Analysis of VSI-DTC Fed 6-phase Synchronous Machines Ibrahim Abuishmais*‡, Waqas M. Arshad*, Sami Kanerva† *ABB Corporate Research, SE-72178 Västerås, Sweden †ABB Oy, Machines, FI-00380 Helsinki, Finland ‡Norwegian University of Science and Technology O.S. Bragstadsplass 2E, 7491 Trondheim, Norway Ibrahim.Abuishmais@elkraft.ntnu.no +47 73594280 Abstract— High power drives with multiphase machine utilizes paralleled legs converters to realize required power. In addition to the reduced rating of the used semiconductor devices, higher redundancy level could be achieved. Being a relatively new technology for the combination of VSI-fed operation and salient pole synchronous machines, a through analysis is needed. This paper investigates 6-phase synchronous machines with emphasis on redundancy, fault conditions, the machine’s behavior under non-sinusoidal voltage profiles and sensitivity of the design parameters. It is shown that new design thinking is required when considering converter-induced machine losses, especially those on the rotor surface. Redundancy study shows the possibility of operating the machine at half load when one supply system is totally or partially lost without exceeding machine’s total losses. When studying fault scenarios, the worst case is found to be 4-phase short circuit (equivalent to 2-phase in a 3-phase machine) for the studied cases. Output from sinus supply voltage study was utilized to understand losses distribution inside the machine and establish an effective comparison with different voltage profiles. A study with square wave and DTC supplies shows higher losses in damper bar, when compared to sinus supply. Voltage profiles of two different DTC schemes are studied which show that with particular well-thought control strategies one can improve the machine losses specially those in the damper bars. performance advantages of a synchronous motor over an induction motor and the DTC superiority over other converter control schemes. The presented work looks at some of the many aspects associated with this relatively new concept of 6-phase salient-pole synchronous motors fed with DTC-controlled voltage source converters. Issues such as motor design parameters sensitivity, behavior during normal, faulty and partially-faulty (redundancy) operations are addressed by considering the interaction between source’s time harmonics and machine’s space harmonics and the relevant additional losses. Keywords—Multiphase machines, synchronous machines design, direct torque control. Fig. 1. Schematic drawing of 6-phase machine stator windings, the two winding sets are 30o displaced. I. INTRODUCTION Many industry segments today are increasingly asking for medium-large motor solutions with traditional demands of high efficiency, high power density, reliability and superior control aspects for variable speed operations along with a new demand of redundancy. Dual stator (or 6-phase) motors with 30 degrees displacement between the two 3-phase windings sets (see Fig. 1), provides a solution with this relatively new demand of redundancy. A 6-phase motor satisfies the reliability demands since one of the systems provides a redundancy in case the other fails. Powering the two sets by two different converters; i) adds more redundancy level particularly if one supplying system fails ii) reduces the size of semiconductor devices used to built the converter making the size of large drive system rating feasible and iii) increase the total system efficiency. The choice of synchronous motors fed with voltage source converters and employing direct torque control (DTC) provides a very competitive solution due to C A a b B II. LITERATURE SURVEY-A HISTORICAL NOTE The increase demand on high generation units in late 1920’s was restricted by the available circuit breaker capacities at that time. In 1929, design engineers proposed the dual stator windings generator as a solution of the high rated current breaking ability [1] followed by the first addressing of such kind of machines in AIEE in 1930 [2]. The generated voltage in the two windings of separate systems was equal in phase which introduced several discussion issues in generator connections and high voltage switching until P. Robert et al [3] proposal to displace the two windings by 300. This in addition to solving the connection issues, also resulted in a reduction in stray losses. In 1973, Fuchs and Rosenberg [4] modeled the machine mathematically, using the orthogonal transformation steady state model describing the machine behavior. It is noticed that the used transformation matrix ignores any mutual effect between the two winding sets. In 1974, Nelson and Krause [5] presented a model of multiphase induction machine. Although the proposed 882 c 2008 IEEE 978-1-4244-1742-1/08/$25.00 c mathematical model can be useful to gain a better understanding, the authors’ assumptions of uniform airgap as well as ignoring the saturation and eddy current effects, makes such model oversimplified to analyze a salient pole machine. However, the authors highlighting of the advantages of the dual stator configuration to achieve higher reliability level and expanded overall drive system availability rate, are valuable. Results of analytical and experimental investigation for 6-phase voltage source inverter driven induction machines were presented in 1983[6],[7]. 