UK Parking Qualifications Strategy Page 1 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY…..……………………………………………………………..……………………….......3 2 SCOPE OF THE QUALIFICATIONS STRATEGY 2.1 Overall scope of the qualifications strategy .................................................... 5 2.2 Priorities within the overall scope ............................................................... 11 3 SECTOR WORKING ENVIRONMENT 3.1 Special features or characteristics .............................................................. 16 3.2 Future trends........................................................................................... 17 4 CURRENT QUALIFICATIONS AND OTHER LEARNING PROVISION 4.1 Main qualification types............................................................................. 19 4.2 Current volumes ...................................................................................... 21 4.3 Match to employers’ needs ........................................................................ 22 5 5.1 6 OTHER SECTOR USES OF QUALIFICATIONS Consumer protection ................................................................................ 24 HOW THE BRITISH PARKING ASSOCIATION WILL HELP REALISE THE FUTURE 6.1 Vision of future qualifications ..................................................................... 26 6.2 Past and future dialogues .......................................................................... 27 6.3 Practical help ........................................................................................... 28 6.4 Future evolution of the qualifications strategy .............................................. 28 Page 2 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The British Parking Association is the standards setting body for the UK parking sector and as such has taken responsibility for advancing the skills agenda for the sector. It is the largest professional association in the UK representing organisations in the parking and traffic management industry. The BPA has around 700 member organisations equally split between the public and private sector. The parking sector requires a clear route map to enable it to get from where it currently is to the position of having a clear skills and qualifications framework in place. This qualifications strategy (QS) provides the vehicle to refocus and be explicitly clear about the priorities for the professional development of the parking sector, obtain a more detailed understanding of the practical action needed to achieve these priorities and the resources required to implement the actions. The UK Parking Sector Skills Strategy set out a number of clear aims to improve and develop the skills, knowledge, qualifications and professionalism of the sector’s workforce and to create a learning culture in the sector. It is essential that the QS is developed in a way to achieve these aims and that activity is focused on the essential building blocks for the creation of a parking profession. A series of research documents, including the UK Parking Sector Skills Strategy has been used as a base for the QS. As far as was possible these reports utilised the available national secondary data sources, for example Annual Business Inquiry, Annual Population Survey 2006 and 2001 Census. Qualitative research was also commissioned to inform the skills needs and skills supply assessments. Unfortunately, the parking sector does not have appropriate standard industry classifications and only two parking occupations are currently separately identified in national statistics. The weakness in the data sets makes the task of profiling the parking sector and workforce particularly difficult. To summarise the main findings, the parking sector has a consistently high proportion of the workforce with no or below level-2 (level-5 SCQF) qualifications and skills gaps were identified in the most essential skill and knowledge areas such as the law, customer service and communications. Research for the skills strategy confirmed that there are very few nationally accredited parking qualifications, those available cover front line operational occupations only. The sector currently has only one suite of NOS, it too applies to the front line operational workforce. There is very low uptake in parking qualifications across the FE sector in all four nations. Page 3 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final This vicious circle perpetuates the low skills trap and prevents the sector from moving towards its vision of providing excellent service to the community through the knowledge, skills and professionalism of the workforce. Legislation and technology were identified as the main drivers of skills change within the sector, including civil parking enforcement and the extension of CCTV enforcement. Whilst there are broad similarities between the four nations in relation to their skills policies, there are differences in both how the devolved administrations organise the parking sector and variations in how far they have adopted the legislative framework which will need to be addressed. Starting from this low base it is essential that the sector is enabled and supported to confidently articulate its qualification needs to providers and for providers to be reassured that the sector is serious about up-skilling its workforce. The BPA is committed to providing leadership to the sector in learning, skills and qualifications. To achieve this goal, two overarching priorities have been developed. The first priority is to build full functional and occupational maps for sector occupations and work activities thereby charting the groups for whom vocational qualifications are appropriate and the related standards. The process will identify gaps, reveal where updates are necessary and classify existing applicable generic qualifications. Priority areas for nationally accredited qualification development are CCTV enforcement, notice processing and car park attendant. The priority for national occupational standards development is administration and notice processing. Parking management has been identified as a priority area for the development of specialist modules that can be accessed either as stand alone units of learning or in conjunction with generic qualifications. The second priority is to develop a recognised career pathway, linked to qualifications, that for the first time gives learners the opportunity to progress flexibly in the sector and helps employers to establish a learning culture. Clearer signposting of possible progression opportunities should help increase the demand for learning within the sector. These actions will enable the sector to establish clear priorities for learning and skills and to conduct a more informed dialogue with providers and funding agencies, driving up both the supply and demand for skills. Page 4 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final 2 SCOPE OF THE QUALIFICATIONS STRATEGY 2.1 Overall scope of the qualifications strategy 2.1.1 The UK Parking Sector The UK parking sector covers a diverse range of activities in the public and private sectors. Broadly speaking it covers the following activities: • Local authorities responsible for traffic management as well as both on-street and off-street parking activities • Private sector operators responsible for off-street parking, for example, car parks, hospitals, railway stations, supermarkets and airport parking sites • Private sector subcontractors working on on-street parking • Specialist learning providers and consultants advising both on- and off-street operations • Specialist equipment manufacturers and suppliers (e.g. pay and display machines) • Operators carrying out specialist activities such as vehicle immobilising, vehicle removal and debt recovery (bailiffs) and so on It has been estimated that the parking sector employs about 60,000 people in the UK1. Of these: • 18,000 work on-street • 24,500 work in off-street activities • 10,000 are office-based • 3,000 are in management positions • 5,000 are in support services (for example, finance, human resources) Employers in the parking sector span both the private and public