NOVEMBER 2012 The Official Membership Publication of The International Comanche Society VOLUME 39, NO. 11 PA referred irparts Chosen for value and service NEW SALES HOURS 7:15am to 8:00pm EST. Call or check online for details! New Surplus Parts for all Pipers PA-18 through Cheyenne • Airframe Parts • Accessories, bellcranks • Bushings, cowling • Cables, gears, spars • OHC Rotables • Propellers .com/props.htm • and a whole lot more! Discounts from 25% to 85% off list price FREE online parts search www.preferredairparts.com Due to the size and diversity of our inventory, we need P/N’s from you. Items to help complete your order: Champion Oil Filters Donaldson Air Filters AN, MS, NAS Hardware Preferred Airparts, LLC Division of JILCO Industries Inc. 11234 Hackett Rd, PO Box 12 Kidron, Ohio 44636 USA 800-433-0814 Toll free US and Canada 330-698-0280 PH 330-698-3164 FAX sales2@preferredairparts.com We Buy inventories of parts for nearly anything, also tired or damaged Cessna twins, Caravans, Citations, engines and propellers. The Comanche Flyer is the official monthly member publication of the International Comanche Society P.O. Box 1810 Traverse City, MI 49685-1810 U.S.: (888) 300-0082 Other: (231) 946-3712 Fax: (231) 946-6180 E-mail: ICS@villagepress.com www.comancheflyer.com Volume 39, No. 11 • November 2012 www.comancheflyer.com Published By the International Comanche Society, Inc. ICS President Zach Grant Cell: (317) 201-4293 E-mail: L1011jock@sbcglobal.net (e-mail preferred contact) Managing Editor Kim Blonigen E-mail: kblonigen@cox.net Display Advertising Manager John Roddy (800) 773-7798 Fax: (231) 946-9588 E-mail: jroddy@villagepress.com Trading Post & Classified Advertising Nancy A. Whitten Ph: (800) 773-7798, Fax: (231) 946-9588 E-mail: nancy@villagepress.com Graphic Design Brandon Hoffman E-mail: bhoffman@villagepress.com Printer Village Press 2779 Aero Park Drive Traverse City, MI 49685-0629 www.villagepress.com Maintenance Resource Advisors Dave Clark Ph: (817) 860-4393 Email: dave5201@att.net Zack Grant Cell: (317) 201-4293 Email: L1011jick@sbcglobal.net(Email preferred contact) Karl Hipp Ph: (970) 963-3755 Email: khipp@99victor.com Lucky Lougue Ph: (903) 345-9198 Email: lucky@asod.com ICS Tool Loan Program Matt Kurke 8192 Sanctuary Drive, Unit 1 Naples, FL 34104 Ph: (239) 593-6944 mkurke@comanchegear.com The Comanche Flyer (ISSN 08994223, USPS 2-324) is available to members; the $25 annual subscription rate is included in the Society’s Annual Membership dues in US funds below. Comanche Flyer is published monthly by Village Press U.S., Canada, Mexico One year $69, Two years $130 UK, Europe One year $95, Two years $182 Australia, SA, and all other countries One year $83, Two years $158 Spousal Members One year $34.50, Two years $65.00 Cover Photo Jon Hankins’ Comanche 180 (N5390P), “Speedbird,” taking off from Lake Havasu City, Ariz. for the first leg of the Air Race Classic. Copyright Notice The act of making a submission for publication is an express warranty that such contribution does not infringe on the rights or copyright of others. Nothing appearing in the Comanche Flyer shall be reproduced or distributed without the express permission of the publisher. Postmaster Send address changes to the above address. Periodical postage paid at Traverse City, MI 49686 NOVEMBER 2012 CONTENTS 2 Letter from the President Zach Grant Comanche Spirit 4 The Adventures of “Speedbird” 6 ICS Name Badge Order Form Shannon Hankins Feature 9 Comanche Flyer Needs your Stories, Tips and Tricks! 10 ICS Board of Directors, Tribe Chiefs, & Tribe Representatives 2011-2012 ICS Standing Committees 11 Maintenance Resource Advisors ICS Tool Loan Program CFF-Trained CFIs ICS News 12 ICS 2012 Annual General Membership Meeting Wright Brothers’ Master Pilot Award Feature 14 Stabilator Horn Issue Online Intelligence 16 Single Winterization Technical Q & A 18 Piper and Lycoming Service Bulletin Source and a Non-Starting Engine Dave Clark Convention News 20 North To Alaska – ICS 40th Anniversary It’s a Party and You’re Invited! Feature 28 2012 Baltimore Convention in Review 31 ICS Membership Renewal Form 32 ICS Items for Sale From the Logbook 34 An African Adventure: Flying a Twin Comanche around Africa (Part 3) Pete Morse Robert Limb 40 From the Tribe Chiefs Featured Fly-In 44 Visiting Historic Vicksburg, Miss. 46 Comanche Classifieds 48 Advertisers’ Index Hugh Hunton INTERNATIONAL COMANCHE SOCIETY, INC. Comanche Flyer • 1 LETTER FROM THE PRESIDENT B y the time you read this, the ICS Fall Board Meeting would have come and gone. This fall, we are going to be tackling some big issues. Chief among those is how do we, as your elected officers and board members, ensure the continued success of the ICS. When looking at some things that have been historically ICS: We have always had some version of the “Flyer,” and we have continually been made up of tribes, who have been responsible for the execution of the annual convention that encompasses the mandated Annual General Meeting. While I spent a significant amount of time justifying the Flyer at the convention in Baltimore, I did not have to justify the convention itself. If I would have been asked to do so, I would have had great difficulty. The folks that come to the annual conventions always have a good time as far as I can tell. The same folks come back year after year, and that’s great… BUT…less come back every year, and the numbers are reaching the point of not supporting the effort. For the second year in a row (almost the third, if it were not for some very good fortune on behalf of the Southwest Tribe), the convention has sustained pretty substantial losses that can only be attributed to lack of interest in attending. Granted, there are so many other things that we could do with our week than come spend a lot of money and time with fellow Comanche owners and pilots. Certainly from the membership numbers NOT attending, it would seem the majority would rather do other things. This begs the question: Why do we put so much effort into something if it is a guaranteed failure? Surely, it is not fair to the tribes and all of the volunteers, and it certainly isn’t fair to the rest of ICS who have to foot the bill for the society’s share of the losses. Like it or not, we are all paying for the conventions when they end up in the red. The simple answer would be that we all need to come to the convention and make it a solid financial success. The fact is the same people will probably show up, because they have the time and the money. Comanche Flyer Submission Guidelines All members are encouraged to submit articles for publication in the Comanche Flyer. If you have an article about a maintenance event, trip, piloting technique, or anything else pertinent to Comanche ownership, please share it with your fellow members. For those with access to the Internet, please submit the article via e-mail, preferably in Microsoft Word. You may also include the article in the body of your e-mail message. Include your full name, as you would like it published, and your ICS number. Please attach digital pictures, if applicable, in jpeg format. For best results, use the highest resolution setting your camera will allow. Photo files under 500 kb in size typically do not reproduce well. Although submissions are reviewed for technical accuracy, the information in this magazine is meant for reference only. Any modifications, alterations, or major repairs to U.S. aircraft require FAA-approved data as a basis for beginning work, and as such should not be based solely on information contained in this magazine. The International Comanche Society does not endorse any piloting adverse to published FAA regulations. Submissions are subject to editing and revision unless specifically requested to be published as submitted. The right is reserved to publish or not, any submission. Deadline for all submissions is the 20th of the month, approximately 40 days prior to month of publication. Send to: Kim Blonigen, Managing Editor at kblonigen@cox.net Articles and photos may also be sent via U.S. Mail to: Kim Blonigen • 2031 South Beech • Wichita, KS 67207 2 • Comanche Flyer NOVEMBER 2012 The rest of the society needs a real reason to attend the convention. In recent years, the Dayton convention was the most attended and made the most money. It had some very cool aviation-themed events, and we greatly benefited from the aviation heritage of Dayton. Put another way, people wanted to come because it had a serious draw. How do we duplicate that success? Well, each convention is unique, and I would hope that we would never be duplicating anything. I do hope that as we go forward, we come up with a new plan and tradition that more closely realizes today’s societal needs and wants and that we can transform the ICS convention from limited and unviable to exciting and prosperous. I hope we can keep the traditions I mentioned alive for as long as possible. Maybe there is an idea out there that we haven’t thought of. If you have one, send it to me, and we will take a look. Remember, just because you come up with the idea, doesn’t mean you will be stuck doing the legwork, but if you really want to, I’m sure no one at ICS will complain! Happy Flying, F o r o v e r 3 7 y e a r s , t h e I n d u s t r y Ch oice! adlog THE ™ MAINTENANCE RECORD-KEEPING SYSTEM FOR VIRTUALLY ALL GENERAL AVIATION FIXED & ROTARY WING AIRCRAFT plus EXPERIMENTAL and HOMEBUILTS 14/15 color coded sections, simplify, organize and centralize all data. Provides lightning-fast retrieval of all maintenance ADs, service bulletins and inspection requirements for your aircraft. Includes AD search, text of applicable ADs, and 1 year AD revision service. Keeps you on top of all required repetitive activity- annuals, 100 hour inspections, transponder/altimeter checks, VOR checks, etc. ORGANIZED FOR LOGICAL, STRAIGHTFORWARD UPKEEP. Because adlog saves your maintenance facility valuable time, you save valuable money. E-Mail: info@adlog.com 1-800-235-6444 FAX: 1-631-765-9359 AEROTECH PUBLICATIONS, INC. P.O. Box 1359, Southold, NY www.adlog.com Zach Grant ICS Past Presidents 2009-2010 Bernie Mazurek 1996 Bryce Campbell 1984 Jerry Irvin 2007-2008 Dave Fitzgerald 1995 Jess Bootman 1983 Bill Stanyer 2006 Lawrence Paratz 1994 Chuck Medicus 1982 Norn Berneche 2005 Karl Hipp 1993 Dale Vandever 1981 Ben Kitchens 2004 Skip Dykema 1992 Bill Jackson 1980 Jack Holaway 2003 John Van Bladeren 1991 Martin Busch 1979 Larry Larkin 2002 Larry Rackley 1990 George Burson 1978 Clifford Younger 2001 Robert Noble 1989 William Creech 1977 Art Shriver 2000 David Buttle 1988 Jim Fox 1976 Mike Keedy 1999 Roy Roberts 1987 Pat Rowe 1975 George Smith 1998 Harley McGatha 1986 Ted Peifer 1974 Paul Rechnitzer 1997 Charles Wiseman 1985 Bill Shank 1973 Andy Speer NOVEMBER 2012 Comanche Flyer • 3 C O M A N C H E COVER STORY: COMANCHE SPIRIT The Adventures of “Speedbird” by Shannon Hankins I t’s 8:00 a.m. on June 19, 2012. Temperatures were hitting 100-plus degrees, and it was race day! Last June, I had the privilege of racing in my first Air Race Classic. My co-pilot, Pam Rudolph, and I raced in my husband’s beloved 1959 Comanche 180. We took off from Lake Havasu City, Ariz. on the adventure of a lifetime. For those who don’t know, the Air Race Classic is an all-women transcontinental air race that had its first race back in 1977. Its predecessor was the All 4 • Comanche Flyer Women’s National Air Derby, nicknamed the “Powder Puff Derby,” which ran from 1929 until it was renamed in 1977. That first race had participants such as Amelia Earhart, Louise Thaden, Marvel Crossen, Bobbi Trout and Florence “Poncho” Barnes, to name a few. The race route is 2,681 statute miles, and has a different start and terminus every year. Every aircraft is handicapped with its fastest TAS, and the pilots race to beat that speed. The more knots over your handicap, the better your score. Opposite page: Jon and Shannon flying the Comanche together (above left). Race co-pilot, Pam Rudolph (below), and her supportive husband, Bill. Jon (far right) celebrating Shannon and Pam’s successful race finish. NOVEMBER 2012 Spirit NOVEMBER 2012 Comanche Flyer • 5 Pam and I have longed to participate in this historic race for many years. We share over 20 years of enthusiasm for flying. We are also very active in our local 99s Rio, Colo. chapter, which planned to host the 2012 Air Race Classic. This year with the race start being in our hometown of Lake Havasu City, we decided to make it happen. The main concern had been what airplane to fly. My husband, ICS Member Jon Hankins, an enthusiastic Comanche owner, offered the use of N5390P, and I was ecstatic! We nicknamed the Comanche “Speedbird,” and I knew she would do a great job for Pam and I in the race! A Background of the Aircraft and its Owner Jon has owned N5390P since March 10, 2006. He bought her in Medford, Ore., and flew her down to her current home in Bullhead City, Ariz. Jon is fortunate to be able to use his 180 for work, as well as being able to take more trips to Texas to visit family. Working as an IA and a maintenance supervisor for TriState CareFlight, he often needs to fly parts, other employees, or himself to take care of maintenance issues for the helicopters and King Airs he is responsible for. One year he logged over 240 hours in the airplane. We live at Sun Valley Airpark (A20) in Fort Mohave, Ariz. Jon and I met three years ago, and after a lot of flying to see each other (I live in Lake Havasu City, about a 20-minute flight from A20), we were married November 5, 2011. Jon and I are both avid aviators, and we have enjoyed flying N5390P in various flight activities with the 99s, including a local air derby where we came in fourth place. I work for my family and as a flight instructor in Lake Havasu City, and I’m able to use Speedbird, on occasion, to make the commute to work. Back to the Race Preparation for the race was somewhat arduous. Since Jon is a certified IA, he does his own maintenance on Speedbird. This year he needed to complete the 1,000-hour gear AD and replace the stabilator horn and torque tube as part of the annual. A lot of work went into the annual, and Jon made sure everything was perfect for race day. We had a long trip ahead of us starting in Lake Havasu. The course then went on to Gallup, N.M.; Hereford, Texas; Goodland, Kansas; Columbus, Neb.; Watertown, S.D.; Ashland, Wis.; Sault Ste Marie, Mich.; Benton Harbor, Mich.; and finally finishing out in Batavia, Ohio at Sporty’s Pilot Shop. I showed up to get Speedbird inspected before the race and loved that our little 180 brought so many positive memories and comments from the volunteers. Most of the pilots were talking so fondly of my Comanche 180. One of the inspectors affectionately called her “Baby Comanche.” Race day came, and Pam and I were ready. We took off out of Havasu number 27 out of 49 racers, headed to Gallup, (continued on page 8) Help Us Get to Know You! Order an ICS Name Badge Today Wear an ICS name badge at fly-ins, air shows and all aviation events. Actual size is 2 X 3 inches. Blue on white plastic with 3-color ICS logo. $10 includes shipping in the U.S., Canada and Mexico. Overseas, add $1 per order. For additional badges, use this format on plain paper. Enclosed is $_______________ for _____ badges Type or print CLEARLY (What we see is what you’ll get.) 1. Nickname ____________________________________________________________________ 2. Name _______________________________________________________________________ 3. City & State __________________________________________________________________ 4. Plane # _________________ Tribe ______________________ ICS # ____________________ Nonmembers should leave ICS # blank or show crew title. Choice for above badge (circle one) SAFETY PIN ALLIGATOR CLIP Please make checks payable to Doris Click and send to: 228 Doolittle St., Orlando, FL 32839-1474 6 • Comanche Flyer NOVEMBER 2012 PROPELLERS DOWTY HARTZELL MCCAULEY MT PROPELLER SENSENICH RAPCO DISTRIBUTOR WOODWARD PT6A LARGE INVENTORY SAME DAY SHIPPING UNCOMPROMISED QUALITY COMPETITIVE PRICES WORLD CLASS WARRANTY FACTORY TRAINED TECHNICIANS http://www.rockyprop.com e-mail: rockyprop@rockyprop.com 800-462-7605 2865 AIRPORT DRIVE ERIE, CO 80516 FAX: 303-665-7164 FAA/EASA CRS FR6R545N GOVERNORS Get Oiled Before You Start! Install an Oilamatic Aircraft Engine Preoiler REDUCE ENGINE WEAR! Up to 70% of engine wear is caused by insufficient lubrication during start. Certified on Comanches and Twin Comanches http://www.oilamatic.com P.O. Box 5284 • Englewood, CO 80155 (303) 770-0175, 1-800-343-7623, FAX (303) 793-0493 NOVEMBER 2012 Update Your Old Comanche Panel Make Room for a MFD Update your panel to a standard “T” configuration. Add space for new electronics. All panels computer drawn and laser cut. ‘58-60 Centerstack Conversion ‘61-68 Single or Twin $950.00 (Fully STC’d) $825.00 (Fully STC’d) Recuts left side – $250 • Recuts right side – $100. (Prior Panels) Contact: John Van Bladeren at: Ron & John’s Comanche Service 2007 SE Ash Street • Portland, OR 97214 (503) 329-8512 (Day or Night) • Fax: (503) 234-0677 e-mail: johnv@spiretech.com Comanche Flyer • 7 our first stop, with full power the whole way and trying to fly the most perfect cross-country flight we could. N5390P is strong and fast, and we loved flying her as fast as she could go for four days. Enduring turbulence and weather conditions that made for challenging decisions, we learned a tremendous amount about flying and about ourselves. We landed in Batavia at Sporty’s Friday morning, June 22. Our supportive husbands were cheering for us on the ground, and we couldn’t believe that we were the third airplane to finish the Air Race Classic. Our final score placed us 24th out of the 49 racers. We were second place in leg six and the second fastest Piper aircraft in the race. We were elated! It was our first race, and we learned so much. Speedbird did a great job! We love our “Baby Comanche,” N5390P. 8 • Comanche Flyer Pilot Shannon Hicks-Hankins and co-pilot Pam Rudolph with Speedbird at the finish in front of Sporty’s. NOVEMBER 2012 FEATURE Comanche Flyer Needs your Stories, Tips and Tricks! SEPTEMBER 2012 VOLUME 39, NO. 9 Publication of Membership The Official tional The InternaSociety Comanche Share your Comanche Knowledge with your Fellow ICS Members D o you have a good technical tip or overhaul story you can share? What about a flying experience or recent instructional experience where you’d learned a lesson from which all pilots could benefit? Maybe a trip you took in your Comanche that you’d recommend to others. We also desperately need in-flight photos of your Comanche to feature on the cover of the Flyer (needs to be at least 1 MB in size to print well). Anything you can share that would be helpful to fellow ICS members, we need you to send in your information! You don’t have to be a writer by trade, just put your thoughts down and