Frequency Modulation
History of Frequency Modulation
Edwin Armstrong is most commonly known for
inventing frequency-modulated or FM radio in 1933.
Frequency modulation or FM improved the audio signal
of radio by controlling the noise static caused by
electrical equipment and the earth's atmosphere.
However, Edwin Armstrong should be known for
inventing three key innovations: regeneration,
superheterodyning, and frequency modulation.
What is Frequency Modulation?
Frequency modulation (FM) is the method of conveying
informations over a carrier wave by varying its frequency
and keeping amplitude constant.
Edwin Howard Armstrong
Concept of Frequency Modulation
Modulation is carried only as
?
variations in frequency. That is,
any signal level variations will not
affect the audio output.
?
FM wave is not affected to noise
and interference. So FM is used
for high quality broadcast
transmissions.
?
It is possible to apply the
modulation to a low power stage
of the transmitter, and it is not
necessary to use a linear form of
amplification to increase the
power level of the signal to its
final value.
?
For FM transmission, it is possible
to use non-linear RF amplifiers to
amplify FM signals in a
transmitter. This is more efficient
than the linear RF amplifier
Therefore, for a given power
output, less battery power is
required.
Carrier
Modulating Wave
Higher frequency,
shorter period when
modulating signal is
positive maximum
Features of FM Signals
Lower frequency,
longer period when
modulating signal is
negative cycle
Modulated Result
Learning
Disadvantages of Frequency Modulation
Requires more complicated demodulator and hence slightly more expensive than the very
simple diode detectors used for AM. Also requiring a tuned circuit adds cost.
Some other modes have higher data spectral efficiency: Some phase modulation and
quadrature amplitude modulation formats have a higher spectral efficiency for data
transmission that frequency shift keying, a form of frequency modulation.
Sidebands extend to infinity either side: The sidebands for an FM transmission theoretically
extend out to infinity. To limit the bandwidth of the transmission, filters are used, and these
introduce some distortion of the signal.
Block Diagram of Frequency Demodulation
Input
Signal
Vin
¦
in
Phase Detector
or Comparator
Error Voltage Vin
¦
in + ¦
out
Low-Pass
Filter
V¦ DC
¦
out
Amplifier
¦
in - ¦
out
Output
Signal
Amplified Audio Signal
Voltage
Controlled
Oscillator, VCD
V0
The PLL detector uses PLL technology to demodulate FM signals. The diagram below shows a
simple PLL detector. The phase detector compares the phase of the FM input and the VCO
output. Frequency deviation of the carrier results in a phase difference between the two and
the phase detector sends an error voltage to the low pass filter. The filtered error signal is
used to change the VCO output frequency in order to reduce the phase error. The output of
the low pass filter has an amplitude that is proportional to the deviation of the FM input, so it
is actually a replica of the original modulating signal. FM is converted directly to audio.
Frequency
Modulated signal
Modulator (FM)
Radio Frequency
Power Amplifier
Radio Frequency
Generator
Advantages of Frequency Modulation
Resilient to noise: Reduction in noise. As most noise is amplitude based, this can be removed
by running the signal through a limiter so that only frequency variations appear. This is
provided that the signal level is sufficiently high to allow the signal to be limited. Resilient to
signal strength variations: It makes FM ideal for use in mobile applications where signal levels
constantly vary. This is provided that the signal level is sufficiently high to allow the signal to be
limited.
Does not require linear amplifiers in the transmitter: As only frequency changes are required
to be carried. Enables greater efficiency than many other modes.
0.5
fm
For small values of modulation index,
when using narrow-band FM, FM signal
consists of the carrier and the two
sidebands spaced at the modulation
frequency either side of the carrier. This
looks to be the same as an AM signal,
but the difference is that the lower
sideband is out of phase by 180 degrees.
As the modulation index increases it is
found that other sidebands at twice the
modulation frequency start to appear.
As the index is increased further other
sidebands can also be seen.
