Do It Your-Self-Assembly ................................................................ 1 Overview ................................................................................... 1 Brief Background Information .................................................. 3 Activity 1: Molecular Do-Si-Do ....................................................... 4 Overview ................................................................................... 4 Game 1 ...................................................................................... 4 Game 2 ...................................................................................... 5 Activity 2: Shake and Make; Charge Recognition .......................... 8 Overview ................................................................................... 8 Setup ......................................................................................... 8 Procedure .................................................................................. 8 Links and References .............................................................. 10 Activity 3: 3D-tection; Molecular Shape Recognition ................... 11 Overview ................................................................................. 11 Setup ....................................................................................... 11 Procedure ................................................................................ 11 Extended Background Information for Teachers.................... 14 Vocabulary .............................................................................. 15 Links and References .............................................................. 16 6th - 8th Grade The following is a series of three activities that illustrate the requirements of molecular recognition. Altogether, the activities require three 50-minute class periods to complete. All of the activities involve group work. Self-assembly is a process by which molecules recognize each other and stick together. Molecules that stick together during self-assembly may form themselves into specific, ordered structures under the right conditions. Nano is very, very small. Self-assembly can be used by scientists to create objects on the nano-scale. Researchers in the field of nanotechnology are studying selfassembly and molecular recognition in order to create new materials and technologies. Confusion about bonding, chemical reactions, molecular behavior Confusion about particles at all levels: atoms, molecules, cells, and types of molecules involved in body functions. Students act as molecules and simulate self-assembly of different structures. Students identify rules and conditions that apply to the selfassembly of molecules. (Self-assembly happens when molecules recognize each other and stick together.) Through a lock and key activity, students understand the concept of molecular recognition. (i.e. When two molecules stick together, it means that they have recognized each other’s unique shapes and electrical charges.) Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 1 Students identify the challenges scientists face in simulating selfassembly at the molecular (nano) level. Students understand that the natural process of self-assembly can be used to manufacture large quantities of very, very small things. It can also be used to build small- or large-scale nanostructures. Particle Model of Matter Grades 6 – 8 (one 8-10 week unit at Middle School Level) Structure and behavior of Atoms and Molecules (includes particle concept, movement, and conservation principles). Modeling across topics such as matter and energy (Modeling is fore grounded) Across Grades 4 – 8 Important aspects of understanding and engaging in using models, (constructing, critiquing, and revising models) as well as important aspects of the nature of models (understanding that models are tools for making predictions and explanations). Atomic molecular theory Across grades K – 8 Concepts central to this theory such as particles, motion of particle, conservation, etc. Nature of matter (Nanoscience literacy) Across grades 7 – 14 Structure of matter, periodic table, and ionic forces (i.e. interatomic forces) Laboratory experiences in life sciences Grades 1 – 13 Atomic theory Grades 7 – 14 Atomic composition and structure subatomic, inter-atomic interactions Material kinds have characteristic properties that can be measured and explained Grades K – 8 Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 2 Matter can be transformed, but not created or destroyed, through physical and chemical processes. Good measurements provide more reliable and useful information about object properties than common sense impressions Grades K – 8 We can learn about the world through measurement Modeling is concerned with capturing key relations among ideas rather than surface appearance Grades K – 8 We can learn about the world through modeling Arguments use reasoning to connect ideas and data Grades K – 8 We can learn about the world through argument Return to Table of Contents All biological processes are made possible through chemical attractions between molecules. Molecules identify and bind to each other based on several properties including their threedimensional shapes as well as their electronic charges. Return to Table of Contents Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 