PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Ceylon Electricity Board April|2014 Initial Environmental Examination PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Executive Summary Background: This power transmission project proposed by Long-term Transmission Development Plan of CEB falls under categorization of prescribed project as per National Environment Act. Upon the environmental approval request from CEB, as the project approving authority, Central Environmental Authority has delegated approval process to Kegalle Regional Office. After the site visit of the proposed transmission line route by the Environmental Scoping Committee, the Terms of Reference (TOR) has been issued by CEA for the preparation of Initial Environmental Examination Report (IEER) for the project. This IEER has been prepared as per the said TOR. This IEER covers the construction and operation of above project, consists of following components. Construction of 132 kV 21.5 km, double circuit (Zebra) Thulhiriya to Kegalle transmission line. Construction of 132/33 kV GSS at Kegalle. Installation of 15 MVAr (3x5 MVAr) capacitor banks including 33 KV BSC bays at Kegalle 33 kV Bus Bar. Augmentation of Thulhiriya GSS with 2 nos. of 132 kV line bays. Under Clean Energy and Network Efficiency Improvement Project, Asian Development Bank has extended financial support for power transmission infrastructure development in Sri Lanka, which includes the proposed 132kV transmission line from Thulhiriya to Kegalle. Justification of the Project: At present Kegalle, Mawanella, Pogahawela and Rambukkana areas has an estimated load growth rate of 5%. Since most of the areas around Kegalle are fed by long 33kV distribution lines starting from either Thulhiriya GSS or Kiribathkumbura GSS, said areas experience poor service levels of electricity supply due to voltage drops and frequent interruptions. This project will address said problems and meet the demand growth in abovementioned areas and thereby relieve loading of Thulhiriya and Kiribathkumbura Grid Substations. Proposed Kegalle GSS will also improves the voltage profile of 33 kV distribution system and reduce distribution losses hence this project will improve quality and reliability of the system. Domestic, commercial and industrial consumers of Kegalle and surroundings will benefit in terms of reliability and voltage profile. In addition, the quality improvement of the power supply would enable further electrification of more households and new industries. Once Kegalle GSS is in operation, lengthy 33kV distribution lines will not be required from Kiribathkumbura and Thulhiriya GSSs, thus reducing distribution losses and improve overall efficiency of national grid. Initial Environmental Examination: This report intends to identify and evaluate environmental and socio-economic impacts of the proposed project development and suggest adequate mitigatory measures. IEER identifies critical environmental attributes required to be monitored subsequent to the implementation of the proposed project and establish the Environment Monitoring Plan. IEER outcomes are expected to incorporate into project design to minimize potential impacts due to construction and operation of the project. During the preparation of the report baseline data on existing Page 1 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE physical, ecological, economic, and social condition were established with support of preliminary survey, field study and secondary data. With the aid of field study, baseline data on existing natural and social environment and the predicted impacts on it due to the project were established. Existing Environment: 22.5km long proposed transmission line originates from existing Thulhiriya GSS and traverse through 9.16 km of paddy fields and 11.6 km on home gardens and rubber estates approximately. Lands in the project area have been used mainly for the purposes of residents, cultivation of paddy, commercial and other crops. This line route follows undulating mountainous terrain for most of its length varying from 60m~210m. Total project area lies within wet zone which receives annual rainfall around 2500mm. Thulhirikanda and Hunuwala kanda Forest Reserves are the only protected areas in close proximity of the line route, but proposed alignment is well away from any such environmentally sensitive areas. Home gardens exhibit the maximum floral bio diversity while faunal diversity is almost same in all land uses. Most residential lands are cultivated and have single story houses. People who are living in the project area have mix attitude towards the project and majority are willing to accept as this development is having national importance, as well as local improvements of power supply. Proposed Northern Expressway is the most important infrastructure development take place in this region which is implemented by Road Development Authority. CEB will work with RDA in close coordination to avoid any conflicts and come up with most environmentally, technically and financially sound solution for both projects. Anticipated Environmental Impacts: Generally, the environmental impacts from the transmission lines are minimal compared to many development projects of similar scale. The main impacts anticipated from this project are removal/pruning of trees along the transmission line corridor of30m width (especially in the rubber cultivations and home gardens). Possibility of landslide hazards due to the tower foundations located in steep terrain (approximately 50% of the total length) is also anticipated. Erosion due to tower foundations and temporary access roads located in steep terrain is also a potential impact to a lesser magnitude. Obstruction to the natural waterways and disturbance to the natural ecosystems caused by location of foundations and access roads in wetlands is a possibility. Main social impact is the disturbance caused by location of tower footings within home gardens and the disturbance and constraints caused by the conductors spanning over houses and/or home gardens. Temporary disruption of farming activities and disturbance of crops (especially in the paddy fields) during foundation work is another potential impact. Most of the environment and social impacts mentioned above have been avoided or minimized by selection of the line route with environmental perspective. There will be no resettlement activities involved in construction of transmission line of grid substation. Proposed mitigation Measures: As the proposed line mostly goes through paddy fields, rubber cultivations, environmentally sensitive areas with high biodiversity are avoided in the preliminary planning stage. Therefore cutting of rubber and coconut trees can be considered as most prominent impact. As these are commercial plantations, removal of these trees are also becomes an economic impact. For the loss of plantations/home garden trees, the amount for compensation for plantations as per the assessment of the relevant DS/GS will be paid directly to the land owners, as stipulated in the Electricity Act 2009. Where the line traverse through cultivations such as paddy, damages to the harvesting will be minimized by adjusting the Page 2 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE timing of construction activities, and any damages and/or disturbance to the cultivation would be compensated as per the valuations of relevant DS/appropriate authority. Due to mountainous terrain of the project area, disasters such as landslides and earth slips may occur. In the sloping terrain, wherever possible transmission towers will be located in relatively flat locations in stable, hard soil free from erosion and earth slips. Possibility of erosion by tower foundations located in hilly terrain should be minimized by construction of earth retaining structures and/or turfing wherever necessary. In case new access roads were absolutely necessary, they would be maximum 3-4m wide and completely removed after the completion of project work. CEB has obtained a landslide investigation report on the proposed project from National Building Research Organization (NBRO), which is attached as annex 6.2. The report gives a detailed description of the landslide prone areas, and the mitigation measures required to be adopted for the tower foundations located on such areas. These recommendations will be strictly adhered during the construction of the project. Monitoring Plan: The recommendations of the IEE Report are made available to the Project Manager (CEB) of the Project. The Monitoring Plan will be implemented by the Project Manager and his staff with the coordination of the Environment Unit of CEB, and the selected contractor/s would be made responsible for implementing appropriate mitigation measures mentioned in the IEER. The Monitoring Plan outlines a systematic, continuous and technical way of monitoring the environmental impacts. It also includes a description of the mitigation measures, monitoring parameters, frequency, responsible institutions and key persons and facilities available with such agencies. The proposed Monitoring Plan is mentioned in table 6.1. Conclusion: A number of alternative line routes have been proposed based on 1:50,000 topographical maps during initial route selection and among those, three alternatives were preferred for further evaluation, all of which has avoided the protected areas mentioned above, and were located avoiding the human settlements as much as possible. Due to the higher density of population and smaller plots of land within areas of Hunuwala, Dewalegama and Egalla etc, the social impacts were more prominent compared to the other impacts. After the comparison of those alternatives, the proposed route has been selected as more attractive with emphasis to the land use, social concerns, as well as environmental impacts, compared to others. The proposed project will improve operational efficiency and quality of power, reliability of the system and at the same time will reduce transmission losses. Electricity consumers of the Keggalle and surrounding areas will be positively benefited, with enhanced quality and reliability of power supply to the region through the project, and it will boost economic development of the area by strengthening the power transmission infrastructure. Main negative impacts are removal of trees along the line corridor and location of transmission line above relatively smaller plots of lands, while other construction impacts are primarily short term and will be diminished with time. Overall, the major social and environmental impacts associated with the transmission projects are minimal compared to many development projects of similar scale and can be mitigated to an acceptable level by implementation of recommended measures and by best engineering and environmental practices. Considering above, implementation of this project could be strongly recommended in view of its national and local benefits. Page 3 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE ABBREVIATIONS ADB - Asian Development Bank CEA - Central Environmental Authority CEB - Ceylon Electricity Board DoF - Department of Forest Conservation DS - Divisional Secretary DSD - Divisional Secretaries Division DWLC - Department of Wild Life Conservation EMoP - Environmental monitoring plan GoSL - Government of Sri Lanka GSS - Grid Substation ha - hectare (=10,000 square meters) IEE - Initial environmental examination km - kilometer kV - kilovolt m - Meter MoPE - Ministry of Power and Energy MW - megawatt NEA - National Environmental Act NBRO - National Building Research Organization PAA - project approving agency SLLRDC - Sri Lanka Land Reclamation and Development Corporation RDA - Road Development Authority RoW - right of way Page 4 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE INITIAL ENVIRONMENTAL EXAMINATION REPORT ON THE PROPOSED 132 kV TRANSMISSION LINE FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 1. Introduction 06 2. Description of the proposed project and reasonable alternatives 09 3. Description of existing environment 18 4. Description of the anticipated environmental impacts 38 5. Proposed mitigatory measures 58 6. Monitoring program 65 7. Conclusion and recommendation 70 Annexes Page 5 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 1. Introduction 1.1. Background of the project Ceylon Electricity Board has identified a list of projects, based on the Long-term Transmission Development Plan 2011-2020, which are critical for the overall development of the power system. Considering the requirements of Sri Lanka’s power system with medium to long term, it has been decided to implement transmission projects required for network efficiency improvement and loss reduction including proposed 132kV transmission line from Thulhiriya to Kegalle. Page 6 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 1.2. Objective of the proposed project and justification of the project Summarize the need or problem being addressed by the project and how the proposed project is expected to resolve the problem or the issue. Due to the fast emerging energy demand of the area, there is a distinct necessity for strengthening and expanding the transmission network. Under the adopted standards, the forecast loading of each Grid Sub Station (GSS) is compared with the firm capacity and the necessary transformer augmentations as well as construction of new substations. According to the analysis done by CEB, it is evident that Kiribathkumbura GSS will get overloaded by the year 2015 and Thulhiriya GSS will get overloaded by the year 2018. With the increasing demand Kegalle, Mawanella, Polgahawela and Rambukkana areas will suffer voltage drop and frequent failures. This sub-project will meet the demand growth in Kegalle, Mawanella, Polgahawela and Rambukkana areas and thereby relieve loading of Thulhiriya and Kiribathkumbura Grid Substations. Proposed GSS will also improve the voltage profile of 33 kV distribution systems and reduce distribution losses hence this project will improve operational efficiency and quality of power, reliability of the system and at the same time will reduce losses. This improvement of transmission infrastructure will permit the electrification of rural areas which are inaccessible with the present situation. 1.3. Objective of the IEE report Specify the objectives of the assessment and the relationship of the results to project design and implementation. This report intends to identify environmental, social and economical impacts of the proposed project development and suggest adequate mitigation measures. The initial environmental examination (IEE) report comprises baseline data on the existing condition of physical, ecological, economical and social information, together with anticipated environmental impacts and proposed mitigation measures. IEER outcomes are expected to be incorporated into project design to minimize potential impacts due to construction and operation of the project. Also this report will facilitate CEB to get the environmental clearance to implement the project and provide guidance for the selected contractor to carry out construction activities in environmentally and socially sound manner. 1.4. Extent and scope of the study The scope of the study is to prepare IEER after relevant field studies, reviewing secondary information, ecological & sociological surveys, consultation with stakeholders and local communities living along the transmission line (particularly the individuals / families residing in houses located within the 30m wide line corridor). Outcomes of the studies helped to identify high impact areas and as a result proposed line route was optimized accordingly to minimize environmental impacts. The IEE report identifies baseline environmental setting, critical environmental attributes required to be monitored during construction & subsequent to the implementation of the proposed project. IEE will identify anticipated impacts of the project, propose possible interventions to mitigate the negative impacts if any in short, medium and long term and establish Environment Monitoring Plan. Page 7 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 1.5. Methodologies adopted in report preparation Secondary information was gathered from publication of government and other research groups in the preliminary stage. Two study teams were deployed for ecological and sociological surveys on 100m wide strip on either side from the center of the proposed transmission line by walking. In case of Grid Substations, a distance of 100m from the boundaries of the Project site was taken. While 100% sampling was done within the RoW which is 15m on either side of the centre line, samples were taken up to 50m from the centre line on either side for studies. With the aid of field study, baseline data on existing physical, ecological, economic, and social conditions were established. Field personnel walked along transects along the proposed route mostly during the day to record plants and animals. Species were then listed separately for each of the different taxonomic groups. The conservation status of the species i.e. endemism, rarity and threatened status, was also determined. A questionnaire survey has been carried out to collect more quantitative data from affected parties. Respondents were selected from residents living on the RoW as well as upto 50m on either side from the centre line. Data collected through questionnaire were analyzed to get information on demography, land ownership, nature of affected group and positive/ negative attitude towards the project and used for the final report. In addition to these, CEB hired licensed surveyors to carry out profile survey to identify land features along the line route. Outcomes of the IEE studies and profile survey were incorporated into the design and CEB has optimized the line route by introducing new angle points and shifting some angle points along the alignment in order to minimize ecological and sociological impacts. IEE study was extended to cover all the deviations. National Building Research Organization (NBRO) then carried out land slide risk assessment for the adjusted line route, which is given as an addendum to the initial report (Annex 6.4). 