299 EXTRATERRESTRIAL APPLICATIONS OF SOLAR OPTICS FOR INTERIOR RI,UMINATION N93-17449 David A. Eijadi and Kyle D. Williams BRW, Inc. 700 Third Street South Minneapolis MN 55415 Solar optics is a terrestrial technology that has potential extraterrestrial applications. Active solar optics (ASO) and passive solar optics (PSO) are tuo approaches to the transmission of sunh'ght to rerru)te interks_ spaces. Active solar optics is most approptgate for task illumination, while PSO is most appropriate for general illuminations. Research into solar optics, motit_ted by _ conse_c_tion, has produced lightu_ight and low-cost materials, products that bale applications to NASA's Controlled Ecological Life Support System (CELSS) program and its lunar base studies. Specifically, pr_m h'ght guides have great potential in these contexts. Several applications of solar optics to lunar base concepts are illustrated. INTRODUCTION The purpose of solar of the visible or task optic systems and powered require effectively (ASO) A sustained thereby precision diffused need smaller aarpdwer source. system collecting solar design and effectively require initially remote to develop the developed interiors research beamed • . criteria design the need beamed will Active light only systems and beamed and The sunlight impetus quantity basic sizing lighting and and directionality types of PSO low-cost S}_tem materials those (CELSS) of strategies (E/jad,) of the available that reduces in comparison an aperture 1983). based on to con- The system the desired sunlighL There systems (Fig. 1) [. t _- refractive are two have throughout included possible, focal areas the development paid to alternatives with INTERIOR LENS _N_ program energy the and development conservation, nonimaging within the use for heliostat controls, control lessons learned transferable. \ \ ..j_L_....7 . \ _,r] -. [ enclosures. particular attention systems, and strategies artificial that reduce the volume of optical material required to transtx)rt light. Terrestrial and extraterrestrial criteria will no doubt be different; are directly "%-. II of hazards, ease for selective optics protective of ASO systems, integrated of the "X_\ II II II considerations of "-_'///"_ _ ][ of or applications control area \/N. that When imaging optics are used, the possibility is eliminated through the use of selective filters many of fenestration systems: _ NASA's PSO designs. conflagration however, OPTICS to lighted designing I f in .sources enables size and are used light natural into Wherever has been ventional EXTERIOR LENS for this conservation, parallel Life Support . transmissivity. Throughout is a form of aperture MULTIPLIER LENS technologies _. that do not produce life or safety weatherability, and optical coatings containment PSO system the ratio o,ar opt,c ,ec o,o es for energy requirements) PSO and ASO systems of lens designs of construction, and light. control buildings. (lightweight volumeric Controlled Ecological lunar base appli_:ations. Critical build sunlighting for concentrating of Earth-sheltered and development, appfied minimize (PSO) The SOLAR \ effort began in,9 8 Uu.n the "ene, were on optics as beamed deliver but use of general dependence Passive as well areas is to enable as a source reduce to light systems design .spectrum illumination. less deliver optics (SO) of the solar illumination electrically solar portion PASSIVE in developing DETAIL OF "MULTIPLIER LENS" terrestrial Fig. 1. Refractive PSO system and 300 2nd Conference on Lunar Bases and Space Aclivities Fresnel lenses of the COLLECTOR collector in a uniform array system is turned is diffused of efficiency, light the and a mathematical efficiency (E_ad,; diffusion, and The absorption at ratio model 1983). the were the acrylic Passive solar optics require system. determination and the distance is aimed of the is a function at of repose of the latitude from the system a low the For overall scattering, to through for each system the the arrays. electrical to the target. horizon. light a separate angles An reaching contribute backup arrays area. to estimate dirt, as light is reflected The target used of of illumination the cff the resulting of illumination depreciation systems direction, a horizontal ,surface, can be design purposes. Empirical effects in 90 ° to that in each the target to the total available on assumed to be 10% for preliminary testing }, light distribution approximate '.._',,........