sector. Within local government in England, Scotland and Wales, parking is usually, although by no means exclusively, a function that is linked to the wider highways and transportation function. Within Great Britain there are currently 442 local authorities divided between the three nations as follows: • • • England - 388 local councils (including unitary, county, borough and district authorities) Scotland - 32 unitary councils Wales - 22 unitary councils Whilst parking in local government ranges from large parking units in metropolitan areas employing hundreds of people, to small rural districts where one person may take on responsibility for parking, it nevertheless is an extremely important function within local government and one that has a fundamental impact on everyday life in 1 UK Parking Sector Skills Strategy, British Parking Association, 2007, page 16. Page 5 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final towns and cities across the UK. Over 200 councils across the UK now have some form of civil parking enforcement. In Northern Ireland parking is dealt with differently, where it is managed by the Department for Regional Development. Within the private sector, employment within the parking sector tends to be dominated by a number of very large ‘national’ organisations. The services provided include responsibility for off-street parking, for example car parks, hospitals, railway stations, supermarkets and airport parking sites. In addition there are some private sector subcontractors working on on-street parking. 6.4.1.1 Standard Occupational Classification / Standard Industrial Classification Parking appears under SIC code 63.21 ‘other supporting transport activities’ which is extremely broad and includes activities that fall outside of the private parking sector. In addition the code excludes private sector on-street contractors and vehicle removal companies. The code also excludes the large number of local government employees engaged in the parking profession which are classified under the SIC codes concerning public administration. The SOC codes only enable identification of data for ‘traffic wardens’ and ‘car park attendants’. The BPA is committed to lobbying ONS to improve the relevance of the classification codes in relation to the industry. In the meantime, a feasibility study will be considered to review if the industry will support a basic employer LMI benchmarking survey. The sector has experienced significant growth in the workforce over the period 1998 – 2005, with employment increasing by about 145% (40,352 jobs) across Great Britain, however, due to issues with the SIC code the data cannot be analysed to determine whether this growth is specific to the parking sector. The largest increase in numbers has been in London, which accounted for well over 50% of all such growth in Great Britain. London contained the highest level of employment (47%) for this parking SIC code and is undoubtedly the centre of activity in relation to other supporting land transport activities. The North West (11% of employment) and Yorkshire and the Humber (8%) also had a relatively large share of employment at this time. 2.1.2 Occupations covered The UK parking sector is necessarily diverse, with a wide range of occupations from strategic level parking managers, to tactician-focused contract managers to a large base of operational staff. The following table 2.1 maps parking sector occupations against generic qualifications. Page 6 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final Table 2.1 Parking sector occupations NQF and FHEQ England, Northern Ireland and Wales Level-8 / D Doctorate SCQF Scotland Managing director, chief executive Level-7 / M Masters SCQF level-11 Masters, SVQ 5 Parking manager, area manager, parking operations manager Level-6 / H Honours degree SCQF level-10 SCQF level-12 Doctorate Honours Degree Contract manager, contract compliance manager, manager of several car parks, call centre manager, debt recovery manager, correspondence manager Level-5 / I HND, Foundation degree SCQF level-8 Assistant operations manager, contract manager, contract compliance officer, permit supervisor, call centre supervisor Level-4 / C Certificate of Higher Education, NVQ level-44 SCQF level-7 Parking attendant supervisor (onstreet, off-street), civil enforcement officer supervisor, pound supervisor, permits officer, debt recovery officer, appeals officer, representations officer, correspondence officer Level-3 NVQ level-3, A-levels SVQ level-3, can sit at SCQF level-6 or 7, Higher SCQF level-6 SCQF level-5 / 6 Intermediate level-2 / Credit Standard Grade at SCQF level-5 Senior on-street parking attendant / civil enforcement officer, senior off-street parking attendant, dispatch controller Level-2 / 3 SCQF level-5 Intermediate level-2 / Credit Standard Grade at SCQF level-5 Parking attendant, civil enforcement officer, vehicle immobiliser, removal truck driver, pound officer, administrative assistant, closed-circuit television enforcement operator, call centre operator, customer service officer Level-2 GCSEs at A to C, NVQ 2 Intermediate level-2 / Credit Standard Grade at SCQF level-5 Trainee parking attendant / civil enforcement officer, trainee administrator / notice processor Level-1 GCSEs at D to G, NVQ 1 Higher National Diploma SVQ 4 can sit at SCQF level-8 or 9 Higher National Certificate HNC SCQF level-6 SVQ level-2 sits at SCQF level-5 SCQF level-4 Page 7 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final Intermediate level-1 / General standard grade, SVQ level-1 sits at SCQF level-4 2.1.3 Population of learners Research for the UK Parking Sector Skills Strategy estimated the sector employs some 60,000 people covering the breadth of the UK parking sector including those working in equipment manufacturing and supply, debt recovery and other specialist activities. This qualifications strategy is intended to clarify and support learning for those involved or wishing to become involved in activities which are core to parking and not represented within the footprints of other SSCs. The BPA is aware that as with all sectors there are overlap areas, for example transport planners sit with GoSkills. The intention is to update skills and encourage career progression for those already within the sector as well as improving recognition and attractiveness of the sector as a profession to those seeking employment. The parking sector in the UK has a high proportion of traffic wardens2 and an extremely high proportion of car park attendants that are male (about 90% of the workforce comparative to 53% for all occupations). Female car park attendants and traffic wardens generally appear to have higher qualification levels than their male counterparts. The proportion of car park attendants and traffic wardens with no qualifications are concentrated in the 35+ age bands. The Annual Population Survey 2006 and 2001 Census indicated that the parking sector has been particularly successful in attracting workers from black and minority ethnic backgrounds in London. Outside of London however, there is scope for attracting a more ethnically diverse workforce. • 71% of traffic wardens are white, which compares with a figure of 92% for all occupations in the UK. • 82% of car park attendants are white, which again compares with a figure of 92% for all occupations in the UK. There is a consistently high proportion of traffic wardens and car park attendants across England, Wales, Northern Ireland with below level-2 or no qualifications (see table 2.2). Data for Scotland is not directly comparable but there would appear to be a similar profile. Table 2.2: Proportion of traffic wardens and car park attendants with no qualifications by nation Nation Traffic wardens Car park attendants England 28% 43% Northern Ireland 40% 60% Wales 31% 54% Scotland 41% 45% UK 30% 44% UK (all sectors) 10% 10% Source: 2001 Census and APS 2006 2 Traffic warden and car park attendant are currently the only two standard occupational classification (SOC) codes available for the parking sector. It is noted that these categories are not in keeping with standard industry terminology. Page 