TRANSACTIONS OF THE AMERICAN MATHEMATICAL SOCIETY Volume 171, September 1972 BOUNDARYLINKS AND AN UNLINKINGTHEOREM^) BY M. A. GUTIÉRREZ ABSTRACT. dimensional link This paper gives to be trivial. An 777-link is an embedding (72 + 2)-space. isotopy There the standard cobordant trivial link. to the trivial An interesting Tzz-link is trivial disk; concept, weaker if the embedding with boundary The purpose be (i) boundary, (i) of this paper triviality, trivial; as [7l and [9l. relations, is to give is that any link to if the link to an embedding are called some is which of dimension for a link on the homotopy space, sends meridians to type as follows: is an epimorphism > 4 and (72 + l)- manifolds. conditions are reflected an of the (72 + l)- of m compact of the link in the ambient in 772generators link: copies Seifert homotopic conditions if, and only if, there i. be an m-link of boundary to one of ttz disjoint These These of the image 77,(X) onto the free group Let than if it extends An 772-link is boundary (ii) such are found in [2ll, to it is called extends the sphere. (ii) trivial. of X, the complement into the links one, we say it is a slice. an 772-link is boundary manifolds amongst via our equivalence Any link isotopic for a higher of the 77-sphere relations and definitions to compare, criterion copies equivalence Some results it is useful theoretic of ttz disjoint are various and cobordism. Generally, a homotopic from to generators. \Jm S , the wedge of 772circles; suppose ir.(X) = rr. ( V S1) and that for Then z = 1 meridians are sent is a boundary link where i (q - l)-connected. In particular As by-products, presented for z < q < 7 (« + l) on to generators. the Seifert manifolds for q = V2(n + l), we obtain some results can be chosen to be X is trivial. about cobordism of links which are in §3. Essentially, this the supervision Received of J. Levine, by the editors AMS 1969 subject Key words is the author's thesis, whose September help Boundary the author at Brandeis is glad University under to acknowledge. 28, 1971. classifications. and phrases. written Primary 5520, 5720. zn-link, lower central series of a group, Seifert manifolds. (1) This paper was written in Méjico under the auspices of the O. A. S. Multinational Plan. 49I Copyright © 1972, American MathematicalSociety License or copyright restrictions may apply to redistribution; see http://www.ams.org/journal-terms-of-use 492 M. A. GUTIÉRREZ 0. Notation. smooth or PL, In this locally paper, flat, all manifolds, categories, As usual 5" 772S" is a disjoint and union D"+1 boundary if it extends manifold of Seifert manifolds of 272copies and isotopies All manifolds , M 2. stands belong and the to the are oriented for the disjoint ' =1 (n + l)-disk. union of In particular, of Sn. X: 2225"—►Sn+ to an embedding with boundary for £. 2mz ' are the n-sphere An 22z-link is an embedding orientable mappings consistently. and if M I. (i -..'-. = 1, • • •,* 722) are manifolds, them. [September ^m_, S". (222, s > l); V ■—►S"+ The collection In particular, if the we say that , where is V . is a compact, \V .