1
2
4
Bandwidth of a Frequency Modulated Signal
In the case of an amplitude modulated signal the bandwidth required is twice the
maximum frequency of the modulation. Whilst the same is true for a narrowband FM
signal, the situation is not true for a wideband FM signal. Here the required bandwidth can
be very much larger, with detectable sidebands spreading out over large amounts of the
frequency spectrum. Usually it is necessary to limit the bandwidth of a signal so that it does
not unduly interfere with stations either side. As a frequency modulated signal has
sidebands that extend out to infinity, it is normal accepted practice to determine the
bandwidth as that which contains approximately 98% of the signal power. Normally the
bandwidth of a wideband FM signal is limited to the Carson's Rule limit - this reduces
interference and does not introduce any undue distortion of the signal. In other words for a
VHF FM broadcast station this must be (2 x 75) + 15 kHz, i.e. 175 kHz. In view of this a total of
200 kHz is usually allowed, enabling stations to have a small guard band and their centre
frequencies on integral numbers of 100 kHz. A rule of thumb, often termed Carsons' Rule
states that 98% of the signal power is contained within a bandwidth equal to the deviation
frequency, plus the modulation frequency doubled, i.e.:
BT = 2 ( Ä f + fm)
FM Modulation Index
Audio Stage
Vc
Spectra of an FM signal with differing
levels of modulation index
Block Diagram of Frequency Modulation
Audio Signal
Relative Levels of Carrier
a n d S i d e b a n d s fo r a
Frequency Modulated
Signal
Vout
¦
out
Feedback path
M
The modulation index is equal to the ratio of the frequency deviation to the modulating
frequency. The modulation index will vary according to the frequency that is modulating the
transmitted carrier and the amount of deviation. However when designing a system it is
important to know the maximum permissible values. This is given by the deviation ratio and is
obtained by inserting the maximum values into the formula for the modulation index. D =
(Max deviation frequency) / (Max modulation frequency) For a VHF FM sound broadcast
transmitter the maximum deviation is 75 kHz and the maximum modulation frequency is 15
kHz giving a deviation ratio of 5.
Frequency modulation Bessel functions & sidebands. Any signal that is modulated produces
sidebands. In the case of an amplitude modulated signal they are easy to determine, but for
frequency modulation the situation is not quite as straightforward. They are dependent upon
the not only the deviation, but also the level of deviation, i.e. the modulation index M. The
total spectrum is an infinite series of discrete spectral components expressed by a complex
formula using Bessel functions of the first kind.
The total spectrum can be seen to consist of the carrier plus an infinite number of sidebands
spreading out on either side of the carrier at integral multiples of the modulating frequency.
The relative levels of the sidebands can be obtained by referring to a table of Bessel functions.
It can be seen from the image below that the relative levels rise and fall according to the
different values of modulation index.
The bandwidth of a frequency modulated signal varies with both deviation and modulating
frequency. Increasing modulating frequency reduces modulation index - it reduces the
number of sidebands with significant amplitude and hence the bandwidth.
Increasing modulating frequency increases the frequency separation between sidebands.
The frequency modulation bandwidth increases with modulation frequency but it is not
directly proportional to it. Frequency modulation bandwidth is of importance as it is with
any other form of signal. With band occupancy growing, and pressure on spectrum space,
it is necessary to ensure the bandwidth of a frequency modulated signal falls within its
specified allowance. Any undue signal spread outside this is likely to cause interference to
other users.
Expressions for the frequency modulated signal:
vout = Ecc [w
sinw
mt]
ct + M¦
vout = Ecc
) [cos (w
J0 (M¦
) cos w
ct + J1 (M¦
c + w
m) t - cos (w
c- w
m)t]
+J2 (M¦
)[cos (w
+
2w
)t
+
cos
(w
2w
)t]
c
m
c
m
+J3 (M¦
)[cos (w
c + 3w
m)t - cos (w
c - 3w
m)t]+---
Even for sinusoidal modulation the number of side
frequency pairs is theoretically infinite. The Jn (M¦
)
functions are Bessel functions. Amplitudes are in
peak volts.
Instantaneous frequency
¦
¦
cos w
i = ¦
c + D
mt Hz
¦
i is the instantaneous frequency [Hz]
¦
is the carrier frequency [Hz]
0
D
¦
is the frequency deviation [Hz]
Modulation index
The ratio of the frequency deviation to the modulating signal frequency.
Minimum bandwidth required
BWmm = 2n¦
m
w
m is the modulating signal frequency or
message signal [rad/s]
D
¦
M¦
=
¦
m
where n = M¦
+ 1 rounded to the next integer