EnSURE Energy Savings in Urban Quarters through Rehabilitation and New Ways of Energy Supply Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions 3.1.2 Output April 2011 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Partner’s project responsible of the output: Agenda 21 consulting l.t.d (PP12 Cooperation: all EnSURE partners 2 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Index Examination of Local Power Supply System ........................................................................................ 4 PP 1 - City of Ludwigsburg (Ludwigsburg - DE) .................................................................................... 7 PP 2 - GAL Genova (Genoa-IT ............................................................................................................ 11 PP3 – SIPRO (Ferrara-IT)..................................................................................................................... 17 PP 4 – Faenza Municipality (Faenza-IT).............................................................................................. 20 PP 5 – KEK (Debrecen-HU) ................................................................................................................. 27 PP 6 - Gorenjeska (Kranj-SLO) ............................................................................................................ 28 PP 7 - PRAGA (Warsawa-PL) ............................................................................................................... 30 PP 8 – Sopot Municipality (Sopot-PL) ................................................................................................ 32 ANNEX I .............................................................................................................................................. 38 ANNEX II ............................................................................................................................................. 39 Notes .................................................................................................................................................. 73 3 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Examination of Local Power Supply System This document “Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions” (3.1.2 output) is part of the WP 3 “Concepts for an energy efficient urban development” and properly for the Action 3.1 “Joint analysis of the current energy situation of urban district”. It is included also in the complete version of the Handbook output (2.1.3.). It is a sort of database on local energy supply systems in 8 cities/regions with the identification of local power supply system defining type of fuels, type of power system (individual, centralized), age of technology for all local partners. Local partners: PP 1 - City of Ludwigsburg (Ludwigsburg - DE) PP 2 - GAL Genova (Genoa-IT PP3 –SIPRO (Ferrara-IT) PP 4 – Faenza Municipality (Faenza-IT) PP 5 – KEK (Debrecen-HU) PP 6 - Gorenjeska (Kranj-SLO) PP 7 - PRAGA (Warsawa-PL) PP 8 – Sopot Municipality (Sopot-PL) Every partner had the possibility to fulfill a “checklist” for all data. It is a sort of map (see followed table). It is divided in some sections in order to collect more data possible about the power supply system of local partners. Some partners have utilized this tool, but other not, collecting in another way the requested data. The following pages present all available data of all local partners. Checklist for data’s collection a) Condition of power supply system a1) heating system Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served Installed power Annual consumption Type of fuels Type of power system (individual, centralized) Age of technology Main past intervention a2) air conditioning Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served Installed power Annual consumption Type of fuels Type of air conditioning system (individual, centralized) Age of technology 4 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Main past intervention a3) lighting Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served Insallation of low consumtion devices o Annual consumption o Age of technology o Main past intervention b) Building b1) Type of building Private Public Historic value Residential Public services Industrial b2) Condition of building year of construction construction material roofs insulations doors and windows location related to public transport general state of the building c) Social aspects c1) Residential buildings Type of ownership (property, rent, public, private) Social condition: lower class, middle class, higher class c2) Public buildings Typology of users c3) Business premises Typology of enterprises d) Methodology of analysis on desk survey on site inspection all building inspections versus samople analysis documentation already available provided (layouts, technical diagrams of utilities systems, utilities manuals) instrumental surveys (thermographic and thermoflow analyses, etc.) documentation to be produced e) Key tools and indicators for energy diagnosis 5 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions energy balance sheet and CO2 balance sheet annual energy consumption per surface unit (kWh/m2/year) total annual energy consumption of the building and the quarter distribution of consumption by type of usage (heating, air conditioning, lighting, etc.) CO2 emissions per surface unit (kg/m2/year) CO2 emissions from the building and the quarter (t/ year) 6 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions PP 1 - City of Ludwigsburg (Ludwigsburg - DE) Condition of power supply Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served City of Ludwigsburg has about 85.450 inhabitants Density of population is in the City of Ludwigsburg 2.014 inhabitants/km², administrative district Ludwigsburg: 751 inhabitants/km² 52.000 households in Ludwigsburg, number of flats is unknown a1) heating system Installed power Our own public utility company Ludwigsburg-Kornwestheim built up a new co-generation plant with a yearly power of 10 Mio kWh electricity and 48 Mio kWh heating from biomass, supply of about 70% of the whole district heating of the City Annual consumption Final energy consumption in the year 2007: 2.244 Mio kWh/a Main Proportions: households 45% and traffic 28% Per capita: average 25.700 kWh/a Type of fuels 25% oil, 25% petrol, 29% gas, 18% electricity, 3% renewable energies (from the final energy consumption); 2007 Type of power system (individual, centralized) new co-generation plant with biomass (wood chips from the region) district heating (new co-generation-plant): connection of new residential area “Hartenecker Höhe”, city centre, public buildings, current plans for an extension of the district heating six heating stations, three block heating stations (public utility company) natural gas pipeline (public utility company) local heating network: housing area “Sonnenberg” – geothermal energy individual power supply – gas, oil Age of technology new co-generation plant was build up in 2009 Main past intervention New co-generation plant from the public utility company Ludwigsburg-Kornwestheim in 2009 Geothermal energy plant “Sonnenberg” a2) air conditioning --a3) lighting --7 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions b) Conditions of buildings (construction material, roofs, insulations, doors and windows, location related to public transport. Etc…) Construction material High proportion of listed buildings (baroque buildings, walling, timber framing, mansard roof, brick, sandstone, exposed masonry, perforated facades) architectural and artistic monuments: inner city 340, districts 93 Main proportion: post-war buildings (main challenge, typical building structures 1950s to 1970s) New building areas with high energy standards, e.g. new building area “Hartenecker Höhe”, former military site, now single familiar houses and multi family houses with high energy standards Public transport very good connection within the region of Stuttgart, fast accessibility (ten minutes by train to the regional metropolis Stuttgart) two sub-urban railway lines, further several direct train connections from Ludwigsburg to Stuttgart and other cities in the region Ludwigsburg: different bus lines, good accessibility of the whole City c) Social aspects c1) Residental buildings Type of ownership 37 percent of the habitations are in ownership (source: Coummunal housing policy Ludwigsburg: Weeber + Partner, page 29) a high rate of ownership you can find in the districts of „Hoheneck“, “Oßweil”, “Neckarweihingen” and “Poppenweiler” (50 percent) Social conditioning the population of Ludwigsburg is distinguished by a high wealth (like the metropolitan area Stuttgart) the higher class and the upper middle class prefer the northern part of the east-district (Ost-Nord) and the outskirts of Ludwigsburg e.g. “Pflugfelden”, “Hoheneck”, “Oßweil”, “Neckarweihingen” and “Poppenweiler” (source: Coummunal housing policy Ludwigsburg: Weeber + Partner) 8 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions c2) Public buildings --c3) Business premises --e) Key tools and indicators for energy and diagnosis energy balanced sheet and CO2 balance sheet 1) energy consumption the actual final energy demand in Ludwigsburg for 2007 was around 2,244 million kWh/a the energy is attributed to households at 45%, followed by transport with 28% Renewable energy contributes about 3% of the final energy demand in Ludwigsburg 2) CO2 - emissions 1990: 582 kt/a (7,1 t/a/capita) 2007: 539 kt/a (6,2 t/a/capita) 2010: 521 kt/a (6,0 t/a/capita) these results includes all emissions of the whole city of Ludwigsburg (territorial principle) Potentials for renewable energies “This could cover around 38% of today’s electricity demand in Ludwigsburg. Photovoltaics would play the major role followed by biomass (regional level) and hydro power use. If a 20% reduction in the overall electricity demand by 2025 is assumed due to the implementation of energy efficiency measures, then renewable energy could have a share of 47% in the City of Ludwigsburg. The potential to use renewable energy for heat generation in Ludwigsburg totals around 350 GWhth (wood on a regional level). This would cover almost 39% of today’s heating demand in Ludwigsburg. Solar thermal will play the most significant role followed by wood use and surface geothermal heat collected through 9 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions geothermal probes and collectors. If a 40% reduction in the overall heating demand by 2025 is assumed due to the implementation of energy efficiency measures, then renewable energy could have a share of 64.5% in the City of Ludwigsburg for the heating demand.” (source: Integrated Climate Protection and Energy Strategy: page 5 and 6) Methodology of Integrated Climate Protection and Energy Strategy “The system