\ is called V . ate disks, £ a collection we say that <£ is trivial. Consider find tubular Let £..: S"—► S" neighborhoods , the restriction T. of Im(x) X be Sn+ - U T -, a compact same homotopy type as S"+ Consider these arcs arcs and generators X is called the A and, meridians. when the generators [l8l; Gffl is by definition, Ambient collection bundle surgery. of Seifert ÓV¿ =Sn of the are mutually x S" to a common miS disjoint [20]. x Sm) and of the basepoint; for 22> 2, its fundamental is denoted Let manifolds G indicates the by Fim) the union group of is free in 222 or by F{a X.: mS"—* Sn+ for it. Let V ., we can find embeddings where 72th member (| G .. In particular, , ■■■, a ] V. = V ■ and of the lower link and V. —>/ be a map with \V \ a /" With the aid of the (trivial) ip.: the two copies central if F = F(tt2), F<u= 1 [lO]. be a boundary /.: and W. = \ix, t) £ V. x l\ fix) < t\. V .q U V.j, which with boundary are specified. if G is any group, 1. S The group Finally, series = L-, manifold - Im(£). in X joining called of X. to S" ii = 1, • • •, 222); we can W . —►Sn+ ; notice are attached that (0) = normal dW . = by the boundary. The manifold y = s"+2- U<A,(wO is called 5"+ Z™ = liVi0 cut U Vn). along the V ■, a compact The composition manifold with V{ = Vu C Y is called boundary viv See [20]. Let <p:Skx Dn+1~k —>V. be an embedding; define 9ÍV-, <p) as W. U Dk +l x Dn+ 1 ~ L where the handle * is attached to V . by cp; 99 (V¿, cp) is equal Z to V{ U xivi> 0). s = I - t. Suppose that for some k > 1, the V ■ ate zè-connected. By Alexander duality HqiY; Z) =2HqiVi; Z), q < k - 1; let Ya= 5"+2 - Int Uy<aWy, then by [7, §4], Y x is 1-connected. If Y is 1-connected, then by the van Kampen License or copyright restrictions may apply to redistribution; see http://www.ams.org/journal-terms-of-use theorem we have 19721 BOUNDARYLINKS AND AN UNLINKING THEOREM 493 »1<*„I> 0=77j((9W .) 1 77.(Y)=0 7+1 1 r n^y) therefore Y theorem, Y is then . is 1-connected and, by induction, so is Y. By the Hurewicz (k - l)-connected. Lemma (1). // (i) n > 2k + 1 or (ii) n - 2k or 2k - 1, n <4, 77fe(V¿)is in ker v. t, the embedding where cp is an embedding Proof. since ß pair of 77, ,(Y, W .). an embedding This g: D latter a.. (3) of [7]. v.^a. ß' g can be isotoped By using Let = 0, ß a tubular of £ n,(V is the boundary is ¿-connected, —> Y representing V . is 1-connected, g(S ) represents to 8 (V ., cf>), a. We refer to the proof of Lemma ing to a under V. = VÇ, C dY, Since if/.: W.—» Y U W . extends representing and a £ hence which ) correspondof an element by (1) of [6], there is transversal by (2) of [6] and (3) of [7l neighborhood of Im(g) is to the boundary. so that we get the desired extension. 2. The Fundamental and H An) =0, where coefficients. fundamental i Lemma Proof. groups group. Let 77= 77j(X); in [4l it is proven that H (n) is the The inclusion qth homology A C X induces Hy\n) = Zm group of 77 with trivial a homomorphism integral i: F(m) —» 77 of groups. (2). For n > 2, i induces In fact, Proposition F(m)/F(m). z*: F(t72) C 77/77 . 7 induces of F(t7z) and In particular, i±: * (3). £ 77/77., 7 an isomorphism 77. The result the meridians J ^ follows on the first now from [l8, of it generate is a boundary '7 'finite, a free and second Theorem subgroup homology 3-4]. of 77/77 . link if, and only if, the inclusion í¿; F(t7z) C 77/77^ is an isomorphism. Proof. that onto If X. is a boundary »# is an isomorphism. \/m S by projection Let link, 77/77 = F(t7z) via i„ as in [l6l. \Jm Sl be the wedge of t?2 circles, to get a diagram License or copyright restrictions may apply to redistribution; see http://www.ams.org/journal-terms-of-use Suppose now we can map A 494 M. A. GUTIÉRREZ [September X a -E-►v which by [3, p. 194] can be completed fundamental s1 if and only if the corresponding diagram of groups 77 \ p*_^ F(?72) can be completed, So there PL, that is, is a map locally flat) ? Firn) if i^ is an isomorphism. q: X —►\Jm S map. Choose which can be approximated points x . in the z'th circle by a smooth (resp. of \/m S ; the manifolds