Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government Consultation Paper – December 2013 This document provides information and seeks feedback from prospective tenderers on a proposed upcoming tender process for travel management services for the Australian Government. This document is not a notice or otherwise a part of any tender process for travel management services, which is yet to be determined or commence. Important Notice: The information in this document is indicative only and the Department of Finance (Finance) reserves the right, in its absolute discretion, to change any aspect of this strategy at any time. Finance makes no representation and does not warrant that: - any information contained in this document is accurate, current or complete; - any feedback given or comments made by prospective tenderers in response to this document will be used or otherwise acted upon or taken into account; or - a future tender process will be undertaken at a particular time, in a particular manner, or at all. Nothing in this document or arising from this document gives rise to or is intended to give rise to: - a contract; or - any obligation on the part of the Australian Government, or expectation on the part of any recipient of this document, in connection with any subsequent tender process. Where appropriate, Finance may incorporate feedback into any subsequent tender documentation, or otherwise use it to inform the proposed approach to market. Finance does not guarantee that any or all feedback will be incorporated in any subsequent approach to market. Finance also reserves the right to respond, or not respond, to specific questions or submissions at its own discretion. Information contained in any future request for tender material will supersede information contained in this document. Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 1 of 13 Introduction The whole of Australian Government travel arrangements are coordinated procurements, established by Finance that service the diverse travel needs of approximately 150 Australian Government departments and agencies (‘ the Government agencies’). Prior to the introduction of the whole of government travel arrangements, there was no consistent approach to travel procurement across Government agencies. A Scoping Study (‘the Study’) into the travel arrangements noted the decentralised approach to travel procurement, with no overarching coordination and strategic management, had resulted in a fragmented approach with inconsistent practices, duplication of effort and different pricing levels across the Government agencies. In response to the findings of the Study, Finance established and implemented the whole of Australian Government travel arrangements, with the objectives to: - reduce the cost of supply to Government agencies; - continue to meet the business needs of Government agencies; - contribute to a competitive and viable industry; - establish fair, equitable and transparent processes; and - optimise savings through cost reductions, improved efficiencies and promotion of behavioural change. Phase 1 of the travel arrangements came into effect on 1 July 2010, with the establishment of a panel of five (5) Travel Management Companies (TMCs) to provide travel management services, and pricing arrangements with four (4) domestic and twelve (12) international airlines (Airlines). Phase 2 of the travel arrangements improved efficiencies further, through the appointment of a single travel card provider, a sole accommodation program manager, and a panel of two car rental providers. These arrangements came into effect on 2 July 2012. Further information on the current arrangements can be found at: http://www.finance.gov.au/procurement/travel-and-related-services/index.html Both phases of the travel arrangements have provided bottom line savings to the budget, improved contractual efficiencies, increased transparency and provided greater value for money in the purchasing of travel services. Whilst the current travel arrangements are a significant improvement on the decentralised approach prior to 1 July 2010, there is scope for further improvements. This paper sets out the potential strategy for the renewal of the travel management services (‘the Services’). It is intended that the Services will include integration with the service providers under the Phase 2 travel arrangements, to the extent that the Services: - allow travellers and travel bookers to directly access the inventory of the accommodation program manager and the car rental service providers; - use the whole of government travel card arrangement for travel expenses, where payment occurs automatically; and - provide comprehensive (third level) data for all charges incurred. Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 2 of 13 Travel Management Services Requirements Finance intends to approach the market in the second quarter of the 2014 calendar year to establish new travel management service contracts for the Australian Government. The objectives for the travel management services arrangement include: - continuing to maximise value for money for the Commonwealth; - creating a sustainable business model for the travel industry; - increasing the use of technology to streamline the interaction between Government agencies, travel services providers and users of Government travel related services; and - contributing to transparency of travel expenditure through the provision of accurate and timely travel data. Within the context of the objectives for this project, the key elements of the new travel management services are: - for individuals – a service that is accessible, easy to use, and allows travellers to easily manage their travel (air, accommodation and car rental) requirements; - for Government agencies – a solution that promotes administrative efficiency , with minimal implementation effort, reduces cost and supports effective reporting and travel expense management across diverse system, policy and operational environments; and - for Finance – an arrangement where the service providers are fully accountable for the services they provide to the Australian Government. Finance expects the eventual Travel Service Provider(s) (TSP) will contribute to these objectives by: - developing