20140625-26 EPPSRWG Item 02 GMD RSC EOP 10

advertisement

GMD Update

RSC Item 10

6/24/2014

2

Outline

• FERC Approval of EOP-010-1

• EOP-010-1 Comments Addressed by FERC Order 797

• EOP-010-1 Implementation Date

• Review of EOP-010-1 Requirements

• GMD Planning Standard TPL-007 in Development

• Next Steps

3

FERC Approval of EOP-010-1

• NERC Standard EOP-010-1 developed to address the first stage of

FERC Order 779 which was released in May 2013.

• Order 779 directed NERC to develop GMD Standards in two stages to mitigate impacts of GMD events.

– Stage 1 – Standard to address the impacts of GMDs on BES.

– Stage 2 – Standard that require BES operators/owners to conduct initial and on-going assessments of potential benchmark GMD events.

• NERC GMD Task Force continues work on Planning Standard TPL-

007 to address stage 2.

• NERC Issued EOP-010 to address stage 1.

– Received NERC approval in November 2013.

– FERC NOPR (Notice of Proposed Rulemaking) issued in January 2014.

• FERC Approved EOP-010-1 on Thursday June 19 th , 2014 at their

June open meeting.

4

FERC Approval of EOP-010-1

• FERC Order No. 797 (Docket No. RM14-1-000) Issued on June 19,

2014, approved EOP-010-1.

• Several commenters on the NOPR supported approval without modification.

• Other commenters raised issues regarding:

– The applicability of EOP-010-1

– Effectiveness of GMD operational procedures

– Implementation plan

– Other issues

• FERC approved the violation risk factors and violation severity levels associated with EOP-010-1.

– R1, R2, and R3 all have a VRF of Medium.

5

EOP-010-1 Comments

• FERC agreed with NERC that EOP-010-1 should only be applicable to RCs and

TOPs.

– Commenters suggested that more entities (GOPs, BAs) having a transformer with a high side wye-grounded winding with terminal voltage greater than 200kV be subject to standard.

– FERC stated NERC petition and White Paper provided adequate justification for standard to only be applicable to TOPs.

• Commenters suggested operational procedures alone are not sufficient to mitigate the impacts of GMD Events.

– FERC noted that procedures are not a complete solution to the risks of a GMD on the BES.

– However, procedures are an important first step and can be implemented quickly and more comprehensive protections will be addressed in stage two standards (TOP-007).

• One commenter suggested that a six month implementation period is not enough.

– FERC stated that no other commenters expressed this concern.

– FERC stated TOPs do not need to wait for the RC to develop an RC GMD Plan prior to the

TOP developing its own GMD Operating Procedure.

• Commenters expressed concern that EOP-010-1 does not address electromagnetic pulses (EMPs) and that NERC did not provide enough time for public discussion.

– FERC stated that Order 779 specifically excluded EMPs from the scope, and that NERC provided ample time for public discussion.

6

Implementation of EOP-010-1

• FERC approval of EOP-010-1 occurred on June 19 th , 2014.

• EOP-010-1 states the standard will be effective:

– “The first day of the first calendar quarter that is six months after the date that this standard is approved by an applicable governmental authority”

– Six months from June 19 th , 2014, is December 19 th , 2014.

– The first day of the next calendar quarter is January 1 st , 2015 .

• One caveat to the effective date of EOP-010-1 is the effective date of R2. EOP-010-1 R2 replaces IRO-005-3.1a, R3.

– IRO-005-3.1a R3 is pending approval for retirement.

– EOP-010-1 R2 will not become effective until the day after the ret irement of IRO-005-3.1a R3.

7

EOP-010-1 Requirement Summaries

• GMD Plan development in response to EOP-010-1

• R1: Each Reliability Coordinator must develop a GMD Operating

Plan that:

– Coordinates GMD Operating Procedures in its RC Area.

– Includes activities to mitigate GMD events.

– Includes a process to review GMD Operating Procedures of

Transmission Operators in RC Area.

• R2: Each RC must share forecasted and current space weather information as stated in RC’s GMD Operating Plan.

• R3: Each TOP must develop a GMD Operating Procedure to mitigate GMD events that includes:

– Steps to receive space weather information.

– System Operator response actions to preset conditions.

– Conditions for terminating the Operating Procedure.

8

MISO GMD Plan Development

• Intended to prepare MISO for GMD events.

• Gathered ideas for this plan from multiple sources.

• Utilized steps and procedures from:

– MISO RTO-OP-053-r8.1 Geo-Magnetic Disturbance Procedure

– MISO RTO-OP-018-r9.1 Conservative System Operations Procedure

– NERC GMD Task Force GMD Operating Procedure Template

– Discussion with other RTO/ISOs

• GMD Plan will detail MISO actions:

– Relay details received from NOAA

– Enter Conservative Operations

– Follow mitigation steps

9

TOP GMD Operating Procedure

• Any TOP subject to EOP-010-1 (TOP area includes a power transformer with a high side wye-grounded winding with terminal voltage greater than 200 kV) needs to have a GMD Operating

Procedure.

• All TOP Operating Procedures must be coordinated by their RC.

• In order for MISO to review TOP Operating Procedures and be ready for standard implementation on 1/1/15, all TOP GMD

Operating Procedures should be submitted to MISO by November

2014.

• A TOP GMD Operating Procedure Template is available here: http://www.nerc.com/comm/PC/Geomagnetic%20Disturbance%20Task

%20Force%20GMDTF%202013/Template_TOP.pdf

Future Planning Standard: TPL-007

• Requires a planning assessment of the system for its ability to withstand a Benchmark GMD Event without causing a wide area blackout, voltage collapse, or large load loss.

– Applicability: PCs, TPs, TOs, GOs

– Need system models— DC (GIC calculation) and AC (power flow)

– Transformer information-- internal winding resistance

– Substation grounding information

• Studies that may be necessary to perform a GMD assessment:

– Transformer GIC Impact Calculations

– Power Flow System Studies – calculate reactive power loss

– Impact of Harmonics on Protection and Control

– Generator Impact Studies

10

TPL-007: Assessment Process (Simplified)

11

Next Steps

• MISO to provide a draft version of its GMD Operating Plan

• MISO to work with the Emergency Preparedness Power

System Restoration Working Group (EP/PSRWG) to develop a process to review GMD Operating Procedures of

Transmission Operators in its RC Area.

– Process required per R1 of EOP-010-1.

– MISO proposes using a similar process established for reviewing

System Restoration Plans per EOP-006.

– Review process needs established by fall 2014.

• TOPs begin developing their own GMD Operating Procedures per R3 of EOP-010-1.

– GMD Operating Procedures need to be submitted to MISO by

November 2014 for MISO to review per new review process.

– MISO needs approximately 30 days to review all GMD Operating

Procedures prior to January 1 st , 2015 effective date.

12

13

Questions?

Andy Witmeier

Manager Regional Ops Engineering – Central Region awitmeier@misoenergy.org

Download