Ahmed Blanco, Caylee Chunga, Branden Diniz,
Brittany Mowe, Bowei Wei
Advisors:
Jon Abraham
Barry Posterro
Overview
• What is an Economic Scenario Generator?
• Basics
─ Regime Switching (Markov Chains)
─ Inverse Transform Methods
• Calibration
─ Maximum Likelihood Estimation
─ Covariance Matrix
─ Cholesky Decomposition
• Our ESG
─ Differences
─ Results
─ Recommendations
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
What is an Economic Scenario
Generator?
• Model that simulates correlated returns of multiple assets
• Life Insurance
Companies
─ Asset Liability
Management
• Property and
Casualty Insurance
Companies
─ Dynamic Financial
Analysis
• Banks
─ Balance Sheet
Management
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Regime Switching (Markov Chains)
• A system of multiple states that switch based on fixed probabilities
• Growing regime and falling regime
• Movement between states is determined by random numbers and an application of inverse transform method
Ending in
Regime 1
Ending in
Regime 2
Transition Matrix
Starting in
Regime 1
.8
Starting in
Regime 2
.65
.2
.35
1
1
2
2
…
Sample Regime Switching
Starting in
Regime
Random
Number
Ending in
Regime
.76998
1
.82837
2
.21792
2
.57101
1
… …
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Regime Switching (Markov Chains)
• A system of multiple states that switch based on fixed probabilities
• Growing regime and falling regime
• Movement between states is determined by random numbers and an application of inverse transform method
Ending in
Regime 1
Ending in
Regime 2
Transition Matrix
Starting in
Regime 1
.8
Starting in
Regime 2
.65
.2
.35
1
1
2
2
…
Sample Regime Switching
Starting in
Regime
Random
Number
Ending in
Regime
.76998 1
.82837
2
.21792
2
.57101
1
… …
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Regime Switching (Markov Chains)
• A system of multiple states that switch based on fixed probabilities
• Growing regime and falling regime
• Movement between states is determined by random numbers and an application of inverse transform method
Ending in
Regime 1
Ending in
Regime 2
Transition Matrix
Starting in
Regime 1
.8
Starting in
Regime 2
.65
.2
.35
1
1
2
2
…
Sample Regime Switching
Starting in
Regime
Random
Number
Ending in
Regime
.76998
1
.82837 2
.21792
2
.57101
1
… …
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
• For our model we need to generate normal random numbers to use as stock returns
• We convert a uniform random number, x, to have a normal distribution.
• We use the Inverse Transform Method.
• 𝑌 = 𝑋 𝑓𝑟𝑜𝑚 𝐸𝑥𝑐𝑒𝑙
∗ 𝜎 + 𝜇
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF) of the
Normal Distribution
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Inverse Transform Methods
(Continuous)
Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF) of the
Normal Distribution
Begin with a uniform random number on
(0,1) and use the Inverse
Transform method to develop a random number that is normally distributed.
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Inverse Transform Methods
(Continuous)
Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF) of the
Normal Distribution
0.80
µ=6 F -1 (0.8)=9
This is the random number in the Normal Distribution resulting from a uniform random number of 0.80
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Ending in
Regime 1
Ending in
Regime 2
Starting in
Regime 1
.8
.2
Starting in
Regime
2
2
1
1
…
Starting in
Regime 2
.65
.35
Random
Number for
Regime
.76998
.82837
.91732
.57101
…
Ending in
Regime
2
1
1
2
… 𝜇 𝜎
Regime 1 Regime 2
.05
-.02
.01
.05
Random
Number for
Return
.65868
.27794
.35738
.66318
…
Transformed
Number
.05660
.02139
.02179
.04371
…
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Ending in
Regime 1
Ending in
Regime 2
Starting in
Regime 1
.8
.2
Starting in
Regime
2
2
1
1
…
Starting in
Regime 2
.65
.35
Random
Number for
Regime
.76998
.82837
.91732
.57101
…
Ending in
Regime
2
1
1
2
… 𝜇 𝜎
Regime 1 Regime 2
.05
-.02
.01
.05
Random
Number for
Return
.65868
.27794
.35738
.66318
…
Transformed
Number
.05660
.02139
.02179
.04371
…
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Ending in
Regime 1
Ending in
Regime 2
Starting in
Regime 1
.8
.2
Starting in
Regime
2
2
1
1
…
Starting in
Regime 2
.65
.35
Random
Number for
Regime
.76998
.82837
.91732
.57101
…
Ending in
Regime
2
1
1
2
… 𝜇 𝜎
Regime 1 Regime 2
.05
-.02
.01
.05
Random
Number for
Return
.65868
.27794
.35738
.66318
…
Transformed
Number
.05660
.02139
.02179
.04371
…
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• Definition: A method of estimating the parameters of a model given data.
