Guides for Learning & Teaching: Session Design & Planning in 9 steps 1 Centre for Professional Learning and Development Guides for Learning and Teaching Session Design and Planning in 9 steps Introduction This guide contains information to help you design and plan (and ultimately deliver!) successful sessions. Each of the 9 steps shown below is explained in more detail in the sections, which follow to identify: The purpose and benefits of each step for you and your students Questions to consider in each step Where you can find further guidance to help you at each step Step 1 Decide the purpose of your session Step 2 Design learning activities aligned appropriately to the intended learning outcomes Step 3 Identify how you will monitor your students’ learning in the session Step 4 Identify how and when you will evaluate the effectiveness of your session Step 5 Schedule your session’s running order & timings Step 6 Identify the resources you will need to deliver the session Step 7 Source and check those resources Step 8 Identify risks and their impact on your session’s success Step 9 Create your contingency plan for times when those key things go wrong Creating a session plan is ideal as it avoids you having to start from scratch each time you deliver the session. It makes the session explicit and so can be used by others in your absence. See the CPLD Guide to Using and Creating Session Plans for further guidance. How this guide relates to the UKPSF and NTU Professional Standards for Teaching and Supporting Learning in HE Areas of Activity Areas of Core Knowledge (Ks) Professional Values (Vs) 2 A1, A2 K2, K3 V3 Step 1 Determine the purpose of your session Why? For you as tutor: Provides a clear focal point for designing the session content Provides a measure or benchmark against which you evaluate your session’s impact – were you and your students able to achieve what was intended? For your students: Provides valuable information to your students to help them understand what to expect from the session, and what’s expected of them. Provides a benchmark against which your students can assess for themselves their knowledge prior to the session - ‘where am I now?/what do I already know? They can use the same benchmark to monitor and assess their progress during and after the session – helps give them feedback, and information to help judge what they have learned. That’s one of the factors which supports learning. How? By defining the aim of the session By defining what you intend the students to learn by the end of the session (the learning outcomes) By defining how your session relates to others in a series such as a module or programme Useful questions to consider: Is this a stand-alone session or part of a module or course? If the latter, do I know how does it fit with the wider module and/or course? If not, how can I find out? What is my overall aim in providing the session? What do I want the students to be able to ‘do’, ‘know’, or ‘be’ as a result of completing the session? – which bits of the module learning outcomes does this session address? How am I going to enable the students to understand the purpose of the session? Information you will need to get started: If your session is part of a module or wider programme, you will need the module aims and learning outcomes to determine how the session fits in with those. It isn’t expected that every session will have to address all the learning outcomes of a module, but it is important to know which ones you are expected to address so you can mirror those in your session’s aims and outcomes. Have the aims and learning outcomes for your session already been written? If the aims and learning outcomes already exist, are they appropriate and do they align with the rest of the module. If not, what changes can you discuss with the module or programme leader to help? Further guidance: Your course team colleagues Course and module specification – for learning outcomes CPLD Guide to Writing Learning Outcomes NTU Quality Handbook via the CADQ website 3 Step 2 Design learning activities aligned appropriately to the intended learning outcomes Why? For you as a tutor: To improve your chances of selecting methods and approaches appropriately aligned to the learning outcomes. To focus your attention when designing sessions onto what your students are doing rather than on what you like to do. For your students: You help improve their chances of learning what you intended them to. Useful questions to consider: What teaching methods could I use to teach the topic? Which methods will actively engage my students in the learning process? Have I selected the best methods for learning what’s set out in the intended learning outcomes? How? Use the action verbs in the learning outcomes to guide your design of learning activities – make sure what you get the students to do and practise is what’s defined in the learning outcomes. For instance, if your students need to learn to evaluate, the session activities should enable them to learn how to evaluate and practise it. Avoid selecting a method just because it’s how you like to learn. Go for methods, which have the best chance of enabling the students to get actively engaged in learning. Avoid extremes of variety in your methods – either too much or too little! Search around in open learning resources and ask colleagues what they do. This will help inspire ideas and help you create a bit of variety to meet your learners’ different learning preferences. Stay critical though – are they using methods which support active engagement? Observe more experienced colleagues (both within and outside your discipline for inspiration – but observe critically. Are there methods actively engaging the students in learning? Are the students achieving the learning outcomes? Ask them why they chose to teach the way they do – sometimes, a method is used because of familiarity rather than for its effectiveness at supporting learning. Ask your students for ideas on how they’d like to learn a subject. Experiment and evaluate – don’t give up on something first time you use it! Students take time to understand a new method. Explain your methods to students and evaluate critically! Further guidance: CPLD Guide to Designing for Active Learning to help you select learning methods, which support deeper, rather than superficial learning. 