a strategic partnership with Finance to provide exceptional levels of service to the Government agencies, where issues are quickly identified and resolved; - representing the Australian Government’s interests when dealing with relevant parties in delivering the Services to the Australian Government; - acting reasonably at all times to ensure the success of the arrangement, including minimising risk for the Government agencies; - maintaining open and effective communication with Finance as the manager of the arrangement and with the Government agencies as the recipients of the Services; - providing transparent fee arrangements, including reflecting any discount or other reduction linked to the Services; - recognising the need for delivering consistent and high quality products and services across the Government agencies, allowing tailoring where appropriate to suit the specific needs of the Government agencies; - actively contributing and supporting innovation in service delivery; - actively managing an integrated supply chain to deliver seamless services, data and reporting; - driving efficiencies in service delivery to support value for money to the Australian Government; and - providing services consistent with the Australian Government’s travel policies, including any individual guidelines of the Government agencies in respect of travel (which may include policies that restrict the use of certain fares). Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 3 of 13 Key features of the new arrangement are likely to include: a. a whole of government arrangement, managed by Finance, consisting of a panel of one, or more, TSP(s) delivering consistent and high quality products and services across the Government agencies, tailored to the requirements of approximately 150 Government agencies where required; i. TSP(s) must have the capacity to deliver the Services to the Government agencies. This involves the accurate and timely processing of approximately 700,000 domestic and 65,000 international bookings per annum, and the management of approximately 100,000 traveller profiles; b. clear contractual arrangements will be established so that service providers are accountable for delivering the Services to the highest possible standards. This includes having the appropriate contractual (or other) mechanisms in place with (and potentially between) the parties (including those contracted under Phase 2) delivering the Services to Finance and Government Agencies; c. a one stop shop that meets Government agencies’ travel needs, with an online booking tool or system (‘the OBT’) as the preferred booking channel for domestic and international travel. That is, travel bookings and amendments (pre- and post-ticketing) can be made online for air, accommodation and car rental; d. to the extent possible, direct contact with the travel service provider (i.e. consultant assisted travel bookings) would be used: for VIP services; in emergencies; where the OBT is unable to perform the function; or when access to the OBT is restricted (e.g. due to geographical location); e. the Services (OBT and consultant support) would need to be available 24/7 (except for OBT scheduled maintenance requirements) and also accessible through mobile devices (e.g. smart phones, tablets); f. transparent pricing that reflects the cost efficiencies from booking online compared to less efficient and potentially more expensive booking methods, but only to the extent that the OBT has the requisite functionality (e.g. making changes pre- and post-ticketing, booking of international travel); g. provision of comprehensive pre-defined data that does not require extensive manual intervention by Finance or Government agencies for reporting purposes; and h. the TSP contract will be for four years, with two extension options – the first extension option of two years and the second extension option of one year. Attachment A – provides an overview of the Australian Government travel profile. Attachment B – sets out the high level functions and travel management service requirements. Attachment C – sets out an overview of the current travel management service processes. Attachment D– provides a schematic of the proposed travel management services model. Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 4 of 13 Indicative Timeline and activities The following table sets out a high level indicative timeline and activities in order to deliver the project. Start-up RFT Process Implementation (Now – Feb 2014) (Mar – Oct 2014) (Nov 2014 – Apr 2015) - Appointment of resources - Consultation with agency and suppliers - Draft RFT documents - Establish due diligence data room - - Issue RFT Evaluate bids (including testing of solutions) Negotiate and execute Develop change management plan - Finalise Transition Plan Implement new arrangement - Agency communication - Services commence Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 5 of 13 Industry Consultation Finance welcomes any relevant feedback on its intended approach. In particular Finance would like feedback on the following: A. The current average online adoption rate (for booking domestic travel) across the Australian Government is approximately 60%. The adoption rate has been gradual (from an approximate average of 14% prior to the introduction of whole of government travel arrangements). The rate also differs across the Government agencies, ranging from approximately 10% to over 95%. The introduction of the OBT has proven successful in simplifying travel bookings; delivering efficiencies; reducing cost; and influencing traveller behaviour. Finance is now considering extending the use of the OBT to booking of international travel. Finance is also looking at ways to increase the OBT adoption across the Australian Government to further influence traveller behaviour, reduce cost and deliver greater efficiencies. Ideally, the OBT should be the preferred mechanism for booking domestic and international travel (including the management of pre- and post-ticketing changes). Consultant assisted travel bookings would be used: for VIP services; in emergencies; where the OBT is unable to perform a function; or when access to the OBT is restricted (e.g. due to geographical location). Is the online booking functionality