boundaries for the analysis of the energy and CO2 emissions balance were drawn by the physical borders, i.e. the emissions resulting from energy use in the city are attributed to the city (“bubble principle”). One exception is electricity use, where the polluter pays principle was followed, for which emissions from power plants providing electricity to the city will be attributed to the city although the energy conversion takes place outside of Ludwigsburg. Another exception is the consideration of traffic from the motor vehicle stock ascribed to Ludwigsburg, where the national German average kilometres travelled and specific fuel consumption values differentiated by type of motor vehicle and engine design were applied.” (source: Integrated Climate Protection and Energy Strategy: page 4) Sources: Integrated Climate Protection and Energy Strategy: University of Stuttgart (Institute of Energy Economics and the Rational Use of Energy), January 14, 2011 Coummunal housing policy Ludwigsburg: WEEBER+PARTNER (Institute of urban planing and social research), August 2005 10 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions PP 2 - GAL Genova (Genoa-IT a) Condition of power supply system a1) Heating system Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served In 2001 the total number of houses was just over 300,000 and about 270,000 were occupied; the average area of each apartment was equal to 81,9 m2. Surfaces and volume of houses total occupied Number 305.244 272.146 Surface (m²) 24.997.511 22.286.988 Volume (m³) 82.491.785 73.547.094 Installed power As for the plants you find that about half of the housing is equipped with central heating system and the remaining part has autonomous systems or equipment for each individual room. Type of heating system for houses Type of heating Houses Number % centralized 148.385 48,61 autonomous 126.707 41,51 Individual equipment 29.134 9,54 No installation 6.804 2,23 total 305.244 100 Annual consumption Thermal quality From the energy point of view, a survey conducted by ARE on a sample of 50 energy certificates for various kinds buildings in the town of Genoa consisting of individual apartments, condominiums, office buildings, schools, industrial buildings and sports facilities, showed a specific heat consumption in the real conditions of utilization equal to 151 kWh / m 2 years compared with a mean value required by Legislative Decree no. 192/2005 and its updates equal to 40 kWh/m2 years. This makes the civil service sector significant from an energy standpoint in that it provides big margins to reduce consumption. This situation is due to the fact that most of the buildings was made before the first regulation in energy consumption in the civil services, (Law 373/76), plus the high presence of load-bearing masonry buildings that, contrary to conventional opinion, are particularly inefficient in terms of heat loss in winter. 11 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions In addition, the twenty years 1970 ÷ 1990 saw a large diffusion of autonomous heating systems with combined instant production of sanitary hot water that requires a strong oversizing of the boiler compared with the loads for heating, predominant in terms of energy, and that is the cause of low efficiency and high fuel consumption for the same service. Also the centralized systems are generally oversized, including thermal stations renewed after the entry into force of the DPR 412/91. Power quality No data are available on the quality of building stock in terms of energy efficiency in electrical field and there are no reference standards containing indices with which to compare the characteristics of the Genoese buildings. It can be said that the situation is similar to other municipalities in northern Italy. There is in particular a growing demand for summer cooling by using single air conditioners (portable or single split type) low-cost and low efficiency. The entry in the market for non-specialized retailers such as supermarkets and department stores that put on cheapness of the product rather than quality, has encouraged the use of such systems, become available to consumers in all income classes. This process was also supported by the absence of legislation equivalent to that on heating, regulating the design, installation and operation of cooling systems. The City of Genoa has joined in February 2009 the initiative the Covenant of the European Union with the aim of reducing by 2020 over 20% of CO2 emissions. The Action Plan for Sustainable Energy (SEAP) is a key document that defines the energy policies, that the City of Genoa intends to take in order to achieve the objectives of the Covenant. Final Energy consumption - City of Genoa – year 2005 Local and civil transport sectors Legend: Natural gas Electricity Fuel Gas oil Combustible oil Liquid gas 12 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Type of fuels b) Building b1) Type of building Private Public Historic value Residential Public services Industrial The building stock of the City of Genoa, according to the last census in 2001, has a little more than 33,000 buildings, of which about 32,000 used Used buildings use quantity % houses 29.408 91,74 cohabitation 182 0,57 hotel 42 0,13 office 218 0,68 Commerce and industry 976 3,04 communication and transports 37 0,12 Recreational activities school and sportive 242 0,75 303 0,95 13 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions hospital 22 0,07 church 156 0,49 other 471 1,47 total 32.057 100 b2) Condition of building year of construction Regarding the construction period it is noted that in the late ‘20s and early ‘70s the residential construction stock, which accounts for 89% of all buildings, has more than doubled, from about 13,000 to almost 28,000 buildings, to reach about 30,000 by the end of 2001 Period of construction of buildings used for habitation use quantity % before 1919 12.982 44,14 from 1920 to 1945 5.988 20,36 from 1946 to 1961 5.672 19,29 from 1962 to 1971 3.282 11,16 from 1972 to 1981 812 2,76 from 1982 to 1991 563 1,91 from 1992 to 2001 162 0,55 Total 29.408 100 construction material it is pointed out that, in the domestic field, the load-bearing masonry structure is the most prevalent in buildings constructed before 1945 and was subsequently replaced by reinforced concrete pile-empty box. Construction type of buildings used for habitation material quantity % bearing masonry 18.226 61,98 reinforced concrete ground floor 8.402 closed 28,57 reinforced concrete ground floor 898 open 3,05 other (reinforced concrete and 1.882 masonry bearing, steel, wood, etc.). 6,40 total 100 29.408 general state of the building 14 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions The condition is quite good in terms of construction for 68% of the buildings. Conservation status of the buildings used for habitation Conservation status quantity % Very good 6.826 20,59 good 15.466 46,64 mediocre 6.238 18,81 terrible 878 2,65 Without indication 3.751 11,31 total 33.159 100 c) Social aspects c1) Residential buildings Type of ownership (property, rent, public, private) Occupied houses by residents in residential buildings - 2001 Census. City of Genoa Property Rent Other Total 274.487 96.033 24.755 395.275 d) Methodology of analysis on desk survey on site inspection all building inspections versus sample analysis documentation already available provided (layouts, technical diagrams of utilities systems, utilities manuals) instrumental surveys (thermographic and thermoflow analyses, etc.) documentation to be produced e) Key tools and indicators for energy diagnosis energy balance sheet and CO2 balance sheet annual energy consumption per surface unit (kWh/m2/year) total annual energy consumption of the building and the quarter CO2 emissions per surface unit (kg/m2/year) CO2 emissions from the building and the quarter (t/ year) distribution of consumption by type of usage (heating, air conditioning, lighting, etc.) 15 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Bibliography: Sustainable Energy Action Plan – Municipality of Genoa-Environment and energy department; ARERegional Energy Agency of Liguria Region; CRUIE-Research Centre in town planning and ecological engineering of University of Genoa Inventory of greenhouse gas emissions in the Province of Genoa – CO2 emissions referred to the final Energy use – Province of Genoa- Environment department 16 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions PP3 – SIPRO (Ferrara-IT) General information about the province The area covers about 2,600 square kilometers and is bordered on the north by Po river and on the south by the Rhine river. Originally dominated by forests, marshes and brackish valleys, this territory was substantially modified over the centuries from multiple remediation make it more hospitable and appropriate for productive activities. The territory of Ferrara has not yet reached its full formation and transformation, and it is possible to observe big differences between the northern part of the Province, called Alto Ferrarese, and the southern, called Basso Ferrarese. The average altitude is around zero, with peaks of +18 (in the Town of Cento), vast areas of -3 (in the Municipalities of Codigoro and Comacchio, an area of about 13,000 is under the sea level), and valleys, permanently covered by brackish water (15,000 ha). The current physical structure of Ferrara territory is still influenced by several problems related to the hydrographic network, to the natural and artificial subsidence, to the sea level rise and decrease of sediment supply from rivers (in order to contrast the subsidence phenomenon). The eastern part of Ferrara Province (named “Basso Ferrarese”), marked by significant thicknesses of compressible deposits, was and is affected by significant vertical sinking of the soil. This issue has important consequences in Ferrara urbanization generating into the “Basso Ferrarese” dispersed residential areas which led to multiple " scattered houses " very far apart (not to be considered as urban areas). There are many large areas for agricultural use, with few industrial sites grouped in a few areas well defined and circumscribed. Moreover this part of the territory is characterized by important protected natural areas (such as Parco del Delta del Po), which in order to be safeguarded require special regulations over all the local planning policies. The remaining part of the province (north-west) is characterized by a different scenario: there is much more continuity in the residential urbanization, coupled with a broader industrial expansion that exploits agricultural areas (which remain a distinctive feature of the remaining plain territory). The environmental issue dealt with by the Region Emilia Romagna through the regulation about ecologically and environmentally equipped industrial