tell your story – it will be edited, if needed. Below is a list of regular columns in the Flyer, and a few new ones that have been suggested (the word count provided is only an average to help guide you). Cover photo/Comanche Spirit – Not only do you get to have your Comanche on the cover of the Flyer, but we like to feature the owner so ICS members can get to know you better. You can fill out an owner questionnaire and the editor will write a story about you, or you can submit your own. Average length is 1,000 words. Maintenance Q & A – Do you have a question regarding maintenance on your Comanche? Send it in and we’ll have our Technical Directors suggest some solutions. As questions come in and a reader has an alternate solution, they can send them in as well. This would be an ongoing format for maintenance discussion. Letters to the Editor – Send in your comments about an article you read in a past Comanche Flyer. Or you can also send items of interests you’d like to share with other Comanche owners that may not be long enough for an article. Really, we’d like to hear from you! From the Logbook – If you have a trip that you’d recommend to other members, or a particular “adventure” you’ve taken in your Comanche that you’d like to share, this is the column! We have featured trips in story and journal formats. Average length is 1,500 words. Technically Speaking – We like to feature technical information you have found useful in maintaining your Comanche. Maybe it was an ongoing problem that you finally found a solution or you want to warn other owners of an issue that occurred with your airplane. Anything technical is featured in this column. Average length is 500-1,200 words. Product/Vendor Information – Did you have a good experience with a vendor that you’d like to share or have you recently purchased a product that you’d recommend to other ICS members? The best information that most owners get is from others who have experienced it, so share with us! Average length is 250-750 words. NOVEMBER 2012 Fly-In Reports – A pretty popular column, but we don’t see the experiences some of the tribes are having. Send us your story. We’d like to hear how your Tribe is getting together and sharing the camaraderie. Average length is 250500 words. Best of the Flyer – This is an easy one. If you know of an article in past Flyers that you found useful and you think needs repeating, send a copy and we’ll reprint it. If you have a story that you don’t feel fits into any of the above categories, send it anyway. Most issues include feature stories and we’d like to hear from you. What do you enjoy learning or reading about in the Flyer? Do you have something you can contribute? We’d like to hear from you! Send your contributions and ideas to Editor Kim Blonigen at kblonigen@ cox.net, or 2031 S. Beech, Wichita, KS 67207. Comanche Flyer • 9 2012-2013 ICS Board Of Directors President: Secretary: Vice President Treasurer: Zach Grant, ICS #15515, NC Tribe 6736 Chapel Hill Rd. Indianapolis, IN 46214 Cell: (317) 201-4293 Email: L1011jock@sbcglobal.net Bob Cretney, ICS #2269, SC Tribe 428 McDaniel Rd Ferris, TX 75125 Cell: (214) 725-6584 Email: bob.cretney@lecwireless.com Jerry Jesion, ICS #14746, NC Tribe 26980 Coachlight Woodhaven MI 48183 Ph: (734) 692-6152 Email: gjesion@gmail.com Pat Donovan, ICS #12246, MS Tribe 421 Piper Ct. Troy, MO 63379 Phone: (636) 462-8370 Email: icstreasurer@centurylink.net Past President: Bernie Mazurek, ICS #7947, NC Tribe 41816 Rayburn Dr. Northville, MI 48168-2085 Ph: (734) 420-2691 Cell: (734) 717-4946 Email: bmazurek@aol.com CFF President: (non-voting) Lorne Harmon, ICS #12436, SW Tribe 1491 Northridge, Prescott, AZ 86301 Ph: (928) 717-2630 Email: flying@cableone.net Tribe Representatives and Chiefs Southeast: Tribe Chief/Tribe Rep Phillip Hobbs, ICS #10509 Ph: (704) 360-4754 Email: phobbs1@carolina.rr.com Northeast Tribe Tribe Chief/Tribe Rep Bernie Stumpf, ICS #7300 25 Littlebrook Rd. Westerly RI 02891 Ph: (401) 348-0997 Email: bernard.stumpf@verizon.net North Central: Tribe Chief Bob Williams, ICS #13853 647 Robins Gate Akron, OH 44319 Ph: (330) 867-6711 Cell: (330) 592-3111 Email: gus_wms@yahoo.com Tribe Rep Cliff Wilewski 1651 Grumman Drive Rockford IL 61109 Ph: (815) 395-0500 Cell: (815) 979-7785 Email: cliff@heritageaero.com Mid States: South Central: Europe: Tribe Rep Hugh Hunton, ICS #6821 2569 Barron Road Keithville LA 71047 Ph: (318) 925-2302 Email: hhunton@comcast.net Tribe Rep Monica Rehkopf, ICS #14462 Am Loh 5 Siggenhofen 85570 Germany Ph: 49-8121-229333 (h) 49-8121 229333 (w) Email: mrehkopf@omnijet.de Tribe Chief Bob Cretney, ICS #2269 428 McDaniel Rd Ferris, TX 75125 Ph: (214) 725-6584 Cell: (214) 725-6584 Email: bob.cretney@lecwireless.com W. Canada: Tribe Chief/Tribe Rep Ken Mori, ICS #3894 1433 Copper Mountain Court Vernon BC V1B 3Y7 Canada Ph: 250-545-2491 (home) Email: coppmtn1@telus.net E. Canada: Tribe Chief/Tribe Rep Stewart Campbell, ICS #16294 229 Yellow Birch Drive Kitchner ON N2N 2P4 Canada Ph: (519) 568-7491 Email: sgcampbell@primus.ca Tribe Chief/Tribe Rep Lester Breckenridge, ICS #9711 Rt #3, Box 87 Appleton City, MO 64724 Ph: (417) 395-2397 (h) Cell: (660) 679-1473 Email: ljbreck@live.com Southwest: Tribe Chief Ed Moore, ICS # 12926 456 S Sierra Way San Bernardino CA 92408-1425 Ph: (909) 888-9859 Email: edmoore7472p@aol.com Tribe Rep Scott Myers, ICS #16819 1041 Jasmine Ct. Vista, CA 92081 Ph: (760)727-7444 (w) Cell: (760)-519-8604 Email: n9382p@gmail.com Northwest: Tribe Chief Dennis Springer, ICS #10237 4796 Drew St. N.E. Salem, OR 97305 Ph: (503) 390-9444 Email: DJ8161P@comcast.net Tribe Rep Bill Case, ICS # 16889 P.O. Box 549 Lebanon OR 97355 Ph: (541) 259-5557 Cell: (503) 260-2473 Email: billcase01@msn.com 10 • Comanche Flyer Tribe Chief Barrie Taylor, ICS #13930 16 Church Lane South Creake NR21 9LX UK Ph: 00 44 1328823560 Email: abwt@btinternet.com S. Africa: Tribe Chief/Tribe Rep Russell Knowles, ICS #16469 Box 1114, Halfway House 1685 South Africa Ph/Fax: +27 11 8052902 Cell: +27827809228 Email: rusknow@iafrica.com Australia: Tribe Chief/Tribe Rep John Moore 10 Cooper Grove Strathfieldsaye VIC 3551 Australia Ph: +61-3-5439-3293 Email: chief@comancheflyer.com.au 2012-13 ICS Standing Committees & Chairpersons: Historical – Chair: Bruce Thumann, SC Internet Technology – Chair: Dave Fitzgerald, NC Technical Resources – Chair: Zach Grant, NC Finance & Budget – Chair: Pat Donovan, MS Bylaws, Standing & Special Rules – Chair: Don W. Nelson, NW Nominating – Chair: Bruce Ladrie, SE Nominating Committee: Pete Morse, NE Bruce Thumann, SC Flagship – Chair: Cliff Wilewski, NC Elections – Chair: Sally Williams, SE Editorial Review – Chair: Zach Grant, NC Editorial Committee: Zach Grant, NC – Chair Bernie Mazurek, NC Dave Fitzgerald, NC Lorne Harmon, SW Hank Spellman, NC Fleet Airworthiness – Chair: Dave Fitzgerald, NC Fleet Airworthiness Committee: Hans Neubert, SW – Co-Chairman Dave Fitzgerald, NC – Co-Chairman Annual Convention – Chair: Shirley Nelson, NW NOVEMBER 2012 MAINTENANCE RESOURCE ADVISORS Dave Clark Ph: (817) 860-4393 Email: dave5201@att.net Zack Grant ICS TOOL LOAN PROGRAM CFF-Trained CFIs Matt Kurke Certified flight instructors who have completed a CFF training program 8192 Sanctuary Drive, Unit 1 Naples, FL 34104 Ph: (239) 593-6944 mkurke@comanchegear.com Cell: (317) 201-4293 Email: L1011jick@sbcglobal.net (Email preferred contact) Karl Hipp Ph: (970) 963-3755 Email: khipp@99victor.com Lucky Lougue Ph: (903) 345-9198 Email: lucky@asod.com The International Comanche Society, Inc. (ICS) publishes this list in the spirit of open discussion. The opinions, statements and claims made by the instructors are their own and not those of the International Comanche Society (ICS) or the Comanche Flyer Foundation, Inc. (CFF). The listed CFIs have undergone an extensive training program specializing in the Comanches. ICS and CFF assume no responsibility for any actions between its members and the listed CFIs. Roger Wentowski – AL Single, (205) 290-8401 rwentowski@btsal.com Todd Underwood - AZ (Phoenix/Prescott) Single/Twin, (623) 202-6910 todd@atjeu.com Bill Archer - AZ (Phoenix/Mesa) COMANCHE FOUNDATION, INC. INC. COMANCHE FLYER FOUNDATION, Maurice Programs Maurice Taylor Video Programs COMANCHE FLYER FOUNDATION, INC. Take advantage advantage of of Maurice’s Maurice’s knowledge, these Take expert knowledge, captured captured on onINC. these COMANCHE FLYER FOUNDATION, Maurice Taylor Programs professionally produced Great tools for professionally produced videos. Video for mechanics, mechanics,too. too. Maurice Taylor Video Programs Take advantage of Maurice’s expert knowledge, captured on these Program Walk-around Program 1: Preflight Walk-around Take advantage of Maurice’s expert knowledge, captured on too. these Program 2: videos. Tech Tips: A tools Closer professionally produced Great forLook mechanics, Program Closer Look COMANCHE FLYER FOUNDATION, INC. professionally produced videos. Great tools for mechanics, too. Program 3: Comanche Landing Gear Program 1: Preflight Walk-around Program Landing Gear Maurice Taylor Video Programs Program Preflight Program Flight Tips Program Tech Tips: Walk-around A Closer Look Program 4:2:1: Single Comanche Flight Tips Take advantage of Maurice’s expert knowledge, captured on these Program 2: Tech Tips: A Closer Look Program Flight Tips Program5:3:Twin Comanche Landing Gear Program Comanche Flight Tips professionally produced videos. Great tools for mechanics, too. Program 3: Comanche Landing Gear (Programs 1-3 apply apply to both both the twin Program 4: Single Comanche Flight Tips (Programs 1-3 to the single single and and twin models.) models.) Program 1: Preflight Walk-around Program 4: Single Comanche Flight Tips Program 5: programs Twin Comanche Flight Tips All five five programs on DVD. All onAone one DVD. Program 2: Twin Tech Tips: Closer Look Program 5: Comanche Flight Tips (Programs 1-3 apply to both the single and twin models.) DVD each $101.00 plus shipping (North America $4.00, elsewhere DVD each $101.00 plus shipping (North America $4.00, elsewhere$7.00) $7.00) Program 3: Comanche Landing Gear (Programs 1-3 apply to both the single and twin models.) All and five programs onlonger oneFlight DVD. VHS and4:PAL PAL tapesComanche are no available VHS tapes are no longer available Program Single Tips Allshipping five programs on one$4.00, DVD. DVD each $101.00Program plus (North America $7.00) Books 5: Twin Comanche Flight elsewhere Tips Books DVD each $101.00 plus shipping (North America $4.00, elsewhere $7.00) VHS and PALto tapes are longer (Programs apply both theno single andavailable twin models.) Intothe the Wind: Wind: The1-3 Story of Max Conrad by Sally Buegeleisen Into The Story of Max Conrad by Sally Buegeleisen VHS and PAL tapes are no longer available Books Enjoythis thisaccount account of ofAll the life life and and feats of legendary five programs on one pilot DVD. Enjoy the feats of legendary pilot Max Max Conrad, Conrad,including including Books his record setting flights in our own Comanche N110LF. pb, 264pp. Into the Wind: The Story of Max Conrad by Sally Buegeleisen his record setting in our ownAmerica Comanche N110LF. pb, 264pp. DVD each $101.00 plusflights shipping (North $4.00, elsewhere $7.00) Into the Wind: Story(North of Max Conrad byelsewhere: SallyConrad, Buegeleisen Price: $21.50 plus plus shipping (North America: $5.00: $12.00.) Enjoy this $21.50 account ofThe the life pilot Max including Price: shipping America: $5.00: elsewhere: $12.00.) VHS and and PALfeats tapes of arelegendary no longer available Enjoy his thisrecord account of the life and feats of legendary pilot Max Conrad, including setting flights in our own Comanche N110LF. pb, 264pp. PA-30& & Multi-Engine Multi-Engine Flying Flying by Alice S. Fuchs. pb, 68pp. Books PA-30 by Alice S. Fuchs. pb, 68pp. his record setting flights in our own Comanche N110LF. pb, 264pp. Price: $21.50 plus shipping (North America: $5.00: elsewhere: $12.00.) Price $9.00 plus shipping shipping (North America: $2.00; elsewhere: $4.50.) Into the Wind: The Story(North of Max Conrad by elsewhere: Sally Buegeleisen Price $9.00 plus (North America: $2.00; elsewhere: $4.50.) Price: $21.50 plus shipping America: $5.00: $12.00.) PA-30 &account Multi-Engine Flying by Alice S.pilot Fuchs. 68pp.including Enjoy this of the life and feats of legendary Max pb, Conrad, Please fill out to order PA-30 & plus Multi-Engine Flying by Alice S. Fuchs. pb, 68pp. merchandise purchases and/or your donations can be Please fill out to any order PriceThese $9.00 shipping (North $2.00; elsewhere: $4.50.) his record setting in America: our own Comanche N110LF. pb, 264pp. Please circleflights items above and indicate multiple quantities. Price $9.00 plus shipping (North America: $2.00; elsewhere: $4.50.) Please circle items above and indicate any multiple quantities. made through CFF on(North the ICS website withelsewhere: either a credit Price: $21.50 plus shipping America: $5.00: $12.00.) Item(s) cost: _______________ Please Add all shipping: _____________Order Total: _________________ fill out to order card or our newly availabe PayPal option. Please visit: Item(s) cost: _______________ Add all shipping: _____________Order Total: _________________ Please fill out to any order PA-30 & Multi-Engine Flying Alice S.multiple Fuchs. pb, 68pp. Please circle items above andby indicate quantities. www.comancheflyer.com Please circle items above and indicate any multiple quantities. Price $9.00 plus shipping (North America: $2.00; elsewhere: $4.50.) Item(s) cost: _______________ Add all shipping: _____________Order Total: _________________ Item(s) cost: _______________ Add all shipping: _____________Order Total: _________________ TO ORDER BY MAIL Please fill outPLEASE to order FILL OUT Please circle items above and indicate any multiple quantities. Item(s) cost: _______________ Add all shipping: _____________Order Total: _________________ Mail to: CFF c/o Shirley Nelson, 925 Ludwick Avenue, Blaine, WA 98230-5109 Ship to name: ____________________________________________________ Telephone: 360-671-7388, Fax: 360-671-7388 Ship toAddress: name: ____________________________________________________ Street ___________________________________________________ Street Address: ___________________________________________________ Enclose check or money order State: made______________________ payable to CFF. City: ________________________________ Ship to name: ____________________________________________________ City: ________________________________ State: ______________________ Zip Code: ____________________________ Country: ___________________ Ship toAddress: name: ____________________________________________________ Street ___________________________________________________ Zip Code: ____________________________ Country:____________________ ___________________ Telephone: ___________________________ E-Mail: Street Address: ___________________________________________________ City: ________________________________ State: ______________________ Telephone: ___________________________ E-Mail: ____________________ City: ________________________________ ______________________ Zip Code: ____________________________ State: Country: ___________________ Ship to name: ____________________________________________________ COMANCHE FLYER FOUNDATION, INC. Zip Code: ____________________________ Country: ___________________ Telephone: ___________________________ E-Mail: ____________________ COMANCHE FLYER FOUNDATION, INC. Street Address: ___________________________________________________ Telephone: ___________________________ E-Mail: ____________________ City: ________________________________ State: ______________________ COMANCHE FLYER FOUNDATION, INC. Zip Code: ____________________________ Country: ___________________ COMANCHE FLYER FOUNDATION, INC. Telephone: ___________________________ E-Mail: ____________________ NOVEMBER 2012 COMANCHE FLYER FOUNDATION, INC. Single/Twin, (480) 203-3043 flyawaboy@cox.net Sheldon Bresin – CA Single & Twin, (909) 629-2626 shellflycfii@verizon.net Kristin Winter - CA (Northern) Single & Twin, (707) 477-4727 Kristin_winter@comcast.net Samuel Appavoo – Canada Twin, (519) 524-7301 appavoo@cabletv.ca Malcolm Dickinson - CT/NY Single, (203) 698-2600 malcolm@malcolm.cc Ira Menin – IA Single, (712) 239-5142 iracomman@aol.com Charles Classen – IL Single, (815) 269-2552 classaero@illicom.net Larry J. Whitbeck - IL Single, (217) 732-9704 skyhawk-2@hotmail.com Zach Grant - IN (Indianapolis) Single/Twin, (317) 201-4293 L1011jock@sbcglobal.net Scott Spencer - IN (Indianapolis) Single, (317) 291-9792 aerokinetic@sbcglobal.ne Dave Stewart – IN Single, (219) 462-0182 comanchedave@ATTB1.com Ken Shaffer - MD Single, (301) 751-4100 ken@comancheguy.com Steve Smith - MT Single/Twin, (406) 425-0754 Sgsmith744gmail.com George Richmond - NE (Omaha) Single and Twin, (402) 350-1915 l49fe@cox.net Kevin C. Baun – OH Twin, (740) 881-9878 kbaun@columbus.rr.com Orlando Brown – OK Single, (405) 376-4056 c172@worldnet.att.net William Harris – VA Single & Twin, (540) 731-4772 bill@motioncontrol.org Steve Zaboji – VA Single & Twin, (703) 471-1764 SZaboji@aol.com Dennis R. Carew – WI Twin & Single, (920) 749-9558 Capt.carew@gmail.com CFIs interested in becoming a CFF-trained Comanche flight instructor should contact Dennis Carew at capt.carew@gmail.com. Comanche Flyer • 11 ICS 2012 Annual General Membership Meeting September 14, 2012, Baltimore, Md. Budget Approval, Bylaw Revision and Candidate Election Results by Sally Williams, ICS Elections Chair C ongratulations to those ICS members who participated in the electronic ICS 2012 election. Our first attempt at electronic voting showed a decline in the number of ballots cast from previous years for the slate of 2012-2013 ICS officers, the proposed bylaw change, and the 2013 budget. As an example, in 2011, 392 of 2,334 current members returned ballots resulting in 16.80% of the current membership voting. Casting ballots electronically eliminated the necessity of mailing, organizing and counting paper ballots – a definite cost and time savings. However, as a reminder, our ICS bylaws state in ARTICLE VIII, NOMINATIONS AND VOTING how we will decide the election of officers, accept the budget, approve any bylaw change, and establish the quorum for the purpose of holding our Annual General Membership Meeting. This is why you were encouraged to cast your ballot, as every vote counts. Thanks to Dave Fitzgerald, our webmaster, for developing electronic voting through our ICS web site. Electronic voting rapidly indicated the number of members who logged into the ICS web site and voted, and through safeguards collected and tallied the ballot results. The ICS Elections Committee – Sally 12 • Comanche Flyer Williams, Monica Rehkopf, and Jenny Buttle – urge you to continue to take part in the future of ICS by casting your ballot in every election. The 2012 election results are