Reducing Risks, Saving Lives Save the Children’s approach to Disaster Risk Reduction and Climate Change Adaptation savethechildren.net Children and disasters Above, left and right A cyclone drill by community members and the Cyclone Preparedness Program (CPP), Hassan Nagar Union, Bhola District, Bangladesh Jeff Holt / Save the Children Middle panel, left Operation Reach Summer Day Camp program at the Lower Coast Algiers Community Center, Louisiana. The goal of the workshops is to ease anxiety related to the upcoming hurricane season by providing children with information and resources Susan Warner / Save the Children Middle panel, right Kids at the Crosstown Learning Center, Oklahoma test new whistles included in backpacks provided to them by Save the Children as part of their disaster preparedness program. The backpacks contained supplies for disaster preparedness like flashlights, hygiene items, teddy bears and whistles Michael Wyke / Tulsa World Third panel, left A young child eats some Plumpynut, a high-nutrition food for severely malnourished children, in southern Ethiopia. Global shortages of food and higher prices are drastically reducing children’s access to health care, nutrition and education which they need to thrive Colin Crowley / Save the Children Third panel, right Children perform dances Vietnam as part of a flood recovery and disaster risk reduction programme in a preschool supported by Save the Children in Northern Vietnam AB Kyazze Disasters have the biggest impact on the poorest communities and the most vulnerable people. And it is children who bear the brunt: they may not know when to flee or where to go; they are exposed to even greater danger if separated from their parents and families; they may not understand what is happening and become psychologically distressed. Longer term affects can also be felt by children, when families become food insecure and financially insecure it can lead to children dropping out of school or becoming vulnerable to malnutrition. In most disasters, more than half of those who are affected or die are children. A growing threat Over the past two decades, the number of natural disasters has doubled. Not only are there more floods, cyclones, droughts and severe cold spells but experts also predict the severity of these events will increase as a result of climate change and environmental degradation. Glaciers and ice caps are melting, rainfall patterns are changing and drought conditions are affecting more and more of the world’s land mass. The impact of non-climate-related disasters, such as earthquakes, is also increasing, due to urbanisation and population growth. Children’s lives and well-being are also threatened by epidemiological disasters, such as the avian influenza pandemic, and technological disasters, such as the Bhopal industrial catastrophe in India and the recent Fukushima nuclear accident in Japan. Children need not face such dire predicaments. Many of the disasters that affect children around the world are cyclical and to some degree predictable: droughts in the Sahel and the Horn of Africa, flooding in India and the deltas of Bangladesh, and hurricane season in Central America and South East Asia. Whilst natural disaster cannot be prevented, communities can be prepared and made more resilient to these events, and their impacts can be mitigated and moderated through appropriately designed interventions. What is Disaster Risk Reduction? Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) is any activity carried out by a village, community, aid agency or government that helps to prepare, mitigate, adapt and increase resilience toward the impact of disasters. These activities can be legislation, policies, strategies and practices that are developed and applied to minimise vulnerabilities and disaster risks. DRR makes economic sense. The United Nations estimates that for every US$1 invested in preparing for a disaster, US$7 of losses can be prevented. DRR should become part of everyday development work, and an underlying principle by which all development programs are judged to be climate and disaster resilient, thereby safeguarding the development investment. Unless we invest in it now, decades of progress in poor and disaster-prone communities could be lost. In January 2005, 168 of the world’s governments agreed to adopt the Hyogo Framework for Action, a global blueprint for disaster risk reduction efforts during the next decade. Its goal is to substantially reduce disaster losses by 2015 – loss of lives and the loss of social, economic, and environmental assets of communities and countries. What is Climate Change Adaptation? DRR saves lives In 2007, Cyclone Sidr in Bangladesh killed around 3,500 people. But a year later, a similarly powerful Cyclone Nargis in Myanmar (Burma), claimed more than 146,000 lives. Given the similarity in geography and population density in the two countries, why was there such a huge difference in the death tolls from the two disasters? In Bangladesh, around 1.5 million people on the coast were able to flee to shelters before the storm hit. The government’s early warning