Linac Coherent Light Source Project Update
Recent reviews
Budget, continuing resolution
LCLS Experiments
FAC new members
Highlights – changes, new issues
Charge
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
External Independent Review 10 May – 10 June 2004
ARTHUR P. MARTIN, PE
Principal Engineer – Review Lead
CHARLES W. HESS, P.E.
Chief Nuclear Engineer
DONALD N. FULTONBERG
Project Manager
EDWARD T. McCARTY
Senior Mechanical Engineer
Dr. James L. Anderson
Subject Matter Expert
Dr. Brian E. Newnam
Senior Scientist
CHANDER BIJLANI, PhD, P.E.
Principal Nuclear/Safety Engineer
CONSTANTINOS (DINOS) NICOLAOU
Supervising Project Controls Engineer
HOWARD S. COHEN, P.E.
Principal Nuclear Engineer
JOHN SERGENTANIS
Senior Project Engineer
ALAN J. DEMPSEY
Plant Test and Operations Manager
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
Outcome of EIR
Final report received
Corrective Action Plan submitted to DOE
Project validation letter expected shortly
Validation of budget/schedule
This one just could NOT have gone better
LCLS Team performed superbly
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
DOE Lehman Review 10-12 August 2004
Notification of review in July
Committee:
Todd Ditmire, UT Austin
Dave Gurd, ORNL
Suzanne Herron, ORNL
G. Desaulnier, consultant
Jeff Hoy, DOE
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
George Neil, JLAB
Ilan Ben-Zvi, BNL
R. Wunderlich, DOE
Bruce Warner, LLNL
J. Muhlstein, DOE
Kem Robinson, LBNL
P. Elleaume, ESRF
G. Stalnaker, LLNL
Pat Dehmer, DOE
Al Macrander, ANL
Dixon Bogert, FNAL
S. Tkaczyk, DOE
Hanley Lee, DOE
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
LCLS Project Baseline Shown at 8/10/04 Review
Linac Coherent Light Source BCWS Profile (AYM$)
WBS
System
FY02
FY03
June 2004
FY04
FY05
FY06
FY07
FY08
Total
1.1 Project Mgmt., Admin. & Integration
1.2 Injector System
1.3 Linac System
1.4 Undulator System
1.5 X-Ray Transport & Diagnostics
1.6 X-Ray Endstations
1.9 Conventional Facilities
Estimated Base Cost
Contingency
Total Estimated Cost (Base + Contingency)
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.43
0.64
0.18
0.57
0.70
0.00
0.11
3.64
0.00
3.64
2.50
1.60
1.17
1.90
0.75
0.46
1.44
9.82
0.00
9.83
3.74
12.67
5.51
9.80
3.82
0.55
5.69
41.79
8.08
49.87
3.98
3.66
12.75
14.17
9.52
4.11
29.15
77.34
7.84
85.18
4.05
0.71
5.27
18.65
7.58
10.04
18.94
65.24
22.42
87.67
3.30
0.35
1.00
0.44
1.50
1.43
7.34
15.37
21.45
36.82
19.01
19.63
25.89
45.53
23.88
16.59
62.68
213.20
59.80
273.00
2.1 Project Mgmt., Admin. & Integration
2.2 Injector System
2.3 Linac System
2.4 Undulator System
2.5 X-Ray Transport & Diagnostics
2.6 X-Ray Endstations
2.9 Conventional Facilities
Other Project Costs
1.50
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.50
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.67
0.44
0.00
0.02
0.78
0.00
0.00
1.91
1.83
0.97
0.00
0.30
0.89
0.23
0.00
4.21
1.63
0.81
0.00
0.47
0.00
0.96
0.00
3.87
5.22
4.16
1.22
4.98
1.94
0.81
0.00
18.33
9.55
0.10
0.77
0.08
1.17
0.51
0.00
12.18
20.40
6.48
1.99
5.84
4.78
2.50
0.00
42.00
Total Project Costs (Base + Cont. + OPC)
1.50
3.64
11.74
54.08
89.04
106.00
49.00
315.00
Linac Coherent Light Source Funding Profile (AYM$)
TEC Funding
OPC Funding
Total Funding
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
$90
FY02
FY03
FY04
FY05
FY06
FY07
FY08
Total
0.00
5.93
7.46
50.08
85.54
90.00
34.00 273.00
1.50
0.00
2.00
4.00
3.50
16.00
15.00
42.00
1.50
5.93
9.46
54.08
89.04 106.00
49.00 315.00
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
~29.5% contingency
on work remaining
LCLS is ~30%
complete on PED
Lehman Review Debrief
Concern expressed about budget/schedule
Conventional Facilities Contingency
Tunneling
FY2005 schedule did not reflect CR
Procurement staffing, schedule
CF Independent Cost Estimate due 15 Oct.