sites-AEA (i.e. new generation of industrial sites) have recently opened a new period in the local economic development. SIPRO, as Managing Authority of the future AEA, will be in charge of the redevelopment of 3 industrial sites, which include the implementation of 7 photovoltaic plants, realized on industrial sites or landfill areas. In addition the number of biomass plants is growing thanks also to the still very important agricultural sector. b) Building b1) Type of building X Industrial-business incubators b2) Condition of building-business incubators’ network 17 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions year of construction:The incubator of S. Giovanni di Ostellato was the first to be built, in 1999. The other 2 incubators in Copparo and Ferrara were built in 2000-2001. Finally the incubator located within the area of the Technological Pole in Ferrara was built in 2008. construction material: Pre-stressed reinforced concrete, cement for the Technological Pole incubator roofs: In San Giovanni di Ostellato there is pitched roof whereas in the other business incubators the roofs are flat Insulations: Some works for the insulation of windows and doors were concluded in 2008 in Copparo and Ferrara (see following chart). location related to public transport: The business incubators in Ferrara-Cassana, Copparo and S. Giovanni di Ostellato are all located within industrial sites, therefore well connected with the main roads and highway, nevertheless no public transport is foreseen to connect these sites with the urban areas. The Technological Pole incubator is located in the university area, therefore it’s connected also with public transport. general state of the building: Heat loss characterized the business incubators in Copparo, FerraraCassana and S. Giovanni di Ostellato, it was mainly due to a bad design of the heating system. The problem was partially solved with some the works realized for the energy efficiency (listed in the following chart) c) Social aspects c3) Business premises X Typology of enterprises The enterprises located in the network are very different the one from the other: service companies as well as productive activities are hosted in the premises. Here is a list of the main sector of activities currently settled in the 4 incubators: Technological Pole business incubator technological transfer and industrial application of new polymeric materials; services linked to space technologies and remote sensing sector; system for measurement of ionizing radiations, particularly for Nuclear Medicine; topography and cartography. Ferrara business incubator environmental services; technologies for the sea fishing; environmental engineering projects; alternative energy sources Copparo business incubator business catering services; metal-mechanical sector; industrial automation and electrical plant engineering; communication and advertisement; 18 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions San Giovanni di Ostellato metal-mechanical sector; Being the sectors of activity very different, the request for energy varies a lot and this implies difficulties in the effort to implement a plan for the energy efficiency in the overall network. In the past years several improvements have been adopted in the business incubators of Copparo and Ferrara-Cassana mainly to optimize the isolation systems and to decrease the energy use. In the following chart the main interventions have been summarized: Type of work Description Business incubator Energy efficiency Thermoregulation system for the Copparo and Ferrara boiler switch on and off Energy efficiency Boiler replacement Energy efficiency Insulation of the pipes’ heating Ferrara system Comfort Floors Insulation Copparo Comfort Insulation of windows and doors Ferrara and Copparo Comfort False ceiling installation Ferrara Comfort Thermal solar panels Cassana Ferrara The business incubator of the Technological Pole in Ferrara is slightly different as it was built several years after the first 3 infrastructures, therefore some special works for the energy efficiency have been foreseen since the very beginning. It has been planned and realized with special systems for the use of alternative energy and the provision of systems and facilities for the innovative enterprises hosted there and the environmental safeguard. It is provided with a thermal solar plant, pre-setting for chimney extractor hood, pollutant liquids drainpipe, gas supply plant in all premises, cooling and electricity generation with counters on each premises. The infrastructure has also been pre-set for the supply of energy through district heating system, in addition the incubator is provided with a co-generation system for the production of thermic energy and electricity (produced by thermic wastes). In the future, the possibility to implement some energy audits for the different business incubators should be considered. d) Methodology of analysis X on site inspection e) Key tools and indicators for energy diagnosys General information about the energy system in the Province of Ferrara are provided in the Study about the Technical status-quo. See the Annex I. 19 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions PP 4 – Faenza Municipality (Faenza-IT) 1) Via Ponte Romano a) Condition of power supply system a1) heating system Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served: o Number of flats: 10 per building, total 80 o Equivalent inhabitants: mean 2 per housing unit, 20 per building, total 160 o Usable heated surface: approx. 41.2 m² per unit, approx. 412.5 m² per building, total approx. 3300 m² Installed power: Approx. kW 4.8 (radiators), approx. kW 25 (generator) Annual consumption: Approx. 840 Nm³ per housing unit (heating approx. 92%, domestic hot water approx. 8%) Type of fuels: Natural gas Type of power system (individual, centralized): Individual Age of technology: Late '80s Main past intervention: Main renovations: works by individual users and / or by the jointly-owned building, for example: replacement of the heating boiler, replacement of the windows staircases a2) air conditioning Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served: Single /multi-split systems, if installed by the owners Installed power: Variable Annual consumption: Not available Type of fuels: Electricity Type of air conditioning system (individual, centralized): Individual Age of technology: Variable Main past intervention: Not available a3) lighting Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served o Number of flats: 10 per building, total 80 o Equivalent inhabitants: mean 2 per housing unit, 20 per building, total 160 o Usable heated surface: approx. 41.2 m² per unit, approx. 412.5 m² per building, total approx. 3300 m² Insallation of low consumtion devices: During the progressive replacement Annual consumption: Not available Age of technology: Variable Main past intervention: Not available b) Building 20 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions b1) Type of building Private and/or Public Residential b2) Condition of building year of construction: 1955 construction material: Plastered bearing masonry, concrete and masonry floors roofs: Unheated attic and pitched roof insulations: Broken Insulation; any thermal insulation interventions are not known doors and windows: (Depending on the block) metal (also with double frame) or with PVC double glazing location related to public transport: Served by bus stop general state of the building: Various c) Social aspects c1) Residential buildings Type of ownership: property and rent; public and/or private Social condition: lower class d) Methodology of analysis on desk survey: √ on site inspection: √ all building inspections versus sample analysis: sample analysis documentaion already available provided: architectural layouts instrumental surveys: thermographic and thermoflow analyses documentation to be produced e) Key tools and indicators for energy diagnosys energy balance sheet and CO2 balance sheet: not available annual energy consumption per surface unit (kWh/m2/year) o risc.: approx. 180 o a.c.s.: approx. 15 o tot.: approx. 195 total annual energy consumption of the building and the quarter o housing units approx. 8.1MWh/ year o entire building approx. 81MWh/ year distribution of consumption by type of usage (heating, air conditioning, lighting, etc.) o approx. 85% for heating uses o approx.15% for electric uses CO2 emissions per surface unit (kg/m2/year) o approx. 40 for heating uses o approx. 22 for electric uses 21 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions CO2 emissions from the building and the quarter (t/year) o single housing unit approx. 2,5 t/year o entire building approx. 25 t/year o block (n. 8 buildings) approx. 200 t/year 2) Via Corbari (Palazzi) a) Condition of power supply system a1) heating system o Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served: o Number of flats: 20 per building, total 40 o Equivalent inhabitants: total 130 Usable heated surface: approx. 59.5 m ² per unit, total approx. 2380 m ² Installed power: Approx. kW 5.0 (radiators), approx. kW 25 (generator) Annual consumption: Approx. 1075 Nm³ per housing unit (heating approx. 86,2%, domestic hot water approx. 14%) Type of fuels: Natural gas Type of power system (individual, centralized): Individual Age of technology: 1988 Main past intervention: Main renovations: works by individual users and / or by the jointly-owned building, for example: replacement of the heating boiler, closure of the back loggias by metal staircases single glass windows a2) air conditioning Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served: Single /multi-split systems, if installed by the owners Installed power: Variable Annual consumption: Not available Type of fuels: Electricity Type of air conditioning system (individual, centralized): Individual Age of technology: Variable Main past intervention: Not available a3) lighting Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served: o Number of flats: 20 per building, total 40 o Equivalent inhabitants: total 130 o Usable heated surface: approx. 59.5 m² per unit, total approx. 