Chapter 4 Engr228 Circuit Analysis Dr Curtis Nelson Chapter 4 Objectives • Understand and be able to use the node-voltage method to solve a circuit. • Understand and be able to use the mesh-current method to solve a circuit. • Be able to determine which technique is best for a particular circuit. • Understand source transformations and be able to use them to solve a circuit. • Understand the concept of Thevenin and Norton equivalent circuits and be able to construct one. • Know the condition for maximum power transfer to a resistive load and be able to calculate the value of the load resistor that satisfies this condition. Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 1 Circuit Analysis • As circuits get more complicated, we need an organized method of applying KVL, KCL, and Ohm’s law. • Nodal analysis assigns voltages to each node, and then we apply Kirchhoff's Current Law to solve for the node voltages. • Mesh analysis assigns currents to each mesh, and then we apply Kirchhoff’s Voltage Law to solve for the mesh currents. Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 2 Review - Nodes, Paths, Loops, Branches • These two networks are equivalent. • There are three nodes and five branches: – Node: a point at which two or more elements have a common connection point. – Branch: a single path in a network composed of one simple element and the node at each end of that element. • A path is a sequence of nodes. • A loop is a closed (circular) path. Review - Kirchhoff’s Current Law • Kirchhoff’s Current Law (KCL) states that the algebraic sum of all currents entering a node is zero. iA + iB + (−iC) + (−iD) = 0 Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 3 Review - Kirchhoff’s Voltage Law • Kirchhoff’s Voltage Law (KVL) states that the algebraic sum of the voltages around any closed path is zero. -v1 + v2 + -v3 = 0 Node Example • Node = every point along the same wire 6K V 10V 4K 3 nodes Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 4 Nodes How many nodes are there in the circuit(s) below? Notes on Writing Nodal Equations • All terms in the equations are in units of current. • Everyone has their own style of writing nodal equations – The important thing is that you remain consistent. • Probably the easiest method if you are just getting started is to remember that: Current entering a node = current leaving the node • Current directions can be assigned arbitrarily, unless they are previously specified. Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 5 The Nodal Analysis Method • Assign voltages to every node relative to a reference node. Choosing the Reference Node • By convention, the bottom node is often the reference node. • If a ground connection is shown, then that becomes the reference node. • Otherwise, choose a node with many connections. • The reference node is most often assigned a value of 0.0 volts. Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 6 Apply KCL to Find Voltages • Assume reference voltage = 0.0 volts • Assign current names and directions • Apply KCL to node v1 ( Σ out = Σ in) • Apply Ohm’s law to each resistor: v1 v1 − v 2 + = 3.1 2 5 Apply KCL to Find Voltages • Apply KCL to node v2 ( Σ out = Σ in) • Apply Ohm’s law to each resistor: v1 − v2 v2 − 0 = + (−1.4) 5 1 We now have two equations for the two unknowns v1 and v2 and we can solve them simultaneously: v1 = 5V and v2 = 2V Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 7 Example: Nodal Analysis Find the current i in the circuit below. Answer: i = 0 (since v1=v2=20 V) Nodal Analysis: Dependent Source Example Determine the power supplied by the dependent source. Key step: eliminate i1 from the equations using v1=2i1 15 = v1 − v2 v1 − 0 + 1 2 v1 − v2 v −0 + 3i1 = 2 1 3 i1 = v1 − 0 2 Answer: 4.5 kW being generated Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 8 Example #1 V1 V2 0V V1 = 3 V1−V 2 V2−0 +2= 5 1 13 V2= 6 Example #2 • How many nodes are in this circuit? • How many nodal equations must you write to solve for the unknown voltages? V2 V1 V3 0V Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 9 Example #2 – node V1 V2 V1 V3 0V V1−V 3 V1−V 2 +3+ =0 4 3 96 + 3V 1 − 3V 3 + 36 + 4V 1 − 4V 2 = 0 8+ At node V1 7V 1 − 4V 2 − 3V 3 = −132 Example #2 – node V2 V1 V2 V3 0V At node V2 Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E V 2 − V1 V 2 −V 3 V 2 − 0 −3+ + =0 3 2 1 2V 2 − 2V 1 − 18 + 3V 