4 Step 3 Why? Identify how you will monitor your students’ learning in the session It’s easy to be so focused on what we’re doing as tutors, that we forget to consider what our students are doing, and what progress they are making towards achieving the intended learning outcomes. This is often be left until formal summative assessment, yet we can build formative feedback activities into our sessions that provide them and us with timely information about understanding and progress. For you as tutor: Provides you with information to help you gauge the extent to which your session is working for your students – are they learning what you intended them to learn? Prompts us to focus on our students’ learning rather than our teaching. Helps us focus on impact rather than just delivering content. Provides valuable information to inform future session content, and the evaluation of your sessions. For your students: Can help them learn how to evaluate and monitor their own progress and learning. Can encourage them to become more independent learners. Helps them become more aware of their own progress and help them target areas needing extra work and study. Useful questions to consider: What methods can I use to monitor student progress and learning? Are there some methods that are quicker and easier to use than others? Which methods are easy to use with large numbers of students? How? The following 7 ideas are adapted from ‘53 Interesting Things to Do in Your Lecture’ 1992 (4th edition) by Graham Gibbs, and Sue & Trevor Habeshaw. The instant feedback questionnaire in which you provide a number of statements students can respond to in terms of how well they understand them. You can use in-class voting systems that now provide the anonymised results on the screen, so student get feedback about their performance in relation to others in the class without any individual having to be identified. The ‘3 most important things’ in which you ask your students to list on a scrap of paper or post-it notes (or on-line if you have access to the technology), the 3 most important things from today’s session, and get them to leave you with those with you. It’s fascinating to see how others interpret what’s important, and you can use this information to provide feedback or recap important learning points from the session. There are many alternatives you could ask, including ‘ the most important message I took from today’s session is..’ and ‘the one thing I am struggling to understand is…’. The ‘one-minute paper’ in which you ask your students to write anonymously non-stop for one minute on anything they have learned from the session without worrying about punctuation, grammar, structure, order etc. – they just randomly write things down as they occur to them. Gather 5 these in and look through them to compare the range of learning from the session. Start with a test – this can enable you to judge how much has been retained form previous sessions or let’s you find out the level of understanding and knowledge about a new topic. It can also help re-focus students’ attention and helps them settle into the session. Finish with a test – to let you round off a session and provide you and your students with important feedback about how much they have understood and learned. You could use hand-outs, online tests, on screen questions with answers that are revealed as you go etc. Spot test – at any point during the session, or in any session to help maintain that element of surprise. Usually very brief and help provide a brief interlude during a session to refocus attention. ‘Are there any questions?’ – the one we probably instinctively rely on the most! But as Gibbs and colleagues point out “it is so routinely ineffective that it has come to mean ‘That’s all for today’.” (1994, p143). Students often need time to reflect on what they want to ask, or are too busy note-taking to have time to think about the real questions they need to ask. Or, they may just be too busy packing up, or think the tutor doesn’t really mean it, or feel too awkward to ask in front of a large group. Questions can be more effective if the following are done: Provide a pause of several minutes for students to work in small groups to create a question – this prevents them from feeling isolated in asking the question Ask them to swop questions with another group – and try to answer them Then any they can’t answer – say you’ll be asking a couple of the groups to read those unanswered questions out to the whole group. 6 Step 4 Identify how and when you will evaluate the success of your session Why? For you as tutor: To enable you to know if you’re doing the right thing – to what extent are your teaching methods helping your students learn what’s intended? To help you establish an important dialogue with your students that can help you share your expectations of each other, and clarify the purpose of the sessions. To enable you to contribute to the Programme and Module evaluation. For your students: To provide them with an opportunity to give feedback to the module team about the teaching on the course. Useful questions to consider: What criteria should I use to judge my session as effective? What are the most sustainable ways of sourcing information to enable me to evaluate the effectiveness of my sessions? When should I evaluate my sessions? How? Use learning outcomes as benchmarks against which to evaluate progress– the effectiveness of any session should be judged by how well the students have learned what was intended as a result of participating in the session. Evaluate the extent to which your methods encouraged active rather than passive learning. Reflect on the extent to which the factors, which support successful learning are reflected in your methods. Evaluate your students’ reactions to the methods used – what do they think helped them learn and why? What was less helpful and why? Further guidance: Find ideas for designing active learning activities in CPLD Guide to designing for Active Learning Find ideas about using quizzes in various forms and media in the CPLD ‘Guide to Using Quizzes to Assess Student Learning’. 