system included broadcasting messages on the radio, mobilising volunteers and making announcements with megaphones. The government had learned from terrible experiences. Cyclone Gorky hit the coast of Bangladesh in 1991, claiming more than 138,000 lives. Before that, in 1970, Cyclone Bhola killed more than half a million people. There is no scientific ambiguity to the fact that the world’s climate is warming and that this warming over the past 50 years is attributable in part to man’s activities1. There is a wide consensus that this warming will lead to changing rainfall patterns, rising sea levels, increased spread of tropical disease, loss of biodiversity and increased frequency and amplitude of weather related natural disasters. It is recognized that there are both areas of convergence and divergences between CCA and DRR. CCA programs, accepting the inevitability of a changing climate, are activities which aim to make adjustments in natural and human systems in response to actual or expected climate stimuli and their effects2. Adaptation can be as much about exploiting beneficial opportunities as well as guarding against harm. For Save the Children, adaptation is principally about practical measures in programming, policy and advocacy which reduce vulnerabilities or increase resilience of children and their communities from the negative effects of climate change. DRR and CCA are not mutually exclusive but in fact interdependent; a CCA project may be just as vulnerable to natural hazards as any other project and therefore needs a DRR component to protect the CCA investment. To address the risks and uncertainty predicted by climate change, both DRR and CCA analysis and programming must attempt to factor in the unpredictability of what may happen in the future as the planet continues to warm. Save the Children’s approach to DRR and CCA Children are particularly at risk in a disaster and vulnerable to the incremental impacts of climate change. It is essential that their immediate and longer-term survival, protection and developmental needs are considered in any activities to prepare for or mitigate a potential disaster, or adapt to the negative impacts of longer-term climatic trends. Communities and local authorities need to listen to children to find out what risks they might face and how they might respond to them. Save the Children has pioneered child-centred DRR. Child-centred DRR means putting children at the heart of DRR activities – recognising the specific vulnerabilities children face from disasters, which differ to those faced by adults, and ensuring children are appropriately planned for and addressed in DRR programs and policies. It’s also important to recognise that children are not one homogenous group and the challenges they face from disasters differ if they are a child under the age of five, a girl from a marginalised community or a child living with a disability. Our programs seek to ensure that the needs and capacities of all children are considered in how people prepare for, react to, and recover from disasters and adapt to long term trends. We work to make this happen at all levels – with children, communities, local and national governments and regional and international organisations. What do DRR and CCA entail? Most DRR and CCA work falls into five main categories: Preparedness activities enhance people’s ability to deal with a disaster. These include ensuring that communities and local government have emergency plans 1 IPCC, 2007: Summary for Policymakers. In: Climate Change 2007: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, M.L. Parry, O.F. Canziani, J.P. Palutikof, P.J. van der Linden and C.E. Hanson, Eds., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 7-22. 2 Based on the IPCC definition of adaptation in: IPCC TAR, 2001 a. Climate Change 2001: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. IPCC Third Assessment Report, Cambridge University Press. The children’s own role in DRR In Cuba, as a result of Save the Children’s DRR programme, children conveyed early warning messages before hurricanes to help spread the word of impending storms. In Brazil, Save the Children has taught children to measure rainfall to give early warning of floods or landslides. In disaster-prone areas of Sri Lanka, Thailand, the Philippines and elsewhere, children have assessed the risks they face, helped draw up emergency preparedness plans and maps, took part in drills and evacuation simulation activities, and raised awareness of the risks among their peers and adults in their community. As well working in their communities, children in Thailand and Sri Lanka have also advocated for their national governments to cater for children’s needs in their emergency preparedness plans. in place that map the hazards in a community and develop strategies to combat them, make sure people know where to evacuate to, and pre-position emergency supplies, such as food and shelter materials in disaster-prone areas. For example, in Afghanistan, Save the Children works with communities so that they understand the risks of flooding, especially for children, and how