TECHNICAL NOTES Anchorage and Bracing of Equipment and Mechanical Systems - Compilation of Available Guidance Minkyu Lee Fire Protection Research Foundation © October 2012 The Fire Protection Research Foundation One Batterymarch Park Quincy, Massachusetts, U.S.A. 02169-7471 E-Mail: foundation@nfpa.org Web: www.nfpa.org/foundation (This page left intentionally blank) Foreword Guidance on good installation practice for seismic bracing and anchoring is available from many diverse sources. For ease in use, this report is a compilation of references to this information: existing codes, standards and best practices for installation of equipment and mechanical systems to mitigate post earthquake damage. It includes readily available information on sprinkler systems, combustible liquid systems, piping, electrical equipment, and mechanical equipment from U.S. and selected international sources. The content, opinions and conclusions contained in this report are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the Fire Protection Research Foundation. The Foundation makes no guaranty or warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of any information published herein. Acknowledgements The Fire Protection Research Foundation expresses gratitude to those that assisted with the development and review of the information contained in this report. The Research Foundation appreciates the guidance provide by the Project Technical Panel: CNA Insurance, FM Global, Liberty Mutual, Tokio Marine Management, Inc., Travelers Insurance, XL Group, and Zurich NA. Special thanks are expressed to the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) for funding this project. Keywords: seismic, earthquake, brace, bracing, anchor, anchoring, anchorage (This page left intentionally blank) Anchorage and Bracing of Equipment and Mechanical Systems - Compilation of Available Guidance Minkyu Lee Fire Protection Research Foundation The Fire Protection Research Foundation One Batterymarch Park Quincy, Massachusetts, U.S.A. 02169-7471 E-Mail: foundation@nfpa.org Web: www.nfpa.org/foundation Page 1 of 17 Acknowledgements Table of Contents Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................. 2 Table of Contents ................................................................................................................ 2 1. Introduction and Background ..................................................................................... 3 2. Standards and Guidance Compilation Process ........................................................... 3 3. Standards and Guidance Compilation......................................................................... 5 1. Sprinkler system....................................................................................................... 5 1.1 Sprinkler system piping .................................................................................... 5 1.2 Fire pump .......................................................................................................... 6 1.3 Sprinkler system water storage tanks ............................................................... 6 2. Combustible liquid systems ..................................................................................... 7 2.1 Combustible liquid tanks .................................................................................. 7 2.2 Combustible liquid piping ................................................................................ 7 3. Medical Gas piping .................................................................................................. 8 4. Refrigerant piping .................................................................................................... 9 5. Cable Trays ............................................................................................................ 10 6. Transformers .......................................................................................................... 10 7. Tanks (other) .......................................................................................................... 11 8. Ovens/furnace ........................................................................................................ 11 9. General ................................................................................................................... 