6-phase machine model with mutual leakage coupling included was presented by Schiferl and Ong [8], [9]. Back EMF voltage and input current harmonics are also studied. Advantages of multiphase machines, in general, are presented in [10],[4]. A review on multiphase induction machine drives is recently reported in [11]. III. ANALYSIS OF 6-PHASE SYNCHRONOUS MACHINE A. Harmonic Fields The nature of synchronous machines and all AC machine designs in general, e.g. rotor saliency and stator’s slotting, imposes several deviations from the ideal targeted sinusoidal harmonic free fields and smooth DC torque. The investigation of these phenomena is interesting due to its effect on machine performance and efficiency i.e. total losses and output power. To analyze harmonic field’s causes, analytical approach can be applied. This approach depends on classical analysis of the geometrical parameters of the machine and to determine the resultant flux density. To elaborate more, flux density can be obtained by multiplying permeance waves which are function of stator slotting and rotor saliency by MMF waves see (1) [12]. By applying this approach, the harmonics behavior of the machine can be studied analytically. μ0 A 1 . MMF (θ , t ) δ (θ , t ) A = Λ (θ , t ). MMF (θ ,t ) Β(θ , t ) = (2) These harmonics are stationary, in other words the wave speed is zero with respect to the synchronous speed. On the other hand, rotor permeance wave depends on pole symmetry. Studied machine has a symmetrical pole pitch geometry which means that permeance wave has following harmonic orders: j = 1, 2,3,... ±2 j h S &R υ S &R = (3) j = 1, 2, 3,... (5) nhx (θ ) = N h cos(hθ − ζ ) h = 1, 2,3... (6) Where x index refers to the six phases; A, B, C, a, b, and c, the factor N h is the windings factor at different harmonic order, while ζ is the phase shift between the two supply systems. The winding functions for different phases can be expressed as [13]; Nh nh (θ ) = N h cos(hθ ) = A nh (θ ) = N h cos(h{θ − B Nh = 2 (e jh (θ − 2π ) +e 3 − jh ( θ − nh (θ ) = N h cos( h{θ + C Nh 2 (e jh (θ + 2π ) +e 3 − jh ( θ + (e 2 2π ) 3 2π 3 ) − jhθ (7) ) (8) ) = α N h (e h' 2π 3 +e }) 3 2π jhθ − jh ' ) |h ' = ± h }) (9) ) =α −h ' N h (e − jh ' ) |h ' = ± h 2π Where α = e 3 . The three remaining functions for the other supply system can be derived in the same manner. j π Introducing the operator β = e 6 , this indicates the physical displacement between the two systems i.e. 30o in the studied case. Winding function of second stator set can be expressed as: nha (θ ) = β h ' N h (e − jh ' ) |h '=± h (10) n (θ ) = α β N h (e (11) b h h' h' − jh ' ) |h '=± h nhc (θ ) = α − h ' β h ' N h (e − jh ' ) |h '=± h (12) The resultant magneto motive force is expressed as: MMF S (θ , t ) = ¦ nhx (θ ) × ikx (t ) x = A , B .. = ∞ ∞ ¦ ¦{ h '=−∞ k =1 Nh 2 ((1 + β h ' β − k ) + α h 'α k (1 +β h ' β − k ) −h ' All of these harmonics pulsate with twice the synchronous speed. Combined effect of rotor and stator (4) 2) Stator and Rotor MMF Stator MMF is a direct result of its winding, in case of 6-phase machines, windings arrangement is interesting as it results in short circuiting some of machine space harmonics for certain time harmonic orders. Windings as a function of space can be expressed as: j i = 1,2,3,... i, j = 1, 2,3,.. Rotating with speed = slots QS is given by QS = 12. p.qS . Where p is number of pole pairs. Stator spatial harmonics due to slotting can be expressed as h R = 2. j h S & R = 12.qS .i ± 2 j (1) 1) Stator and Rotor Permeance Harmonics Stator permeance harmonics result mainly due to slotting. For a given number of slots per phase per pole qS in 6-phase machine stator, total number of stator h S = 12.q S .i permeance results in a waveform with the following harmonic contents: −k + α α (1 + β β )) I k e k h' j ( kwt − h 'θ ) } (13) Here k is the time harmonic order and the superscript “S” indicates the stator MMF. 2008 13th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference (EPE-PEMC 2008) 883 Using (13), speeds of airgap space harmonics can be predicted at any time harmonic “ k ” (k=1 for the fundamental harmonic of supply current) and the space harmonic h’=1,-5, 7,-11, 13 … etc. It can be noticed that applying different sets of space and time harmonics, results in several harmonics