below. Please keep in mind that everyone did not vote on every issue or candidate. Ballot Issue #2: Approval of proposed addition to ICS Bylaw, ARTICLE I, MISSION AND VISION, Section 3. Conduct and Ethics as published in the July 2012 Comanche Flyer. Passed with 87.74% FOR, and 6.45% AGAINST. Ballots Received: ELECTION OF OFFICERS 155 current members returned ballots resulting in 6.8% of the current membership voting. President, Zach Grant (Uncontested) 100.00% voted FOR Ballot Issue #1: Approval of the 2013 Operating Budget as published in the July 2012 Comanche Flyer. Passed with 92.90% FOR, and 2.58% AGAINST. Vice President, Bob Cretney (Uncontested) 97.42% voted FOR Secretary (VACANT) Treasurer, Pat Donovan (Uncontested) 96.77% voted FOR Date Prepared: September 14, 2012 ICS Webmaster Assistant Needed W e are looking for a member who would be interested in becoming an assistant to help manage the ICS website. It would be good to have some basic understanding of HTML, css, java script and mysql, although being proficient in all of these programming languages is not entirely necessary. If you are interested, you can contact Dave Fitzgerald at aaviator@neo.rr.com or call him at (330) 936-7979. NOVEMBER 2012 Southeast Tribe Member, Roger Jennings, Receives the Wright Brothers’ Master Pilot Award I CS Member Roger Jennings of the Southeast Tribe was recently awarded the Wright Brothers’ Master Pilot Award. This award is widely considered the most prestigious award the FAA issues to pilots certificated under Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations. It specifically recognizes senior aviators who as safety minded professionals, have contributed over 50 years to the piloting of aircraft. incident-free flight operations, and a certificate of recognition personally signed by Michael Huerta, acting administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration. In lasting tribute, his name will be recorded for posterity in the “Roll of Honor,” (also known as “the Aviation Safety Hall of Fame) a leather-bound book prominently displayed today at the FAA Headquarters Building in Washington, D.C. Roger will hold scroll number 14 representing the state of Southfor Carolina. flying the environment The award, of course named Volunteers after Roger started flying during the sumbrothers Orville and Wilbur Wright, is mer of the early 1960s learning to fly at intended to recognize and celebrate the lifetime commitment and accomplishwhat we know today as the Charlotte ments of pilots such as Roger Jennings, Douglas International Airport. He sucwho continuously present a positive cessfully completed his first solo on June image of the FAA in respect to aviation 17, 1961 at6th the Horizontal controls of an Aeronca 7FC Champ. Shortly after his solo, and safety. It consists of a commemorative wooden plaque, a distinctive gold lawith only 14 hours total flight time, Roger pel pin signifying 50 years of accident/ purchased a Piper J-4 Cub Coupe. At age 25, he moved to Las Vegas, Nev. where he finished his private pilot’s license and eventually traded the Coupe for a retractable-gear Globe Swift. Soon enough, a stronger, faster single Comanche was purchased and flown for14 years, yet in 1982 was replaced by Roger’s now beloved and tenderly cared for Twin Comanche with its greater comfort, safety, and counter-rotating propellers. Volunteer Pilots Needed Roger is also the proud owner of a Lake Amphibian which he confides is since 1979. mostly just for fun. Having now owned the PA-39 Twin Comanche for the last 32 years, Roger has completed or overseen 15 Supplemental Type Certificate improvements and is justifiably pleased with his exceptionally smooth and quiet running bird. Phone: 307-332-3242 • www.lighthawk.org Congratulations Roger, for being honored for this prestigious award! Volunteer Pilots Needed Volunteer Pilots Needed Volunteers flying for the environment since 1979. Volunteers flying for the environment since 1979. Phone: 307-332-3242 www.lighthawk.org Phone: 307-332-3242 www.lighthawk.org Comanche Flyer • NOVEMBER 2012 Quarter 13 FEATURE Stabilator Horn Issue A D 2012-17-06 is the final rule on the stabilator horn issue and can be found via the Current News tab on the ICS home page (comancheflyer.com) or by going to the FAA website (www.faa.gov). Service Bulletin 1189 referenced in the AD can also be found on the ICS home page under Current News. Clarification of the AD from ICS President Zachary Grant: As with all things that are met with significant emotion, please DO NOT jump to conclusions. Please READ the official FAA text of the AD, as well as the Federal Register comments. Discuss these with your maintenance person or organization, and make sure everyone understands what must be done, what credit can be taken for the previous inspections, if any, and what the future inspection compliance schedule looks like. Below are some points about the AD. 1. The AD requires that the inspection be completed using the inspection procedure in Piper SB 1189 (removal from aircraft, removal from torque tube, Dye Penetrant inspection, reassembly if found crack free). No other method of inspection is allowed under this AD, and unless the inspection was done as per SB 1189, no credit can be taken, however the AMOC process is allowed if you wish to apply for one. 2. The initial inspection interval is 100 hours time in service from whatever time you have on the aircraft on Oct 22, 2012, the effective date of the AD. IF, the horn has been inspected as per SB 1189 previously, the AD allows for the repetitive inspection criteria to be used as outlined below. 3. If after the inspection, the old parts are reused, repetitive inspections are then required every 500 hours TIS or five years, whichever comes first. 14 • Comanche Flyer THIS IS NOT CALENDER YEARS, but in fact five years from the date signed off. If a NEW horn is installed, then there is a 1,000 hour/10-year moratorium on inspections, but after that period, you must replace again, or be subject to the fiveyear/500 hour inspections, same as with the reused parts. 4. If your aircraft has been previously inspected as per SB 1189, then there is no requirement to re-inspect within 100 hours of Oct. 22, 2012. You must, however, look back and see when the previous inspection was done, and whether it reused an existing or salvaged pitch horn, or if you installed a new one. Based on that information, the next inspection is due at 500 hours/five years from time and date, or 1,000 hours/10 years from time and date, respectively. 5. The torque values stated for the horn through bolts are “FAA-ese” for stating that the torque value should be 60 in/lbs., plus measured nut drag. Please do not misunderstand the AD and torque automatically to 120+ in/ lbs. (see note one in the AD text). 6. The STC for the Australian ICS horn, may or may not be a terminating action for the AD, based on how the STC is written, when and if it is approved, and whether the AD is revised based on that STC. We hope that it will be a terminating action removing the requirements for future repetitive inspections. Although Piper and the FAA do not believe constant removal and inspection will do more harm than good, there is always the possibility of that. Available in the Mechanics Corner area of the Technical tab on the ICS home page is a step-by-step direction on how to best remove and reinstall the tail assemblies. Please pay special attention to this to minimize the potential for damage during disassembly and reassembly. Last, but not least, please report any issues to ICShorn@yahoo.com. Although no mandatory reporting is required in the AD, as your type club and primary advocate before the FAA, we would like to have as much supporting data as possible for future initiatives should they be required or desired. If you have any further questions, please contact one of the Maintenance Resource Advisors at ICS and we will be happy to go over what is required. All of our contact information is listed on page 11, of this Flyer. ASHBY AIRCRAFT GLARESHIELDS Cessna - Piper - Beech - Mooney One piece hand-laminate with a molded Naugahyde texture, designed to tuck under the windshield from the front totally covering the top of the instrument panel. Protects Instruments from Intense Heat The glareshield extends (3) three inches past the front of the panel to shade instrument faces. The reinforced “lip” forms a nifty handhold on the Glareshield’s front edge and provides room for mounting optional FAA approved lights for greater night visibility. Call Toll Free 1-877-4-SPRUCE 7 7 7 8 2 3 www.aircraftglareshield.com NOVEMBER 2012 Cluster Gauges S.W., AC, Rochester Overhauled QK1R429K Fuel Senders Overhauled STC SHIMMY DAMPER KIT ALH-001 & ALH-002 APPROVED FOR PIPER MODELS PA24, 30, & 39 SER. WE OVERHAUL ALL INSTRUMENTS Airspeed Indicator Altimeters Tachometers VSI WE STILL DO AEROMARINE INSTRUMENTS LIKE AIRSPEED FUEL FLOW Heater Overhauls Oil Temp Conversion Kits “The ONLY STC approved kit on the market” Use the New Rochester Probe with your AC Gauge STC Oil Temperature Coupler Kit, ALH-I-005 Approved for Piper Models PA-23 PA-24 PA-30-39 OVERHAUL YOUR HOT PLATE WE OVERHAUL P/N 21286-000 GEAR MOTOR AND OTHER GEAR AND FLAP MOTORS FOR OTHER AIRCRAFT 1084 East Water Street, Hangar #3 Piper Airport, Lock Haven, PA 17745 Phone 1-800-443-3117 or 1-570-748-0823 Fax 1-570-748-1786 Web Site: www.airpartsoflockhaven.com E-MAIL: gmckinney@airpartsoflockhaven.com PA-24-180/250/260/400, PA-30, PA-39 Complete Kits PA-24-180/250/260/400 PA-30/39 FAA/STC, PMA Approved $769 Fixed Strap Kit $969 Inertial Reel Kit Rear lap belts available. * Three Leg Design * Rugged Construction * #6000 Capacity Ram * Range 24" – 41" * Locking Safety Collar * Slide Under Fit MODEL 324 We look forward to 2012 offering the same great quality parts, service and helpful information we have become known for. Best wishes for you and yours in 2012, Bob Weber and your Comanche family at Webco Aircraft $229.00 EA. Tail Stand / Weight Available Online Webco Aircraft is thankful for the support the ICS and Comanche owners have shown us over the years. - alphaaviation.com WEBCO AIRCRAFT LLC 1134 North Oliver Road, Hangar G Newton, Kansas 67114 316-283-7929 • www.webcoaircraft.com sales@webcoaircraft.com 1-800-653-5112 Fax 1-952-856-5158 NOVEMBER 2012 Comanche Flyer • 15 ONLINE INTELLIGENCE www.comancheflyer.com Single Winterization From the Comanche Owner’s Forums I can’t seem to find any information on winterization kits or plates for my single. My old Piper Warrior had a plate for cold weather operation. The Comanche 250 doesn’t have cowl flaps, so I’m concerned about operating this plane in sub-zero weather without some way of offsetting the airflow. Are there any cold weather 250 pilots out there with some tips for this up-andcoming winter? Scott ___________________________________ The only thing you might want to do is cover the oil cooler. You can be as sophisticated with this endeavor as you would like to be, duct tape being on the low end of the scale. An aluminum plate covering the cooler works well also. Then if you’re really paranoid, you can fine tune the air flow through the cooler by drilling holes in the aluminum plate. At the end of the day, holes aren’t needed, and you can safely cover the cooler without concern that you will overheat the oil. But to be on the safe side and satisfy your concern, start with the duct tape and cover only half, and see how that works. If you’re satisfied, you can be done. If you want the oil warmer, cover some more. You’ll probably end up with the cooler being entirely covered. Since the same type airplanes differ, be conservative and start with half. You can call Lycoming to verify what I have said, and I recommend that. Dave Gitelman 16 • Comanche Flyer ___________________________________ I was thinking the vernatherm controlled the oil temperature. it in the spring. Or, at some time, I have removed it on the way south, just four plate nuts and screws. ___________________________________ Jay If the vernatherm is operating correctly, it will close the oil cooler off when temperatures drop. If your oil temps are dropping as the weather cools off, then it’s likely that the vernatherm is sticking “open.” I’ve had my IO-320s at temps of 30 below for as long as two-and-a-half hours and never seen oil temps drop below about 180. I don’t like the winterization kit thing because it causes issues when flying from cold to warm areas. For example, that flight at 30 below was going from Oregon to Palm Springs in the winter time, and I sure didn’t want my oil cooler covered when I departed from Palm Springs at 85 degrees. Jay ___________________________________ [I was thinking the vernatherm controlled the oil temperature.] It does, to some extent, in conjunction with the oil cooler. In very cold weather, the oil temp may not get high enough, and in that case the only way to increase it is to limit the cooling at the oil cooler. Dave Gitelman ___________________________________ Dave, and all, I have had a plate solid over mine for years, and it works fine. I install it during the fall and remove ___________________________________ I spoke with Lycoming yesterday and received the following information from one of their engineers: First, the vernatherm allows oil to always flow at a minimal amount to prevent cold oil staying static in the cooler. He was not sure of the amount that flows, but he said it was a reasonable enough flow to allow cooling the moment the engine starts. At roughly 150° F, it starts to allow more flow until a maximum flow at 185° (these temps may not be exact). It is important you maintain at a minimum of 165° oil temp because it is roughly 50° hotter in other areas of the engine, and you need to burn off any water that is present. He stressed that while the entire engine is vulnerable to corrosion from this moisture, when you shut down your motor, you don’t want water to settle on the top of your camshaft. Cylinder walls are also sensitive to this moisture. I have the stock Comanche oil temp gauge that only gives me a 60°, 200°, and 260° mark, and the gauge is graduated so I don’t know when 165° is obtained. The next time I have it in the maintenance hangar, we’re going to remove the oil temp probe and place it in some water heated to 165° and then mark that position on the oil temp gauge. NOVEMBER 2012 He had no issue with blocking the oil cooler in cold weather, especially for those who like to do low power cruising at higher altitudes. Also, on a related subject, he recommended a min cylinder head temp of 150°. Scott ___________________________________ Are you sure he said 150° min cylinder head temp? If that’s what I saw, I’d be really concerned. I’d believe 250. In any case, he confirmed for you that covering the oil cooler is perfectly acceptable. I wouldn’t get too concerned about determining an exact point on the temp gauge. If the temp is around the 200 mark, you’re good. If it’s significantly lower, then you need to raise it. Excellence Defined. Performance Driven. Top Prop for Piper. ™ Experience enhanced performance from one or more significant benefits: shorter take-off distance, lower noise levels, better ground clearance, reduced tip erosion, increased climb rates & cruise speeds, and smoother operation. It’s what you expect from the market leader. Arrow & Turbo Arrow TOP PROP Seneca II & III PERFORMANCE CONVERSIONS Dave Gitelman ___________________________________ Cherokee 235 & Dakota Unbeatable Plus Three™ warranty – 3 years or 1,000 hours. TOP PROP Malibu/Mirage (3-Blade Composite) PERFORMANCE CONVERSIONS PIPER Dave, Yes, he said 150° F min cylinder head temp. The discussion started because I was concerned that in my Comanche, the CHT temp gauge green arc starts at 275° F, and many times the temp indicates below that in low power cruises. I also found this 150° min CHT temp in this Lycoming operations manual, page 52: http://www.lycoming.textron. com/support/tips-advice/key-reprints/ pdfs/Key%20Operations.pdf Scott ___________________________________ Comanche 180 (2-blade) Comanche 260 Twin Comanche (2-blade) Built on Honor – since 1917. Tel: 1-800-942-PROP (7767) or (937) 778-4201 Email: TopProp@HartzellProp.com www.HartzellProp.com The following is from a series of online postings from the Comanche’s Owner’s Forum. These postings are provided for informational purposes only. The views expressed in these postings represent the opinions of individual Comanche owners and have not been vetted by the ICS technical committee. As a responsible pilot and aircraft owner, you should always seek advice from an experienced, trusted source, such as your A&P or CFF-trained CFI, before applying any of the techniques or recommendations presented in these postings. The postings are printed as they appeared. Due to space considerations, only selected posts have been published. NOVEMBER 2012 Comanche Flyer • 17 Lance & Turbo Lance Che TECHNICAL Q&A onabplitatisitinullacmesr Piper and Lycoming m Service a s t o b uBulletin cledrivonabpli x iSource itpldfs q wae r t y a b s e d l and a cNon-Starting d u n t e r b a Engine llisweemo Edited by Dave Clark Q: A: Is there a place where I can get both the Piper and the Lycoming Service Bulletins? Yes. Below is a link to the Lycoming SBs which you can download in pdf format: http://www.lycoming.textron.com/ support/publications/service-bulletins/ index.html And this is a link to the Piper Comanche SBs: http://www.piper.com/home/ pages/PublicationResults.cfm Since these two links are from the manufacturer’s websites, they are closer to “the horse’s mouth” and would likely be complete. Dave Clark • • • • • • • • • • • Q: I have a 1962 PA24-260 with an O-540 engine. After a flight, this aircraft will not start. I changed out the ignition vibrator and got three starts and then nothing. The engine does not even try to fire. I also replaced the ignition switch and the coil in the LH magneto. I have checked all the wiring and made sure of the ground connections. I have cleaned the battery cable clamps and ensured the manual 18 • Comanche Flyer primer is working. The internal engine timing checks out and I have good spark in all the plugs. The compressions are all WNL. Do you have any ideas of what may be wrong? A: You have an O-540 engine on your PA24-260, which is carbureted, not fuel injected. This makes a difference in the approach to the problem. I had an experience similar to yours on a PA24-180 (which also has a carbureted engine) on which I performed an annual inspection before it was shipped to Australia. I had trouble starting the engine for a ferry flight. I tried five times, and it started on the fifth try. I thought during the 45-minute flight how underpowered the engine seemed to be, but I dismissed it. Since I fly a Twin Comanche, and the little O-360 would seem anemic. In hindsight, I reckon it may have been operating on reduced power. I flew the plane to my home airport where it went into the avionics shop, and then I taxied it to my hangar. Again, I had great difficulty starting it, cranking for a very long time until it finally fired. I’d prime, and it would kick over, but then die. Twenty minutes later the engine quit. It is the only true engine failure that I have experienced, and it was on the ground. So I set about checking it out and replacing everything: bladders, hoses, screens, and then the carburetor. The fuel bladders had been “refurbished” and I found a sliver of residue from the sealant was in the carburetor fuel nozzle. Even though you have fuel, you may not have atomization, and this is what I’d direct you to. If you feel that you have spark, and good mechanical condition, i.e., good compressions, then fuel is the only other option. While you have tested that you have flow, if you don’t have atomization then you will not gain a balanced fuel/air mixture, and I suspect the problem is going to be in the carburetor. I would open the carburetor and clean it out, especially the nozzle, and then give it a try. Also check the logbooks and see if the tanks have ever been “refurbished” since that will be a warning flag. If you find that the engine starts after you clean out the carburetor, then you will have identified the problem. You might also contemplate having the carburetor overhauled since the nozzles do wear, and this is an item that does need overhauling. It rarely gets done. Usual cost is about $1,000 for an overhaul if you send it out. Pat Berry NOVEMBER 2012 Tired of your stem?... Whatta drag! esru plit edle mor OAT Outside Air Temperature gauge Replace your present stem thermometer with a new digital read-out • New features: night light, auto-power shut-off, stand-by battery, push button switches. $1370 MADE IN USA $1785 PHONE: (954) 966-7329 FAX: (954) 966-3584 5614 SW 25 St., Hollywood, FL 33023 WEB: www.survivalproductsinc.com EMAIL: sales@survivalproductsinc.com • Reads F° or C° in large, easily read numbers. • Tiny no-drag outside fairing. Go faster! • Designed by Comanche owner for Comanches. • Models for Brand X low and high wing planes. • No wiring. Accurate to 1°; Resolution, 0.1° • Contains 2 easily replaced 5000 hour batteries. $79.98 + 4.95 S&H (CT add 6% tax) Send check or money order & plane make and model to: Questair, Inc. PO Box 1225, Orange CT 06477 Tel: 203-795-0611 NOVEMBER 2012 Fax: 203-795-3291 Comanche Flyer • 19 NORTH TO ALASKA – ICS 40TH ANNIVERSAR ICS will commemorate its 40th year in 2013 and the Northwest Tribe wants to celebrate at the 2013 Convention by CRUISING NORTH TO ALASKA! Electronic registration available on the ICS web site (www.comancheflyer.com). 