www.progressivefuelslimited.com 1865 Veterans Park Dr. Suite 303 Naples, Florida 34109 239.390.2885 PFL Weekly RIN Recap Sep 22, 2016 To Sep 28, 2016 RINS started the day early on Monday with levels flat to Friday. E16 traded $0.87 gaining some strength but only reaching levels of $0.8725. The B16 started the week maintaining their +11 penny spread on the E16 only trading in small volumes. E17 and B17 trading activity increased. Also on Monday D3 markets tightened as several refiners appear to be closing out there 2016 obligations. On Tuesday RIN trading picked up with E16 trading up to a $0.88 with the majority of the volume going through at $0.87 and $0.875. B16 hung just below the $1 level. On Wednesday the conference commenced and activity was somewhat muted. RINS remained flat with the high of the day transacting at $0.885. The B16 broke through the $1 mark with 2017 RINS experiencing increased interest.Thursday the RIN market traded in sparse volume as the conference in Chicago crosses into the second day. Levels were flat to Wednesday with levels seen in the market at 87/ 88. The E15/ E16 spread was found at +5. B16 for the session remained at the $1 level with limited interest. Low High Close D6 - 15 87.00 D6 - 16 86.75 D6 - 17 86.75 D5 - 15 98.75 D5 - 16 97.25 D5 - 17 98.75 D4 - 15 99.75 D4 - 16 98.25 D4 - 17 99.75 D3 - 15 159.00 D3 - 16 203.00 D3 - 17 230.00 89.00 87.29 88.75 87.00 87.50 87.04 102.00 100.15 100.00 98.63 102.00 100.10 103.00 101.20 101.00 99.63 103.00 101.10 161.00 160.00 207.00 205.00 240.00 235.00 RBOB/Ethanol CBOT ETHANOL RBOB Month Settle Month Settle Oct 16 1.5400 Oct 16 1.4668 Nov 16 1.4710 Nov 16 1.4421 Dec 16 1.4200 Dec 16 1.4142 Jan 17 1.3890 Jan 17 1.4107 Etoh - RBOB Diff Imp. E85 Price w/RINS Month Settle Month Calc Oct 16 0.07 Oct 16 0.7870 Nov 16 0.03 Nov 16 0.7247 Dec 16 0.01 Dec 16 0.6771 Jan 17 (0.02) Jan 17 0.6503 1.69 RBOB 1.59 Etoh 1.49 E85 w/o RINs 1.39 1.29 1.19 8/4/2016 8/19/2016 9/3/2016 9/18/2016 RIN Values - 2016 BO Futures ULSD Futures Oct 16 33.09 Oct 16 1.5102 Dec 16 33.34 Nov 16 1.5191 Jan 17 33.58 Dec 16 1.5297 33.83 Jan 17 1.5432 Mar 17 ULSD + RIN Value Oct 16 3.005 Nov 16 3.014 Dec 16 3.024 Jan 17 3.038 D4 '15 D5 '15 D6 '15 D4 '16 D6 '16 D5 '17 D4 '17 D6 '17 D5 '16 107 102 97 92 87 82 77 72 67 62 1/8/2016 2/22/2016 4/7/2016 5/22/2016 7/6/2016 8/20/2016 Ethanol Destination Values Spot Arb Snapshot (cpg) D5 - D6 Diff FOB Santos Implied NYH Anhydrous Chicago NYH LA Ethanol -11.25 535.00 568.25 159.63 163.25 169.50 185 175 165 155 145 135 2/18/2016 520 500 480 460 2/18/2016 Argo NYH LA 3/4/2016 3/19/2016 4/3/2016 Santos 3/4/2016 3/19/2016 4/3/2016 This report has been prepared by Progressive Fuels Limited (PFL) personnel for your information only and the views expressed are intended to provide market commentary and are not recommendations. This report is not an offer to sell or a solicitation of any offer to buy any security. The information contained herein has been compiled by PFL from sources believed to be reliable, but no representation or warranty, express or implied, is made by Progressive Fuels Limited, its affiliates or any other person as to its accuracy, completeness or correctness. Copyright 2015 Progressive Fuels Limited. All Rights Reserved. RIN Values - 15 Day - D4 D5 D6 D4 '15 D5 '15 D6 '15 D4 '16 D5 '16 D6 '16 D6 '17 D5 '17 D4 '17 107 102 97 92 87 82 77 9/9/2016 9/11/2016 9/13/2016 9/15/2016 9/17/2016 9/19/2016 9/21/2016 9/23/2016 9/25/2016 9/27/2016 RIN Values - D3 D3 '15 D3 '16 D3 '17 255 230 205 180 155 130 105 11/25/2015 12/30/2015 2/3/2016 3/9/2016 4/13/2016 5/18/2016 6/22/2016 7/27/2016 8/31/2016 PFL 2015-16 D6 Outlook 2016 Projections (September STEO) EIA Projected Gasoline Consumption (STEO est.) Fuel Ethanol Blended into Gasoline (STEO est.) Fuel Ethanol production (STEO est) Ethanol demand at 10% (calc) 9,360 940 990 936 mb/d mb/d mb/d mb/d Chg from Aug ‐330 10 0 23 September ' 15 9,270 940 950 927 2016 D6 RINs Weekly average Ethanol production Most recent 4 week average YTD avg D6 RINs from ethanol based on ytd avg. 963.0 999.5 953.4 14,616 week ended 4 wks ended through million RINs Jan‐Dec EMTS D6 RIN data Annualized D6 Production based on EMTS 8,707.0 10,454 million RINs million RINs 9/23/2016 9/23/2016 9/23/2016 RFS2 Data 2015 RVO 2016 RVO 2017 RVO Advanced 2.88 billion gal Advanced 3.61 billion gal Advanced 4.00 billion gal Cellulosic 123 million gal Cellulosic 230 million gal Cellulosic 312 million gal Biomass-based 1.73 billion gal Biomass-based 1.90 billion gal Biomass-based 2.00 billion gal Renewable 16.93 billion gal Renewable 18.11 billion gal Renewable 18.8 billion gal Prepared by Progressive Fuels Limited T: 239.390.2885 chris@progressivefuelslimited.com