1.6. The approvals needed for the proposed development from state agencies Department of Agrarian Development (approval is pending) National Building Research Organization (Received) 1.7. Any conditions laid down by state agencies in granting preliminary clearance for the project Letter from the Dept. of Agrarian Development to Sri Lanka Land Reclamation and Development Corporation (SLLRDC) requesting their recommendations is attached as annex 6.1. Recommendation letter from SLLRDC is attached as annex 6.2. Dept. of Agrarian Development has assured that their permission will be granted once CEB secured the ownership of the land with the letter attached as annex 6.3. Landslide Investigation Report by National Building Research Organization containing specific mitigation measures is attached as annex 6.4. Page 8 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 2. Description of the proposed project and reasonable alternatives Description of the project 2.1. Aim and scope of the project State the project’s main objectives, main beneficiaries and the expected social economic effects. The project envisages construction of Construction of 132 kV 21.5 km, double circuit (Zebra) Thulhiriya to Kegalle transmission line. Construction of 132/33 kV GSS at Kegalle. Augmentation of Thulhiriya GSS with 2 nos. of 132 kV line bays. Currently areas surrounding Kegalle experience poor service levels of electricity supply due to voltage drops and frequent interruptions. The proposed project will improve operational efficiency, quality and reliability of power supply to the consumers in Kegalle and surroundings (Mawanella, Galigamuwa, Rambukkana, Aranayake etc.). At the same time, it will enhance the reliability of the transmission system and will reduce system losses. Main beneficiaries would include the community in Kegalle and suburbs including small and large scale domestic/commercial consumers in Kegalle, Polgahawela, Mawanella, Galigamuwa, Aranayake and Rambukkana. Supply of power to both the local areas and regions will boost economic development of the area by strengthening the power transmission infrastructure. Surrounding areas will benefit from improved level of service and more rural households will get connected to the grid. 2.2. Justification of the project This section should consider justification of the project in relation to social economic benefits and any environmental costs and benefits where applicable. At present Kegalle, Mawanella, Pogahawela and Rambukkana areas has an estimated load growth rate of 5%. Currently no 132kV transmission lines are located within areas surrounding Kegalle. Hence, most of the areas around Kegalle are fed by long 33kV distribution lines starting from either Thulhiriya GSS or Kiribathkumbura GSS. As a result said areas experience poor service levels of electricity supply due to voltage drops and frequent interruptions. Constructing a new 132kV/33kV GSS in Kegalle and connecting it to the National Grid through proposed Thulhiriya – Kegalle 132kV transmission line (21.5 km) will address the problems mentioned above. This transmission line project is aimed for strengthening and expanding transmission network in Kegalle and suburbs in order to cater the future developments. Also this project is important for meeting the increasing demand in mentioned area and minimizes the low voltage problems currently encountered, and improves the reliability of electricity supply to consumers of the said areas. Page 9 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE The main benefit of the proposed 132 kV Thulhiriya Kegalle Transmission line is the quality Improvement of electricity supply provided to the area in terms of reliability and voltage profile. In this aspect, the quality improvement of the power supply would benefit the present rural communities already electrified and enable further electrification of more households and new industries. Once Kegalle GSS is in operation, lengthy 33kV distribution lines will not be required from Kiribathkumbura and Thulhiriya GSSs, thus reducing distribution losses and improve overall efficiency of national grid. 2.3. Description of the proposed project 2.3.1. Present ownership of the project site Augmentation of existing Thulhiriya GSS is limited within its current extent which is a property of CEB. The proposed Kegalle GSS will be situated on private land which will be purchased from its 8 owners, who have given their consent to sell their allotments to CEB. Part of Kegalle land is a paddy field while rest is left uncultivated. 2.3.2. Present use of land It has been observed that the land use between two terminal locations of above line consists mainly of paddy, rubber and home gardens. Paddy fields account for 43 % of total length of the line, where environmental and social impacts caused by the line are minimal. Around 31% of the route goes through home gardens while 19% goes through rubber plantations, where cutting/ removal of trees along the 30m wide corridor would raise some environmental concern, but considering the marginal bio-diversity in home gardens and commercial plantation, such impacts will not be significant. Social impact arising from removal of trees is more considerable and such issues will be addressed in mitigation plan. Land use along the proposed Kegalle- Thulhiriya 132kV transmission line is as follows, Land use type Paddy Percentage of total line length 42.64% Home Garden 31.3% Rubber 18.8% Shrubs 6.4% The 21.5 km transmission line from Thulhiriya GSS to Kegalle traverses through 9.16 km of paddy fields and 10.75 km approximately on home gardens and rubber estates. A large number of rubber trees and home garden trees in the RoW have to be removed for which CEB will have to pay compensation as per assessment of Grama Niladhari which is to be endorsed by Divisional Secretary, in accordance with the Electricity Act of 2009. Page 10 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 2.3.3. Pradeshiya Sabaha Area(s), Divisional Secretariat(s), Provincial Council(s) in which the project is to be located i. Pradeshiya Sabha: Warakapola Kegalle Galigamuwa Rambukkana ii. Divisional Secretariat Warakapola Kegalle Galigamuwa Rambukkana ii. Provincial Council Sabaragamuwa 2.3.4. Proposed timing and schedule including phased development (if any) Proposed timing and schedule is attached as annex 5.4. 2.3.5. Applicable laws, regulations, standards and requirements covering the proposed project National Environmental Act Nº 47 of 1980, amendment Nº 56 of 1988, and other amendments Electricity Act No. 20 of 2009 Agrarian Services Act (Nº 58 of 1979) Agrarian Development Act Nº 46 of 2000 Felling of Trees (Amendment Act Nº 01 of 2000 and Act to amend felling of trees control) Forest Ordinance Act Nº 13 of 1966 Forest (Amendment) Act Nº 65 of 2009 Land Acquisition (Amendment) Act, Nº 13 of 1986 Monuments and Archaeological Sites and remains Act, 1958. Act Nº24 of 1958 Antiques Ordinance, 1960 Soil Conservation (Amendment) Act Nº 24 of 1996 2.3.6. Clearances / permits obtained from relevant state agencies and or local authorities Clearance from Department of Agrarian Services was requested for the proposed construction of GSS in a paddy field which is not an agricultural activity. In turn they have requested Sri Lanka Land Page 11 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Reclamation Development Corporation (SLRDCC) to send their recommendations for above development, including a drainage plan (if required), before giving their clearance. Request letter from Department of Agrarian Services is attached in annex 6.1. CEB has already paid the relevant estimate to (SLRDCC) for above consultancy work, and their recommendations are attached as annex 6.2. Owners of the proposed GSS land are willing to sell their allotments and the purchasing process is underway in collaboration with the Department of Valuation. Dept. of Agrarian Development has assured that their permission will be granted once CEB secured the ownership of the land. (Annex 6.3) In addition, considering the landslide hazards (if any) in the hilly areas encountered along certain parts of line route, CEB has obtained a report from National Building Research Organization regarding above (including their recommendations and proposed remedial measures). NBRO report is attached as annex 6.4. 2.3.7. Provide a location map indicating the project site, surrounding development and infrastructure within 100 m of the site (at appropriate scale) Location map is attached as annex 5.1. 2.3.8. Give details of the project characteristics including its principal features; project related permanent structures, project related temporary structures. (Including route and length of the transmission line design of transmission towers, switch yard, grid substation etc. and indicate same on a plan) The project consists of the following components: Construction of 132kV 21.5km, double circuit (Zebra) Thulhiriya to Kegalle transmission line having approximately 82 Nos. Lattice towers of around 30m of height Construction of 132/33kV Grid Substation at Kegalle 1 Nos. 31.5MVA, 132/33kV transformers 132kV single Busbar arrangement including bus section 33kV single Busbar arrangement including bus section 2 Nos. 132kV single Busbar transmission line bays 2 Nos. 132kV single Busbar transformer bays 8 Nos. 33kV feeder bays, 2x33kV transformer bays 15MVAr (3x5 MVAr) capacitor banks including 33kV BSC bays Augmentation of Thulhiriya GSS with 2 Nos. of 132kV line bays Extension of the 132kV single Busbar transmission line bays Space for the bays are within the existing GSS Length of Thulhiriya Kegalle Transmission line is 21.5 km including of approximately 82 nos of four legged steel lattice towers having an average height of 27~28m from ground level. Each of four legs is embedded in concrete foundation. Transmission line consists of several types of towers catering to different requirements of line route. The most common type is line towers, TDL which has foundation Page 12 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE dimensions of approximately 2450x2450x3000mm (length, width and depth). TD1 angle towers are used to form angles from 00 to 100 and its foundation is 3150x3150x3000mm. TD3 angle towers are used for angles from 100 to 300 and have foundation of 3500x3500x3000mm. For angles from 300 to 600, TD6 towers are used and it has foundation size of 3800x3800x3500mm. Terminal towers from the ends of line routes where they connect to grid substations and has the largest base of 4000x4000x3500mm. Typically 132kV transmission towers have heights of 27~28m. 2.3.9. Type of transformers to be installed and their capacity details should also include the location extent and type of grid substation/s This project envisages the construction of Kegalle GSS in Molagoda, 5km from Kegalle on Kandy road. One 31.5MVA, 132/33kV transformer will be installed in it along with other components stated in Section 2.3.8. Breaker Switched Capacitor (BSC) banks will be installed at the Kegalle GSS which are used for voltage support and reactive power compensation in grid substations. By doing so it helps to reduce the losses in power transformers and transmission lines, and to release the capacity constraints in transformers and lines. Other than that, they are installed to control the load power factor at the Grid Substation level (33kV). 2.3.10. Drawing showing the project layout plan especially in relation to grid substations, switch yards etc. Layout plan for proposed Kegalle GSS is attached as annex 5.3 and proposed route for the 132kV transmission line is attached as annex 5.1. 2.4. Methodology of construction 2.4.1. State the proposed time schedule for construction Proposed time schedule for construction of Thulhiriya-Kegalle Transmission line is shown in annex 5.4. 2.4.2. Details of land preparation activities Land preparation mainly requires in construction of grid substation and tower foundations. Area required for tower foundation varies according to different tower types and typically varies between 4-7 perches. It involves removing vegetative cover and excavation up to 2.3m below ground. Laying of foundation completes in 4-10 weeks depend on soil condition. After backfilling, only four stubs will expose above ground, which are less than the size of 2x2 feet. Land slide related impacts arising due to land preparation for project activities (mainly the Tower foundations) in hilly areas have been addressed in attached report of study conducted by NBRO (Annex 6.2). After few months of construction, vegetative cover will reinstate for some extent and in case of home gardens certain species of trees can be grown while in paddy fields, same land use may continue with some restriction on harvesting machinery. Page 13 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE For the construction of Kegalle new grid substation, all the arrangements have been made to purchase approx 5 acres of land earmarked for proposed development from 8 Nos. of its owners. All the owners have already given their consent for selling the lots owned by them, and the official process for purchase of the land is underway. The land need to be cleared of vegetation and leveled. Substation site will be filled to a height of 1.2 m above the Kandy road. Since the part of the land is a paddy field, the clearance for filling and development of the land is requested from the Dept. of Agrarian Development. In order to maintain uninterrupted drainage of the area due to filling, a drainage plan is requested from the Sri Lanka Land Reclamation and Development Corporation (SLLRDC), which will be incorporated into the filling plan. This plot of land will accommodate control building, main transformer foundation, other equipment foundations and gantry structures to support conductors. Depth of excavation is very unlikely to exceed 2.5m in good soils which are found in selected land for GSS. There is no natural forest or cultivations in selected land for GSS, therefore ecological impact is minimal. 2.4.3. Nature and type of any structures There are two main types of towers in transmission lines which are steel lattice structures. Suspension towers- These structures are designed only to carry the weight of conductors in straight-line portions of transmission line. Therefore, all conductors have been attached to tower cross arms with glass insulators and continuously run through these towers. Tension towers- These towers are used in angle points where transmission line deviates from its route. Since these towers are designed to withstand both conductor tension and weight, they are stronger and having a wider base, compared to suspension towers. The continuity of the electrical power transmission will be provided by a separate jumper loop. There are several types of tension towers to accommodate different angles of deviation as mentioned in section 2.3.8. Tension towers are also used as section towers in longer straight sections of the transmission line. Special type of tension tower is used at the termination point of transmission line at GSS which is called as terminal tower. Grid substation houses power transformers mounted on concrete foundations and, several types of structures for mounting current transformers, voltage transformers and other switchgear which are all steel lattice structures on concrete foundations. 2.4.4. Methods of construction of grid substations/switch yards towers and laying of conductors Typically grid substation structures to accommodate switchgear do not require large foundations. Reinforced concrete foundations will be sufficient in good soil conditions while precast concrete piles are used for places with poor soil characteristics. In case of Kegalle GSS, reinforced concrete foundations placed on well compacted soil fill would be sufficient. For tower foundations, there are nine strength classes decide upon soil parameters and level of water table, ranging from homogeneous rock to most week soils. Page 14 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE The erection of structures needs some skilled personnel and supervisory staff. Although many different tower erection methods practiced and, the selection of an erection method depends on various parameters such as the adaptability of selected methods to each site conditions, time and the cost, etc. Conductor stringing is a specialized process, which needs highly skilled linemen, tools and machineries. The earth wires and line conductors are strung at a tension using pilot wires, tensioners, pullers and pulleys. Adequate number of linemen and proper communication facility has to be available during the stringing process. 2.4.5. Infrastructure facilities required / provided Separate parking and storage spaces should be allocated to construction vehicles, equipments, material storage yards, disposal sites, and labour camps for human resource during mobilization stage to avoid any environmental impact and public inconvenience. Selected sites must comply with the local laws and regulations and need approval from authorities to utilize these facilities. All construction sites and labor camps are to be provided with electricity either via temporary connection from national grid or onsite generator. Selecting accessible sites will eliminate the need of access road construction. Also it is important that selection of temporary lands is done reasonably away from highly populated areas, water bodies, natural flow paths, agricultural lands, important ecological habitats and residential areas. 2.4.6. Details of any access roads to be built, improved (existing condition and anticipated improvement) Although the line construction will rely on many existing roads, new access roads/tracks may be built to reach certain tower locations without vehicular access, if it is absolutely necessary. In such locations, maximum efforts will be made to manually transport equipment in knocked-down state to tower locations, to avoid building new access roads. Building materials to such locations would also be handcarried wherever possible. If it is absolutely necessary 3-4 m wide temporary access roads will be sited carefully to minimize the environmental and/or social issues such as soil erosion in the hilly areas, disruptions to paddy farming operations in the paddy fields etc. These temporary access roads will be completely removed, and ground is reinstated after the completion of the project. Since the new GSS at Kegalle is adjacent to Kaudaulla road off Kandy road, it requires only upgrading of existing culvert across the stream. 2.4.7. Other resources /facilities required / provided Temporary labour camps will be provided with proper water and sanitary facilities. Since project sites are mostly located in rural areas of the wet zone which is rich of natural streams, hygienically sound sanitation facilities are to be setup in and around labor camps, which should not cause ground or surface water pollution. Page 15 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 2.5. Work force Labor requirements, availability of labor in the area, employment of local people, occupational health and safety facilities required / provided. As the proposed project is a major construction, the CEB will call for tenders and award the construction to a contractor. It will be either a national or international contractor, and they will employ the relevant workforce. For skilled labor, it is highly likely that personals from outside the locality will be employed while for unskilled labor, personnel from within the locality are utilized. Nature of the works in construction activities has a high incidence of occupational ill health. In awarding the tenders, the CEB will also ensure that occupational health and safety of the workers are looked after properly by the contractor. Health and safety impacts will be in terms of risk of accidents. Necessary training regarding the safety aspects of the personnel working on the line will be provided by the contractor. Contractors are obliged to maintain occupational health and safety facilities that comply with national labor rules and standards, in order to assure safe work environment. CEB will exercise necessary care and supervision over contractor’s execution of work and take suitable steps as are practicable in the circumstances to avoid a foreseeable risk of death or injury. 2.6. Maintenance procedure State the standard practice and any deviation required CEB does monitoring and supervision of the Project during the construction of the project as well as operational phase. Once the project is handed over to the CEB, it ensures that the transmission line is maintained properly and in good condition. The lifetime of a transmission line is more than 50 years, during which maintenance works are comparatively less, and limited to following. (i) (ii) (iii) Removal of rust and re-painting (old galvanizing) of any tower steel members with corrosion Replacing any damaged insulators Removal/pruning of trees/branches of them which may grow above 3m, height along the 35m wide line corridor. There will be no environmental or social impacts anticipated under item (i) and (ii). Since the trees that would grow above 3m would be cut/ removed along the 35m wide line corridor before the line is energized, the additional impact from item (iii) is also, insignificant. The lifetime of a GSS is also more than 50 years and maintenance works involved are limited to following items. (i) (ii) Filtering/changing of topping up transformer oils Removal and replacement of equipment Since no transformers, circuit breakers or any other equipment containing PCB would be installed in the GSS under this project there will be no environmental or social impacts anticipated from above activities. Page 16 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE - Sources of hazardous / electronic waste (if any) During construction of grid substations, CEB will not use PCB or asbestos for any new transformers, and disposal of none of those substances from old transformers are involved in this project. Construction of project components will not generally result in hazardous or electronic waste. In case of such event, CEB will proceed according to the CEA guidelines of hazardous waste disposal. 