20 • Comanche Flyer NOVEMBER 2012 – ARY International Comanche Society Convention CONVENTION NEWS It’s a Party and You’re Invited! I n 1973, a small organization was born and named the International Comanche Society. That group has grown over the years and in 2013 will celebrate 40 years as an organization. The Northwest Tribe is throwing a birthday party on land and sea, and we are inviting you, your family and friends to join us as we celebrate. The 2013 Convention will be June 27 – July 7. Thursday, June 27, through Saturday, June 29, we will be at the Holiday Inn in Renton, Wash. On Sunday, June 30, we will board Holland America Cruise Line’s MS Oosterdam for a 40th Anniversary Cruise to Alaska. The room rate at the Holiday Inn will be $109 per night, and they will honor that rate three days before and after the nights ICS members will be staying. The hotel is close to both the commercial airport at SeaTac and the general aviation airport in Renton (RNT), and they will provide shuttle service to both airports. Our host FBO will be PRO FLIGHT, who is a member of ICS and has great people to work with. The convention registration form will have a space for you to enter your flight number and time of arrival if you are flying commercial. If you are flying your own airplane, please enter the approximate time of your arrival. This DAY LOCATION ACTIVITY Sunday June 30 Seattle, Washington Puget Sound Depart 4:00 p.m. Scenic cruising Monday July 1 At Sea Tuesday July 2 Tracy Arm and Twin Sawyer Glaciers Scenic cruising Wednesday July 3 Juneau, Alaska Full day Thursday July 4 Sitka, Alaska Full day Friday July 5 Ketchikan, Alaska Morning, half day Saturday July 6 Victoria, British Columbia Evening Sunday July 7 Seattle, Washington Arrive 7:00 a.m. NOVEMBER 2012 information is provided to the hotel so that they can schedule shuttle drivers. Their goal is to not make us wait long periods of time at either airport. The party starts on Thursday with registration and a welcome dinner that evening. Friday will include board meetings, seminars and a trip to Pike Place Market and the harbor area. In order to get the information in the Flyer, we have not included the costs of that trip. It will be whatever the bus company charges for transportation and can be paid at the time of the convention. Friday night will be Tribe night, and we will be providing a list of area restaurants in the Flyer at a later date. Saturday will start with the Annual Meeting and new Board Meetings. It will also include Airport Day, which will be held at the Renton Airport with seminars in the morning, a barbecue lunch at the airport and Flagship judging in the afternoon. That evening will be our 40th Birthday Banquet at which time the Flagship Awards will be presented, and a representative from Holland America will be there to give information on boarding and what you can expect on the cruise. On Sunday, June 30, we will board the MS Oosterdam and sail to Alaska, our northern-most state in the Northwest Tribe. On the following Sunday, July 7, the cruise will return to Seattle and transportation will be provided to the Holiday Inn. If you are flying out commercial or on your own airplane, the Holiday Inn will provide a shuttle for you. We advise you let them know before you leave on the cruise so they can schedule drivers. Shuttle service will also be available to you as long as you wish to stay at the hotel. Comanche Flyer • 21 What is a Party without a Present? The Northwest Tribe will be presenting commemorative gifts of a 40th Anniversary wine glass and a 40th Anniversary windbreaker for all who attend the convention. (If you would like extra wine glasses, as soon as we have a price, we will provide a chance for you to order more.) The ICS convention registration form has a place for you to enter sizes for your windbreaker. If you wish to have it ICS 40TH ANNIVERSARY ICS ICS 40TH 40THMEETING ANNIVERSARY ANNIVERSARY ANNUAL & CONVENTION ANNUAL ANNUAL MEETING MEETING & CONVENTION CONVENTION JUNE 28 - JULY 7,2013 & JUNE JUNE28 28--JULY JULY7,2013 7,2013 Host Airport: Renton Municipal Host HostAirport: Airport:Renton RentonMunicipal Municipal PERSONAL INFORMATION Name: PERSONAL PERSONALINFORMATION INFORMATION (RNT) (RNT) (RNT) Spouse: Name: Name: Guests: Spouse: Spouse: Address: Guests: Guests: Address: Address: ARRIVAL INFORMATION By Comanche (RNT) Date Arrival Time ARRIVAL ARRIVAL INFORMATION INFORMATION By ByComanche Comanche(RNT) (RNT) Date Date Arrival ArrivalTime Time Commercial Airline Date Arrival Time Commercial CommercialAirline Airline Date Date Arrival ArrivalTime Time Registration # Registration Registration## Flight No. Flight FlightNo. No. personalized, there is information on the form for that as well. Registration forms for the convention and the cruise are in this Flyer and on the ICS website. (continued on page 24) Return by April 30th Return Returnby byTribe April April30th 30th Northwest Northwest Northwest Tribe Tribe Shirley Nelson 925 Ludwick Avenue Shirley Shirley Nelson Nelson Blaine WA 98230-5109 925 925Ludwick Ludwick Avenue Avenue email: sanelson7@comcast.net Blaine Blaine WA WA 98230-5109 98230-5109 email: email: sanelson7@comcast.net sanelson7@comcast.net ICS INFORMATION Your # ICS ICSICS INFORMATION INFORMATION Spouse ICS# Your YourICS ICS ## Additional Guests: Spouse SpouseICS# ICS# Additional AdditionalGuests: Guests: Phone NNo. Phone PhoneNNo. NNo. Type Enter Flagship □ No□ Type Type Yes Enter Enter Flagship Flagship NAME Yes OF YesAIRLINE □□ No□ No□ NAME NAME OF OFAIRLINE AIRLINE Note: Transportation is provided by the Holiday Inn from both Airports. Note: Note:Transportation Transportationisisprovided providedby bythe theHoliday HolidayInn Innfrom fromboth bothAirports. Airports. Registration by April 1st Registration AFTER April 1 Registration Registration by byApril April 1st 1st Thursday Registration Registration Registration AFTER AFTER April April11 Friday Thursday ThursdayRegistration Registration Friday Friday Friday Saturday Friday Friday Saturday Saturday Saturday Saturday Saturday Saturday Saturday Saturday Per Person Per Per PerPeraon Person Person Dinner Buffett and Hospitality Per PerPeraon Peraon Old Bd Mtg, Seminars,Hospitality Dinner Dinner Buffett Buffett and andHospitality Hospitality Tribe Night ( on your own) Old OldBd Bd Mtg, Mtg, Seminars,Hospitality Seminars,Hospitality Annual General Tribe TribeNight Night ((on onMtg your yourown) own) Airport Annual AnnualDay,Seminars, General GeneralMtg Mtg Lunch Banquet Airport AirportDay,Seminars, Day,Seminars, Lunch Lunch Flag Ship Awards, Registration Package Banquet Banquet 40th Windbreaker Jacket** Flag FlagAnniversary Ship ShipAwards, Awards, Registration Registration Package Package Sunday's Transportation from Hotel to and from the Cruise Terminal 40th 40thAnniversary AnniversaryWindbreaker WindbreakerJacket** Jacket** IfSunday's you would Transportation like your name & Hotel airplane # on your Anniversary Sunday's Transportation from from Hotelto toand and from from the the40th Cruise Cruise Terminal Terminal Number Price TOTAL $Price 225.00 TOTAL Number Number Price TOTAL $$$ 275.00 225.00 225.00 included $$ 275.00 275.00 included included included included included included included included included included included included included included included included included included 30.00 EA. included included 30.00 30.00EA. EA. IfIfyou youwould would like your your name &&airplane airplane on on your your40th 40thAnniversary Anniversary **Provide yourlike name andname airplane No. Cost##of $15.00 each **Provide **Provide your your name name and andairplane airplane No. No. Cost Cost of of$15.00 $15.00 each each□ x large □ xx large □ small□ medium □ Large Please mark Jacket Sizes Please Pleasemark markJacket JacketSizes Sizes 15.00ea 15.00ea 15.00ea small□ small□ medium medium□□Large Large□□xxlarge large□□ xx xxlarge large□□ NO REFUNDS AFTER APRIL 1ST NO NO REFUNDS REFUNDSAFTER AFTERAPRIL APRIL1ST 1ST TOTAL PAID TOTAL TOTALPAID PAID IF YOU ARE ONLY ATTENDING THE CONVENTION AND NOT THE CRUISE callHoliday Inn, Renton 465-4329 and mention International Comanche Society (ICS) for $109Inn, rate. IF IFYOU YOUWa ARE ARE(800) ONLY ONLY ATTENDING ATTENDING THE THECONVENTION CONVENTION AND AND NOT NOTTHE THE CRUISE CRUISE callHoliday callHoliday Inn, That rateWa is available 3 nights prior and 3International nights after convention. Renton Renton Wa (800) (800)465-4329 465-4329 and and mention mention International Comanche ComancheSociety Society(ICS) (ICS)for for$109 $109rate. rate. That rateattending is isavailable available 3nights nights prior priorand and 33nights nights after afterconvention. convention. IfThat you rate are the 3entire convention cruise, commercial airlines and hotel reservations can be made with our travel agentthe andentire registration formcruise, is included in the Flyer andand on hotel our ICS Website can If Ifyou you are are attending attending the entire convention convention cruise, commercial commercial airlines airlines and hotel reservations reservations canbe bemade made with withour ourtravel travelagent agentand andregistration registrationform form isisincluded includedininthe theFlyer Flyerand andon onour ourICS ICSWebsite Website FOR MORE INFORMATION : SHIRLEY NELSON : PHONE-360-671-7388 FOR INFORMATION :: SHIRLEY FORMORE MORE INFORMATION SHIRLEYNELSON NELSON::PHONE-360-671-7388 PHONE-360-671-7388 CELL: 360-305-0287 EMAIL: sanelson7@comcast.net CELL: CELL:360-305-0287 360-305-0287 EMAIL: EMAIL:sanelson7@comcast.net sanelson7@comcast.net 22 • Comanche Flyer NOVEMBER 2012 INTERNATIONAL COMANCHE SOCIETY INTERNATIONAL COMANCHE SOCIETY Northwest Tribe Presents---40th Anniversary Celebration Cruise and Hotel Registration Northwest TribeEnrollment Presents---40th Anniversary Celebration Cruise Enrollment and Hotel Registration Name: ______________________________________________________________________ Home Phone: __________________________ Address: ______________________________________________________________________Home Cell Phone: Name: ______________________________________________________________________ Phone: __________________________ __________________________ City: ______________________________________________________________ State: __________ ZIP CODE: ____________________ Address: ______________________________________________________________________ Cell Phone: __________________________ EMAIL ADDRESS: ___________________________________________________________________________________________________ City: ______________________________________________________________ State: __________ ZIP CODE: ____________________ STATEROOM REQUEST---Please specify what category or deck on the ship EMAIL ADDRESS: ___________________________________________________________________________________________________ Best Available Interior: ________________________________________________________________________________________________ STATEROOM REQUEST---Please specify what category or deck on the ship Best view: _____________________________________________________________________________________________ Best Available Available Ocean Interior: ________________________________________________________________________________________________ Best Available Deluxe Veranda: _________________________________________________________________________________________ Best Available Ocean view: _____________________________________________________________________________________________ Best Available Superior Veranda Suite: ____________________________________________________________________________________ Best Available Deluxe Veranda: _________________________________________________________________________________________ Other Stateroom Request: _____________________________________________________________________________________________ Best Available Superior Veranda Suite: ____________________________________________________________________________________ PASSENGER NAMES (Complete Legal Names as appear on your passport): Other Stateroom Request: _____________________________________________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________ Date of Birth ______________________ Citizenship _________________ PASSENGER NAMES (Complete Legal Names as appear on your passport): ______________________________________________________ Date of Birth ______________________ Citizenship _________________ ______________________________________________________ Date of Birth ______________________ Citizenship _________________ ______________________________________________________ Date of Birth ______________________ Citizenship _________________ ______________________________________________________ Date of Birth ______________________ Citizenship _________________ ______________________________________________________ Date of Birth ______________________ Citizenship _________________ ______________________________________________________ Date of Birth ______________________ Citizenship _________________ Special Occasion: Birthday ________________________________ Anniversary ______________________ Other _____________________ ______________________________________________________ Date of Birth ______________________ Citizenship _________________ Special Needs or Requests: Occasion: Birthday _____________________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________ Anniversary ______________________ Other _____________________ Special Needs or Requests: _____________________________________________________________________________________________ PAYMENT INFORMATION: DEPOSIT OF $350.00 per person due by JANUARY 16th 2013 PAYMENT INFORMATION: FINAL PAYMENT due in our office by APRIL 1st, 2013. DEPOSIT OF $350.00 per person due by JANUARY 16th 2013 Check: __________________________ FINAL PAYMENT due in our office by APRIL 1st, 2013. CREDIT CARD#: ___________________________________________________________________ EXP DATE: ______________________ Check: __________________________ BILLING ADDRESS IF DIFFERENT FROM ABOVE: _______________________________________________________________________ CREDIT CARD#: ___________________________________________________________________ EXP DATE: ______________________ CARDHOLDER’S SIGNATURE : ________________________________________________________________________________________ BILLING ADDRESS IF DIFFERENT FROM ABOVE: _______________________________________________________________________ AUTHORIZED AMOUNT: ____________________________________________________________________________________________ CARDHOLDER’S SIGNATURE : ________________________________________________________________________________________ EMERGENCY CONTACT NAME AND PHONE: __________________________________________________________________________ AUTHORIZED AMOUNT: ____________________________________________________________________________________________ EMERGENCY CONTACT NAME PHONE: __________________________________________________________________________ ****Please be advised that there is AND a Non-Refundable Travel Agency Registration Fee of $35.00 per person to be paid by CHECK ONLY. ****Please be advised that there is a Non-Refundable Travel Agency Registration Fee of $35.00 per person to be paid by CHECK ONLY. Mail to: TRAVEL LEADERS/KATY VAN TRAVEL, Inc. 17756 Katy Freeway, Suite 4 Mail to: TRAVEL LEADERS/KATY VAN TRAVEL, Inc. Houston, Texas 77094 17756 Katy Freeway, Suite 4 Houston, Texas 77094 Phone: 281-492-2007/1 800 808-8747 Fax: 281-492-0586 or email Elena, Gracie or Pat for any questions regarding your travel requests and further information. Phone: 281-492-2007/1 800 808-8747 Fax: 281-492-0586 or email Elena, Gracie or Pat for any questions regarding your travel requests and further information. HOTEL INFORMATION We have reserved rooms at the Holiday Inn Renton, Washington for those wishing pre and post accommodations. Shirley Nelson has HOTEL INFORMATION made arrangements for your group meetings prior to your cruise. Rooms are available for three nights before and three nights after the sailing. Roomsrooms are $109.00 night plus tax. No Washington charges will be to your A credit card will guarantee your room has for We have