with zero speed, particularly if h '− k = ±6n condition is satisfied, here n is an integer. The common term in (13) i.e. (1 + β be either 0 or 2: h' β −k ) will Fig.2. Airgap fields for a sinus-fed 6-phase synchronous motor. (14) It is clear that harmonic suppression criterion depends on the phase shift between the two different systems as well as the order of the interacted harmonics. On the other hand, rotor’s excitation creates MMF wave containing harmonics rotate with the synchronous speed and have the order hmR = 1,3,5... (15) The situation for a 6-phase machine is provided in TABLE I showing what harmonics are to be expected due to the interaction between different MMFs and various machine permeances. From this information, a preliminary estimation of the machine behavior for a selected design interacting with a certain converter can be made. This increases machine controllability, knowing the close relation between stator MMF harmonics and the electrical phase shift between the two windings sets. To identify field harmonics; an alternative approach is the FEM analysis employing long time stepping solutions. From the knowledge of fields; torques, losses and damper bars currents developed in the machine can be derived. Fig.2 shows main harmonic contents of the airgap flux density during sinus operation. As can be seen, although the 5th and 7th harmonics are present in the airgap (due to rotor pole saliency) they have no impact on torque pulsations. Permeance hm = 1, 3, 5... and i , j = 1, 2, 3, .. 12.qS .i ± hm Rotor saliency 2. j ± hm Combined stator and rotor (+) Combined stator and rotor (-) 2X X 6 12 18 24 28 30 hmR S R 12.qS .i ± hm S R 2. j ± hm 12.q .i + 2. j ± h S 12.q .i − 2. j ± h S S m S m 12.q .i + 2. j ± h R 12.q .i − 2. j ± h R S S m m qS is the number of slots per phase per pole. Superscript “S and R” referred to stator and rotor, respectively. 884 3X R i , j = 1, 2, 3, .. Stator slotting 4X Rotor MMF and hmS 5X Harmonic order hmS = 6 m + 1, m = 0, ±2, ±4, ±6,... Average 6X 0 TABLE I. AIRGAP FLUX DENSITY HARMONICS Stator MMF B. Harmonic Torque and Speed Torque components in synchronous machine are produced mainly by the interaction of stator and rotor fields. Besides the DC torque component that accelerates the machine, pulsating torque components appear at the shaft, these components can be divided into two types, transient and persistent [15]. For persistent non-decaying pulsating components; harmonic orders of developed torque at machine shaft can be predicted utilizing flux linkage components or airgap MMF since it differs only by scale from flux linkage wave. Basically, the produced torque is an interaction between two consecutive flux components resulting in torque with frequency that equals the difference between involved wave’s frequencies, taking into account the direction of rotation. For example the 11th MMF component rotates in negative direction with respect to rotor flux rotating direction. It interacts with DC flux component rotating at synchronous speed resulting in {1(-11)} 12th torque component and same order of the induced damper bars current. See Fig. 3 . Current [A] ­0 if n is odd (1 + β h ' β − k ) = ® ¯2 if n is even Fig. 3. Correlation between developed torque and damper bars current harmonic spectrums. In spite of existence of 5th and 7th (17th, 19th …etc) harmonics in machine’s airgap, these harmonics do not contribute in torque production. The same applies to damper bars induced current. 2008 13th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference (EPE-PEMC 2008) In 6-phase machine’s airgap the fact that the 5th and 7th space harmonics order due to stator MMF are absent results from the combined effect of physical displacement between the two stator windings and electrical phase shift between supplies voltages. It can be concluded that 6th harmonic torque will not appear. Same applies to interpret 18th absence knowing that 17th and 19th MMF components do not exist. On the other hand, airgap fluxes of 6-phase machine contain the same 11th, 13th, 23rd and 25th component’s magnitude compared to three-phase machine which means torque pulsations at frequencies 12th and 24th remain the same in the two different machines. C. 5th, 7th, 17th, 19th Time Harmonics Behavior The discussed 6-phase machine, differs with a 3-phase machine in terms of its response to 5th, 7th, 17th, 19th,… time harmonics. With 300 degree space shift between the two winding sets and with the same electrical phase shift between the supply voltages, certain harmonics disappear from airgap fluxes. A generalized form of required displacement is π / n for even sets number and 2π / n for odd number of sets, where n is number of phases [5]. Analytically, analyzing the MMF wave and its interaction with the different permeance functions explains the