2.7. Evaluation of alternatives 2.7.1. The “no action” alternative (i.e. one based on current practices without approval of the project) "No-action" would mean the proposed activity would not take place, and the resulting environmental effects from taking no action would be compared with the effects of permitting the proposed activity or an alternative activity to go forward. The “no-action” alternative is developed for two reasons. It is almost always a viable choice in the range of reasonable alternatives, and it sets a baseline of existing impact continued into the future against which to compare impacts of action alternatives. This is important context information in determining the relative magnitude and intensity of impacts. As mentioned in Section 2.2, presently areas around Kegalle are fed from either Thulhiriya GSS or Kiribathkumbura GSS by long 33kV distribution lines. As a result said areas experience poor service levels of electricity supply due to voltage drops and frequent interruptions. Considering the demand growth rate, those substations are predicted to be overloaded in coming years. Constructing a new 132kV/33kV GSS in Kegalle and connecting it to the National Grid through Thulhiriya – Kegalle 132kV transmission line (22.5 km long) will address the problems mentioned above. This transmission line project is aimed for strengthening and expanding transmission network in Kegalle and suburbs in order to cater the future developments. Also this project is important for meeting the increasing demand in mentioned area and minimizes the low voltage problems currently encountered, and improves the reliability of electricity supply to consumers of the said areas. Development activities of this project are invariably associated with social and few environmental impacts. Social impacts include cutting down of valuable trees and planting of tower footings in private properties. The environmental impacts are relatively much less, and limited to cutting down of trees in rich plantations of rubber, temporary impacts to the paddy fields during construction of tower foundations, and prompting of soil erosion in the hilly terrain. However, most of the social impacts could be properly compensated as explained in later chapters, while the environmental impacts involved are easily mitigable, except cutting down of trees, which do not involve protected areas or those with high biodiversity, but mostly trees of commercial value. So when compared, positive benefits adequately justify the implementation of the project. Therefore no-action alternative is not acceptable. 2.7.2. Alternative routes, design and technology selection, construction techniques, and maintenance procedures etc. Alternatives considered as bellow The “No action “ alternative Option 1 Page 17 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Option 2 Option 3 The other alternatives are shown against 1:50,000 topographical map and attached as annex 5.2. These were evaluated based on the environmental and social impacts, the cost effectiveness of the transmission line etc. The Alternative 1 having minimum social and environmental concerns, with reasonable cost effectiveness have been selected. Evaluation of alternative is given in detail in section 7.1. Page 18 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 3. Description of the existing environment STUDY AREA Grid Substation (s) / Switchyards The project sites and 100m from the boundaries of the project site (include Gongan Ela levels, GSS contour levels and reservation demarcated in a map of Kegalle) Transmission line Transmission line route and 50m on either side of the center line of proposed line routes or the area of maximum risk. 3.1. Physical Environment 3.1.1. Topology Recent Topographical data clearly indicating reserve areas, marshy areas, water bodies, canals, streams, drainage, channels Kegalle is the capital city of the district which is one of the two districts of Sabaragamuwa province the other being Ratnapura district. The elevation of the district of Kegalle varies from 30-170m from the MSL. The highest elevation is towards the South-East of the district. The landform features vary from plateaus to steep escarpments with medium to high elevations: and from broad valleys to steep gullies. The district of Kegalle exhibits complex topographical features consist of hills and ridges, broad valleys, gorges and plateaus. Proposed line traverse through northern part of the district, which is also a hilly terrain. Highest peak along the line route was observed in Puwakdeniya area while Kandegedara, Dewalegama and Hunuwala areas have isolated peaks. Kegalle district nourishes many rivers including Kelani River, Maha Oya and Attanagalu Oya. But this proposed line route does not cross any major rivers or streams. Proposed land for Kegalla GSS is adjacent to Gonagan Ela and proposed site layout is attached with survey plans. This land has to be developed with subjected to the approval of Sri Lanka Land Reclamation and Development Corporation (SLLRDC). Their permission for development will follow the environmental approval. 3.1.2. Climate and meteorology Precipitation patterns, relative humidity and temperature, potential hazardous weather events The mean annual daily temperature in the district is estimated to be between 22.50C to 32.50C and diurnal range is around 60C. November, December and January are Page 19 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE considered as the coldest months while April to June as the hottest months. Humidity of the district increases with the altitude and also varies from the wet zone to dry zone. The average humidity varies between 70-80% during the day time and between 88-94% during the night. Highest monthly rainfall receives in October as 302.7mm and lowest rainfall recorded in January as 33.6mm. About 60%-75% of the district receives rainfall over 3,000 mm per year. 3.1.3. Geology & soil General geology of the area, soil types and distribution The district of Kegalle lies within the southern part of Vanni Complex as per lithotectonic classification of the island. This project area is made up of Charnockite, Garnetbiotite gneiss and Quartzite. Main soil types encountered in this rolling, hilly and steeply dissected terrain are Red-Yellow Podzolic soils with Low Humic Gley soils. These soil characteristics and weather makes desirable conditions for commercial crops such as tea, rubber and coconut which occupy vast area of the district. 3.2. Ecological Resources 3.2.1. Existing natural and man-made habitats in and around the project site and, distribution and density of fauna and flora of them. Following table shows the details of the habitats that will be intercepted by the transmission line and their extents in the total corridor. Table 3. 1 Land use of the line corridor including the types of habitats and their extents (ha) No Total Line Length Land Usage i) Open scrubland ii) Rubber iii) Home Garden iv) Paddy 21.5 km Percentage 6.4 18.79 31.3 42.64 Corridor 30 30 30 30 Total 4.1 12.1 20.1 27.4 The project area comprises of predominantly paddy lands then home gardens, rubber plantations and open scrublands. Table 3.2 Summary of the distribution of flora according to the habitats in the project area shows the distribution of the flora while Table 3.3 shows the distribution of the fauna in the affected habitats. The full list of flora and fauna species encountered in the Project affected areas is shown in annex 7. Page 20 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Flora Table 3. 2 Summary of the distribution of flora according to the habitats in the project area Habitats The extent in the corridor (30m) % No. of species in the habitat types Biodiversity % in the ecosystem Endemic % Nationally species Threatene d species % Vulnerable species % Paddy lands Home gardens Rubber Scrublands Total 42.64 31.3 18.79 6.4 22 96 19 11 148 14.86486 64.86486 12.83784 7.432432 1 2 0 1 4 0 2 1 0 0 0 2 0 1 0 0 0 4 1 2 2 0 0 9 2 Fauna Table 3. 3 Summary of the fauna in the different habitats in the Project area Habitats The extent in the corrid or (35m) % Category biodiver of fauna sity No of speci es obse rved Paddy lands 54.23 % 26.8421 1 Birds Mammals 6 7 6 2 29 1 Butterflies Dragonflies Amphibian sReptiles Birds Mammals 6 3 1 4 29 2 Home gardens Rubber Plantati 30.76 % 10 23.6842 1 23.6842 1 Butterflies Dragonflies Amphibian s Reptiles Butterflies 8 Dragonflies 1 Ende mic specie s % Endang ered species % 1 1 5.9 4.4 4.4 % Near Thre aten ed % 4 1 1 4 1 1 NA NA NA 2 1 Vulner able species 1 2. 22 2. NA NA NA NA NA NA 1 NA 2.2 2.22 Page 21 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE ons Amphibian s Reptiles Open Scrub lands 5 25.7894 7 Birds Mammals 0 4 29 3 Butterflies Dragonflies Amphibian sReptiles Birds Mammals 13 0 0 4 29 3 4 1 1 1 1 1 6.1 2 22 1 NA NA NA NA 1 1 NA NA NA NA NA 2. 04 2 1 2.04 3.2.2. Rare threatened and endemic species Table 3.4 The distribution of endemic, threatened and vulnerable flora in the Project area shows the distribution of endemic, threatened and vulnerable flora in the Project area. Flora Table 3. 4 Family The distribution of endemic, threatened and vulnerable flora in the Project area Scientific name Apocynaceae Walidda antidysenterica Clusiaceae Garcinia quaesita Cycadaceae Cycas nathorstii Lythraceae Lagerstroemia speciosa Sapotaceae Madhuca longifolia Moraceae Ficus fergusoni Euphorbiaceae Bridelia mooni Common name Idda Goraka Madu Habitat Species Status Endemic Small tree Tree Endemic Conservation PA Status LC HG LC * * Native VU * Muruta Small tree Tree Native NT * Mee Tree Native NT * Endemic LC Endemic LC * Kosgonna Tree Path kela Tree R OS * * Page 22 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Fauna Table 3. 5 The distribution of endemic, threatened and vulnerable fauna in the Project area Family Scientific name Nymphalidae Euploea sylvester Notocrypta paralysos Onychargia atrocyana Orthetrum luzonicum Fejervarya kirtisinghei Hylarana gracilis Otocryptis wiegmanni Gallus lafayetii Common name Double Banded Crow Hesperiidae Common Banded Demon Coenagrionidae Marsh Dancer Libellulidae Marsh Skimmer Dicroglossidae Kirtisinghe's Frog Ranidae Sri Lanka wood frog Agamidae Sri Lankan kangaroo lizard Phasianidae Sri Lanka Jungle fowl Cercopithecidae Semnopithecus Sri Lanka vetulus Purplefaced langur Species category Species Status Conservation PA HG R OS Status Butterfly Native * Butterfly Native Near Threatened Vulnerable Dragonfly Native Vulnerable * Dragonfly Native * * Near Threatened Amphibians Endemic Vulnerable * Amphibians Endemic LC * Reptiles Endemic LC Birds Endemic LC Mammal Endemic Endangered * * * * * * * * * * ABBREVIATIONS: SS – Species Status, ED – Endemic, CS – Conservation Status, EN – Endangered, OS – Open Scrublands, PA – Paddy, HG – Home gardens, R – Rubber 3.2.3. Proximity to protected area There are no forest reserves or wildlife reserves in the immediate line route but Thulhiriya Forest Reserve/Koskanda Forest Reserve is located more than 100m away from the line route in Thulhiriya. This is about 200 acres in extent and comprise of predominantly Mahogany which are about 25 yrs old. The origin of this forest reserve had been a Mahogany mono-cultural plantation established by the Forest Department about 25 years ago. However, with time due to dearth of management this area had become naturalized. The predominant vegetation is Mahogany (Swietenia macrophylla) trees and their seedlings while others like Halmilla (Berrya cordifolia) , Puwak (Areca catechu), Kitul (Caryota urens) , Alstonia Lunimidella (Melia dubia),, Kaduru (Cerbera Page 23 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE manghas), Gadumba (Trema orientalis), Bowitiya (Melastoma malabathricum), Hik (Lannea coramandelica), Ginisapu (Michelia champaca) also prevail. 3.3. Socio – economic considerations 3.3.1. Present land use pattern As shown in the Table 3.6, lands in the project area have been used mainly for the purposes of residents, cultivation of paddy, commercial and other crops. The total line length is 21.4 km. and 42.64% of it traverses over paddy land whereas 37.37% and 18.79% run over home gardens and Rubber Cultivations respectively. There were 52 families residing in or in the vicinity of line route and only 34% of them had cultivated their home gardens (Table 3.7). As the public roads are concerned the proposed line crosses over two points of major roads. Table 3. 6 Land Use Data No Land Use Data Total Line Length Land Usage i) ii) iii) iv) i) ii) iii) iv) Open scrubland Rubber Home Garden Paddy No of Crossing Railway Major (A ,B type )road crossing River Crossing Tanks Table 3. 7 21.4 km Percentage of total line length (%) 6.4 18.79 31.3 42.64 Corridor width (m) Total affected Area (ha) 30 30 30 30 12.1 24.2 27.4 2 1 - Distribution of families by the land use Land Cultivated Land Not Cultivated land Total Frequency 34 18 52 % 65.4 34.6 100.0 3.3.2. Population characteristics of the divisions crossed The proposed transmission line traverses through four divisional secretary’s divisions such as Rmbukkana, Kegalle, Galigamuwa and Warakapola in the District of Kegalle. According to the census year 2001, the total population of Kegalle District remained at 785,524, accounting for Page 24 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 4.2% of the total population of the country. As estimated by the Department of Census in 2011 that number had increased up to 837,179. However the District percentage of the total population of the country still remains the same. The four Divisional Secretary’s Divisions under consideration of this study have a population of 359,392 accounting for 43% of the total population of the District of Kegalle. The distribution of population in the four Divisions is as shown in the Table 3.8. The highest number of population (31.3%) is recorded from the Warakapola Division. Ethnic composition of the population of those four Divisions is evident from the Table. 3.9. Being the majority, Sinhalese accounts for 34.4%, whereas the Tamil and Muslim people represents 2.8% and 2.6% respectively. Religious information of the people in the four divisions is given in the Table.3.10. Accordingly 92.7% are Buddhists and the rest belongs to other religions such as Hinduism, Islam, Catholic and Christian. Table 3. 8 Population by Divisional Secretary’s Divisions Population Divisions Source No % Rambukkana 82,373 23 Kegalle 90,494 25.2 Galigamuwa 73,942 20.5 Warakapola 112,583 31.3 Total 359,392 100 : Department of census and statistics 2011 Table 3. 9 Distribution of Population by Ethnicity Division Rambukkana Kegalle Galigamuwa Warakapola Total Source : Sinhalese Tamil Muslim 78542 1028 2646 86676 2652 1051 70012 2738 715 103869 3565 5100 339101 9983 9512 (94.4%) (2.8%) (2.6%) Department of census and statistics 2011 Other Total 157 115 477 49 798 (0.2%) 82373 90494 73942 112583 359392 (100%) Other Christian 2368 561 Other Total 14 16 82373 90494 Table 3. 10 Distribution of population by the Religion Division Buddhists Hindu Islam Rambukkana Kegalle 75093 85209 799 1985 2817 1235 Roman Catholic 1282 1488 Page 25 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Galigamuwa Warakapola Total Source : 69712 2241 1263 451 103316 2773 5731 536 333330 7798 11046 3757 (92.7% ) (2.2%) (3.1%) (1.0%) Department of census and statistics 2011 267 246 3442 (1.0%) 8 17 55 (0.01%) 73942 112583 359392 (100%) 3.3.3. Socio – Economic status Housing Quality and quantity of housing units reveal socio-economic status of people in any society. As the Divisions under consideration are concerned, majority of people live in permanent housing units. As the Table 3.11 indicates, 91.1% of the housing units is single storied and only 5.6%is two storied. Line-rooms and shanty units account for only 1.2% and 0.4% of the shelters respectively. Quality of the housing units could be understood by analyzing the principle material used for the construction of walls and roof. The Table 3.12 provides data on the type of material used for building houses. There are 92,172 housing units in the four Divisions and 67.5% of them have been constructed with bricks and another 23.8% with cement blocks and stones. The housing units that had been made of materials such as mud, cadjans and planks account for 7% of the total number of housing units in the four Divisions. However, housing units having cadjans for the roof remained at 0.1%. Tiles and Asbestos have been used for 67.2% and 20.0% of housing units respectively (Table 3.13) Table 3. 11 Distribution of Housing Units by Divisional Secretary’s Divisions Division Rambukkana Kegalle Galigamuwa Warakapola Total Source Single Two Three Attach Flats Twin storie Stor or more ed hous d ed stored house e 20168 1384 82 37 25 36 20616 1939 174 113 28 18076 919 29 39 35 26974 1364 57 55 64 85834 5606 342 244 25 163 91.1% 5.6% 0.4% 0.3% 0.02% 0.2% : Department of census and statistics 2011 Line room s 97 357 497 254 1475 1.2% Huts Shan ty 102 102 127 83 414 0.4% other Total 25 13 7 24 69 0.07% 21956 23342 19729 29145 94172 Page 26 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Table 3. 12 Distribution of Housing Units by the Principle Material of Construction Divisional Secretary’s Division Rambukkana Kegalle Galigamuwa Warakapola Total Source Brick 18088 15774 12893 15448 Cement block stones 2021 5473 4899 9570 Cabook 72 88 125 226 Pressed soil bricks 331 608 487 1517 Mud Cadjan Plank Other Total 1178 1184 1134 2029 67 15 86 78 175 178 86 209 24 22 19 68 21956 21342 19729 29145 246 (0.3%) 734 (0.8%) 133 (0.1%) 92172 (100%) 62203 21963 511 2943 5525 (67.5%) (23.8%) (0.6%) (3.2%) (6.0%) : Department of census and statistics 2011 Table 3. 13 Distribution of Housing Units by the Principle Material of Construction Divisional Secretary's Division Tile Rambukkana 15037 4060 Kegalle Galigamuwa 13661 13359 6293 3676 Warakapola Total Source Asbestos Concrete Zink, Aluminum sheet Metal sheet Cadjan Other Total 672 196 1765 200 26 21956 900 383 174 204 2167 1953 120 133 27 21 23342 19729 2170 8055 (8.6%) 252 705 (0.7%) 21244 4461 668 288 63301 18490 2623 862 (67.2%) (20.0%) (2.8%) (0.9%) : Department of census and statistics 2011 62 29145 136 94172 (0.1%) (100%) Taken as a whole, the main source of drinking water for the people of the four Divisions is water well. More than 76% of the households depend on wells for drinking water and only 13% are provided with pipe-born water. The rest gets water from other various sources. (Table.3.14) Table 3. 14 Distribution of Households by the Principle Source of Drinking water Divisional Secretary's Division Rambukkana Well Pipe-born Water Other Sources Total Households 16886 4020 823 22034 Kegalle 13563 6672 1245 Galigamuwa 16606 707 1491 Warakapola 25451 938 1226 Source : Department of census and statistics 2011 23407 19760 29188 Page 27 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Table 3.15 provides data pertaining to the principle type of energy used for illuminating the households. The national grid of electricity serves 31.7% of households for lighting their houses, where as kerosene oil is used in 8.2% of the households in the four Divisions. The percentage of households depending on solar power, biogas and other source of energy remains below one for the whole area. A household survey was conducted with reference to the families residing in or in the vicinity of the proposed transmission line route. The following Tables reveal the socio-economic and other relevant information of families in the range of the project, as the line traverses over their home gardens and other cultivations. Table 3. 