APPROVAL AUTHORITY POLICY Category: General Responsible Office: Associate Vice President and Controller Responsible Executive: Vice President for Finance and Administration Date Established: 10/16/08 Date Last Revised: 03/02/12 Date Posted to Library: 03/07/12 Summary This policy provides guidance on the delegation and assignment of authority to approve transactions; identifies the circumstances under which approvals are required by the president, provost, vice-presidents and The Research Foundation operations manager; and requires that transactions requesting payment to an individual with approval authority be approved by the next higher level of authority. Policy BACKGROUND The University at Buffalo (UB, University) enters into and executes many transactions which obligate university resources. A sound internal control environment requires that only authorized individuals or their designees approve transactions. Internal controls help to ensure that transactions are: legitimate, appropriate, and allowable executed in accordance with university policy and relevant financial, legal, and contractual requirements reviewed for errors prior to execution. POLICY STATEMENT Only authorized individuals may approve transactions that obligate the University to receive or spend funds, provide or receive services, and/or otherwise commit its resources. Individuals may enter into these transactions only if they have the appropriate level of authority. Transactions requesting payment to an individual, or that benefit an individual with approval authority, require approval by the next higher level of authority. No approver may authorize a payment to oneself or benefitting oneself, including but not limited to, personnel transactions, employee expenditure reimbursements, procurement card transactions, petty cash reimbursements, and travel or entertainment expenditures. This standard of ‘two sets of eyes’ reviewing transactions promotes accountability as well as the appropriate use of the University’s resources. Delegation of Authority The State University of New York (SUNY) Board of Trustees and the Research Foundation (RF) Board of Directors have vested authority in the president, provost, and RF operations manager to contractually bind and commit the resources of the University. Where permitted, these individuals may delegate authority to the vice presidents and deans who may further delegate such authority to other qualified employees to improve operational efficiency. Approval Authority PAGE 2 OF 10 Delegations of approval authority must be documented, kept current, maintained in the departmental files, and a copy provided to the University business office charged with oversight of the transaction (e.g., Human Resources, Financial Services, Sponsored Projects Services). Guidelines for delegating approval authority include: The authority to act and responsibility for performance should reside at the lowest possible organizational level. Approvers should be those that know enough about the transaction to verify its accuracy, allowability, and consistency with policy. Approval authority should add value to the transaction, such as being a final control. Additional approvals may be required by academic units. Segregation of Duties Adequate segregation of duties is important for effective internal control. Segregation of duties provides necessary checks and balances to detect errors, deter fraud, and prevent concealment of irregularities. In general, the approval, reconciliation, and record keeping functions should be separated among employees. When these functions cannot be separated, a detailed supervisory review of related activities is required as a compensating control activity. Some examples of segregation of duties are: the person who initiates the purchase of goods or services should not be able to authorize payments the person who maintains and reconciles accounting reports should not be able to authorize purchases or payments the person who receives cash should not be the person who deposits cash or reconciles the account. APPLICABILITY This policy applies to all University accounts and funding entities including all State, Research Foundation, and University at Buffalo Foundation accounts. DEFINITIONS Approval Authority – permission to approve transactions for execution. This approval attests to the accuracy, validity, and appropriateness of the transaction within the university’s program objectives and budgetary authorizations. Transaction approval may be performed electronically in accordance with system requirements or manually with a handwritten signature. Endowed Chair – an academic position of the highest faculty honor supported by earnings from invested funds. Exception Approval – the approval required when hiring an individual under the specific situations for which an affirmative action search