─ In other words, finding the values of the parameter set with the highest probability of resulting in the observations.
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• For regime switching with 2 regimes, there are 6 parameters:
─ 𝜇
1
& 𝜇
2
─ 𝜎
1
& 𝜎
2
─ 𝑝
1,2
- Means for Regime 1 & 2
- Standard deviations for Regime 1 & 2
- Probability of starting in Regime 1 and ending in 2
─ 𝑝
2,1
- Probability of starting in Regime 2 and Ending in 1
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• Invariant probabilities 𝜋
1
= 𝑝
2,1 𝑝
1,2
+𝑝
2,1 𝜋
2
= 𝑝
1,2 𝑝
1,2
+𝑝
2,1
• Normal pdfs 𝜙
𝑋−𝜇
1 𝜎
1 𝜙
𝑋−𝜇
2 𝜎
2
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• We multiply the invariant by the normal… 𝜋
1
∗ 𝜙
𝑋−𝜇
1 𝜎
1
2
𝑋−𝜇
2 𝜎
2
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• Then add these to get the first pdf value 𝜋
1
∗ 𝜙
𝑋−𝜇
1 𝜎
1
2
𝑋−𝜇
2 𝜎
2
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• Now we begin the recursion…
Currently in Regime 1 Currently in Regime 2
Previously in R1 Previously in R2 Previously in R1 Previously in R2
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• Probability of being in the previous regime
─ Regime 1’s contribution to the pdf
𝑃. 𝑅. 1 𝑝
1,1
∗
𝑃𝐷𝐹
• Regime switching probability
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• Multiply by the normal pdf… 𝑝
1,1
∗
𝑃. 𝑅. 1
∗ 𝜙
𝑃𝐷𝐹
𝑋 − 𝜇 𝜎
1
1
= 𝑅𝑒𝑔𝑖𝑚𝑒 1,1 𝑝𝑑𝑓
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• Now in Regime 1, Previously in Regime 2 𝑝
2,1
∗
𝑃. 𝑅. 2
𝑃𝐷𝐹
∗ 𝜙
𝑋 − 𝜇 𝜎
1
1
= 𝑅𝑒𝑔𝑖𝑚𝑒 2,1 𝑝𝑑𝑓
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• Now in Regime 2, Previously in Regime 1 𝑝
1,2
∗
𝑃. 𝑅. 1
𝑃𝐷𝐹
∗ 𝜙
𝑋 − 𝜇 𝜎
2
2
= 𝑅𝑒𝑔𝑖𝑚𝑒 1,2 𝑝𝑑𝑓
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• Now in Regime 2, Previously in Regime 2 𝑝
2,2
∗
𝑃. 𝑅. 2
∗ 𝜙
𝑃𝐷𝐹
𝑋 − 𝜇 𝜎
2
2
= 𝑅𝑒𝑔𝑖𝑚𝑒 2,2 𝑝𝑑𝑓
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• Estimated pdf values
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
• Natural log of estimated pdf values
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Calibration (Maximum Likelihood
Estimation)
Parameters which we solved for using Excel’s built-in “Solver”
Metric we maximized to by solving for the parameters
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Where Next?