2380 m² Insallation of low consumtion devices: During the progressive replacement Annual consumption: Not available Age of technology: Variable Main past intervention: Not available 22 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions b) Building b1) Type of building Private and/or Public Residential b2) Condition of building year of construction: 1988 construction material: Reinforced concrete structure and plastered brick cladding, concrete and masonry floors roofs: Concrete and masonry terraced floors with thermal insulation and waterproofing insulations: Broken Insulation; any thermal insulation interventions haven’t been done subsequently doors and windows: Metal double glazing location related to public transport: Served by bus stop general state of the building: Good c) Social aspects c1) Residential buildings Type of ownership: property and rent; public and/or private Social condition: middle class d) Methodology of analysis on desk survey: √ on site inspection: √ all building inspections versus sample analysis: sample analysis documentaion already available provided: architectural layouts instrumental surveys: thermographic and thermoflow analyses, thermo hygrometric survey. documentation to be produced e) Key tools and indicators for energy diagnosys energy balance sheet and CO2 balance sheet: not available annual energy consumption per surface unit (kWh/m2/year) o risc.: approx. 136 o a.c.s.: approx. 24 o tot.: approx. 160 total annual energy consumption of the building and the quarter o housing units approx. 9.5 MWh/anno o entire building approx. 381MWh/anno distribution of consumption by type of usage (heating, air conditioning, lighting, etc.) o approx. 80% for heating uses o approx.20% for electric uses CO2 emissions per surface unit (kg/m2/year) 23 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions o approx. 32 for heating uses o approx. 25 for electric uses CO2 emissions from the building and the quarter (t/year) o single housing unit approx. 1,9 t/year o entire building approx. 76,2 t/year 3) Via Corbari (Villette) a) Condition of power supply system a1) heating system Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served: o Number of flats: 9 o Equivalent inhabitants: 4 per housing unit, total 36 o Usable heated surface: approx. 120m ² per unit, total approx. 1080m ² Installed power: Approx. kW 9.0 (radiators), approx. kW 25 (generator) Annual consumption: Approx. 2200 Nm³ per housing unit (heating approx. 88%, domestic hot water approx. 12%) Type of fuels: Natural gas Type of power system (individual, centralized): Individual Age of technology: 1986 Main past intervention: Main renovations: works by individual users and / or by the jointly-owned building, for example: replacement of the heating boiler a2) air conditioning Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served: Single /multi-split systems, if installed by the owners Installed power: Variable Annual consumption: Not available Type of fuels: Electricity Type of air conditioning system (individual, centralized): Individual Age of technology: Variable Main past intervention: Not available a3) lighting Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served: o Number of flats: 9 o Equivalent inhabitants: 4 per housing unit, total 36 o Usable heated surface: approx. 120 m² per unit, total approx. 1080 m² Insallation of low consumtion devices: During the progressive replacement Annual consumption: Not available Age of technology: Variable Main past intervention: Not available 24 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions b) Building b1) Type of building Private - Residential b2) Condition of building year of construction: 1986 construction material: Prefabricated system made of lightened reinforced concrete (vertical panels and floors) roofs: Unheated attic and insulated pitched roof insulations: EPS type (intermediate insulation into the walls and under covering surface) doors and windows: Timber-wood double glazing location related to public transport: Served by bus stop general state of the building: Good c) Social aspects c1) Residential buildings Type of ownership: property and rent; private Social condition: middle class d) Methodology of analysis on desk survey: √ on site inspection: √ all building inspections versus sample analysis: sample analysis documentaion already available provided: architectural layouts instrumental surveys: thermographic and thermoflow analyses. documentation to be produced e) Key tools and indicators for energy diagnosys energy balance sheet and CO2 balance sheet: not available annual energy consumption per surface unit (kWh/m2/year) o risc.: 122 ÷ 136 o a.c.s.: 16 ÷ 18 o tot.: 140 ÷ 155 total annual energy consumption of the building and the quarter: o housing units approx. 16.8÷18.6 MWh/year o entire building approx. 151÷167.4 MWh/year distribution of consumption by type of usage (heating, air conditioning, lighting, etc.) o approx. 75% for heating uses o approx.25% for electric uses CO2 emissions per surface unit (kg/m2/year) o approx. 30 for heating uses 25 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions o approx. 28.5 for electric uses CO2 emissions from the building and the quarter (t/year) o single housing unit approx. 23.5 t/year o entire building approx. 211.5 t/year 26 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions PP 5 – KEK (Debrecen-HU) Kek partner has provided a complete document on “Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions” mapping the energy sources of the city of Hajdúszoboszló. This report it provided by StrateGIS Szolgáltató és Tanácsadó Kft, expert in that. Below we present the index but to have a complete view of the document, see the Annex II. Index of the report 1. Introduction of Hajdúszoboszló 2. Electricity supply 3. Natural gas supply 4. Propane gas supply 5. District heating 6. Solar power 7. Wind power 8. Hydropower 9. Geothermal energy 10. Biomass 27 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions PP 6 - Gorenjeska (Kranj-SLO) a) Condition of power supply system a1) heating system Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served / no flats Installed power / 50kW Annual consumption / cca 6000 l Type of fuels / light oil Type of power system (individual, centralized) / central heating Age of technology / 1978 Main past intervention / 1978 a2) air conditioning Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served / no flats Installed power / 300W Annual consumption / 90kWh Type of fuels / electricity Type of air conditioning system (individual, centralized) / local ventilation of sanitary premises, other part of the building natural ventilation through windows Age of technology / 1985 Main past intervention / 1985 a3) lighting Number of flat (families, n. of peoples, surface) served / no flats Insallation of low consumtion devices / no installed saving lights Annual consumption / no info Age of technology / 1956 Main past intervention / 1985 b) Conditions of buildings construction material / armed concrete, full brick roofs / flat AB plate with z bitumen hidroisolation insulations / hidroisolation of roof plate doors and windows / massive woden door, woden windows with double glazing location related to public transport / 300 m c) Methodology of analysis on desk survey / no tecnical documentation exist on site inspection / visual overview of the building was made all building inspections versus samople analysis/ detailed overview of the building follows documentaion already available provided (layouts, technical diagrams of utilities systems, utilities manuals) / only one shematic tloris is available instrumental surveys (thermographic and thermoflow analyses, etc.) / no 28 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions documentation to be produced /architectual measurement of the building, elaborate - study of the construction phisics of the existing state of art, "PZI rebuilding of the object and energy sanation of the building with overview of the necessary work and costs, elaborate of the construction phisics o the building d) Key tools and indicators for energy diagnosys energy balance sheet and CO2 balance sheet/ data after analysis annual energy consumption per surface unit (kWh/m2/year) / data after analysis total annual energy consumption of the building and the quarter/ data after analysis distribution of consumption by type of usage (heating, air conditioning, lighting, etc.) / data after analysis CO2 emissions per surface unit (kg/m2/year) / data after analysis CO2 emissions from the building and the quarter (t/ year) / data after analysis 29 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions PP 7 - PRAGA (Warsawa-PL) a Condition of power supply system a1 heating system Residential buildings: 215 Buildings with usable space: 11 Total number of buildings: 226 Living premises: 16.628 Usable premises: 430 Total number of premises: 17.058 Number of living rooms : 55.753 Living surface (m2): 862.886 Usable surface (m2): 55.437 Number of cooperative members: 16.547 Inhabitants number (appr.): 50.000 Installed power o 72,65 MW heating o 19,88 MW hot water Annual energy consumption(for 2009) o 496760,05 GJ heating (137 989 MWh o 250477,47 GJ hot water (69 577 MWh) Type of power system: Central heating installations in RSM "Praga" are being supplied by cenral heating system of city Warsaw. The source of heating is electro power station "Żerań" which is powered by coal. Age of technology: The age of central heating installations is different (installed 1961-2010). Old cental heating and hot water installations are being consecutively replaced by new ones (pipes and valves) or modernized (installing of thermostatic valves and automatic). This works are conducted according to the needs and financial possibilities. a2 Air conditioning: There is no in RSM "Praga" a3 Lighting: There is no data. Collecting of this data would require a lot of time and costs. b Conditions of buildings: Multi family buildings constructed in period 1961-2010 construction material: mainly concrete big plate Insulations: In period 1961-2010 buildings have been constructed according to the different heat protection engineering standards. 30 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Before changing the regulation of Now November 2008 Type of elemet PN-57 PN-64 PN-74 PN-82 PN-91 External walls 1.16 1.16 1.16 0.75 0.55-0.73 0.30-0.50 0.30 Flat ventilated roof 0.87 0.87 0.7 0.45 0.3 0.3 0.25 Attic roof 1.05 1.16 0.93 0.4 0.3 0.3 ≤ 0.22 - - 2.0-2.6 2.0-2.6 2.0-2.6 1.7 - 1.8 Windows (independence on the climatic zone) - Insulatin works on RSM "Praga" buildings are being consecutively conducted. 