15 Households by the Principle Type of Lighting Division Electricity Kerosene Solar Bio gas from national power grid Rambukkana 20370 1622 21 11 Kegalle 21732 1654 13 Galigamuwa 17993 1742 19 1 Warakapola 26350 2773 48 8 Total 86445 7791 101 20 (91.6%) (8.2%) (0.1%) (0.02%) Source : Department of census and statistics 2011 Other Total 10 08 6 9 33 0.03%) 22034 23407 19761 29188 94390 (100%) Apart from the information pertaining to the four Divisional Secretariats motioned above, this household survey further provides a detailed account of the families to be affected. The survey identified 52 such families and their distribution in the four Divisions is as shown in the Table 3.16. Galigamuwa and Warakapola Divisional seemed to have 75% of households compared to others. Table 3. 16 Distribution of Families by Divisional Secretariat and District Divisional Secretariats within the District (Kegalle) No. of Families % 14 26.9 Warakapola 4 7.7 Kegalle 25 48.1 Galigamuwa 9 17.3 Rabukkana Total 52 100 The Table 3.17 shows the distribution of families by GramaNiladari Divisions. They fall in to 9 Divisions such as Egalla, Thulhiriya, Kolongalla, Walagama, kawdamulla, Talgama, Veragoda, Page 28 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE deldeniyaand Kandegedara. Over 67% of families live in three GN Divisions such as Egalla (13.4%), Kawdamulla (13.5%) and Kandegedara (40.4%) Table 3. 17 Distribution of Families by Grama Niladhari Division Grama Niladari Division No. of Families % Egalla Thulhiriya Kolongalla Walagama Kawdamulla Talgama Veragoda Deldeniya Kandegedara Total 7 5 3 3 7 1 2 3 21 52 13.5 9.6 5.8 5.8 13.5 1.9 3.8 5.8 40.4 100 Graph for table 3.17 No. of Families by GN Division 25 20 15 10 5 0 As shown in the Table 3.18 there are 190 members in the 52 families. Families with four or more members account for 57% of total families. Female population represents 51.1% (Table 3.19). As the age of the household members is concerned nearly 59% is below the age of 18 years and over 60% is in between 19 and 55 years. Only 3.2% is over the age of 65. (Table 3.20), According to the Table 3.21, only 32.6% of family members are employed, whereas 22.6% is still school children. Page 29 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Table 3. 18 Distribution of the Families by the Number of Family Members No. Family Members 1 2 3 4 5 6 Total No. of Families 3 7 12 16 11 3 52 % Population % 5.8 13.5 23.1 30.8 21.2 5.8 100 3 14 36 64 55 18 190 1.58 7.37 18.95 33.68 28.95 9.47 100.00 Table 3. 19 Distribution of population of families by gender Gender Male female Total No. of People % 93 97 190 48.9 51.1 100.0 Table 3. 20 Distribution of population of families by Age Age category Below 18 years 19-30years 31-55years 56-65years Above 65 years Total No. of People 55 37 78 14 6 190 % 28.9 19.5 41.1 7.4 3.2 100.0 Table 3. 21 Distribution of members of families by work or Education work or Education Number % Employed School children Pre- school Total 62 43 11 190 32.6 22.6 5.8 100.0 Land Possession The Table 3.22 on land possession of the households reveals an important factor that deserves due attention of the proposed project. That is the very low quantity of lands belongs to Page 30 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE majority of families. For over 65% of families the quantity of land ranged between 0.125 Acre and 0.26 Acre. Another 21% of families live in lands less than 0.5 Acre in quantity. (Table 3.22). The nature of land ownership is as shown in the Table 3.23. Accordingly 86.5% of households claimed private ownership for their land whereas 3.8% of households were on leased lands. The rest 9.6% had no legal possession. Table 3. 22 Distribution of families by the quantity of Land Possession Quantity of land Less than 0.125 acre above0.125 to 0.25 acre above e0.25 to 0.5 acre above 1 to 2 acre above 5 acre Total Frequency 14 20 11 6 1 52 % 26.9 38.5 21.2 11.5 1.9 100.0 Table 3. 23 Distribution of families by the nature of land Ownership Land ownership Private lands Lease lands Other(No Deeds/No Permits) Total frequency 45 2 5 52 % 86.5 3.8 9.6 100.0 Residence of people As the residence is concerned, 94.2% of families have been in their lands as permanent residents and only 3 families (5.8%) live as temporary residents. (Table 3.24). The period of residence is, over for 10 years for 67.3% families and between 6 and 10 years for 7.7% of families. The rest has been there for less than 5 years (Table 3.25). Except one family living in a wattle and daub house, all the families possess permanent houses but with limited space (Table 3.26). The floor area of houses of 77% of families ranged between 500 and 1000 square feet. Only 11% of families responded to have floor areas over 1000 square feet (Table 3.27). Additional building is available only for 32% of families in their residential lands. (Table 3.28) Table 3. 24 Distribution of families by the residence Residence Permanent temporary Total frequency 49 3 52 % 94.2 5.8 100 Page 31 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Table 3. 25 Distribution of families by the period of residence Period of residency Below two year year 2 -5 year 6-10 More than 10 No response Total frequency 3 6 4 35 4 52 % 5.8 11.5 7.7 67.3 7.7 33 Table 3. 26 Distribution of families by the condition of the House Condition of the house Permanent Building in Good Condition Wattle and daub house Total frequency 51 1 52 % 98 2 100 Table 3. 27 Distribution of families by the quantity of floor area Square Feats of the floor <500 501-1000 1001-2000 >2001 NR Total Frequency 19 21 5 1 6 16 % 36.5 40.4 9.6 1.9 11.5 100.0 Table 3. 28 Availability of the other buildings situated in the household lands Building No any other building Other buildings(Toilets/Store/Ect) Total frequency % 35 17 52 67.3 32.7 100 Use of mass media and IT Being the most popular electronic media, television is available for 92.3% of the families (Table 3.29) Radio sets are used by 82.7% of respondents (Table 3.30). Though 92.3% of families possesses television sets, only 76.9% of them have erected antennas. Most of the families (72.5%) have fixed them outside the house, whereas 22.5% have fixed them over the roof of the house. (Table 3.31 and Table 3.32) The mean height of the antenna is 12.5 feet and the maximum height being 15 feet. (Table 3.33) Computers are available for only 30.8% of the 52 Page 32 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE families (Table 3.34) However, only 7 families (13.5%) reported the use of internet facilities. (Table 3.35) Table 3. 29 Distribution of families by the use of television sets Response yes No Total frequency % 48 92.3 4 7.7 52 100 Table 3. 30 Distribution of families by the use of radio Response yes No Total frequency % 43 82.7 9 17.3 52 100 Table 3. 31 Distribution of families by the use of antenna Response frequency % yes 40 76.9 No 12 23.1 Total 52 100 Table 3. 32 Distribution of families by the place where the antenna is fixed Place Inside the house Fixed on roof Fixed outside Total frequency 2 9 29 40 % 5 22.5 72.5 100 Table 3. 33 Height of the antenna Height of the Antenna N Mean height Maximum height Statistics 40 12.55feet 15 feet Table 3. 34 Distribution of families by the use of Computers Response yes No Total frequency % 16 30.8 36 69.2 52 100 Page 33 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Table 3. 35 Distribution of families by the use of Internet Facility Response yes No Total frequency % 7 13.5 45 86.5 52 100.0 Domestic industries As the domestic industries are concerned, only 15.4% of families reported to have such industries (Table 3.36). Table 3. 36 Distribution of families by the availability of domestic industries Response yes No Total frequency 8 44 52 % 15.4 84.6 100.0 Occupation of householders The information given in the Table 3.37 show the types of occupation and the number of householders involved in them. State sector permanent employees represent only 15.4 of householders, whereas permanent employees in the private sector represent 5.8%. Over 15% are employed in temporary capacities in the private sector. Self employment accounts for 46.2% of householders. Over 13% has not directly revealed their means of living. (Table 3.38) Table 3. 37 Distribution of families by the occupation of householder Occupation Farming/Agriculture Meson/Carpenter/Driver Labor Small Business security/Police/Army Government officer/Teacher No Occupation Private sector Not mentioned Total Frequency 9 10 2 10 6 6 1 2 6 52 % 17.3 19.2 3.8 19.2 11.5 11.5 1.9 3.8 11.5 100 Page 34 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Economic Status of residents Income of the family is a good indicator of the economic status of people. The level of income as revealed by the respondents is shown in the Table 3.39. For over 36% of families the monthly income ranged between Rs. 5000 and 25000. Over 25% of families enjoy an income that ranged between Rs. 25000 and 50000 per month. As income is a sensitive factor for people, some refrained from revealing it. In the present study 17 families (32.7%) remained silent without responding to the question of their monthly income. Table 3. 38 Distribution of families by the occupation category of householder Occupation category Permanent Government Job Permanent Privet sector job Temporary privet sector Self Employment Retired Not mentioned Total Frequency 8 3 8 24 2 7 52 % 15.4 5.8 15.4 46.2 3.8 13.5 100 Table 3. 39 Distribution of families by the level of monthly income Income range Rs 5000-15000 Rs15001-25000 Rs25001-50000 Above Rs.50000 No Response Total Frequency 8 11 13 3 17 52 % 15.4 21.2 25 5.8 32.7 100 Future plans for constructions Questioned about plans for any future construction in their residential lands, only 9.6% responded affirmative. The rest majority had no such plans at the time of survey (Table 3.40). Three families plan to construct or/and reconstruct houses for residential purposes and two families have plans for constructing buildings for business purposes (Table 3.41). Table 3. 40 Future Plans for construction in the land Response Yes No Total Frequency 5 47 52 % 9.6 90.4 100.0 Page 35 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Table 3. 41 Type of Construction construction House/Reconstructions Building for Business Total Frequency 3 2 5 % 60 40 100 People’s opinion on the project The survey focused its attention to learn about peoples’ opinion on the proposed power project and it reveals mixed responses. Whereas, 44.2% of families expressed their opposition to it a similar number accepts the project. Six families (15.5%) are on the fence being unable to have a proper calculation of the project. (Table 3.42) Table 3. 42 Distribution of families by preference for the proposed power line Response Yes No No response Total Frequency 23 23 6 52 % 44.2 44.2 11.5 100.0 Furthermore, their willingness to accept the project was questioned to learn about reasons and the responses are as mentioned in the Table 3.43. Over 65% of positive respondents has seen the project from the perspective of national development and had realized its necessity as an infrastructure facility. Only 2 families (8.7%) agree with the project on the compensation to be provided for any damage to their properties (Table 3.44) Those who opposed the project also responded giving reasons for their stand. Over 30% of negative respondents are highly concerned with the problem of decreasing economic value of their land and properties caused by the power projects. Another 39.1% is concerned with the threat posed by the transmission line to the safety of their lives. They shared a fear of thunder strikes on those residing in the vicinity. The negative impact on the existing income was also raised by two families. They were afraid of losing their current income. (Table 3.44) Table 3. 43 Distributions of families by willing to accept the proposed power line by reason Reason Necessary for Because of Compensation Because it is Compulsory No response Total Frequency 15 2 2 4 23 % 65.2 8.7 8.7 17.4 100 Page 36 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Table 3. 44 Distributions of families by unwilling to accept the proposed power line by reason Reason No response Loss of value of lands Risk/Unsafe Loss of trees Not Trusted on Loss of Income source Total Frequency 2 7 9 2 1 2 23 % 8.7 30.4 39.1 8.7 4.3 8.7 100 Table 3. 45 Distribution of families by willing to accept a reasonable compensation and allow the uprooting of Trees Response Yes No No response Total Frequency 27 16 9 52 % 17.3 51.9 30.8 100 Willingness to accept compensation Peoples’ willingness to accept reasonable compensation and to allow the project to proceed with its tasks of clearing land and home gardens was also asked in the survey and their responses are given in the Table 3.45. Only 27 families (51.9%) expressed their will to accept reasonable compensations for the damage to be caused to their land and properties, including cultivations. However, 30.7% rejected to accept compensation on the assumptions such as decreasing land and property value, suspicion over getting a reasonable compensation and loss of valuable cultivation (Table 3.47). Those accepting the compensation reiterated the same reason given for their positive stand towards the project (Table 3.46). Table 3. 46 Distribution of families by reasons given for the willingness to accept compensation and allow the uprooting of trees Reasons No response Development of the country Because of Compensation Because it is Compulsory Total Frequency 8 5 8 6 27 % 29.6 18.5 29.6 22.2 100 Page 37 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Table 3. 47 Distribution of families by reasons given for the unwilling to accept compensation and allow the uprooting of trees Reasons No Response Loss of value of the land Loss of trees Because it is compulsory No trust on Compensation Total Frequency 3 4 4 4 1 16 % 18.8 25 25 25 6.3 100 Page 38 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 4. ENVIRONMENTEL IMPACTS 4.1. Construction Impacts 4.1.1. Physical Resources 4.1.1.1. Impacts on surface water quality due to soil erosion and silting Construction and operation of power transmission lines have minimal impact on surface or ground water quality. Water bodies may contaminate due to spilling of construction materials and surface runoff from construction site. If the surface runoff meets the river, there may be temporary increase in turbidity level of the river. When the soil is excavated to erect towers, they should be levelled so that this would not disrupt the movement of water and drainage. During the construction of foundations in paddy fields, the soil excavated will be generally utilized for backfilling, except in rare connections where excavated soil is not suitable for backfilling. In such cases, the excavated soil would not be left in the paddy field, but will be carried away and dumped in a suitable place. Considering the relatively small amount of excess soil, in most of the cases these are given to the neighbouring landowners, upon their request. If such places are not readily available, a proper place/s for dumping excess soil would be located in consultation with relevant DS, and levelled properly. Project activities including excavation, cut and fill operations, removal of trees and green cover vegetation etc., will enhance the soil erosion during the rainy season. The impact on soils will be due to the soil erosion at the tower construction site and along the access routes. Excavation activity and land clearance in the erosion prone areas have to be minimized while conducting site selection for towers. Leveling and stabilization of tower construction sites will be done after completion of construction activities which will avoid increased acceleration of surface runoff and damage to the topsoil. 4.1.1.2. Impacts of tower construction activities on hydrological patterns of the surrounding area Transmission towers are usually sited away from reservations of public streams and rivers. But excavation for tower footings and dewatering will affect local hydrological patterns in areas where water table is quite high. Also proposed activities may create temporary impacts to the existing drainage system in the area including irrigation canals, natural flow paths, and also the earth and line drain. Thus, it will create temporary inundation closer to the above locations during rainy season. Various mitigation measures to minimize anticipated impact due to obstruction of natural flow paths and existing drainage are listed in the following chapter. Proposed land for Kegalle GSS is adjacent to Gongan Ela and its development activities will include filling of the existing land above 1.2m from Kandy road level. Since the filling will be carried out totally outside the reservation of Gongan Ela, no impact will be caused to the hydrological pattern of it. All filling activities will be carried out under guidelines of SLLRDC with Page 39 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE minimum hindrance to local drainage patterns. Recommendations laid out by SLLRDC are attached as annex 6.2. 4.1.1.3. Impacts on fauna and flora or on existing habitats due to changing land use patterns Proposed route alignment does not cross any protected forest or wildlife areas or ecologically sensitive wetland. As mentioned earlier on section 2.3.2 about present land use, this line does not traverse any natural forest areas or forest plantations. No land use change take place when power line follows paddy fields which is the highest percentage of land use type (42.64%) traversed by the transmission line. Paddy cultivation can be continuing even under the tower itself. Rubber and home gardens are the secondly most affected by transmission line. Since all the trees growing above 3m height will have to be removed/ pruned along 30m corridor along the transmission line route, number of trees removed would be high in rubber plantations, and home gardens with high-grown trees. Rubber plantations and home gardens are generally considered as degraded habitats. Hence impacts in such areas are also relatively lesser. Ecological impacts related to flora and fauna on existing habitats is addressed under Cl. 4.1.3. 4.1.1.4. Impacts on canals, other irrigation structure and water bodies As tower locations will be carefully selected away from natural steams, irrigation canals and water bodies, the construction and operation of the power lines will not have any major impact on the surface and ground water quality in the area. Ground water pollution can take place, if chemical substances and oily waste get leached by precipitation of water and percolate to the ground water table. For transmission line construction activity, no chemical substance or oil is used hence there is no impact on ground water quality. The silt discharge from the earthwork around water bodies, oil, grease and fuel released from the construction vehicles/equipment and spoil from construction and other construction related activities such as raw sewerage from worker accommodation sites will mix with runoff water. This situation will increase during the rainy season and have a critical impact on surface and ground water. 