they can prepare themselves ahead of time. In Vietnam, we help children take part in community meetings to assess risks and hazards; children produce risk maps and action plans for schools. Leveraging our skills and experience in the education sector, much of Save the Children’s preparedness work is conducted through school-based DRR programs that then extend into surrounding communities. Early warning activities give people time to respond to a disaster. An early response, particularly to slow-onset disasters such as droughts, is not only cheaper but more effective. By responding early, families are able to protect their livelihoods and are therefore in a stronger position to recover. In Ethiopia, Save the Children has worked with the government since the1980s to both analyse vulnerability and run early warning systems for food crises. And in Sri Lanka, we worked with districtlevel disaster management committees and provided megaphones and loudspeakers to be used as part of early warning systems. Save the Children continues to develop and implement better vulnerability analysis and early warning systems. We are currently working with Action Contre la Faim to strengthen integrated food security and nutrition surveillance systems that support better early warning for food price increases. Mitigation activities reduce the risks from disasters. Vietnamese children who participate in our DRR program have identified areas where flooding was a risk to them and their communities. They have also come up with ways of reducing the risk, such as building embankments and strengthening bridges. In Myanmar (Burma), Save the Children is helping to reinforce schools, ensuring children and adults will have a safe place to seek shelter in the event of another cyclone. And in India Save the Children has constructed child-friendly disaster shelters in flood and earthquake prone districts and in a coastal areas the local community was hired to build a 5 km sea wall to mitigate the risk of flooding and speed up the natural desalination of agricultural land. Activities to promote resilience enhance communities’ capacity to cope and recover after a disaster strikes. Save the Children has pioneered the Household Economy Approach (HEA), which can predict food crises by understanding the impacts of droughts on the ability of different groups of people to access food for their families. As part of our work in social protection, we annually transfer food or cash to reduce the risk of food crisis among poor families. We are also piloting innovative approaches to insurance to protect vital assets of the poorest people. In Zimbabwe, due to the increased of droughts, we encouraged farmers to use drought-resistant crops. Activities that support communities’ adaptive capacity to predicted climate change trends. Save the Children is working with communities to enhance their resilience and support adaptation to the impacts of climate change. In Mozambique, our cash grants and training is supporting diversification away from natural resources-based livelihoods. We are also conducting operational research on how to improve water management to mitigate the Left Students at Ban Talaynork School in Ranong province, Thailand, crosscheck a “risk and resource” community map they developed showing areas that are at risk and those that are safe Save the Children Right Fatema, a water and sanitation field facilitator, instructs Limon and Nayeem, both age eight, on proper hand washing techniques at a school-based awareness session in Bangladesh Jeff Holt / Save the Children effects of climate change. In Guatemala, Save the Children works in watershed protection involving activities such as nursery establishment and management, the formation of community committees to monitor watersheds, and tree planting. We are working with the Tropical Forest Group to explore opportunities for climate finance in the rangelands of Ethiopia. Save the Children is also a member of the Africa Climate Change Resilience Alliance (ACCRA) with Oxfam, CARE, World Vision and the Overseas Development Institute (ODI) which seeks to understand how existing social protection, livelihoods and DRR interventions build adaptive capacity. In addition, we are a member of a number of global and regional consortia which collectively try to increase the evidence base of the impact of Climate Change on children and communities. Information gathered is used to influence governmental policies and national development practice. Save the Children reduces risk through five areas of focus: Advocacy and Policy – ensuring that government plans take into account the needs of children in disasters. For example, in Vietnam, to ensure that the needs of children are considered Save the Children has successfully advocated for and supported the participation of the Head of the Children’s Division from the Department of Social Welfare in the National Disaster Committee. In Asia Save the Children is part of a ASEAN Partnership Group (APG) which is a consortium of international NGOs that supports the implantation of the ASEAN Agreement on Disaster Management and Emergency