12 10. Others ................................................................................................................. 14 11. Private Company Literature ............................................................................... 16 12. Related Information............................................................................................ 17 13. Guidelines from Outside of the United States .................................................... 17 Page 2 of 17 1. Introduction and Background There is range of equipment and mechanical systems in buildings that are vulnerable to seismic damage. The failure of fire protection systems; the release of fire protection agents, fire protection liquids, or flammable or combustible liquids or gases; and the creation of fire hazards are all forms of property damage which can occur during an earthquake. Equipment damage mitigation strategies include the provision of restraint, for example anchors and bracing systems, or other design details such as flexible joints. Vulnerable equipment types include sprinkler systems, combustible liquid systems, piping, electrical equipment, and mechanical equipment. Each of these types has unique requirements for installation of seismic bracing, anchors, and specific methods for protecting equipment from earthquake damage. The goal of this project was to identify and compile available guidance in the literature into a readily accessible form. Note that this is not a complete list of references; however an attempt was made to identify those readily available publications of most relevance to the topic. 2. Standards and Guidance Compilation Process An extensive search of published standards, publications, and the academic literature was conducted and references were compiled. Each publication was assigned a unique index number. To assess the most current version, all of the guidance is sorted by date. To aid readers who are seeking information about a specific type of equipment, the guidelines are grouped by equipment type. Some documents in the list are available on line; some are available through the NFPA library; and some require purchase. For each publication, the list includes the title, specific page or chapter numbers where relevant, date of publication, a brief summary or comment about the information, and links on where to find it. The compilation has twelve sections. Other than the final two sections, each section is for a different type of equipment: sprinkler systems, combustible liquid systems, medical gas piping, refrigerant piping, cable trays, transformers, tanks, ovens/furnaces, general equipment, and other equipment. Sprinkler systems and combustible liquid systems are divided into subcategories. The sprinkler systems section is divided into sprinkler system piping, fire pumps, and sprinkler system storage tanks. The combustible liquid systems section is divided into combustible liquid tanks and combustible liquid piping. The Page 3 of 17 general equipment section includes information that is not specific to a particular type of equipment. Section 11 contains selected literature published by manufacturers/other private sector organizations. This list was subjectively chosen, and includes those private sector guidelines thought to be useful to readers. Section 12 contains relevant publications which are not guidelines for seismic protection or do not belong in any of the above categories. Section 13 contains selected, readily available, international publications which may be of interest. Many guidelines are listed several times, since they are applicable to more than one type of equipment. The page numbers or chapter numbers are provided for each specific type of equipment covered in the document. Some guidelines are specifically designed for a specific type of site or project, such as a nuclear facility; this is explained in the comments. It should be noted that even though types of equipment are separated by section in the compilation, readers may need to look at multiple sections for one equipment installation. For example, for ovens, an installer may need to refer to the sections for ovens, exhaust stacks, suction tanks, piping, fire pumps, etc. Page 4 of 17 3. Standards and Guidance Compilation 1. Sprinkler system 