3 Activity 1 involves two games that help students to establish the rules of molecular recognition. Students act as molecules and follow specific rules that determine how they will bond with each other to form structures. They will learn that scientists may discover and exploit the properties of molecules to build structures not found in nature but useful in the design and construction of new nanoscale devices. Return to Table of Contents (Adapted from http://pbskids.org/dragonflytv/pdf/DragonflyTV_SelfAssemblyGames.pdf.) 20 minutes None None NOTE: An even number of participants is needed. An extra student may assist players and check that the group is following the rules. Anticipatory set: Inform students that they will shrink a billion times to the nanosize of molecules floating in human body fluid. When they come in contact with another molecule (student) they will stick (bond) to them if certain rules are maintained. 1. Tell students the following rules: a) They must hold hands. No hand can be left untouched. b) The RIGHT hand must touch someone else’s right hand and the LEFT hand must touch someone else’s left hand. c) They may NOT cross arms. The result of the game: Participants will be standing in a complete circle with each child alternating in the direction they are facing. Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 4 1. When assembling your circle, what were some key rules required to make it? [Possible Responses] They must hold hands. No hand can be left untouched. The RIGHT hand must touch someone else’s right hand and the LEFT hand must touch someone else’s left hand. They may NOT cross arms. 2. What do you think would happen if you were allowed to cross arms? A different shape would form. Return to Table of Contents (Adapted from http://pbskids.org/dragonflytv/pdf/DragonflyTV_SelfAssemblyGames.pdf.) NOTE: You need a total of 15 kids for this activity. If you have 30 students, you can repeat the following instructions for both groups of 15. Extra students may assist the players as they assemble according to the rules of the game. 35 minutes Each set of 15 students will need: Red gloves or paper wrist bands (6 pairs per 15 students) Blue gloves or paper wrist bands (6 pairs per 15 students) Gather gloves Anticipatory set: Ask students to explain what they think of when they hear the phrase “Laws of Attraction.” 1. Remind them that they are molecules floating in cellular fluid, which is mostly water, and that they are a billion times smaller than their normal size. When they come in contact with another molecule (student) they will stick (bond) to them if certain rules are maintained. 2. Divide each set of 15 participants into three groups as described below: Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 5 Group 1 = 3 participants Group 2 = 6 participants Group 3 = 6 participants 3. Distribute gloves (or wrist bands) Group 1: Give each participant a pair of RED gloves to put on each hand. Group 2: Give each participant one red glove and one blue glove. Place one glove on each hand (it doesn’t matter which color goes on which hand). Group 3: Give each participant only one blue glove (they can put it on either hand). 4. Read the rules for each group Group 1: They must hold hands. No hand can be left untouched. They may only hold hands with someone who has the SAME color glove that they do. They may NOT hold hands with any other members of Group 1. Group 2: They must hold hands. No hand can be left untouched. They may only hold hands with someone who has the same colored glove as they do. They may NOT hold hands with any other members of Group 2. Group 3: They may only hold hands with someone who has the same color glove as they do. They may NOT hold hands with any other members of Group 3. The result of the game: The students create a star pattern. When assembling your star shape, what were some key rules required to make it? Possible Responses or Points for a Mini-Lecture: Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 6 Laws of attraction: A blue colored glove could only touch a blue colored glove and red colored glove could only touch a red colored glove. The same rules apply to atoms and molecules, but the rules are a little different. If the blue colored glove (atom) is a positive charge and the red colored glove (atom) is a negative charge, they would bond. In this case, two red gloves would never touch each other just like two negative charges repel each other. (This is similar to how the opposite poles of magnets attract and the same poles repel one another). Shape (lock and key): Along with polarity, a molecule’s shape is also an important factor in assembly. For the snowflake activity, the shapes where bonding occurred were hands (as opposed to feet or elbow or ears, etc.). Molecules often fit together like a lock and key or pieces of a puzzle. Only one shape will fit into another shape to bond, and only if the charges of the two molecules allow it. Shape AND charge are important for molecular recognition. What can you conclude from the way you all followed the same set of rules about the pattern you got? What can you conclude about how molecules would behave if the conditions for them are exactly the same? Return to Table of Contents Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 7 Activity 2 demonstrates how molecules bind to each other according to forces of attraction or repulsion. The placement of charge determines the possible structures that molecules can make when they come together. This activity can be performed as a demonstration if purchasing the magnetic pieces is cost prohibitive. Or, you can purchase one set and incorporate it as one activity in a rotation that includes several of the pre/post activities. Return to Table of Contents One 50-minute class period Each group will need: Skrooz or Roger’s Connection pieces are magnetic construction toys consisting of plastic building pieces containing embedded neodymium magnets and steel bearing balls which can be connected together to form various geometric shapes and structures. 