4.1.1.5. Impacts on other proposed or planned government / private sector / development activities in the vicinity As per regulations enacted by GoSL, it is mandatory for CEB to seek clearance prior to construction from highways, railways, telecommunications and wherever necessary from aviation authorities that are likely to be affected by construction of lines. In case of any interference of utilities, CEB wishes to follow best practice guidelines. Page 40 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Northern expressway Accordingly CEB has written to Road Development Authority to provide RoW of Northern Expressway in Devalegama area. Any line crossing with road corridor will be constructed with adherence to technical specifications and RDA guidelines. Road Development Authority has planned a new highway from Enderamulla to Habarana to be constructed in four stages. Stage 3 of this new road has been proposed to build from Ambepussa to Katugastota. According to the preliminary layout made available to CEB by RDA, some sections of this road corridor and transmission line share same right of way, particularly in Devalegama area. RDA is currently in the process of optimizing the ROW. CEB will work in close coordination with RDA during the project implementation period to come up with most cost effective, technically and environmentally sound solution beneficial to the country. 4.1.2. Human and socio - economic impacts 4.1.2.1. Public safety / potential relocation of people etc. Safety As the proposed transmission line carrying 132 KV runs over an area that is under complete use for cultivation of paddy, Rubber and other crops of home gardens and also for residential purposes characterized with higher human activities, movements, and settlements with higher population density , the project has to pay special attention to the safety of people in the short and long run of the project activities, as the potential harm on the life and well-being of the residents cannot be ignored. Those live in the households, work in the lands and cultivations and move in the areas and roads over which the power line runs are the people directly or indirectly exposed to any potential negative impact. There are 52 families with 190 members residing in or in the vicinity of the power line route apart from people who work and move in the same area under the project. As the household members are concerned ,nearly29% are below the age of 18 years and 3.2% are over 65 years of age who deserve special attention with reference to safety under any project activity. As high–voltage lines are having an arc across an air gap they may have a lethal impact on people working or moving very close to such transmission lines even without any physical contact. As the transmission line runs over home gardens and paddy fields, people living and working in those areas have to take precautionary measures to protect themselves keeping the maximum distance over 15-17 feet between themselves/ objects in their hands or physical Page 41 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE contact and the power line. In particular, farmers using modern harvesting and other equipments have to be ever conscious about the precautionary measures. Fallen lines With all the technical and other safety measures taken by the project, still one cannot hundred percent assure the smooth functioning of the systems as unexpected natural or anthropogenic incidence might cause severe damage to towers, lines and grid stations. Peoples’ fear of transmission lines People in the area expressed their views and attitudes towards transmission line with special emphasis on the negative impact on their physical well-being. They believed that high tension power lines cause disabilities and diseases in human beings living in the close vicinity of such lines. Cancer and skin diseases were cited as dangerous impacts of power lines. Another strong belief among people was that transmission lines and towers connected to them attract thunder strikes and thereby endanger the lives of people. They also had the fear of spreading the fire emanating from the thunder caused ignition in transmission lines. Potential Relocation of People As the transmission line has been designed with special emphasis on minimum impact on human settlement, it causes no relocation of households living in or in the vicinity of its route course. There are 52 families living in or in the vicinity of the line route and those residents have to continue their use of existing housing facilities under indispensable precautionary measures and conditions pertaining to the expansion and reconstruction of them in the future. Land for the proposed grid station For the construction of Kegalle new grid substation, all the arrangements have been made to purchase approx.5 acres of land earmarked for proposed development from 8 Nos. of its owners. All the owners have already given their consent for selling the lots owned by them, and the official process for purchase of the land is underway. Existing access road in the Grid station location The access road leading to four lands which runs through the land identified for the construction of the sub-station in Kagalla. Project should take action to relocate the said road (with same width of the existing road) along the boundary of the land to be purchased. The people of the village are also prepared to accept such an alternative within the land area of the project. Page 42 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 4.1.2.2. Impact on the agriculture / plantation sector and land use of the area Impact on the land use pattern As shown in the Table 4.1, lands in the project area have been used mainly for the purposes of residents, cultivation of paddy, commercial and other crops. The total line length is 21.5 km. and 42.64% of it traverses over paddy land whereas 37.37% and 18.79% run over home gardens and Rubber Cultivations respectively. There were 52 families residing in or in the vicinity of line route and only 34 of them had cultivated their home gardens (Table 4. 2.), as the public roads are concerned the proposed line crosses over two points of major roads. Table 4. 1 Land Use in the line route No Land Use Data Total Line Length Land Usage i) ii) iii) iv) i) ii) iii) iv) Coconut Rubber Home Garden Paddy No of Crossing Railway Major (A ,B type )road crossing River Crossing Tanks 21.5 km Percentage of total line length (%) 18.79 37.37 42.64 Corridor width (m) 30 30 30 30 Total affected Area (ha) 12.1 24.2 27.4 2 - Table 4. 2 Distribution of families by the land use Land Cultivated Land Not Cultivated land Total Frequency 34 18 52 % 65.4 34.6 100.0 Paddy lands The proposed transmission line traverses for 42.64% of its total length over paddy fields. Selection of this line route over paddy lands avoids a serious impact on residential areas and plantations with high grown crops such as Rubber, Jack, Teak etc. However one cannot ignore its impact on the paddy fields including the irrigation systems and the people working on them. The use of paddy lands for the construction of supportive towers would not cause considerable reduction of paddy lands available for cultivation as farmers could cultivate the area under the towers leaving only the tower bases. Page 43 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE The construction phase of the power line over the paddy field definitely keep the line route, access roads and tower bases out of cultivation and the construction activities may also disturbs the irrigation system leaving the adjacent paddy land out of cultivation for a considerable period of time depending on the completion of the project. Any disturbance to the irrigation system may cause inundation over a vast area of paddy lands causing damage to cultivations. Existing access roads and newly constructed access roads for the transportation of materials are needed to be turned back to their original condition so that they may not cause unanticipated negative impacts. Rubber cultivations As mentioned earlier Rubber cultivations are subjected to 18.8% of the total length of the power line and that length with its due width is to be cleared removing all the high grown trees. This requirement would cause a considerable lost to the owners of the lands of those cultivations. Furthermore, the conditions imposed preventing the cultivation of high grown trees would compel the owners to change their pattern of land use. The impact of land clearance for the construction and maintenance of the power line, results in reducing the income that people earn from their home gardens, and other cultivations. It should not be taken for granted as most of people economically depend on the income of their home gardens, paddy and other cultivations for meeting the basic needs. Over 35% of the 52 households under consideration earn Rs. 25000 or less than per month. Home gardens The construction of transmission line affects considerable portion of home gardens over which the line traverses for 31.3% of its total length. As the 52 households are concerned 65.4 % of them possess home gardens less than 0.25 acre in quantity and they have the face the total removal of high grown trees in those small plots of lands. The project requires to clear 35m width of the area removing all trees grown or growing more than 3m in height. The project requirements prevent all the 52 householders and other land owners from using the line route for the cultivation trees growing over 3m .The householders were highly concerned about the loss of their home garden crops and its economic impact on the family budget as such products ease their economic hardship. Removal of Jack and coconut trees from home gardens has a serious impact on families depending on them for meeting the basic needs. 4.1.2.3. Other socio – economic impacts / benefits if any : Limitations of the construction of buildings The people of the affected area are highly concerned about the traversing of power line over their buildings and the inevitable ceiling on the height of constructions imposed by the project. Nearly 10% of the households have future plans of construction. However all expressed their Page 44 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE apprehension about the negative impact of the power line on their safety and future use of their lands for constructions. Construction of tower bases in small plots of lands will further reduce the quantity of land area available human use if such lands are selected. Degrading of land and property values People in the areas to be affected by the project were dissatisfied with an anticipated impact of decreasing land and property values as a result of the restrictions accompanied by the project. They anticipated a considerable decrease in land price after project implementation. The symbolic value of lands, properties, and cultivations are higher than their real value as people assign various cultural meanings to them on the ground of inheritance, memories, and emotional attachments. Any negative impacts on such properties are deeply felt by the owners as their lives are interwoven with them. Quality improvement of electricity supply With new substation to be built in Kegalle, number of current issues in electricity supply to surrounding areas to be resolved. New substation will eliminate lengthy 33kV lines which currently supply Kegalle, Mawanella, Polgahawela and Rambukkana areas from Kiribathkumbura and Thulhiriya GSSs. This will respond to low voltage problems encountered and improve the reliability of electricity supply to consumers of the said areas. On the other hand, this project will reduce distribution losses and improve overall efficiency of the network. 4.1.3. Ecological Resources 4.1.3.1. Impacts on existing habitats in and around the project site The transmission line traverses across paddy lands (42.64%) followed by home gardens (31.3%) and then rubber plantations (18.8%). When floral species diversity was considered the highest was in home gardens followed by paddy lands and then rubber lands and lastly open scrublands. Despite the fact that two endemic species were found in home gardens compared with one each in paddy lands and open scrublands when percentage endemism was taken highest is found in open scrublands (9.09%) followed by paddy lands (4.54%) and then in home gardens (2.08%). With regards to the occurrence of species with high conservation status, two nationally threatened species were encountered in the home gardens while one was encountered in paddy lands. Rubber plantations and open scrublands did not have any. With regards to the vulnerable species, one species was encountered in home gardens. Therefore when taken as a summary for the flora, the percentage endemism and species with high conservation status was highest in home gardens (71.42%) followed by paddy lands (28.57%) and then open scrublands (14.28%). However, when the project area is taken overall, the level Page 45 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE of endemism of flora is 3.37% while the percentage of nationally threatened species is 2% and the percentage of vulnerable species is 0.67%. With regards to fauna, the habitats exhibited a relatively high biodiversity. Paddy lands and open scrublands exhibited the highest (26.84% and 25.79% respectively) followed by home gardens and rubber plantations (23.68% and 23.0% respectively). There were two endemic amphibians and one endemic bird found in the paddy lands. Percentage endemism was highest in open scrublands (6.12%) followed by paddy lands (5.9%), home gardens (4.4%) and rubber plantations (4.44%). With regards to the species with high conservation status, the percentage of endangered species was 2.22% in all the habitats except in paddy lands. Percentage vulnerable species was highest in paddy lands (4.44%) followed by rubber plantations. Paddy lands recorded the highest near threatened species percentage (4%) followed by rubber plantations (2.22%) and open scrublands (2.04%). Of the habitat types the highest faunal diversity was recorded in paddy lands (51%) followed by homegardens (45%) and rubber plantations with other natural flora (45%). The least was recorded from open scrublands (19%). When the species diversity was considered, highest was recorded in birds (33.73%) followed by butterflies (26.50%), reptiles (10.84%), dragonflies (8.41%) and mammals (4.81%). The highest butterfly occurrence was recorded in open scrublands (68.42%) followed by rubber plantations (17.77%), homegardens (13.33%) and paddy lands (11.76%).Despite the fact that there was a high biodiversity in birds they were rather common in almost all the habitats. However, dragonflies were more prevalent in paddy lands. Amphibians were seen in paddy lands as well as wet areas in open scrublands. While reptiles were common to all the habitats mammals were seen mostly in other habitats except in paddy lands. Impact of the project on the habitats The major impact that will arise from the construction of the transmission line on ecosystems is the removal of trees more than 3m height in a corridor of about 35m. When considering the percentage occurrence of trees in the habitats along the line route, out of the total species found, 27.27% species are trees which will be removed. Despite the fact that there is high species diversity in home gardens, only 16.66% of the species encountered are trees. In rubber plantations all the trees on the corridor have to be removed. In the open scrublands, 63.63% of the species are trees. Due to the removal of the trees in the line corridor of about 35m disturbance and discontinuity will incur to the habitats which will affect both plants and animals. Despite the fact that the major disturbance will be during the construction period, due to the discontinuity of the corridors the impact on the same on animals especially on those who are slow moving could be significant. Further, this will impact on the biodiversity of the habitats. Page 46 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE In order to ascertain the significance of the impact of the project on the habitats and their function, a scoring system was developed (Impact Score) using the following criteria. The extent of the habitat affected Present status of disturbance % Biodiversity % Endemism Percentage occurrence of species with high conservation status (CR, EN, NT, VU) Marks were given from 1-5, the 1 being the least affected while 5 being the most affected. The results are shown below; Table 4. 3 Rating of habitats for their importance in biodiversity, endemism and conservation status Habitat type Extent affected % Level of disturba nce Biodiversity Endemism CR % % % EN % NT % VU % Total score Paddy Home Rubber Open 42.64 (3) 31.3 (3) 18.79 (2) 6.4 (1) 2 3 2 1 20.85 (2) 44.27 (3) 18.25 (2) 16.605 (2) 0 2.22 (3) 2.22 (3) 2.04 (3) 4.27 (2) 2.08 (2) 1.1 (2) 1.2 (2) 2 2.52 (1) 1.11 (1) 1.02 (1) 14 18 14 14 5.22 (4) 3.24 (3) 2.22 (2) 7.6 (4) Land area affected More than 80% (5); 40-80% (4); 20-40% (3); 10-20% (2); less than 10% (1) Biodiversity More than 60% (5); 40-60% (4); 20-40 % (3) 10-20% (2) 0-10% (1) Endemism More than 10% (5), 5 -10% (4); 2.5 – 5% (3), 1-2.5 % (2); < 1 Conservation Status CR – 5; EN – >10% (4); EN < 10% (3); NT – > 10% (3); NT < 10% (2); VU – > 10% (2) ; VU < 10% (1) From 20 – 25 From 15 – 20 From 10 – 15 From 0 – 5 : The disturbance on the habitat will be highly significant : The disturbance on the habitat will be moderately significant : The disturbance on the habitat will be less significant : There will be no significant impact on the habitat Based on the above rating, it could be concluded that of the habitats affected by the Project, home gardens will be moderately affected while the affect on the paddy, rubber and open scrublands will be less affected, As the home gardens provide a, means of connectively of the ecosystems especially for the fauna with special reference to arboreal fauna, creation of gaps by felling trees > 3m height will have a significant negative impact on their movement. Despite the fact that the impact on rubber plantations in a biodiversity perspective is less, due to felling of large number of trees > 3m height the plantation will be negatively affected. As there are many birds in all these habitats, when trees are removed the trees used by birds for roosting Page 47 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE and nesting will be affected and in turn their continuity will be affected. However, in these ecosystems except for Sri Lanka Jungle Fowl other birds are not endemic or with high conservation status. Due to the clearing of trees especially in the home gardens, rubber plantations and also open scrublands, the arboreal mammal (Sri Lanka Purple Faced Langur) and other animals like squirrels, monkeys etc. will be affected. Due to the ground clearing along the transmission line, habitats of ground inhabiting animals like amphibians, reptiles etc. will be affected; such openings will encourage the encroachment of these natural and naturalized habitats reducing the habitats for wildlife further. During the construction of the towers which are situated 300m apart, there would be lot of activity especially during the day time which includes noises from equipment, vehicles and others which affects the fauna adversely. The conglomeration of a large labour force located in labour camps during the construction period, may cause intrusion into the day to day life of the area as well as cause disposal of waste both solid and liquid to the surrounding land uses causing pollution. Another prominent impact especially during the operational stage is the electrocution of fauna. The types of animals which will be mostly at risk are arboreal mammals and birds. Animals cannot understand that electrical power lines and transformers carry deadly current. To monkeys and other arboreal wildlife, power poles and lines look like trees and vines. When an animal grasps a live electrical line while its feet or trail touches the parallel line beneath it, a deadly circuit formed, and it is electrocuted. However, in the design of this high tension 132kV power line, about 4m is kept vertically between two parallel lines and 10m distance kept horizontally and therefore there is a remote chance for an