1.1 Sprinkler system piping Index # 1.1-1 1.1-2 Reference Volume/Title Pg(s) or chapter AFSA/ Seismic Bracing & Restraint Layout and Calculation AFSA/ Seismic Bracing Requirements for Fire Sprinkler Systems FM DS2-0 / Installation 1.1-3 Guidelines for Automatic Sprinklers p 79 ~ p 80 FM DS2-8 / Earthquake p 4 ~ p 8, 1.1-4 Protection for p 20 ~ p 33 Water-Based Fire Protection Systems 1.1-5 NFPA 13/ Standard for the installation of Sprinkler Systems p 85 ~ p 86, p 393 ~ p 461 Date Published Comments Link 09/2011 Handout document that explain how to layout sprinkler system piping using NFPA 13 and ASCE 7. http://www.firesprinkler. org/convention/handouts/ 9-15_Seismic2.pdf 09/2011 Handout document that explain how to design and install sprinkler system piping using NFPA 13 and ASCE 7. http://www.firesprinkler. org/convention/handouts/ 9-15_Seismic1.pdf Guide which addresses the attachment of pipe hanger assemblies to steel purlins. 04/2011 The section addresses hangers, not braces, but short hangers may be used as restraints. Recommendations on sway brace locations and brace 05/ 2010 connections for fire protection systems which include piping. 2010 1.1-6 SMACNA/ The Seismic Restraint Manual for Mechanical System 2008 1.1-7 FEMA P-414/ Installing Seismic Restraint for Duct and Pipe 01/2004 http://www.fmglobal.com /fmglobalregistration/Vsh ared/FMDS0200.pdf http://www.fmglobal.com /fmglobalregistration/Vsh ared/FMDS0208.pdf Standard and guide to hanging, bracing, and restraint of system piping. http://www.nfpa.org/abou tthecodes/AboutTheCode s.asp?DocNum=13 This is manual to install seismic restraint for piping and ductwork mainly for HVAC system but does not differentiate other type of pipes. This manual includes requirement and practical guide about how to install restraint for each different size and material of the pipe. Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for ducts, pipe, and in-line equipment (dampers, coils, fans, VAV boxes, valves, pumps, heat exchangers, strainers, air separators, etc.). http://smacna.org/booksto re/index.cfm?fuseaction= search_results&keyword =Seismic%20Restraint% 20Manual:%20Guideline s%20for%20Mechanical %20Systems,%203rd%20 Edition Page 5 of 17 http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=14 37 1.1-8 CLSE, AFSA/ NFPA 13 - 2002 Edition Seismic Design for Fire Sprinkler Systems 2002 This is PowerPoint course document that explains how to design and install sprinkler system piping step by step using NFPA 13. http://www.clse.org/edu/s eismic08-05/seismic.pdf 2012 Seismic restraint guideline for piping, water heaters, storage tanks, ovens and furnaces, water pumps, electric generators, combustible tank, and general HVAC systems. http://www.ashrae.org/res ources-publications/bookstore/pr actical-guide-to-seismicrestraint p 42 05/2010 Anchorage of Fire pump installations http://www.fmglobal.com /fmglobalregistration/Vsh ared/FMDS0208.pdf p 26 ~ p 27 12/2002 Seismic restraint installation guide for pumps http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=15 57 1.2 Fire pump ASHRAE/ 1.2-1 Practical Guide to Seismic Restraint 1.2-2 1.2-3 FM DS2-8 / Earthquake Protection for WaterBased Fire Protection Systems FEMA 412/ Installing Seismic Restraints for Mechanical Equipment 1.3 Sprinkler system water storage tanks ASHRAE/ 1.3-1 Practical Guide to Seismic Restraint 1.3-2 FEMA 412/ Installing Seismic Restraints for Mechanical Equipment p 28 ~ p 29 2012 Seismic restraint guideline for piping, water heaters, storage tanks, ovens and furnaces, water pumps, electric generators, combustible tank, and general HVAC systems. http://www.ashrae.org/res ources-publications/bookstore/pr actical-guide-to-seismicrestraint 12/2002 Seismic restraint installation guide for tanks which includes water tanks http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=15 57 Page 6 of 17 2. Combustible liquid systems 2.1 Combustible liquid tanks 2.1-1 FEMA 412/ Installing Seismic Restraints for Mechanical Equipment p 28 ~ p 29 12/2002 Seismic restraint installation guide for tanks and gas cylinders http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=15 57 2.2 Combustible liquid piping 2.2-1 UFC 3-310-04/ Seismic Design of Buildings ASHRAE/ 2.2-2 Practical Guide to Seismic Restraint 2.2-3 SMACNA/ The Seismic Restraint Manual for Mechanical