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Covariance Matrix
• Definition: a matrix that depicts the covariance of an array of random variables relative to each other.
𝐶𝑜𝑣 𝑀𝑎𝑡𝑟𝑖𝑥 =
𝑉𝑎𝑟[𝑋
𝐶𝑜𝑣[𝑋
⋮
2
1
] 𝐶𝑜𝑣[𝑋
, 𝑋
1
⋮
1
, 𝑋
] 𝑉𝑎𝑟[𝑋
2
]
2
]
⋯
⋱
𝐶𝑜𝑣[𝑋
1
, 𝑋 𝑛
]
𝐶𝑜𝑣[𝑋
2
, 𝑋 𝑛
⋮
𝐶𝑜𝑣[𝑋 𝑛
, 𝑋
1
] 𝐶𝑜𝑣[𝑋 𝑛
, 𝑋
2
] ⋯ 𝑉𝑎𝑟[𝑋 𝑛
]
]
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Cholesky Decomposition
• Theorem: every symmetric positive definite matrix can be decomposed into a product of a unique lower triangular matrix (the Cholesky factor) and its transpose.
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Cholesky Example
0.015 0.009
A =
0.009 0.048
Decompose the matrix to get L and L T
L =
0.122
0 and L T =
0.122 0.073
0.073 0.206
0 0.206
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Cholesky Example
0.015 0.009
A =
0.009 0.048
Decompose the matrix to get L and L T
L =
0.122
0 and L T =
0.122 0.073
0.073 0.206
0 0.206
Stock 1 Stock 2
2.307
2.629
0.710
-0.796
1.614
-0.163
⋮ ⋮
-0.265
0.494
0.122 0.073
X
0 0.206
=
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Cholesky Example
0.015 0.009
A =
0.009 0.048
Decompose the matrix to get L and L T
L =
0.122
0 and L T =
0.122 0.073
0.073 0.206
0 0.206
Stock 1 Stock 2
2.307
2.629
0.710
-0.796
1.614
-0.163
⋮ ⋮
-0.265
0.494
0.122 0.073
X
0 0.206
=
Stock 1 Stock 2
0.283
0.712
0.087
-0.112
0.198
0.085
⋮ ⋮
-0.032
0.082
Covariance Matrix
0.015 0.009
0.009 0.048
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
The ESG
A
1
=
A
2
=
0.015 0.009
0.009 0.048
0.010 0.003
0.003 0.022
L
1
T =
L
2
T =
0.122
0.073
0 0.206
0.100
0.030
0 0.145
Regime Stock 1 Stock 2
⋮
2
1
1
2.307
0.710
1.614
⋮
2.629
-0.796
-0.163
⋮
2 -0.265
0.494
0.122 0.073
0 0.206
X OR =
0.100 0.030
0 0.145
Regime Stock 1 Stock 2
1
1
0.283
0.712
0.087
-0.112
⋮
2 0.161
0.025
⋮ ⋮
2 -0.027
0.064
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
The ESG
A
1
=
A
2
=
0.015 0.009
0.009 0.048
0.010 0.003
0.003 0.022
L
1
T =
L
2
T =
0.122
0.073
0 0.206
0.100
0.030
0 0.145
Regime Stock 1 Stock 2
⋮
2
1
1
2.307 2.629
0.710
-0.796
1.614
⋮
-0.163
⋮
2 -0.265
0.494
0.122 0.073
0 0.206
X OR =
0.100 0.030
0 0.145
Regime Stock 1 Stock 2
1
1
0.283 0.712
0.087
-0.112
⋮
2 0.161
0.025
⋮ ⋮
2 -0.027
0.064
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
The ESG
A
1
=
A
2
=
0.015 0.009
0.009 0.048
0.010 0.003
0.003 0.022
L
1
T =
L
2
T =
0.122
0.073
0 0.206
0.100
0.030
0 0.145
Regime Stock 1 Stock 2
⋮
2
1
1
2.307
2.629
0.710
-0.796
1.614 -0.163
⋮ ⋮
2 -0.265
0.494
0.122 0.073
0 0.206
X OR =
0.100 0.030
0 0.145
Regime Stock 1 Stock 2
⋮
2
1
1
0.283
0.087
0.712
-0.112
0.161 0.025
⋮ ⋮
2 -0.027
0.064