15 October revised baseline to DOE
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
Schedule Guidance
Show 1 year float to CD-4
Assume continuing Resolution thru December
Project completion before end of 2QFY2009
Plan Higher contingency for conventional
facilities
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
ESAAB Meeting
2 November 2004
CD-2B, complete LCLS Project Baseline
CD-3A, Begin Long-Lead Acquisitions
Prerequisite for approval:
Project Execution Plan
Project Management Plan
Partner Labs’ management must approve
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
Continuing Resolution
No definitive guidance on allocation of PED/R&D
CR limits total year’s allocation of PED to $7.5M
R&D not limited by CR, but by other constraints
DOE might provide >$1M month
$30M Long-Lead acquisitions
New start
$0 under a CR
Stops construction at SLAC and ANL
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
LCLS Experiments
DOE-BES plans to approve and fund a bundle of
experiment stations as a “major item of equipment” (MIE)
project
Patterned on “Spallation Neutron Source Next Generation”
(SING) Instrument MIE
CD-0 imminent
CDR, CD-1 (for the bundle) next summer
Separate CD-2 for each station as designs mature
SSRL does construction management of all
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
LCLS Scientific Advisory Committee
Membership
Roger Falcone Nora Berrah Phil Bucksbaum Robert L. Byer Hans Fraunfelder Wayne Hendrickson
Stephen R. Leone Margaret Murnane Jochen R. Schneider Francesco Sette Sunil Sinha Dietrich von der Linde -
UC Berkeley, USA, Chair
Western Michigan University, USA
University of Michigan, USA
Stanford University, USA
LANL, USA
Columbia U
UC Berkeley, USA
University of Colorado-Boulder, USA
HASYLAB, Germany
ESRF, France
UCSD, USA
University of Essen, Germany
Meetings
27-28 October
25-26 October
8-9 July
1-2 December
2004 - Meeting 2 – Start planning experiments
2004 - LCLS Experimental R&D Workshop
2004 – Meeting 1- Review Letters of Intent
2003
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
Call for Letters of Intent
Three types of proposals
Complete end stations
Proposals for scientific experiments
Special instrumentation
32 Letters of Intent received
256 Signatories
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
Results
SAC has defined 5 research thrusts for LCLS
Coordinator, SSRL contact named for each
No prioritization of programs at this time
Detector Development Referred to Special
Committee
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
LCLS Experiment Programs
Program
Team Leader
Co-leader
SSRL Contact
Coherent Scattering
at the Nanoscale
G. B. Stephenson
K. Ludwig
S. Brennan
Pump/Probe Diffraction
Dynamics
K. Gaffney
D. Reis
J. Larrson
A. Lindenberg
Pump/Probe High Energy
Density (HED) Physics
R. Lee
P. Hermann
J. B. Hastings
Nano-particle and Single
Molecule(non-periodic)
Imaging
J. Hajdu
J. Miao
H. Chapman
J. Arthur
Atoms, Molecules &
Optical Science
L. Di Mauro
N. Berrah
J. B. Hastings
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
Defining LCLS Experiment Stations
Ultrafast Science and LCLS Experiments Workshop 25-26
October 2004
http://www-conf.slac.stanford.edu/ssrl/2004/workshops.htm
A Workshop in Ultrafast Science and LCLS Experiments at SSRL will be organized on October 25-26,