is not required. Internal Control – the integration of the activities, plans, attitudes, policies, and efforts of the people of a department working together to provide reasonable assurance that the department will achieve its mission. Approval Authority PAGE 3 OF 10 RESPONSIBILITY Approver Ensure you have the authority to approve the transaction or execute the contract. Verify the transaction conforms to University policies; and federal, state, and local laws. When appropriate, assess the impact of the transaction on other aspects of the University and the broader community; consult with any constituencies who might be impacted. Confirm that funds have been allocated or are otherwise available within regularly approved budgets, special appropriations, or restricted or designated accounts. Ensure that there is no real or apparent conflict of interest on your part or on any other individual or organization involved in the transaction. When there is a real or apparent conflict of interest, resolve it prior to processing the transaction. When required, obtain additional review and approval. Vice Provost,Vice Presidents and Deans Responsible for overall operations of their units. Delegate approval authority as necessary and appropriate. Maintain a written delegation plan documenting the name and signature of the approver and the scope of delegation. Review the written delegation plan annually and update as appropriate. Provide the business office with oversight of the transaction the most current listing of delegations. All actions requiring the signature of the provost must also include the signature of the appropriate vice provost, vice president, or dean. President and/or Provost Delegate approval authority as necessary and appropriate. Maintain a written delegation plan documenting the name and signature of the approver and the scope of delegation. Review the written delegation plan annually and update as appropriate. Provide the business office with oversight of the transaction the most current listing of delegations. Notify or obtain approval from the Chancellor for personnel transactions when required by the Board of Trustees policy. PROCEDURE The following charts list the transactions which require the signature of the president, provost, vice president, and/or RF operations manager. Approval Authority PAGE 4 OF 10 HUMAN RESOURCE TRANSACTION APPROVAL REQUIREMENTS APPOINTMENTS, REAPPOINTMENTS, AND PROMOTIONS Provost or Vice President (non-academic) And /Or President Approval Authority may be delegated. All delegations must be documented, kept current and maintained in the department. Appointments and promotions to titles of Distinguished Professor, Distinguished Teaching Professor, Distinguished Service Professor X And Appointments, reappointments, and promotions to endowed chairs and named professorships (State and UBF appointments) Appointments, reappointments, and promotions of the campus RF Operations Manager Appointments and promotions of faculty with tenure (UP-3) X* X And X X And X X** Permanent appointments for professional staff (UP-3) X And All appointments, reappointments, or promotions with a salary above the salary maximum for the grade/rank X And Appointments and promotions for administrative staff for the rank of MP1, MP2, and MP3 X And Appointments, reappointments, and promotions for all staff within the Provost’s or vice presidents’ offices (State, RF, and UBF) X Appointments, reappointments, and promotions of Vice President’s (State, RF, and UBF) Appointments, reappointments, and promotions of professional staff to the rank of SL-4 and above X Paid appointments, reappointments, and promotions in academic rank at the level of Associate Professor or above (qualified or unqualified title) X *Appointed by the SUNY Board of Trustees upon Chancellor’s recommendation. X** X X X **President’s approval required by the SUNY Board of Trustees Policies. Provost or Vice President And LEAVES (non-academic) /Or Approval Authority may be delegated, but must be documented, kept current and maintained in the department. All applications requesting Title E (sabbatical) or Title F leaves. X And Presidential sick leave (Title C.5 Additional Sick Leave) at full pay, partial pay, or without pay; i.e., once sick leave accruals have been exhausted or, if combined use of accruals and additional sick leave granted exceeds six months at partial or full pay or one year without pay X And President X X Approval Authority PAGE 5 OF 10 HUMAN RESOURCE TRANSACTION APPROVAL REQUIREMENTS (continued) Provost or SALARY CHANGES AND ADDITIONAL Vice President And COMPENSATION (non-academic) /Or Approval Authority may be delegated, but must be documented, kept current and maintained in the department. All base State and/or UBF* salary increases for faculty and professional staff, including also receives, and temporary