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Our ESG
• Uses 3 regimes instead of 2
─ 3 rd regime represents an economic crash and occurs rarely
─ µ
3
, σ
3
, third Covariance Matrix
• Uses 10 Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)
─ ETFs track groups of stocks
• Outputs Daily Returns
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Regime 1 μ
1
Parameter μ
1
Simulation σ
1
Parameter σ
1
Simulation
SPY 0.00080
0.00079
0.00751
0.00726
VXX -0.00679
-0.00674
0.02517
0.03496
EFA 0.00064
0.00063
0.00899
0.00987
OIL 0.00004
0.00004
0.01466
0.01812
FEZ 0.00057
0.00055
0.01259
0.01379
EEM 0.00028
0.00027
0.01138
0.01149
HYG 0.00015
0.00015
0.00328
0.00409
TLT -0.00005
-0.00006
0.01210
0.00871
IWM -0.00043
-0.00045
0.02431
0.01007
GLD -0.00034
-0.00033
0.01474
0.01019
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Results: Covariance Difference
Simulated Covariance Matrix
Regime
1
SPY VXX EFA OIL FEZ EEM HYG TLT IWM GLD
SPY 0.000053 -0.000191 0.000060 0.000047 0.000080 0.000065 0.000017 -0.000025 0.000064 0.000008
VXX -0.000191 0.001222 -0.000223 -0.000145 -0.000297 -0.000232 -0.000068 0.000092 -0.000241 -0.000021
EFA 0.000060 -0.000223 0.000097 0.000071 0.000125 0.000093 0.000022 -0.000029 0.000073 0.000023
OIL 0.000047 -0.000145 0.000071 0.000328 0.000090 0.000084 0.000020 -0.000035 0.000060 0.000053
FEZ 0.000080 -0.000297 0.000125 0.000090 0.000190 0.000116 0.000028 -0.000042 0.000095 0.000024
EEM 0.000065 -0.000232 0.000093 0.000084 0.000116 0.000132 0.000024 -0.000028 0.000080 0.000030
HYG 0.000017 -0.000068 0.000022 0.000020 0.000028 0.000024 0.000017 -0.000004 0.000021 0.000006
TLT -0.000025 0.000092 -0.000029 -0.000035 -0.000042 -0.000028 -0.000004 0.000076 -0.000029 0.000010
IWM 0.000064 -0.000241 0.000073 0.000060 0.000095 0.000080 0.000021 -0.000029 0.000101 0.000013
GLD 0.000008 -0.000021 0.000023 0.000053 0.000024 0.000030 0.000006 0.000010 0.000013 0.000104
Actual Covariance Matrix
Regime
1
SPY VXX EFA OIL FEZ EEM HYG TLT IWM GLD
SPY 0.000053 -0.000191 0.000060 0.000047 0.000080 0.000065 0.000017 -0.000025 0.000064 0.000008
VXX -0.000191 0.001224 -0.000224 -0.000146 -0.000298 -0.000233 -0.000068 0.000092 -0.000241 -0.000021
EFA 0.000060 -0.000224 0.000097 0.000070 0.000125 0.000093 0.000022 -0.000029 0.000073 0.000023
OIL 0.000047 -0.000146 0.000070 0.000328 0.000090 0.000084 0.000020 -0.000035 0.000060 0.000053
FEZ 0.000080 -0.000298 0.000125 0.000090 0.000190 0.000116 0.000028 -0.000042 0.000095 0.000024
EEM 0.000065 -0.000233 0.000093 0.000084 0.000116 0.000132 0.000024 -0.000028 0.000080 0.000030
HYG 0.000017 -0.000068 0.000022 0.000020 0.000028 0.000024 0.000017 -0.000004 0.000021 0.000005