System 2.2-4 UFGS-13 48 00.00 10/ Seismic Protection for Mechanical Equipment B-9(p 108) ~ B-15(p 114) 05/2012 2012 2008 10/2007 This manual is for DoD projects and includes seismic design for buildings which includes bracing and restraints on piping. Seismic restraint guideline for piping, water heaters, storage tanks, ovens and furnaces, water pumps, electric generators, combustible tank, and general HVAC systems. This is manual to install seismic restraint for piping and ductwork mainly for HVAC system but does not differentiate other type of pipes. This manual includes requirement and practical guide about how to install restraint for each different size and material of the pipe. Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for boilers and furnaces; water heaters; expansion air separator tanks; heat exchangers; water chiller units; cooling towers; refrigerant piping; pumps with motors; large commercial dryers; gas dryers; flash tanks; accumulator tanks; storage tanks for oil and water; steam, water, oil and gas pipe; valves and fittings for piping; steam-fed kitchen appliances; thermal storage units; air and refrigerant compressors; air Page 7 of 17 http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DOD/UFC/ufc_3_310_0 4.pdf http://www.ashrae.org/res ources-publications/bookstore/pr actical-guide-to-seismicrestraint http://smacna.org/booksto re/index.cfm?fuseaction= search_results&keyword =Seismic%20Restraint% 20Manual:%20Guideline s%20for%20Mechanical %20Systems,%203rd%20 Edition http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DOD/UFGS/UFGS%20 13%2048%2000.00%201 0.pdf 2.2-5 FEMA P-414/ Installing Seismic Restraint for Duct and Pipe 2.2-6 FEMA P-414/ Installing Seismic Restraint for Duct and Pipe 2.2-7 SSC-02-03/ Improving Natural Gas Safety in Earthquakes 2.2-8 FEMA-233 Earthquake Resistant Construction of Gas and Liquid Fuel Pipeline Systems Serving, or Regulated by, the Federal Government 01/2004 p 107 ~ p 148 p 26 ~ p 43 01/2004 handling units; lab scrubbers, pollution control equipment; ducts; unit heaters; exhaust and return fans; solar heating units, etc. Seismic restraint and bracing, installation guide for ducts, pipe, and in-line equipment (dampers, coils, fans, VAV boxes, valves, pumps, heat exchangers, strainers, air separators, etc.). Anchor selection guide for ducts and piping. http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=14 37 http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=14 37 07/2002 Fuel gas shut-off valves – earthquake actuated and excess flow actuated. http://www.seismic.ca.go v/pub/CSSC_200203_Natural%20Gas%20S afety.pdf 07/1992 Overview of measures taken by Federal Agencies to protect pipeline systems as well as above-ground storage tanks. http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=16 39 This is manual to install seismic restraint for piping and ductwork mainly for HVAC system but does not differentiate other type of pipes. This manual includes requirement and practical guide about how to install restraint for each different size and material of the pipe. Seismic restraint, anchor, installation guide for ducts, pipe, and in-line equipment (dampers, coils, fans, VAV boxes, valves, pumps, heat exchangers, strainers, air separators, etc.). http://smacna.org/booksto re/index.cfm?fuseaction= search_results&keyword =Seismic%20Restraint% 20Manual:%20Guideline s%20for%20Mechanical %20Systems,%203rd%20 Edition 3. Medical Gas piping 3-1 SMACNA/ The Seismic Restraint Manual for Mechanical System 3-2 FEMA P-414/ Installing Seismic Restraint for Duct and Pipe 2008 01/2004 Page 8 of 17 http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=14 37 4. Refrigerant piping Index # 4-1 Reference Volume/Title ASHRAE/ Practical Guide to Seismic Restraint 4-2 SMACNA/ The Seismic Restraint Manual for Mechanical System 4-3 UFGS-13 48 00.00 10/ Seismic Protection for Mechanical Equipment 4-4 FEMA P-414/ Installing Seismic Restraints for Duct and Pipe Pg(s) or chapter Date Published 2012 2008 10/2007 01/2004 Comments Link Seismic restraint guideline for piping, water heaters, storage tanks, ovens and furnaces, water pumps, electric generators, combustible tank, and general HVAC systems. This is manual to install seismic restraint for piping and ductwork mainly for HVAC system but does not differentiate other type of pipes. This manual includes requirement and practical guide about how to install restraint for each different size and material of the pipe. Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for boilers and furnaces; water heaters; expansion air separator tanks; heat exchangers; water chiller units; cooling towers; refrigerant piping; pumps with motors; large commercial dryers; gas dryers; flash tanks; accumulator tanks; storage tanks for oil and water; steam, water, oil and gas pipe; valves and fittings for piping; steam-fed kitchen appliances; thermal storage units; air and refrigerant compressors; air handling units; lab scrubbers, pollution control equipment; ducts; unit heaters; exhaust and return fans; solar heating units, etc. Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for ducts, pipe, and in-line equipment (dampers, coils, fans, VAV boxes, valves, pumps, heat exchangers, strainers, air separators, etc.). http://www.ashrae.org/res ources-publications/bookstore/pr actical-guide-to-seismicrestraint Page 9 of 17 http://smacna.org/booksto re/index.cfm?fuseaction= search_results&keyword =Seismic%20Restraint% 20Manual:%20Guideline s%20for%20Mechanical %20Systems,%203rd%20 Edition http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DOD/UFGS/UFGS%20 13%2048%2000.00%201 0.pdf http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=14 37 5. Cable Trays Index # Reference Volume/Title Pg(s) or chapter Date Published Comments Link http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DOD/UFC/ufc_3_310_0 4.pdf 5-1 UFC 3-310-04/ Seismic Design of Buildings B-7(p 106) ~ B-8(p 107) 05/2012 This manual is for DoD projects and includes seismic design for buildings which includes bracing and restraints on suspended equipment (HVAC ducts, cable trays and bus ducts, electrical conduits, conduit racks, and vibration isolation). 5-2 FEMA 413/ Installing Seismic Restraints for Electrical Equipment p 30 ~ p 50 09/1994 Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for cable trays http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=46 26 Date Published Comments Link 6. Transformers Index # Reference Volume/Title 6-1 UFGS-26 05 48.00 10/ Seismic Protection for Electrical Equipment 6-2 IEEE 693-2005/ Recommended Practice for Seismic Design of Substations 6-3 IEEE 344/ Recommended Practice for Seismic Qualification of Equipment for Nuclear Power Generating Station Pg(s) or chapter 10/2007 Purchase Required – Link to 2004 draft provided Purchase Required 05/2006 2004 Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for control panels, pumps with motors, lighting fixtures, motor control centers, switchboards (floor mounted), air handling units, switchgear, unit substations, transformers, storage racks, solar heating units, conduits, engine-generators, free standing electric motors, etc. Seismic design of general equipments which include transformers. Does not address Class IE equipment for nuclear power stations. This document addresses Class IE equipment which IEEE defines as essential to the safe shutdown of a nuclear reactor and to the avoidance of radioactive material release. This may target a standard that exceeds our expectations for normal business application. Page 10 of 17 http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DOD/UFGS/UFGS%20 26%2005%2048.00%201 0.pdf http://ebookbrowse.com/ 05-ieee-693-draft-92004-pdf-d91094869 http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/ xpl/articleDetails.jsp?tp= &arnumber=1440989&co ntentType=Standards&so rtType%3Dasc_p_Seque nce%26filter%3DAND% 28p_Publication_Number %3A9842%29 6-4 FEMA 413/ Installing Seismic Restraints for Electrical Equipment p 24 ~ p 25 09/1994 Seismic restraint and anchor, and http://www.fema.gov/libr installation guide for ary/viewRecord.do?id=46 transformers 26 Date Published Comments 7. Tanks (other) Index # Reference Volume/Title 7-1 GAP.2.0.9.1/ Seismic Bracing 7-2 UFGS-13 48 00.00 10/ Seismic Protection for Mechanical Equipment 7-3 FEMA 412/ Installing Seismic Restraints for Mechanical Equipment Pg(s) or chapter 06/2008 10/2007 p 28 ~ p 29 Seismic bracing installation guide for general equipment which includes tanks. Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for boilers and furnaces; water heaters; expansion air separator tanks; heat exchangers; water chiller units; cooling towers; refrigerant piping; pumps with motors; large commercial dryers; gas dryers; flash tanks; accumulator tanks; storage tanks for oil and water; steam, water, oil and gas pipe; valves and fittings for piping; steam-fed kitchen appliances; thermal storage units; air and refrigerant compressors; air handling units; lab scrubbers, pollution control equipment; ducts; unit heaters; exhaust and return fans; solar heating units, etc. Link http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DOD/UFGS/UFGS%20 13%2048%2000.00%201 0.pdf 12/2002 Seismic restraint installation guide for tanks and gas cylinders. http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=15 57 Date Published Comments Link 2012 Seismic restraint guideline for piping, water heaters, storage tanks, ovens and furnaces, water pumps, electric generators, combustible tank, and general http://www.ashrae.org/res ources-publications/bookstore/pr actical-guide-to-seismicrestraint 8. Ovens/furnace Index # 8-1 Reference Volume/Title ASHRAE/ Practical Guide to Seismic Restraint Pg(s) or chapter Page 11 of 17 HVAC systems. 8-2 FEMA 412/ Installing Seismic Restraints for Mechanical Equipment p 12 ~ p 13 12/2002 Seismic restraint installation guide for boilers, furnaces, humidifiers, and water heaters. http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=15 57 Pg(s) or chapter Date Published Comments Link Seismic restraint guideline for piping, water heaters, storage tanks, ovens and furnaces, water pumps, electric generators, combustible tank, and general HVAC systems. Description of risk reduction methods for seismic damage of nonstructural components. Aimed at a non-engineering audience. http://www.ashrae.org/res ources-publications/bookstore/pr actical-guide-to-seismicrestraint 9. General Index # Reference Volume/Title 9-1 ASHRAE/ Practical Guide to Seismic Restraint 9-2 FEMA E-74 Reducing the Risks of Nonstructural Earthquake Damage – A Practical Guide 9-3 ASCE 7-10/ Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures 2012 01/2011 http://mitigation.eeri.org/ files/FEMA74_FieldMan ual.pdf 2010 Seismic design requirements and regulations for general buildings, structures, and equipment. http://www.techstreet.co m/cgibin/detail?doc_no=asce% 7C7_02;product_id=1082 081 9-4 UFGS-13 48 00/ Seismic Protection for Miscellaneous Equipment 08/2008 Storage cabinets, storage racks, shelving, partitions, ornamentations, signs and billboards, furnishings. http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DOD/UFGS/UFGS%20 13%2048%2000.pdf 9-5 GAP.2.0.9.1/ Seismic Bracing 06/2008 Seismic bracing for general equipment. 10/2007 Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for boilers and furnaces; water heaters; expansion air separator tanks; heat exchangers; water chiller units; cooling towers; refrigerant piping; pumps with motors; large commercial dryers; gas dryers; flash tanks; accumulator tanks; storage tanks for oil and water; steam, water, oil and gas pipe; valves and fittings for piping; steam-fed kitchen 9-6 UFGS-13 48 00.00 10/ Seismic Protection for Mechanical Equipment Page 12 of 17 http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DOD/UFGS/UFGS%20 13%2048%2000.00%201 0.pdf 9-7 UFGS-26 05 48.00 10/ Seismic Protection for Electrical Equipment 9-8 FEMA 232/ Homebuilders’ Guide to EarthquakeResistant Design and Construction 9-9 CSSC/ Commercial Property Owner’s Guide to Earthquake Safety 9-10 9-11 9-12 9-13 IBC 2006 section 1613/ Earthquake Loads – General FEMA 412/ Installing Seismic Restraints for Mechanical Equipment FEMA 413/ Installing Seismic Restraints for Electrical Equipment SAND93-8012/ Nonstructural Seismic Restraint Guidelines 10/2007 p 64 ~ p 67, 141 p ~ 150 p 06/2006 01/2006 appliances; thermal storage units; air and refrigerant compressors; air handling units; lab scrubbers, pollution control equipment; ducts; unit heaters; exhaust and return fans; solar heating units, etc. Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for control panels, pumps with motors, lighting fixtures, motor control centers, switchboards (floor mounted), air handling units, switchgear, unit substations, transformers, storage racks, solar heating units, conduits, enginegenerators, free standing electric motors, etc. Seismic resistant design guide including anchor installation guide for general home equipment such as walls, water heaters, and office equipment. Seismic restraint guide for water heaters, walls, floors, roofs, and general building contents. This guide was generated by California Seismic Safety Commission and it was distributed under the provisions of the Government Code Selection. http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DOD/UFGS/UFGS%20 26%2005%2048.00%201 0.pdf http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=21 03 http://www.seismic.ca.go v/pub/CSSC_200602_COG.pdf 2006 Seismic building requirements, calculations, and standards. http://www.iccsafe.org/St ore/Pages/Product.aspx?i d=3000X12 p 96 ~ p 121 12/2002 Anchor selection guide for general mechanical equipment. http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=15 57 p 151 ~ p 159 09/1994 Anchor selection guide for general electrical equipment. http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=46 26 1993 Seismic restraint guideline for general nonstructural equipment, such as tables, refrigerators, tanks, and gas cylinders. http://www.osti.gov/bridg e/servlets/purl/10185956unXkWP/native/1018595 6.pdf Page 13 of 17 10.Others Index # 10-1 10-2 10-3 10-4 10-5 10-6 10-7 Reference Volume/Title UFC 3-310-04/ Seismic Design of Buildings Pg(s) or chapter Date Published Comments Link 05/2012 This manual is for DoD projects and includes seismic design for buildings which includes bracing and restraints on suspended equipment (HVAC ducts, cable trays and bus ducts, electrical conduits, conduit racks, and vibration isolation) and general base-mounted equipment. http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DOD/UFC/ufc_3_310_0 4.pdf 2009 Contains sections on state-ofthe-art requirements for anchorage design of nonstructural components. http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=41 03 04/2008 Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for storage racks. http://www.palletracksyst ems.com/documents/AN SI_testing_standards.pdf 02/2008 Background document to FEMA 74, Reducing the Risks of Nonstructural Earthquake Damage – A Practical Guide. Presents current practice and knowledge with regard to bracing and anchorage of nonstructural components and contents. http://www.atcouncil.org/ pdfs/SOAReport.pdf p5~p6 09/2005 Seismic bracing installation guide for water heaters. www.pdc.org/pdf/prepare dness/fema530.pdf p 7 ~ p 24 09/2005 Seismic bracing, anchoring, and strengthening guide for houses. www.pdc.org/pdf/prepare dness/fema530.pdf 09/2005 Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for storage racks. http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=14 39 B-6(p 105) ~ B-8(p 107) FEMA P-750 NEHRP Recommended Seismic Provisions for New Buildings and Other Structures RMI MH16.1:2008/ Specification for the Design, Testing and Utilization of Industrial Steel Storage Racks ATC-69 Reducing the Risks of Nonstructural Earthquake Damage: State-of-the-Art and Practice Report FEMA 530/ Earthquake Safety Guide for Homeowners FEMA 530/ Earthquake Safety Guide for Homeowners FEMA 460/ Seismic Considerations for Steel Storage Racks Located in Areas Accessible to the Public Page 14 of 17 10-8 10-9 10-10 10-11 10-12 10-13 Nonstructural Earthquake Mitigation Guidance Manual FEMA P-414/ Installing Seismic Restraints for Duct and Pipe FEMA 450-1 NEHRP Recommended Provisions for Seismic Regulations for New Buildings and Other Structures – Part 1: Provisions and Part 2: Commentary NIST GCR 97-732/ Fire Hazards and Mitigation Measures Associated with Seismic Damage of Water Heaters FEMA-172 NEHRP Handbook of Techniques for Seismic Rehabilitation of Existing Buildings FEMA-202 Earthquake Resistant Construction of Electric Transmission and Telecommunication Facilities Serving the Federal Government http://www.bchelpline.co m/BCAToolkit/resource_ files/tech_manuals/earthq uake/Nonstructural_EQ_ Tech_Manual.pdf 04/2004 Guidance on practical mitigation measures for reduction of nonstructural seismic damage. 01/2004 Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for duct, pipe, and in-line equipment (dampers, coils, fans, VAV boxes, valves, pumps, heat exchangers, strainers, air separators, etc. ). 