--- REFLECTOR reflector array so that lighting section of is designed The topmost Earth-based systems, for panel each successively "abutting collector panel is aimed higher until all the useful or desired annual solar horizons are within one or more regions of the array. The to redirect Active in that Fig. 2. solar they systems (Fig. 2). Each system terrestrial applications; however, to extraterrestrial applications. undesired radiation components selective to radiation the heliostat and and needs similar in terms protecting proposed is worth of the exterior shield with interior PASSIVE PSO system Fresnel multiplier lens; one focal consists of three lens; and exterior apart generally result can system the multiplier, lenses in an axial The cone of vision approximately refractive mechanically of an ASO system transport and (4)a (3)artificial distribution system RADIATION SOLAR Z)STAT of view but The PSO exhibits at an angle GUIDE and expense 12.5% and 6.25%, system be installed length REDIRECTING MIRRORS of 32 °. The at the of view on one or both MIRRORS are spaced of depend- INTERMEDIATE NETWORK axes, respect- some chromatic to the ground PASSIVE installations elements: (3)reflector sunlight reflector of the SOLAR reflective ( I ) collector OPTIC equal PSO array; (2) system array. The collector array the clerestory window opposes the collector consist clerestory through faces the to the array and DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM SYSTEM of window; sun and reflector redirects the to the desired target area. Sunlight is diffused approx10 ° when reflected from either array. The pattern of the Fig. 3. are ( 1 ) the networks; of the site for best performance. REFLECTIVE array. The cone the cone It should to the latitude sunlight imately the efficiency, aberrations. reflects PSO ,systems that (3)pris- arrangement. the limitations in a .solid angle double ing on increasing and controls; elements: and of focal major from MIRROR Without Current with SYSTEM major Fresnei interior length OPTIC azimuth. three a heliostat, components 000 lens in order to axes altitude and ively. The four (2)intermediate (Oleson lens is placed ahead of the exterior the cone of vision in one or both total are distinguished a multiplier increase multiplier OPTICS for protecting consideration SOLAR (2)exterior lens. The approximately f-stop heliostat; sources process applies of filtering A meteorite to that systems a component, area. 1986). A refractive matic physically of the CELSS module Olson, is described the same design Consideration addressed. coating REFRACTIVE (1) of be SOLAR array are designed to the target tracks the solar disk. It is also possible to physically integrate the electrical backup illumination system within the sunlight distribu- Reflectb,,e PSO system. tion network. reflective optics have of the reflector the collector ACTIVE MINIMUM TARGET WIDTH _TARGET FLOOR angles the light from Active solar optic system. light (Fig. 3). Eijadi and Simply put, reflectors network. tally the heliostat or ve,*,ically to occupied space. Various materials et al., 1987). cables, and tracks that beam the The intermediate the delivery were prism device, a series which of materials included holographic pipes, (PLG). Distribution guides illuminates for use in the system network pipes, light sun and positions investigated Intermediate reflective the sunlight into the intermediate transport network transports the light horizon- is evaluated reflectors, evaluated specular reflectors, on the basis of interior performance, and of integration or cost, constructibility, best with the least practices. intermediate amount ease networks of physical were material pipes worked nearly as well. with the preferred choice for the sources should be high-intensity as close to the distribution for that resource unnecessary distribution discharge device prior to absorption and maintenance. A proof-of-principle model at the University building. of Sunlight alternately and introduced distributions with was light into nearly Civil from identical halide fire should materials used. common horizontal practice. Among those are heliostats, distribution networks, and fixtures capable electric systems for have light. been A conceptual are reduced of this paper relates transportation The light to the work use guides on ASO of both are hollow tubes more stable resist higher made at varying weighs formed than the made temperatures, thicknesses using the principle The film used thick walls polycarbonate, 248°F but about 0.13 lb/ft (0.064 into nearly microscopic similar study plant prompted typically the presented guides either for the light. an optical 190°E polycarbonate Each is 0.022" film (0.56 can can ram) be and kg/m). The surface of