reserved at theper Holiday Inn Renton, for made thoseprior wishing pre stay. and post accommodations. Shirley Nelson either two double beds onegroup king meetings bed per your of for nights younights wish us to request on your made arrangements for or your priorrequest. to your Please cruise.advise Roomsthearenumber available three before and three nightsbehalf. after the sailing. Rooms are $109.00 per night plus tax. No charges will be made prior to your stay. A credit card will guarantee your room for either twoCARD doubleGUARANTEE beds or one INFORMATION king bed per your request. Please advise the number of nights you wish us to request on your behalf. CREDIT __________________________________________________________________________ DATES FOR ACCOMMODATIONS ____________________________________________________________________________________ CREDIT GUARANTEE INFORMATION __________________________________________________________________________ King BedCARD ________________ Two Doubles ________________ DATES FOR ACCOMMODATIONS ____________________________________________________________________________________ The Inn Renton, Washington has aTwo complimentary shuttle service between SEATAC and PRO-FLIGHT at Renton Airport to their hotel. KingHoliday Bed ________________ Doubles ________________ Please advise us of your arrival and departure information when it is available and we will make the appropriate arrangements for you. The Holiday Inn Renton, Washington has a complimentary shuttle service between SEATAC and PRO-FLIGHT at Renton Airport to their hotel. Please advise us of your arrival and departure information when it is available and we will make the appropriate arrangements for you. NOVEMBER 2012 Comanche Flyer • 23 The Ship MS Oosterdam This ship accommodates a total of 1,916 passengers on a vessel of 82,000 tons. There are fewer guests, so you get more personal attention, and a sense of spaciousness and elegance throughout. These are the advantages of cruising aboard a Holland America Line ship. Large Interior Stateroom, approximately 151-233 sq. ft. Category L prices from $1,099 per person Large Ocean View Stateroom, approximately 174-180 sq. ft. Category F prices from $1,399 per person Deluxe Verandah Ocean View Stateroom, approximately 212-359 sq. ft. with verandah Category VF prices from $1,499 per person Superior Verandah Suite, approximately 372-384 sq. ft. with verandah Category SY prices from $2,299 per person * Additional categories are available upon request. * Port charges are included. Government taxes are additional at $156.86 per person. Third or fourth in the cabin are $599 per person plus government taxes. All special meal requests and the purchase of trip cancellation and medical insurance is available and highly recommended for your travel protection. Please contact our experienced travel personnel to make these arrangements on your behalf. They can also make commercial airline arrangements for those wishing to fly into Seattle/Tacoma International Airport. 24 • Comanche Flyer NOVEMBER 2012 Sample Excursions in the Ports of Call: Juneau – Helicopter flight-seeing and glacier trek, dog sledding on the Mendenhall Glacier Ketchikan – Alaska bear adventure by floatplane, magnificent Misty Fjords by floatplane Sitka – Sitka bike and hike, volcano coast exploration by ocean raft, wilderness sea kayaking adventure And More – It’s all your choice for an outstanding experience with scenic cruising and excursions that will expand your horizons with wilderness adventure. NOVEMBER 2012 Comanche Flyer • 25 PILOT’S OPERATING HANDBOOK AND FAA APPROVED AIRPLANE FLIGHT MANUAL “Formerly Published And Produced by the late Douglas L. Killough” Piper Aircraft ceased production of the Comanche and Twin Comanche in 1972, several years before the General Aviation Manufacturers Association (GAMA) established specifications for the contemporary Pilot’s Operating Handbook (POH). As a result, the Owner’s Handbook published by Piper is incomplete by modern standards. Now available EXCLUSIVELY from the INTERNATIONAL COMANCHE SOCIETY, INC., through it’s licensed agents, is the upgraded Pilot’s Operating Handbook and FAA approved GAMA format Airplane Flight Manual. Discounted to current ICS members at $75.00 each, plus shipping (must ask for ICS member discount and provide ICS membership number when placing order). Available only through Webco Aircraft at 316-283-7929 or www.webcoaircraft.com. Available Bound or Unbound/Un-punched. There are SIXTEEN different GAMA format manuals available for the Piper Single and Twin Comanche. Please order your manual by “Manual Number 1-16” from the chart below. TO ORDER CALL WEBCO AIRCRAFT AT 316-283-7929 OR WWW.WEBCOAIRCRAFT.COM. Specify “Bound” or “Unbound/Un-punched.” Order Qty Manual Number Model Gross Weight Year(s) Mfg Flight Manual Report Number SN Begin SN End 01.) 180 2550 1957-64 1047 24-1 3687 02.) 250 2800 1958-60 997 103 2298 03.) 250 2900 1961 1127 2299 2843 04.) 250 2900 1962-64 1179 2844 3687 05.) 250 2900 1962-64 1220 (FI) 2844 3687 06.) 260 2900 1965 1334 4000 4299 07.) 260 2900 1965 1333 (Carb) 4000 4299 Singles: Not Avail 08.) 260B 3100 1966-68 1359 4300 4803 09.) 260B 3100 1966-68 1358 (Carb) 4300 4803 10.) 260C 3200 1969-72 1545 4804 5028 11.) 260T 3200 1970-72 1640 (Turbo) 4901 5028 12.) 400 3600 1964-65 1295 26-3 148 13.) PA30 3600 1963-68 1269 30-2 1744 1969 1515 1745 2000 Twins: 14.) 26 • Comanche Flyer PA30T 3725 1964-68 1269 (Turbo) 143 1744 1969 1515 (Turbo) 1745 2000 15.) PA39 3600 1970-72 1605 39-1 155 16.) PA39T 3725 1970-72 1605 (Turbo) 1 155 NOVEMBER 2012 Adventurous volunteer pilots needed for conservation missions FAA REPAIR STATION YYBR664L CUSTOM ENGINE OVERHAULS (and exchange) “A TOP RATED SHOP” - March 2010 Aviation Consumer New limit standards, new cylinder options, O.E.M. fuel systems, each engine balanced and test run. * T.B.O. WARRANTY * Cylinder & Accessory Service Volunteers flying for the environment since 1979. (800) 397-8181 www.poplargroveairmotive.com Phone: 307-332-3242 E-mail: dallen@poplargroveairmotive.com 11619 Rt. 76 Poplar Grove, IL 61065 t www.lighthawk.org Half Horizontal Adventurous volunteer pilots needed for conservation missions Volunteers flying for the environment since 1979. Phone: 307-332-3242 t www.lighthawk.org NOVEMBER 2012 Comanche Flyer • 27 FEATURE ICS President Zach Grant presenting at the General Meeting. 2012 Baltimore Convention in Review Pete Morse, ICS-NE Chief (retired) T he weather was perfect for the 2012 Baltimore Convention – bright sunny days, with daytime temperatures in the low 80s and nights cooling to the lower 70 degrees. The gentle breezes made exploring Baltimore on foot very pleasant, and the clear skies were perfect for flying. Attendees at one of the many seminars provided at the convention. 28 • Comanche Flyer NOVEMBER 2012 The Flagship award winner was this PA30 (N8818Y) owned by Alan and Kate Burrows of the European Tribe. ”Comanche row” at the Martin State Airport. Charlie and Patti Littwin from the Southeast Tribe won the award for Best Single with their PA24-260 (N143VP). The Best Twin award was given to Ron and Lynn Ward from the Northeast Tribe for their PA30 (N11KY). NOVEMBER 2012 Comanche Flyer • 29 A number of ICS members took the suggestion to come early and spend time enjoying the sights of Baltimore. The Inner Harbor area has undergone a major facelift in the past few years and offers many fine attractions. The free transportation on the Charm City Circulator bus routes made everything within easy reach. About 60 people attended the full convention, a decline over past years. Again the ICS Convention was held responsible for unfilled hotel rooms. The total attendance did swell to over 85 for the weekend events. There was lively participation in scheduled meetings and good attendance for the various seminars. Of special interest were the speakers from NASA who spoke on topics ranging from the Joint Polar Satellite System, a source of weather images and analysis, to current exploration projects of the Mars Rover. Another popular presentation was by pilot Fred Hall telling of his experiences flying the Berlin Airlift in the late 1940s. ICS-member seminars on insurance and maintenance were well attended, with quality cooperation from the vendors present. Other topics covered were the Comanche Pilot Proficiency Program (CPPP) and problems with aging aircraft, both in the form of an open discussion, and drawing on the expertise of ICS President Zach Grant. The vendors were quite busy, talking to a number of the attendees. The Friday evening dinner and General Membership Meeting proved very successful. Convention attendees enjoyed a fine buffet dinner followed by the meeting. Most people stayed to find out what ICS has been doing and to participate in the open question and answer portion. Van transportation was provided to and from Martin State Airport each day of the convention. This was especially important for the strong turnout for Airport Day on Saturday. Members got to inspect the many aircraft that flew in, especially the seven entries in the Flagship competition. This year we offered a Pilot Companion ground school as an alternative to Airport Day activities, with 25 people attending. The course covered the process of a flight, from initial planning to ground and flight operations, explaining what is going on in the mind of the pilot. While the pace, at times, was like drinking from a fire hose, many attendees felt encouraged to take an active part in future flights with their pilots. The final convention activity, a dinner and three-hour cruise on the Spirit of Baltimore, was very popular. The dinner buffet was excellent and the relaxed atmosphere provided plenty of time to get better acquainted. Photos from the convention, including Airport Day, were on display in a running slide show during dinner. The Flagship awards were presented at the close of dinner with Charlie and Patti Littwin from the Southeast Tribe winning for Best Single with their PA24260 (N143VP); Best Twin was awarded to Ron and Lynn Ward from the Northeast Tribe for their PA30 (N11KY); and the Flagship winner was Alan and Kate Burrows of the European Tribe for their PA30 (N8818Y). Thank you one and all to those who made this convention a reality. Baltimore certainly lived up to its name as the “Charm City.” Flat Rate Annuals - Structural Repairs - Modifications Expert Glass Replacement - Engine Overhauls Update Your SUN VISORS! • Provides maximum protection • • • Offering Pre-purchase Evaluations in our shop or at aircraft location • • Contact us for AD Note 2012-17-06 Stabilator Horn Assembly Inspection • • New Horns & Tubes Available Now • Pick Up & Delivery Service Available • Our experienced Licensed Staff takes pride in assuring customer safety and customer satisfaction, with special attention to detail. In service since 1983 CLIFTON AERO Clifton Airport P.O. Box 249 Clifton, TX 76634 Tim Talley ICS #8375 30 minute flight SW of Dallas/Ft. Worth 254-675-3771 www.cliftonaero.com • e-mail: cliftonaero@digitex.net 30 • Comanche Flyer from disabling glare Uses your existing mounts Affordable As an optometrist and Comanche Owner, (ICS# 13091), I wanted better sun visors for my Comanche, so I obtained field approval for my anti-glare sun visors. $10 plus S & H includes plans and 337 Field-Approved paperwork. A perfect sample pair for your use as a pattern to make your own is available for a $197 deposit, refundable IF returned within 15 days. No returns after 15 days. Dr. Steven A. DeGroff DeGroff Aviation Technologies 150 Forest Park Drive Berne, IN 46711 260-466-2848 • fax: 260-589-2911 email: c2020@drdegroff.com NOVEMBER 2012 INTERNATIONAL COMANCHE SOCIETY, INC. KEEP YOUR MEMBERSHIP GOING! ---------------------- PLEASE PRINT ---------------------- You know how valuable the International Comanche Society has been to you for helping you learn about and enjoy your Comanche airplane, both singles and twins, providing a high-quality magazine, and for the camaraderie you’ve experienced among your fellow members. Don’t let your membership lapse or miss a single issue of Comanche Flyer! And for convenience, we are now offering multiple-year memberships! Fill out the renewal form below, and e-mail, fax, or mail it back to us, and keep enjoying the International Comanche Society! Name: __________________________________________________ ICS Number: ___________________________________________ Address: ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ City: ____________________________________________State: _________Zip: __________________ Country: ___________________ Telephone: ______________________________________________ Fax: __________________________________________________ E-Mail: _______________________________________________________________________________________________________ Aircraft Model: _____________________________________________Based Airport Identifier: ___________________________________ Registration/Tail #: __________________________________________Serial #: ______________________________________________ Renewal Selection U.S., Canada, Mexico* One year – $69 Two years – $130 Spousal Renewal UK and Europe** One year – $95 Two years – $182 Australia, South Africa, other One year – $83 Two years – $158 Spouse’s ICS# ____________________ One year – $34.50 Two years – $65 *Includes second-class mailing of the Flyer **Includes $9 returned to the EU tribe for communications YOUR SPOUSE CAN JOIN, TOO! -------------------------- PLEASE PRINT -------------------------- One of the beauties of owning and flying your own airplane is the quality time you get to spend with your spouse, traveling to new destinations or social events, and filling the memory book for years to come. Your spouse can also join the International Comanche Society for only $34.50! With a spousal membership, your spouse will receive a Membership Kit containing a folder, membership card, membership certificate, a cloth ICS patch, ICS decal, access to the popular ICS website and discussion forums, and voting rights! Simply fill out the form below and return it with payment to start your spouse’s membership today! Your Name: ______________________________________________ Your ICS Number: ________________________________________ Spouse’s Name:_________________________________________________________________________________________________ Address: ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ City: ____________________________________________State: _________Zip: __________________ Country: ___________________ Telephone: ______________________________________________ Fax: __________________________________________________ E-Mail: _______________________________________________________________________________________________________ Spousal Membership One year – $34.50 Two years – $65 PAYMENT INFORMATION MC Visa (Please total all selections) Check or Money Order Credit Card Number: _____________________________________________________________Exp. Date: ____________________ Amount Paid (U.S. Funds): ______________________________________________________________________________________ Authorized Signature: __________________________________________________________________________________________ Please mail to: International Comanche Society, P.O. Box 1810, Traverse City, MI 49685-1810. NOVEMBER 2012 Comanche Flyer • 31 Tips Manual Creech Manual Ball Cap Knit Polo (light blue, mens with pocket, ladies no pocket) Coffee Mugs Lapel Pins Polo Shirts (with pocket) Stone Washed Denim Shirt Decal, Patch Mens Ultramarine Knit Polo Shirt Code Item ICS11 Tips Manual Price Qty Total $60.00 Version Updated ! Available Soon Easy to use, fold flat spiral bound, 365 pages. Updated version due soon. ICS23 Care and Maintenance of the Piper Comanche Single (Creech Manual) Donated by Maintenance Director and life-long member, Bill Creech. Tips on care and maintenance of your Single Comanche. $25.00 WINDSHIELDS WINDOWS & LENSES 1,000+ Aircraft Models 10,000+ Quality PMA’d Parts ICS27 Mens Ultramarine Polo Shirt with Pocket Circle selection: Single: S M L XL XXL $35.00 ICS24 Mens Light Blue Knit Polo Shirt with pocket Circle selection: Twin: S M L XL Single: S XL $35.00 More than just UV. we offer complete Solar Control. ICS09 Mens White Polo Shirt with pocket Circle selection: Single S M L XL XXL Twin S M L XL XXL Both S M L XL XXL $35.00 Full UV Protection AND Reduce temperatures by 10°-20° F or more.