2 − 3V 3 + 6V 2 = 0 − 2V 1 + 11V 2 − 3V 3 = 18 10 Example #2 – node V3 V2 V1 V3 0V At node V3 V 3 − V 2 V 3 − V1 V3−0 + − 25 + =0 2 4 5 10V 3 − 10V 2 + 5V 3 − 5V 1 − 500 + 4V 3 = 0 − 5V 1 − 10V 2 + 19V 3 = 500 All 3 Equations 7V 1 − 4V 2 − 3V 3 = −132 − 2V 1 + 11V 2 − 3V 3 = 18 − 5V 1 − 10V 2 + 19V 3 = 500 Answer: Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E V1 = 0.956V V2 = 10.576V V3 = 32.132V 11 Voltage Sources and the Supernode If there is a DC voltage source between two non-reference nodes, you can get into trouble when trying to use KCL between the two nodes because the current through the voltage source may not be known, and an equation cannot be written for it. Therefore, we use a supernode instead. The Supernode Analysis Technique • Apply KCL at Node v1. • Apply KCL at the supernode. • Add the equation for the voltage source inside the supernode. v1 = 1.0714V v2 = 10.5V v3 = 32.5V Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E v1 − v3 v1 − v2 + = −3 − 8 4 3 v1 − v2 v1 − v3 v v + = −3 + 2 + 3 − 25 3 4 1 5 v3 − v2 = 22 12 Modified Example V2 V1 V3 0V Modified Example – node V1 V2 V1 V3 0V At node V1 V1−V 3 V1−V 2 +3+ =0 4 3 96 + 3V 1 − 3V 3 + 36 + 4V 1 − 4V 2 = 0 8+ 7V 1 − 4V 2 − 3V 3 = −132 Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 13 Modified Example – node V2, supernode supernode V2 V1 V3 0V At node V2 V 2 − V1 V 3 − V1 V3−0 V2−0 −3+ − 25 + + =0 3 4 5 1 20V 2 − 20V 1 − 180 + 15V 3 − 15V 1 − 1500 + 12V 3 + 60V 2 = 0 − 35V 1 + 80V 2 + 27V 3 = 1680 Supernode V 2 −V 3 = 1 Solving Simultaneous Equations 7V 1 − 4V 2 − 3V 3 = −132 − 35V 1 + 80V 2 + 27V 3 = 1680 V 2 −V 3 = 1 V1 = -4.952 V V2 = 14.333 V V3 = 13.333 V Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 14 Mesh Analysis: Nodal Alternative • • • • A mesh is a loop that does not contain any other loops within it. In mesh analysis, we assign mesh currents and solve using KVL. All terms in the equations are in units of voltage. Remember – voltage drops in the direction of current flow except for sources that are generating power. • The circuit below has four meshes: Mesh Example Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 15 The Mesh Analysis Method Mesh currents Branch currents Mesh: Apply KVL Apply KVL to mesh 1 ( Σ drops = 0 ): -42 + 6i1 +3(i1-i2) = 0 Apply KVL to mesh 2 ( Σ drops = 0 ): 3(i2-i1) + 4i2 -10 = 0 i1 = 6A i2 = 4A Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 16 Example: Mesh Analysis Determine the power supplied by the 2 V source. Applying KVL to the meshes: −5 + 4i1 + 2(i1 − i2) − 2 = 0 +2 + 2(i2 − i1) + 5i2 + 1 = 0 i1 = 1.132 A i2 = −0.1053 A Answer: -2.474 W (the source is generating power) A Three Mesh Example Follow each mesh clockwise Simplify Solve the equations: i1 = 3 A, i2 = 2 A, and i3 = 3 A Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 17 Example • Use mesh analysis to determine Vx I2 I1 I3 Example - continued − 7 + 1( I 1 − I 2) + 6 + 2( I 1 − I 3) = 0 I2 I1 3I1 − I 2 − 2 I 3 = 1 Equation I 1( I 2 − I 1) + 2 I 2 + 3( I 2 − I 3) = 0 I3 − I1 + 6 I 2 − 3I 3 = 0 Equation II 2( I 3 − I1) − 6 + 3( I 3 − I 2) + I 3 = 0 − 2 I 1 − 3I 2 + 6 I 3 = 6 Equation III I1 = 3A, I2 = 2A, I3 = 3A Vx = 3(I3-I2) = 3V Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 18 Current Sources and the Supermesh • If a current source is present in the network and shared between two meshes, then you must use a supermesh formed from the two meshes that have the shared current source. We can eliminate the need for introducing a voltage variable by applying KVL to the supermesh formed by joining meshes 1 and 3. Supermesh Example • Use mesh analysis to evaluate Vx I2 I1 I3 Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 19 Supermesh Example - continued I2 I1 I3 Loop 2: 1( I 2 − I 1) + 2 I 2 + 3( I 2 − I 3) = 0 − I 1 + 6 I 2 − 3I 3 = 0 Equation I Supermesh Example - continued Supermesh I2 I1 I3 I1 = 9A I2 = 2.5A I3 = 2A Vx = 3(I3-I2) = -1.5V Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E −7 + 1( I1 − I 2) + 3( I 3 − I 2) + I 3 = 0 I1 − 4 I 2 + 4 I 3 = 7 Equation II I1 − I 3 = 7 Equation III 20 Node or Mesh: How to Choose? • Use the one with fewer equations, or • Use the method you like best, or • Use both (as a check). Example Does nodal analysis or loop analysis have fewer equations? 