TLT -0.000025 0.000092 -0.000029 -0.000035 -0.000042 -0.000028 -0.000004 0.000076 -0.000029 0.000010
IWM 0.000064 -0.000241 0.000073 0.000060 0.000095 0.000080 0.000021 -0.000029 0.000101 0.000013
GLD 0.000008 -0.000021 0.000023 0.000053 0.000024 0.000030 0.000005 0.000010 0.000013 0.000104
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Results: Covariance Difference
Simulated Covariance Matrix
Regime
1
SPY VXX EFA OIL FEZ EEM HYG TLT IWM GLD
SPY 0.000053 -0.000191 0.000060 0.000047 0.000080 0.000065 0.000017 -0.000025 0.000064 0.000008
VXX -0.000191 0.001222 -0.000223 -0.000145 -0.000297 -0.000232 -0.000068 0.000092 -0.000241 -0.000021
EFA 0.000060 -0.000223 0.000097 0.000071 0.000125 0.000093 0.000022 -0.000029 0.000073 0.000023
OIL 0.000047 -0.000145 0.000071 0.000328 0.000090 0.000084 0.000020 -0.000035 0.000060 0.000053
FEZ 0.000080 -0.000297 0.000125 0.000090 0.000190 0.000116 0.000028 -0.000042 0.000095 0.000024
EEM 0.000065 -0.000232 0.000093 0.000084 0.000116 0.000132 0.000024 -0.000028 0.000080 0.000030
HYG 0.000017 -0.000068 0.000022 0.000020 0.000028 0.000024 0.000017 -0.000004 0.000021 0.000006
TLT -0.000025 0.000092 -0.000029 -0.000035 -0.000042 -0.000028 -0.000004 0.000076 -0.000029 0.000010
IWM 0.000064 -0.000241 0.000073 0.000060 0.000095 0.000080 0.000021 -0.000029 0.000101 0.000013
GLD 0.000008 -0.000021 0.000023 0.000053 0.000024 0.000030 0.000006 0.000010 0.000013 0.000104
Actual Covariance Matrix
Regime
1
SPY VXX EFA OIL FEZ EEM HYG TLT IWM GLD
SPY 0.000053 -0.000191 0.000060 0.000047 0.000080 0.000065 0.000017 -0.000025 0.000064 0.000008
VXX -0.000191 0.001224 -0.000224 -0.000146 -0.000298 -0.000233 -0.000068 0.000092 -0.000241 -0.000021
EFA 0.000060 -0.000224 0.000097 0.000070 0.000125 0.000093 0.000022 -0.000029 0.000073 0.000023
OIL 0.000047 -0.000146 0.000070 0.000328 0.000090 0.000084 0.000020 -0.000035 0.000060 0.000053
FEZ 0.000080 -0.000298 0.000125 0.000090 0.000190 0.000116 0.000028 -0.000042 0.000095 0.000024
EEM 0.000065 -0.000233 0.000093 0.000084 0.000116 0.000132 0.000024 -0.000028 0.000080 0.000030
HYG 0.000017 -0.000068 0.000022 0.000020 0.000028 0.000024 0.000017 -0.000004 0.000021 0.000005
TLT -0.000025 0.000092 -0.000029 -0.000035 -0.000042 -0.000028 -0.000004 0.000076 -0.000029 0.000010
IWM 0.000064 -0.000241 0.000073 0.000060 0.000095 0.000080 0.000021 -0.000029 0.000101 0.000013
GLD 0.000008 -0.000021 0.000023 0.000053 0.000024 0.000030 0.000005 0.000010 0.000013 0.000104
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Results: Covariance Difference
Simulated Covariance Matrix
Regime
1
SPY VXX EFA OIL FEZ EEM HYG TLT IWM GLD
