Information Systems

advertisement

PROCEEDINGS

of the Eleventh

nternational Conference

on

Information Systems

December 16-19, 1990 Copenhagen, Denmark

Editors

Janice I. DeGross

University of Minnesota

Maryam Alavi

University of Maryland, College Park

Hans Oppelland

Erasmus University

V I U Sponsored by

The Society for Information Management and

College on Information Systems, The Institute of Management Sciences in cooperation with

Special Interest Group on Business Data Processing, Association for

\ ^ y Computing Machinery and for Information Processing

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Foreword xi

Welcome from the Conference Chair : xv

Finding International Contracting Opportunities: AI Extensions to EDI

Ronald M. Lee and Sandra Donaldson Dewitz, University of Texas, Austin 1

A New Approach for Conflict Resolution and Rule Processing in a Knowledge-Based System

Akhil Kumar, Cornell University 15

The Design of Computer Based Support for Task Communication within Organizations

Surinder Singh Kahai, University of Michigan, and Randolph Cooper, University of Houston 25

An Evaluation of Electronic Meeting Systems to Support Strategic Management

Alan R. Dennis, Craig K. Tyran, Douglas R. Vogel, and J. F. Nunamaker Jr., University of Arizona 37

Structuration Theory and Information Systems Research

Geoff Walsham and Chun-Kwong Han, Cambridge University 53

Toward a Theory of the Deep Structure of Information Systems

Yair Wand, The University of British Columbia, and

Ron Weber, The University of Queensland 61

Cross-Cultural Information Technology Research: The Case of

Eastern Europe and the USSR

William K. McHenry, Georgetown University; Joel Snyder and Kevin Lynch,

University of Arizona 73

Institutions and the International Diffusion of Information Technology

V. Gurbaxani, J. L. King, and K. L. Kraemer, University of California, Irvine;

F. W. McFarlan, Harvard Business School; and K. S. Raman and C. S. Yap,

National University of Singapore 87

Abstraction Based Modeling: An Empirical Study of the Process

Ananth Srinivasan and Dov Te'eni, Case Western Reserve University 99

A Comparison of the Data Aggregation Approach with the Logical Relational

Design Methodology

Dinesh Batra and Peeter J. Kirs, Florida International University I l l

Desktop Computerization as a Continuing Process

Mary Zmuidzinas and Rob Kling, University of California, Irvine; and

Joey George, University of Arizona 123

A Diffusion of Innovation Approach to MIS Infusion: Conceptualization, Methodology and

Management Strategies

Tae Hyoung Kwon, Hankuk University of Foreign Studies 139

Case-Based Reasoning in Software Effort Estimation

Steven Vicinanza, Michael J. Prietula, and Tridas Mukhopadhyay, Carnegie Mellon University 149

On the Economics of the Software Replacement Problem

Dhananjay K. Gode, Anitesh Barua, and Tridas Mukhopadhyay, Carnegie Mellon University 159

Computer Training and Computer Anxiety in the Educational Process: An Experimental Analysis

Jane Webster and James B. Heian, The Pennsylvania State University; and

Jeffrey E. Michelman, University of North Florida 171

User Information Satisfaction: Toward Conceptual Clarity

K. Kyu Kim, Inha University 183

Strategic Information Systems in Manufacturing Industries

Mogens Kuhn Pedersen, Roskilde University Centre 193

The Use of Strategic Information Technology by Entrepreneurial Firms

Peter Weill, University of Melbourne, and Marianne Broadbent, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology . 205

Allocation of Databases in a Distributed Database System

Sudha Ram, University of Arizona, and Sridhar Narasimhan, Georgia Institute of Technology 215

Issues in Distributed Model Management Systems

Waleed A. Muhanna, The Ohio State University 231

A Source Tagging Theory for Heterogeneous Database Systems

Y. Richard Wang and Stuart E. Madnick, Massachusetts Institute of Technology 243

Systems Developers: Preoccupations, Knowledge and Power

Hugh Willmott, Manchester School of Management; Jan Mouritsen, Per Flensburg, and

Bente Elkjaer, Copenhagen Business School 257

What Is an "End-User"? Identifying Multiple Relationships Among Information System Users

C. J. Martin, Loughborough University 265

Approaches to Strategic Information Systems Planning Experience in Twenty-One United Kingdom Companies

Michael J. Earl, London Business School 271

An Agency Theory View of the Management of End-User Computing

Vijay Gurbaxani, University of California, Irvine, and

Chris F. Kemerer, Massachusetts Institute of Technology 279

An Empirical Test for the Expansion-Control Model for Managing End-User Computing

James C. Brancheau, University of Colorado, Boulder, and

Donald L. Amoroso, University of Colorado, Colorado Springs 291

VI

PANELS

Track Chairs: Jon A. Turner, New York University, and Claudio Ciborra, University of Trento 305

Panel 1:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Panel 2:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Panel 3:

Panel Chair:

Panelists

Panel 4:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

National IT Policies in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union (Session M2.3)

Seymour Goodman, University of Arizona

Dmitri S. Chereshkin, Academy of Sciences

Adrian Davidoviciu, National Commission on Informatics

Tomasz Jarmoszko, The MOSAIC Group, University of Arizona

Wladyslaw Turski, University of Warsaw

Tibor Vamos, Academy of Sciences

Lessons Learned from Information Technology Research on Small Organizations

(Session M2.4)

