electrical engineering division Arc Flash hazard analysis Planning Kit Everything You Need To Ensure The Success of Your Arc Flash Project training institute WHAT IS AN ARC FLASH? An arc flash occurs when electric current passes through the air instead of its intended path. The result is extremely high heat that causes severe burns, blinding light, and an explosion causing hearing damage, bodily injury and can be fatal. CONTENTS 4 5 6 8 9 10 10 11 A Message for Managers Before You Get Started What’s the Process Making an Apples to Apples Bid Comparison How to Identify Compliant Labels Template for Soliciting Bids Request Study & Label Samples Arc Flash Questionnaire SHOCK HAZARD ANALYSIS? NFPA 70E-2012 130.4 requires that a shock hazard analysis be performed before beginning energized work. AVO includes a shock hazard analysis as part of its arc flash hazard analysis and shock protection boundaries are printed on the labels. AVO places a high priority on electrical safety and offers a full package of electrical safety services. why use this kit? This Kit will help you plan and execute a successful Arc Flash Hazard Analysis, by showing you how to: ff Build internal support for your analysis ff Identify the components necessary for compliance ff Compare bids effectively who is this kit for Managers who are responsible for the safety of personnel in their facilities and OSHA compliance. Managers who are planning to complete an Arc Flash Hazard Analysis and want to collect pricing from qualified providers. 2 | Arc Flash Study Kit www.avotraining.com/eed electrical engineering division what do you need for a successful arc flash hazard analysis? The success of your Arc Flash Hazard Analysis depends on the support of people committed to protecting personnel from arc flash hazards. A narrow focus on costs or short cuts offered by some engineering firms typically comes at the expense of personnel safety. ff Get Support. From the CEO to the electricians’ helper, your entire team needs to understand the value of this analysis. Communicate, communicate, communicate. Once people understand the injuries and fatalities this study can prevent and the significant financial effects, they are more likely to join you in supporting the project. ff Allocate Resources. Before, during and after. The ability to implement mitigation recommendations, scheduling training, and supporting a strong preventative maintenance program will all contribute to the success of your Analysis. In this Kit, you will find information that will aid you in achieving the following goals: © 2012 AVO Training Institute Arc Flash Study Kit | 3 training institute Don’t let it happen to you Multiple arc flash incidents occur in workplaces across the U.S. every day. The risk of an arc flash explosion occuring at your facility is not negligible. The ongoing trend towards increasing power usage combined with an aging electrical infrastructure actually forecasts greater risk in the near future. 4 | Arc Flash Study Kit The Electrical Power Research Institute estimates direct and indirect costs to an employer from a fatal electrical accident in the millions. This includes: ff ff ff ff ff ff ff ff ff Medical costs Lost productivity Workers compensation Hiring and re-training Equipment replacement Facility repair Insurance premium increases OSHA citations Litigation and punitive damages And in the end, OSHA will enforce compliance, including performing an Arc Flash Hazard Analysis, through a succession of inpections that can leave you scrambling. While every facility will have its’ own unique set of costs, it has been proven, without exception, it is far more expensive to allow one arc flash accident to occur than it is to prevent it. www.avotraining.com/eed electrical engineering division before you get started Use this checklist as a guide to avoid common mistakes that can sabotage your analysis before it even starts. Read the current edition of the NFPA 70E. Attend a training course. Share Arc Flash Hazard Analysis plans with your electrical workers and ask for their feedback. Collect existing one-line diagrams. Collect electrical equipment maintenance records. Collect any previous engineering study data - such as short circuit studies, protective device coordination or load flow studies. Confirm the loads are properly identified in the panel board directory to streamline the data gathering process. Select a plant electrician or technician familiar with equipment within the facility to accompany the engineering technician during data collection. Communicate the schedule and purpose of the engineering technician who will be performing data collection to all facility personnel. Arrange for special access clearance, as required, to reach areas with electrical equipment. Determine if there are acceptable conditions for the engineering technician to take photographs within your facility. Identify safety requirements specific to your facility that the engineering technician will need to follow during data collection. Select the person who will review the draft Arc Flash Hazard Analysis Report during the review period Schedule electrical personnel for training in NFPA 70E safe work procedures course. © 2012 AVO Training Institute Arc Flash Study Kit | 5 training institute what’s the process? start to finish: your arc flash hazard analysis AVO Electrical Engineering Division adheres to a standardized process in performing every Arc Flash Hazard Analysis. This correlates with IEEE Standard 1584, Chapter 4. Prior to beginning the actual study, we will hold a project meeting (via conference call or on site) with all personnel who will be involved, to establish roles, responsibilities and the plan for data gathering. A standard analysis will apply to three phase equipment rated 240 volts or greater and rated lower than 240 volts when served from a transformer 125 kva and larger.