180 buildings (out of 215) have been already insulated. Flatroofs have been insulated in 41 buildings.Windows have been exchanged in common spaces of 78 buildings C Methodology of analysis Analysis are based on invoices from energy suppliers, analysis of architectonical projects, observations and inspections. Full analysis (energy use balance) for purpose of cental heating and hot water for all buildings have to be done d Key tools and indicators for energy diagnosys Annual energy consumption: in everage 123,35 kWh/m2 for heating Everage annual CO2 emissions: 42,1 kg CO2/m2 in a year Total annual CO2 emissions: 70 988 t CO2 31 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions PP 8 – Sopot Municipality (Sopot-PL) Condition of power supply system A1) heating system The heating power supply system in Sopot is: About 262 local sources (the amount changes with new emerge sources and liquidation of inoperative ones)and the biggest one has a disposal raw = 16MW. Some big sources work for local heating plant networks and serve several buildings. There is 16 of this kind of local networks, 4 of them are exploited by owners of buildings and boiler houses, the rest by OPEC (District Enterprise of Energetics, Gdynia). The biggest heating plant is 16MW and serves 114buildings, the total installed power is 87WM. This heating system supports about 54% of flat usable areas, 90% of commercial areas, and all public buildings. The dominant fuel is gas – 86% of heat, 7% is coal and fuel-oil. Heating plant network, GPEC (District Enterprise of Energetics, Gdańsk. It serves the south part of Sopot – about 13.0MW Individual heat sources in dwelling houses and commercial areas, exploited by users. It’s about 28% of usable areas and some commercial areas, 4 of them by heating pump (0,5MW). The dominant fuel is gas – 85%, 11% coal and solid fuels, 2% fuel oil. 2% of dwelling houses uses electric power. Heat requirement, status quo = about 113MW and 794 TJ a2) air conditioning We don’t have any local supply system so every flat/building administrates its apart system. a3) lighting The source of the energy in Sopot is transformer station 110/15kV (GPZ – Transformer/Switching Station; two transformers, the power 25MVA each). Double track line is provided do GPZ from “Gdańsk Leźno”, and that is connected with track line 110kV with network supply 110kV from Gdańsk and Gdynia. Switching station 15kV GPZ supports the power distribution 15kV. It works with rings system, that provides the bilateral powering from the Transformer stations 15/0,4kV. 15kV network provides energy to transformer stations 15/0,4kV. From the station threw low tension network 0.4kV is distributed to receiver. The network is after renovation and most of it is in a good technical condition. The networks density of 15/0.4 kV, especially in 1 part of Sopot (Dolny Sopot) is small, it causes decrease of tension. Street light, installed power: 487191 Watt lighting fitting tipe Amount power [W] Sodium-vapor 3258 453625 Mercury-vapor 246 28353 Fluorescent lamp 130 5213 b) Building 32 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions b1) Type of building Register of Historic Monuments Street Age Material ul. 1 Maja 10 1893, 1913 stone 23 Marca 72 1920 Stone/wood 23 Marca 74 1920 Stone/wood 23 Marca 68/70 1920-1922 Stone/wood 3 Maja 16 1902 stone ul. Abrahama 10 1922 Stone Al. Niepodległości 618 1857, 1974 1870, Stone Al. Niepodległości 752 2nd part of Stone/timber XVII, the end frame of XIX Al. Wojska Polskiego 1 1907 Wood Ul. Andersa 25 1906 Stone/timer Armii Krajowej 68 1912 Stone Ul. Ceynowy 3 80ties Stone Chmielewskiego 9 1901 Stone Ul. Chopina 36 1912 Stone Ul. Chrobrego 48 1909 Stone Czyżewskiego 12 1790 Czyżewskiego 13 1905 Goyki 3 1880 1st part of XIX cent Stone 1894, 1933 1893 19ties, 20ties Grottgera 3 Changes/modernization 1893 Stone 1913-15 Stone Grunwaldzka 11 1880-1890 Stone Grunwaldzka 17 90ties Stone Grunwaldzka 33 1897 Stone/timber Grunwaldzka 70 1905 Stone Grunwaldzka 4/6 1910-1920 Stone Haffnera13 1905 Stone Haffnera72 1910-15 Stone Haffnera86 1870 Stone 33 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Helska 1 1907 Stone/timber Jagiełły 10 1897 Stone Jagiełły 12 1899 Stone Kazimierza Wielkiego 1 20s Stone Kilińskiego12 1906 Stone/timber Kościuszki1 1860 Stone Kościuszki 29 1898 Stone Kościuszki41 1891 Stone Kościuszki43 19s Stone Kościuszki 63 19s Stone Królowej Jadwigi 3 1906 Stone Królowej Jadwigi4 1910 Stone Królowej Jadwigi5 1907 Stone Królowej Jadwigi 6 1910 Stone Królowej Jadwigi 7 1914 Stone/timber Królowej Jadwigi 9 1914 Stone Lipowa 9 1910 Stone/timber Majkowskiego 8 1906-1907 stone Malczewskiego 30-35 19s stone Małopolska 5/7 1900-1910 Stone/timber Mickiewicza 12 1908 Stone Mickiewicza 36 1920 Stone Mokwy 5 End of XIX c stone Mokwy 6 1900 Stone Mokwy 7 1987 Stone Mokwy 5b 1900 Stone Moniuszki 10 20s Stone/timber Morska 7 1904 Stone/timber Obr. Westerplatte 3 19s Stone Obr. Westerplatte 24 19s Stone Obr. Westerplatte 30 1904 stone Obr. Westerplatte 18-20 1870 Stone Paderewskiego 12 1920 Stone Parkowa 10 1895 Stone Parkowa 24 19s Stone Parkowa 43/45 1905 Stone/timber 34 1910 1993 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Parkowa 5 1919 Stone/timber Plac Konstytucji 3 Maja 1899 – 1901 stone Plac drojowy 1 1903 Stone Poniatowskiego 8 1900-1903 stone Powstańców Warszawy 2/4/6 1910-1911 stone Powstańców Warszawy 12/14 1927 stone Powstańców Warszawy 1870 Stone Sobieskiego 35 1895 Stone Struga 6 20s Wooden Struga 11 Wooden Władysława IV 30 1910 Stone Władysława IV 32 1910 Stone Władysława IV 37 1911 Stone Władysława IV 48 1907 Stone Wybickiego 30a 1914 Stone Wybickiego 43, 43a 1913 stone 1989 According to the Communal record of antique buildings: There is a list of 1257 buildings from the XIX and XX century. About 70% are made of stone (brick), about 15% are timber frame/stone construction. During last 13 Years thanks to “Revitalization of the historic part of Sopot” 279 elevations were renovated. Industrial: no industrial buildings Residential cooperative => about 134 multifamily buildings Residential „Przylesie” 9 multifamily buildings - 20758,92m2, 4 utility objects –> 20 premises 1439,53 m2, 1460 citizens 792 flats: 694 owner properties o 14 tenant flats o 4 rented o 6 social (unfortunately I have only from one residential so detailed information) 35 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions SOCIAL INFRASTRUKTURE Education and bred: 23 public + 2 un-public Public utility: 8 objects Sport and culture department: 20 objects 7 churches and 2 sacral objects Free standing business objects: 11 Administration: 2 objects + other office buildings = 42 000 m2 Touristic objects: 35 36 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions ANNEX 37 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions ANNEX I Energy System of the Province of Ferrara “Assessment of the current situation and of the energy supply system” 38 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions ANNEX II Examination of the local power supply system in PP 5 KEK partner regions (Basic data on energy supply in Hajdúszoboszló and its region) 39 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions 2CE166P3 EnSURE project Energy Savings in Urban Quarters through Rehabilitation and New Ways of Energy Supply Output 3.1.2 Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions (Basic data on energy supply in Hajdúszoboszló and its region) WP3: Concepts for an energy efficient urban development ACTION 3.1: Joint analysis of the current energy situation of urban districts Prepared by: StrateGIS Szolgáltató és Tanácsadó Kft. Project partner name and identification number: Eastern Hungarian European Initiations Foundation (KEK) PP5 Responsible name and surname: Dr. György Norbert Szabados Function: project manager Contact details (tel. and email address): +36 20 51 99 585, szabados@agr.unideb.hu 2011 40 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions ABSTRACT It is a well –known fact that prevailing politics have a determining effect on the energy supply of the World and of course Europe and Hungary as well. Being aware of this situation, more efficient and more economic exploitation of energy sources must be aimed at. To achieve these particular targets, detailed mapping of the region, and within it, the city of Hajdúszoboszló has to be realized to gain more information about the presence of conventional (fossil) and alternative (renewable) energy sources. Since energy prices are determining factors in all areas of life, rationalizing its utilization in order to achieve sustainable development and to sustain the quality of life is an absolute necessity. Our mission was to contribute to a better standard of living of the city of Hajdúszoboszló by detailed mapping of its energy sources. 41 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction of Hajdúszoboszló ...................................................................................................43 Electricity supply ..........................................................................................................................48 Natural gas supply.........................................................................................................................53 Propane gas supply........................................................................................................................54 District heating ..............................................................................................................................56 Solar power ...................................................................................................................................59 Wind power ...................................................................................................................................61 Hydropower ..................................................................................................................................62 Geothermal energy ........................................................................................................................63 Biomass .........................................................................................................................................66 42 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Introduction of Hajdúszoboszló Hajdúszoboszló is situated in the north-eastern part of the Great Hungarian Plain, 200 kilometres from Budapest and 21 kilometres from Debrecen in Hajdú-Bihar County. It the centre of the Hajdúszoboszló sub region (Figure 1.) that was named after the city itself. Here you can find the largest thermal spa in Hungary. Figure 1: Geographical location of Hajdúszoboszló Source: www.googlemaps.com More specifically the town is located in the region of the Hajdúhát, the Hortobágy, the Great Sárrét and the Berettyó. The landscape of the city is primarily determined by the fact that it is a flatland accompanied by smaller and larger earth heaps, loess and sludgy areas, with wavy elevations. The Eastern Main Canal runs along the western part of the city and smaller rills and brooks trickle across the town. Due to the Great Hungarian Plain character of the land, the city is characterized by warm and dry climate. During the summer season the number of the daily sunshine hours is especially high, which is beneficial for the city from the aspect of tourism. Despite the little precipitation in Hajdúszoboszló there is always appreciable air movement. It is very rare when the air is calm. The favourable climatic properties also supported the development of this curing resort. 