animal to touch two lines which is a prerequisite for electrocution. However, at the proximal end where the lines are hanged to the tower, there is a chance of this happening as the distance becomes small. Further, a distance of 17.5m is kept on either side of the transmission line as the buffer area so that the animals jumping on to the transmission line from nearby trees is very remote. However, if the transmission line is not kept clean of vegetation there is a chance of damage to wildlife from tree branches and vines, touching a live line. Impacts to wetlands A good part of the transmission line traverses along or across paddy fields which are associated with wetlands. They serve vital functions including storing runoff, regenerating groundwater, filtering sediments and pollutants, and providing habitat for aquatic species and wildlife. The construction and maintenance of transmission lines can impact wetlands in the following ways: Heavy machinery can crush wetland vegetation and wetland soils. Wetland soils, especially very peaty soils can be easily compacted, increasing runoff, blocking flows, and greatly reducing the wetland’s water holding capacity. The construction of access roads can change the quantity or direction of water flow, causing temporary damage to wetland soils and vegetation. Page 48 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Construction and maintenance equipment that crosses wetlands can stir up sediments, endangering fish and other aquatic life. Clearing forested areas can expose the land to invasive and shrubby plants, thus removing habitat for species in the forest interior. Vehicles and construction equipment can introduce exotic plant species. Any of these activities can impair or limit wetland functions. Organic soils consist of layers of decomposed plant material that formed very slowly. Disturbed wetland soils are not easily repaired. Severe soil disturbances may permanently alter wetland hydrology. A secondary affect of disturbance is the opportunistic spread of invasive weedy species. These invasive species provide little food and habitat for wildlife. Impacts on scrub forests/forests There are no high canopied forest areas along the transmission line route. At Thulhiriya, the Thulhirikanda Forest Reserve is located more than 100m from the line route. However, there are scrub lands with scattered trees in certain sections of the line route. However, the impact on these will be less as the occurrence of trees more than 3m height occurring on the line route is not a common occurrence. Impact on the Project on the survival of the species with high conservation status The following criteria was used in the development of a scoring system to assess the impact of the Project on the survival of the species in the habitats with special reference to those who are endemic and having high conservation status. The parameters of the criteria were; Conservation Status Global distribution Distribution in Sri Lanka Mobility of the species When conservation status of the species was considered the maximum scoring was given to the critically endangered species (5 marks) followed by endangered species (4 marks), Data Deficient species (3 marks), Near Threatened species (2 marks) and vulnerable species (1 mark). When the global distribution of the species was considered, endemic species were given 5 marks while those having a distribution in both Sri Lanka and India were given 4 marks. Those who are prevalent in South Asia were given 3 marks while those in Asia were given 2 marks. The species having a wide distribution across continents were given 1 mark. Page 49 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE When the distribution of a species within Sri Lanka was considered, 5 marks were given to those who are found only in the Project area. The species found in another climatic zone were given 4 marks while those that inhabit more than one climatic zone were given 2 marks. When mobility of the species was considered, those who have higher mobility and could move fast will be less affected than those who have less mobility. Species having highest mobility were given 1 mark (birds) while those having little mobility can be given 5. Table 4. 4 the details of the assessment and the rating done on the floral species encountered Species CS Global distribution C E D N V Endemic to R N D T U Sri Lanka Walidda antidysenterica (Idda) Garcinia quaesita (Goraka) Cycas nathorstii (Madu) Lagerstroemia speciosa (Murutha) Madhuca longifolia (Mee) Ficus fergusoni (Kosgonna) Bridelia mooni (Path kela) From 10-15 From 5-10 From 0-5 Distribution in SL In In S. In India Asi Asia and a SL In other Restrict Found contine ed to in one nts too Project climatic area zone Found in more than one climatic zones 4 Over all ratin g 9 5 5 2 1 1 2 3 2 7 4 6 4 9 4 2 8 5 4 9 5 4 9 : Significant impact on the survival of species : Moderate impact on the survival of species : Low impact on the survival of species Page 50 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Table 4. 5 The details of the assessment and the rating done on the faunal species encountered Species CS Global distribu tion C E D N V Endemi R N D T U c to Sri Lanka Euploea sylvester (Double branded crow) Notocrypta paralysos (Common banded demon) Onychargia atrocyana (Marsh dancer) 2 Orthetrum luzonicum (Marsh skimmer) 2 Fejervarya kirtisinghei In India and SL In S. Asia In Asia 1 2 In other contin ents 1 Rest rict ed to Foun d in othe r 1 5 5 Otocryptis wiegmanni (Sri Lanka Kangaroo Lizard) 5 Gallus lafayetii (Sri Lanka Jungle Fowl) 5 Fou nd on mor 2 Level of mobi lity & Over all ratin g 3 8 1 2 3 7 1 2 3 8 2 3 11 2 4 12 2 4 11 3 11 4 11 4 Hylarana gracilis (Sri Lanka Wood Frog) From 15-20 From 10-15 From 5-10 Distributio n in SL () 3 2 : Significant impact on the survival of species : Moderate impact on the survival of species : Low impact on the survival of species Page 51 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE From 0-5 : No impact on the survival of species When the probable impacts on the survival of species in different habitats were considered, the proposed project will have moderate impacts on the survival of the following species; Orthetrum luzonicum (Marsh skimmer) Fejervarya kirtisinghei (Frog) Hylarana gracilis (Sri Lanka Wood Frog) Otocryptis wiegmanni (Sri Lanka Kangaroo Lizard) Gallus lafayetii (Sri Lanka Jungle Fowl) Therefore, despite the fact that the line route traverses along paddy lands major part of its route, the impact on the trees on the borders cannot be considered as non significant. Impact on this on paddy lands is minimal as there are fewer trees compared with other habitats. The impact on the open scrublands will also be small as these areas are dominated by shrubs and the trees are seen scattered. The impact on the rubber plantations and the home gardens are the most as these ecosystems are dominated by trees. Impacts on agriculture/plantation sector and land use of the area The proposed transmission line has been planned to traverse above paddy lands for about 42.64% of its path followed by 31.3% over home gardens, 18.79% over rubber lands, about 6.4 % above scrub forest areas. When it is traversing along the paddy lands it is not expected to change the land use very much. However, when an area of 30m is cleared from home gardens leaving only trees which are less than 3m in height, the land use of the same will be affected. It has been estimated that an area equivalent to 12 ha of rubber plantations in the Kegalle Districts will be removed and therefore the land use of these areas will be changed. Since there are only scattered trees in the scrub forest areas the impact on this is not very significant. Impacts on agriculture Paddy The transmission line traverses major part of its route along paddy fields. Due to the absence of a tree cover it is not required to remove trees. However, especially during the construction period, there would be much disturbance due to the erection of the towers. As about 4~9m2 per leg has to be excavated at the depth of 2m to construct the tower foundation this will disturb the soil much and also disrupt the irrigation canals and thus reducing their capacity and flow rate. It also encourages weed infestation. During the construction, the farm operations have to be stopped. Any wind breaks that are present around the paddy fields if it coincides with the 35m buffer area has to be removed. During the tower construction, accidental spillage of fuel or lubricants may occur due to plant and machinery breakdowns and carelessness of workers. If these pollutants move into streams, rivers, lagoons, or ponds even the ground water can get contaminated. Water plants and fish can also be affected. Due to the small scale and scattered nature of construction, Page 52 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE intensity of such impact is very minimal. Further, even during the operational period, the presence of towers and power lines on top will hinder the use of high tech equipment in farming i.e. combined harvester. Rubber cultivations According to the land use along the transmission line, 12 ha of rubber lands will be directly affected. About 19,200 rubber trees will be lost to the country. When an average yield of rubber plantations is taken as 1200 kg/ha/yr the yield loss from rubber will be 14,400 kg/yr. Therefore, the loss of these trees should be compensated adequately. The advice of the Rubber Cultivation Board should be requested with regard to designing a proper compensation package for this. Home gardens About 24.2 ha of home gardens will be directly affected along the transmission line route. These gardens comprise of a mixture of trees and crops which provides multitudes of needs to the home gardener i.e. timber, small wood, fuel wood, fruits, food and medicine. As it is required to clear 30m width of the area from vegetation especially those which are more than 3m in height or those which has potential to grow more than 3m the a good part of the vegetation will be lost to the home gardener who will lose cash income as well as security from food, timber and other essential goods. For the houses which are having small extents of land, the area available for cultivation will be greatly limited. The loss of these valuable crops needs to be adequately compensated. Although it is allowed to grow crops with short statures, people do not like to work under these lines due to safety reasons. 4.1.3.2. Impact on migratory patterns of fauna in the region When considering the habitats affected by the Project, the highest faunal biodiversity was exhibited by paddy lands (26.84%) followed by open scrublands (25.78%) and then home gardens and rubber plantations. The main contributors for the relatively high biodiversity are the birds which roamed across all the habitats. Further butterflies were also abundant in all the habitats while dragonflies were more abundant in paddy lands. However, due to their high mobility the impact of a development project will be much less on them as they are not localized. Reptiles were also common in all the habitats and they too have high mobility and can move out of disturbance. With regard to mammals, there is an endemic and endangered monkey (Sri Lanka Purple Faced Langur) seen in all the habitats except in paddy lands. As they are arboreal animals, they would prefer to have continuous canopy for their free movement. Due to the Project, there would be felling of trees and therefore their free movement will be affected and they will also become a nuisance to households and could create an environmental and social issue. The faunal species which would be most affected will be amphibians which inhabit the streams associated with paddy lands. There are two endemic frogs i.e. Kirtisinghe's Frog and Sri Lanka wood frog that are also endemic. The former is vulnerable too. As major land use affected (42.64%) is paddy the impact on Page 53 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE the amphibians due to the project could be high especially since they are less mobile and would be localized. 4.2. Safety and security 4.2.1. The structural safety of the transformers and transmission lines specially during unpredictable operational loads Transmission lines are designed to trip out of service (turn off), if they fall and touch ground or contact trees. Transmission lines are not likely to fall unless encounters a severe impact such as hit by a tornado or a truck or due to anthropogenic activity. All the tower types are been tested for critical load combinations in state of the art laboratory facilities in India. Therefore it can be certain that structural failure of towers is very unlikely. 4.2.2. Lightning danger from transformers and transmission lines: Tall objects such as transmission towers, poles and trees are more likely to intercept lightning strikes. Transmission lines are therefore usually built with a grounded shield wire at the top of the poles. This protects the transmission line from lightning. Lightning is not more likely to strike houses or cars near the transmission line. Shorter objects under or very near a line may actually receive some protection from lightning. 4.2.3. The possibility of any accidental hazards or fire hazards: When working near high-voltage transmission lines, electrical contact can occur even if direct physical contact is not made because electricity can arc across an air gap. As a general precaution, no one should be on an object that is taller than 15 to 17 feet under and overhead high-voltage electric line. Individual with specific concerns about whether it is safe to operate vehicles or farm equipment near transmission lines should contact their electricity provider directly. 4.2.4. Landslide hazards Since around 50% of the total line length traverse along hilly terrain, construction of towers in steep areas (especially foundation excavation) may cause instability, and can induce landslide hazards, particularly in rainy season. 4.2.5. Proposed precautionary measures / safeguard: a. Workers : Personal protective equipment like safety gloves, helmet, mufflers etc. will be provided during the construction period and during the maintenance work. First aid facilities will be made available with the labor gangs and doctors called in from nearby towns when necessary. The safety and Page 54 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE emergency procedures manual will be kept. Necessary training regarding the safety aspects of the personnel working at the project site will be provided. b. Communities in the neighborhood: It will be ensured that anybody working on the property is properly briefed on the electrical infrastructure, clearance zones and plant, machinery and equipment specifications. c. Surrounding environment to be taken in the event of any possible accident, fire hazards: Activities may create accidental damage to public and the construction workers. Therefore, contractors should take necessary action to enhance personal safety during the Construction through the following measures: Organize awareness programs relevant to the personal safety of the workers and the public in the area. Installation of warning signs to particular locations such as transverse points of local road network of transmission lines. Provide protective safety belts, footwear, helmets, goggles, eye-shields, and clothes of workers depending on their duty. Arrangement of proper first aid unit, fire fighting gear and transport facilities to take injured people to the hospitals. d. Landslide hazards Considering the possibility of landslides triggered due to tower foundations located in hilly terrain, a complete report regarding possibility of landslides and proposed precautions/ remedial measures have been obtained from NBRO, which is attached as annex 6.4. However, few minor deviations has been effected to the initially proposed route in order to minimize the social impacts, including a smaller length closer to Kegalle GSS .Since thet length also traverse above hilly terrain, an addendum to the initial report (which should be read in conjuction with previous report) from NBRO has also been obtained, which is also attached as 6.4. The recommendations given in the said reports shall be strictly adhered to, during the construction of the tower foundations. 4.2.6. Impact on visual environment, historical sites and sites of special values No archeological, historical or cultural important sites are affected by the construction of the line. During profile survey, it is ensured that the proposed route of transmission line does not affect any public places like playgrounds, schools, places of worship or other similar establishment etc,. Pinnawala Elephant Orphanage is the most important tourist attraction in the area and selected line route option traverses about 4km away from it. Proposed line does not traverse places of known archeological importance. Page 55 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 4.3. Railway Tracks & Highways & Road Development Proposed alignment of transmission line does not interfere with railway tracks but crosses several A and B grade roads. This transmission line crosses A6 road near to Exsisting Thulhiriya Substation, B539 NelundeniyaAlawwa Road in Ragalkanda GN division, A19 Polgahawela- Kegalle Highway in Walagama GN division, B 199 Karandupona- Rambukkana Road in Galpala GN division. Issues related to proposed Northern expressway is discussed in section 4.1.1.5 4.3.1. Details in regard to the exact crossing points of the railway tracks and roads None of proposed 132 kV Thulhiriya to Kegalle transmission line is traverse across any railway tracks but this transmission line cross A6 road near to Exsisting Thulhiriya Substation, B539 Nelundeniya- Alawwa Road , A19 Polgahawela- Kegalle Highway , B 199 Karandupona- Rambukkana Road. 4.3.2. Details regarding the distance from the middle of the road to the posts. The height of the line route from the roads. In case of road crossing, CEB will ensure to keep required safety clearance as recommended by RDA. Clearance to the bottom conductor from the finished road level will be 6.7m as per technical specification of CEB which is greater than RDA requirement. 4.4. Mono cultivation land areas Paddy fields are the main land use type and the only farmland traversed by the transmission lines. As explained above, 42.64% of the Thulhiriya - Kegalle line has been located over paddy lands, in order to reduce the social impacts caused by locating the proposed transmission line along residences and/or home gardens. As mentioned earlier in section 4.1.2.2, rubber cultivations are encountered in 18.8% of the total length of the power line and that length with its due width is to be cleared removing all the high grown trees. Extent of this impact is discussed in section 4.1.3.1. 4.5. Wildlife and forest reserve areas None of proposed 132 kV Thulhiriya - Kegalle line is traverse across any areas under the purview of Department of Wildlife Conservation and the nearest wildlife sanctuary, Kurulu Kele in Kegalle is Page 56 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE about 4.5 km away from the proposed sites. No wildlife sanctuary, national parks, or ecologically sensitive areas are present in the nearby area of RoW. There are no forest reserves in the immediate vicinity of line route but Thulhiriya Forest Reserve is located more than 100m away from the line route in Thulhiriya. This is about 200 acres in extent and comprise of predominantly Mahogany which are about 25 years old. Further details were addressed in section 3.2.3. 4.6. Kandyan forest gardens Kandyan Forest Gardens (KFG) are primarily located in Kandy district while some can be observed in Matale, Kegalle and Rathnapura districts. KFG demonstrate tropical rain forest structure with maximum tree height of 30-35m consists of few canopy layers. Findings of the ecological survey confirm the high species diversity exist in the home gardens. Impacts to the home gardens due to project activities are discussed in section 4.1.3.1. 