8 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final For an employer, the problems that can be related to a poorly qualified workforce include lower productivity, profitability and efficiency. Failure to invest in development can lead to poor morale and motivation which affects performance and can result in costly higher turnover. Research commissioned by the BPA indicated that a lot of operational staff moved on because of the lack of development opportunities or clarity of progression routes3. In a changing environment an adaptable, flexible and skilled workforce is essential to maintain a competitive edge and provide excellent services. A predominately unqualified workforce is likely to be less confident about change and take longer to implement changes and adapt working practices. In England and Wales, the transition from parking attendants to civil enforcement officers (CEOs) and the recommendation that all new and existing CEOs hold a level-2 nationally accredited qualification is a significant challenge for the sector. The BPA is seeking to tackle these issues by: developing and maintaining accredited parking qualifications, developing and maintaining the specialist learning modules and units of learning and achievement, promoting the use of specialist parking modules and units as options within general qualifications, developing and maintaining national occupational standards. 2.1.4 Range of current provision Employers use a range of generic qualifications in subjects such as customer services, leadership and management, business administration etc. The formal qualifications types held within the parking sector are: • Scottish and national vocational qualifications (S/NVQs) • Vocationally related qualifications (VRQs) • Higher education qualifications • Customised qualifications There are few nationally accredited parking qualifications specifically related to the sector and they are concentrated at NQF level-2 (equivalent to SCQF level-5). The S/NVQ level-2 in Controlling Parking Areas is being updated during 2008 and from 2009 will offer five pathways: parking control, barrier and pay station control, vehicle immobilisation, vehicle removal and CCTV enforcement. Other recent changes include the replacement of the level-2 certificate for parking attendants with the VRQ level-2 award for civil enforcement officers (parking) which sits on the QCF. The two level-3 qualifications, supervising parking areas and parking clerical, have both expired. It would appear that these were not fit for purpose and subsequently there was poor take up. Work undertaken to inform this qualification strategy has highlighted the need to revisit qualification provision for these occupations, underpinning the need for a functional and occupational mapping exercise. 3 Parking Workforce Survey February 2006 Turquoise Thinking Ltd Page 9 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final By the end of 2009 the BPA will have facilitated the development of a nationally accredited award for notice processing in conjunction with City & Guilds. The BPA’s strategy is to make available specific underpinning parking knowledge in VRQs and to then encourage learners to migrate into existing generic qualifications, for example, team leadership, business administration and management. This provides a learning pathway with both technical and generic elements and widens the choice for development. Table 2.3 Qualifications available to the parking sector 2008 Qualification England Wales Scotland Northern Ireland S/NVQ level-2 Controlling Parking Areas ● ● ● ● ● ● + + ● ● * * BTEC level-2 Award in Vehicle Immobilisation VRQ level-2 Award for Civil Enforcement Officers (Parking) + This qualification is linked to the SIA licence to practise for vehicle immobilisers. Vehicle immobilising on private land is unlawful in Scotland, local authorities can choose to immobilise if they wish, but rarely do so. The SIA currently has no remit in Northern Ireland so SIA licences to practise are not required. * The devolved administrations in Scotland and Northern Ireland have not adopted the legislation in full at this time. However, the role is essentially the same and therefore the award is relevant. There are currently three customised intermediate awards concerning decriminalised parking and CCTV enforcement. The CCTV enforcement award was developed out of a specific need in London and it is intended to develop a nationally accredited CCTV qualification by the end of 2009. This is in anticipation of increased demand due to the expected extension of CCTV enforcement powers throughout England and Wales in 2009. The sector also benefits from non-qualification based provision including: • Continuous professional development opportunities • Unaccredited training by employers and private learning providers • Informal and semi-structured work-based learning including induction training It is the BPA’s vision that the Institute of Parking Professionals (IPP) will grow the capacity to administer and develop from the wealth of existing unaccredited activity, a Page 10 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final range of accredited parking learning and development that will update professionals and contribute to their continuing professional development. The overwhelming conclusion from the skills needs assessment, assessment of current provision and resulting gap analysis (January 2008) showed that there is a very low uptake in parking qualifications across the FE sector in all four nations. This very low uptake also means that the parking sector does not appear to benefit from government funding designed to increase participation in provision within the FE sector (in England currently under Train to Gain4). 2.2 Priorities within the overall scope The vision expressed for the parking sector can be summarised ‘from activity to profession’. The UK Parking Sector Skills Strategy states that “our vision is of a vibrant parking sector that provides excellent service to the community through the knowledge, skills and professionalism of the workforce”. Currently the parking sector only has one suite of national occupational standards (NOS) that apply to the front-line, operational workforce. The BPA has applied for funding to develop functional and occupational maps to identify where further NOS are required. Concurrently the BPA is developing specialist NOS, in conjunction with the Council for Administration, for notice processing staff. The research underpinning the UK Parking Sector Skills Strategy and further skills needs analyses identified the following major learning and qualification issues in the parking sector. Due to the importance of these occupations, some of these areas are already being addressed. • There are significant skills gaps even in the most essential skills and knowledge areas for example, communication, the law and customer service. • There are gaps in sector specific qualifications and several occupational groups that are currently not served by a nationally accredited qualification. Whilst generic qualifications would be suitable for some occupations it is considered that a case can be made for specific qualifications for: • o parking managers o car park attendants o administrators / notice processors in parking back-offices o closed-circuit television parking and traffic enforcement The absence of a clear and structured suite of qualifications is a barrier to sector entry, progression and retention. Specifically there are significant gaps at supervisory and management levels which impede career progress. 