Response (AADMER) which is a regional action plan for the implementation of the Hyogo Framework for Action. We are also working closely with the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) to develop a children and disasters framework. Institution Strengthening – ensuring that relevant institutions are able to implement effective policy around children and disasters and CCA. For example, in Indonesia, Save the Children has piloted primary school curriculum around DRR and worked with the Ministry of National Education to develop a national curriculum and teacher trainer guides. Similar work is being carried out in Laos, Timor Leste and the Philippines. Local Government & Partners Capacity Building – ensuring that these crucial agencies have the skills necessary to protect children during their preparation for disasters and their response. For example, in Colombia, we trained community leaders and local authorities on child protection in emergencies to ensure that children’s needs and rights are considered in preparing for and responding to disaster. Community – empowering communities and families to mitigate identified risks of disasters. For example, Save the Children works with community based DRR committees to conduct hazard, vulnerability mapping exercises and develop DRR preparedness plans and strategies to reduce disaster risk. We also ensure children are represented in these groups so their voices are heard. In Tajikistan, communities are given small grants to plan out mitigation activities which decrease the vulnerability children face during a disaster. Left A young girl plays at school in Northern Vietnam. Save the Children is focusing on DRR work in Vietnam following severe floods in October 2007, which destroyed harvests and forced many people to leave their homes. AB Kyazze Right A young boy works on a map of his village in the Irrawaddy Delta, Myanmar (Burma). Save the Children is helping children identify the dangerous areas and safer places if there is another cyclone. Two thirds of the children in the village were killed when Cyclone Nargis swept across the delta in May 2008 Tina Salsbury / Save the Children Front cover Tin Lin Htun (right), eight, works on a map of his village in the Irrawaddy Delta, Myanmar (Burma). Tin Lin Htun survived Cyclone Nargis by clinging onto a log. His parents also survived but he lost three siblings. Children’s Role in Disasters – allowing for the meaningful participation of children to increase their resilience. For example, in the United States of America, our school-based program focuses on children creating family plans and builds on children’s natural potential for resilience. In Myanmar (Burma), children take part in developing community maps and illustrating the safest place in the village in the event of another cyclone. In Mozambique, Save the Children has developed and distributed the ‘River Board Game’, an informative and stimulating way to teach children about the risk of disasters and how to protect themselves. We also ensure we reach children who are out of school through clubs and community activities. Moving forward Save the Children has made DRR a priority. Over the past five years we have implemented DRR and CCA programs in over 35 countries. We aim to invest the equivalent of 10 per cent of our global emergency response funding on DRR and CCA activities. We currently have a solid and expanding base of DRR and CCA programs in education, child protection, livelihoods and emergency response, and we aim to increase our DRR and CCA programming in health and nutrition to mirror our program priorities. Save the Children will seek to incorporate DRR and CCA into its program planning worldwide so that they become standard practice at the local level. We will also build an evidence base for DRR and CCA models that are replicable, scalable and can be easily introduced in other countries. Our recommendations • Governments need to support an age appropriate, child-centred approach to Disaster Risk Reduction that focuses on the specific risks faced by children. • Donors and Governments should commit to investing funding in DRR before an emergency happens to build resilience of children and communities. Climate Change Adaptation funding should also include DRR as a priority theme and ensure funds directly reach vulnerable children and communities. • Donors and national governments need to adopt legal frameworks to make vital infrastructure including schools, hospitals and housing disaster resilient to save children’s lives in emergencies. • National Adaptation Programs for Action (NAPAs) must make explicit reference to how projected trends of climate change will impact on children and how the NAPAs will reduce this impact. • Existing frameworks such as the United Nations Convention of the Rights of the Child must be upheld to protect children’s rights during disasters. • The links between Disaster Risk Reduction, Climate Change Adaptation, livelihoods and social protection need to be strengthened to ensure better outcomes for children and build resilience to disasters and climate change. savethechildren.net