phenomena. An alternative analytical way is presented by M. Abbas et al. [6] and T. Jahns [14] using the generalized two-phase real component transformation for n-phase machine. The one can conclude that the excitation voltage time harmonics such as 5th, 7th, 17th, 19th …etc. are prevented from contribution to the airgap flux and torque pulsations while they are contributing in the supply input current. The reactance of these harmonics current paths appears to be relatively small. To verify these analytical conclusions flux paths inside the machine were studied with Finite Element Method (FEM). Applying an input supply containing only one harmonic order e.g. 5th or 7th at a time, field maps and relative permeability of the rotor region were in focus. Fig. 4 shows field maps in four different cases. 5th and 7th harmonic in supply result in flux which is totally linked in stator region only. This leads to same theoretical conclusions that these components will not contribute in torque pulsations or induce any damper bar currents. It also shows that the stator linkage part of the reactance will disappear making the total path reactance small. The same observation can be noticed in case of 17th and 19th time harmonic orders. On the other hand, 11th, 13th …etc harmonic results in flux paths linked throughout the rotor region. Fig. 4. Field maps for different supply harmonics. IV. DESIGN PARAMETERS Sensitivity study for machine’s design parameters is also studied, e.g., teeth dimensions, winding layout, wedge material, damper bars and rotor pole shape. The motivation behind this study is to establish a qualitative comparison between the effects of different design parameters on one of the main studied operating aspects, e.g. machine’s harmonic fields. It is found that the behavior is not much different to a 3-phase machine. One important difference is to think about pole shape induced 5th, 7th, 17th, 19th etc. harmonics in airgap that induce significant stator harmonic currents and thus affecting machine performance. Such an optimization can be combined with a decrease in the airgap length, which results in a decrease in field windings copper loss at the cost of an increase in damper bar losses. V. REDUNDANCY ANALYSIS Using machine with (n) winding systems makes it possible to operate under faulty or partially faulty conditions i.e. open phase or short circuit faults, if each phase’s supply or group of phases is being fed from independent supply, like independent inverters. The investigation of the state of being supplied by (n-1) systems is called redundancy analysis. One of the main motivations behind using the 6-phase or double threephase stator design is to provide a high level of redundancy. Redundancies modes include supply system failure and internal machine faults. In former case losing one supply system means that the machine is driven by three phases out of six in the healthy case. Open phase faults are also considered in this redundancy study. The simulated cases are: 1. Supplying the 6-phase machine with only one three-phase set, the other three phases are blocked by introducing very high external impedance. 2. Lowering the input current of one system by 25%. 3. Lowering the input current of one system by 65%. 2008 13th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference (EPE-PEMC 2008) 885 Simulation results for the first redundancy case are provided in Fig. 5, for 50% load torque. Losing three supply phases out of six but developing the same output torque means that the connected phases have to deliver all the required input power. As Fig. 5 shows the increase in the current magnitudes is approximately 100%, it is also noticeable that the waveforms are not identical i.e. they do not contain same harmonic contents. Total harmonic distortion of the input current decreases from 8.5% in case of healthy six phases supply to 6.47% for the three phase supply case. The most significant components are 5th and 7th with big difference in their magnitudes and phase angles. The reason of less distorted input current is the absence of harmonic low impedance paths, in particular for 5th, 7th, 17th and 19th components. As the correspondent counteracting harmonic MMFs which were generated by the adjacent stator set are absent, these fields are able to link through the rotor. Torque pulsations at 12th and 18th are observed in output torque spectrum. 