SPY 0.000053 -0.000191 0.000060 0.000047 0.000080 0.000065 0.000017 -0.000025 0.000064 0.000008
VXX -0.000191 0.001222 -0.000223 -0.000145 -0.000297 -0.000232 -0.000068 0.000092 -0.000241 -0.000021
EFA 0.000060 -0.000223 0.000097 0.000071 0.000125 0.000093 0.000022 -0.000029 0.000073 0.000023
OIL 0.000047 -0.000145 0.000071 0.000328 0.000090 0.000084 0.000020 -0.000035 0.000060 0.000053
FEZ 0.000080 -0.000297 0.000125 0.000090 0.000190 0.000116 0.000028 -0.000042 0.000095 0.000024
EEM 0.000065 -0.000232 0.000093 0.000084 0.000116 0.000132 0.000024 -0.000028 0.000080 0.000030
HYG 0.000017 -0.000068 0.000022 0.000020 0.000028 0.000024 0.000017 -0.000004 0.000021 0.000006
TLT -0.000025 0.000092 -0.000029 -0.000035 -0.000042 -0.000028 -0.000004 0.000076 -0.000029 0.000010
IWM 0.000064 -0.000241 0.000073 0.000060 0.000095 0.000080 0.000021 -0.000029 0.000101 0.000013
GLD 0.000008 -0.000021 0.000023 0.000053 0.000024 0.000030 0.000006 0.000010 0.000013 0.000104
Actual Covariance Matrix
Regime
1
SPY VXX EFA OIL FEZ EEM HYG TLT IWM GLD
SPY 0.000053 -0.000191 0.000060 0.000047 0.000080 0.000065 0.000017 -0.000025 0.000064 0.000008
VXX -0.000191 0.001224 -0.000224 -0.000146 -0.000298 -0.000233 -0.000068 0.000092 -0.000241 -0.000021
EFA 0.000060 -0.000224 0.000097 0.000070 0.000125 0.000093 0.000022 -0.000029 0.000073 0.000023
OIL 0.000047 -0.000146 0.000070 0.000328 0.000090 0.000084 0.000020 -0.000035 0.000060 0.000053
FEZ 0.000080 -0.000298 0.000125 0.000090 0.000190 0.000116 0.000028 -0.000042 0.000095 0.000024
EEM 0.000065 -0.000233 0.000093 0.000084 0.000116 0.000132 0.000024 -0.000028 0.000080 0.000030
HYG 0.000017 -0.000068 0.000022 0.000020 0.000028 0.000024 0.000017 -0.000004 0.000021 0.000005
TLT -0.000025 0.000092 -0.000029 -0.000035 -0.000042 -0.000028 -0.000004 0.000076 -0.000029 0.000010
IWM 0.000064 -0.000241 0.000073 0.000060 0.000095 0.000080 0.000021 -0.000029 0.000101 0.000013
GLD 0.000008 -0.000021 0.000023 0.000053 0.000024 0.000030 0.000005 0.000010 0.000013 0.000104
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Recommendations
• Create a user-friendly interface
• Alternative platforms
─ Matlab would allow implementation on the WPI supercomputer
• Output results to a .txt file
─ Avoids Excel’s row limitations
• Introduce an automatic results checker
• More experimentation with regime 3
• Improve run time
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Appendix I – Our 3 rd Regime
• Mean:
─ Twice the mean of Regime 2
• Standard Deviation:
─ .5 times the Std. Dev. of Regime 2
• Covariance:
─ .5 times the Covariances of Regime 2
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Appendix II – Mean & St. Dev.