the film is prismatic facets that transmit light in the ASO system. It is approximately 0.022" (0.56 mm) and comes in widths up to 24" (61 cm). The of the film are formed into grooves so that sunlight is reflected with backing is added a diffusion to the film. with other synthetic any OPTICS of approximately TO FREEDOM clearly identified solar with electric other using source. fiber optic Fresnel power, behavior investigation of fiber cables cables hybrid lenses used concentrates during the light on 2712 The fluorescent 10%. An aluminum 30 minutes of darkness in the fluorescent lamps spaced other will have because transmit each a shorter of mutual by system light of an HID with the attributable evaluated HID/fiber advantages life span in the system. optic cables light source and HID/fiber lamp optic were than HID more difficult lamps cannot Each study of these utilized technology; would, optic because optic (3)HID in turn, (1)the cables lamps maintenance, when these costs work require the greatest of additional system was efficiency and and design represented HID would be transHID light source that fiber system, to the development of better and The hazard; technology, a_.d significant losses of efficiency at the interface of the two; (2)higher costs an unknown cooling, system is a health interference. considered via fiber and (4) this configuration systems The orbit. would provide lighting would optic lamps during lamps with the cables coming from the heliostat. about the HID/fiber optic system include integration directly HID light manageable. hybrid be integrated Concerns associated a that transmit lamp replacement will be HID lamp; and (4) fluorescent was deemed unknown assumed using and the is utilized fluorescent lights and fiber optic cables. Solar illumination mitted to the plants as before, but a remote would one glass fibers adjacent to the plant trays, to the plants and the solar ( l ) mercury closely mass. cycles lamps a remote provide 7500 fc (80,700 lux). Concerns in using the fluorescent/fiber the and systems, with to grow illumination fluorescent integrated to cost, short and need 1986). In fact, based on a volume, with of two optic the illumination system using fluorescent lamps was identified as the In this system, a heliostat with an array of 2712 fluorescent lamps, 750fc (8070 lux) in film. The films are called 3M. The acrylic film is the of growth lamps; (3)fluorescent than with a remote of total internal reflection (Saxe et al., 1986). in the PSO system is an optical-grade acrylic to that used outgassing are in the and artificial with but vs. study lighting combination concerns light of the with OF SOLAR design Unknown be sunlight grade polycarbonate or acrylic polymer "Scotchlamp Film" by their manufacturer, than degradation to USED systems of the prism and distribution greater the associated light to the plant-growth units. Solar illumination the 60 minutes of available sunlight, and the selective offered PROPERTIES OF MATERIALS FOR SOLAR OPTICS of the no artifidal supplement (2) aspect be base, Hazards SPACE STATION identified: unique or a lunar in vertical and of delivering A variety heliostats system is presently marketplace. The station APPLICATIONS The hybrid best choice. were identical A complete Canada. of ASO and/or heliostat source by Whitehead systems to with Engineering PLG and produced in Toronto, components control the Mineral operation Several and space not be a problem. parametric the energy using of is feasible. such as the were downward associated and sunlight of the device and in in LEO. No a rethinking distribution fabricated, coatings with The designed, beamed conjunction plants in the CELSS module (Oleson and Olson, an all-solar illumination system was preferred, efficiencies. installed in to any a metal the same guides because constructed Minnesota's oxygen be subjected (light fixture) should be linear and oriented maximize distribution and minimize room losses to the com- the films degrade monatomic not as possible utilization. design, exposed personal into device. Artificial light (HID) sources located is paid for and should losses light with 301 decidedly incorporated Prism the current impact needed films should their design. They should be dedicated, airtight passageways that are as short as possible. Depending on precise distances, PLG and reflective With of or similar films (A. Zderad, optics manufacturing process to determine if direct exposure If the films are used in a controlled environment included fiber optic cables, diffusing and PLG. Each component was conventional construction It was