** ICS28 Stone Washed Denim Shirt Circle selection: S M L XL XXL Circle selection: Single Twin Circle selection: Long Sleeve Short Sleeve $35.00 ICS14 Ladies Light Blue Knit Polo Shirt Circle selection: S M L XL XXL Circle selection: Twin Both Single $35.00 ICS32 Ball Cap Circle selection: Tan Blue Circle selection: Twin Single $14.00 ICS26 Coffee Mug Circle selection: Single Twin $7.50 ICS10 Lapel Pin Circle selection: Single Twin Logo $5.00 ICS05 Decals (price for 2) $5.00 ICS06 Cloth Patch $6.00 Item USA Canada Foreign Creech Manual $4.00 $16.00 Decal or Patch $1.00 $1.25 $1.25 Any Other Item $5.50 $15.00 $26.00 $31.00 MENTION THIS AD GET A ICS MEMBERS: 10% DISCOUNT OFF COMANCHE PARTS More NEW G.A. Aircraft have GLAP Windshields and Windows than any other source* Toll Free: 888-826-2759 Web: www.glapinc.com Great Lakes Aero Products, Inc. 915 Kearsley Park Blvd Flint, MI 48503 Tel: Fax: e-mail: (810) 235-1402 (810) 235-5260 sales@glapinc.com Cards ® FAA/PMA approved // Windshields, Windows, Wingtip & Tail Cone Lens’ available for other makes & models // Manufacturer Since 1973 // Parts are shipped with scratch protection and/or appropriate packaging // Michigan residents add 6% sales tax // Not responsible for typos // C.O.D. Orders are shipped UPS or Fed-EX only // Windshields, windows & Lens’ are made from the highest quality Acrylic or polycarbonate sheet conforming applicable portions of ASTM D-4802, LP-391, MIL-P-5425-D, LP-393 & ASTM D3935 // *Note: Based on GAMA data for new GA piston aircraft manufactured from 2003 to current, 1 of 3 aircraft Manufactured uses GLAP Windows & Windshields. // **From material manufacturer information. // 10% Discount is for call in orders only. SUB TOTAL Michigan residents please add 6% sales tax Handling Shipping $6.00 TOTAL Ship Order To: Innovation. Reliability. Value. Name: The Original Lightweight Starter ICS #: Street Address: City: Payment: State: MC Visa Card # Zip: Exp. Date: Order by mail, fax, phone or web: International Comanche Society P.O. Box 1810 Traverse City, MI 49685-1810 US: (888) 300-0082 Other: (231) 946-3712 Fax: (231) 946-6180 http://www.comancheflyer.com/buy-merchandise.php INTERNATIONAL COMANCHE SOCIETY, INC. NOVEMBER 2012 Imitated, but never equaled — the benchmark of lightweight starters for Lycoming engines. Features a high torque series-wound motor, allmetal gears, and four heavy-duty ball-bearings. No “compromises” — no plastic gears, bushings, or troublesome Bendix drive, STC/PMA and no permanent magnet O-235 thru motor requiring high current IO-720 draw. Weighs just 10.2 lbs. 123 E. 4th Street • P. O. Box B • Newton, KS 67114 Voice: 316-283-8000 • Fax: 316-283-7400 Web: www.BandC.info Comanche Flyer • 33 An African Adventure: Flying a Twin Comanche around Africa (Part 3) by Robert Limb Editor’s Note: Below is the remainder of Robert Limb’s 2011 adventure of flying around the African continent in his 1964 Twin Comanche. Part Three begins where Robert is getting ready to leave Nairobi. T he following morning, I headed to the airport and met Moses; we were quickly through security and at the Comanche. Moses had already paid the landing fees and parking, so all I needed to do was file the flight plan for that day’s flight, as well as the one to Lokichogio in northern Kenya. I filled in the appropriate forms in the Kenya CAA dispatch office and then waited for approval to depart. After several minutes, the friendly lady told me there was a problem with my clearance to fly in the Nairobi FIR. After several calls and some problems logging in to their computer system, I was told that my overflight clearance would only permit me to fly from Nairobi to Lokichogio, but that she was trying to get a hold of the manager of the CAA to get permission for my detour via Masai Mara. Everyone was very helpful; after an hour of trying she apologised and told me they couldn’t get the manager, and no one else could give me the necessary approval. I headed back to the plane and explained the problem to Moses. As I secured it for parking until the flight to Lokichogio, a couple of Kenyan pilots came up and asked about my Comanche and trip. Moses explained the problem I had and the next thing I knew, they were offering to drop me off with their Cessna Caravan at Kichwa Tembo. Evidently they were taking several people to another lodge about five miles away; they also kindly offered to pick me up the morning of my flight 34 • Comanche Flyer to Lokichogio, as they would be collecting others in the Masai Mara. Thirty minutes later we were taxiing out in the Caravan and soon on our way across the Rift Valley to Kichwa Tembo. Once in the air, the boys were really flying low – no more than 30 feet off the ground at about 140 knots – that was fun. They pointed out some giraffes which we quickly dodged around before making a curved approach into Kichwa Tembo airstrip. The Murram surface was good, but quite rough. I was glad I didn’t have to land on it in the Twin Comanche, especially as the loose gravel could have damaged the propellers. I thanked Military checkpoint in El Arish, Sinai. NOVEMBER 2012 From the Logbook Final checks being made to the replacement tyre and wheel at Malakal. my pilot friends for the excellent flight and then met people from the lodge who had a much-needed welcome drink. The game drives in Masai Mara were excellent, and the ranger guide was very knowledgeable being from the region. The animals were wonderful, and we saw the big five. With so much space and a feeling of tranquility, the environment was very different from that I experienced in Sabi-Sabi in Kruger. I would recommend both, as each is unique. After an excellent weekend, with great hospitality and food, it was time to head back to Nairobi and on to Lokichogio. As promised, the Cessna Caravan arrived. Without shutting the engines down, I hopped on board, and we were soon on our way. As soon as we landed at Nairobi Wilson Airport, I was met by Moses who had completed all of the formalities, and I had the approved flight plan, NOTAMS, etc. The density altitude at just after noon was 9,000 feet (the airport elevation is 5,540 feet OAT 36 Deg C). From the performance calculations, I required NOVEMBER 2012 a good deal of the available 5,200-foot runway to take off. I also was well above the single engine maximum altitude of 5,500 feet, so there was little room for error. Once I was cleared for takeoff, I powered up the engines and held on the brakes for a final check. I released the brakes and accelerated quite rapidly down the runway. Rotation was at 90 MPH indicated airspeed which was actually a ground speed of about 105 MPH; it definitely felt faster than normal. Once clear and climbing at 500 ft/min, I made a gentle right turn, as requested, and was cleared to my cruising level of FL100. As the flight was relatively short, I filed VFR. After several frequency changes given to me by Wilson, I finally got contact with Nairobi Control. I gave them my estimates for NAK and LOV VORs, and for Lokichogio. I was flying up the Rift Valley, the visibility was quite poor due to haze, but I could make out several lakes which appeared to be in old calderas. The steep edges of the valley were quite impressive, and I could see Mount Kenya off to my right, some 50 miles away. Comanche Flyer • 35 At Lodwar, the green part of the lower Rift Valley had been replaced by dry rocks and scrub. About 25 miles from Lokichogio, I requested descent and cleared. The airfield was only at 2,000 feet elevation. Engines shutdown and paperwork completed, the handler got a single 55-gallon drum I needed to refuel. Everyone was very welcoming and explained that the airfield was very quiet since the UN moved in to south Sudan following independence. The town was very poor with sand for roads, mud huts, and the odd basic shop on either side of the street. The hotel was a compound of round huts with straw roofs; I was shown to my room (hut) which was clean, but somewhat Spartan. A quick shower of cold water only was somehow refreshing. After dinner and drinks, I looked at the weather on my iPad; thanks to the United Nations there was a good internet connection. The bed had a mosquito net and a spray can was attached to the wall which I activated. There was no air-conditioning, but the fans seemed to do the job. The next day, I was headed to Sudan and into the Arab part of Africa. From Kenya to White Waltham The next morning, I paid the bill which included dinner, drinks, transportation and the room and rounded it up to $50, including a tip. At the airport, 36 • Comanche Flyer I was waved through the security hut and walked to the plane. I loaded the flight plan into the Garmin and checked it against my PLOG and the airways chart for correctness – you don’t want to be off course in Sudan as they will shoot you down with a missile or something similar! I had to fly at or above FL120 because of potential targeting from the ground – not a particularly comforting thought. Takeoff was to the east, and I had to fly about 70 miles in that direction before joining the airway and flying north because of the military area on the border with Sudan. About 80 miles before I reached the reporting point, Adono Addis asked me for my latest estimate for Khartoum which was 20 minutes later than I had originally calculated at 09:40, due to the stronger than predicted headwinds. A little later Addis told me that Khartoum airport was closing between 09:00 and 13:00 UTC and asked if I had the NOTAMS. I responded that I had the NOTAMS given to me in Lokichogio, and there was nothing about Khartoum closing. After further waiting, Addis called me back and told me that Khartoum could not accept me until after 13:00, which was about six hours away, and asked what I planned to do. I weighed my options: I could proceed to Dongola which was my alternate, but they might not have Left, the painted columns at Medinat Hebu – still rich and vibrant after 3,500 years of exposure to the elements. Flying over a field full of giraffes in Masai Mara (right). fuel, and it would be very tight to return to Khartoum after getting there. I had landing permission in Sudan, but not in Ethiopia, and I doubted there would be avgas there. Looking at the airfields in Sudan, I had two viable options: Malakal which was 136 nm to the west of my track and 364 nm from Khartoum, or El Obeid which was 366 nm away and a further 201 nm from Khartoum. I got out the plates for both options and they were both suitable airports. I elected for Malakal, as it was the nearest to my planned route and the shortest overall distance to Khartoum. I contacted Addis and explained the plan, which they relayed to Khartoum. At about 40 miles out, I started my descent and as I got closer, I could see the airfield which was right next to the White Nile. I touched down smoothly and kept the aircraft straight in the gusty conditions, but as I lost rudder authority at about 40 knots, I got caught by a strong gust. I touched the brakes and used the nose wheel to keep on the centre line of NOVEMBER 2012 the runway, as there was quite a bit of rubble at the edges of the runway even though it was reasonably wide. I must have hit the brakes too hard because as I finally slowed down for the exit on my right, I realised I had a flat tyre. Fortunately, I was able to clear the runway and move to a suitable parking place on the very wide apron. I shutdown the engines and completed my paperwork, then got out to have a look at the tyre. It was completely flat. Very quickly about 15 people showed up and I explained that I needed a jack as I had a spare tyre and inner tube. Almost immediately a man appeared with a truck jack and some breeze blocks. He spoke good English and I showed him the jacking point under the wing. He seemed very knowledgeable and told me he was a driver and mechanic; he even made sure the good wheel was chocked. I showed them how to take the wheel off and soon we had it free, but the brakes pads were still around the disk. After some further discussion, someone unscrewed the hydraulic line and the wheel was free, but hydraulic oil was starting to leak out of the hose which I tried to plug with a rubber glove. The mechanic soon had the wheel halves apart and the new tyre and inner tube installed. I got the wheel with the new tyre installed on the axel and fitted the brakes. We still needed to inflate the tyre which I should have done before fitting it to the axel, but I was concerned about the ground clearance. We got a truck and used its air supply to inflate the tyre to the correct pressure. We needed to bleed the brakes, and I had a small quantity of the correct hydraulic oil, but despite valiant efforts using a redeployed oxygen cannular hose to act as a hydraulic line to the bleed valve, we were unable to get all the air out of the line. The right brake on the unaffected tyre was fine, but the left brake was soft due to the trapped air. I now had two good tyres, but only one fully working brake. I gave the mechanic $200 and asked him to buy a meal for everyone who helped me. He initially refused, but I insisted. I decided to repack the plane, prepare the PLOG, and program the Garmin for the flight to Khartoum. It was around 12:00 UTC and I wanted to leave in the next 30 minutes. I called the handling agent NOVEMBER 2012 on my Satphone and gave him a revised ETA for Khartoum. Fortunately, the gusty conditions that prevailed when I landed had dissipated, and I was soon heading northwards to Khartoum. After finally establishing two-way communication with Khartoum, they passed me the latest weather which included: visibility of 4,000 metres in a sand storm! About 30 miles from LAGRA, I requested descent and was cleared. An Egypt Air 737 was cleared for the ILS, and I was number two with a KLM 777 behind me. As the sun was starting to go down, I repeated my approach brief and checked all the Navaids one more time. I was cleared for approach and asked to keep my speed up. I was soon fully established on the ILS using the autopilot for a fully coupled approach. I could see the lights of the city and at about two-and-ahalf miles, I picked up the runway lights. Just as I landed, the KLM 777 reported he was at eight miles. With only one fully functional brake, I was careful exiting the runway and used differential power to follow behind the ramp vehicle. Khartoum airport is a very busy place and I was parked next to a monster Russian helicopter. After shutting down, the marshaller asked me what time I planned on departing the next day, as he was concerned that the helicopter would blow my plane over. Fortunately, my departure time was well before that of the helicopter. The handling agent and fuel people were soon at the plane; and accompanying them was a soldier with a rifle who stood guard. Back at the terminal building the next morning, we passed through the crew/ employees channel. After no less than six security scanners and metal detectors for my bags, we finally arrived at a departure gate and boarded a bus to the plane. Twenty minutes after takeoff, I leveled off at FL100 and set up the aircraft for long range cruise. The Nile River was now far off to my west, but was still a distinct bright blue line in the haze over the Nubian Desert. Landing at Luxor, I noticed that the airport and apron were enormous, but I only saw one other aircraft which looked like a Hawker! I discussed the hydraulic oil for the brake with the handling agent, and asked him to try and source it. WARREN GREGOIRE & ASSOCIATES LLC 1933 DAVIS STREET, SUITE 276 SAN LEANDRO, CA 94577 VOICE 510-633-9353, FAX 510-633-9355 WEBSITE www.warrengregoire.com Unfortunately, the only container with the required fluid was empty. After securing the aircraft, we headed to the terminal building which was large and very modern, but empty. Allah, my handler, used to be an accountant at my hotel and had secured a good rate for me. He also organized a visit to Karnak Temple for the light show that evening, and a guide and taxi the next day to visit the Valley of Kings and a few other archaeological sites. The hotel is on the eastern bank of the Nile, and from my balcony, I could see across the river to the Valley of the Kings. I was up early the next morning and after breakfast, the taxi with my guide, Salah, picked me up. We crossed the Nile and followed the road along the west bank to the Valley of Kings. Unfortunately cameras were not allowed in the Valley of Kings, but the tombs were very impressive, and I was able to visit those of Ramses II, IV and Tutankhamen. We then visited Hatshepsut to see several tombs constructed for high officials, all very interesting and in many ways more revealing about the daily lives of Comanche Flyer • 37 the ancient Egyptians. For me, the most impressive thing about all the monuments and tombs was the richness and vibrancy of the painted murals and columns after 3,500 years of exposure to the elements. The next morning, I woke at 06:00 for the relatively short flight to El Arish, Sinai on the Mediterranean Sea. After paying Allah, I called the tower for start and taxi. I got my clearance, but it wasn’t as I had filed. I asked the controller to repeat the clearance and wrote it down. I reprogrammed the Garmin with the new routing which took me up the Red Sea and very close to the Israeli border. It was almost 10:30 a.m. local time and quite warm, so the climb to FL100 was done at the optimum speed for best cooling. There was a lot of traffic routing in and out of Sharm; my TCAS had more targets than I’d seen for quite sometime. Despite that, I appeared to be away from the traffic and enjoyed the views of the Red Sea and St Catherine’s Mountain. Later, I was running up the eastern coast of the Sinai Peninsula, and in the haze could make out the Saudi coast on the far side of the Red Sea. I soon reported 10 miles to TBA, but the controller didn’t respond immediately. I tried again, as I was quite aware that I was in a very sensitive area and wanted to make sure my radio calls were clear. I knew they were being monitored by the Israelis, and they had one fighter airborne at all times to reduce response time. At eight miles to TBA, I was told to proceed direct. I flew from the desert over the green oasis which was El Arish. On landing and parking, I requested fuel straightaway to allow an early start in the morning. I parked and removed my bags from the aircraft. At that time, I realized I couldn’t find the key for the plane. After further searching, it occurred to me that with all that happened in Luxor, I may have inadvertently left it in the door. Up to this point, I had been meticulous with a set procedure for the key, but it was rumbled by all the hassle with refuelling. The golden rule is to always refuel on arrival. With the exception of Port Elisabeth where the fuel was closed for the day, I had stuck to that rule except in Luxor. My handler called the guys in Luxor (they belong to the same handling company) to see if they could find the key. 38 • Comanche Flyer I asked him about security at the airport and understood it wouldn’t be a problem. We boarded a bus for the 60-metre journey to the terminal and after a short wait while the immigration official checked my passport, Osman, my handler, told me that I had to have an armed guard and police escort to the hotel due to the security situation, as we were close to the border with Gaza. We got in the taxi, and with the police escort, proceeded with speed to the hotel. Every few hundred yards, there were tanks, soldiers and some anti-aircraft installations dug in beside the road; about every mile, in the middle of the road, there were large mounds of sand which needed to be slowly negotiated like a chicane while a machine gun covered the area. It all looked quite serious, but the police just waved to their colleagues at the checkpoints. I was more concerned about the AK-47 that the policeman had in the front seat, going off by accident. After 20 minutes, we arrived at the hotel which sat behind the beach facing the Mediterranean Sea. Once I was checked in, I wandered around town, it was very quiet. I awoke quite saddened to be leaving Africa after what had been a great adventure. Osman arrived to take me to the airport, with no police escort this early in the morning. He informed me that they had found the key in Luxor and would mail it to my home address in the UK. We took the bus to my plane and as we were pulling alongside it, the driver said something about a flat tyre! I got off the bus and could see that the tyre on the main gear on the side opposite to the one that blew in Malakal was deflated. I discussed with Osman and we decided to wait for the Egypt Air training people to arrive. The bus took us to their workshop where I examined a tyre on one of their 17 brand new G1000 Skyhawks; it was the same size and type as my aircraft - what luck! Osman went to talk to the manager of the maintenance workshop, and a few minutes later, returned and introduced me to him. The manager was happy to assist. We went in the workshop, and they allowed us to borrow their air compressor with its reservoir and hose and pressure gauge. We wheeled it across to my plane and in no time had the tyre inflated. However, we could hear the sound of air escaping. The maintenance manager came, and we all agreed that the tyre needed to be looked at. Thankfully they were willing to assist. I