7V V1 V2 V3 0V Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 21 Dependent Source Example Find i1 Answer: i1 = - 250 mA. Dependent Source Example Find Vx I2 I1 I3 Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 22 Dependent Source Example - continued I1 = 15 A Equation I I2 1( I 2 − I 1) + 2 I 2 + 3( I 2 − I 3) = 0 − I1 + 6 I 2 − 3I 3 = 0 Equation II I1 I3 1 I 3 − I1 = Vx Equation III 9 Vx = 3( I 3 − I 2) Equation IV I1=15A, I2=11A, I3=17A Vx = 3(17-11) = 18V Textbook Problem 4.52 Hayt 7E • Obtain a value for the current labeled i10 in the circuit below I10 = -4mA Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 23 Linear Elements and Circuits • A linear circuit element has a linear voltage-current relationship: – If i(t) produces v(t), then Ki(t) produces Kv(t) – If i1(t) produces v1(t) and i2(t) produces v2(t), then i1(t) + i2(t) produces v1(t) + v2(t), • Resistors and sources are linear elements – Dependent sources need linear control equations to be linear elements • A linear circuit is one with only linear elements The Superposition Concept For the circuit shown below, the question is: • How much of v1 is due to source ia, and how much is due to source ib? We will use the superposition principle to answer this question. Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 24 The Superposition Theorem In a linear network, the voltage across or the current through any element may be calculated by adding algebraically all the individual voltages or currents caused by the separate independent sources acting “alone”, i.e. with – All other independent voltage sources replaced by short circuits (i.e. set to a zero value) and – All other independent current sources replaced by open circuits (also set to a zero value). Applying Superposition • Leave one source ON and turn all other sources OFF: – Voltage sources: set v=0 These become short circuits. – Current sources: set i=0 These become open circuits. • Then, find the response due to that one source • Add the responses from the other sources to find the total response Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 25 Superposition Example (Part 1 of 4) Use superposition to solve for the current ix Superposition Example (Part 2 of 4) First, turn the current source off: i′x = Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 3 = 0.2 6+9 26 Superposition Example (Part 3 of 4) Then, turn the voltage source off: ix′ = 6 (2) = 0.8 6+9 Superposition Example (Part 4 of 4) Finally, combine the results: ix = ix′ + ix′ = 0.2 + 0.8 = 1.0 Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 27 Example: Power Ratings Determine the maximum positive current to which the source Ix can be set before any resistor exceeds its power rating. Answer: Ix < 42.49 mA Superposition with a Dependent Source • When applying superposition to circuits with dependent sources, these dependent sources are never “turned off.” Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 28 Superposition with a Dependent Source Current source off Voltage source off ix = ix’+ix’’=2 + (−0.6) = 1.4 A Superposition Example Find voltage Vx. First, solve by nodal analysis. (42-Vx)/6 = (Vx-(-10))/4 + Vx/3 Vx = 54/9 = 6 volts Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 29 Example - Continued (3 || 4) (12 / 7) × 42 = × 42 6 + (3 || 4) 6 + (12 / 7) Vx( 42V ) = = 9.333V Example - Continued Vx(10V ) = − (6 || 3) 2 ×10 = − ×10 (6 || 3) + 4 2+4 = −3.333V Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 30 Example - Continued Vx = Vx( 42V ) + Vx(10V ) = 9.333 − 3.333 = 6V Source Transformation and Equivalent Sources The sources are equivalent if Rs=Rp and vs=isRs Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 31 Source Transformation • The circuits (a) and (b) are equivalent at the terminals. • If given circuit (a), but circuit (b) is more convenient, switch them. • This process is called source transformation. Example: Source Transformation We can find the current I in the circuit below using a source transformation, as shown. I = (45-3)/(5+4.7+3) = 3.307 mA I = 3.307 mA Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 32 Example Use source transformations to find Ix Example - continued Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 33 Example - continued Example - continued IX = Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 2 2 1 = = A 1+ 2 + 3 6 3 34 Textbook Problem 5.24 Hayt 7E • Using source transformations, determine the power dissipated by the 5.8 kΩ resistor. 