BUSINESS New Buildings SMALL OFFICE INCENTIVE WORKBOOK SIMPLE SOLUTIONS FOR BIG ENERGY SAVINGS Boost operating income and asset value through energy efficiency Energy Trust of Oregon knows that reducing building energy use by installing energyefficient equipment and systems has been shown to increase net operating income, or NOI, and asset value. For example, according to ENERGY STAR®, installing a highly efficient variable refrigerant flow, or VRF, heating system in a 40,000-square-foot office building can save up to $0.34 per square foot every year in energy costs, translating into an additional NOI of $13,496. At a cap rate* of eight percent, this results in a potential asset value boost of $168,700. Energy-efficient solutions also can contribute to enhanced tenant comfort, higher occupancy rates and lower operation and maintenance costs. Energy Trust can help you capture these benefits and earn cash incentives for energy-efficient equipment and building practices with our market solutions package for office buildings less than 70,000 square feet. Whether you’re planning to build a new office or kicking off a major renovation, it provides a simple way to identify the best energy solutions for your office space. * NOI divided by the sales price or value of a property expressed as a percentage. Energy Trust outreach managers can offer input and feedback as you make energy-related decisions and assist you in completing this workbook. If you have questions or need help getting started, contact the outreach manager listed here. Name Email Phone Number 1 HOW TO USE THIS WORKBOOK What is the small office incentive package? This package offers an all-in-one, step-by-step process for designing and selecting energy-efficient systems and equipment that are cost-effective and qualify for cash incentives. To help you drive for the deepest savings possible and maximize your incentive benefit, we have grouped the equipment and practices to align with four efficiency tiers. There are base requirements that must be met to qualify for incentives for each tier. You may then select additional electives to earn even higher incentives. The table below presents the base incentive amount for each tier, as well as the incentive levels when combined with electives. Incentives are calculated on a per-square-foot basis and will depend on the equipment selected and the number of elective options you install. BASE INCENTIVE BASE + 2 ELECTIVES BASE + 4 ELECTIVES VERY BEST n/a n/a $2.00/sq ft BEST $0.80/sq ft $0.90/sq ft $1.00/sq ft BETTER $0.35/sq ft $0.45/sq ft $0.55/sq ft GOOD $0.25/sq ft $0.35/sq ft $0.45/sq ft Use this workbook throughout the course of your project to set efficiency targets, select equipment, estimate incentives and facilitate communications and decision making. Your Energy Trust New Buildings outreach manager will work with you to provide input and guidance on how to maximize the energy efficiency of your building and your incentives. STEP 1 Review “Part 1: Lighting,” and select your lighting power density, or LPD,target. STEP 2 Review “Part 2: HVAC,” and select your heating, ventilation & air conditioning, or HVAC, system. STEP 3 Review “Part 3: Electives,” and select any additional equipment or systems you plan to install. Project Name Square Footage The following pages present the options for lighting, HVAC and additional elective equipment and design practices eligible for incentives. Please indicate the equipment you plan to install by completing the tables below. HOW TO USE THIS WORKBOOK 2 PART 1: LIGHTING Efficiency requirements All projects must achieve a minimum lighting power density, or LPD, of 0.78 watts per square foot. This represents a 15 percent reduction in LPD beyond what is required in the whole-building lighting power allowance for office spaces in 2010 Oregon Energy Efficiency Special Code, or OEESC. Refer to Table 505.5.2(a) in the OEESC for further detail. If you use space-by-space lighting power allowances then you must demonstrate an overall LPD reduction of 15 percent. Refer to Table 505.5.2(b) in the OEESC for further detail. Elective option Projects pursuing higher-efficiency targets can elect to achieve an LPD of 0.6825 watts per square foot using whole-building lighting power allowances, or 25 percent beyond code using the space-by-space allowances. See Part 3: Electives for further