discussed with the manager the type of tyre needed and showed him the details in the maintenance manual on my laptop. He also confirmed that it was the same type as they used! We inspected the tyre, and it seemed to be in good shape, but the air was escaping from the valve assembly. After more inspection, it appeared that the air was leaking around the valve itself – they suspected damage to the brass thread or seal. Osman had a discussion with the manager in his office and he was willing to sort everything for $300. A new inner tube was installed and the wheel reassembled. As they were doing this, I observed that they have a pump for hydraulic oil. I asked the manager if we could also purge one of the brakes, as I thought it had some air in the line – he was happy to assist. A bit later, the CFI of Egyptian Aviation Academy came over and asked if he could show the students the airplane. I was soon conducting a tour and shaking hands with everyone. We had a photo session with the mechanics, and I paid the manager and thanked him and the team for their help. I taxied back to my original parking place, and everything was working correctly. As I was getting ready for takeoff, I got several calls on the radio from the instructors and the CFI wishing me all the best for my trip. It was 304 nm to Milos across the Agean Sea, and as the miles counted down, I started seeing many of the Greek Islands – Karpathos, Rhodes, Santorini and, far to my south, Crete. As I approached Milos, I was given the rest of my routing which was Tripolis, Araxos, and finally Kerkira on Corfu. As I reached Araxos, I could see the lights illuminating the towns on the islands in the Ionian Sea; it was quite picturesque. As I approached, I saw the runway and the lights of the town clearly. After landing, parking and securing the plane for the night, the handler and I were soon in the terminal building where customs had a cursory look at my passport – welcome to Corfu. I arranged with Takis, the handler, to meet after the Easy Jet flight arrived in the morning, as my wife, Tracey, was bringing the spare keys for the plane. Once in a taxi, it took only five minutes before arriving at the Hotel Bella Venezia, close to the centre of town. NOVEMBER 2012 The next morning, after rising unusually late for my trip, Takis called and said the Easy Jet flight had landed 15 minutes early. We pulled up just as Tracey exited and Takis waved from inside the terminal. We met him and then proceeded through security and across the apron to the plane. With the spare key, I soon had the cover and various plugs installed, and we headed back to the hotel to drop off Tracey’s bags. The next couple of days were spent exploring Corfu. We were up bright and early for our flight to Cannes-Mandelieu. After preflight checks and loading, Tracey managed to squeeze into the passenger seat without dislodging the bundle of cables for the Satphone, tracker, iPad and Garmin. After cleared for takeoff, we quickly turned over the bay to the north of Corfu, on track to Brindisi. was happening, I got a TCAS alert 400 feet above me. A minute or so later, a DA42 passed overhead heading northwards. I reported the TCAS alert to Rome, but they had no knowledge of the aircraft. I picked up the latest Cannes ATIS and Nice informed me to expect a LOC A follow by VPT A to Rwy 17. The latter is a visual manoeuvre with defined waypoints mainly to reduce noise. When I reported visual with the field, I was told to fly to LUXUS which was the entry point for the visual manoeuvre. We followed the procedure and landed after a flight of four hours 50 minutes. We were soon in the taxi headed to our hotel on the Croisette and then went to the beach. After an enjoyable two days in Cannes, we headed to the airport for the return flight to White Waltham. It was quite a long trip, as ATC didn’t give any shortcuts. As we passed over the mountains to the east of Salerna, the winds were changing very rapidly from a sudden 25-knot tailwind to a 10-knot headwind, and back to a 25-knot tailwind. Amazingly, the flying conditions were relatively smooth. Turning at Sorrento to fly across the bay of Naples, I had a great view of the island of Capri on my left side, and Vesuvius on my right. As we turned over to Elba, we were told to contact Marseille. Just as that London managed to shorten our route a little, and left us at FL100 until we approached Midhurst. A rapid descent over Farnborough and we were soon handed over to White Waltham for the final landing of the trip. For the statisticians amongst you, the total distance travelled on this “African Adventure” was 14,233 Nautical Miles as recorded by the Spidertracker. Total flight time was 104.8 hours. Fuel consumed was 5,365 litres or 51.2 litres per hour. Average speed was 135.8 knots. Twentyfour landings AND takeoffs were made! Amazingly the only problems were a flat tyre on landing at Malakal and a deflated tyre whilst parked overnight at El Arish. Despite being almost 48 years old, N7EY never missed a beat – a true testament to the quality of build and design of the Piper Twin Comanche. The Egypt Air maintenance workshop team and Robert (third from left). A look back at Corfu Town on departure. NOVEMBER 2012 Comanche Flyer • 39 FROM THE TRIBE CHIEFS MID-STATES TRIBE Saturday Lunch Fly-Ins Saturday Lunch Fly-Ins will be posted in our new Comanche Winds newsletter which will come out every other month, and are now posted in the calendar summary in the Flyer. Also, we will be sending out e-mail notices a month before and the week of the fly-in. There are several fly-ins already in the process, so watch your e-mails. These fly-ins will focus on having fun, kicking tires, telling stories and promoting more new and old friendships among our tribe members. Be sure to contact the fly-in host for last minute changes or cancellations, especially if you are not on the Mid States Tribe fly-in or newsletter list. If you would like to host a lunch fly-in, please call Sarah McKinley at (816) 868-1015 (cell) or e-mail at flyingmacs@aol.com. Tribe E-mail Updates maintenance talk and lunch, to your liking. You should be able to find a schedule of the lunch fly-ins on the South Central Tribe website at http://groups.msn.com/ SouthCentralTribeICS/welcome.msnw and in the South Central Tribe newsletter Smoke Trails. (If you wish to organize a lunch fly-in, please contact Bruce Thumann at bruce@contractbuilderssupply.com or (713) 875-3056.) Tribe E-mail Updates If you are not receiving the South Central Tribe’s Smoke Trails Newsletter and would like to, please e-mail Bruce Thumann at bruce@contractbuilders supply. com, and he will make sure to amend the list to include your e-mail address. SOUTHEAST TRIBE *** UPDATED *** Annual New Year’s Fly-In Fort Myers, Fla. (FMY) December 29-31, 2012 – January 1, 2013 If you are not receiving the Mid States Comanche Winds newsletter and would like to, please call Sarah McKinley at (816) 868-1015 or by e-mail at Flyingmacs@ aol.com and she will make sure to amend the list to include your e-mail address. The Southeast Tribe will host their 33rd annual New Year’s Fly-in at the Crown Plaza Fort Myers at Bell Tower, at Fort Myers, Fla. It has been 15 years since the tribe has had their last New Year’s Eve at Fort Myers and many things have changed. SOUTH CENTRAL TRIBE Deluxe rooms are $120.99 per night, tax included, which includes one king or two double beds. Contact the Crown Plaza sales reservations directly at (239) 210-2462, and ask for Christine Brosh, you must state you are with ICS for the above rate. To ensure your reservation, Saturday Lunch Fly-Ins If it is difficult for you to make a full weekend fly-in, you may find the Saturday lunch gatherings with Comanche camaraderie, sharing of flying stories, DATE TRIBE EVENT/LOCATION Nov. 3 MS Nov. 10* NE Dec. 1 MS Dec. 1* NE Dec. 29-Jan. 1 SE Lunch Fly-in/ Topeka, Kansas (TOP) Saturday Fly-In / Staunton, Va. (SHD) Lunch Fly-in/ Sikeston, Mo. (SIK) Saturday Fly-In / Georgetown, Del. (GED) Annual New Year’s Eve Fly-In/ Fort Meyers, Fla. (FMY) * The following Sunday is the raindate. 40 • Comanche Flyer INFO SOURCE/HOST Mac and Sarah McKinley at flyingmacs@aol.com Pete Morse at pete.morse@rogerscorporation.com Pat Donovan at pa24pilot@centurylink.net Pete Morse at pete.morse@rogerscorporation.com Doris Click at dorisclick@aol.com a credit card is needed. ICS has a block of 15 rooms held until 11/30/12. After this date, our block of rooms will go back to the general public and the hotel cannot guarantee a room. If your room is booked by 11/30/12, the ICS room rate will be valid prior and after the function. Cancellation can be made up to 72 hours beforehand. If you cancel within less than 72 hours, or are a no-show, you will be liable for one night on your credit card. Check-in time is 3:00 p.m. If you arrive before then and your room isn’t yet available, you are welcome in the ICS Hospitality room. The hotel is going to try and put all of our rooms together near our hospitality room. The hotel has complimentary wireless, high-speed internet access and a refrigerator and microwave in each room. There is also an exercise room, tropical heated outside pool and free parking. They offer a buffet breakfast for $10.95 each morning, or you can eat at any of the other restaurants in the area. Agenda: Saturday, December 29: Fly into Page Field, Fort Myers (FMY) to FBO Base OPS Aviation (open from 7:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.); their telephone number (239) 590-6600. Tie-down fee for three nights will be waived with a fuel purchase of 10 gallons. It has been noted, that Page Field has the cheapest fuel in Florida. The hotel has complimentary shuttle service either from Page Field or South West International Airport to the Crown Plaza. Call the Crown Plaza Hotel for service at (239) 482-2900. If you plan to rent a car, rentals are available at the airport: Hertz (239) 931-3154. Switlik Aviation Maintenance Shop (Ed at (239) 936-3666) is also on the field. If you’re driving to our event, use exit 136, off of I-75. After checking in, come relax in the hospitality room. At 7:00 p.m., we will meet for dinner at our hotel especially set up for our group. Sunday, December 30: Everyone will be on their own to visit all the local attractions: Edison/Ford Winter Estates Historic Homes; drive to Fort Myers Beach, Sanibel or Captive Islands; or play golf at one of the golf courses. Adjacent to the fabulous Bell Tower Shop is an abundance of boutiques, up-scale shopping, dining, entertainment and a 20-screen movie theater. NOVEMBER 2012 F.A.A. Certified Repair Station VI4R597M Custom Engine Overhaul “The top-rated shop” Aviation Consumer March 2010 2-YEAR 500-HOUR WARRANTY Call L.J. or Herman 800-204-0735 Website: zephyrengines.com • E-mail: zephyrengn@aol.com Tip Tank Kits Extended Range, Gross Weight Increase, more useful load, Lower Engine & Airframe Maintenance • Fifteen (15) U.S. gallons each, aluminum tip tanks. • LED navigation lights now available. • Osborne Tip Tank Kits are original Piper factory equipment. Your Midwest Comanche Specialists www.heritageaero.com 815-395-0500 815-395-9044 (fax) 1651 Grumman Drive Rockford, IL 61109 NOVEMBER 2012 Aerodynamic Efficient Gross Weight Increase System Choices Customer Approval • • • • Increased Stability Aluminum Constructed Product Quality Product Support FAA approved installation kits in stock. Distributors for JP Instruments, Whelen Lighting, and Shadin Extended discount pricing for ICS MEMBERS Phone: 800-963-8477 • (760)245-8477 • Fax: (760)245-5735 Heritage Aero, Inc. 18173 Osborne Rd, Victorville, CA 92394 • www.jlosborne.com • E-mail: info@jlosborne.com ICS 12289 PA-30 N808N Comanche Flyer • 41 REGISTRATION FORM NAME: __________________________________________________________________________ Registration Fee: $ 20.00 per person NUMBER OF PEOPLE TOTAL ____________________ $___________________ Need to know if you plan to attend either dinner to reserve your place. Broadway Dinner Theater $35.00 per person tax and gratuity included. Pay for Broadway Dinner/show with your hotel room when checking in #____________________ New Year’s Eve Dinner/Dance celebration, pay with your room. #____________________ Check Total for Registration $_____________________ Mail checks, made out to ICS Southeast Tribe, with registration form, to Doris Click, 228 Doolittle Street, Orlando, FL 32839, by December 14, 2012. Please register with the hotel directly for rooms. Remember to state “ICS” for the rate. The SE Tribe sends an open invitation to ALL ICS members to come join us and take in another New Year. If you plan to be one of the 10 air planes flying to Fantasy of Flight (see specific information next page), please register with Bruce Ladrie by calling (919) 427-898, or by e-mail to bruce.ladrie@ gmail.com and send an advance deposit of $12.50 per airplane. Bruce must have your deposit check, payable to South East Tribe ICS, in order for you to be included in the registration sent with a signed contract to confirm our organization’s reservation. Fantasy of Flight will NOT accept personal checks due that our group is receiving a special rate. It is a MUST that Bruce has your check in hand by November 28 for you to be registered. Once Fantasy of Flight receives our registration, with ICS’ deposit check, they will e-mail Bruce the full detailed requirements/forms that are needed to be filled out and signed. In turn, Bruce will then forward the e-mail on to those paid registrants to complete. Please include all the necessary information/ forms that Fantasy of Flight is requiring, with your final payment back to Bruce by December 7. He will then forward all the registrations with the final amount due to Fantasy of Flight. Again make your payment check payable to South East Tribe ICS. Bruce will hold your deposit check of $12.50 until 10 planes have registered. The cut-off date to register your airplane is November 28. If the necessary 10 planes are not met by this date, your check will be returned to you, and the Fantasy of Flight fly-in will be cancelled. Your advance deposit of $12.50 is nonrefundable once our contract is sent to Fantasy of Flight. AIRCRAFT COVERS At 5:00 p.m., we will meet in the lobby to attend Broadway Palm Dinner Theater for “Fidder on The Roof.” The hotel’s van will transport those who do not have a car. The show starts at 5:30 p.m. Dinner will be a five-course gourmet buffet of beef, fish and chicken, for $35.00 per person, tax and gratuity included. We have three tables reserved until December 14. Tickets sell out fast, so please make your reservation early. TOLL FREE: Monday, December 31: & ENGINE PLUGS 800.777.6405 phone: 408.738.3959 fax: 408.738.2729 e-mail: bruce@aircraftcovers.com WWW.AIRCRAFTCOVERS.COM Bruce’s Custom Covers, 989 E. California Ave. Sunnyvale, CA 94085 42 • Comanche Flyer Matt Kurke will present a seminar at 8:30 a.m. to noon at the FBO’s conference room. The ladies can “shop ‘til they drop.” Our Comanche group will gather at our reserved tables at 7:30 p.m. in the dining room for dinner. Chef Kevin is preparing a very special multiple-course dinner selection, which will not be on the menu. In addition to the special dinner, you may choose from the hotel’s regular popular menu. A D.J. will play from 8:00 p.m. until midnight bringing in the New Year with noise makers and champagne. A cash bar will be available. Tuesday, January 1: Depart, at your leisure, after enjoying breakfast. NOVEMBER 2012 Fantasy of Flight Details F antasy of Flight is a private airfield in Polk County, Fla. where permission to land is mandatory and will be granted only by following the guidelines. Fantasy of Flight requires a minimum of ten (10) airplanes to qualify for their fly-in program, plus 20 persons. Reservation Requirements Reservation at least (4) weeks prior to arrival. Acceptance and signature on their form. Adherence to all applicable deadlines. Acceptance and signature by every pilot of the “Fly-In Agreement” found on their website at www.fantasyofflight.com/flyinagreement.htm Advance Deposits A non-refundable advance deposit of $12.50/per airplane is due with a signed contract to confirm our Organized Fly-In reservation. The deposit may not be transferred. Confirmation/Guarantees Fantasy of Flight requires guaranteed numbers, ten (10) days prior to arrival: Total number of aircraft attending Total number of guests Expected arrival time Expected group meeting time Final Payment Balance is due no later than ten (10) days prior to arrival, based on the guaranteed number of aircraft provided to Fantasy of Flight. No refunds or credits will be given for food and beverage due to cancellations or “no shows.” Let’s Keep ’em Flying! Engine Baffles • Replacement Landing Gear Wire Harness Kits • Stabilator Services • Conduit and Harness Installation Service SOUTHWEST FLORIDA www.comanchegear.com 877-593-6944 Toll-Free 239-404-7524 Cell Cancellations ADVANCE DEPOSIT REFUNDS GIVEN ONLY IF CANCELLATION IS IN WRITING AND IS RECEIVED BY Fantasy of Flight no later than ten (10) business-days prior to your arrival. An advance deposit refund, less $12.50/per plane cancellation fee, will be given. Proof of Insurance All pilots must be personally insured, hold a current pilot certificate and current medical certificate. Individual Pilot Registrations Each pilot will be required to sign and return a “Pilot Registration Form” as provided by their Sales Representative. Each pilot will then be registered for checkin upon arrival. Runway Information Fantasy of Flight’s runways are 5,000 feet and 2,600-feet long. The runways are grass and always kept in top condition. All pilots are required to make their own judgment as to the current condition of the runways. Pilot Rate Includes: Landing Fee Admission to Fantasy of Flight Private one-hour guided tour Specially selected lunch in themed Officers Club All taxes/gratuities: $73.00 per pilot Passenger Rate Includes: Admission to Fantasy of Flight Private one-hour guided tour Specially selected lunch in themed Officers Club All taxes/gratuities: $41.00 per person NOVEMBER 2012 Comanche Flyer • 43 FEATURED FLY-IN Visiting Historic Vicksburg, Miss. by Hugh Hunton 44 • Comanche Flyer NOVEMBER 2012 O n Friday, September 7, summer was still hanging on in the deep South with a forecast high of 100 degrees. That morning, Clara and I loaded 78P to attend a South Central Tribe weekend Comanche Fly-in in Vicksburg, Miss. We took off at 8:00 a.m. and turned east for an expected one-hour flight. Leveling at 5,500 feet where it was smooth and still cool with good enough visibility to enjoy the Louisiana scenery, the Mississippi River soon came into view. What a shock to see the water so low! Overflying the Vicksburg/Tallulah Airport, we saw that several Comanches (and a Cardinal) had already arrived. After landing, we were greeted by our friend and tribe guru Bruce Thumann. He escorted us to Southern Heritage Air Foundation’s big hangar for check-in and beverages. In this hangar was a P-51, a T-6, an Aviat Husky on amphibious floats, a Swearingen SX 300, a meticulously restored Beech 18, and a Beech Barron, ALL in flying status. The Foundation’s Waco happened to be away at the paint shop that day, or else it would have been in the hangar as well. There were also all kinds of artifacts and flying memorabilia in the adjacent rooms. It was a really neat place! The ironclad river gunboat “Cairo” at the Riverboat Museum. Note from your hosts, Bruce and Tina Thumann: Y ou will note that the Vicksburg post fly-in report above was written by SC member and Vicksburg guest Hugh Hunton. That was for two reasons, mainly because Hugh did an excellent job, but just as important, because if I had written the report, I could not have resisted going into great detail about our typical close calls that always seem to haunt any Thumann fly-in. Just so you won’t think this one went off without a hitch and was the beginning of a new era of normalcy for the Thumann fly-ins, here is the short version. 