50 rods, 26 balls http://www.magz.com/, 84-piece set, $28.95 https://www.rogersconnection.com, 88-piece set = $38.95 Shoe boxes (one per group) (5 minutes) Create some 2-D and 3-D shapes with the Skrooz Set out Skrooz and shoeboxes Return to Table of Contents Anticipatory Set: Discussion: Ask students to explain the term “self-assembly.” Ask them if they can think of anything that can self-assemble. Answers may be written on a note pad or white board. Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 8 Explain to students that scientists are researching ways to replicate how molecules can naturally self-assemble, but they face many challenges. This activity will provide a some insight to those challenges. 1. Separate students into groups of 3 or 4. 2. Provide each group is with a handful of magnetic pieces. 3. On a piece of paper or an overhead, show students examples of different premade 2-D and 3-D shapes (show examples). 4. Ask students to build the same magnetic shapes found in the example (transferred to PowerPoint or overhead). 5. Once the shapes are created by hand, ask the students to pull apart the pieces and place those required to make those shapes in a shoe box. 6. Ask students to shake the shoe box, with the magnetic pieces inside, to see if self-assembly of the shapes they just created occurs. Observe how frequently those patterns occur. How often did the patterns you created with your hands occur in the box? What was different about the assembly process of creating the desired shapes? How efficient was the process in terms of time and yield? Molecules will always follow the same assembly patterns if the conditions are exactly the same. The trick for scientists is to figure out the specific conditions that cause certain molecules to bond in certain ways (temperature, shapes, etc.). Scientists can grow really tiny molecular structures in a lab as long as they can figure out what conditions to set. If they set the right conditions, the atoms and molecules do the work and form the specific structures they want. To facilitate this, recognition elements must be built in so that assembly is specific and spontaneous. Return to Table of Contents Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 9 Share the following examples of self-assembled biological structures and show the associated video clip which demonstrates each process: a) formation of lipid bilayers which surround and contain the contents of cells, Bilayer Formation Through Molecular Self-Assembly: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lm-dAvbl330 b) Unraveling of DNA helices to access the genetic code which gets copied into proteins and subsequent folding of polypeptide chains into 3D proteins which creates all of the structures of our bodies, DNA Transcription and Protein Assembly: http://www.allthingsscience.com/video/535/DNA-Transcription-and-Protein-Assembly c) The assembly of enzymes and their substrates to make reactions happen than they naturally would, Industrial Enzymes Animation Clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrKgjbqZTwU&feature=related. Return to Table of Contents Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 10 Activity 3 demonstrates how molecules must fit together, like a lock and key, in order to identify each other and initiate a new function as a combined unit. Return to Table of Contents One 50-minute class period Each group will need: Play-dough (or Sculpey) Play-dough Recipe: http://www.instructables.com/id/How-toMake-Playdough-Play-doh/?ALLSTEPS – OR – Sculpey clay: http://www.sculpey.com/ Rolling Pins (one per group if available) Assortment of different types of keys (several per group, may be obtained for free from hardware store as they generally keep extras or mistakes) One small, opaque bag containing a small item with unique and distinctive shape (per group) Set out play dough, rolling pins, keys, and objects for each group Return to Table of Contents Anticipatory Set: Hold up a key. Ask students what it is used for (students will likely say that it is to lock/unlock something). Ask them if it could unlock the door to their house or a car (students will likely say no). Ask them why this key could not unlock the door to their house or a car (students should likely say that only a certain key can open the door to their house or a car). Explain to students that the self-assembly of molecules work very much like a lock and key. This helps molecules identify each other and initiate a new function as a combined unit. Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 11 1. Divide students into groups of three or four students. 2. Give some Play-dough (or Sculpy), a rolling pin, and keys to each group. 