4 The Learning and Skills Council’s Train to Gain service provides impartial, independent advice on training to businesses across England. Train to Gain provides access to a skills broker who carries out a needs analysis of training and helps assess current and future skills needs. The broker also explores funding opportunities for training, including funding available from public sources to support the government’s skills agenda. Page 11 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final • The parking sector does not have any apprenticeships relevant to parking occupations. • Legislation and technology were identified as the main drivers of skills change within the sector across the UK. In particular, in England and Wales, it is anticipated that the implementation of the Traffic Management Act 2004 and associated regulations will significantly increase the demand for qualifications and skills development. To address these issues and move towards the achievement of the sector’s vision, two overarching strategic objectives have been developed. These incorporate the key priorities in terms of development activity needed to ensure that a relevant qualification framework is available and ensuring there is a sound structure for employers to access and enable their use of the qualifications. 2.2.1 Priorities for qualification reform • To develop a full functional and occupational map for the sector To develop a framework of national occupational standards and vocational qualifications for the parking sector it is essential to define all the occupations that make up the profession (the occupational map) and all the work activities that are included within these occupations (the functional map) across the four nations. The occupational map will enable the UK parking sector to determine all those groups within the sector for whom vocational qualifications may be appropriate. The functional map will facilitate the definition of the work activities for which an occupational standard could be set. This will enable the identification of potentially relevant occupational standards that the parking sector might use within its qualification framework and highlight any gaps. The analysis will be used to inform qualification reform and provide the basis for an ongoing and detailed dialogue about relevant qualifications and development with employers, awarding bodies, funding agencies and learning providers. In recognition that no sector is wholly self-contained the mapping process will seek to engage with other sector skills councils and standards setting bodies to refine areas of overlap. This work will also support the BPA in its lobbying of the ONS to improve the relevance of SIC and SOC codes for the parking sector. • To develop a recognised career pathway linked to qualifications The work on the occupational and functional mapping priority will directly feed into the second priority which is to provide career development information, enabling the UK parking sector to show the routes and pathways to qualification for each Page 12 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final occupation and bring together information that includes academic and professional awards, S/NVQs and other related vocational qualifications. ‘Job families’ can be identified and their transferable skills mapped, which will enable the workforce to assess any gaps in their skills set and facilitate progression. This will assist the BPA to work closely with employers, awarding bodies, funding agencies and learning providers to establish a more structured suite of relevant qualifications and development that supports the workforce linked to the sector’s career pathways. The development of clear pathways enables learners to progress flexibly (both ‘vertically’ and ‘horizontally’) within the sector using qualifications and development to further their skills, knowledge and understanding. The establishment of career pathways contributes to the development of learning cultures within organisations. 2.2.2 Links 2.2.2.1 Skills and other policy drivers Within each of the four UK home nations there is an underlying and common recognition that the development of skills is key to improving productivity in each nation. Although quite different and distinct policy frameworks exist within each nation, briefly outlined below, it is clear that all the home nations consider that better skills are key to improving individual life chances. In particular, it is generally recognised that the increasing pace of technological change requires a flexible and adaptive workforce that is ready to re-skill and re-train to keep pace with the economy’s skills needs. To summarise, the common policy threads with particular application to the parking sector include: • • • • • Placing an increasing emphasis on skills for the employed. Placing a focus on those who have not achieved a NQF level-2 / SCQF level-5 qualification. Developing more flexible qualifications and dividing more qualifications into units so that accreditation can be built up more easily. There is also recognition of the need to speed up accreditation of qualifications and improve the assessment of people’s existing skills and knowledge. Increasing the use of ICT to deliver and assess learning. Ensuring the FE and HE sectors seek to meet the needs of employers. Principal Policy links England The Leitch Review set out recommendations for the optimal level of skills in the economy, estimated levels of investment required and made the case for effective development and deployment of employees’ skills. Qualifications are to be employerled and there is an emphasis on overcoming barriers to training and upskilling. In addition, Leitch calls for ‘fit for purpose’ provision delivering the skills the sector requires. Page 13 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final The BPA is currently working with awarding bodies to update the NVQ level-2 in controlling parking areas which is due to expire in 2008. The BPA intends for the qualification to migrate to the Qualifications and Credit Framework (QCF). The LSC’s ‘Agenda for Change’ has highlighted the need for further consultations with further education bodies. This is particularly significant given the low take up of the limited FE provision. The BPA is committed to ensure that the FE sector is better engaged to provide the skills, learning and qualification opportunities the parking sector requires. The Foundation Learning Tier involves the reform of provision below level-2 for all learners over the age of 14 working below this level. This includes 14 to 19 year olds, adults with skills gaps and adults or young people with learning difficulties/disabilities. The BPA will identify and review entry levels to the profession and where appropriate encourage targeted and suitable provision. However, it should be noted that both the TMA and SIA licensing requirements recommend a minimum entry NQF level-2 qualification. Principal Policy links Wales Many of the education and skills policies in England are also applicable in Wales. In particular the QCF in England is planned to dovetail seamlessly with the CQFW in Wales, the main difference being the inclusion of higher education in the framework in Wales. The BPA organised its first Welsh national group meeting in September 2008. This forum will enable the BPA to strengthen their engagement with Welsh employers. The Wales Workplace Learning Review initiative highlights the need for management and leadership skills. The development of higher level parking management qualifications will align with this goal. Principal Policy links Northern Ireland The implementation of the Essential Skills for Living Strategy and Action Plan for Adult Literacy (2002) is of particular importance to the workforce development activities of the parking sector in Northern Ireland because of the high concentration of the parking workforce with no qualifications. The Skills Strategy for Northern Ireland (2004) sets out an overarching framework for the development of skills including essential skills, employability skills and work-based skills. Success through Skills (2006) sets out a vision to deliver high productivity, increased global competitiveness, a future in the global marketplace and enabling people to progress up a skills ladder in order to raise the skills levels of the whole workforce. Improving the appropriateness and supply of qualifications, and providing the sector with better career pathways information should drive up the demand for learning. Page 14 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final Principal Policy links Scotland Scotland has a well developed network of programmes and initiatives addressing skills development. The four key documents define the way in which work in relation to skills has been directed. The Framework for Economic Development in Scotland deals with overall economic policy. A Smart Successful Scotland sets out the strategic direction for the Enterprise Networks’ activities. Life through Learning; Learning through Life sets out the key challenges facing Scotland including technological change, population change and closing the opportunity gap. Most recently Skills for Scotland: a Lifelong Skills Strategy (2007) shows how all of the constituent parts of the Scottish education and learning systems can contribute to a world class skills base. At the heart of these strategies is the recognition that future prosperity and success, both as a nation and as individuals, will depend on the strength of the match between the skills of the workforce and the changing needs of employers. The BPA intends to work with the SQA to ensure as far as possible qualifications are relevant and included in the SCQF. Improving the information available to employers through case studies, national meeting networks and the learning & development forum should help to encourage the take up of qualifications. 