A practical guide to strengthening flexible partnerships and pathways at NCEA Level 3 3+2 approaches Purpose of this guide This document provides information about how to strengthen partnerships between secondary, tertiary, industry training and employment with better pathways through education at Level 3. Pathways and partnerships will engage and retain more learners by providing: a greater choice of programmes improving achievement at Level 3 or equivalent in different contexts supporting progression to further study and employment. This guide has been developed to help people who are interested in developing new programmes of learning using more than one provider. Background to 3+2 approaches Education and training needs to build on student centred pathways and programmes which have led to improved NCEA Level 2 achievement in the last few years. These include a range of learning options for 16-19 year old learners aligned to Vocational Pathways. Secondary-tertiary-industry programmes and initiatives, such as trades academies, Gateway, STAR and fees-free support the improved achievement of NCEA Level 2. Using the Vocational Pathways at Level 3 as an organising framework for curriculum and programme delivery and student decision making can help extend links from learning beyond Level 3. This will support learners’ career and study choices to Level 4 and above, and lead to higher skill development for industry, business and the community. Using the available flexibility in the system beyond compulsory education is the key to improving engagement, retention and progression for 16-19 year olds. 3+2 approaches can operate within existing funding and assessment policy arrangements. Some of these approaches already exist where schools, other providers and industries are exploring these flexibilities. Purpose of 3+2 approaches The purpose of 3+2 is to offer greater choice of curriculum and programmes for learners in the senior secondary school at Level 3. Current mechanisms support part time enrolment across multiple settings so learners can be engaged and enrolled in programmes that offer different combinations of time, setting and activity. The following table shows some examples of possible options using this flexibility. 04/03/16 Version 2 1 Table 1: Example options for learners (ages 16-19) enrolled part-time in multiple settings1 School Tertiary Industry training Gateway2 STAR (either by days or in portions of time) (either by days or in portions of time) (either by days or in portions of time) (either by days or in portions of time) (as agreed) A 2 2 B 2 C 2 2 C 2 3 D 3 E 3 Options F 2 1 1 connections 2 2 3 G 1 2 connections connections 2 3 By blocks H (3+2) 20 weeks3 I (2.5+2.5) 17 weeks 20 weeks J(4 +1) 27.2 weeks 8 weeks 16 weeks 3+2 approaches show ways in which Level 3 programmes aligned to Vocational Pathways can provide diverse programmes using a multi partnership approach. While secondary schools have traditionally done well in preparing those school leavers who move on to degree-level study (around 30% of school leavers), they typically do less well in preparing the remaining 70% of school leavers for further study, training and employment. This latter group of young people has diverse needs. 3+2 approaches are primarily aimed at better meeting the curriculum needs of students who have already turned 16 and who have achieved NCEA Level 2. There are also others likely to benefit (see below: What cohort information tells us). What cohort information tells us For every 100 young people who enter Year 9 (based on 1994 cohort): 23 leave school before completing NCEA Level 2 16 learners complete NCEA Level 2 and leave without attempting NCEA Level 3 18 learners complete NCEA Level 2, return to school, but do not gain NCEA Level 3, and 43 learners complete NCEA Level 2 and go on to gain NCEA Level 3 of the initial 100 entrants, 30 young people go to degree level study as school leavers. 1 Calculations are approximate and based on the hours indicated in Tables 2 and 3 in this document Gateway is arranged through schools. This column shows additional time organised from the school setting. 3 20 weeks in school is approximately 2 terms 2 26/02/16 Version 2 2 The opportunity for 3+2 approaches is primarily for the group of 18 learners who return to school with NCEA Level 2 but leave without completing NCEA Level 3. It may also appeal to: some of the 23 who quit before NCEA Level 2, and some of the 16 who leave with NCEA Level 2 and might stay if the curriculum offering were different some of the group of 43 who progress to achieving NCEA Level 3; after all, only 30 of these go directly to degree level study on leaving school up to 13 of the 30 might also find a mix of school and/or tertiary/work appealing – particularly if careful subject selection and programme planning keep the possibility of gaining a University Entrance award alive. 3+2 approaches work best when they are focused on results: 3+2 gives learners the option to achieve NCEA Level 3 and work towards a tertiary qualification or undertake industry training. Learners and their families/whānau will clearly understand the requirements and benefits of school and tertiary education, including industry training they have strong partnerships: when schools, tertiary education providers and industry training organisations (ITOs) work together to support learners by developing partnership agreements that acknowledge different roles and responsibilities. Partnerships may range from informal arrangements to well defined arrangements with more formal agreements. Although formal agreements are not mandatory, it may help providers maximise programme coherence for the learner learners and their families/whānau and employers have good information about the 3+2 approach and the work required to achieve meaningful qualifications (at the start and as they work through the qualifications) schools, industry training organisations and tertiary education providers work together to provide high quality education that supports learners. Best practice could include aspects such as planning the overall programme together, providing coordinated quality assurance approaches4, coordinated pastoral care and ensuring high quality communication to learners, families and whānau. The benefit story For learners, 3+2 approaches 4 open up learning opportunities that cannot be delivered solely at school, or at a tertiary organisation build on previous achievement and experience at NCEA Level 2 help learners achieve NCEA Level 3 and work towards a relevant tertiary qualification help learners gain insights to the wide range of careers and jobs available help learners begin to experience tertiary or work based learning while still at school Each provider is responsible to meet NZQA quality assurance expectations for their setting. 