43 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions The accessibility of the town is ideal due to the closeness of the seat of Hajdú-Bihar County (the town in only 21 kilometres from Debrecen) and some of the main traffic lines in Hungary. The railway line No. 100 and the highway No. 4 run through the town. The transport-geographical position of Hajúszoboszló was improved on with the completion of motorway M35 in 2006. Although the motorway does not cross the area of the city, it reaches highway No. 4 at Ebes – near Hajdúszoboszló – which allows quick access to the motorway. Beside the good road system the city lies between two regionally significant town – Derecske and Balmazújváros. The 1st chart shows the main demographic data of Hajdúszoboszló. Demographic data 238.7 km2 Area Population Total 23,282 people Density 99.9 people/km2 Table 1: Demographic data of the town of Hajdúszoboszló Source: own edition based on www.wikipedia.com As summarized in chart 1 the area of Hajdúszoboszló is 23,870 hectares, its total population is 23,282 people and its population density is 100 people per km2. The city is the center of the sub region named after the city. This region is a medium-sized area of Hajdú-Bihar County with a medium population. The micro-regional role of the city is important.1 1 Local Sustainable Development Plan of the City of Hajdúszoboszló (Local Agenda 21) 44 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions The following picture (Figure 2) illustrates the settlement units and structure of the city: Figure 2: The settlement structure units of Hajdúszoboszló Source: Local Sustainable Development Plan of the City of Hajdúszoboszló (Local Agenda 21) The settlement structure of the city is characterized by a bipolar structure. The city centre includes the residential area of the former medieval town. It is surrounded by the outer ring of the suburbs developed from the orchards and gardens of the medieval town. Experts of the Integrated Urban Development Strategy – during the planning of the function upgrade rehabilitation of the town – distinguished two characteristic structural parts of the city that are important in terms of the regional development. • The Hungarospa Hajdúszoboszló Medical Spa, which is located in the north-north-eastern part of the city, induced the development of a complex holiday resort supplied with services in large quantities and high quality. • The spatial centre of the city allows the access and use of public services mostly for the local population. These two central parts are separated from each other both geographically and functionally. 45 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Utility services Piped water 98% Electricity 100% Street lighting 100% Sewer 79% Gas 95% Constructed road 95% Table 2: Utility services in Hajdúszoboszló Source: own edition The town's access to public services can be considered advantageous, as the 2nd chart shows as well. The length of the constructed drinking water network was 108.2 kilometres in 2008. As Figure 3 shows, with the construction of the drinking network the number of homes connected to it was continuously increasing (with 17.05% within 10 years). In 2008 the number of homes connected to the water network was 10,523. Figure 3: The changes of public utility gap in Hajdúszoboszló Source: szferastudio.hu The year of 2005 was of great importance in terms of the development of the public sewer network as in this year, due to the support of the European Union, its length doubled. At the present it is 82 kilometres long which means that 758 meters sewer pipe comes to 1 kilometre drinking water pipe. The number of homes connected to the sewer network doubled in 2005 as well and it 46 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions slightly increased until 2008 (7896 homes). The sewer network is still incomplete in 47 streets – the city submitted an application for the building of the missing sections which is under processing already and hopefully it will close the slightly opened public utility gap of the town. The following figure shows the size of the utilities in the town. 47 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Electricity supply The electricity in Hajdúszoboszló is supplied by the Debrecen region of the E.ON Tiszántúli Áramhálózati Zrt. The amount of the supplied electricity is 94,389,000 kWh. 15,314 customers are connected to the network and most of them are qualified as household customers (figure 4). Figure 4: The typical power consumption data between 2000 and 2008 Source: KSH T-Star The number of household electricity consumers since has increased by 21% since 2000. The quantity of electricity supplied to households has increased more dynamically with 44 %. The latter has increased thank to the spread of modern household appliances and computers which are continuously increasing the energy consumption despite of the technological development. The total amount of the supplied energy shows an increasing tendency as you can see in figure 5, except the year of 2003. It can be stated that more and more electrical energy is needed to meet the demands of the consumers. 48 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Figure 5: The total amount of the supplied energy Source: own edition Hajdúszoboszló and its farmland are equipped with 138 transformers. In the inner city you can mostly find underground cable network which is 24 kms long while in the suburbs are supplied with landline network which is approximately 16 kms long. We can state that the quality of the cables is safe and satisfactory. The medium voltage network is supplied by the Hajdúszoboszló substation with a 20 kV landline cable. The length of the low voltage network is 122 kms of landline cable and 72 kms of underground cable. These lengths are increasing year by year as you can see in figure 6. Low voltage networks are networks that are not greater than 1 kV nominal voltage and they transmit power to the consumers. 49 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Figure 6: The length of the low voltage distributing network Source: own edition The electricity from the power stations gets to the consumers through the national energy grid. At the present the energy grid – after gradually joining the independent blocks with higher and higher quality level – consists of a nationwide connected line network and the substations placed on its nodes. The line network constitutes a coherent, well-organized and high-order configuration. According to the mode of the bond we distinguish radial network, closed circular line and loop network. The last link in the national grid is the consumptive network to which all the small consumers are connected.2 The consumptive network somewhere is radial and somewhere is loop network. Voltage level: 400/230 V. The open line network that is supplied from one feeding-point and branches off towards the consumers is called radial network (Figure 7). The figure shows that the failure of one line involves the failure of the next line supplied by it. In terms of safety of operation it a disadvantageous quality but the operating is easier and the costs are lower. The radial network is the part of the distributing network that supplies the small consumers directly (e.g. rural network). 2 www.elmu.hu 50 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Figure 7: Radial network model Source: www. elmu.hu If we join the branches of the radial network by its endpoint we get a closed circular line (Figure 8). In case of circular line if the line breaks the energy supply of the consumers does not stop as they can be supplied from both directions. Figure 8: Closed circular line model Source: www. elmu.hu The loop network is used for the energy supply of industrial works. In the loop network the cables create a multiple connected closed system thereby ensuring the energy supply of the consumer from more sides (Figure 9). That kind of solution offers high safety of operation but the costs increase significantly and the operating is more complicated as well. 51 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Figure 9: Loop network model Source: www. elmu.hu 52 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Natural gas supply Figure 10 shows the total and the domestic natural gas consumption between 2000 and 2008. Figure 10: Natural gas consumption of Hajdúszoboszló Source: KSH T-star The amount of natural gas supplied for both the population and the municipal and economic sector has dynamically increased between 2000 and 2003. However, after 2003, due to the increase in the market price of gas, consumption decreased by almost 10% mainly in the population. After 2006, thanks to gas price subvention, another decreased can be observed in domestic consumption. The figure clearly shows that changes in local consumption are determined by the population. Domestic consumption is mainly characterized by heating purposes. The difference in the amount gas consumption during winter time is usually compensated by wood or different kinds of carbon with a high sulphur and ash content which – due to inappropriate heating technologies – have an adverse effect on the town’s quality of air. The establishment of public utilities is favourable and the amount of coverage is 95%. The number of natural gas consumers in Hajdúszoboszló is more than 10 000, while the number of domestic consumers is 9 936 and the amount of total transit gas supplied is around 23 500 m3. The number of households linked into the district heating system is 1215. Gas supply in the town works on a 6 bar system. The map of this medium pressure network system in Hajdúszoboszló can be found in Annex 2. 