V'i = q~ ' lix i.) can be deformed to V i. C Sn +2 with dV ii■= L .. Let X and X F-isotopy Sn+ be two m-links of dimension on the z'th component - U. ,.L. if there and an orientation 72. X is a torus preserving arises V = D from it x S homeomorphism by a simple contained /: S"+ in —>5" + such that /(L .) = L* for / / i and either (i) L z. is the core of V (i.e. v v is an isomorphism, (ii) L 2' is the core of fiv) ' Suppose (i) is the case; Theorem (4) (Smythe). inducing an isomorphism For a proof Corollary L z. = (0) x S") and H72(LA = Hn (Sn) -»// z i ifiV)) n ' or and H n ÍL i.) = let H n iS")i —>Hn (V) is an isomorphism. r 27 be the group The group 27/77, = of X and n is a retract p/p2 ani p that of p under preserving of X. a map xp: p —> 27 meridians. see [17]. (5). Every link F-isotopic to a boundary In fact, if X is a boundary, i: Fim) = link is itself a boundary link. Proof. meridians. On the other and the generators Let hand by [l8], are meridians; X be a boundary link, xp: p/pu hence ÍV.! H 1. = 27,(V.) I 1 H 1. —>G the obvious „ tion recall cover v.,: it for the cover of this wedge of circles. copy of y with boundary IntV'.,(izz) the of Seifert homomorphisms. r manifolds group We can to 27 . To motivate ts the cover Let in fact, "7 X should Yiw), 2m_AV -Aw) U Vixiw)); to Int V -Awa .). Suppose and so ipi: F ^ V ■ with fundamental X of X associated \Jm S C X as the meridians; tr/n^ a collection of X cut along and = are tt/ttu X is boundary. Y be the complement construction p/pM and the generators G is presented contain tot w £ F{a., X is obtained for it. G. Let Call find an explicit r its constructhe universal ■• •, a ], be a by identifying by (y x, ■• -, y a; R x, ■■■, R a )> then License or copyright restrictions may apply to redistribution; see http://www.ams.org/journal-terms-of-use 19721 BOUNDARY LINKS AND AN UNLINKING THEOREM Proposition (2) tt= (6). (w, ya: G ^> = rríydí/)), Proof. We have the following RT(ya), wy^w'^y^, presentations: »,«•> = *<--*)) . Here *<*>: 7/. _ we Firn). (1) follows the groups group 495 G^w' amalgamations from Neuwirth's ate in the vertices are performed from considering theorem [l3l. of the universal along the edges We can simply cover of such assume of \/m S cover. that and that the Assertion (2) follows the group extension 1 —> 77 —> 77-► E(t72) —» 1 which splits 3. since F(7T2)is free [ll, Cobordism. A link X. is split by (72 + l)-spheres that they S C X. are cobordant Im(K) meets cobordant Given if there IVl. if the L . can be separated XQ and Jl,, exists link is called K: mS" x I —►Sn+ x I where split-cobordant. 72> 2, ÍV î a collection of Seifert for it. Theorem (7). Every boundary link of dimension Proof. As in III.6 of [4l, we can add handles dimension taken other 72, we say and K|ttz5" x {t\ = £( for ' = 0, 1. A link it be an 772-boundary link of dimension manifolds from each 772-links of dimension an embedding d(S"+2 x /) tranversally to a splitted Let Chapter below the middle to be disjoint. embeddings and, The result by general n > 2 is split-cobordant. to the V"+ position is a collection [l9l, in D"+3 up to one these of manifolds handles W"+ can be in D"+ and j .: V ■x I —*W . satisfying (i) W. O Sn+2 = V. and jfx, t) =Y2(t + l)x in D"+i. (ii) dW.= IC U j.(dV. x /) U V¡, where V\ O V¡ - 0, VJ n f{(dV{x /) = dV[ = j.(dVi x 0). (iii) V- is connected up to the middle dimension. (In particular for 72 even, V. is a disk.) (iv) W. is obtained from j.