26/02/16 Version 2 3 help learners choose and plan a pathway to employment and access the relevant learning opportunity to get started. For schools, 3+2 approaches help provide and support learners to achieve meaningful, relevant qualifications help to better connect with tertiary education and industry training (employment) opportunities for their learners help to retain learners part-time in meaningful and relevant learning programmes when they might otherwise leave after completing NCEA Level 2 or during the NCEA Level 3 year deliver certainty of funding for part-time students enable better engagement of all learners, including Māori and Pasifika, through meaningful and relevant learning programmes help access curriculum and pathways that schools are unable to offer help build direct, curriculum-focused relationships with employers help build opportunities for shared practice and industry understanding for teachers contribute towards regional/national skills development. For industry training organisations, 3+2 approaches deliver stronger entry points for learners into industry training/recruitment (their own skills supply chain) (currently only 7% of students from school are entering industry training) enable strengthened collaboration across the education sectors to increase the supply of skilled workers create additional opportunities to support industry skills development contribute towards regional/national skills development. For tertiary providers, 3+2 approaches create stronger pipelines for learners into tertiary study through improved collaboration create opportunity to provide programmes with learning contexts that make connections to the relevance of school based learning for all learners, including Māori and Pasifika build opportunities for shared practice and for tertiary tutors to understand younger students contribute towards regional/national skills development create additional opportunities to support industry skills development For employers, 3+2 approaches provide access to more learners who are being supported into industry training by many schools position employers to champion progression and skills development allow employers to be pro-active about addressing and ensuring their skills/labour supply chain 26/02/16 Version 2 4 ensure employability skills are gained and young people meet employer needs. For communities, 3+2 approaches allow them to see their young people engaged in learning that leads to future qualifications, employment opportunities and success allow them to gain a better understanding of the positive outcomes of industry training and vocational learning in tertiary and other settings, and qualification pathway options for their young people promote programmes with learning contexts that better engage all learners including Māori and Pasifika. Early examples of 3+2 approaches A number of schools and other providers, trainers and employers are already exploring this territory and offer examples of good practice that others may choose to follow. In 2016, partnerships have been developed between two Hamilton schools and a polytechnic to offer school and tertiary learning for a group of approximately 30 students. The three days at school comprises mathematics and physics plus the student’s choice of one other subject connected to the contexts provided in the tertiary setting. The remaining two days are spent at the polytechnic studying either building and construction or mechanical engineering. The Level 3 assessment standards contribute to NCEA Level 3 and offer pathway opportunities to studying the NZ Diploma in Engineering. In 2016 at Taieri College, in partnership with the Primary ITO, some students are combining school with industry training. They attend school for three days a week (or in a block if this suits the industry better) with their courses designed around their agricultural interest. For the remaining time, they work in an agricultural setting of their choice, including dairying, sheep/beef, horticulture or forestry. For them, this arrangement helps to bridge the gap between school and tertiary education. Employers and students see the value of on-job experience, leading to possible employment opportunities down the track. The principal credits the supportive community with making this offering a possibility. Technical details Students are entitled to a free secondary school place until 1 January of the year following their 19th birthday. Legally, once a student turns 16 they may attend school part-time if they wish. The Ministry acknowledges the legitimacy of part-time attendance for students aged 16 years old and over in the roll-return guidelines, which explain how to calculate part-time students into full-time equivalents. Principals have the right to determine the nature of their school’s curriculum and how it is offered, guided by the boards of trustees’ policies and national requirements set out in the National Education Guidelines and associated documents. 3+2 approaches use the following current system settings for funding and fees: o credit reporting and the costs associated are the responsibility of each setting. In most instances these costs are passed on to the student (see learner costs section p.8) o tertiary education providers receive Student Achievement Component (SAC) Level 3+ funding for part-time students 26/02/16 Version 2 5 o industry trainees are eligible for industry training funding (pro-rated Standard Training Measure funding for part-time trainees) o there is no specific funding to support the administration or pastoral care needs of students engaged in a 3+2 programme o while tertiary providers can charge fees for these programmes, they do not need to o learning from tertiary qualifications can count towards NCEA when these qualifications are assessed by unit standards. Some programmes that work toward a New Zealand qualification may not be assessed in this way, and therefore will currently not count towards NCEA. This will need to be checked with the tertiary provider o 3+2 approaches are possible under current Education Performance Indicators (EPIs) and performance-linked funding settings for the tertiary system, but there may be some concern that tertiary providers will be disadvantaged. Due to the relatively small numbers of learners currently involved, this is unlikely; the Ministry intends to work with the TEC to monitor impact. Supporting learners: tertiary education providers, ITOs and schools will continue to provide appropriate pastoral care to students. Existing obligations under the Vulnerable Children’s Act continue to apply, and some additional obligations are being progressively introduced . http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2014/0040/latest/DLM5501618.html While 3 days in school plus 2 days in tertiary or industry training (‘3+2’) is the model in this guide, other splits between school and secondary and tertiary/industry training, such as 2+3, or 2+2+1, are also possible approaches. Secondary schools and tertiary organisations are funded differently. The following paragraphs show how it might work in school or tertiary settings. How it might work in a school setting Table 2 shows an indicative time breakdown based on the hours in a school and possible number of subjects, or integrated courses, with approximate hours that could be offered with variations of a 3+2 approach. It is expected in 3+2 approaches that schools will work towards developing coherent learning programmes that are composed of either subjects or subjects integrated into a cross curricular course, and learning outside of school. 