information. Required documentation Please submit the following documentation to Energy Trust along with your incentive application: FF Lighting layouts and schedules FF ComCheck documentation FF Invoices Project information Please fill in the table below to indicate the LPD target you have selected. LIGHTING Square Footage of Office Space PART 1: LIGHTING Total Allowed Watts (from ComCheck) Total Proposed Watts (from ComCheck) Percentage Better than Code Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 3 PART 2: HVAC Selecting your HVAC system Selecting an HVAC system and properly sizing the equipment is fundamental to ensuring optimal building performance. Each of our HVAC options correspond to the incentive tiers presented on page 2. The most common HVAC system types for office buildings are detailed below. Once you have reviewed the options and requirements, select your system and complete the corresponding project information tables. All “good” and “better” HVAC options require economizers on units greater than 5 tons. Installing economizers on all HVAC units, regardless of size, will automatically qualify your project for the “better” incentive tier. ECONOMIZERS Economizer requirements* • Economizers for packaged rooftop units must be factory installed. • The damper motor must be fully modulating. • The damper drive mechanism must consist of a direct modulating actuator with gear-driven interconnections and a permanently lubricated bushing or bearing on the outside and return dampers. • The economizer must include a proportional damper control. An economizer regulates and optimizes the amount of outdoor air brought into a building for cooling and ventilation. This cooling is often referred to as "free cooling" because there is no need for mechanical systems to condition your building— saving energy and money on utility bills. Economizers also improve indoor air quality by reducing carbon dioxide levels. Economizers are required by code (503.3.1 and 503.4.1 ) on units 5 tons and greater in size. • The economizer must be locked out when in heating mode. • There must be a dedicated thermostat stage for the economizer. • The economizer control type must be differential dry-bulb, fixed dry-bulb, differential enthalpy or dew point/dry-bulb temperature control. • The economizer must include a changeover control with a setpoint/ dry-bulb limit of 65-75 degrees Fahrenheit, or °F. • The economizer must provide relief air with a barometric damper in the return air duct upstream of the return air damper, a motorized exhaust air damper or an exhaust fan with backdraft dampers. Elective option • If selecting a “good” HVAC system, you may receive an elective credit by installing an economizer on a three- or four-ton air conditioning unit. * Contact Energy Trust for any exceptions. PART 2: HVAC Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 4 HVAC OPTIONS FOR BUILDINGS WITH GAS HEAT (If your building has electric heat, please go to page 8.) Check the box below that corresponds with your system type and efficiency goal. Rooftop unit FF GOOD Efficient unit with 80 percent gas furnace and economizers as required by code FF BETTER Efficient unit with 80 percent gas furnace and economizers where not required by code Split air conditioning system FF GOOD Efficient unit with 80 percent gas furnace and economizers as required by code FF BETTER OPTION 1 Efficient unit with 80 percent gas furnace and economizers where not required by code FF BETTER OPTION 2 Efficient unit with 91 AFUE gas furnace and economizers as required by code Variable air volume system (VAV) FF GOOD VAV system with 80 percent boiler and economizers on units as required by code FF BETTER VAV system with 92 percent efficient condensing boiler and economizers on units as required by code Radiant heating and cooling system FF VERY BEST Radiant floor or ceiling panels with 91 percent gas boiler, high-efficiency heat recovery chiller or heat pump chiller, dedicated outdoor air system, or DOAS, and FOUR electives General efficiency requirements Rooftop Unit Size Cooling Efficiency < 65,000 Btu/h PSZ: 14 SEER/11.6 EER Split system: 14 SEER/ 12 EER > 65,000 Btu/h and < 135,000 Btu/h 11.5 EER/11.9 IPLV > 135,000 Btu/h and < 240,000 Btu/h 11.5 EER/11.9 IPLV PART 2: HVAC | OPTIONS FOR BUILDINGS WITH GAS HEAT Gas Furnace Or Boiler Efficiency Requirements 80-90% Thermal