4.7. Irrigation tanks a) Names of the tanks and co-ordinates Proposed 132 kV Thulhiriya to Kegalle line does not traverse any irrigation tanks under the purview of Irrigation Department. b) Angle point A6 – riverine environment near “Thalgahayaya” The only riverine ecosystem along the line route can be observed in between angle point 5 and 6 related to Ragala oya in Egalla GN division in Warakapola DS division. At this location, line route crosses the stream in perpendicular angle causing minimum damage to the vegetation along the waterway. 4.8. Agrarian development matters Paddy fields are the main land use type and the only farmland traversed by the transmission lines. As explained earlier, there will be no change in the land use planning due to the project in the paddy fields, except for the safety precautions to be adopted when using the harvesting machines with a higher reach. Paddy cultivation will be continued under the transmission line, and even under the towers, during the operational phase of the project. However it may cause some problems for those working in the paddy lands for cultivation and harvesting of paddy, if necessary actions are not taken to prevent such impact. In particular use of some of modern harvesting equipments (capable of extending to a higher reach) under the transmission line without precautionary measures may results in accidents due to electrocution. Adequate clearances will be Page 57 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE maintained during the tower spotting/ profile survey of the project, for the operation of such machines which are used in the paddy fields traversed by the transmission line. Considering the significant length of the transmission line traversing over paddy land, special attention has to be paid to the physical protection of the operators of such machines. Creating proper awareness among the owners, farmers and the operators of said equipments regarding the under mentioned aspects is very important in avoiding such accidents. 4.9. Archaeology areas As a result of the survey works carried out along the line route, no archeologically important areas were identified. There are no specific sites of any significant religious or cultural value, which are relevant to the line route or to proposed GSS site. However, if any such site is encountered even at a later stage, CEB will ensure to make necessary deviations, as per the directives of Department of Archaeology. Page 58 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 5. Proposed Mitigatory Measures Potential adverse environmental impacts associated with transmission lines has been avoided or minimised through careful route selection. The alignment is sited away from major settlements, whenever possible, to account for future urban expansion. Forests areas and thick vegetation areas are avoided wherever possible; however route alignment passes through paddy fields, home gardens, rubber plantations and scrub lands etc,. As a result, the line route does not cross any protected areas or environmentally sensitive habitats. CEB will not acquire any private lands for tower placement, instead pay market price for land area occupied by the tower footing and owner is entitled for use his land as safety guidelines permits. Mitigation of impacts on surface water quality and local hydrological patterns All the angle tower locations (at turning points of the line route) are already decided while exact positions of suspension towers will be decided in a later stage after completion of the ground profile survey along the line route. As a preconstruction measure, no tower will be sited close to reservations of public streams, rivers or any other water bodies. It will avoid disruption of existing drainage paths and reduce possibility of meeting surface runoff with water body which will eventually increase turbidity levels. As line traverse in hilly terrain, excavation for tower footings will expose soil in slopes and aggravate soil erosion in rainy season. Possibility of erosion from tower foundations located in hilly terrain is minimized by construction of earth retaining structures and/or turfing wherever necessary. Once the soil is excavated for tower foundations, the earth should be backfilled or removed from the site. The loose soil should be protected with mulch (living: e.g. crop cover or non-living: e.g. paddy straw, forest leaves, and other agricultural crop residues or manmade materials such as tarpaulins). In addition to these mitigation measures, specific remedial measures mentioned in NBRO landslide investigation report (attached as annex 6.2) shall be strictly adhered to during tower construction in hilly terrain. During the construction of foundations in paddy fields, the soil excavated will be generally utilized for backfilling, except in rare occasions where excavated soil is not suitable for backfilling. In such cases, the excavated soil would not be left in the paddy field, but will be carried away and dumped in a suitable place. Considering the relatively small amount of excess soil, in most of the cases these are given to the neighbouring landowners, upon their request. If such places are not readily available, a proper place/s for dumping excess soil would be located in consultation with relevant DS, and levelled properly. Care is taken not to obstruct any natural process such as surface water runoff and stream water flow, during construction works. Any existing water channels should be diverted properly. In case the location of tower foundations close to river bank is unavoidable, best engineering practices will be adopted to avoid / minimize disturbances to the banks or and also not to obstruct any natural processes such as surface water runoff and stream water flow or any other canal/stream having significant flow during construction works. Earth retaining structures will be built with necessary Page 59 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE drainage facilities around the towers located in sloping areas or any locations disturbed by the project implementation. Once the towers are constructed, the loose soil should be covered with vegetation as much as possible to avoid soil erosion and sedimentation. Proposed land for Kegalle GSS is adjacent to Gongan Ela and its development activities will include filling of the existing land above 1.2m from Kandy road level. Since the filling will be carried out totally outside the reservation of Gongan Ela, no impact will be caused to the hydrological pattern of it. All filling activities will be carried out under guidelines of SLLRDC with minimum hindrance to local drainage patterns. In order to maintain an uninterrupted drainage in the area (as well as Gongan Ela) after filling, CEB has requested a drainage plan for the said development from SLLRDC which will be incorporated in to the filling plan. The storm water drainage system designed to adequately higher intensity of rainfall would be installed in the new GSS, which should be discharged to the Gongan Ela. Mitigation of impacts on flora and fauna due to land use change During the planning stage, CEB has taken maximum effort to avoid conservation areas under forest and wildlife departments and any other sensitive ecosystems. As mentioned in section 2.3.2, paddy (42.64%) is the main land use type along the line which has relatively minimum impact on flora and fauna due to the transmission line. Home gardens (31.3%) and Rubber (18.79%) are second and third largest mono cultivation lands which get affected by transmission line. Shrub is the only other land use type traversed by the transmission line. Since only the trees growing above 3m along the corridor should be removed, the impact would be limited to removal of few isolated trees, and would not cause a significant change of land use. Mitigation of impacts on canals, other irrigation structure and water bodies As explained under section 4.1.1.4, impacts caused by the project on canals, other irrigation structures and water bodies is very less, mainly due to the selection of the line route. Even the minor impacts anticipated will be mitigated by incorporation of following measures: Provisions of temporary drainage facilities to the particular locations if existing drains are obstructed due to construction activities. Paving and surface treatment for exposed soil in excavation Maintenance of all drainage paths by avoiding blockages at all times. Temporary labour camps will be provided with proper water and sanitary facilities. Hygienically sound sanitation facilities are to be setup in and around labor camps, which should not cause ground or surface water pollution. Mitigation of other ecological impacts Paddy fields are the main farmlands traversed by the line corridor, and paddy is allowed to be continued to grow along the line corridor and even under the towers itself. The timing of the Page 60 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE construction activities in the paddy fields would be adjusted as far as practicable, to avoid the harvesting period. Only damages to the crop would be compensated to the owners, as per the assessment of relevant DSs. In the home gardens which will be affected, only trees over 3m which are beneath the transmission line along line corridor would be removed for which appropriate compensation would be paid to the land owners/tenants. As stipulated in the Electricity Act (latest revision), compensation for removed or pruned trees will be paid at a fair market rate to the respective land owners based on tree type, its age and expected income from the tree. The assessment of the value will be made by the Divisional Secretary. Cleared vegetation and any timber will be made available to the land-owner for his own use, and will not be acquired or used by CEB or any other Government agency. For the rubber plantations, the Ceylon Electricity Board (CEB) would seek advice from the Rubber Cultivation Board with regard to the compensation rate and would take appropriate measure to effect this. In the absence of this, the Divisional Secretary will be requested to value the crop and provide the information to the CEB. Mitigation of the impacts on the fauna, flora and migration paths of wild animals Any development effort will incur some negative impact on the environment. However, every effort has been taken in the proposed project to minimise the negative impacts, mostly during the selection of proposed line route. With regard to the flora which also includes 5 endemic species, two near threatened and two vulnerable species, the CEB would get the assistance from the Forest Department in promoting these species either in home gardens of the same locality or in appropriate locations. The CEB will negotiate with the Forest Department for the cost incurred and would effect it. With regards to the fauna, the birds, dragonflies have high mobility and will shy away from the construction sites during the construction period and are expected to return to the project area after the things are settled down. The reptiles will also be less affected as they can readily move out of site. With regard to the amphibians and fish in the project areas especially the paddy fields where they are predominant, the impact from the construction activities will be of much impact. Among the amphibians there are two which are endemic and also one is endangered too, however, they occur in similar habitats in other climatic zones too. Hence, the impact on the population of them would not be significant. In order to address these good practice guidelines will be effected during the construction period in all the aspects. They are detailed in the Monitoring Plan in Chapter 7. Mitigation of the impacts on wetlands and low lying areas Major part of the transmission line traverses along paddy fields and low lying areas/wetlands. Sediment deposition through diversion of runoff in road construction can be a setback to the usefulness of wetlands. Silt pits should be erected at suitable points to avoid this. When the soil is excavated to erect towers, they should be leveled so that this would not disrupt the movement of water and drainage. Ideally the construction should be carried out in the dry season so that this would not disrupt with the paddy cultivation. Good housekeeping practices should be adopted during Page 61 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE construction so that these wetlands will not be adversely affected by water pollution and disposal of solid waste. Mitigation of Socio-economic impacts Mitigation of socio-economic impacts is indispensable to assure the well-being of people to be affected by the project, Even though the project has been designed with minimum impact on people and their properties, it is further reiterated that the implementation phase should be carefully carried out so that the project may further reduce the social impact identified in this report. Above mentioned social impacts can be mitigated by means of making necessary changes in the current plan of the project. The height of the transmission line should be increased to the required level or above for safety clearances at places where it runs above buildings, public roads and railway lines and also at places where such a requirement is well evident from the safety point of view. Suspension towers on the transmission line should be shifted along the line route to the maximum extent so that they may bring about minimum impact on people and their properties. Durable cradle guards above crossing points of railway tracts and also above places where such a requirement is evident should be installed for additional safety so that any breakdown in the transmission line may not affect the people and other means of transportation. The cradle guards should be strong enough to bear the heavy bundles of wires used for the transmission line. Preventive guards should be installed around the towers to be erected in the human settlements to prevent children’s entrance to the towers and climbing on it. Even though the project is not causing any resettlement, the National Involuntary resettlement policy should be strictly adhered to in case of any relocation of people and their properties (which is very unlikely as explained earlier). In such cases the project should give the maximum benefit to the affected people. CEB will make provisions for any houses along the transmission line corridor that are already approved by local authority. If it is a two story construction, necessary provision may be kept after raising the height of the towers. All the owners of proposed land for Kegalle have agreed to sell their allotments to CEB, and purchasing process is underway. However, in case any acquisition of lands for the construction of the Kagalla grid station should be carried out, reasonable compensation for the land owners will be given. A new access road should be constructed along the boundary of the proposed land for Kegalle GSS before closing the existing access road through the land. Any damage to the properties and cultivations affected by the Project (including cutting/uprooting of the trees in the transmission line corridor) has to be properly compensated, as per the provisions given under Electricity Act No. 20 of 2009. As per the said Act, all the compensations have to be paid as per the assessment of relevant Divisional Secretary. All such compensation should be estimated with special concern about the existing prices in the market and estimated cost for recovering the damage. Page 62 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Compensation for lands for the construction of suspension towers should be carried out within the legal framework prescribed by the Electricity Act No 20 of 2009 and relevant other laws. For such lands/ properties, a reasonable compensation is estimated based on the area of the land affected, considering the disability and/or disturbance caused by the tower at land and property values in the current market should be paid to the owners. A comprehensive package of compensation had already been prepared by the Coconut Cultivation Board to the land owners who are losing their coconut lands. However, for valuable trees located in home gardens such package is not readily available although according to the Electricity Act advice is given to pay them at the price valued by the Divisional Secretary of the area. However, if there is a national prescription for this based on the current market prices it would benefit all equally. People should be made properly aware of the project, its national contribution and direct or indirect positive impact of it on their life and future generations so that they may act in favor of the project. Such awareness may prevent them from any individual or collective anti-project movement. Compensation for all the damage and acquisition of land should be made available at the initial stage of the project as the people lose all or part of their means of income soon after the clearance of lands. Such action is required to enable the affected people to meet their economic and other needs. People should be made aware of the impact of high tension power transmission lines and be also educated of the way they should work and look after their children without raising any object up to the power lines and doing anything without necessary care. Especially those working in the paddy fields should be educated not to raise their paddy clearing equipments up to the level of transmission line. All the new access roads constructed for the project should be removed if they lead to cause any problem to people and their properties and cultivations. Action should be taken to protect land from inundation by removing the soil from the areas dumped. Seasons of cultivation (Maha and Yala) should be avoided as much as practicable in the period of construction and unavoidable continuation of any construction work in any season of cultivation should be carefully managed with due compensation for the loss of harvest. Care should be exercised to protect people and domestic animals in the period of construction of transmission line. Mitigation of the impacts from construction sites The project may cause a conglomeration of internal and external labour in the project sites. Workers may come from either the same locality or from other areas. There would be many worker camps established. The impacts from these would increase opportunities for employment for the local people which is a positive move but on the negative side the accumulation of waste both liquid and solid, intrusion to the village life etc. should be managed. Waste disposal should be properly organized so Page 63 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE that there would not be any littering and pollution of nearby water bodies. All the construction sites, stores of materials, temporary and permanent buildings, and vehicles and constructing equipments and utensils used for cooking etc. should be carefully maintained so that they may not be conducive to the breeding of mosquitoes including the lethal, dengue mosquitoes. All the disposals should be properly supervised. Practice guidelines should be adhered to in this connection. The workers should be guided properly by the project management so that the workers will integrate effectively with the village environment and not cause any harm to the socio cultural environment. Mitigations to ensure safety and security All possible safety measures should be taken to prevent any adverse impact on the workers, communities in the neighborhood and surrounding environment. The safety measures adhered to in the construction of the project is shown in Annex under the section minimum factors of safety. The clearance height of the transmission