3Z Current [A] 0 -3Z 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 Fig. 6. Input currents during redundancy case 2. Pre-event Post-event 3Z 92% Post-event 65% 0 0 3Z -Z 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 -2Z 0.3 Time [s] 0.4 0.5 Pre-event Post-event 5Y 4Y 3Y 2Y Y 0 0 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 0.6 0.1 0.2 0.3 Time [s] 0.4 0.5 0.6 Fig. 5. Input current (above) and developed torque during redundancy event. During these redundant conditions, input current was limited by introducing a high external resistance. It is found that the best machine behavior is obtained for case 1. Total machine losses are the lowest compared to the other cases. Input currents for the case 2 and 3 are shown in Fig. 6 and Fig. 7, respectively. for Case 2 where one of the two supplies experiences a partial fault condition causes a reduction of input current approximately by 25%, healthy supply current increases by 68%. Similarly, current reduction in Case 3 by 65% causes an increase in the healthy supply current by 92%. This asymmetry in input currents causes more loss to be dissipated in the two last redundancy cases compared to Case 1. Moreover, torque pulsations like 6th and 18th appear due to asymmetry. Bar losses increase as well. VI. FAULT ANALYSIS Several different fault cases have been studied, namely; 2×three, 2×two and single phase faults. All short circuits are simulated without introducing any fault impedance. Short circuit currents as well as induced currents in the field windings have been investigated. Results show that the 2×2-phase short circuit results in the highest currents, see Fig. 8. Investigation of flux densities during the different fault conditions show that 2×2-phase case results in the highest stator saturation i.e. lowest machine inductances and hence highest short circuit currents. During single phase faulted phase experiences an increase in the magnitude as expected, but the adjacent phases also experience such an increase. (a) 6 Current P.U. 0.2 7Y 6Y 0.6 Time [s] Fig. 7. Input currents during redundancy case 3. 0.1 0 -5 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 Time [s] 0.5 0.6 0.7 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 Time [s] 0.5 0.6 0.7 4 Current P.U. -3Z 0 Torque [N.m] 0.6 Time [s] Z 886 Post-event 25% 2Z Current [A] Pre-event 68% Current [A] Pre-event 3Z 3 1 0 2008 13th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference (EPE-PEMC 2008) (b) 0 -2 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 Time [s] 0.5 0.6 0.7 Current P.U. 6 1 0 T 0.95T 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 Time [s] 0.5 0.6 0.7 Faulted phase Current P.U. 1.05T 4 (c) 5 0 Adjacent phases -5 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 Time [s] 0.5 0.6 0.7 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 Time [s] 0.5 0.6 0.7 4 Current P.U. Normal Supply Square-wave supply 1.1T 2 Torque [Nm] Current P.U. 4 2 0 Fig. 8. Per unit phase (above) and field current (down) for: (a) 2×threephase fault, (b) 2×two phase-fault condition and (c) single phase fault. VII. SUPPLY WAVEFORMS Different supply voltage waveforms have been simulated. The aim is to investigate the impact of supply voltage waveform on harmonic fields, machine losses and developed torque. The studied voltage waveforms are: 1. Sinusoidal voltage: the ideal supply waveform. 2. Square wave voltage: With π / 4 P.U. peak and with 1 P.U. peak. 3. Voltage Source Inverter “VSI” waveforms: DTC scheme. Analyzing the machine under square wave supply facilitate understanding of machine’s behavior avoiding the complexity of simulating the stepped voltage waveforms as in DTC case. However, both are presented here. Motivation behind studying two different square waves with different magnitudes is to show the effect of increased voltages i.e. higher flux level, than that the machine is designed for. It is found that the square wave supply results in high magnitudes of THD in stator currents and voltage supply (25-50% higher than sinus cases) and about 5-20% higher losses in total. Instantaneous developed torque in case of sinus and square wave with fundamental component equaling rated voltage (i.e. π / 4 P.U.) peak, are shown in Fig. 9. The torques have same DC value, but higher frequency torque pulsations arise for the later case. An increase of approximately 340% in pulsating magnitude for 12th and 24th components was found. 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 Time [s] 0.35 0.4 0.45 0.5 Fig. 9. Developed torque versus time at sinus and square wave supply voltages. Direct torque control “DTC” scheme embeds the control of the motor and supply inverter together. Switching of inverter devices is dependant upon the electromagnetic state inside the motor. Control signals are produced after comparing reference torque and flux values with real time values and error band limited by hysteresis control method. Such scheme leads to stepped voltage with high harmonic contents and variable switching frequency. The DTC although can have high THD in supply voltage, the magnitude in stator currents is considerably lower and with almost the same total losses as for the sinus case, showing the effectiveness of the DTC solution as far as power density of the motor is concerned. For input voltage and current waveforms see [16] . TABLE II compares the three studied cases. TABLE II. COMPARISON BETWEEN SINUS AND NON-SINUS VOLTAGE WAVEFORM: THD, LOSSES AND MAIN TORQUE PULSATION.