Efficiency, or AFUE, or 91% Thermal Efficiency/ 91% AFUE and above for "better" systems Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 5 Efficiency requirements for radiant heating and cooling for “very best” option • The system must use active or inactive hydronic radiant panels or a hydronic radiant floor to heat and cool conditioned spaces. • Ventilation air must be provided by a DOAS. • Hot water for heating must be supplied with a condensing boiler that has a minimum efficiency of 90 AFUE (boilers < 300 kBtu/hr), 90 percent thermal efficiency (boilers between 300-2,500 kBtu/hr) or 90 percent combustion efficiency (boilers > 2,500 kBtu/hr). • Chilled water must be supplied by an air- or water-cooled chiller exceeding code part-load and peak efficiencies by a minimum of 10 percent at standard ARI test conditions. Refer to Table 503.2.3(7) in the OEESC for further detail. • Hot water and chilled water temperatures must be reset based on demand. • The chilled water loop must have high humidity lock-out. Other requirements for “very best” system types • The project team must participate in an early design planning and coordination meeting. • The project team must submit the design to New Buildings for review. • HVAC controls must be code compliant and have different temperature schedules for occupied and unoccupied time periods. VERY BEST OPTION ELECTIVE A DOAS is required for "very best" incentives. If the system also contains an energy recovery wheel that is not required by code, the project may request an elective credit. To qualify, the energy recovery wheel must have energy recovery effectiveness equal to or greater than 50 percent. Energy Trust staff will review project information and conduct calculations on a caseby-case basis to determine if this qualifies as an elective. See page 14 for further information. Program documentation FF Mechanical schedules and/or cut sheets showing the cooling equipment model number, size and cooling efficiency FF Mechanical schedule and/or cut sheet indicating heating equipment size and efficiency FF Economizer documentation: economizer cut sheet, economizer controller capabilities and temperature sensor cut sheets FF Email from owner/contractor to certify that each of the economizer requirements listed above has been met FF Invoices PART 2: HVAC | OPTIONS FOR BUILDINGS WITH GAS HEAT Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 6 Project information ROOFTOP UNITS AND VAV SYSTEMS Quantity AC Unit Size AC Unit Efficiency Heating AC Make and Model Furnace/Boiler Information Cooling Size Economizer on units where not required by code? Furnace/Boiler Make and Model Efficiency RADIANT HEATING AND COOLING Supply water temperature reset based on demand? High humidity lockout on chiller loop? Floor or Panel? Boiler Information Floor Panel Size Boiler Make and Model Efficiency PART 2: HVAC | OPTIONS FOR BUILDINGS WITH GAS HEAT Chiller Information Size Chiller Make and Model Efficiency Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 7 HVAC OPTIONS FOR BUILDINGS WITH ELECTRIC HEAT Check the box below that corresponds with your system type and efficiency goal. Packaged or split system heat pump FF GOOD Efficient unit and economizers on units as required by code FF BETTER Efficient unit and economizers where not required by code VAV system FF GOOD Efficient VAV system with electric reheat or a hybrid heat source (e.g., gas furnace with electric reheat) and economizers as required by code Other systems FF BEST OPTION 1 Efficient VRF heat pump with a DOAS. FF BEST OPTION 2 Efficient water source heat pump, or WSHP, with a DOAS. FF VERY BEST Radiant floor or ceiling panels with efficient heat pump chiller or heat recovery chiller, condensing gas boiler, DOAS and FOUR electives Efficiency requirements for "good" and "better" system types Heat Pump Size Cooling Efficiency Heating Efficiency < 65,000 Btu/h 14 SEER/12 EER 8.5 HSPF > 65,000 Btu/h and < 135,000 Btu/h 11.5 EER/11.9 IPLV 3.4 COP > 135,000 Btu/h and < 240,000 Btu/h 11.5 EER/11.9 IPLV 3.2 COP Efficiency requirements for VAV systems Air Handling Unit Size Cooling Efficiency < 65,000 Btu/h PSZ: 14 SEER/11.6 EER > 65,000 Btu/h and < 135,000 Btu/h 11.5 EER/11.9 IPLV > 135,000 Btu/h and < 240,000 Btu/h 11.5 EER/11.9 IPLV > 240,000 Btu/h and < 760,000 Btu/h 10.5 EER/10.9 IPLV ≥ 760,000 Btu/h 9.7 EER/11.0 IPLV PART 2: HVAC | OPTIONS