3. Inform students that, based on their new knowledge of selfassembly, they will use Play-dough (or Sculpy) to design their own molecular models that will address how shapes of molecules are important to self-assembly. 4. Inform students that their goal will be to create two “molecules that will fit together in only one unique pattern, like a lock and key.” 5. Ask students to use their rolling pin to smooth out a piece of Play-dough. Ensure that each Play-dough chunk is big and thick enough to retain the shape of a key pressed into it. 6. Once they have rolled out their Play-dough, have students press some keys into the Play-dough to create a print (mold) of a key. 7. Mix the keys and see if members of the group can match each key to each mold without distorting the molds. 8. Ask: How long did it take? Was it easy or difficult? Were there any keys for which it was difficult to discriminate which mold they matched? 9. Inform the students that this process usually takes place in a suspension of liquid which fills your body cells. 10. Next, distribute bags with small items, one per group. Tell students not to look at the items within. They may use their hands to feel the shapes of the items. Ask each student to create a Play-dough mold (molecule) that will recognize the shape within the bag. After students have created their molecules, ask them to remove the item from the bag and see if it can bond with the molecule that they made out of Playdough without distorting the molds. Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 12 Imagine all of the reasons why your body cells would need to be able to identify and link to other cells or molecules in the way we simulated using Play-dough. (Teacher: make a list of student responses and keep it posted in the classroom.) What did you discover when you tried out different key molds? Possible Response: It took a bit of movement and jostling to get the keys to fit into the molds without changing the shape of the molds. What did you discover when you tried to match the Play-dough molds to the items in the bags? Possible Response: Students will have to move the molds over the surface of the items, testing various orientations, in order to find the right fit. This takes time and energy. The molds really have to be exact to get them to fit together. What if you had to use couldn’t use your eyes to judge whether the mold and the item fit together? Possible Response: The shapes of the molds must be extremely precise and unique for each specific object in order to discriminate between them. The movements one would make to test the fit need to be tiny and incremental so that no possible matching points are overlooked. What do you think might happen if there is a problem with the key not fitting properly into the lock? In other words, what might happen to the body if the molecules do not self-assemble properly? For example, what would happen if the antibody could not bind to the antigen? What do you think might cause this to happen? Possible Response: Disease causing organisms could go undetected, within the body, reproduce and cause symptoms. Our body would not be able to find them and destroy them. Or, molecules in charge of causing reactions to happen might not be able to find and attach to the ingredients they need…therefore reactions won’t happen and this might cause Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 13 symptoms because important work might not get done inside the body. Return to Table of Contents Understanding self-assembly is key to understanding how scientists research, design and create things at the nano level. Nature has been self-assembling things for billions of years by exploiting the “rules” of the nanoscale. Now scientists are using this information to create new materials and devices, such as: medical treatments for different diseases miniature diagnostics called “labs on chips” diagnostic methods that can determine whether someone has a disease before they even have symptoms. The “rules” of the nanoscale define way that matter sticks together and behaves. Atoms are attracted to each other based on electric charge and bind to form molecules. Molecules then stick together based on electrical charge and three-dimensional shape. When they match, molecules snap together like magnetic locks and keys. This is known as molecular recognition. When this process requires very little to no energy, the scientific community calls it self-assembly, since the formation of molecules happens by itself. Biological molecules rely on selfassembly to form and maintain the structures of life. Cells rely on molecular recognition to sense their environment, to communicate, and to identify their “friends” and “foes.” Just as you recognize and respond to your surroundings using your senses of sight, sound, touch and smell, cells use surface molecules to collect information about their surroundings and react accordingly. For example, bacterial cells have sugar sensors on their surfaces. When a sensor nears a sugar molecule, it binds to it and causes the cell to creep in the direction of increasing sugar concentration. Why does it creep in that direction? Because it has sensed one sugar molecule and wants more. It’s sort of like Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 14 when you smell chocolate chip cookies baking in the oven and move toward the delicious smell so