* You will need to determine if you want an expanded scope that includes all 208 volt or DC equipment, or if you want a single phase analysis. The entire project will be performed under the supervision of a Registered Professional Engineer (PE). step 1 step 2 data collection power system modeling step 3 short circuit study step 1: data collection Qualified staff must gather data from all applicable electrical equipment. Required information includes: ff Data from the utility, including available fault current, operating voltage, and specifics regarding the utility’s protective equipment at the point of service ff Specifics for each protective device in the electrical system, including manufacturer, model, available time/current settings, and short-circuit interrupting rating ff Transformer impedance, tap settings and ratings ff Conductor specifics, including lengths, sizes, and types of all overhead lines, bus ducts, and cables step 2: power system modeling One line diagrams must be developed or updated to show the current configuration and modes of operation for the power system. Accurate electrical system drawings are necessary to identify power sources, voltage levels, electrical equipment and protective devices. If you already have one-line diagrams, we will update the data and work from them, if possible. We use SKM Power Tools for Windows®, ETAP®, ARC Pro® and other available engineering software. step 3: short circuit study A short circuit study is required to determine the magnitude of current flowing throughout the power system at critical points at various time intervals after a “fault” occurs. These calculations will be used to determine the bolted fault current, which is essential for the calculation of incident energy and interrupting ratings of your equipment. Comparison of equipment ratings with calculated short circuit and operating conditions will identify underrated equipment. We perform this study in accordance with ANSI Std. C37 and IEEE Std. 141-1993 (Red Book). * IEEE 1584 working group is considering changes for its next revision. 6 | Arc Flash Study Kit www.avotraining.com/eed electrical engineering division step 4 step 5 protective device coordination step 6 arc flash calculations step 7 reporting step 4: protective device coordination A protective device coordination should be performed to ensure selection and arrangement of protective devices limits the effects of an overcurrent situation to the smallest area. Results will be used to make recommendations for mitigation of arc flash hazards. Although this is an optional study, arc flash mitigation cannot be performed without completing this step. We perform this study in accordance with IEEE Std. 2422001 (Buff Book). step 5: arc flash calculations These calculations are based on available short circuit current, protective device clearing time and distance from the arc. Calculations of incident energy levels and flash protection boundaries will be completed for all relevant equipment busses. The magnitude of arc hazards are determined using methods from NFPA 70E®, IEEE 1584 or NESC Tables 410‐1 and 410‐2, as applicable. step 6: reporting Upon completion of the calculations, we will prepare your Arc Flash Hazard Analysis Report. This will be supplied to you for a short review period, during which your team can review mitigation recommendations. At this point, we can hold a Management Summary meeting to intepret the report results. Upon approval, we will provide a final report and full sized one-line diagrams, stamped by our Registered PE. The drawings and report will also be supplied to you in a digital format. label installation So how long is this going to take? Duration is affected by the type of equipment and other conditions, but through experience we have established the following Project Duration Formula: 3.2x = y 100 where x = the quantity of components in your power system (phase equipment rated 240 volts or greater and three phase equipment rated lower than 240 volts when served from a 125+ kva transformer) and where y = the estimated duration of the project (in days) step 7: label installation We will generate and install arc flash hazard warning labels. These labels identify incident energy and working distance, nominal system voltage, and the arc flash boundary. In addition to standard requirements, our labels also include Limited, Restricted and Prohibited approach boundaries, date, upstream protective device and recommended personal protection equipment. We can also provide bolted fault current if desired. We provide labels that are compliant with NFPA 70E 130.3(c), NEC 110.24(A) and ANSI Z535. © 2012 AVO Training Institute Arc Flash Study Kit | 7 training institute making an apples to apples bid comparison Comparing Arc Flash Hazard Analysis bids can be confusing. If your prices are widely varied, very likely so are the deliverables you’re getting with each. Use the following chart to compare bids. SCOPE avo Field Data Collection * Analysis of Equipment Less Than 240v Available Power System Modeling Short Circuit Study Identify Underrated Equipment Protective Device Coordination Non-Commercial Mitigation Recommendations Determine Incident Energy Levels Determine Flash Protection Boundaries Arc Flash Report Draft Review Period Interim Review by Professional Engineer Print Arc Flash Labels Produce Full-sized One-Line Diagrams Final Report Stamped by Professional Engineer Installation of Arc Flash Labels * Final Report, One-lines and Digital Files Delivered ** BID 2 BID 3 * Data collection and installation of labels can be completed by your Qualified personnel or by AVO Electrical Engineering Division. ** You may also want to consider both AVO’s NFPA 70E training and an annual Data Maintenance. 