2.2.2.2 Specific legislative drivers Decriminalised parking enforcement (DPE) is the process whereby responsibility for traffic enforcement transferred from the police to local authorities throughout the UK. With the implementation of the Traffic Management Act 2004 in England and Wales on 31st March 2008, the process is now known as civil parking enforcement (CPE). Parking attendants in Wales and England are now known as civil enforcement officers. The linked Parking Policy and Enforcement Operational Guidance to local authorities recommended that new and existing civil enforcement officers hold a level-2 nationally accredited qualification listed on the national qualification framework that is crossreferenced to the national occupational standards in parking control. In addition, it is possible that authorities will grow the role and include a wider range of enforcement or a wider ‘neighbourhood warden-type’ activities. The devolved administrations in Northern Ireland and Scotland have not adopted the new legislation in full. However, the front line role remains essentially the same across the four nations and the qualification, which reflects good practice, is therefore relevant and fit for purpose. Page 15 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final 3 SECTOR WORKING ENVIRONMENT 3.1 Special features or characteristics 3.1.1 Barriers to access Parking employers face a range of barriers to access to learning. There are a limited number of providers offering a narrow range of qualifications. The Scottish / national vocational qualification option is limited due to the very few occupationally competent assessors available for work-based assessment. Additionally a significant proportion of the workforce work in shift patterns which is an additional challenge to accessing classroom-based provision. It can be disproportionately costly to carry out workbased assessment for many operational staff as they often work alone, for example, out on patrol. For many specific learning needs it is unlikely there will be sufficient numbers to commission local provision. This is also the case for certain groups of staff like senior managers. This places an additional, often prohibitive, cost burden (travel, accommodation, etc) on employers as they are forced to seek provision further afield. In rural areas this situation is also true for operational staff. The BPA will prioritise better engagement with the FE sector in order to address some of these barriers. It is also committed to review and revise the range and quality of information provided to employers about Scottish and national vocational qualifications in order to facilitate the re-engagement of the sector with this form of learning. 3.1.2 Legislative differences The differences in legislation and terminology across the four nations means the potential learner population available to complete a totally tailored qualification is too small and it is not economically viable for awarding bodies to proceed. The different legislation frameworks for statutory and private land enforcement issues further complicates the matter, albeit that good practice is common to most of what the sector does across the four nations and across the public / private divide. The shift towards self-regulation through qualification attainment and codes of practice is also impacting on the sector. Whilst recognising that there are legislative differences, it is the BPA’s intention to work with awarding bodies and industry experts to ensure that the development of qualifications reflect good practice, applicable across the four nations and public / private employers. 3.1.3 Career path definition There has been a lack of consistent training, development or a structured qualification framework in the sector. Consequently there is no recognised career path. Although the UK Parking Sector Skills Strategy, sector skills agreement based research and now the qualifications strategy are actively changing this, there must be some recognition of the challenge the industry faces. Employers want relevant qualifications to improve Page 16 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final the skills of the workforce, attractiveness of their organisations to new recruits and professional reputation to the public, however the industry lacks confidence in defining what it needs as it has never used qualifications in this way before. Compounding this situation is the lack of specific data concerning the parking sector due to the extremely broad classifications of the standard occupational and industrial datasets (SOC/SIC). One of the findings of the qualitative data research5 suggested that as a consequence, awarding bodies have been reluctant to develop qualifications for fear of poor take up and employers, in turn, are frustrated with the slow response to their demands. Hence the dual priorities addressing supply and demand issues have been formulated to address and improve this relationship. 3.1.4 Local variance As a comparatively new industry, there is an extraordinary amount of variance in roles and responsibilities even for those who share a job title. Developing meaningful and relevant modules has been identified as key to allowing individuals to shape their development in line with their organisational need, but this is a lengthy process and again potentially compromises take up figures. 3.2 Future trends The lack of accurate labour market data makes a detailed analysis of the future workforce particularly difficult. Developments in the BPA include the commissioning of an improved member database which will help to address the data gap. However, it is possible to review the existing information and attempt to extrapolate trends and discuss potential scenarios. There does appear to have been growth in the sector. Whilst technology and legislation may result in fewer people on patrol, other roles are evolving. For example, the extension of regulations under the Traffic Management Act 2004, will give authorities outside London the power to enforce a range of moving traffic offences using CCTV. The same Act is leading a number of authorities to consider a wider enforcement role for civil enforcement officers, implying that there will be a greater need for wider knowledge and skills. It would appear from SOC code analysis6 across all four nations, and local government data that the sector has an ageing workforce profile. In addition, the data indicates the sector is heavily dominated by males, who have traditionally achieved fewer qualifications. This implies there will be a continuing skills gap, particularly in relation to qualifications. 