FOR BUILDINGS WITH ELECTRIC HEAT Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 8 Requirements for all “very best” and “best” system types • Project team must participate in early design planning and coordination meeting. • Project team must submit the design to Energy Trust for review. • HVAC controls must be code compliant and have different temperature schedules for occupied and unoccupied time periods. System-specific efficiency requirements for “very best” and “best” system types Radiant heating and cooling systems • The system must use active or inactive hydronic radiant panels or a hydronic radiant floor to heat and cool conditioned spaces. • Ventilation air must be provided by a DOAS. • Hot water for heating must be supplied with a heat recovery chiller or heat pump chiller exceeding code minimum efficiency by at least 10 percent. Refer to Section 503.2.3 of the OEESC for further detail. • Hot water and chilled water temperatures must be reset based on demand. • The chilled water loop must have high humidity lock-out. VERY BEST & BEST OPTION ELECTIVES A DOAS is required for "best" and "very best" incentives. If the system also contains an energy recovery wheel that is not required by code, the project may request an elective credit. To qualify, the energy recovery wheel must have energy recovery effectiveness equal to or greater than 50 percent. Energy Trust staff will review project information and conduct calculations on a caseby-case basis to determine if this qualifies as an elective. See page 14 for further information. For variable refrigerant flow systems • Systems must meet CEE Tier 1 efficiency requirements for IEER, EER, and COP. Variable Refrigerant Flow Heat Pump Size Cooling Efficiency: Heating Efficiency: < 65,000 Btu/h 14 SEER/12 EER 8.5 HSPF > 65,000 Btu/h and < 135,000 Btu/h 11.1 EER/14.0 IEER 3.4 COP > 135,000 Btu/h and < 240,000 Btu/h 10.7 EER/13.5 IEER 3.2 COP > 240,000 Btu/h 10.1 EER/12.3 IEER 3.2 COP • The system must provide ventilation air by using a DOAS. Water source heat pump systems • Systems must meet CEE Tier 1 efficiency requirements. • Systems must have a cooling efficiency of 14 EER. • Systems must have a heating efficiency of 4.6 COP. • Projects installing a WSHP system with a back-up supplemental boiler must install a condensing boiler with a minimum efficiency of 91 AFUE, 91 percent thermal efficiency or 91 percent combustion efficiency (depending on boiler size). • Ventilation air must be provided by a DOAS. PART 2: HVAC | OPTIONS FOR BUILDINGS WITH ELECTRIC HEAT Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 9 Required documentation FF Email from owner/contractor to certify that each of the economizer requirements listed on page 4 has been met FF Mechanical schedules and/or cut sheets showing the equipment model number, size, heating efficiency and cooling efficiency FF Energy recovery ventilator cut sheets/documentation FF Economizer documentation (economizer cut sheet, economizer controller capabilities and temperature sensor cut sheets) FF Invoices Project information HEAT PUMP Quantity HP Size (tons) HP Efficiencies HSPF/COP Economizer on units not required by code? HP Make and Model SEER/EER VAV SYSTEMS Air Handling Unit Size Cooling Efficiency Requirements Electric Heating or Hybrid? SEER Heat PART 2: HVAC | OPTIONS FOR BUILDINGS WITH ELECTRIC HEAT EER IPLV Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 Hybrid 10 VARIABLE REFRIGERANT FLOW OR WSHP Quantity VRF Outdoor Condensing Unit or WSHP Size (Btu/h) Heating/Cooling Efficiencies HSPF VRF Outdoor Unit(s) Make, Model and Capacity VRF Indoor Unit(s) Make, Model and Capacity SEER RADIANT HEATING AND COOLING Radiant Floor or Radiant Panel? Heat Pump Chiller or Heat Recovery Chiller Information Size Heat Pump Chiller or Heat Recovery Chiller Make and Model Supply water High humidity temperature lockout on reset based on chiller loop? demand? Floor Panel Efficiency PART 2: HVAC | OPTIONS FOR BUILDINGS WITH ELECTRIC HEAT Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 11 PART 3: ELECTIVES The following tables present elective options you may select to achieve additional incentives. Please indicate the electives you plan to install in the tables below and provide the corresponding installation details. LIGHTING Check to select Which method are you using? Whole Building LPD • For Interior Lighting