8 | Arc Flash Study Kit www.avotraining.com/eed electrical engineering division how to identify compliant labels keeping compliant labels This is an example of an arc flash hazard warning label produced by AVO Engineering Division. Every characteristic of this label is intentional and serves a purpose. When selecting a provider, you should ensure the labels meet the following minimum compliance requirements. AVO Engineering Division provides the following optional information: inventory identifiers, bus numbers, bolted fault current, and approach boundaries. Once your compliant labels are installed, it’s not over. NFPA 70E requires that your labels be updated when you make major equipment or system changes and at a minimum of every 5 years. AVO Engineering Division offers a lowcost Data Maintenance Plan that will keep your labels in compliance. NFPA 70E 130.5(C) Requirements ANSI Z535 Requirements Orange header with warning symbol nec 110.24 (A) Requirements Nominal voltage “WARNING” text Maximum available fault current Arc Flash boundary Font and label size Date Hazard level indicator, only one of the following is necessary: Incident energy and working distance Clothing arc rating and required PPE Hazard Risk Category White with black text (or reverse) nFPA 70E 130.4 Requirements Resistant to environment nec 110.16 Requirements Label placement Limited approach boundary Restricted approach boundary Prohibited approach boundary © 2012 AVO Training Institute Arc Flash Study Kit | 9 training institute A Template for Soliciting Bids An Arc Flash Hazard Analysis is a complex project and we understand that you may need to compare multiple providers. Putting together a Request for Proposals can be time consuming. Based on our experience we’ve developed a template to help you avoid known problems that arise from incomplete RFP’s. This 14 page Arc Flash Hazard Analysis Request for Proposal template includes the following sections: ff Project Objective ff Provider Qualifications & Experience ff Detailed Scope of Work with Deliverables ff Pricing Criteria ff Evaluation Criteria If you need assistance customizing this RFP or have any questions regarding the contents, please contact Melanie Farley at Melanie.Farley@avotraining.com or 214.331.7318. Download the Word document www.avotraining.com/common/ documents/avotraining/RFP.doc Request Report & Label Sample It is always a good idea to request samples of the Arc Flash Hazard Analysis Report from each potential provider. While this Report is based on technical data, you need to ensure that the report uses language and formatting that will be easily understood by all relevant personnel. 10 | Arc Flash Study Kit Besides the results from each part of the study, the report should include: ff An executive summary with concise findings and recommendations ff The methodology used ff The input data used, including any assumptions in calculations ff Protective device time current curves We consider samples of our reports and one-line diagrams propriety information. For this reason, we will want to speak with you about your project before sending you samples. Contact Melanie Farley Direct: 214.331.7318 1.877.594.3156 Melanie.Farley@avotraining.com Fax 214.331.7363 www.avotraining.com/eed electrical engineering division Arc Flash Questionnaire The duration and cost of your arc flash project is directly related to the size and complexity of your power sytem. However, many facilities don’t have up-to-date one line diagrams. We can use the following information to quote your project. Please complete this page for each facility you would like quoted. Email it to Melanie.Farley@avotraining.com or fax it to 214.331.7363 to receive a proposal. Name: Facility: Company: Download the Word document www.avotraining.com/common/ documents/avotraining/AFQ.doc Phone: Email: Date: 1. How many three phase transformers do you have with a 480 volt secondary rating? What is the kva size of each transformer? 5. How many motor control centers do you have? How many buckets do you have in the motor control centers? Do not include spares. 2. How many three phase transformers do you have with a 208 volt secondary rating? What is the kva size of each transformer? 6. How many three phase bus ducts do you have? 3. How many three phase 480 volt panelboards, switchboards, etc. do you have? On average, how many three phase breakers are in them? Do not include spares. 7. How many bus plugs do you have in the bus ducts? 4. How many three phase 208 volt panelboards, switchboards, etc. do you have? On average, how many three phase breakers are in them? Do not include spares. 8. How many capacitors do you have? © 2012 AVO Training Institute Arc Flash Study Kit | 11 get access to the best arc flash expertise Melanie Farley National Sales Manager 1.877.594.3156, ext 7318 214.331.7318 Fax 214.331.7363 Melanie.Farley@avotraining.com electrical engineering division www.avotraining.com