(V ■x ¡) by adding We use now the engulfing argument of Lemma handles of index < }/2n. 4 of [9l for W y in the notation of [2, Theorem 2], X = V[ and V (of [2]) = D"+3 with cuts along the W\ (l < i < m). The hypothesis of the engulfing theorem is verified as in [9] so we can find a ball B*+3 in V with Bj D W, = V[. Now we repeat the argument for V = D" +3 with cuts along Vf, U B ,, W2, ••-,"/ we get B ,,-•-, 0 1 D"+ - ß contains 4. retic Unlinking criterion and to the engulfing process. By induction B 772 with B Z. f~lW2. = V'. Then B ,1 # • ■■ ü B 772 is a ball B and Z a cobordism of X to a link split spheres in codimension for determining whether two. by the "spheres The following an 772-link of dimension or not. License or copyright restrictions may apply to redistribution; see http://www.ams.org/journal-terms-of-use dB y is a homotopy 72 > 4 is trivial theo- 496 M. A. GUTIÉRREZ Theorem (8). X is homotopy is generated sult X be an m-link equivalent [l5] for 272= 1, 72= 3. setting, results of the cover of X cut along [7] for the case > 7. to this Cappell 772= 1, 72> 4 and by work, Lee [5] proved [l] in his thesis is to be taken with integral X of X made in §2: the Seifert n Ax) = F(m) the re- obtained, in a to ours. all homology the construction copies link, where X; if trivial. Simultaneous similar n > 4 with complement of the trivial X is itself has been found by Levine In this paragraph call then for 222> 2 and odd dimensions more general of dimension to the complement by the meridians, This result Shaneson Let [September manifolds. These coefficients. X is obtained copies Re- by pasting are called Yiw), w £ Fim), and have boundary 2ÍV .Aw) U V .Aw)). Lemma (9). Let be 1-connected Proof. X be a boundary if, and only if, In fact, if the manifolds, Proposition (6), assertion X is in this case link; the Seifert (2). the universal VÇ are simply connected, it n = F{a x, ••-, cover F(m)w= since the map Int V . C X factors By a result 27.(int V .) = 27.(V.) that of Serre [l4], /': D map above; The technique resent a1.. 1 The by general V,, ••-, an innermost component of / without altering by induction. Lemma and (i) v. V ,, • • •, V,, (10). Suppose • 27,(V.) —» z7,(y) simply of the manifolds If 2 < k, , 1-connected. is a monomorphism about the Suppose that, a £ rr X(V^) repa = 0; if 2 > k + (1) to eliminate of Lemma • •■ V ■ such f1. are disjoint. and let on V ■ as in Lemma V, V .) say by a2, to the connected. V .). 77.(int of the remark a A (D ) O (\J we can make the Seifert Vj the map X of X by construction. regular because choose ] the cover generated, the images us to make Vk ate 1-connected; 1, a £ ker v. „ and we can do surgery follows [l9] to 27= F(t22) by a Then, though is finitely fl. exist A position of [7, §5] allows by induction, 1. —» X (l < 2 < 272, 1 < j < r) be transverse f2.(S ) C Int V.2 represents 1 r inclusion can be chosen by the meridians. Conversely, —» 27= F is zero because a2 . Let manifolds n = 27.(X) z's free generated a. The result (9) are So, now (k — l)-connected for t = 0, 1, all i, (ii) 27,(lnt V¿) —»77,(X) z's zero for all i; then 27,(VC) = 0 for all i. Proof. Let a £ 77^VÇ ); by (ii) there is a map /: Dfe+1 —»X such that f(Sk) C Int V . and represents inverse image D + ; let /'). We may assume component If of D * As in Lemma in [7]. that / is ¿-regular , V . is a not necessarily M be an innermost nected submanifold (some a. by / of Um of it, i.e. such that with dW = M and suppose (4) of [7], /|zVf extends By a sequence of such to all connected V . so that ze-manifold there exists a con- f\M maps M to V . to W and we can eliminate manner described /-1(U V¿) = Sk so that vt t^a = 0 for some t and, by (i), modifications License or copyright