5 6 Parking Workforce Survey February 2006 Turquoise Thinking Ltd Skills Needs Assessment for the Parking Sector January 2008 - “traffic wardens and car park attendants” Page 17 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final 3.2.1 Technology Advances in technology are significantly changing the way in which parking enforcement is managed, for example automatic number plate recognition (ANPR) and CCTV mean fewer people are required on patrol. Increasing numbers of local authorities are contracting out parking-related services. For those managing these services there is a widening skills gap concerning the commissioning and management of those contracts. The BPA intends to tackle this by better signposting the existing relevant procurement and / or management units / modules and developing, if necessary, parking specific modules. 3.2.2 Career path The sector aspires to become an attractive employment proposition for potential recruits, particularly young people, and to retain its existing experienced workforce. As the parking sector and inter-related services evolve there will be an increasing need to clarify career options and to signpost potential career pathways. This is currently exemplified by the debate about parking services adopting wider civil enforcement roles. Also, as parking becomes increasingly recognised as a profession in its own right, there will be elements that are recognised as specialist roles, for example, traffic order makers. The career pathway will need to be wider than just front line operational roles due to the already complex and changing nature of job roles. It is envisaged that the pathway will need to consider multiple occupations and potential career choices across the industry and potentially to look beyond into linked professions. Page 18 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final 4 CURRENT QUALIFICATIONS AND OTHER LEARNING PROVISION 4.1 Main qualification types Within the National Qualifications Framework (NQF) and Qualifications and Credit Framework (QCF) applicable in England, Wales and Northern Ireland and the Scottish Credit and Qualifications Framework, there are currently only 3 nationally-accredited, parking-specific qualifications available to the sector. These are: • Level-2 S/NVQ in Controlling Parking Areas • Level-2 VRQ award for Civil Enforcement Officers (Parking) • Level-2 VRQ award for Vehicle Immobilisers (linked to SIA licence to practise) In recent years a small number of customised qualifications, outside of these qualification frameworks have been developed to meet increasing demand for qualifications as the sector evolves. A particularly strong example is the development of several CCTV enforcement short-course-based qualifications which were created for the London market in response to a legislative change specific to the area. There are currently no dedicated apprenticeships for the sector. All current qualifications focus on operational roles (level-2) within the sector. Learners wishing to enhance their careers through further formal development have no choice but to opt for generic qualifications. The level-2 VRQ award for civil enforcement officers (parking) was designed to standardise and independently validate the induction training all civil enforcement officers receive in line with the Traffic Management Act 2004 statutory guidance which came into force in England and Wales on 31st March 2008. The qualification is also being used to assess and “top up” the knowledge of experienced officers. The role of traffic attendant and parking attendant in Northern Ireland and Scotland, respectively, is essentially the same. However, the devolved administrations in these two countries have not adopted the new legislation in full so equivalent role holders do not share the same job title. The level-2 S/NVQ in controlling parking areas also satisfies the requirements of the Traffic Management Act 2004. The S/NVQ is suitable for experienced CEOs and is often used successfully as a continuing professional development tool for those who have already completed the VRQ. Research7 indicated that parking organisations offered a wide range of largely unaccredited skills and knowledge learning and development to employees. In the private sector the majority of training was reported to be delivered in-house by company trainers and managers/supervisors. The approach to training was categorised as informal and, in the majority of cases, involved on-the-job training. The public sector tends to access internal generic provision or outsources to external providers. Views differed on the need for accredited provsion. In general, the public sector and parts of the private sector supported accreditation if it was flexible and could be adapted / enhanced to meet different organisation needs. 7 An Assessment of Current Provision for Skills Needs for the Parking Sector January 2008 Page 19 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final The Parking Workforce Survey 2006, reported that 48% of the workforce had received or were receiving parking specific training. The same research identified the essential skills and knowledge for the sector as: • Managing conflict and aggression • Health and safety • Management • The law • Information technology • Customer services 4.1.1 Purposes The current qualifications are targeted at the frontline operational workforce. The VRQ was designed to deliver a high quality standardised induction for CEOs across the sector. The learning is classroom-based and covers the core knowledge areas for CEOs and must be completed before the CEO enforces alone. The vehicle immobilising BTEC award is linked to the SIA licence to practise in England and Wales. The SIA currently has no remit in Northern Ireland so SIA licences to practise are not required. Vehicle immobilising on private land is unlawful in Scotland, local authorities may choose this method to enforce but rarely do so. CCTV enforcement qualifications on Edexcel’s customised qualification framework are listed on the London Councils’ Code of Practice for Operation of CCTV Enforcement Cameras as a requirement before being allowed to enforce using CCTV. This is delivered in a classroom environment with practical as well as traditional exam-based assessment. 4.1.2 Inter-relationships (including progression routes) The level-2 award for civil enforcement officers (parking) underpins the knowledge to the level-2 S/NVQ in controlling parking areas. The BPA wishes to replicate this good practice model in other areas, for example, notice processing. It is useful to note that the S/NVQ is applicable to a wider range of learners than the VRQ as it covers the following occupational areas: parking control, barrier and pay station control, vehicle immobilisation, vehicle removal and, as of January 2009, CCTV enforcement. 4.1.3 Availability from different providers The main types of organisations that offer parking qualifications are employers, private sector learning providers and public sector FE colleges. The main providers of qualifications to the parking sector are a relatively small number of private sector learning providers. An analysis of FE enrolments on parking qualifications in 2005/06 revealed that there is very low uptake of parking qualifications offered by public FE providers across the four nations. Page 20 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final Table 4.1: Enrolments on FE parking provision in 2005/06 Qualification England Northern Ireland Scotland Wales NVQ level-2 Controlling Parking Areas 28 0 0 0 54 0 0 0 25 0 0 3 BTEC level-2 Vehicle Immobilisation NVQ level-2 Parking Control Source: ILR 2005/06 4.2 Current volumes Table 4.2 provides a profile of the total numbers of candidates registering each year for the level-2 NVQ and total numbers successfully completing. Reliance on the private sector rather than taking up FE provision means that parking organisations are potentially missing out on government funding designed to increase participation in accredited provision (e.g. Train to Gain in England). Table 4.2: Level-2 NVQ Controlling Parking Areas (City & Guilds / Edexcel) Year Enrolled Completed 2004/05 272 33 2005/06 404 324 2006/07 341 248 In terms of future data requirements, the new learning & development forum will provide a platform on which parking organisations can come together as a learning and development community to explore information needs, express priorities and