Differences
Results: Mean & St. Dev. Difference With Differences
Regime 1 μ
1
Parameter μ
1
Simulation Differences σ
1
Parameter σ
1
Simulation Differences
SPY 0.00080
0.00079
7.37E-06 0.00751
0.00726
-0.00024
VXX -0.00679
-0.00674
-4.2E-05 0.02517
0.03496
0.009786
EFA 0.00064
0.00063
1.11E-05 0.00899
0.00987
0.000874
OIL 0.00004
0.00004
-6E-06 0.01466
0.01812
0.003458
FEZ 0.00057
0.00055
1.7E-05 0.01259
0.01379
0.001194
EEM 0.00028
0.00027
1.07E-05 0.01138
0.01149
0.000107
HYG 0.00015
0.00015
4.33E-07 0.00328
0.00409
0.000821
TLT -0.00005
-0.00006
4.95E-06 0.01210
0.00871
-0.0034
IWM -0.00043
-0.00045
1.24E-05 0.02431
0.01007
-0.01424
GLD -0.00034
-0.00033
-7.5E-06 0.01474
0.01019
-0.00455
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Appendix III – Covariance
Differences
Regime 1
SPY
VXX
EFA
OIL
FEZ
EEM
HYG
TLT
IWM
GLD
SPY VXX EFA OIL FEZ EEM HYG TLT IWM GLD
0.00000004 0.00000024 0.00000004 0.00000010 0.00000001 0.00000001 0.00000000 0.00000001 0.00000001 0.00000020
0.00000024 0.00000151 0.00000051 0.00000013 0.00000095 0.00000049 0.00000007 0.00000039 0.00000037 0.00000014
0.00000004 0.00000051 0.00000008 0.00000025 0.00000007 0.00000002 0.00000002 0.00000003 0.00000000 0.00000022
0.00000010 0.00000013 0.00000025 0.00000050 0.00000057 0.00000002 0.00000001 0.00000002 0.00000011 0.00000019
0.00000001 0.00000095 0.00000007 0.00000057 0.00000006 0.00000001 0.00000001 0.00000000 0.00000005 0.00000032
0.00000001 0.00000049 0.00000002 0.00000002 0.00000001 0.00000008 0.00000006 0.00000001 0.00000000 0.00000021
0.00000000 0.00000007 0.00000002 0.00000001 0.00000001 0.00000006 0.00000001 0.00000007 0.00000002 0.00000007
0.00000001 0.00000039 0.00000003 0.00000002 0.00000000 0.00000001 0.00000007 0.00000001 0.00000016 0.00000010
0.00000001 0.00000037 0.00000000 0.00000011 0.00000005 0.00000000 0.00000002 0.00000016 0.00000003 0.00000025
0.00000020 0.00000014 0.00000022 0.00000019 0.00000032 0.00000021 0.00000007 0.00000010 0.00000025 0.00000007
Minimum: 1.81E-09
Maximum: 1.5E-06
Worcester Polytechnic Institute
Appendix IV – ETFs Used
ETF/ETN
Underlying
Index/
Commodity
SPY
S&P 500
Features of the Index
Largest 500
U.S. companies
IWM
Russel 2000
Smallest 2000 companies in the Russel
3000 index of small-cap equities
TLT HYG
Barclays U.S.
20+ Year
Treasury
Bonds
U.S. Treasury
Bonds that will not reach maturity for twenty or more years
Markit iBoxx
USD Liquid
High Yield
High yield corporate bonds for sale in the U.S.
GLD
Gold bullions spot price
Bars of gold with a purity of
99.5% or higher
ETF/ETN EFA VXX OIL FEZ EEM
Underlying
Index/
Commodity
MSCI EAFE
Features of the Index
Large-cap and medium-cap equities
S&P 500 VIX
Short-Term
Futures
S&P GSCI
Crude Oil Total
Return
CBOE Volatility
Index which measures the volatility of
S&P 500 futures
Returns of oil futures contracts with
West Texas
Intermediate
EURO STOXX
50
50 of the largest and most liquid
Eurozone stocks
MSCI Emerging
Markets
Medium-cap and large-cap equities from emerging markets
Worcester Polytechnic Institute