26/02/16 Version 2 6 Table 2: Variations of a 3+2 approach - indicative subjects based on hours Institution Funding Possible allocation of time by days 3 2 4 Comments 1 School FTE hrs/year (based on 34 weeks/year) 510 hrs 340 hrs 680 hrs 170 hrs School Estimated subject time available approx 3/4 subjects approx 2/3 subjects approx 5 subjects 12-16 8 -12 20 approx 1/2 subject s 4-8 Approx hrs per subject per wk Estimate 34 weeks/year Assumes 25 hrs contact time a week, or 5 hrs a day Total estimate 850 hrs/year When schools are developing variations on a 3+2 learning programme they need to consider aspects such as: how the learning will be split either across the week or in blocks of time; and the proportion of time spent in each setting learners’ needs, aspirations and vocational direction including progression opportunities to Level 4 and above qualifications deliberate “joint venture decisions” such as planning the design of the overall learning programme, and coordinating how learning in one setting is connected to learning in another using the flexibility of the school based part of the learning programme to support the learner’s pathway so it does not require them to do the entirety of each subject offered. The advantage of this approach is there is more time available for other types of learning contextualising learning by including industry-based learning make learning more relevant using a flexible assessment portfolio of achievement standards and unit standards, with options for achieving NCEA Level 3, industry qualifications, and University Entrance if required, and accessing other awards how the learner will be mentored and supervised, while working across multiple settings. How it might work in a tertiary setting Table 3 shows the number of hours and possible credits5 in a tertiary/industry setting using variations of a 3+2 approach. Tertiary providers offer a wide range of courses and qualifications that learners are able to start while still at school. 5 ‘Possible credits’ means the approximate number of credits offered within that time, where each credit represents 10 notional learning hours 26/02/16 Version 2 7 Table 3: Tertiary/Industry Setting using variations on a 3+2 approach Area Tertiary Hours Time and Credit Allocation 2 3 1 12 hrs 18 hrs 6 hrs Comments 4 24 hrs % of time 40 % 60 % 20 % 80 % Hrs/year 480 hrs 48 720 hrs 72 240 hrs 24 960 hrs 96 Possible Credits6 1 x EFTS/STM = 30 hrs/week Estimate 40 weeks/year Total estimated 1,200 hrs/year % of 30 hrs Based on notional 10 hrs/credit Other practical considerations 1. Learner costs 2. Student loans and allocations 3. In a school setting entry to NCEA costs $76.70 (incl. GST) per student per year. Financial assistance is available. STAR can be used to pay for learning based in a tertiary setting. NZQA can charge people and education institutions fees for specific purposes under section 254 of the Education Act 1989. More information about fees for school and tertiary providers is available at http://www.nzqa.govt.nz/assets/About-us/Our-role/NZQAFees.Table.pdf. Tertiary providers have discretion over whether or not to charge fees. Industry training may have some additional costs for the learner. To access a student loan, the learner must be studying 0.25 EFTS or more. A student studying 0.25 EFTS can only use a student loan to cover course fees, as a person needs to be studying full-time to borrow for living costs and course-related costs. If learners are under 18 years of age they need parental consent to borrow. Note that if a 3+2 learner accesses a student loan for course fees, the amount they access will count towards their lifetime consumption limit of up to seven EFTS – about seven to eight years of full time study. Working for Families Families of ‘3+2’ students will still be able to access Working for Families Tax Credits payments for each "dependent child", provided the child is: o 6 18 years or younger, and These numbers of credits are indicative only, as variations may occur to meet different learner needs. 26/02/16 Version 2 8 o financially dependent. This means children supported financially don't: 4. 5. o work more than 30 hours a week, or o receive a student allowance, a benefit or other government assistance. Employment and wages Wages must be paid to those in industry training, including those on 3+2 approaches. For workers and those in industry training aged 16+, the adult minimum wage or minimum starting out wage applies. The adult minimum wage applies to all employees aged 16 years and over who are not starting out workers or trainees (see below) and all employees who are involved in supervising or training other employees. The starting-out wage applies to starting-out workers who are: o 16 and 17-year-old employees who have not yet completed six months of continuous employment with their current employer o 18 and 19-year-old employees who have been paid a specified social security benefit to work with a single employer since they started being paid a benefit. Once they have completed six months continuous employment with a single employer they will no longer be a starting out worker and must be paid at least the adult minimum wage o 16 to 19-year-old employees required by their employment agreement to undertake industry training for at least 40 credits a year in order to become qualified. Youth Payment (16 and 17 not living at home) The Youth Payment is a weekly payment which helps young people aged 16 or 17 who can't live with their parents or guardian and aren't supported by them or anyone else. The requirements for this payment are outlined at http://www.workandincome.govt.nz/individuals/a-z-benefits/youth-payment.html The combination of school and tertiary or training in 3+2 approaches adequately satisfies the Ministry of Social Development’s (MSD) requirement of ‘full-time’ study for 16 and 17 year olds. Once students turn 18, they need to transfer to student allowance/loans. 6. Qualifications mapping tool By the end of March 2016, a qualifications mapping tool that maps Levels 3-7 qualifications aligned to Vocational Pathways and occupations, will be available on the Youth Guarantee website. This will enable users to: search for a job explore qualifications identify next steps with current qualifications explore Vocational Pathways identify appropriate exit points. 