increases X And over 10% of base salary and all chair stipends All RF salary increases, including over-the-maximum increases, require approval of the Principle Investigator and the Chair or Dean All State salary increases with a new salary above the maximum for the grade/rank X And All salary changes for administrative staff at the rank of MP1, MP2, or MP3 X And Salary changes (State, RF, UBF) for administrative staff within the provost’s or vice presidents’ office: below 10% X above 10% X And Requests for extra service compensation (State, RF, and UBF) for persons with official state titles of Vice President, Dean, or Director who report directly to the Provost (UP-8 for UUP academic and professional employees). Advance approval from the Chancellor is required for extra service payments to Management Confidential (M/C) employees (UP-6 for M/C professional employees) X And President X X** X X X *This applies to University employees paid on the UBF payroll. It does not apply to employees paid by UBF and working in the UBF Administrative Offices. **A letter signed by the President must be sent to SUNY System Administration. Provost Or Vice President And OTHER HUMAN RESOURCE TRANSACTIONS (non-academic) /Or Approval Authority may be delegated, but must be documented, kept current and maintained in the department. Time and attendance records and requests for individuals with the titles of Dean, Director, Vice Provost, or Vice President reporting directly to the president, provost, vice presidents X And Request for reclassification of lines for all administrative positions for the rank of MP1, MP2, or MP3 X And UP 211 for the rehiring of retired state employees X And Request for reclassification of lines for all administrative positions within the provost’s or vice presidents’ office require the approval of X Or the next level of authority Review of proposed department chair appointments and reappointments, including draft letters to the appointee from the dean or vice president X President Direct reports only X X X Approval Authority PAGE 6 OF 10 UB JOBS APPROVAL REQUIREMENTS – STATE & UBF* APPOINTMENTS Hiring Manager/ Dean Provost or University Department Or Vice Human Approver Chair Director President Resources Approval Authority may be delegated. All delegations must be documented, kept current and maintained in the department. All departments under the Office of the President, Vice President and Director of Athletics Vice President for Development and Alumni Relations Vice President for Finance and Administration Vice President for University Life and Services Classification and Recruitment Approvals X X X Hiring Proposals Faculty X X X Professional and Classified X X X Exception Approvals (must be UB JOBS STATE APPOINTMENTS approved by EDAAA) Faculty Professional X X X X X X All department under the Office of the Provost Except for the Vice President for Health Sciences Departments Classification and Recruitment Approvals X X X Hiring Proposals Faculty and Professional X X X X Classified X X X Exception Approvals (must be X Faculty and Professional X X X approved be EDAAA) Classification and Recruitment Approvals Hiring Proposals Faculty and Professional Classified Exception Approvals (must be X X X All departments under the Vice President for Health Sciences X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X approved by EDAAA) Faculty and Professional *These requirements apply to University employees paid on the UBF payroll. They do not apply to employees paid by UBF and working in the UBF Administrative Offices. Approval Authority PAGE 7 OF 10 UB JOBS APPROVAL REQUIREMENTS – RESEARCH FOUNDATION APPOINTMENTS UB JOBS RESEARCH FOUNDATION APPOINTMENTS Dean Provost or Research University Principal Or Vice Foundation Human Investigator Chair Director President OM Resources Approval Authority may be delegated. All delegations must be documented, kept current and maintained in the department. Classification and Recruitment Approvals X X or X or X X Hiring Proposals X X or X or Exception Approvals X X or X or X X X X UB JOBS APPROVAL REQUIREMENTS – RESEARCH INSTITUTE ON ADDICTIONS RESEARCH INSTITUTE ON ADDICTIONS (RIA) Principal Investigator Director Deputy Director Provost or Vice President Research Foundation OM University Human Resources UB JOBS State and RF Appointments Classification and Recruitment Approvals Hiring Proposals Exception Approvals X X X or X or X X X X or X X State X X X RF X X OTHER UNIVERSITY TRANSACTION APPROVAL REQUIREMENTS OTHER TRANSACTIONS Annual SUNY internal control certification Annual RF salary plan New and revised university policies Service center and departmental fees RF funded travel to any country identified by the US Department of State with a travel warning (requires advance written approval from the RF operations manager and president, with written notice