currently and readily available to allow the Australian Government to manage its domestic and international travel bookings as described above? If so, can the OBT also perform pre- and post-ticketing changes? Is your organisation able to provide this system? Describe any integration (including information) requirements and associated lead time that you consider are necessary for the provision of the Service including the rollout of the OBT to Government agencies. Is the greater focus on an OBT the most effective approach to influencing traveller behaviour? What other measures could/would need to be taken in conjunction with the OBT being the preferred channel for booking travel? B. The Government agencies have a broad range of travel requirements, including, but not limited to: simple point to point ; multi-leg domestic and international bookings; charter flights; small and large group travel; excess baggage requirements; long stay accommodation;, special needs (disabled and elderly passengers, unaccompanied minors, freight); and VIP services. Considering the proposed strategy for OBT as the preferred travel booking channel, are there any limitations to using the OBT to meet the Australian Government travel requirements? C. The OBT will need to provide the Australian Government travellers and travel bookers with access to inventory of the Australian Government contracted: airlines; accommodation program manager; car rental service providers; and non-contracted airlines. The online booking tool will also need to support the processing of payment to these service providers, using the whole of government travel card arrangement. Describe any integration (including information) requirements and associated lead time necessary for travel management service provider(s) to integrate their systems Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 6 of 13 with the Australian Government contracted airlines, accommodation program manager, car rental and travel card service providers. Some service providers (e.g. accommodation program manager, car rental providers) distribute their inventory through channels other than global distribution systems. What are the likely challenges for travel service provider(s) to integrate their systems with such service providers? Is your organisation able to implement this integration? D. Finance is considering incorporating a pre-trip approval requirement as part of the OBT where the pre-trip approval function would be made available to those Government agencies that choose to take up that functionality. The decision to pursue the inclusion of the pre-trip requirement , as part of the OBT, remains with Finance. At this stage, Finance intends to assess this during the RFT process, based on whether the proposed solution by prospective tenderers: meets the business needs of the Government agencies; is efficient and seamless to implement (including interfacing with Government agencies’ systems (e.g. with a HR system); and incurs additional cost (if any). Is pre-trip approval functionality currently and readily available? Are you able to provide it? What level of customisation or configuration would be necessary to achieve the above requirement? How would a pre-trip approval system accommodate the airline ticketing conditions such as instant ticketing? How would a pre-trip approval system accommodate a bundled or consolidated booking which includes air sector(s), accommodation and car rental segments? Can a pre-trip approval system facilitate or aid post-trip cost acquittal and reconciliation (i.e. an end-to-end solution)? E. Finance expects to routinely receive comprehensive data from the TSP(s), in a consistent format (as defined by Finance) with little need for manual intervention (including cleansing and editing) by Finance. Finance is also considering the portability of data, particularly in relation to traveller profile data. What do you consider to be the system limitations in relation to providing uniform, pre-defined and formatted data? Is your organisation able to meet this requirement? What level of customisation or configuration would be necessary to achieve the above requirement? How do you currently manage profile data? How do you ensure the security of data, including profile data? How do you ensure the portability of profile data between the suppliers providing the Services to the Australian Government? How do you make this data available to the Australian Government, including hand over at the expiry of the contract? F. The key objectives for the travel service arrangements are to: optimise savings through cost reductions; improve efficiencies; and promote behavioural change. What travel related services or products do you consider may contribute to these objectives? Which of these services do you consider would need to form part of the core services as opposed to optional services? Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 7 of 13 Are these services or products currently and readily available? Are you able to provide them? G. Finance is considering the appropriate number of service providers for the Services. Considering the volume and diversity of Australian Government’s travel, and the proposed strategy, do you consider that a single provider has the capacity to manage and deliver the services described at Attachment B? Is your organisation able to perform this role? What are the benefits (including in relation to pricing) and the risks of a single service provider as opposed to a panel of service providers? Describe any set up (including information) requirements and associated lead time that you consider are necessary for service provider(s) to transition to the new arrangement and deliver the services. Submitting your comments Comments on the paper can be directed to: - traveltender@finance.gov.au - Procurement Coordinator Blog The closing date for providing feedback on this consultation paper is 10:00am 31 January 2014. Feedback and comments should not be more than 30 pages in length, including attachments. Where appropriate, Finance may incorporate feedback into any subsequent tender documentation, or otherwise use it to inform the proposed approach to market. Finance does not guarantee that any or all feedback will be incorporated in any subsequent approach to market. Finance also reserves the right to respond or not to specific questions at its own discretion. Finance encourages organisations to respond to this consultation paper. However, organisations that do not respond to this consultation paper will not be excluded for that reason from any subsequent approach to market. Finance will not pay for any information requested nor is it liable for any costs incurred by respondents. Organisations are directed not to approach Government agencies in relation to this consultation paper or the upcoming approach to market. Finance asks that correspondence occurs through the email address or Procurement Coordinator Blog (details set out above). Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 8 of 13 Attachment A – Overview of Australian Government’s travel profile Air Travel (1) 1. Spend ($): Volume (sectors): Bookings: Domestic: $265 million 1,200,000 680,000 International: $150 million 195,000 65,000 Total: $415 million 1,395,000 745,000 Air travel spend and volume is for the 2012-13 financial year. Air travel spend is Airline spend GST included. International Air travel includes Trans Tasman. Air travel volume is the number of one way sectors. Top City Pairs (by volume) (2) 2. Domestic: International: Canberra - Sydney Sydney – Los Angeles Canberra - Melbourne Sydney – Singapore Canberra - Brisbane Brisbane – Honiara Sydney - Melbourne Sydney – Bangkok Sydney - Brisbane Sydney – Dallas/Fort Worth Brisbane – Townsville Sydney – Dubai Adelaide – Canberra Sydney – London Melbourne – Brisbane Sydney – Hong Kong Adelaide – Melbourne Sydney – Jakarta Perth - Sydney Brisbane – Port Moresby Top City Pairs is the number of sectors between the cities. Domestic is originating from both cities. General Profile: approximately 150 Government agencies approximately 100,000 travellers The Australian Government has office locations in all Australian capital cities and a large number of regional areas. Most travel originates from Canberra, Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane. The Australian Government’s travel requirements are wide-ranging. In addition to the standard domestic and international booking services, they can include (but are not limited to) services such as: VIP bookings Excess Baggage and small freight Group travel Conference bookings Limousine transfer and services / Local transportation services Charter flights Passport / Visa applications Travellers requiring assistance Specialised travel booking services (transport of dangerous goods, transport of prisoners, witnesses and/or asylum seekers, secure hand delivery, freight, unaccompanied baggage, disabled support services) Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 9 of 13 Attachment B – High level functions and travel management service requirements. Function Services store traveller information to facilitate travel bookings store agency profile information to facilitate agency travel policy and expense reconciliation (e.g. booking references, cost centre structure) Profile Management Online Travel Management Customer Support and Training central or travel booker self registration (online and offline) agency creation and maintenance of traveller profiles (online) TSP creation and maintenance of traveller profiles (offline) password set up and maintenance real time or passive data-feeds from HR, financial or card management systems air, hotel and car rental inventory research (domestic and international) air, hotel and car rental (delegate) approval air, hotel and car rental bookings (including the use of supplier credits) ability to book special requirements (eg group travel and bulk booking) air, hotel and car rental booking amendments and cancellations ability to prioritise presentation of air fares, hotel and car rental rates ability to book ancillary services such as rail and ferry ability to manage additional baggage/freight 24/7 access through various mediums including smart phones and tablets provision of comprehensive itinerary that consolidates all aspects of travel (air, hotel, car) air, hotel and car rental inventory research (in tool) help and support air, hotel and car rental booking (in tool) help and support offline air, hotel and car rental amendments and cancellations 24/7 offline traveller support including travel booking for VIP and emergency bookings or due to deficiency or unavailability of online travel management tool feedback/complaints (in tool) connectivity to Commonwealth contracted air, hotel and car rental providers Inventory Management ticket fulfilment (where applicable) air, hotel and car rental booking confirmation Payment based on the whole of government travel card arrangement for travel expenses, where payment Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 10 of 13 Function Services occurs automatically in the background (virtual card and card in hand) Systems Integration manage air, hotel and car rental refunds due to agencies assist agency travel expense reconciliation with provision of enhanced data feed integration with Government agencies’ system including, Financial, HR or Card Management systems integration with /connectivity to Commonwealth contracted air, travel card, hotel and car rental providers’ systems Information Management provision of timely, accurate and complete transactional data data to include specific information and in format that aligns with Commonwealth’s reporting requirements travel data (and traveller profile information) owned by the Commonwealth travel data (and traveller profile information) stored and handled in a secure environment in Australia. Contractual Relationship strategic partnership with Finance as the contract manager Government agencies are recipient of travel services acting reasonably to ensure success of service delivery representing the Commonwealth’s interests open communication with Finance and with Government agencies Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 11 of 13 Attachment C –Overview of the current travel management service processes. Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 12 of 13 Attachment D - Proposed travel management service model Procurement of Travel Management Services for the Australian Government – Consultation Paper Page 13 of 13