concluded that 1988). presence films lens guides, devices the of solar testing has been performed in deep ,space. A further investigation of the thermal and ionic space environment in relation to these (E/jadi fiber optic solid-angle Applications Testing has been performed on low-Earth-orbit (lEO) environment munication, the Williams: is an were were are required preheating; mass of all the fiber optic cable required. identified as having the safety, accessibility, compared to the centralized fluorescent 302 2nd While solar Conference two artificial transmission guides rather than fiber to improve the cost and utilize source. The are technology, so a reduction transmit to eliminate cables physical PLG is a (C. Wheelwright, to utilize ASO of HID lamps and fiber for will of light reduce with less optic could module; concentrate and (4) The the system rays station space air plenum, fluorescent mass for the light the opportunity the heliostat to a porthole incorporating the Domvtn, exists on PLG can filter UV and IR radiation in a similar fashion as fiber important when plant growth is concerned (Saxe the harmful optics, which et al., 1986). down is similar is OF SOLAR TO THE The initial advantage conservation SO on of of available the outposts Moon for wavelengths, interior heliostat thereby ASO for scheme First, many with solar The disadvantages and, of using second, harmful concepts SO from the may be mitigated night lunar are, loss to be excessive lunar this fact we operations. energy is desirable made the wherever first, equatorial plane for continuous latitudes, there nights. is only In either location, axis enables on tracking the horizontal day than rather the could then pipe illumination. spectrum for simple: The need for housing (H6rz, to provide in general and ASO is used to provide with it. an operational 1985). applications access during of solar luminance has not been that base from Fig. 4. the This office buildings. illumination habitat use is located, lighting. Lun_ outpost using ASO. of solar either as at the lunar of the Moon. SOLAR RADIATION _.... • PSO WITH COATING •" SELECTIVE \ __.A;O_ 1V2° to the availability two-week the design from of the movement there systems. emphasis The movement be simplified small to be placed of the sun during seasonal is a (Burke, 1985). At days and two-week PSO and ASO systems Earth-based the PSO design vertical, ecliptic, the on by tracking lunar the ,sun and speculated on schematic diagrams illustrated lunar the .. - .... .-.. We have taken several lunar base schemes how PSO and ASO might be apl_iied. The represent ,A. MoouEs_ Earth. stages of development .. . . , Fig. 5. . -.-. . . . • • . . . . Operational / .... .. . . - . base using ASO and PSO. or ,scheme determined. the light As the base solar Iack the This concept for the CELSS module. in Fig. 5 shows is used is to integrate the ASO ,system can grow a lava tube for (Walter, optics proves lunar sunlight will be Similarly, the ASO design can on one axis rather than two. here concept outpost light diffuser. Removing the could be lined with PLG. A interior terrestrial optics concepts environradiation if dust assumption inclined will be modified tilt of the lunar One an evaluation use of SO would be if a polar location were site for hmar habitation. Because the Moon's possibility the lower on the Moon Solar visible a primary source of power and interior illumination poles, or as a secondary source at the lower latitudes The most promising selected as the initial interesting an HID lamp, modules, current such lighting lunar is very the if a_-ailable the with to provide inside shows natural in efficiency Earth can be utilized (Ehn'cke, 1985). The location of the first lunar site Given for or radiation. the desired the potential space station habitat and of all-artificial sources is the sunlight to these shielded can filter out undesired transmitting for any of using regolith illumination. Third, the technology is the only mechanical device used. access outpost advantages areas from 1987). shown base Passive diagrams OPTICS the Longer-range threefold. to transmit SO systems Assoc., more to The modified BASE habitable protection provides a way menus. Second, using space. are encapsulate formations LUNAR the use several to the one proposed the lava tube THE APPLICATION for the A preliminary identified plenum similar 1985). can be easily fluorescent lamp, and lamp, the plenum space incorporates advanced et al., but Figure4 1985). supplemented the The (Duke outposts. Nixon, Teague heliostat, and lunar and preliminary between sun's first substituting