that you can eat some! Scientists have discovered thousands of these sensor molecules (also called antigens) that cells use to probe their surroundings and now use them to connect cells together into shapes that are useful to them. Sensor molecules must have very exact and picky shapes that can only “dock” with certain molecules from their environment. This pickiness is called specificity, because each molecule only recognizes a specific mate. Each sensor must dock with only one very special type of molecule so that cells can tell the difference between different conditions and react in the best way. Researchers can mimic the specificity of molecular recognition to design and build sensors that identify and respond to chemicals in the body or in the environment. For example, miniature glucose sensors, made up of small pieces of specially-shaped proteins mounted on a surface, can detect the exact concentration of sugar in a diabetic patient’s blood, communicate that amount to the patient and even deliver an appropriate concentration of insulin in response. (The insulin allows diabetic cells to absorb and store the glucose, which they normally cannot do by themselves.) While there are still many challenges in simulating molecular recognition and self-assembly, scientists and engineers get better at it every day. Return to Table of Contents Antibody (ˈantiˌbädē/): proteins generally found in the blood that detect and destroy invaders. Antigen: (ˈantijən/): a harmful substance which enters the body which causes the body to make antibodies as a response to fight off disease. Atom (/ˈatəm/): the basic unit of matter, sometimes described as building blocks. Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 15 Cell (sel/): the smallest structural and functional unit of an organism. Cell surface receptors: proteins on the surface of cells that allow other proteins to bind to the cells. Law of Attraction: the name given to the belief that “like attracts like.” Molecule (/ˈmäləˌkyool/): a group of two or more atoms that stick together. Molecular Recognition (mə¦lek·yə·lər ′rek·ig′nish·ən)):the specific interaction/recognition between two or more molecules . Nanoscale (ˈnanəˌskāl,): Very very small. Having dimensions measured in nanometers. Nanotechnology (ˌnanəˌtekˈnäləjē): the science of working with atoms and molecules to build devices that are extremely small. Receptor (/riˈseptər/): specialized proteins in the cell membrane that take part in communication between the cell and the outside world. Self-assembly (self/ \-ə-ˈsem-blē\ ): the process by which a complex macromolecule (as collagen) or a supramolecular system (as a virus) spontaneously assembles itself from its components. Specificity (\ˌspe-sə-ˈfi-sə-tē\): the quality of being specific. Return to Table of Contents Image of antibody/antigen lock and key binding Each antibody binds to a specific antigen; similar to a lock and key. Image courtesy of Fvasconcellos, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antibody Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 16 Antibodies and antigens: Like Play-dough molds and hands, antibodies and antigens fit together, like a lock and key. Antigens are foreign particles not recognized by the body that can cause illness and/or disease. An antibody is part of the body’s immune system and attaches to the antigen to help fight off (neutralize) the disease (antigen). Antibodies are important in keeping our bodies in balance. All lock-and-key-type reactions take place in the fluids of the body, which is about 65% water. Antibody Immune Response: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrYlZJiuf18 The molecules of the body are constantly in motion. Their shapes flip and flop between all of the positions that they can possibly take and that require the least amount of energy. If molecular shapes and charges match, this constant motion allows molecules to wiggle around until they are able snap together. This is how Nature accomplishes the millions of reactions that take place to keep us alive. If a reaction requires more energy than simple wiggling provides, then Nature uses special molecules, called enzymes, to provide more energy, bring molecules close together and that cause specific shape changes to happen. Computer simulations can help us predict how molecules might interact and design molecules to interact in ways that are beneficial to us. The Molecular Recognition Waltz: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ozUmnZY6PC8 Disco Docking – Computational Drug Design: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTtrk0Ue-Cg&NR=1&feature=endscreen Bilayer Formation Through Molecular Self-Assembly: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lm-dAvbl330 DNA Transcription and Protein Assembly: http://www.allthingsscience.com/video/535/DNA-Transcription-and-Protein-Assembly Industrial Enzymes assembly Animation Clip: Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 17 \http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrKgjbqZTwU&feature=related. Antibody Immune Response: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrYlZJiuf18 Play-dough Recipe: http://www.instructables.com/id/How-to-Make-Playdough-Play-doh/?ALLSTEPS – OR – Sculpey clay: http://www.sculpey.com/ http://askabiologist.asu.edu/body-depot Return to Table of Contents Arizona Science Center, azscience.org 18