1. Hurricane Isaac went through Vicksburg the weekend before our fly-in (I think Mother Nature had the wrong date down and was one week ahead of schedule!). Although the damage was actually minimal for most in Vicksburg, it did close the Military Park for a day or so, which was our main attraction for the fly-in. NOVEMBER 2012 2. There was only one “black” cloud over Vicksburg Saturday morning, the day of our big event at the Military Park. It let loose just as we were entering the gates of the park. The deluge only lasted long enough to let us know who was in charge of our day, but a slow drizzle “did” serve as a reminder through most of our tour. 3. And for the icing on the cake … we changed hotels only three weeks prior to the fly-in due to bad reviews after the Casino filed bankruptcy at the original hotel. The reviews became such a serious concern that Tina and I actually went back to Vicksburg to stay in the hotel to see for ourselves if the bad reviews were credible. All along, the hotel management insisted that the casino was a separate entity and had not affected the hotel. Long story short, the reviews were credible, and lucky for us, we made the switch to another hotel and casino that very weekend and notified everyone to do the same as soon as we returned from our reconnaissance mission. To say it was a close call would be an understatement. It just so happened that the very weekend of our fly-in was the same weekend we all witnessed moving vans at the original hotel loading up the hotel furnishings for storage. So, if you are living in one of those drought-stricken areas of the country, or even Australia, Africa, or any other “exotic” destination, we are taking money offers to bring floods, hurricanes, or some other form of wet event to your area, disguised as a Comanche Fly-In. Our reputation is well known, and we can practically guarantee water in some form. References available. Disclaimer: Not responsible for devastation beyond our control and/or your expectations. Bruce and Tina Thumann Comanche Fly-Ins “at your own risk.” Comanche Flyer • 45 Bruce’s wife, Tina, soon arrived and loaded us and several other morning arrivals into a van for lunch and a tour of downtown Vicksburg. That evening, the whole group of 28 people gathered for dinner at a fine restaurant in one of Vicksburg’s historic old buildings. It turned out that the building had a long history, but one unique story was that it was the first place shoes were boxed up back in the 1800s. It seems that once shoes started being produced in lefts and rights (pairs), they needed a way to keep the pairs together, and the shoe box was born. Saturday morning at 7:30 a.m., we loaded up into two vans for a visit to the historic National Battlegrounds State Park. The forecasted cool front was passing through so we had to endure several rain showers. Arriving at the park, each van was joined by a park volunteer who narrated the history of the Civil War bat- CLASSIFIEDS • (Two issue minimum) • 25 Words: $50.00/2 issues • 25 Words w/Photo: $70.00/2 issues • Extra Words: $0.40/word • Payment must accompany advertisement order. All advertising must be received by the ICS in writing (mail, fax, or e-mail) five weeks prior to the desired month of publication. Payment must accompany advertisement order. Renewals may be made by telephone, but initial ad must be in writing. The publisher makes no warranties as to the veracity or accuracy of the information provided by the advertiser. The publisher is under no obligation to accept any or all advertisements. International Comanche Society Trading Post & Classified Advertising Contact: tle and the subsequent siege of Vicksburg. It was a two-hour driving tour stopping occasionally to walk through some of the memorials. This was our first time through the park and I guarantee that it will be revisited at a future date! ball which was fired from a Union gunboat still imbedded in one of the walls! After the meal, we were given a tour through the mansion by a lovely lady who really knew the history of the house and its function during the battle. Saturday afternoon was free time for everyone. Clara and I, with a couple from Missouri, visited the historical Vicksburg Civil War Railroad and Riverboat museum. We also toured the ironclad river gunboat “Cairo” that was sunk during the battle and was on display just as it was dug up out of the Mississippi River 100 years later. There was enough wood left to see how the structure was shaped and most of the ironworks, including the paddle wheel, to get a good idea of how the ship was made. It was very interesting! Sunday, we woke up to a beautiful, clear, cool day. The Thumanns shuttled the gang to the airport (located in Louisiana, about 10 miles east of Vicksburg) and since (for once!) we were the closest attendee, Clara and I were able to say our “goodbyes” and watch the early departures fly off into beautiful clear blue skies. We took off at about 10:30 a.m., headed west, and climbed to 4,500 feet in smooth, clear, cool air for our hour flight back to Bluebird Hill Airpark. It was a fun weekend with a lot of fellowship. Thanks to Tina and Bruce for sponsoring another “Great One”! That evening, the attendees dined at Cedar Grove, a B and B that was built around 1840. There is a Civil War cannon Aircraft Wanted (I am a) CASH BUYER for quality Comanche 180. This aircraft is for my personal use, I am not a dealer. I need a solid airworthy airplane that is IFR capable and includes all AD's complied with that I can fly away. No projects please. If you are interested in selling, please contact Mike at 317250-3005 or mamyers215@gmail.com. 1/2 COMANCHES WANTED: All models, runouts OK, needing P&I/Radio upgrades OK, fast discriminate transaction on your ramp 20 years experience/ references. Call Jim, (760) 803-3093. avloc@ yahoo.com. 2/2 Comanches For Sale PA24-180 1959 PA24-180, N6117P, 3766TTAF, 1252SMOH, 191SPOH, Must see rare NDH, price reduced again, Gorgeous “all 9s”, Modern avionics withGarmin 430 IFR Suite, Beautifully restored, Outstanding condition, Very well maintained, Numerous upgrades, “Like new” engine compression, All AD’s, Always hangared, No corrosion, Regularly flown, Complete detailed original logs, Oregon, asking $39,750 /OBO. Call Gabriel or Dave (541) 479-2230, gtjaero@gmail.com. 2/2 PA24-260 1965 260, well maintained IFR. N8651P, S/N 24-4094. TT5540, SMOH1782, Prop1292. New Sky-Tec starter and cables, Stec 50 autopilot, 3-yr new leather interior. King KX155, 170B, KMA, Garmin 496 with XM radar. Paint 6+. Losing medical. All manuals and Powertow included. $69,000. Ken (618)304-4996. 2/2 1962 Comanche 180: s/n 24-3085, approx 2600TTAF. Hangared, needs prop and TLC, good project airplane. Make offer. Call David (516)901-6292. 2/2 Nancy A. Whitten 2779 Aero Park Drive Traverse City, MI 49686 Phone: (800) 773-7798 Fax: (231) 946-9588 E-mail: nancy@villagepress.com 46 • Comanche Flyer 1966 PA260B SN 24-4411 N8954P TTAF 3000, SMOH 1392, Prop SMOH 71 Hrs.Center Stack Panel with 2 King 155's, 6 Seat, Met-Co-Aire Wing Tips, Knots2U Gap Seals, Custom Blue Interior, Electric Trim, Hartzell Prop, 4 Fuel Tanks, 1-Piece NOVEMBER 2012 Windshield, New electric fuel pump, Hangared in Phoenix since I bought it in 1978. Lost Medical, out of Annual, $47,500. Bob (602)996-0800, bobloeb@q.com 2/2 PLACING AN AD? Use this list as a guideline for the information you may want to provide and the order in which to do so. • • • • • • PA30 1967 PA30B: 1330 TT Since New Engs, Props and Airframe. Excellent Condition, Always Hangared. GNS430, GTX 330, MK12D. $72,500. Contact rschub6369@cs.com for details. 2/2 • • • • • • TRADING POST Trading Post is a non-commercial, member to member service provided free of charge, one time per member, per year. The sale of aircraft is not permitted in the Trading Post. • Ads must be submitted in writing only (fax or E-mail OK). • Free ads may not be placed by phone. • First 25 words are free. • Extra words are $0.40 per word. Fax: (231) 946-9588 E-mail: nancy@villagepress.com Parts from 1967 PA-30B: Original tail beacon, two prestolite starters, wing tips with position lights, overhead temperature gage. OTHER: King KR-86 ADF with 42B antennae in the original box, engine oil quick drain, 31 Champion REM 40E spark plugs(need cleaning but good),heater fuel diaphragm, heater shut off valve, Harrison oil cooler model APO9AV06-01,PN 8529245, Harrison oil cooler model APO7AU06-03, PN 8526250, timing light, compression tester, fuel tank selector tray. For information and prices please call 760-873-6429, cell 760-668-0390 or email:lbmcconnell1313@yahoo.com. 2/2 IO-320B1A (PA-30) engine, 403 SMOH, $15K outright, $12.5K w/core exchange, negotiable. PA-30 wings, parts, avionics, engine instruments, all negotiable. Mike (312) 505-2856, Email mabendas@gmail.com. 1/2 NOVEMBER 2012 YEAR, Model Year of Aircraft MODEL, PA 24-180, 250, 260, 400 SERIAL NUMBER, Serial Number of Aircraft N-NUMBER, Registration Number of Aircraft TOTAL AIRFRAME TIME, Total Hours On Airframe AIRFRAME DAMAGE HISTORY, Any Damage History e.g. Gear Up Landing TOTAL ENGINE TIME, Total Hours On Engine Since Factory New or Remanufactured ENGINE TIME SINCE TOP OR MAJOR OVERHAUL PROPELLER TIME, Total Time On Prop Since New or Overhaul ANNUAL INSPECTION DATE FLIGHT INSTRUMENTS, Standard Gyro Panel, Electronic Flight Instrument System RADIO / NAVIGATION EQUIPMENT LISTING, Communications & Navigation Equipment Listing e.g. GPS, ILS, VORs • WEATHER ADVOIDANCE EQUIPMENT, Stormscope, Radar, • SPECIAL EQUIPMENT LISTING, Engine Monitor (EGT, CHT, Fuel Flow, etc.) • AUTOPILOT, Type & Make of Autopilot • INTERCOM • INTERIOR CONDITION & NUMBER OF SEATS • EXTERIOR MODIFICATIONS, Gap Seals, Wing Tips, Speed Mods, Windshield • PAINT CONDITION • HANGERED OR TIED DOWN • AD NOTE COMPLIANCE • GENERAL COMMENTS • ASKING PRICE • CONTACT PHONE NUMBER • CONTACT E-MAIL ABBREVIATION KEY A/C AD’s ADF AH A&P AI A/P AP CDI CHT COM C/R C/T DF DG DME EFIS EGT ELT E/P F/D FGP FWF GPS G/S GSP H/P HP HSI IFR IMC Air Conditioning Airworthiness Directives Automatic Direction Finder Artificial Horizon Airframe & Powerplant Mechanic Aircraft Inspector Audio Panel Autopilot Course Deviation Indicator Cylinder Head Temperature Communication Counter Rotating Carburetor Temperature Direction Finder Directional Gyro Distance Measuring Equipment Electronic Flight Instrument System Exhaust Gas Temperature Emergency Locator Transmitter External Power Plug Flight Director Full Gyro Panel Firewall Forward Global Positioning System Glide Slope Ground Service Plug Heated Pitot Horsepower Horizontal Situation Indicator Instrument Flight Rules Instrument Meteorological Conditions ILS LE LOC LORAN M/B MDH NDH NM NAV OAT OH PET RB R/C RE RG RNAV SB’s SCMOH SFN SFRM SMOH SOH S/N SPOH STOH TBO TT TTAE TTSN XPDR Instrument Landing System Left Engine Localizer (Runway Centerline Guidance) Long Range Navigation System Marker Beacon Major Damage History No Damage History Nautical Miles Navigation Radio Receiver Outside Air Temperature Overhaul Piper Electric Trim Rotating Beacon Rate of Climb Right Engine Retractable Landing Gear Area Navigation Service Bulletins Since Chrome Major Overhaul Since Factory New Since Factory Remanufacture Since Major Overhaul Since Overhaul Serial Number Since Propeller Overhaul Since Top Overhaul Time Between Overhauls Total Time Total Time Airframe and Engine Total Time Since New Transponder Comanche Flyer • 47 ADVERTISING INDEX Aerotech Publications ......................... 3 Aerox ................................................. 43 Air Parts of Lock Haven .................... 15 Aircraft Specialties Services.............. 19 Aircraft Spruce and Specialty ........ 14,48 Alpha Aviation ................................... 15 B & C Specialty Products Inc............ 33 Bogert Aviation ..................................C3 Bruce’s Custom Covers ..................... 42 Clifton Aero ....................................... 30 Comanche Flyer Foundation ............ 11 Comanche Gear ................................ 43 Degroff Aviation Technologies........... 30 General Aviation Modifications ......... 19 Great Lakes Aero Products ............... 33 Hartzell Propeller, Inc. ...................... 17 Heritage Aero, Inc ............................. 41 J.L. Osborne, Inc. .............................. 41 Johnston Aircraft Services ................C4 Knots 2U, Ltd. ...................................C3 Lighthawk ..................................... 13,27 Met-Co-Aire .......................................C3 Mike’s Upholstery ..............................C3 Oilamatic, Inc...................................... 7 Paul Bowen Photography .................... 8 Plane Power .......................................C2 Poplar Grove Airmotive .................... 27 Precision Propeller ............................ 27 Preferred Airparts..............................C2 Questair ............................................. 19 Rocky Mountain Propellers, Inc. ......... 7 Ron & John’s Comanche Service ......... 7 Sky Manor’s Air Repair LLC ............. 13 Sky Tec Partners Ltd ........................C2 Sound Ex Products ............................ 17 Survival Products .............................. 19 Warren Gregoire & Associates .......... 37 Webco Aircraft LLC .......................... 15 Zephyr Aircraft Engines .................... 41 Please support our advertisers! Call Today for Advertising Opportunities Avionics Sales Team Call Toll Free: 800-826-3160 Visit our website for our used Avionics Section FREE! 2012-2013 900+ page Parts Catalog! 48 • Comanche Flyer email us info@aircraftspruce.com John Roddy, Advertising Manager Phone: (231) 946-3712 or 1-800-773-7798, FAX: (231) 946-9588, E-mail: jroddy@villagepress.com NOVEMBER 2012 Over 25 Years serving Comanche Owners Over 25 Years serving Comanche Owners Comply Comply with with SB836 SB836 & & SB836a, SB836a, replacing replacing Battery & Starter Cables. Starter Cables. Battery Comply&with SB836 & SB836a, replacing Replace tired or worn P-Leads Replace tired or worn P-Leads Battery & Starter Cables. Replace Corroded Battery Box Battery Box Replace ReplaceCorroded tired or worn P-Leads Improve Starting Performance Improve Starting Performance Replace Corroded Battery Box Change Bungees in 30 Bungees 30 minutes minutes or or less less Change Improve StartinginPerformance Tow Aircraft with ease with Bogi-Bar Tow Aircraft with ease with Bogi-Bar Change Bungees in 30 minutes or less Perform maintenance with specialized Perform maintenance with specialized Tow Aircraft with ease with Bogi-Bar tools. “Right tool job!” “Right tool for for the thewith job!”specialized tools. Perform maintenance tools. “Right tool for the job!” Tech Savvy Customers Tech SavvyininCustomers See action See products products action !!! !!! www.youtube.com/bogertaviation www.youtube.com/bogertaviation See products in action !!! www.youtube.com/bogertaviation Scan Scan barcode barcode with with Smart Smart Phone Phone to to watch watch Bogert in Hero’s of Manufacturing. Bogert in Hero’s Manufacturing. Scan barcode with of Smart Phone to watch Bogert in Hero’s of Manufacturing.www.bogert-av.com www.bogert-av.com (800) (800) 627-8088 627-8088 or or (509) (509) 736-1513 736-1513 www.bogert-av.com (800) 627-8088 or (509) 736-1513 Aircraft Interiors Standard & Custom Designs LEATHER Naugahyde • Fabric Seats • Headliners • Seat Belts Carpet • Window Trims • Sound Proof • Side Panels Glare Shields • Windows Headrests • Visors • Curtains Call Mike Roney 402-572-8788 ICS #4102 MIKE’S UPHOLSTERY INC. 12303 N. 72nd, North Omaha Airport Omaha, NE 68122 Aircraft Upholstery At Same Location Since 1968 Johnston Aircraft Service now selling and installing Aero-Tech Services’ bladders, and APS “BlackSteel™” brakes AERO-TECH SERVICES TIME-TESTED AND PROVEN TRUE 2-PLY BLADDERS 2-Ply Bladder Lay-up As the diagram represents, Aero-Tech bladders are true 2-ply construction. Both the outer and inner plys are individual layers of raw sheet material. Our proprietary blend of individual rolls. When completely cured and vulcanized this multi-layered construction becomes bonded in one seamless layer creating what many believe to be the most durable bladder on the market. Single-Ply Bladder Lay-up Each ply can be further broken down into layers to show how the sheet material is blended individually during manufacturing. Aero-Tech does not currently manufacture a single-ply bladder. In a singly-ply layup as diagramed, a single layer of raw sheet material is applied and overlapped to complete the assembly. Some manufacturers describe the blended layers of a single-ply or sheet material as multi-ply construction, when in fact it is still only single-ply of material. Bladders backed by a 10-year warranty. should you use APS Brakes? Why should you useWhy APS Brakes? STRENGTH Made from a one-piece forging. Directional grain flow follows the contour of the disc for industryleading strength. No weld to fail. CORROSION RESISTANCE Heat treated after machining for that signature process that resists corrosion. PRECISION MANUFACTURING Precise tolerances and uniform thickness equal top performance and durability. SEMI-METALLIC LININGS • Impregnated with Kevlar® fibers • Last up to 30% longer • Standard with wear indicators Replacement Brake Discs METALLIC LININGS • More durable materials • Better design • Longer wear Johnston Aircraft Service, Inc. wants to extend to you an open invitation to stop in at our facilities and look us over. We have been in the aviation support business since 1947 and have a reputation for quality, reliability, and service. We like, own, work on, and understand “Comanche”. Johnston Aircraft Service P.O. Box 1457 • Tulare, CA 93275 • Phone: (559) 686-1794 or 686-2161 • Fax: (559) 686-9360 e-mail: info@johnstonaircraft.com • Web Site: www.johnstonaircraft.com