53 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions According to the relating legislation ‘natural gas universal service provider: is the holder of authorization who has been authorized by the Hungarian Energy Office to trade with universal service packages for small-scale consumers’. Domestic households and other consumers with a capacity not more than 20 m3/hour can be supplied by natural gas market undertakings with an operational licence issued by the Energy Office in the specific operational area. TIGÁZ Zrt. (a universal natural gas distribution service provider in the North-East region of Hungary) is one example for this since they have the license for universal service and natural gas trade. In case of universal service providers, the conditions of licensing includes, amongst others, the operation of a telephone, electronic and office customer services for clients to manage their notifications, to investigate and solve their complaints and to inform public citizens. The degree of the highest tariffs to be paid for the use of the natural gas system is determined by the Minister responsible for energy policies. Tariffs of gas sold to consumers by gas traders are determined by common agreement or it is included in the gas trader’s regulation. Tariffs of natural gas traded within the framework of universal service – in line with legislative rules and determined in accordance with the license approved by the Hungarian Energy Office – is included in the business rules of the universal service provider. In the case of Hajdúszoboszló, the provider of universal service is the TIGÁZ Zrt. Current tariffs determined and applied by the company are listed in Table 3. Valid tariffs of natural gas by unversal sevice of TIGÁZ Zrt. from 1 April, 2010 sales categor below 20 m3/h between 20-100 m3/h between 100-500 m3/h above 500 m3/h basic fee HUF/piece; HUF/(m3/h); 12 000 19 068 1 000 1 000 gas fee HUF/m3 105,2 86,3 80,5 80,3 Table 3: Universal service tariffs of the TIGÁZ Zrt. Source: Hungarian Energy Office Propane gas supply The Pébé-Coop Ltd. was established in 1990, its members were individuals and a former gas supplier company. Its objectives were clearly focused on the area of propane gas supply. It intended to be a supply company which provides propane gas for domestic and public consumers. The 54 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions company served its customers in the most overall way as possible: this service included the design of consumer systems up to execution and after it the company supplied the consumer systems with gas. They obtained the most high-tech tank cars that meet the requirements of the official licences and it started as the only fully Hungarian owned propane gas supplier company. The company received the licences for supplying propane gas in 1992. At the same time another company was established which aimed the use of propane gas as propellant gas in the same propane gas sector. These are usually used in some cosmetics and other aerosols. The Pébé-Coop Ltd. still has these services and continuously expands them. Currently their service covers the examination and the licensing of propane gas tanks.3 3 www.pebecoop.com 55 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions District heating The Hajdúszoboszló Utilities Water, Sewer and Heat Supply Ltd. was established by the Hajdúszoboszló Local Government Plc., the Hajdúszoboszló Spa Inc. and the Hajdúszoboszló Town Management Plc. At the time of the foundation the ownership percentages were divided into equal parts among the three owners. In 2003 the Hajdúszoboszló Spa Inc. and Town Management Plc. sold their ownership to Hajdúszoboszló Local Government so it became the owner in 100%. The ownership rights are exercised by the Representative Body of the city of Hajdúszoboszló, while the supervision is performed by a three-person supervisory committee. The objectives set up at the foundation are still valid. So the task of the company is the following: • to run the town’s water and distant heating system at the highest possible level • to ensure the adequate quantity and quality drinking water, to purify the waste water with high quality and to ensure the necessary supply of heat service These objects have not changed during the years and their job is to carry out these objects. During the last years every development was made to realize to stated goals. The few years that followed the foundation were of great significance in the development of the company. The organization need to be evolved and the technical and technological background need to be assured after the formation of the company. After the initial difficulties a stable employee circle was developed and the necessary technical and financial background for the operation was set up. Over the years the primary goal was the continuous maintenance, repair and to satisfy the new demands. The activities can be divided into three main groups and there is a fourth activity group covering all the three areas as well. These are the drinking water service, the sewage disposal and cleaning, distance heating and the administration service that contacts these three fields together. In the city the company supplies 1,216 homes and some public consumers with distance heating and hot water. The consumer base increased with 10% thanks to the successful developments in the last few years. In 2004 more than 150 consumers were connected to the system with the reconstruction and construction of the cable in József Attila Street. In 2005 the condominium next to the Forrás Áruház was connected into the system with the future possibility of connecting new customers. It also supplies schools and public institutions. The distance heating plant was built in 1985 with 7+7 MW nominal capacity and hot water boilers. In order to be more diversified in the future they expanded the service with a small gas-driven power station that in its actual condition can generate 1.5 MW thermal powers and 1.5 MW electric powers. In spite of the 56 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions continuous gas price increase the company managed to keep the heat charges at a tolerable level for the customers. The service provider gives all the assistance to those customers who are trying to achieve savings with the upgrading of their systems. The task of the following years will be the modernization of the hot water production urged by the law as well. The Local Government of Hajdúszoboszló acknowledged the work of the company with the Kovács Gyula Prize on 2 September 2005. The Representative Body of Hajdúszoboszló – authorized by the Act XVIII. of 1998 paragraph 53. (8) point e./ about District Heat Supply and the Act LXXXVII of 1990 on Price Setting that was amended several times – creates the supplement of 15/1999. (IX.30.) regulation as the following: Denomination Unit Fee Basic rate a./ Communal - heat Ft/Am3/year 337 - warm water Ft/Am3/year 50 together: Ft/Am3/year 387 2./ Heat-charge (metered) - heating Ft/GJ 4.304 - water heating Ft/GJ 4.304 Table 4: Price of district heating Source: www.kozuzemikft.hu The heat-charge in the chart was the initial heat-cost in 2007. The price need to be paid is 3200,FT/GJ + VAT from 1 August 2010. In Figure 11 you can see the central heating plant of Hajdúszoboszló: 57 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Figure 11: Central heating plant Source: own picture 58 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Solar power If we look at the sunshine duration map of Hungary (Figure 12) we can see that Hajdúszoboszló is located in an area where the number of annual sunshine hours is approximately 2000 hours. Figure 12: The number of annual sunshine hours Source: Hungarian Meteorological Service It means that in the 22.8% of the whole year (8760 hours) there is direct sunshine which theoretically can be used for energy production. In the remaining daylight hours (2380 hours/year) there is diffused sunshine which is not suitable for energy production. Under these circumstances the power producer systems can only reach the 10-30% of their capacity. In a year the town receives 1250 kWh/m2/year on the average which allows the practical use of solar power in the town’s administrative area (in a year and for one m2 1000 kWh is equivalent to the amount of energy contained by about 100 litres oil fuel). In case of single and twin-flat houses – with usual sizing – the 60-70% of the annual hot water demand can be supplied. During the summer season almost all the necessary heat energy can be supplied by the Sun. With warm water preparation solar systems the 30-45% of the global solar radiation can be utilized, with the more effective vacuum tubes this is 40-50%. We can state that solar energy offers a real alternative solution for those citizens of Hajdúszoboszló who would like to choose an environmental friendly way for the energy supply of their homes or workplaces. A system that can supply a part of our everyday needs – talking about 59 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions either warm water or heat – can be built up with a sufficient amount of deductible and tender resources. Beside the many advantages of the solar systems the activity factor and the pay-out period of the investment need to be considered as well. 60 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Wind power The wind power potential of Hajdúszoboszló can be characterized with the relative energy content of the prevailing winds.4 This – as its name says – is a relative quantity that shows the difference between the amount energy supplied by a prevailing wind direction and by a wind direction that is not typical to the area. Based on this, the largest amount of energy is provided by the S-SW winds typical from January till March. The spring and summer seasons are characterized by N-NE winds. During autumn after a major drop the S-SW wind directions supply the most energy. So we can see that the distribution of the wind directions is not steady. From the aspect of utilization we can see seasonally variable N-NE and S-SW prevailing wind directions. Figure 13: wind speeds height distribution of Hungary Source: Hungarian Meteorological Service For wind power exploitation the best are the wind speed over 3 m/s. To characterize the potential of this we need to examine the vertical distribution of wind speeds for which we used the maps of the Hungarian Meteorological Service. The average wind speed increases with the growth of the above ground level. The minimum needed 3 m/s speed can be expected from 10 meters above ground level already in the region of Hajdúszoboszló. But for the cost-effective working of the wind turbines and wind power machines the necessary speed is at least 4 m/s which can be found stably over 50 meters above the ground. 4 Barabás et al: Local Sustainable Development Plan of the City of Hajdúszoboszló (Local Agenda 21), 2010 61 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions The necessary speed zone for the operation of high-capacity wind turbines can be found over 75 meters. Based on the distribution of wind speed accordance to direction and height we can state5 that the wind power potential of the region enables the operation of low-power agricultural wind power machines for water pumping or a small-scale isolated residential energetic utilization but because of the high investment costs and from nature conservation aspects it is not suitable for the installation of large wind turbines. Hydropower The energetic utilization of the Eastern Main Canal, that serves agricultural purposes in the border of the town, is not practical. 