restrictions may apply to redistribution; see http://www.ams.org/journal-terms-of-use the in we will have a = 0. M in the 19721 BOUNDARY LINKS AND AN UNLINKING THEOREM We can now prove the following Proposition Let complement (11). n>2k+l and x. an m-link of dimension n^^nffls1), includes the assumption meridians.) nected Then Seifert Proof. that the fundamental Jl is a boundary manifolds i<k. group group, Following link and we can find a collection an application of Lemma ate not monomorphisms. so by Lemma of X is generated by the of k-con- for it. (9) suppose, Lemma (10), that the V . are all (k - l)-connected —►itÁY) n > 4 whose X verifies (Uk) (U. 497 By [l4l, of (k > 2), and that Vit*'. ni/A/A) ker V-,t (1) it can be eliminated in the notation is a finitely by surgery; generated by Lemma abelian (10) the V. ate now connected. We must kill ttAV •) when n = 2k or 2¿ - 1 under assumption 2k - 1, ker V. is generated is free abelian; by Lemma therefore, (10), the by primitive by Lemma elements (1) v. * can be made V ■ can be exchanged ^zi*|T. by the Mayer-Vietoris theorem, where © integral is the integral Laurent group polynomials T.. and then, With the notation By Lemma (5) of of §2 and = rr.X = 77,X = 0 is presented 0 = Uk*!* -* Z'W® = H AV ) monomorphic .(V .) has torsion monomorphic. H,X ttAv) for 2^-disks. For 72= 2k, notice that 77,(V .) = H, [7], we can make the (LIA). If n = [12] because [8] and by 0ra -^ "kW S6,* -* "k* = 0 ring of Fizz y • • ■, a in m noncommuting 1 viewed variables as the ring of t,, •--, t and where d is given by the formula d(a ® 1) = v.n*a IU From the sequence Lemma ® /.111- i/.,*a ® 1 for a e //,R. (V I ). , d is an isomorphism. (12). Under the present hypothesis, ker v. is generated by primitive elements. Proof. itive Assume element. z = 1 and let Now, pu. ,a = 0 so that Represent i/j ß to p': D + —►X; ß' extends (w £ F(m)), by an embedding contained D + . Consider manifold ,a' a £ ker v. „. in H Ay) iy a (U /3'-1(U V Aw)) V-,(l)); a = pa £ Hl(Y) —» Y(l) C X. can be assumed in X, so ß'~ the components W and hence ß: S Then and is a torsion Since to be transversal ® © , W establishes together a homology License or copyright restrictions may apply to redistribution; see http://www.ams.org/journal-terms-of-use is a primelement. X is contractible, is a ¿-dimensional they, a to the V Aw) manifold with in S , bound a 498 M. A. GUTIÉRREZ [September m (3) "1(/® 1 = 22 {uioa, • h - vaa\ • 1} z= l where o".(resp. Since each loop d is an isomorphism, <f. represent M2 by an arc y,y2 y, Now consider nonconnected those that each fj^a) = 0. Then that In fact, if cri =*Çj + M . of D + , we can join arc it bounds y2 in /3 (W). a 2-disk; Let y £ T. torsion M, The resulting by a Whitney process that represents can be eliminated by 2k + 1 disks generalization reasoning: in particular v. y = 0 for some In such a way we can assume ker vi the above elements, y £ H ,(V Aw)) = H A]/ ■) be represented and y = 0 and the intersection V ■ can be exchanged proof is a direct Notice all represent components. the o. = o. £ T .. of D + —VI and repeat V . (w)) of [7, p. 13]. Thus, V-Al)). component component. is a monomorphism, (resp. (\J are innermost by the method submanifolds Y, hence V„(l) submanifold. and by another in with /3'" Kv i0(l)) = Mj # M"2. of ß'~ by an innermost that by a connected in V ._(l) is nullhomotopic the components of ß'(W) from (3) we conclude we can alter ß' so that the the intersection oi (a A can be represented zf2 and the and o\ ) represents by surgery proof which Since v. \T. y can be eliminated ß'(D and