7. Profile Builder Profile Builder is a tool that allows a learner or educator to see how a programme aligns with the Vocational Pathways. It has been updated to include the Level 3 achievement standards. Users can: 26/02/16 Version 2 9 plan programmes by entering standards they want to do in the future, or see what they are currently undertaking see which Vocational Pathway(s) the credits fall into use the calculator to check achievement of NCEA Level 3 and University Entrance Award. Youth Guarantee website Lifting New Zealand’s achievement rates As we know, giving our students a great start as they enter adult life is important. A Level 2 qualification provides a necessary foundation for progress. Achieving a Level 4 or above qualification leads to improved life outcomes for any person and benefits the community at large. Qualifications at Level 4 and above also lift the skills of New Zealand’s workforce and improves economic performance and social development. Educators need to contribute to the Government’s key economic priority of boosting skills and employment. The revised Better Public Services Result Area 6 target (BPS 6) is for 60% of 25-34year-olds usually resident in New Zealand to hold qualifications at Level 4 or above by 2018. Further work is needed to support better links between Level 2 and Level 4 qualifications. We need to: improve engagement, retention, achievement and progression for all learners improve the range of choices for learners at NCEA Level 3 create effective pathways from school to tertiary study and employment strengthen partnerships and connections with schools, employers, tertiary education providers and ITOs position schools, tertiary education providers and ITOs as equal partners. 26/02/16 Version 2 10 Appendix 1: Student Scenarios Appendix 1 presents a number of scenarios showing the practical application of variations on a 3+2 approach. These scenarios provide examples of how partnership programmes could be shaped to accommodate a particular learner’s status, profile and goals towards a range of Level 3 achievements. These scenarios, while by no means exhaustive, provide insights to different ways of developing alternative approaches to help increase engagement, retention and progression of learners. Possible pathways are illustrated by the relevant pathway colours in the tables. In most of these scenarios Levels 3, 4 and 5 Certificates are shown as National Certificates. With the Targeted Review of Qualifications (TRoQ) currently taking place, National Certificates are in the process of being replaced by New Zealand Certificates. While achievement from National Certificates can be transferred to New Zealand Certificates it is recommended that providers clarify with learners, their families and whānau the certificates they currently offer and how learners’ achievement may be affected in the future by replacement certificates. Further information about TRoQ is available here Literacy and Numeracy requirements for University Entrance are available here Consent to assess information is available here 26/02/16 Version 2 11 Student A Learning Programme Scenario (Engineering focus) Goals Profile Status Motivated at school and keen Currently has NCEA Wants to keep tertiary on a career in a manufacturing Level 2 with a options open and visit a or technology industry Manufacturing and range of engineering Minimal work experience in Technology businesses to see what these industries Vocational Pathway they are like Medium level achievement in Award Post school - would like to maths and stats, technology progress to an and physics apprenticeship in engineering OR to fulltime In a good position to achieve NCEA Level 3 study in applied engineering Partnership Programme Achievement and Progression Secondary (‘3’) 57 NCEA Level 3 credits Achievement standards e.g. maths & stats, physics, construction and mechanical technologies Gateway placements to engineering businesses including some unit standards 26/02/16 Version 2 Tertiary (‘2’) 48 NZQF Level 4 unit standard credits From Level 4 New Zealand Certificate in Engineering Fabrication With a tertiary provider Qualifications Achieve: NCEA Level 3 Plus 48 out of 255-270 credits towards New Zealand Certificate in Engineering Fabrication (Level 4) also includes electives Possible Pathways In employment with industry training agreement to complete Level 4 New Zealand Certificate Engineering Fabrication OR In fulltime tertiary study to begin Level 5 New Zealand Certificate in Engineering (Advanced) 12 Student B Learning Programme Scenario (Primary Industries focus) Goals Profile Wants to keep applied tertiary options open and visit a range of industries to explore careers in processing primary products Post school would like to progress to industry training in a primary industry with related study OR pursue fulltime applied tertiary study in primary industries Partnership Programme Secondary (‘3’) 57 NCEA Level 3 credits Achievement standards e.g. maths & stats, biology, ag-hort, business studies STAR courses for visits to forestry, horticulture and seafood industries Status Currently has NCEA Level 2 with a Primary Industries Vocational Pathway, and was in a Primary Industries Trades Academy in Year 12 Motivated at school and keen on a career in a Primary Industries related industry Minimal work experience in these industries Moderate to high achievement across business studies, economics, technology, ag-hort and biology In a good position to achieve NCEA Level 3 with a UE award. Interested in technical and business applications in the processing side of the primary industries Understands there are forestry, horticulture and seafood opportunities in own region Achievement and Progression Tertiary (‘2’) 48 NZQF Levels 3/4 unit standard credits from Level 4 National Certificate Horticulture (includes electives) With a tertiary provider Qualifications Achieve: NCEA Level 3 UE award Plus 48 out of 140 credits towards Level 4 National Certificate Horticulture Possible Pathways 26/02/16 Version 2 In employment with industry training agreement to complete Level 4 National Certificate in Horticulture in area of specific interest OR In fulltime tertiary study to begin Level 5 National Certificate of Agribusiness OR Level 6 Diploma of Agribusiness OR Level 7 Bachelor of Management Studies (or equivalent degree in Agribusiness) 13 Student C Learning Programme Scenario (Health Care focus) Goals Status Currently has NCEA Level 2 with a Social and Community Services Vocational Pathway Had a positive Gateway placement at a retirement village in Year 12 Motivated at school and keen on a career in a Social and Community Services related industry Minimal work experience in these industries. Has moderate to high achievement across health/PE, social studies, digital technologies and business studies with high achievement in Te Reo Māori In a good position to achieve NCEA Level 3 with a UE award Has strong interest in Māori and Pasifika youth, and elder care Interested in the care and management side of the Social and Community Services industries Understands significant opportunities for Healthcare businesses in own region Partnership Programme Achievement and Progression Secondary (‘3’) Tertiary (‘2’) Qualifications Possible Pathways 48 NZQF Levels Fulltime tertiary Achieve: 57 NCEA Level 3 3/4 industry unit study towards credits NCEA Level 3 with standard credits Level 5 National Achievement certificate from Level 4 Certificate in standards e.g. endorsement Certificate in Health, Disability health, business UE award Health, Disability and Aged Support studies, social Plus and Aged Support 48 out of 70 (team studies and digital (includes management) technologies credits towards