* Sinus Square wave DTC THDi - ++ + THDv - ++ + Ȉ Losses + ++ - Iron Loss - = = Field winding loss 6th torque pulsation + ++ - = + = * Here “-, +, ++” indicate an increase in magnitude while “=” sign indicates fairly compared figures. CONCLUSION A through analysis of VSI-DTC fed synchronous machines is presented in the paper. Such drive arrangement has been proved to provide a competitive alternative for high power drive systems that demand a high reliability operating conditions. The sensitivity study of design parameters showed the possibility to optimize the machine gaining a higher efficiency level by reducing some of the losses. Redundancy analysis showed the possibility of operating the machine at half load when one supply system is totally or partially lost without exceeding machine’s total losses. Saturation level inside the machine varies with fault type that affects fault current as well as field windings induced current during the fault. One natural continuation of this work is to do a multilevel optimization modal where the machine and the converter are optimized together. 2008 13th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference (EPE-PEMC 2008) 887 ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors would like to acknowledge the support from Prof. Tore Undeland (NTNU, Norway), Sonja Lundmark (Chalmers University of Technology, Sweden), Heinz Lendenmann (ABB Corporate Research, Sweden) and Fredrick Kieferndorf (ABB Corporate Research, Switzerland). REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] 888 T. F. Baron, “The double winding generator”, General Electric Review, June 1929. pp. 302-308. P. L. Alger, E. H. Freburghouse and D. D. Chase, “Double windings for turbine alternators”, AIEE Transaction, January 1930, pp. 226-244. R. Robert, J Dispaux and J. Dacier. “Improvement of turboalternators efficiency”, Cigre Meeting, June 8-18, 1966. E. F. Fuchs, and L. T. Rosenberg, "Analysis of an alternator with two displaced stator windings," IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol. 93, No. 6, 1974, pp. 1776-1786. R. H. Nelson, P. C. Krause, “Induction machine analysis for arbitrary displacement between multiple winding sets”, IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol. PAS-93, Issue 3. 1974. pp 841-848. M. Abbas, R. Christen, and T. Jahns, “Six-phase voltage source inverter driven induction motor”, Conference record of 18th annual meeting of IEEE industry application society 1983, pp 503-511. M. Abbas and R. Christen, “Characteristics of a high-power density six-phase induction motor”, Conference record of 18th annual meeting of IEEE industry application society 1984, pp 494-501. [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] R. F. Schiferl, C. M. Ong., “Six-phase synchronous machine with AC and DC stator connection part I: equivalent circuit representation and steady-state analysis”, IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol. PAS-102, No. 8, August 1983. R. F. Schiferl, C. M. Ong., “Six-phase synchronous machine with AC and DC stator connection part II: harmonic study and a proposal uninterruptible power supply scheme”, IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol. PAS-102, No. 8, August 1983. L. Paras, “On advantages of multi-phase machines”, 31st annual conference of IEEE industrial electronic society record, IECON 2005. pp 1574-1579. E. Levi, R. Bojoi, F. Profumo, H.A. Toliyat and S. Williamson, “Multiphase induction motor drives: a technology status review”, IET Electrical power application, Vol. 1, No. 4, July 2007. pp 489-516. S. Toader, “Combined analytical and finite element approach to the filed harmonics and magnetic forces in synchronous machines”, ICEM conference record. Manchester 1994. D.G. Dorrell, C. Y. Leong, and R. A. McMahon., “Analysis and performance assessment of six-pulse inverter-fed three-phase and six-phase induction machines”, IEEE transaction on industry applications, Vol. 42, No. 6, November/December 2006. T. M. Jahns, “Improved reliability in solid state ac drives by means of multiple independent phase-drive units”, PhD dissertation at Massachusetts Institute of Technology-MIT. April 1978. IEEE Std. 1255-2000, “IEEE guide for evaluation of torque pulsations during starting of synchronous motors”, IEEE-SA standards board, August 2000. F. Kieferndorf, H. Burzanowska, S. Kanerva and P. Sario, “Modeling of rotor based harmonics in dual-star, wound field, synchronous machines”. Accepted for ICEM 2008, unpublished. 2008 13th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference (EPE-PEMC 2008)