the theorem of Levine's s. ) C Y(l) and and so by Lemma is proven. (10), The present is remarkably simple and geometrical. Theorem (Lee's homotopyzJ morphic (8) is equivalent to the following form of the Unlinking equivalent ' to K As a last Theorem). statement: Let M" , « > 3, be a closed to K nm =SlxS"#---#S1xSn(m in the category remark, that the fundamental out it both results both s ' then manifold, M is iso- PL. in Proposition group be generated are false. times); (3) and in Theorem by meridians (8), the condition is essential. In fact, with- See [22]. REFERENCES 1. 2. S. Cappell, Thesis, Princeton University, Princeton N. J., 1970. M. W. Hirsch, Embeddings and compressions of polyhedra and smooth Topology 4 (1966), 361-369. 3. S. T. Hu, Homotopy manifolds, MR 32 #6478. theory, Pure and Appl. Math., vol. 8, Academic Press, New York, 1959. MR 21 #5186. 4. M. A. Kervaire, 93 (1965), 225-271. 5. R. Lee, Les Unlinking N. J., 1969. (mimeographed 6. J. Levine, de dimensions spheres supérieures, Bull. Soc. Math. France in codimension two, Princeton University, Princeton, notes). Imbedding Soc. 60 (1964), 433-437. 7. --, noeuds MR 32 #6479. and isotopy of spheres in manifolds, Proc. Cambridge Philos. MR 35 #2292. Unknotting spheres in codimension two, Topology 4 (1965), 9—16. MR 31 #4045. 8. -, Polynomial (1966), 537-554. 9. -, 229-244. Knot invariants of knots of codimension two, Ann. of Math. (2)84 MR 34 #808. cobordism groups in codimension two, Comment. MR 3*9#7618. License or copyright restrictions may apply to redistribution; see http://www.ams.org/journal-terms-of-use Math Helv. 44 (1969), 1972] 10. BOUNDARY LINKS AND AN UNLINKING THEOREM W. Magnus, A. Karrass and D. Solitar, Combinatorial group 499 theory, Interscience, New York, 1969. MR 34 #7617. 11. Academic 12. S. Mac Lane, Press, Homology, Die Grundlehren New York; Springer-Verlag, J. Milnor, Lectures der math. Berlin, on the h-cobordism Wissenschaften, 1963- theorem, Band 114, MR 28 #122. Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton, N. J., 1965. MR 32 #8352. 13. L. Neuwirth, Knot groups, Ann. of Math. Studies, no. 56, Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton, N. J., 1965. MR 31 #734. 14. J.-P. Serre, Groupes (2) 58 (1953), 258-294. 15. J. Shaneson, d'homotopie Embeddings with Amer. Math. Soc. 74 (1968), 972-974. 16. N. Smythe, no. 60, Princeton 17.. Boundary 18. 170-181. 19. links, Univ. Press, N. Smythe abeliens, Ann. of Math. codimension two and h-cobordisms of S X S , Bull. Wisconsin Topology N. J., 1965. Algebraic invariants Seminar, Ann. of Math. Studies, MR 34 #1974. of isotopy of links, Amer. of groups, J. Algebra J. Math. MR 34 #807. J. Stallings, Homology and lower central series 2 (1965), MR,31 #232. R. Thorn, Quelques propriétés Math. Helv. 28 (1954), 17-86. 20. de groupes MR.37 #5887. Princeton, and R. Holmes, 88(1966), 646-654. et classes MR 15, 548. E. Zeeman, Twisting globales des varietés differentiables, spun knots, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 115 (1965), 471—495. MR 33 #3290. 21. A. Haefliger, Differentiable links, Topology 1 (1962), 241-244. 22. V. Poénaru, ment of a submanifold Comment. MR 15, 890. A note on the generators for the fundamental group of codimension two, Topology 10 (1971),- 47—52. MR 26 #5585. of the comple- SCHOOL OF MATHEMATICS, INSTITUTE FOR ADVANCED STUDY, PRINCETON, NEW JERSEY 08540 Current address: chusetts 02115 Department of Mathematics, Northeastern University, License or copyright restrictions may apply to redistribution; see http://www.ams.org/journal-terms-of-use Boston, Massa-