electives) OR STAR courses for Level 4 National With a tertiary Level 6 NZ industry visits to Certificate in provider Diploma in Māori Health care Health, Disability Public Health related businesses and Aged Support OR Level 7 Bachelor of Health Science (or equivalent) Wants to keep applied tertiary options open and visit a range of care businesses and jobs in this sector Interested in career in residential home care or early childhood. Interested in Te Ao Māori care dimensions and the management side of Health Care businesses Post school - would like to progress to industry training in a Health Care industry with related study OR Pursue fulltime tertiary study in a related career such as occupational therapy Profile 26/02/16 Version 2 14 Student D Learning Programme Scenario (Tourism/Hospitality focus) Goals Profile Wants to visit a range of hospitality and tourism businesses to see what they are like Post school - keen to start fulltime applied tertiary study in hospitality/ tourism Partnership Programme Secondary (‘3’) 57 NCEA Level 3 credits Achievement standards e.g. maths & stats, digital technologies, accounting, business studies STAR courses for tourism and hospitality industry visits with possible unit standards option 26/02/16 Version 2 Motivated at school and keen on a career in a Services related industry Has limited work experience in services industries Medium to high achievement in maths and stats, digital technologies, accounting and business studies, including some Merit passes Motivated to achieve NCEA Level 3 with a certificate endorsement. Interested to study business management with an applied focus in the tourism sector in a tertiary setting Achievement and Progression Tertiary (‘2’) Status Currently has NCEA Level 2 with a Services Vocational Pathway Did a food technology course in Year 12 48 NZQF Level 3/4/5 credits from Diploma in Hospitality (Management) At a Polytechnic Qualifications Achieve NCEA Level 3 with certificate endorsement Plus 40 Levels 4- 5 credits out of 240 credits towards Level 5 Diploma in Hospitality (Management, including electives) Possible Pathways Complete Level 5 National Diploma in Hospitality (Management) 15 Student E Learning Programme Scenario (Construction focus) Goals Wants to start working this year and earn some money Interested to explore training in an area of construction Wants to visit a range of jobs across construction industries to see what they are like Understands working towards a Level 4 NZ Certificate in Carpentry is desirable if wanting a career in the construction industry Understands improved achievement in maths and stats and in physics subjects will help achieve Level 4 trade qualification Partnership Programme Secondary (‘3’) 57 NCEA Level 3 credits Achievement standards and/or unit standards e.g. maths & stats, physics, PE, technology Gateway work placement in construction STAR courses for industry visits to construction businesses Unit standards options 26/02/16 Version 2 Profile Moderate motivation in school subjects but wants to stay at school for another year to be connected with friends, sporting and cultural activities Tertiary (‘2’) 48 Level 3/4 NZQF credits National Certificate in Construction (Carpentry) through Part-time employment with industry training agreement Status Has NCEA Level 2 with a Vocational Pathways Award in Construction and Infrastructure and high achievement in Construction and Mechanical Technology Enjoyed being in a Trades Academy with a construction focus in Year 12 and has medium achievement in maths and stats, and did not pass physics Achievement and Progression Qualifications Achieve NCEA Level 3 plus 48 out of 294 credits towards Level 4 National Certificate Construction Possible Pathways Level 4 National Certificate Construction (Carpentry) In employment with industry training agreement 16 Student F Learning Programme Scenario (Hospitality focus) Goals Profile Status Moderate Currently has 50 NCEA Wants to work towards a Level 3 motivation at Level 2 credits aligned to NZC in Hospitality as wants to get school a Services Vocational a job in hospitality Keen to get NCEA Pathway Wants to complete NCEA Level 2 Level 2 with a Has not yet met the with a Vocational Pathway Award Vocational requirements for gaining in Services Industries and gain Pathways Award NCEA Level 2, including Literacy/Numeracy requirements Interested to begin Literacy and Numeracy Choosing several subjects to keep training in open option to gain NCEA Level 3 hospitality Option 1 Part time at school (3 days) in part time training on the job (2 days) and focused on keeping tertiary options open Partnership Programme Secondary (‘3’) Tertiary (‘2’) Achievement and Progression Qualifications Possible Pathways 48 NZQF Levels In employment Achieve 57 NCEA Level 3 3/4 credits from with industry credits NCEA Level 3 Level 4 Nat Cert training to Achievement Level 2 Vocational Hospitality (basic complete Level 3 and/or unit Pathways Award in cookery) National standards e.g. Services Industries through Certificate English, food tech, plus Part-time Hospitality (basic maths & stats, 48 out of 96 credits employment with cookery) health/ PE towards Level 4 industry training OR 20 credits Lit/Num National Certificate agreement fulltime tertiary unit standards Hospitality (basic study Complete NCEA cookery) Level 4 National Level 2 with VP Certificate in Award Hospitality (basic cookery) OR Level 5 NZ Diploma Cookery Option 2 Part time at school (3 days which includes a one day Gateway placement) and in part time training on the job (2 days) and focused on progressing to further industry training with a trade qualification. Partnership Programme Achievement and Progression Secondary (‘3’) 26/02/16 Version 2 Tertiary (‘2’) Qualifications Possible Pathways 17 17 NZQF Level 3 credits from National Certificate in Hospitality via Gateway work placement in hospitality plus 40 Level 2 credits achievement and/or unit standards e.g. English, food technology, health/ PE Vocational Pathway Award Literacy/Numeracy focus 26/02/16 Version 2 48 NZQF Levels 2/3 credits from Level 3 Nat Cert Hospitality (basic cookery) through Part-time employment with industry training agreement. Achieve NCEA Level 3 Plus 48 out of 73 credits towards Level 3 National Certificate in Hospitality (basic cookery) Literacy/Numeracy Level 1 Level 2 Vocational Pathways Award in Services Industries In employment with industry training agreement Complete Level 3 National Certificate in Hospitality (basic cookery - 73 credits) Or Transfer credits towards completion of Level 4 National Certificate in Hospitality (cookery – 96 credits) 18 Student G Learning Programme Scenario (Plumbing related focus) Goals Profile Is interested to explore a possible career in plumbing, drainage and gas fitting. Wants to visit a range of businesses and jobs in construction and infrastructure industries Is interested in understanding how to operate a business Post school - would like to progress to industry training in a construction and infrastructure industry with related tertiary study, OR study fulltime towards an applied construction