output stage Most challenging aspect of output stage design is efficiency Power dissipation is highly correlated to internal junction temperature EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 5 Commonly Used Output Stages EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 6 11.1 Classification of Output Stages Class A Class AB Class B Class C Output stages are classified according to collector (drain) current waveform that results when input signal is applied Figure 11.1: Collector current waveforms for transistors operating in (a) class A, (b) class B, (c) class AB, and (d) class C amplifier stages. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.2 Class A Output Stage 7 (eq11.1) output voltage: vO vI vBE 1 (eq11.2) maximum output voltage: max vO VCC VCE 1 sat (eq11.3/4) minimum output voltage: min vO VCC VCE 2 sat IRL (eq11.5) bias current: I VCC VCE 2 sat RL EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.2 Class A Output Stage EE 3120 Microelectronics II 8 Suketu Naik 9 11.2 Class A Output Stage Figure 11.3 Transfer characteristic of the emitter follower in Fig. 11.2. This linear characteristic is obtained by neglecting the change in v BE1 with iL. The maximum positive output is determined by the saturation of Q1. In the negative direction, the limit of the linear region is determined either by Q1 turning off or by Q2 saturating, depending on the values of I and RL. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.2.3 Power Dissipation Maximum instantaneous power dissipation in Q1 is VCCI. It is equal to power dissipation in Q1 with no signal applied (quiescent power dissipation) 10 Emitter-follower transistor dissipates the largest amount of power when vO = 0 Since this condition (no input signal) may be maintained or long periods of time, transistor Q1 must be able to withstand a continuous power dissipation of VCCI. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11 Class A: Signal Waveforms Figure 11.4: Maximum signal waveforms in the class A output stage of Fig. 11.2 under the condition I = VCC /RL or, equivalently, RL = VCC/I. Note that the transistor saturation voltages have been neglected. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 12 11.2.4 Power Conversion Efficiency (eq11.7) power conversion efficiency: (eq11.8) load power: P L Vˆo / 2 RL (eq11.9) supply power: PS 2VCC I 2 load power PL supply power PS 1 Vˆo2 2 RL 1 Vˆo Vˆo (eq11.10) supply power: 4 IRL VCC (eq11.11) peak output voltage: Vˆo VCC IRL EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.3 Class B Output Stage 13 Figure 11.5: A class B output stage. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 14 11.3 Class B Output Stage Figure 11.6: Transfer characteristic for the class B output stage in Fig. 11.5. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 15 11.3 Class B Output Stage 1 Vˆo2 (eq11.12) load power: PL 2 RL 1 Vˆo2 (eq11.13) power drawn from supplies: PS PS VCC RL total equals PS 1 Vˆo2 RL 1 (eq11.15) efficiency: 2 RL 2 Vˆo VCC (eq11.16) maximum efficiency: max 1 Vˆo2 VCC RL Vˆo 4 VCC 4 78.5% 1 VCC2 (eq11.17) maximum load power: max PL 2 RL EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 16 11.3.4 Power Dissipation (eq11.18) average power dissipation: PD PS PL 2 Vˆo 1 Vˆo2 (eq11.19) average power dissipation: PD VCC RL 2 RL value of Vˆo which corresponds to ˆ 2 (eq11.20) : Vo VCC PD max max average power dissipation (eq11.21) max average power dissipation: PD max EE 3120 Microelectronics II 2VCC2 RL Suketu Naik 17 11.3 Class B Output Stage Figure 11.8: Power dissipation of the class B output stage versus amplitude of the output sinusoid. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 18 11.3.5 Reducing Crossover Distortion Crossover distortion of class B output stage may be reduced substantially: Employing High-gain Op-amp Overall Negative Feedback 0.7V deadband is reduced to 0.7/A0 Slew-rate limitation of op-amp will cause alternate turning on and off of output transistors to be noticeable More practical solution is class AB stage. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 19 Figure 11.9: Class B circuit with an op amp connected in a negative-feedback loop to reduce crossover distortion. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 20 Figure 11.10: Class B output stage operated with a single power supply EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.4 Class AB Output Stage 21 Crossover distortion can be virtually eliminated by biasing the complementary output transistor with small nonzero current A bias voltage VBB is applied between QN and QP EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 22 11.4 Class AB Output Stage (eq11.24) output voltage: vO vI (eq11.25) current iN : iN iP iL VBB vBEN 2 (eq11.25) current IQ : IQ2 iP iN Figure 11.12: Transfer characteristic of the class AB stage in Fig. 11.11. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 23 11.4.2 Output Resistance (eq11.28) output resistance: Rout reN || reP VT (eq11.29) small-signal emitter resistance N: reN iN VT (eq11.30) small-signal emitter resistance P: reP iP VT VT VT (eq11.31) output resistance: Rout || iN iP iP iN EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 24 Figure 11.13: Determining the small-signal output resistance of the class AB circuit of Fig. 11.11 EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 25 11.5 Biasing the Class AB Circuit Figure 11.14 shows class AB circuit with bias voltage VBB. Constant current IBIAS is passed through pair of diodes D1 and D2. In circuits that supply large amounts of power, the output transistors are large-geometry devices. Biasing diodes, however, need not be large. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.5 Biasing the Class AB Circuit 26 Figure 11.14: A class AB output stage utilizing diodes for biasing. If the junction area of the output devices, QN and QP, is n-times that of the biasing devices D1 and D2, a quiescent current IQ = nIBIAS flows in the output devices. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.5.2 Biasing Using the VBE Multiplier Figure 11.15: A class AB output stage utilizing a VBE multiplier for biasing. 27 Figure 11.16: A discrete-circuit class AB output stage with a potentiometer used in the VBE multiplier. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.5.2 Biasing Using the VBE Multiplier 28 VBE 1 (eq11.32) current IR : IR R1 (eq11.33) bias voltage: VBB IR R1 R2 R2 (eq11.33) bias voltage: VBB VBE 1 1 R1 (eq11.34) current IC 1 : IC 1 IBIAS IR IC 1 (eq11.35) base-emitter voltage: VBE VTln IS 1 EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 29 Power Amplifiers EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.7 Power BJTs 11.7.1. Junction Temperature 150OC to 200OC 30 11.7.2. Thermal Resistance (eq11.69) TJ – TA = qJAPD 11.7.3. Power Dissipation Versus Temperature One must examine power-derating curve 11.7.4. Transistor Case and Heat Sink (eq11.72) qJA = qJC + qCA EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.7.4 Transistor Case and Heat Sink TO3 Package TO3 Package: Top View Figure 11.25 The popular TO3 package for power transistors: The case is metal with a diameter of about 2.2 cm; the outside dimension of the “seating plane” is about 4 cm. The seating plane has two holes for screws to bolt it to a heat sink. The collector is electrically connected to the case. Therefore an electrically insulating but thermally conducting spacer is used between the transistor case and the “heat sink.” 31 TO3 with Heat Sink T220 Package EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.7.4 Transistor Case and Heat Sink Figure 11.26: Electrical analog of the thermal conduction process when a heat sink is utilized. 32 Figure 11.27: Maximum allowable power dissipation versus transistor-case temperature. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.7.5 The BJT Safe Operating Area 33 The maximum allowable current ICMax. Exceeding this current on a continuous basis can result in melting the wires that bond the device to the package terminals The maximum power dissipation hyperbola. This is the locus of the points for which vCEiC = PDmax (at TC0). For temperatures TC > TC0, the power derating curves described in Section Figure 11.29: Safe operating area (SOA) of a BJT. 11.7.4 should be used to obtain the applicable PDmax and thus a correspondingly lower hyperbola EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.7.5 The BJT Safe Operating Area Figure 11.29: Safe operating area (SOA) of a BJT. 34 The second-breakdown limit: Second breakdown is a phenomenon that results because current flow across the emitter-base junction is not uniform. Rather, the current density is greatest near the periphery of the junction. Hot Spots Thermal Runaway The collector-to-emitter breakdown voltage (BVCEO). EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 35 11.7.6 Parameter Values of Power Transistors At high currents, the exponential iC-vBE relationship exhibits a factor of 2 reduction in the exponent b is low, typically 30 to 80 (but can be as low as 5). It is important to note that b has a positive temperature coefficient At high currents r becomes very small (a few ohms) and rx becomes important fT is low (a few MHz), Cm is large, C is even larger. ICBO is large, BVCEO is typically 50 to 100V. ICmax is typically in ampere range, as high as 100A. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.9 IC Power Amplifiers High-gain, small-signal amplifier followed by class AB output stage. 36 Overall negative feedback is already applied Output current-driving capability of any general-purpose op-amp may be increased by cascading it with class B or class AB output stage Hybrid IC EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.8.4 Thermal Shutdown 37 Figure 11.35: Thermal-shutdown circuit EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.8.2 Use of Compound Devices 38 Darlington Pair Compound pnp EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 11.8.2 Use of Compound Devices 39 Biasing Darlington Pair Class AB output stage with Darlington npn and compound pnp and VBE multiplier for biasing Compound pnp EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 40 IC Power Amp: Example Figure 11.36 The simplified internal circuit of the LM380 IC power amplifier. (Courtesy: National Semiconductor Corporation.) EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik IC Power Amp: Analysis 41 Figure 11.37: Small-signal analysis of the circuit in Fig. 11.36. The circled numbers indicate the order of the analysis steps. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 42 Summary Output stages are classified according to the transistor conduction angle: class A (360O), class AB (slightly more than 180O), class B (180O), and class C (less than 180O) The most common class A output stage is the emitterfollower. It is biased at a current greater than the peak load current The class A output stage dissipates its maximum power under quiescent conditions (vO = 0). It achieves a maximum power conversion efficiency of 25%, EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik Summary The class B stage is biased at zero current, and thus dissipates no power in quiescence 43 The class B stage can achieve a power conversion efficiency as high as 78.5% The class B stage suffers from crossover distortion The class AB output stage is biased at a small current; thus both transistors conduct for small input signals, and crossover distortion is virtually eliminated. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik 44 Summary Except for an additional small quiescent power dissipation, the power relationships of the class AB stage are similar to those in class B To guard against the possibility of thermal runaway, the bias voltage of the class AB circuit is made to vary with temperature in the same manner as does VBE of the output transistors The classical CMOS class AB output stage suffers from reducing output signal-swing. This problem may be overcome by replacing the source-follower output transistor with a pair of complementary devices. EE 3120 Microelectronics II Suketu Naik