line had been adjusted based on the land use type it is traversing. For example when it is traversing above paddy fields the lowest line will be at least 10m from the ground to provide clearance for the use of any heavy duty agricultural equipment. When it is traversing the roads, despite the fact that the Road Development Authority guidelines stipulates that a clearance of 5.25 meters will be sufficient it also has been increased to 10 meters. When it is traversing across home gardens, clearance has been kept to accommodate a two storied house (30 feet), if the land owner is in possession of a plan approved by the relevant local authority for such construction. In case of any existing buildings/ houses are coming under the transmission line conductors, relevant safety clearance will be maintained to allow for maximum safety even to accommodate person standing on the roof. Further in order to avoid any accidents, the trees above 3m should be removed. These lines should be maintained on a regular basis so that any interruptions due to the contact of trees can be minimized. With regard to the mitigation of adverse impacts on the animals, the vertical distance between two conductors is about 4m and horizontally it is about 10m. Further as the tallest tree underneath the line is 3m, it is very unlikely that the birds or even monkeys could be electrocuted by contacting these lines. Further as the distance to the nearest tree is 17.5m from the centre on either side, this does not allow animals to jump to the line from nearby trees. Mitigation to minimize aesthetics impacts The power line has been designed to traverse along paddy lands to minimize the impacts on built up lands. However, the countryside scenery has been affected somewhat. The form, color, or texture of a line can be modified to minimize aesthetic impacts. The color and construction material of towers can be chosen to blend with or complement the landscape around them. Stronger conductors can minimize line sag. Page 64 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Right of Way (ROW) management can mitigate aesthetic impacts by creating curved or wavy ROW boundaries, pruning trees to create a feathered effect, and screening and piling brush from the cleared ROW so that it provides wildlife habitat. In the end, aesthetics are to great extent based on individual perceptions. Siting, design, construction, and ROW management can mitigate some of the adverse aesthetic effects of a line. It is needed to discuss these measures early in the planning and design process. Page 65 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 6. Monitoring program The Monitoring Plan outlines a systematic, continuous and technical way of monitoring the environmental impacts. It also includes a description of the mitigation measures, monitoring parameters, frequency, responsible institutions and key persons and facilities available to such agencies. Any development efforts will incur some negative impact on the environment. However, every effort has been taken on the proposed project to minimize the negative impacts. Continuous monitoring of project activities will help to keep track on smooth implementation of mitigation measures suggested. The project will be managed by a Project Manager, who will be a Senior Engineer. CEB, through the Project Manager and supporting staff, will bear full responsibility for ensuring that the Project complies with best environmental practices and meeting the mitigation and monitoring requirements described in this IEE report during construction. The IEER would be made available to the Project Manager and his staff, and the CEB is responsible for implementing appropriate mitigation measures mentioned in the IEER. The Monitoring Team headed by PAA would consist of representatives of important stakeholders (Departments of Forest, Wildlife, Irrigation etc). The PAA will conduct reviews and audits to monitor the project during implementation, to examine compliance with the conditions stipulated in the approval issued. The Environmental Unit of CEB will coordinate all environment-related issues and activities, and the CEB will provide it the necessary manpower and financial resources for the same. The direct responsibility of implementing, Provisions in this IEE report, The conditions stipulated by the CEA in the approval for the project in terms of the National Environmental Act. Orders issued by the DS with regard to land-use and compensation, and the local authority regulations will lie with the Project Manager, while the Environmental Unit will provide assistance and play a coordinating role in the process. Page 66 Table 6.1 Monitoring Plan Project activity Pre-construction Selection of transmission line corridor Potential impact Traversing through protected areas, Traversing above houses/ buildings. Excessive requirements for clearance of wayleaves Land use restrictions in areas of high population density Construction Clearance of 30m line corridor Loss of land use Loss of vegetation Proposed mitigation measure Parameter to be monitored Measurement and frequency Avoid traversing above protected and densely populated areas Protected areas in the vicinity Avoid/ minimize traversing above houses/ buildings wherever practicable Examine alternative routes, and select the route causing the minimum impacts on long-term land-use, and minimum possible removal of trees Number of buildings along the line route, urban and suburban centers of population crossed by the line, proportion of line route through such areas Payment of appropriate compensation for trees and crop damage % people who received appropriate compensation Site clearance and access to tower footings Temporary obstruction of access roads, waterways, clearance of trees and shrubs Culverts to be used to cross waterways, minimize disturbance and clearing of vegetation Hindrance to regular social activities, use of rights of way, hindrance to waterways Construction of access roads, construction of tower foundations Air and water pollution, soil erosion from exposure and stockpiling excavated material Resort to the best practice guidelines provided in the Chapter 5 Particulate Matter in the air, Suspended solids in the waters, No of access roads constructed, Status of stockpiling of excavated soil. Stick to specific remedial measures mentioned under annex 6.2 (NBRO report) for foundations located in hilly terrain. Cover the areas exposed during construction with ground The progress of the effort to vegetate the exposed areas with ground vegetation Institutional responsibility Implementat ion schedule During preliminary route selection, reviewed during field visits and in final line design survey, further reviewed after the notices are issued and DS’s rulings CEB Before route finalized Along the especially homegardens Monthly CEB During the process of wayleave clearance CEB Construction period CEB Construction period and when the Contractor leaves one location line - Regularly throughout the construction period, inspection after the completion when the contractor leaves the site Regularly during the site visits; the air and water quality should be measured at monthly intervals line is PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Project activity Potential impact Proposed mitigation measure Parameter to be monitored Measurement and frequency Institutional responsibility Implementat ion schedule vegetation Re use of excavated material as much as possible, Tower foundation and stringing works in farmlands/ paddy fields Loss of agricultural productivity Earthworks in new GSS site resulting in uncontrolled erosion/silt runoff Soil loss, downstream siltation at sites adjoining GSs and also tower footings Dust in the construction areas Handling of construction materials and transportation of materials to and from the site Mechanized construction Equipment layout and installation Use soil conservation practices ie berms, dykes, coir mats, sand bags Avoid cultivation &harvesting periods of paddy fields/ farmlands wherever predictable, Payment of compensation for any losses incurred Staged compacting of filling at Kegalle GSs, covered gravel stockpile and loose material, Cover the exposed areas with vegetation in the long term Damp the worksites with water Apply speed limits to the vehicles, use tarpaulin to cover the material during transport Noise, vibration and operator safety Noise and vibrations caused during construction activities Construction equipment to be well maintained, and operated to minimize the noise & vibrations. Operation of heavy machinery in night hours to be limited to very urgent cases only. Construction techniques and machinery selection seeking to minimize ground disturbance Land area of active agriculture lost at each tower footings and along the transmission corridor Monthly report of the status CEB Construction period Visual observation of runoff and siltation of storm water drains, Suspended solids & oil in the water Monthly report of the status CEB Construction period The number of uncovered vehicles bring material and their speed of travel Roads leading to the construction sites weekly CEB Construction period Construction equipment status, hours of operation, noise and vibration, maintenance Observations during site visits, as frequently as required CEB Construction period Selection of the machinery by the Contractor Construction techniques and machinery creating CEB Construction period Page 68 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Project activity Temporary blockage, loss of service of utilities Nuisance to nearby properties Potential impact Loss of power supply to local areas, when distribution lines crossing the new transmission line are switched off Losses to neighbouring land uses/ values from disposal of waste Proposed mitigation measure Parameter to be monitored Measurement and frequency The noise levels and condition of the said machineries - according to the land use conditions on and around the line route have to be more specific about the noise and vibration levels during the day time and night time (if applicable) Total hours of power shutdown minimal ground disturbance, before commencement of site work Contract specifying careful construction practices. Contract Appropriate contact clauses to ensure satisfactory implementation of contractual environmental mitigation measures. Compliance report related to environmental aspects for the contract Grid Substation transformers located within secure and impervious sump areas with a storage capacity of at least 100% of the capacity of oil in transformers and associated reserve tanks Transformer oil sump checked through physical measurement of volume and visual inspection Minimize the duration of line shutdown by careful programming of work Institutional responsibility Implementat ion schedule Monitored regularly during the period of stringing the conductors. CEB Construction period Incorporating good construction management practices, regularly during construction Submission of duly completed compliance report for each contract – once CEB Construction period Oil sump volume and permeability, Every year after completion CEB During operations Operation and Maintenance Transformer spillage Oil Contamination of land/nearby water bodies Test the content waters for oil Page 69 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE Project activity Electric Shock Hazards Potential impact Injury/mortality staff and public to Proposed mitigation measure Parameter to be monitored Measurement and frequency Careful design using appropriate technologies to minimise hazards Usage of appropriate technologies (number of injury incidents, lost work days) The length of the transmission line which is clear of any obstructions Maintenance of fences Preparedness level for using these technologies in crisis – once a year Every 6 months Regular inspection of the transmission line to clear any vegetation /obstructions Security fences around Grid Substations Appropriate warning signs on facilities Electricity safety awareness raising in project areas Maintenance of warning signs Training/awareness programs for all concerned parties Inadequate periodic environmental monitoring Diminished ecological and social values Staff to receive training in environmental monitoring of project operations and maintenance activities Training/awareness programs for all relevant staff Excessive noise in GSS Nuisance neighbouring properties Grid Substations sited and designed to ensure noise will not be a nuisance Noise levels (dB ) to Institutional responsibility Implementat ion schedule CEB Included in design and monitored throughout operation CEB Throughout operation Report on maintenance – Every 6 months Number of programs and percent of total persons covered – once in 3 year Number of programs and percent of staff covered – once a year Noise levels at boundary nearest to properties in case of complaints from public CEB Page 70 7. Conclusion and recommendation 7.1 Evaluation of Alternatives During the initial route selection, it was observed that the land use between two terminal points mainly consists of plantations (mostly rubber and few coconut trees etc.), home gardens and few paddy corridors. Also, a forest reserve area (Thulhirikanda FR) is located between two terminal points. Therefore, the alternative routes were considered giving due consideration to avoid traversing above said forest reserve, houses/buildings, small plots of lands, home gardens and plantations, and also efforts were given to locate the line route through the paddy corridors wherever available. In the initial stage, a number of alternative line routes have been proposed based on 1:50,000 topographical maps and Google Earth Satellite images which were studied / inspected during preliminary site visits. Among those, three options including the proposed route have been selected as more attractive compared to other, the line routes of which are shown in annex 5.2. These alternative routes have been further studied by relevant officers of CEB, and were compared with emphasis to environmental impacts, land use and social concerns and evaluation analysis is given in Table 7.1 below. The cost of each alternative is also estimated considering the total length, no. of angle points and terrain conditions (flat, hilly, marshy…etc), and included in the comparison. Table 7.1 Evaluation of alternatives SN Description 1. Route Particulars i) Total Line Length Option 1 Proposed Route On Map Option2 Proposed Route On Map Option 3 Proposed Route On Map 21.5 km 21.6 km 22.5 km Terrain Moderately hilly Mountainous Flat and Mountainous iii) Districts Kegalle Kegalle Kegalle iv) Agriculture Paddy, Rubber Paddy, Rubber Paddy, Rubber v) Wet/ Marshy land Only paddy fields Only paddy fields Only paddy fields vi) Other type of land Rock outcrops - - 24 47 32 ii) No. of Houses 2. Land Use Data % of the total length for each alternative i) Paddy 42.64 51.75 48.5 ii) Rubber 18.79 15.38 16.41 iii) Home Garden 31.3 27.2 28.8 iv) Other plantations 7.27 5.67 6.29 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE 3. Other important features i) Railway crossing ii) iii) iv) 4. 5. 6. 7. - - - Major (A ,B type )road crossing 4 4 River Crossing Tanks Construction Problems O& M Problems Estimated Construction cost Overall Remarks 1 - 4 1 Moderate minimum 860 Million LKR Least social impact, shorter in length and away from metal quarries High Moderate 843 Million LKR Higher social impact, and closer to metal quarries 2 Moderate Moderate 830 Million LKR Lengthy and closer to metal quarries Comparison of 3 alternatives revealed that all three options have avoided the forest reserve (Thulhirikanda), and have been located mostly through paddy corridors. Apparently the land use along 3 options were mostly similar, except that option 1 traverse slightly higher percentage of length through rubber and other plantations and home gardens, and somewhat lesser percentage of length through paddy, compared to other two options. However the impact of it on small plots of land is relatively less, and traversing above houses is minimal compared to other two options. Also, option 1 has lesser angle towers, causes minimum damage to settlements and situated well away from metal quarries in the area. It crosses the only river in entire route making minimum damage to riverine vegetation. It is shorter in length and involves minimum ROW problems. Although the cost of option 1 is somewhat higher compared to other two options, considering the various reasons based on information in the table, option 1 has been considered as most suitable. 7.2 Conclusion As required by National Environment Act, this project development falls under prescribed project category and scoping committee headed by CEA as PAA issued a ToR for Initial Environmental Examination. A comprehensive ecological and socio-economical survey was carried out along the line route by a group of experts from University of Sri Jayawardhanapura. Based on the environmental assessment and surveys conducted for the project, the potential adverse environmental impacts associated with the project can be mitigated to an acceptable level by adequate implementation of the mitigation measures identified in the IEER. Adequate provisions are being made in the project to cover the environmental mitigation and monitoring requirements, and their associated costs. Most of the social and ecological aspects were considered and incorporated in to the project design in early planning stage. Proposed alignment has avoided settlements and environmentally sensitive areas Page 72 PROPOSED 132kV TRANSMISSION LINE PROJECT FROM THULHIRIYA TO KEGALLE to the maximum extent and traverse mostly through paddy and rubber lands keeping the social and ecological impact to the minimum. Transmission line will require 30m wide corridor for safety reasons where trees that grow above 3m will be pruned time to time. In paddy fields where 42% of this line traverses, minimum restriction occurs to existing land use. For the trees that are removed in coconut, rubber lands and home gardens, owners will be duly compensated as per the assessment of Grama Niladhari and endorsed by Divisional Secretary, and any timber is given back for their use. There will be temporary disturbance for farming activities which will be compensated accordingly. Pollution due to construction activities such as cut and fill operations, vehicular emissions, noise, vibration and dust related issues are of scattered in nature, short term and will be diminished with time. Also such impacts can be satisfactorily managed by adaptation of careful mitigation measures. Construction of transmission line will generate local employment, as number of unskilled laborers (men/women) will be required at the time of construction activities. Local employment during this period will increase the income and socio-economic standards of the residents of the project area. Electricity consumers (Domestic, commercial and industrial) in Kegalle and surrounding areas will receive positive benefits after the implementation of this new transmission development by improve quality, reliability and voltage profile. At the same time, national electricity grid is benefited by improved efficiency and loss reduction. Given due consideration to above, it can be concluded that benefits of the project far outweigh negative impacts associated with it. Major social and environmental impacts associated with the transmission projects are limited to the construction period and can be mitigated to an acceptable level by implementation of recommended measures and by better engineering and environmental practices. CEB is committed to install, operate and maintain the transmission system in an environmentally and socially responsible manner and will be fully complied with environmental requirements defined by government regulations and guidelines. Page 73