related qualification Moderate to high achievement in maths & stats, physics, and construction and mechanical technologies, including some Merit passes. Moderate motivation to study, doing well in applied learning contexts Has limited work experience in construction and infrastructure industries In a good position to achieve NCEA Level 3 Understands there are significant opportunities in a range of construction businesses in own region Status Currently has NCEA Level 2 with a construction and Infrastructure Vocational Pathways Award, Had a positive Gateway placement at a plumbing business in Yr 12. Partnership Programme Achievement and Progression Secondary (‘3’) Qualifications 57 NCEA Level 3 credits Achievement standards e.g. maths & stats, physics, construction and mechanical technologies, and possibly accounting STAR courses for industry visits to construction and infrastructure businesses. Unit standards 26/02/16 Version 2 Tertiary (‘2’) 48 NZQF Level 3/4 credits from Level 4 National Certificate in Plumbing At a polytechnic or other tertiary provider Achieve NCEA L3 plus 48 out of 219 credits towards Level 4 National Certificate in Plumbing Possible Pathways In employment with an industry training agreement In part-time tertiary study to complete Level 4 National Certificate Plumbing (with options in gasfitting and/or drainage) OR In fulltime tertiary study – to continue with Level 4 National Certificate in Plumbing 19 Student H Learning Programme Scenario (Electronics related focus) Goals Profile Is interested to explore careers as an electronics technician or in electronics related businesses Wants to visit a range of electronics roles across manufacturing and technology industries Is interested to visit the Defence Forces to explore electronics roles Post school - would like to progress to industry training in an electronics related industry with related tertiary study, OR study fulltime towards an applied electronics related qualification Well motivated to study, doing very well in applied learning contexts High achievement in maths & stats, physics, digital technologies and construction and mechanical technologies, including some Merit and Excellence passes. Has limited work experience in manufacturing and technology industries In a good position to achieve University Entrance Understands there are many opportunities in electronics related technical services or manufacturing businesses Partnership Programme Achievement and Progression Secondary (‘3’) 57 NCEA Level 3 credits Achievement standards e.g. maths & stats, physics, digital technologies, and construction and mechanical technologies STAR courses for industry visits to electronics related manufacturing and technology businesses Unit standards 26/02/16 Version 2 Status Currently has NCEA Level 2 with a Manufacturing and Technology Vocational Pathways Award, Had a positive Gateway placement at an electronics manufacturing business in Yr 12 Tertiary (‘2’) 48 NZQF credits from Level 6 NZ Diploma in Engineering (focus on strands in Electronics and Electrical) At a Polytechnic or other tertiary provider Qualifications Achieve NCEA Level 3 UE award plus 48 out of 120 credits towards Level 6 NZ Diploma in Engineering Practice (focus on strands in Electronics and Electrical) Possible Pathways In employment with industry training agreement, with part-time study towards Level 6 NZ Diploma in Engineering Practice OR fulltime tertiary study Level 6 NZ Diploma in Engineering Practice OR Level 7 B.Eng. Tech (Engineering) 20 Appendix 2: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) Below are a number of questions that may arise when people consider using variations of a 3+2 approach. These questions may be added to as the approach is applied and further developed. General Questions and Answers What are 3+2 approaches? 3+2 approaches show ways in which the Level 3 Vocational Pathways could be implemented using a multiple partnership approach. They are for school students who want to achieve NCEA Level 3 while working towards a tertiary or industry qualification (at Level 3 or above). 3+2 enables students to participate part-time in tertiary education or industry training, while also being enrolled part-time at school. Doing 3+2 will help students to make a smoother transition to further study or industry training and employment. The ‘3’ and ‘2’ in ‘3+2’ refer to the amount of time students spend at school or in another setting – in this case three days at school and two days elsewhere. These times aren’t fixed; the split and organisation of time can be structured in whatever way suits the learning needs of the student. For more information about how time could be split (the variations to 3+2), refer to pages 5 and 6 in this guide. Who is 3+2 for? 3+2 is designed to support the kind of 16-19 year old student who: returns to school with NCEA Level 2 to do a year of study and is at risk of not achieving a NCEA Level 3 returns to school with NCEA Level 2, but is likely to leave during the year without achieving NCEA Level 3 leaves school with NCEA 2, but who might return to school and achieve NCEA Level 3 if the curriculum offering were more relevant to them. How do the 3+2 approaches work? 3+2 approaches provide students with more flexibility to pursue areas of learning that interest them, in two different settings. The split between the two education settings for a student through a 3+2 approach will typically be about 15 hours in school and 12 hours (for 48 credits) in tertiary study or industry training a week. Some schools already offer their students something similar to the 3+2 approach, as it is possible to do this within existing school and tertiary funding settings. If the 3+2 timing doesn’t work, then timings can be changed to suit. What are some examples of 3+2 approaches? Some schools already offer their students a programme that reflects the 3+2 approach. 26/02/16 Version 2 21 In 2016, partnerships have been developed between two Hamilton schools and a polytechnic to offer school and tertiary learning for a group of approximately 30 students. The three days at school comprises mathematics and physics plus the student’s choice of one other subject connected to the contexts provided in the tertiary setting. The remaining two days are being spent at the polytechnic studying either building and construction or mechanical engineering. The Level 3 assessment standards contribute to NCEA Level 3 and offer pathway opportunities to studying the NZ Diploma in Engineering. In 2016 at Taieri College, in partnership with the Primary ITO, some students are combining school with industry training. They attend school for three days per week (or in a block if this suits the industry better) with their school courses designed around their agricultural interest. For the remaining time they work in an agricultural setting of their choice, including dairying, sheep/beef, horticulture or forestry. This arrangement helps to bridge the gap between school and tertiary education. Employers and students see the value of on-job experience leading to possible employment opportunities down the track. The school principal credits the supportive community with making this offering a possibility. What are the benefits of 3+2 approaches? 