2003 Architectural, mechanical and electrical component design seismic requirements. http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DHS/fema450_1.pdf 12/1997 Seismic restraint and anchor, installation guide for water heater and fuel gas shut-off valves. http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpu bs/build98/PDF/b98066.p df 06/1992 Includes chapters on methods of strengthening nonstructural elements (e.g. precast elements, curtain walls, etc) as well as electrical and mechanical components. http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=15 12 09/1990 Overview of measures taken by Federal agencies to protect transmission and telecommunication facilities. http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=16 35 Page 15 of 17 http://www.fema.gov/libr ary/viewRecord.do?id=14 37 11.Private Company Literature 11-1 11-2 11-3 Mason Industries, INC Kinetic Noise Control/ Pipe and Duct Seismic Application Manual B-Line/ Seismic Restraint (SRS 06) 11-4 ISAT/ Seismic Design Manuals 11-5 Armstrong Seismic Rx Suspension System/ Seismic Rx® Code Compliant Solution 11-6 USG/ Seismic Technical Guide Purchase Required 10/2011 Seismic restraint guidelines for suspending piping, ductwork, electrical systems, floor, and roof mounted equipment. 2008~ 2009 Descriptive guide for selectioninstallation of seismic restraint for pipes and ducts. This document includes seismic restraint guidance for medical gas piping, sprinkler system piping, and refrigerant piping. 2006 Seismic restraint catalogue which includes many useful guidelines for selecting and installing seismic restraints for cable trays. http://www.masonindustries.com/masonind/ _doc/pdf/SRG1011.pdf http://www.kineticsnoise. com/seismic/pipe_duct/pi pe_duct_seismic_applicat ion.pdf or http://www.kineticsnoise. com/seismic/seismic_rest raint_pipe_duct.aspx http://www.cooperindustr ies.com/content/dam/publ ic/bline/Resources/Librar y/catalogs/seismic_restrai nts/seismic_opa0114_2006/SRS06.pdf Seismic design manuals based on IBC 2003, IBC 2006, and CBC 2007.These manuals are very specific on the topic and cover many types of equipment and structures, including cable trays, ducts, and sprinkler piping. http://www.isatsb.com/pr oducts.php Seismic ceiling suspension components installation/selection guide. http://www.armstrong.co m/common/c2002/conten t/files/34331.pdf Seismic anchor guide includes information on separation joints and how to install them. http://www.usg.com/rc/te chnical-articles/seismictechnical-guide-seismicexpansion-joints-enSC2496.pdf Page 16 of 17 12. Related Information 12-1 UFGS-13 48 00/ Seismic Protection for Miscellaneous Equipment MasterSpec 226313/ Gas Piping for Laboratory and Healthcare Facilities 08/2008 DoD specification listing for seismic protection of miscellaneous equipment. http://www.wbdg.org/ccb /DOD/UFGS/UFGS%20 13%2048%2000.pdf Purchase Required Specification listing for medical gas piping. http://www.masterspec.c om/architectural_specific ations.aspx 12-3 MasterSpec 15074/ Vibration and Seismic Controls for Plumbing Piping and Equipment Purchase Required Specification listing for seismic protection of piping. http://www.masterspec.c om/architectural_specific ations.aspx 12-4 Masterformat (CSI) 13080/ Sound, Vibration and Seismic Control Purchase Required 12-2 Specification listing for seismic protection of piping. http://www.masterformat. com/ 13. Guidelines from Outside of the United States 13-1 13-2 13-3 13-4 Korea Infrastructure Safety Corporation/ How to design building to resist earthquake An Information Booklet for the International Community in Kochi/ Preparing for the Nankai Earthquake Eurocode 8/ Design of structures for earthquake resistance A Guide for Living in Suita/ Earthquake/Tsunamis p 5 ~ p 10 Purchase Required 07/2011 Seismic design and restraint selection (calculation) guide in Korea. Guide is focused at securing walls. http://www.kistec.or.kr/ki stec/earth/earth0701.asp? flashActive=110701 03/2008 Japanese information booklet to prepare for earthquakes, with seismic restraint guidelines for general home equipment. http://www.kochikia.or.jp/info/englishscrip t2.pdf Seismic resistant design manual for bridges, tanks, pipelines, and others. http://www.eurocodes.co. uk/EurocodeDetail.aspx? Eurocode=8 Simple seismic design and restraint guideline in Japan. http://www.city.suita.osa ka.jp/var/rev0/0031/8785/ p12-13.pdf Page 17 of 17