William H. DeLone, The American University

Gunnar E. Christensen, Norwegian School of Economics and

Business Administration

K. S. Raman, National University of Singapore

Louis Raymond, Universit6 du Quebec a Trois-Rivieres

Approaches to the MBA Core Course in Information Systems (Session M3.2)

Edward A. Stohr, New York University

Tawfik Jelassi, INSEAD

Stuart E. Madnick, Massachusetts Institute of Technology

James L. McKenney, Harvard Business School

James A. Senn, Georgia State University

Mark S. Silver, University of California

Executive Information Systems: Assessing Impacts and Value (Session M3.3)

Joyce J. Elam, Florida International University

Tom Clark, Florida State University

Hisham El Sherif, The American University in Cairo and Information and

Decision Support Center, Cabinet of Egypt

Jack Rockart, Massachusetts Institute of Technology

306

307

308

310

Introduction to Mini-Track: Perspectives in Information Systems Research (Panels 5 and 6)

Izak Benbasat, University of British Columbia

Panel 5:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Making Sense of Quantitative Data in Information Systems Research: Tradeoffs,

Strengths and Weaknesses of Three Approaches to Analyzing Empirical Data

(Session M3.4)

Dale Goodhue, University of Minnesota

Fred Davis, University of Michigan

Ron Thompson, University of Vermont

Panel 6:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Making Sense of Qualitative Data in Information Systems Research (Session M4.4)

Allen S. Lee, Northeastern University

Richard Boland, Case Western Reserve University

M. Lynne Markus, University of California, Los Angeles

Michael Newman, University of Manchester

311

312

313 vu

Panel 7:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Panel 8:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Models for the Information Systems Curriculum: What's Happening Internationally

(Session M4.2)

Gordon B. Davis, University of Minnesota

Clive Holtham, City University of London Business School

Herbert E. Longenecker, University of South Alabama

Jay F. Nunamaker, University of Arizona

Andreil Sole, Haute Etudes Commerciales Jouy-en-Josas

Developing Global Information Technology Applications (Session M4.3)

Blake Ives, Southern Methodist University

Sirkka Jarvenpaa, University of Texas, Austin

Alex Mayall, Index Group

Edward Roche, University of Arizona

John Shepherd, Air Products Europe

314

316

Introduction to Mini-Track: Information Technology and Tomorrow's Organization (Panels 9, 10, and 11)

Michael J. Ginzberg, Case Western Reserve University

Panel 9:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Information Technology and Tomorrow's Organization: The Potential for Change

(Session T2.3)

Lynda M. Applegate, Harvard University

John L. King, University of California, Irvine

Klaus Lenk, University of Oldenburg

Daniel Robey, Florida International University

Robert W. Zmud, Florida State University

Panel 10:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Information Technology and Tomorrow's Organization:

New Models for the Global Enterprise (Session T3.3)

Robert M. Mason, Case Western Reserve University

Donald Feldman, BP Oil Europe

Benn R. Konsynski, Harvard Business School

Ronald G. Smart, Digital Equipment Corporation

Charles B. Stabell, Norwegian School of Management . .

Panel 11:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Information Technology and Tomorrow's Organization: Coordination

and Control in Devolving Organizations (Session T4.3)

Robert W. Blanning, Vanderbilt University

Richard M. Burton, Duke University

B0rge Obel, Odense University

Michael J. Prietula, Carnegie-Mellon University

Ann C. Seror, Universit6 Laval

317

318

320

322

Panel 12: Recent Advances in Supporting Collaborative Work (Session T2.4)

Panel Chair: Judith S. Olson, University of Michigan

Panelists: Paul Cornell, Steelcase, Inc.

Stephen Gale, Hewlett-Packard Laboratories

Helmut A. O. Krcmar, University Hohenheim

Robert Luchetti, Robert Luchetti Associates, Inc.

Gary M. Olson, University of Michigan 323 vui

Panel 13:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Panel 14:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Telecommunications Reform in Europe: Implications for

Information Systems Management (Session T3.4)

Charles Steinfield, Michigan State University

Peter Allen, American Express

Nicholas Costello, European Commission, Telecommunications Directorate

Alain Vallee, Directorate for General Regulation, Ministry of Posts,

Telecommunication, and Space

Research Directions in Computer-Aided Software Engineering (CASE) (Session T4.2)

Kalle Lyytinen, University of Jyvaskyla

Francois Bodart, University of Namur

Sue Conger, City University of New York

Wanda Orlikowski, Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Richard J. Welke, Erasmus University Rotterdam

Panel 15:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Teaching by the Case Method: Secrets of the Trade (Session W1.3)

Brandt Allen, University of Virginia

James Cash, Harvard University

Michael Oliff, IMD School of Business

Panel 16:

Panel Chair:

Panelists:

Index of Authors

Business Applications of Neural Networks: Problems and Opportunities (Session W2.3)

Shimon Schocken, New York University

John Hertz, Nordita and Neurotech

Ludwik J. Liszka, Swedish Institute of Space Physics

Douglas L. Reilly, Nestor Inc.

Leo Vercauteren, State University of Ghent

324

326

327

342

345

IX

Download