5 Barabás et al: Hajdúszoboszló Város Helyi Fenntartható Fejlődési Terve (Local Agenda 21), 2010 62 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Geothermal energy Hungary has significant geothermal energy potencies compared to the neighbour countries. This is particularly true in North Hungary and the area of Hajdúszoboszló. Figure 14 shows the characteristics of temperature of geothermal water resources in North Hungary. Figure 14: Temperature of national thermal waters – Eastern Hungary Source: www.energiakozpont.hu Methods of direct use of geothermal energy: Heating of houses and public buildings Heating of greenhouses and walk-in plastic tunnels Drying of crops Poultry breeding , tempered water fish breeding Utilization of heat by heat pumps: heating/cooling Spa, balneology Drinking water Industrial utilization Main areas of utilizing geothermal energy in Hungary are direct heat utilization and balneology (medicinal wells, medicinal waters used in Spas). Currently, the number of operating thermal wells in Hungary is approximately 900 (over 30˚C at outflow) of which around 31% have balneological purposes, more than one quarter of them is used for drinking water production and around half of 63 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions them is for direct heating purposes. Heat content of exploited thermal water is mainly used to heat greenhouses, buildings, swimming pools, to produce drinking water and is sometimes utilized in district heating. It is very important to mention that the utilization of thermal water is state privilege and one who intends to utilize geothermal energy has to acquire the necessary licences. Thermal water can be utilized with medical; health; drinking and sparkling water production; bathing; disposable hot water and hot water production; heat supply and electricity production purposes. When planning the utilization of thermal water, its use has to be multipurpose, repeated, and efficient. The utilization of potential accompanying gases also has to be analysed. When establishing thermal water plants, thermal water rolled out has to be channelled, placed, and returned harmlessly. In Hajdúszoboszló, besides balneological purposes of thermal water utilization, it is used for electricity production as well: • Gas engine: 1339 kW • Heat pump: 2x635 kW • Thermal water: 1200 kW • Viesmann gas boilers: 1200 kW Figure 15 represents the places where geothermal medical facilities are established. The one in Hajdúszoboszló is an internationally well-known Spa centre. Figure 15: Location of medical purpose thermal water places in Hungary Source: VITUKI Environmental Protection and Water Management Research Institute Quality Assurance and Control Group 64 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Besides mainly using geothermal energy with a heating purpose (individual or centralized) it can also be used for electricity production, although geothermal energy based electricity production do not exist in Hungary at the moment. Until the utilization of domestic thermal water for electricity production can only be limitedly realized due to expensive heat-exchange technologies, there are other sources that are, at least supposedly, suitable for this purpose, such as waste waters and other effluents. Figure 16. shows that the amount of solutes in the water in Hajdúszoboszló is the highest in the EasternHungarian area. This is one of the causes why the water of Hajdúszoboszló has such a good effect on the human body. However, high salt content causes serious legal and technological problems such as frequent and expensive desalting of the heat exchangers and the pipelines. Figure 16: Solute content of thermal wells in Eastern Hungary Source: Buday, 2011 65 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Biomass The solid firing biomass in the region is typically firewood and wood chips from forestry activity, looping from horticultures and straw as the by-product of plant culture. The biogas potential development can be seen in the following diagram (Figure 17) : Figure 17: Biogas potential of Hajdúszoboszló Source: Szendrei, 2005 The biomass utilization opportunities in the region of the town can be considered ideal both in terms of geographical location and soil conditions due to the large extent of 32 AK (Golden Crown) lands. The characters of biomass as energy source: • it is stored as chemical energy in the organic materials generating in plants • the energetic utilization must be achieved without rising the amount of carbon-dioxide in the atmosphere, so the ecologically beneficial energy utilization needs special technical solutions • with appropriate use the emission of harmful substances (CO2, CO, SO2,) is significantly less compared to fossil fuels • the lands released by the improperly structured food production can give a realistic basis for the rational exploitation • it has positive impact on rural development and job creation 66 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Figure 18: The distribution of agricultural lands from the aspect of cultivation in the administrative are of Hajdúszoboszló Source: KSH T-Star The land use of Hajdúszoboszló is contained by Figure 18. The great proportion of arable lands (over 80%) is eye-catching. The biomass from these lands is primarily contains agricultural by-products (cutting, maize stalk, sunflower stalk and head, straw). However the large arable lands provide a basis for further expansion of biomass production (e.g. creating rape plantations). In terms of biomass production the 776 km2 area of herbage cannot be taken into account. The low proportion of forests means a significant disadvantage for the city. On the one hand it spoils the microclimate of the region and on the other hand a significant part of the easily usable biomass of the world comes from forests. Therefore the expansion of forest areas is not only reasonable from an environmental aspect but also from an energetic aspect. 67 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Annex 1. Balneology Napjainkban, amint a 19. ábra mutatja, a hajdúszoboszlói fürdő hazánk legjelentősebb és legismertebb gyógyfürdő fürdőkomplexuma. 19. ábra: Magyarország termál-és gyógyfürdői Forrás: http://www.gama-geo.hu/kb/okt/geoterm/Balneologia_11_24.pdf A balneológia a gyógyforrásoknak, gyógyvizeknek a gyógyfürdői alkalmazásával és hatásaival foglalkozó tudomány, azaz gyógyfürdőtan, ami az ásványvizek, iszapfélék, tengeri és folyami fürdők gyógyítási célokra való felhasználásával foglalkozik. A gyógyhelyeken nem csak a gyógyvizet használják fel kezelésre, hanem iszapkezelést, ivókúrát, inhalálást, mechano terápiát (gyógy-masszázst) és étrendi gyógykezelést (diétát) is alkalmaznak. Ezekhez még hozzájárulnak a klíma, a környezetváltozás, és a lelki hatások is. A felsorolt gyógy-tényezők együttes alkalmazása segíti a szervezet regenerálódását. (Egészségügyi ABC Medicina Könyvkiadó Budapest, 1974) Napjainkban csak balneoterápiás kezelést önállóan nem adnak, azt különböző beavatkozásokkal – például iszappakolással, gyógytornával, elektroterápiával, vagy gyógy-masszázzsal kombinálják. A balneoterápiát szinte valamennyi klinikai ág felhasználja gyógykezelésében, ideértve a műtétek utókezelését, valamint a rehabilitációt is. Az alábbi, 5. számú táblázat ismerteti a hazai gyógyvizek típusait és élettani hatásukat előfordulási helyük szerint. 68 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions 5. táblázat: A Magyarországon előforduló gyógyvizek típusai Forrás: saját összeállítás www.a gama-geo.hu alapján 1925-ben Hajdúszoboszlón mélyfúrás következtében a földből kb. 1100 méter mélységből 75°C-os meleg termálvíz tört elő. Analízisek alapján megállapítást nyert, hogy a mélyfúrásból jódos, brómos, konyhasós, hidrogén-karbonátos termálvíz tört fel. A vizsgálatok kimutatták, hogy a víz tartalmaz bitument és ehhez kötődő ösztrogént, továbbá még különböző nyomelemeket: titán, vanádium, réz, cink, ezüst, stroncium, bárium és ólom formájában. Dr. Dalmady Zoltán balneológus, egyetemi tanár szerint "... a fizikai chemia szempontjából rendkívül érdekes vonása a hajdúszoboszlói vizeknek, hogy töménységükben és összetételükben aránylag igen közel állanak az emberi szövetnedvek összetételéhez.” Különös figyelmet érdemel a tengeri fürdőkkel való összehasonlítása, hiszen a hajdúszoboszlói víz maga sem más, mint trias-kori tengerek felidézett szelleme. Konyhasótartalmánál fogva körülbelül ötszörösen hígított tengervíznek tekinthető, de a tengervíztől eltér csekély magnézium, calcium és jelentékeny hydrocarbonat tartalmánál fogva. Ennek dacára éppoly joggal használható úgy a gyógyításra, üdülésre, mint bármely más olyan tengeri fürdő, mely vizének hígítottságánál fogva hasonló töménységű. A következő, 18. számú ábra a hajdúszoboszlói termálvíz pontos összetételét mutatja: 69 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions 20. ábra: A termálvíz alkotórészei Forrás: www.hungarospa.hu A következő két ábrán (19. és 20. számú ábra) látható a kétemeletes fürdő központi gyógyászati tájékoztató térképe: 70 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions 21. ábra: A fürdő központi gyógyászati tájékoztató térképe, földszint Forrás: www.hungarospa.hu 22. ábra: A fürdő központi gyógyászati tájékoztató térképe, emelet Forrás: www.hungarospa.hu A kalciumos és a jódos vizek gyulladásos mozgásszervi megbetegedések esetén hasznosak. A kéntartalmú vízben való fürdőzést a degeneratív gerinc- és végtagízületi bántalomban szenvedőknek javasolják, de a bőrbetegeknek is jót tesz. A szénsavtartalmú vizeket szívbetegeknek, perifériás keringési zavarokkal küszködőknek ajánlják. A konyhasós vizek nőgyógyászati és urológiai gyulladások mérséklésére alkalmasak. A radonos gyógyvizek elsősorban fájdalomcsillapításra használhatók. A hajdúszoboszlói gyógyfürdőben alkalmazott fürdőkúra gyógyító hatást fejt ki a következő betegségek esetén: • Idült ízületi gyulladások (polyarthritis chr.sec.) • Degeneratív ízületi elváltozások (arthrosis) 71 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions • A gerinc különféle idült gyulladásos degeneratív megbetegedései(spondylosis M.Bechterew, chondrosis) • Idült idegfájdalmak, ideggyulladások (neuralgia, neuritis) • Heine medin kór utáni, valamint agyvérzés, agyműtét, vagy más okból kialakult bénulások utókezelése • Idült izomfájdalmak (myalgia) • Sérülések, sportsérülések utókezelése • Elhúzódó, nehezen gyógyuló csonttöréseknél a callusképződés elősegítése • Érszűkületek egyes formái • Idült nőgyógyászati megbetegedések (adnexitis, chr.) • Meddőség • Idült bőrbetegségek (ekcéma, psoriasis, pruritus) Ellenjavallatok: • Heveny gyulladásos megbetegedés • Rákos, rosszindulatú daganatos megbetegedés • Keringési elégtelenség • Súlyos vérnyomás emelkedés • Gümőkóros megbetegedés • Súlyos központi idegrendszeri megbetegedés • Fertőző betegség • Fertőző, undort keltő bőrbetegség • Terhesség A gyógyfürdőben több mint negyven féle kezelés áll a betegek rendelkezésére. A különböző gyógykezeléseket kombinálva alkalmazzák. Többek között masszázst, iszapkezelést, súlyfürdőt, víz alatti masszázst, víz alatti gyógytornát, különböző elktroterápiás kezeléseket és a legmodernebb szoftlézer-kezelést is alkalmaznak.6 6 www.hungarospa.hu 72 3.1.2output Examination of the local power supply system in partner towns/regions Notes 73