to RF Central) RF Operations Manager Or Provost or Vice President (non-academic) And /or President X X X Provost for academic fees, Controller for nonacademic fees X X Approval Authority PAGE 8 OF 10 AUTHORIZATION TO SIGN CONTRACTS OBLIGATING UNIVERSITY RESOURCES CONTRACTS AND SERVICE AGREEMENTS APPROVAL AUTHORITY Contracts and Service Agreements must be signed by an authorized signatory. No other signatures are legally acceptable. Unless otherwise noted, only one authorized signature is required. All State purpose contracts President Provost Vice President for Finance and Administration Associate Vice President and Controller All State leases, revocable permits, and academic Assistant Vice President for Procurement Services agreements Director of Purchasing Director of Contracts State and RF Procurement-related contracts for goods, Assistant Vice President for Procurement Services services, and equipment Director of Purchasing Director of Contracts State and RF Facilities construction and consultant Associate Vice President for Facilities contracts only State Athletics sponsorship and NCAA agreements only Athletic Director Assistant Athletic Director State and RF Research Institute on Addictions (RIA) RIA Director contracts RIA Deputy Director RIA Administrative Officer All Research Foundation contracts President Provost Vice President for Finance and Administration VP for Research & Economic Development Co-Director, Sponsored Projects Services RF Facility Use Agreements Vice Provost, Office of Science, Technology Transfer and Economic Outreach (STOR) Associate Vice Provost, Incubator Manager RF Intellectual property-related contracts only Vice Provost, STOR Associate Vice Provost, STOR Director, STOR AUTHORIZATION TO SIGN PURCHASE REQUISITIONS & PURCHASE ORDERS REQUISITIONS & PURCHASE ORDERS APPROVAL AUTHORITY Requisitions and Purchase Orders must be signed by an authorized signatory. No other signatures are legally acceptable. Unless otherwise noted, only one authorized signature is required. Initiate e-Requisitions Official Department Personnel Approve e-Requisitions Department assigned authorizer Principal Investigator or designee UBF account signatory Sign purchase orders Authorized personnel in Procurement Services Approval Authority PAGE 9 OF 10 OTHER AUTHORIZATIONS NOT REQUIRING PRESIDENT or PROVOSTAPPROVAL ACTIVITY APPROVAL AUTHORITY Unless otherwise noted, only one authorized signature is required. UB Foundation Contracts Executive Director, UB Foundation RF bank accounts Co-Director, Sponsored Projects Services (SPS) Director, Financial Services RIA bank accounts L. Ritzman L. Wikander HIPAA Business Associate Contracts Assistant Vice President for Procurement Services (must be reviewed by the Director of HIPAA Executive Director, UB Foundation Compliance prior to review and execution by the Approval Authority) Space Rehab Requests All approvals are required in the order listed: Facilities Planning Officer Dean, Vice President, Vice Provost, or Athletic Director Vice President Health Sciences (Schools of Dental Medicine, Medicine, Nursing, Pharmacy, and Public Health and Health Professions only) AVP for Academic Budget and Planning Space Request Form All approvals are required in the order listed: Chair or Unit Director Facilities Planning & Management Officer Dean, Vice President, Vice Provost Vice President Health Sciences (Schools of Dental Medicine, Medicine, Nursing, Pharmacy, and Public Health and Health Professions only) Athletic Director for Athletics space only Approval Authority PAGE 10 OF 10 Contact Information Associate Vice-President & Controller 420 Crofts Hall, North Campus Phone: (716) 645-2505 Fax: (716) 645-3701 Susan A. Krzystofiak Assistant Vice President, Human Resources 120 Crofts Hall, North Campus E-mail: krzystof@buffalo.edu Phone: (716) 645-2642 Related Information University Documents: Policies and Procedures for Extra Service Compensation and Summer Employment http://hr.buffalo.edu/files/phatfile/ex_comp.pdf Promotion Policy for Professional Employees http://hr.buffalo.edu/files/phatfile/Promotion_Policy_Prof.pdf Board of Trustees Policy http://hr.buffalo.edu/files/phatfile/BOT_Policies.pdf Related Links: SUNY Policy, Administration of Sabbatical Leaves http://www.suny.edu/sunypp/documents.cfm?doc_id=35 Revision History December 2009 - Revised to add additional sections to the Approval Authority chart. February 2010 - Clarification added to Approval Authority charts UB Jobs Approval Requirements and Authorization To Sign Contracts Obligating University Resources. February 2012 - Clarification of requirements for payments benefitting oneself, documentation of delegations, updates to Approval Authority Charts. Presidential Approval Satish K. Tripathi _________________________________________________ Satish K. Tripathi, President 3/2/12 ________________ Date