3+2 approaches show ways to broaden the choices available and improve the chances of learners achieving NCEA Level 3. The approaches enable greater provision of engaging, relevant programmes that support more successful progression to further study, training and work. For detailed benefits for young people, schools, tertiary, industry training provider and employers refer to pages 2-4 in this guide. Questions and Answers for students How do I get involved in 3+2 approaches? If you are interested in a 3+2 programme, you can ask to be part-time enrolled so that you can take a suitable 3+2 programme. Schools may or may not already have 3+2 options or something similar available. The school will need to consider whether it can offer the learning in this, or a similar, arrangement. Will I be able to achieve University Entrance (UE) through 3+2? Yes. With careful planning a University Entrance award is achievable through variations of a 3+2 approach, but you will have to meet the current University Entrance requirements. More information about these can be found at the New Zealand Qualifications Authority website. Can I achieve a tertiary or industry qualification through 3+2 approaches? The qualifications that support your chosen pathway through 3+2 can be a combination of achievement standards that lead to NCEA Level 3 and National/New Zealand Certificates or Diplomas. 26/02/16 Version 2 22 Whether you can gain the tertiary qualification in the one year of study depends on the number of credits you take in your tertiary study. As tertiary study through 3+2 is part time, you may not complete a tertiary qualification at Level 3 or above in one year. However, you can complete the tertiary qualification in the years following leaving school, if you choose to. If I have achieved a standard in one setting, can I get the credits for doing it again in another setting within my 3+2 programme? No, you can only achieve the credits for any standard once. Your learning programme needs to be carefully managed between providers to make sure you are not achieving standards in one setting (eg. at school) and being expected to do them again in another setting (eg. with a tertiary provider or in industry training). The Government will not pay for them to be done again. Ask your providers for advice about this. Can I get a Student loan to pay for tertiary course fees? If a tertiary provider charges course fees (which they are entitled to do), you may be able to access a student loan for these costs. You must be studying 0.25 'Equivalent Full-Time Student' (EFTS) or more at a tertiary provider to get a student loan for course fees. You cannot get a student loan for living costs and course-related study costs if you are not studying full-time in a tertiary provider. If you are under 18, you will need parental consent to borrow. All eligible New Zealanders can get a student loan for study with a value of up to seven EFTS about seven or eight years of full-time study. This is the lifetime limit for accessing a student loan. If you access a student loan for course costs through 3+2, this will count towards your lifetime limit. You should talk to your parents, whānau and school to help you to make careful choices about the type and cost of tertiary study undertaken through 3+2. Could the credits I have gained doing a 3+2 programme contribute towards another qualification? Sometimes you may find the credits from the standards you have achieved can also count towards another qualification, and you should not have to do them again. Ask your provider about this. If I complete part of a qualification with one tertiary provider can I finish it with another tertiary provider? You will need to check with your provider whether you can do this. 26/02/16 Version 2 23 Where can I get support or help with my study? You can talk to your teachers, deans, guidance counsellors and careers advisers at school. For further information on student loans or allowances, go to the Studylink website. Tertiary education providers generally offer a range of student support services for students needing help or experiencing difficulties. There are several services available from different providers. Will doing tertiary study or industry training help me achieve NCEA Level 3? If you are doing a qualification at Level 3 or higher assessed by unit standards, the credits can be counted towards NCEA Level 3. Note that some qualifications are not assessed by standards and therefore will not contribute to NCEA. If you are not sure, check with your provider. There are many students who leave school without fully completing NCEA Levels 1, 2 or 3, who earn additional credits while undertaking study outside of school. These can also count towards NCEA qualifications. If you think that you might be eligible for something like this you should contact NZQA to confirm whether credits earned in other study can count towards NCEA qualifications. Where can I get help with choosing what to study through 3+2? You can talk about a 3+2 programme with your parents and whānau, teachers, careers advisers or deans at school. The Youth Guarantee website has several tools that can assist you. Students Key Info can help you to plan school and tertiary study and career options. It shows you how you can make progress towards where you want to get to through 3+2 approaches. The Profile Builder is a tool that helps you to explore your study options. By putting in the achievement or unit standards you are currently doing, or those you might like to do, you can see where you are heading and think about where you would like to go. The Profile Builder also includes a Literacy and Numeracy calculator to help you track how you are progressing towards meeting your Literacy and Numeracy requirements for NCEA. The Sussed interactive tool on the Studylink website helps you to understand all of the costs involved with tertiary study. This is helpful if you want to do further study after you leave school. NZQA has developed a mobile App called NCEA Student to help you plan your NCEA study programme, set goals and track your progress. The App is available free from iTunes and the Google Play Store . NCEA Pal is a tool designed by students for students to help you navigate through NCEA and education. NCEA Pal has a timetable tool, diary tool and helps you to keep track of your progress with the Vocational Pathways. It also allows you to connect with your school and import dates and 26/02/16 Version 2 24 notices to the app. NCEA Pal is free to download from the Apple App Store and the Google Play Store The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment’s (MBIE) Occupation Outlook 2015 tool is designed to help you make well-informed career choices. The occupations in the tool are grouped under the six industries used in the Vocational Pathways. The Occupational Outlook App is free to download from the Apple App Store and the Google Play Store The Careers New Zealand website also has a range of