7 Step 5 Schedule your session’s running order & timings Why? For you as a tutor: To give you confidence that all the planned activities will fit the time available To enable you to identify when you need to re-think the amount of content To use as a guide when you are delivering the session – helps you keep on track To minimise the risk of things not going to plan on the day and undermining the success of your session and your own confidence To help you clarify with your students what they can expect from your sessions. For your students: They know what to expect in the sessions To help maintain their confidence in you as an effective tutor They don’t get overloaded with too much and risk missing out on the important items. Useful questions to consider: In relation to my content, what must be done/could be done if time/ is not essential to be done Do I know how long things take in reality? Have I allowed sufficient time for each activity in the session? What should I leave in and what should I leave out? How should I sequence the segments/activities of my session? How? Use a session template adapted to meet your needs to make it easy to capture your session plan information, and to prompt you to consider important details. By sequencing content and activities to fit time available in a coherent and logical sequence. By remembering to leave time for you and your students to arrive and leave the session, and set up and settle. As a guide, fill no more than 40-45 minutes of every hour. Remember NTU etiquette - start any session 5 minutes after advertised time and finish 5 minutes before advertised time to allow time for students to arrive/settle/leave to get to next session. In sessions longer than an hour, build in 10 minutes for comfort break. Remembering that introductions, summing-up and any Q&A, or discussions are also activities – part of the content that needs to be scheduled. Otherwise, you run out of time. Further guidance: Use the session template provided to help you plan – or design/adapt one that works for you. See CPLD Guide to Using Session Templates in your Session Planning. 8 Step 6 Identify the resources you will need to deliver the session Why? For you as a tutor: To plan ahead and be well prepared – this builds your own confidence. To check you have a viable session. To minimise disruption during the session. To enable you to make the students aware of any prep required for the sessions. To maintain your students’ confidence in you as a tutor. For your students: To ensure they are sufficiently prepared and informed so they can participate fully in the session. Useful questions to consider: What does each activity/part of my session require in terms of resources? What do I need my students to prepare and/or bring to the session? How can I ensure they understand what’s required of them? Do I know what teaching room has been booked and what is available in that room? Will I require my students to do any follow-up after the session – and if so, what resources do I need to provide for that? Have I identified resources that can be used by all my students? – or do I need alternatives? (for instance for students with visual or hearing impairment, learning difficulties such as dyslexia) How? List the resources required in your session plan - that way, you don’t have to rethink it next time you run the session; and if you are ill, useful for anyone covering your session. Consider resources as anything from pens, pencils, post-it notes, paper, flip chat paper, slides, visual aids, briefing papers or info for different tasks, activity briefing sheets, artefacts, voting handsets, and handouts. Consider non-digital as well as digital resources. Aim for the most sustainable ones (ie cost-effective to produce, green, ones that minimise your time to create). Identify anything you need to make yourself. Identify anything you can re-use/re-purpose from open resources available for anyone to use Further guidance: An important issue is to ensure that all your resources are fully accessible and appropriate to all your students. See the information provided on Making Resources Accessible and Inclusive. A starting point for using and reusing open electronic resources in your teaching sessions can be found in the NTU Using Technology in Learning and 9 Teaching Learning Room on the Staff tab in NOW: look for the ‘Delivering online content’ section. There is a Guide to AV equipment in all NTU teaching rooms on the Information Services’ website – it also contains instructions on using the equipment To book AV equipment for a room that doesn’t contain AV, please contact: E-mail City Campus: SOS AV City Clifton Campus: SOS AV Clifton Brackenhurst Campus: SOS AV Brackenhurst. Please remember to give them at least 24 hours notice, thanks. Teaching room bookings are handled centrally within the Academic Office – to book a teaching room, email regroomrequests@ntu.ac.uk (Check with your academic admin for local arrangements for academic teams in your School). Room Bookings have also added the following information: Please note that if you require the partitions to be moved in a room you will need to raise a request through the Badger system. Hospitality. Can be arranged at http://www.ntu.ac.uk/hospitality/. Note that catering is not permitted in rooms other than those designated specifically for meetings, further