Power Method (OEESC Table 505.5.2(a)), install a LPD < 0.68W/sq ft Interior Baseline: • For Space-by-Space Method (OEESC Table 505.5.2(b)), a 25% reduction in whole building LPD is required. Space-by- Elective Requirements Air Barrier Material Air barrier • Seal building envelope joints, seams, penetrations, openings and other junctions to limit infiltration. Elective Requirements LPD 25% better than code Lighting Power Installed Fixture Types? Proposed: Space Required Documentation • Lighting plans and lighting schedule • ComCheck documentation • Invoices ENVELOPE Check to select Installed Make and Model • Photos of air barrier being installed (before walls/building is closed) • Architectural drawings and sections illustrating the details of the air barrier • Air barrier materials must have an air permeability no more than 0.004 cfm/ft2 under a DP of 0.3 in water. • Air barrier project specifications (from construction documents) • Refer to Section 606.1.2 of the 2011 Oregon Reach Code for more information (www.bcd.oregon.gov/ committees/11reachcode/ Oregon_Reach_Code.pdf). PART 3: ELECTIVES Documentation Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 12 HVAC Check to select Elective Requirements Static pressure reduction • Using a turning vane. Installed Make and Model Documentation • Narrative indicating methods used for static pressure reduction, the amount by which static pressure is reduced and final static pressure. • Additional options for reducing static pressure include: »» Using a round or oval duct wherever possible to lower leakage and reduce pressure loss »» Use of relief fans in lieu of return fans where possible »» Using automatic dampers on exhaust in lieu of dampers to reduce fan power DOMESTIC HOT WATER Check to select Installed Quantity Elective Requirements Installed Make and Model Documentation Heat pump water heater ENERGY STAR • Equipment cut sheets and invoices Condensing tank water heater 91% thermal efficiency or EF • Equipment cut sheets and invoices Tankless gas water heater • Input capacity of equipment < 200 kBtu/h • Equipment cut sheets and invoices • 0.82 EF PART 3: ELECTIVES Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 13 PLUG LOADS Check to select Requirements Phantom load reduction • 50% of all installed office equipment must be ENERGY STAR rated or other energy plug load reduction strategies must be employed. E.g., providing laptops versus desktops to all employees. • Project documentation, specifications or narrative • 50% of all installed office equipment must be ENERGY STAR rated • Project documentation, specifications or narrative Peak plug load reduction # Advanced Power Strips Installed or Controlled Receptacles Elective Installed Make and Model Documentation • Furniture layout • Electrical plans • Invoices • Purchasing agreement that indicates future equipment purchases will be ENERGY STAR (if applicable) • Energy management installed on all computers • Invoices HIGH PERFORMANCE WINDOWS Check to select Elective Requirements Performance of Installed Windows Documentation High performance windows • U-Value < 0.42 U-Value: • Window cut sheets • SHGC < 0.37 • Architectural drawings/specifications detailing glazing requirements SHGC: SPECIAL MEASURES (FROM 520SM)* Check to select Elective Description Documentation Heat Recovery on dedicated outdoor air system, or DOAS Energy recovery wheel, or ERV, must have energy recovery effectiveness equal to or greater than 50 percent • Mechanical schedules Additional special measures • Completed Form 520SM • Incremental cost • Invoices *Special measures refer to design features that are not defined in this workbook, but may qualify for incentives. Energy Trust will assess these on a case-by-case basis. Energy Trust of Oregon 421 SW Oak St, Suite 300, Portland, Oregon 97204 1.866.368.7878 503.546.6862 fax energytrust.org Energy Trust of Oregon is an independent nonprofit organization dedicated to helping utility customers benefit from saving energy and tapping renewable resources. Our services, cash incentives and energy solutions have helped participating customers of Portland General Electric, Pacific Power, NW Natural and Cascade Natural Gas save on energy costs. Our work helps keep energy costs as low as possible, creates jobs and builds a sustainable energy future. 8/14 PART 3: ELECTIVES Total Estimated Incentive $ 0 14