CELSS module if the heliostat is mounted on the space station structure for better solar access, and a lens with the proper focal length the studies location personal communication, 1988). An opportunity exists, however, if the habitat modules are used (Kaplicky that the There anticipated; as the reveal connection be pole lighting strategies modules favor and can for this Current laboratory guides volumes of 50; (3) HID HID light in previous assume a lunar latitude. light costs same hybrid identified lamps of HID amount the by a factor the prism one light opportunities of a remote calculations PLG for the fiber optic device using only of prism of the advantages same assuming use characteristics the integration the evaluated, The of development order-of-magnitude transfer were may offer some integration unlike so that design, cables to consider optics, and Space Activities evaluated. mass (1)The known PLG can optic and Bases systems was the inherent reasons application material, lighting system system (2) on Lunar - . within is Eijadi The scheme scale of As the with lunar gives is SO Fig. 6 as is for is limited grows, diagram shows a sense used in systems community it. The and shown the of the PSO orientation both by the illumination being to building-specific transmitted a serf-sufficient only used the colony. and The volumc scheme as general can grow with solar light _ \ SOLAR RADIATION • being _ _ r- HELIOSTAT ARRAY TO | PIPE SUNLIGHT THROUGH ] UTILITY SHAFT | _ _ J. (1985) Space and base, Ehricke K. Eijadi D (1983) Conference PSO -__-_--v on Self-sufficient Department HOrz E (1985) using ASO and PSO. colony as and Space 412. Lunar Kaplicky J. ActitSties SO systems needed for is most most filter been lunar module base. in this paper to deliver human appropriate appropriate harmful technologies CELSS described proven various for and be for the activities general for general radiation. should Energy the (T Nixon system to and known on and Earth. task various for use with Active development Both that the of technologies quality illumination, illumination only. It is concluded considered the are quantity solar and of light Oleson optics PSO is systems can these same space phases station of the the 21st Planetary M Report of and 177421, prism Dot'wtn, Study prepared optic pp. 600-603. Bennett D. (1987) Using for habitats. Multi-Axis U.S. In Lunar ed.), Bases pp, 405- Houston. SUlX-rstructure ma_s-shiclding In Lunar Mendell, Baaes ed.), P,. L. (1986) Controlled C_tion L., and light ed.), (W. W, Mendell, Conceptua/Design NASA Ames S., Whitehead solar International A surface-assembled base. (W.W. building De-AC02-83ER-80047, regolith for and an Space pp. 375-380. guides. Research Cobb Center, S. (1986) Proceeck'ngs of Ecological Study. initial- Acti*¢ties Lunar and the Life Support NASA Contractor Moffett Progress Field. in the &_ciety of 144 pp, development Phot¢_Otical Engineers. Teague Assoc. for Boeing (1987) Aerospace Space Station Co. 33 pp. a Planetary Houston. Olson (CELSS): Illuminating Walter, Century Institute, Systems Saxe lunar of of the 2Ist and Miami M., and shelters (1985) support Houston. Actim'ties L_mations Century Institute, D. Century Institute, N. Beziroglu, Contract a permanent the 21st Lunar Sixth Interior of the 21st and Planetary Bases pp. 77- settlement--birth Space Engineering at Source. operational.capability have Mineral of Energy. 125 pp. Lava tubes: Potential and envelope CONCLUSION The and pp. 827-855. in Remote Light ed.), for of Planetary and Bases Presented DiMribution Suntracker that Lunar and ed.), Alternate In Lunar Strategies Actit$ties industrialization Civil Papers Space Clean Energy Research Institute, Miami. Eijadi D., Probst D., Shadid W., De Los Rios Sunlight Fig. 6. The In B. (1985) and In Lunar (W.W. Mendell, Houston. location. (W. W. MendeR, Houston. Roberts Lunar base Century pp. 57-68. civilization. systems. polar 21st Bases ed.), (1985) Century Institute, I LUNAR COLONY "_ a lunar Institute, W., and In Lunar polyglobal ]/r of of the Planetary (W. _b_ Mendell, l r_-_-_._j I_ Merits Actitqties M., Mended lunar c_T_ _____.__] /_;_. • 303 optics REFERENCES Duke l | II'_ \ °°°°_ ,---7 i J| solar vertically. 84. Lunar PSO of optics and PLATFORM Applications To determine the feasibility of applying SO to extraterrestrial applications, and in particular lunar bases, further investigation as to the effect of the thermal and ionic environment and of lunar Burke RESEARCH Williams: dust on the SO sTstem must be undertaken. illumination Active illumination, horizontally colony. available and Lighting E,_dlu, tton.