exceptions are detailed on the hospitality link above. Please be sure to book an additional room for catering if required. E-mail: CATrequests@ntu.ac.uk Ext: (0115 848) 2393 Audio/Visual Equipment. If you have specific requirements please check this is available in the room you have requested or have been allocated. To request audio/visual equipment please contact. E-mail City Campus: SOS AV City Clifton Campus: SOS AV Clifton Brackenhurst Campus: SOS AV Brackenhurst Please note SOS AV require at least 24 hours notice to check and confirm any request. Room Feedback. For any queries regarding room layout, furniture and general health & safety issues about this room. E-mail: mailto:AAO.gptfeedback@ntu.ac.ukExt: (0115 848) 2933 10 Step 7 Source and check those resources Why? For you as a tutor: To enable you to identify any resource constraints and whether you can overcome those, or need to go back and revise your original session plans. To help avoid the stress from leaving things till the last minute. To enable you to find time-efficient ways of preparing resources for your sessions. To use and source resources which all your students can use. For your students: To enable them to be sufficiently prepared to participate fully in the session. To have access to resources they can use. Useful questions to consider: Have any of my students, particular learning needs which will impact on the type of resources they can use? For any resource, what alternatives are available? What do I need to do to create/source accessible and inclusive resources? Other than my students, what other significant resource constraints do I have to take into account? Can I overcome any significant constraints and how? Are there open resources available that I can use in my sessions rather than have to re-create them from scratch? If there are no alternative resources, how could I adjust my session plan without altering the original intended learning outcomes? How many students am I expecting in the session? How? Consider alternatives if you can’t access what you would like to use - do you go back and alter your original activities, or is there another creative alternative you can use? Before you create something from scratch yourself, check open resources repositories and online to see if there are resources already available that you can reuse If using software, check whether the computer in the teaching room has the necessary software you require Check the learning environment and equipment in the room – any constraints and how will you handle those? Will you need to adapt the layout - especially before your use it for first time; do you have time to adapt the layout before starting? The audio-visual equipment varies building to building at NTU. If you use flip charts, check whether they are they available in the room with paper, or do you have to take your own with you? If using artefacts – how can you get everything to the room? If everything is accessible on-line - will you need to take a back-up memory stick or hard copy with you? 11 Step 8 Identify risks and their impact on your session’s success Why? For you as tutor: We know only too well how the best-laid plans are still vulnerable to things going wrong. Minimise your stress levels by anticipating key risks in advance and work out how to minimise the risk of them happening – a mini ‘riskanalysis’ By anticipating any difficulties you can work around those and minimise the chances of them getting in the way of successful delivery of your sessions. Minimises disruption for you and helps maintain your confidence. For your students: Minimises disruption for them also, and helps maintain their confidence in your ability. Useful questions to consider: Which could go wrong when I’m delivering my session? What are the most significant risks – ie the ones that would cause the most disruption? What will I do if something goes wrong? Can I do anything to prevent things going wrong in the first place? Are there simple steps I can take to avoid some risks completely? Are all the risks within my control, or will I need help from others to minimise the chances of them occurring? How? Try to avoid getting bogged down in worrying about everything that could go wrong – you could drive yourself to distraction! Instead, identify the most likely problems that could occur, and rank them as and the extent of disruption they could cause. Then focus on those things that are most likely to cause the most disruption to your session. Or identify the 3 things you would be most worried about if they were to happen to you, and why. 12 Step 9 Create your contingency plan for handling the disruption when things go wrong Why? For you as tutor: To ensure that you minimise the disruptive impact of things going wrong (whether anticipated/unanticipated). To help you stay calm and confident, and in control. For your students: Minimises disruption to their learning. Help maintain their confidence in your ability to cope. Useful questions to consider: What things might I not have anticipated? What will I do if something unexpected happens that disrupts my session? How? Brainstorm ways of minimising the chances, or avoiding those things happening – talk to more experienced colleagues to find out how they do it. By having a contingency ready for all of the following 4 key scenarios: - if your audio-visual equipment fails - you forget the resources you need - your students fail to prepare - students keep distracting/disrupting you and others Write your plan down – for example in your session plan, or another means which you will be able to access easily in your session to remind you and give you time to think! Take the time in the session to think about your reaction before you react. Further guidance: Some of the risks relate to the behaviour of your students and other colleagues. For further information and inspiration, see the ‘CPLD Guide to Tackling Challenging Behaviours’ CPLD January 2015 13