interactive tools to help you to decide what to study. These tools include: Compare Study Options – provides information on earning and employment outcomes from different study options Subject Matcher – gives job information based on the subjects students are most interested in Skill Matcher – generates job ideas based on a student’s skills and interests, and gives them guidance on what to do next Regional Job Matcher – matches skills to jobs in a region You can also call Careers NZ toll free on 0800 222 733 for help. How do I travel to work or get to the tertiary organisation? Part of becoming more independent is to figure out how you get yourself to a place of work or tertiary organisation. Sometimes tertiary organisations can help, so ask the relevant provider. Questions and Answers for education providers and Industry Training Organisations How do schools, tertiary providers and ITOs get involved in 3+2 approaches? There is nothing to stop you looking into it now! For 2016, the Ministry of Education is encouraging schools to explore partnerships with tertiary organisations and industry to provide broader opportunities for young people. If you have any questions about 3+2 approaches or want to become involved, feel free to contact a regional Youth Guarantee Secondary-Tertiary Lead. Contact details are available on the Youth Guarantee website. Is there any additional funding for schools, tertiary providers or ITOs for 3+2? 3+2 approaches use current settings and funding arrangements to support students to participate both in school and either tertiary education or industry training. 26/02/16 Version 2 25 Schools receive funding for part-time students aged 16 and over. The roll-return guidelines on the Ministry of Education website explain how schools can calculate part time students as fulltime equivalents The Tertiary Education Commission (TEC) is responsible for funding the Government's contribution to tertiary education and training. Tertiary education providers receive Student Achievement Component (SAC) Level 3+ funding for any part-time students they enrol. 3+2 learners who are industry trainees are eligible for Standard Training Measure (STM) funding, which is managed by ITOs. ITOs can also apply for limited Joint Ventures and Amalgamation Projects (JVAP) funding to support collaboration7. There is no specific additional funding to support the administration or pastoral care needs of students engaged in a 3+2 programme. Can schools use Secondary-Tertiary Alignment Resource (STAR) or Gateway funding for 3+2 approaches? Both STAR and Gateway funding can be used to help students experience relevant, coherent learning aligned to Vocational Pathways beyond the school. Schools need to be aware of the particular requirements of each of these programmes. The Ministry recommends that the learning from the experiences provided by STAR and Gateway is well connected with the learning in school. Go to the Youth Guarantee website to find out more about STAR and Gateway. The Tertiary Education Commission also provides information on the use of Gateway funding by secondary schools. How could practical delivery be organised? The ‘3’ and ‘2’ in ‘3+2’ refers to the amount of time students spend at school or in another setting – in this case three days at school (0.6 Full time Equivalent (FTE)); two days elsewhere (0.4 FTE). These times aren’t fixed; the split and organisation of time can be structured in whatever way suits the learning needs of the student. For more information about how time could be split refer to pages 5 and 6 in this guide. The school and tertiary institution/ITO will need to agree on how this delivery time is offered. It may not be in a conventional working week; for example, the industry training component could occur during the holidays, or in specific blocks of time. The various partners in the partnership develop the content of their parts of the programme to fit the learning needs of the young person. Partners should liaise with one another to form one coherent programme. 7 JVAP funding is part of the Industry Training Fund managed by the Tertiary Education Commission. One purpose of the funding is to assist industry training organisations (ITOs) to undertake joint ventures. 26/02/16 Version 2 26 Who is responsible for the welfare of a young person? When at school or in a tertiary/industry setting a learner is under the pastoral responsibility and practices of the school or the tertiary/industry provider. It is very helpful for the learner if arrangements are made between partners to report and discuss achievement and progress on a regular basis with the learner and their family/whānau. How could credit reporting be managed? While each partner (school, tertiary institution or ITO) is responsible for reporting credits earned in their setting to NZQA, it can be beneficial to streamline credit reporting through one provider, by agreement. This will minimise unnecessary additional costs to the learner and supports timely reporting of credits. Questions and Answers for parents, family and whānau What are the costs associated with 3+2 approaches? NCEA costs Entry to NCEA for all eligible New Zealanders costs $76.70 (inc GST) per student per year. Check with your provider whether you are required to pay this and how you can do so. For more information about NCEA, fees, and financial assistance, see http://www.nzqa.govt.nz/qualifications-standards/qualifications/ncea/understanding-ncea/howncea-works. An NCEA Guide App is also free to download from the Apple App Store and the Google Play Store Tertiary costs You may be required to pay fees to the tertiary provider for their part of the programme. To cover tertiary course fees, your child may be able to access a student loan. They must be studying 0.25 Equivalent Fulltime Student (EFTS) or more, which is just over one day per week. As they are in part-time tertiary study through 3+2, they will only be able to apply for course fees. Students must be in full-time tertiary study to access a student loan for living costs and courserelated costs. If your child is under 18, they will need parental consent to borrow through the Student Loan scheme. Is my child eligible for Youth Guarantee Fees Free funding through 3+2? Students involved in 3+2 are not eligible for Fees Free support because they are part-time in tertiary, and Fees-Free funding requires full-time tertiary enrolment. The primary focus of the Fees-Free scheme is to provide fulltime students who are 16-19 years with an opportunity to study towards NCEA Level 2 aligned with one or more Vocational Pathways at tertiary education providers free of charge. 26/02/16 Version 2 27 Will the family of a 3+2 student still receive Working for Families Tax Credits for their Child? Families of 3+2 students will still be able to access Working for Families Tax Credits payments for each "dependent child", provided the student is: 18 years or younger, and financially dependent. This supports students financially who do not: work more than 30 hours a week, or receive a student allowance, a benefit or other government assistance. 26/02/16 Version 2 28