influence strategy. Page 21 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final 4.3 Match to employers’ needs 4.3.1 Current use of qualifications It has been outlined previously that the current VRQ is the standardised induction vehicle for CEOs across England and Wales. At the time of writing the TMA 2004 has not been adopted in Scotland and Northern Ireland. There is, therefore, no imperative to take up the qualification in these nations. Evidence from the research8 indicated that the qualification is increasing in popularity; being used as a benchmark for new entrants and specified in tender documentation. Pockets of the parking sector find the current S/NVQ useful, indeed our first group of Scottish colleagues recently completed the qualification. However, the research reported several employer criticisms of the S/NVQ including perceived expense and the lack of competent assessors. There has been little or no pre-requisite for operational roles to hold qualifications. These attitudes are starting to change; public sector organisations, in particular, expressed support for qualifications. This is in part due to increasing pressure on local authorities to demonstrate they employ competent staff. Notice processing was a significant need identified by employers. The research indicated that some employers were not aware of the range of provision currently available and more work needs to be done to signpost and promote qualifications. For more senior roles there is an expectation that an applicant will hold a broad management qualification. Employers reported an interest in parking specific management modules to supplement general existing qualifications, thereby enhancing the options for parking professionals. It is the BPA’s intention to provide strengthened leadership to the sector on these issues by better engaging with FE providers and improving the marketing of vocational qualifications to employers. 4.3.2 Gaps between current provision and employer need The growing success of the VRQ entry level qualification supports the research conclusions that a greater range of appropriately targeted entry level vocational qualifications, would be supported. The priority areas are notice processing (for both statutory and private land parking and traffic enforcement); CCTV parking and traffic enforcement, car park attendants and flexibility to develop additional qualifications as demand grows within the sector, for example vehicle pound staff. There is also a need for better understanding of qualification overlap and clearer signposting to existing qualifications offered by linked sectors that could be taken up, for example bailiffs, equipment, manufacturing and supply, legal roles such as fraud investigators, procurement and contract management. There is a need to develop progression routes once a base of QCF level-2/SCQF level-5 qualifications has been established. Individuals want to know how they can progress 8 An Assessment of Current Provision for Skills Needs for the Parking Sector January 2008 Page 22 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final with recognised qualifications through identifying existing qualifications and offering parking-related add-on modules at levels 3, 4, 5, etc. There is a need to consider a greater variety of qualification types providing additional options for learners on the career pathway. For example, there is the induction-level VRQ for civil enforcement officers at 67 guided learning hours or there is a full NVQ with nothing in between. The sector needs to develop qualifications with pathways so individuals can benefit from government funding whilst completing a qualification that is meaningful to them. Some employers have reported that they have found the S/NVQ process arduous because they cannot find providers with vocationally competent assessors. Some roles are very specific, therefore potential numbers for some qualifications are limited. This makes them unattractive to awarding bodies. One large UK employer is seeking to become an awarding body in its own right to overcome this challenge. The BPA supports this, but is keen to ensure opportunities for structured and appropriate development are available and consistent industry-wide. There is a particular challenge in Scotland and Northern Ireland where terminology differs for a key frontline role as new legislation has not been adopted by the devolved administrations. There are not sufficient numbers to warrant an awarding body offering a separate qualification, particularly as the content of the TMA based qualification is good practice across the four nations and therefore relevant. Page 23 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final 5 OTHER SECTOR USES OF QUALIFICATIONS 5.1 Consumer protection Statutory guidance which came into force in England and Wales on 31st March 2008 strongly recommended that all civil enforcement officers in parking hold a nationally accredited level-2 qualification mapped to the parking control national occupational standards before enforcing parking contraventions alone. The guidance was introduced in support of the TMA 2004. One of the key aims is to increase transparency and public confidence in the management of parking by improving consistency. Introducing standardised qualifications to this key group of staff is an important step. The guidance also states that investment in training, learning and development must be protected. Management development was listed as a priority as was improving the provision for “back office” staff. Specific qualifications could not be included in the guidance as none existed. The BPA is currently working with the Council for Administration to develop NOS for this group of colleagues with the view to developing qualifications based on these NOS in the future. Additional work needs to be done to develop HE provision. The BPA Approved Operator Scheme went live in October 2007. All BPA members involved in private land ticketing or vehicle immobilisation and removal must also sign up to the scheme. The scheme is currently the only one in the UK that holds DVLA accredited trade association status in the parking sector. This means only members of the AOS can have electronic access to DVLA data for parking enforcement purposes. In England and Wales9 individuals who apply, or direct the application of, vehicle immobilising devices (except those directly employed by a public body) must hold a valid SIA licence. One of the requirements in the process to secure such a licence is achieving an SIA approved qualification. For those individuals engaged in the issue of parking tickets on private land there is currently no equivalent process or VRQ route. There is, however, a demand for this as the private land parking enforcement element of the industry wants to be recognised as equally legitimate and professional as the statutory enforcement side of the sector. Once an appropriate qualification is available it could be listed in the relevant codes of practice in the same way the level-2 VRQ is mentioned in the statutory guidance. 9 The SIA currently has no remit in Northern Ireland, therefore vehicle immobilisers in Northern Ireland are not required to hold an SIA licence. Vehicle immobilising on private land is not lawful in Scotland. Local authorities may deploy this enforcement method, but rarely do so. An SIA licence is not required by those directly employed by public bodies. Page 24 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final A car park attendant in England, Scotland or Wales10 who undertakes CCTV security within their role is, unless employed directly by a public body, required to hold an SIA CCTV public space surveillance licence which is again linked to the attainment of an SIA approved qualification11. CCTV enforcement is a growth area for the sector. At the moment there are a small number of qualifications for this area available on the Edexcel customised qualification framework. These were developed to meet the needs of the London Councils’ code of practice as specific London legislation gave London authorities the right to apply to enforce using CCTV on the condition they signed up to the code of practice. The date for enactment of part 7 of the TMA and the extension of powers to use CCTV for parking and moving traffic enforcement throughout England and Wales (if the Welsh Assembly Government introduces parallel regulations) is currently expected to be March 2009. Authorities across England and Wales will then have the right to adopt these powers. The BPA intends to work with awarding bodies to develop a national qualification in 2009. The S/NVQ level-2 in controlling parking areas will be updated during 2008 in response to the recent review of the parking control national occupational standards. During the review, the parking control suite of NOS was extended to cover CCTV enforcement. The revised S/NVQ is scheduled to be available from January 2009 and will offer five pathways (parking control, barrier and pay station control, vehicle immobilisation, vehicle removal and CCTV enforcement) so could be used as a continuing professional development tool for the above roles. 