42.97 mW Textbook Problem 5.6 Hayt 8E (a) Determine the individual contributions of each of the two current sources to the nodal voltage v1 (b) Determine the power dissipated by the 2Ω resistor v17A = 6.462V, v14A = -2.154V, v1tot = 4.31V, P2Ω = 3.41W Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 35 Textbook Problem 5.17 Hayt 8E Determine the current labeled i after first transforming the circuit such that it contains only resistors and voltage sources. i = -577µA Textbook Problem 5.18 Hayt 8E Using source transformations, reduce the circuit to a voltage source in series with a resistor, both of which are in series with the 6 MΩ resistor. Vs = -6.284V Rs = 825.4 kΩ Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 36 Textbook Problem 5.19 Hayt 8E Find the power generated by the 7V source. P7v = 17.27W (generating) Thévenin Equivalent Circuits Thévenin’s theorem: a linear network can be replaced by its Thévenin equivalent circuit, as shown below: Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 37 Thévenin Equivalent using Source Transformations • We can repeatedly apply source transformations on network A to find its Thévenin equivalent circuit. • This method has limitations - not all circuits can be source transformed. Finding the Thévenin Equivalent • Disconnect the load. • Find the open circuit voltage voc. • Find the equivalent resistance Req of the network with all independent sources turned off. Then: VTH = voc and RTH = Req Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 38 Thévenin Example Example Find Thevenin’s equivalent circuit and the current passing thru RL given that RL = 1Ω Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 39 Example - continued Find VTH 10V 6V 6V 0V 0V 0V VTH = 3 ×10 = 6V 2+3 Example - continued Find RTH RTH = 10 + 2 || 3 + 2 Short voltage source 2×3 +2 2+3 = 13.2Ω = 10 + RTH Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 40 Example - continued Thevenin’s equivalent circuit The current thru RL = 1Ω is 6 = 0.423 A 13.2 + 1 Example Find Thevenin’s equivalent circuit Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 41 Example - continued Find VTH 5V 3V 3V 0V 0V 0V VTH = 1× 3 = 3V Example - continued Find RTH Open circuit current source RTH = 10 + 3 + 2 = 15Ω RTH Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 42 Example - continued Thevenin’s equivalent circuit Example: Bridge Circuit Find Thevenin’s equivalent circuit as seen by RL Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 43 Example - continued Find VTH 10V 8V 2V 0V VTH = 8-2 = 6V Example - continued Find RTH RTH Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 44 Example - continued RTH = 2 K || 8 K + 4 K || 1K = 1.6 K + 0.8 K = 2.4 K Example - continued Thevenin’s equivalent circuit Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 45 Thevenin’s Equivalent Circuit - Recap Norton Equivalent Circuits Norton’s theorem: a linear network can be replaced by its Norton equivalent circuit, as shown below: Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 46 Finding the Norton Equivalent • Replace the load with a short circuit. • Find the short circuit current isc. • Find the equivalent resistance Req of the network with all independent sources turned off. Then: IN = isc and RN = Req Source Transformation: Norton and Thévenin • The Thévenin and Norton equivalents are source transformations of each other. RTH=RN =Req and vTH=iNReq Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 47 Example: Norton and Thévenin Find the Thévenin and Norton equivalents for the network faced by the 1-kΩ resistor. The load resistor This is the circuit we will simplify Example: Norton and Thévenin Norton Thévenin Source Transformation Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 48 Thévenin Example: Handling Dependent Sources One method to find the Thévenin equivalent of a circuit with a dependent source: find VTH and IN and solve for RTH=VTH / IN Thévenin Example: Handling Dependent Sources Finding the ratio VTH / IN fails when both quantities are zero! Solution: apply a test source. Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 49 Thévenin Example: Handling Dependent Sources Solve: vtest =0.6 V, and so RTH = 0.6 Ω v test v test − (1.5i) + =1 2 3 i = −1 Example • Find Norton’s equivalent circuit and the current through RL if RL = 1Ω Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 50 Example - continued Find IN Find R total: Find I total: Current divider: 2 + 3 || (10 + 2) = 2 + I= 3 × 12 = 4.4Ω 3 + 12 V 10 = = 2.27 A R 4.4 I SC = 3 × 2.27 = 0.45 A 3 + 12 Example - continued Find Rn RTH = 10 + 2 || 3 + 2 2×3 +2 2+3 = 13.2Ω = 10 + Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 51 Norton’s Equivalent Circuit The current thru RL = 1Ω is 13.2 × 0.45 = 0.418 A 13.2 + 1 Relationship Between Thevenin and Norton RTH = RN VTH = I N × RTH I ISC Slope = - 1/RTH VOC Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E V 52 Recap: Thevenin and Norton Thevenin’s equivalent circuit Norton’s equivalent circuit Same R value RTH = RN 6 = 0.45 ×13.2 VTH = I N × RTH Textbook Problem 5.50 Hayt 7E Find the Thevenin equivalent of the circuit below. RTH = 8.523 kΩ VTH = 83.5 V Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 53 Equivalent Circuits with Dependent Sources We cannot find RTH in circuits with dependent sources using the total resistance method. But we can use RTH = VOC I SC Example Find Thevenin and Norton’s equivalent circuits Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 54 Example - continued Find Voc I2 I1 KVL loop1 − 1 + 250 I1 + 4000( I1 − I 2) = 0 4250 I1 − 4000 I 2 = 1 KVL loop2 4000( I 2 − I 1) + 2000 I 2 + 80 I 2 − 100Vx = 0 Vx = 4000( I 1 − I 2) − 404000I 1 + 406080 I 2 = 0 Example - continued I2 I1 Solve equations I1 = 3.697mA I2 = 3.678mA VOC = 80 I 2 − 100Vx = 80 I 2 − 400000( I 1 − I 2) = 80(3.678mA) − 400000(3.697 − 3.678) = −7.3V Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 55 Example - continued Find Isc I2 I1 KVL loop1 KVL loop2 I3 − 1 + 250 I 1 + 4000 ( I 1 − I 2 ) = 0 4250 I 1 − 4000 I 2 = 1 4000 ( I 2 − I 1) + 2000 I 2 + 80 ( I 2 − I 3) − 100Vx = 0 Vx = 4000 ( I 1 − I 2 ) − 404000 I 1 + 406080 I 2 − 80 I 3 = 0 KVL loop3 80 ( I 3 − I 2) + 100Vx = 0 400000 I 1 − 400080 I 2 + 80 I 3 = 0 Example - continued Find Isc I1 I2 I3 I1 = 0.632mA I2 = 0.421mA I3 = -1.052 A Isc = I3 = -1.052 A Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 56 Example - continued RTH = VOC − 7.28 = = 6.94Ω I SC − 1.052 Thevenin’s equivalent circuit Norton’s equivalent circuit Maximum Power Transfer Thevenin’s or Norton’s equivalent circuit, which has an RTH connected to it, delivers a maximum power to the load RL for which RTH = RL Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 57 Maximum Power Theorem Proof P = I 2 RL I= and 2 VTH RTH + RL 2 VTH VTH RL P = ⋅ R = Plug it in L R +R ( RTH + RL ) 2 L TH 2 2 dP ( RTH + RL ) 2 VTH − VTH RL ⋅ 2( RTH + RL ) = =0 dRL ( RTH + RL ) 4 Maximum Power Theorem Proof - continued 2 2 dP ( RTH + RL ) 2 VTH − VTH RL ⋅ 2( RTH + RL ) = =0 dRL ( RTH + RL ) 4 2 2 ( RTH + RL ) 2VTH = VTH RL ⋅ 2( RTH + RL ) ( RTH + RL ) = 2 RL RTH = RL For maximum power transfer Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 58 Example Evaluate RL for maximum power transfer and find the power. Example - continued Thevenin’s equivalent circuit RL should be set to 13.2Ω to get max. power transfer Max. power is Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E V 2 ( 6 / 2) 2 = = 0.68W R 13.2 59 Practical Voltage Sources • Ideal voltage sources: a first approximation model for a battery. • Why do real batteries have a current limit and experience voltage drop as current increases? • Two car battery models: Practical Source: Effect of Connecting a Load For the car battery example: VL = 12 – 0.01 IL This line represents all possible RL Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 60 Practical Voltage Source vL = vs − Rs iL OR iL = vs v L − Rs Rs voc = v s i Lsc = vs Rs Practical Current Source iL = is − vL Rp v Loc = R p is iLsc = is Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 61 Equivalent Practical Sources iL = vs v L − Rs Rs iL = is − vL Rp • These two practical sources are equivalent if iS = vS RS RS = RP Chapter 4 Summary • Illustrated the node-voltage method to solve a circuit. • Illustrated the mesh-current method to solve a circuit. • Practiced choosing which technique is better for a particular circuit. • Explained source transformations and how to use them to solve a circuit. • Illustrated the techniques of constructing Thevenin and Norton equivalent circuits. • Explained the principle of maximum power transfer to a resistive load and showed how to calculate the value of the load resistor that satisfies this condition. Engr228 - Chapter 4, Nilsson 9E 62