2004. There will also be a pre-registration reception on Sunday evening, October 24th from 5-7 pm.
The tentative schedule for the workshop is a joint session on Monday morning, October 25th. On
Monday afternoon and Tuesday morning, there will be breakout sessions for each of the five thrust
areas of the LCLS: (1) Atomic, molecular and optical physics, (2) High energy density states of matter,
(3) Optical pump-x-ray probe studies in chemistry, biology and materials science, (4) Diffraction
imaging of single objects approaching atomic scale resolution and (5) Coherent x-ray scattering for the
study of dynamics (X-ray photon correlation spectroscopy). The workshop will end with a joint session
on Tuesday afternoon, October 26th. The workshop and breakout sessions will focus on the scientific
goals and technical needs of the LCLS experimental end-stations, as well as experimental
specifications. This workshop provides an opportunity to all users, including potential future users to
participate in building ultrafast science at LCLS by providing input and sharing their scientific ideas.
If you are interested in participating in the atomic, molecular and optical physics breakout session at
the meeting please contact Lou DiMauro (dimauro@bnl.gov), Phil Bucksbaum (phb@umich.edu), Nora
Berrah (berrah@wmich.edu) or Jerry Hastings (jbh@slac.stanford.edu). If you are interested in any of
the other breakout thrust areas please contact John Arthur (jarthur@SLAC.Stanford.EDU).
For program information see: http://www-conf.slac.stanford.edu/ssrl/2004/lcls_workshop.htm
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
Scientific Advisory Committee Meeting
27-28 October
Start of CD-1 activity
Presentations by each Team Leader
Near- and Long-term goals
Performance requirements, near- and long-term
Intensity, repetition rate
Wavelength
Commissioning likely to progress from 1.5 to 0.15 nm
Time scale for production of conceptual design (CD-1)
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
Detector Development
Review requires expertise not on the SAC
Detector Subcommittee formed
Review to be scheduled in early 2005
Y. Amemiya, U. of Tokyo
Gareth Derbyshire, RAL (Chair)
Eric Eikenberry, SLS
Lothar Strueder, Max Planck Inst.
Albert Walenta,
Univ. Siegen
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
Detector Development within the LCLS
LCLS planning included detector
development since 2/2002, @ $4M
Exploratory research at Cornell, in pixel
array detector
Decision to fund further development in
2006, based on initial findings
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
LCLS Design
Seeking commercial source for laser
Dual feed to gun, correction of dipole AND quadrupole RF fields
Dual feed to first accelerating section
Significant progress in planning EPICS controls and in staffing
Laser heater still looks good
Enhanced SASE?
Roll-Away undulator
K-control by means of canted poles
Electromagnet quadrupoles in undulator channel
AC impedance in undulator beam pipe – requires evaluation
New strategies for FEL commissioning
Progress on gas/solid attenuator conceptual design
Conventional facilities
Experiment halls unchanged since last visit
Considering alternatives for Central Lab Office Complex design
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
Membership
Kem Robinson,
Harry Carter,
A. Chargin
John Cleary,
John Corlett,
Massimo Cornacchia,
Roger Falcone,
Josef Feldhaus,
Paul Fouss,
Thomas Himel,
A. Kugler
Wim Leemans,
Pat O'Shea,
Joachim Pflueger,
Thomas Rabedeau,
Jörg Rossbach,
Keith Schuh,
Peter Siddons,
Thomas Tschentscher,
Karen White,
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL), Chair
Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (FNAL)
LLNL
Stanford University (SU)
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL)
SLAC (retired)
UC Berkeley
Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron (DESY)
Argonne National Laboratory (ANL)
Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC)
BJY
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL)
University of Maryland (UMD)
Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron (DESY)
Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC)
Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron (DESY)
Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (FNAL)
Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL)
Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron (DESY)
Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility (TJNAF)
Meetings
29-30 April
2004
12-13 October 2004
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
Charge to Committee
The LCLS Facility Advisory Committee will advise SLAC, SSRL and LCLS
management on the development of the LCLS Project through its several phases:
•
•
•
•
•
•
Accelerator systems design and construction
Undulator systems design and construction
X-ray transport, optics and diagnostics design and construction
Experiment station systems design and construction
Conventional facilities design and construction
Planning and execution of commissioning and early operations
We have expanded the time devoted to breakouts. Please comment on agenda
Thank you for giving your time to this review process. We value your advice
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu
End of Presentation
12 October 2004
LCLS Facility Advisory Committee
John N. Galayda
galayda@slac.stanford.edu