10 The SIA currently has no remit in Northern Ireland, therefore car park attendants performing a security function in Northern Ireland are not required to hold an SIA licence. 11 Those who use CCTV for parking and traffic enforcement only are not required to hold an SIA public space surveillance licence. Page 25 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final 6 HOW THE BRITISH PARKING ASSOCIATION WILL HELP REALISE THE FUTURE 6.1 Vision of future qualifications There are very strong views in the sector as to which skills and knowledge are essential in almost every job. The main drivers of change across the UK have been identified as technology and legislation. Together these pose a considerable challenge to the sector and imply a significant increase in the demand for qualifications. The sector and learning providers emphasised the need for a clear framework that sets out progression routes for people working in the sector linked to both standards and qualifications. This qualification strategy is an ambitious response to these challenges and is underpinned by action planning which includes building capacity amongst the learning and development professionals within the sector to enable them to more effectively engage their organisations with the skills challenge. It is the BPA’s intention to develop a complete set of standards and qualifications for each level of the career pathway. There is a further commitment to develop a core career pathway for the sector in partnership with Asset Skills. These actions will support the overarching aim of increasing learning opportunities for the workforce through the development of more effective partnership working with learning providers in all nations and regions of the UK. Specific activities to achieve these overarching aims are explored below: • The development of NOS-based accredited parking qualifications where gaps are identified and/or change is required due to new policy and the evolution of practice. The current priority areas for development include: o Administration and notice processing (for statutory enforcement and private land ticketing) o CCTV enforcement o Car park attendants • The development and maintenance of a suite of specialist learning modules and units of learning and achievement. This fit for purpose modular approach will facilitate vocational training and enable progression. The current priority area for development is parking management. • The development and maintenance of parking national occupational standards. It is our intention through the mapping exercise to ensure high quality and usable NOS which will form the building blocks for training, development and qualification content. Our priority area for NOS development is administration and notice processing (for statutory enforcement and private land ticketing). Page 26 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final • We are aware of areas of commonality across the sectors and intend to promote the use of specialist parking modules and units with generic qualifications, increasing the transferability of skills. • We intend to increase the demand for learning, skills and qualifications through the development and promotion of opportunities for progression and the related applicable qualifications. The BPA will work with employers and providers to increase learning opportunities to the sector. Initially we will undertake a feasibility study into an apprenticeship scheme and we will work with employers to extend the sector take up of public funding regimes supporting skills development. 6.2 Past and future dialogues The BPA has established joint-working with key employers and stakeholders through the following means: • BPA Council and Executive Board • UK Skills Board for Parking • Institute of Parking Professionals • BPA special interest groups (e.g. Women in Parking / Equipment, Manufacturers and Suppliers) • BPA regional and national groups including the English regions, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales This qualification strategy builds upon research carried out in support of the UK Parking Sector Skills Strategy and sector skills agreement process which involved extensive consultation with employers. Approximately 164 different organisations responded to the 2006 Workforce Survey which carried out 15 in-depth interviews and included the analysis of 352 questionnaire responses and a further 208 follow up interviews. The 2008 Skills Needs Assessment for the Parking Sector held semistructured in-depth interviews with 16 employers and conducted two locality assessments. The 2008 Assessment of Current Provision for Skills Needs for the Parking Sector held semi-structured interviews with 12 learning providers and conducted two locality assessments. The two main awarding bodies City & Guilds and Edexcel were consulted and an online survey was made available to all employees in the parking sector. Page 27 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final The draft qualifications strategy was available for review on the BPA website from July 2008 and further employer consultation was facilitated via a web-based survey and by telephone. Before finalising the qualifications strategy in September 2008, the BPA engaged funding agencies (LSC, DCELLS, English region RDAs), qualifications regulators (QCA, SQA, DCELLS, OfQual, CCEA) awarding bodies (City & Guilds, Edexcel, SQA) and trades unions (UNISON, GMB, T&G of Unite) in the consultation process. 6.3 Practical help The BPA through the UK Skills Board for Parking and its partner SSC, Asset Skills, will create a structured career pathway and promote it to employers, learning providers, information, advice and guidance (IAG) networks and other key stakeholders. Working through the UK Skills Board for Parking, the BPA, supported by Asset Skills, will create a full set of standards and qualifications to improve the skills base of the workforce. The BPA will undertake to develop improved partnership arrangements between funding bodies, providers and employers, brokering access to funding for skills development and qualifications. The BPA will continue to seek funding from the UK Commission for Employment and Skills to deliver its ambitious strategy. 6.4 Future evolution of the qualifications strategy The UK Skills Board for Parking will sign off the qualifications strategy and every six months monitor its implementation. The Skills Board will oversee the development and implementation of the detailed action plan intended to realise the strategic aims of this qualifications strategy. This work will include the development of specific projects and general activity to improve partnership working with the various funding agencies, providers and awarding bodies throughout the UK. It is also envisaged that suitable projects will be championed by the Institute of Parking Professionals. The UK Skills Board for Parking will also be responsible for reporting on progress and the impact of the qualifications strategy to the Learning & Development Forum, the IPP and the BPA Council. Page 28 of 28 UK Parking Qualifications Strategy, January 2009 – Final