Tulane University Staff Advisory Council ATTENDEES ATTENDEES OFFICERS UPTOWN CAMPUS Lane, Christopher,Chair Orgeron, Laurie, Vice Chair Bouyelas, Sheri, Election Coordinator Bourgeois, Kathy,Recording Secretary Ardeneaux, Carol, Corresp.Secretary Lossi, Suzanne, Member At Large Present Present Excused Present Present DOWNTOWN CAMPUS Conners, Linzi Davis, Patrick Haase, Tanya Heisser, Michael Kivell, Anita Leger, Kay Miller, Michael Pasternak, Merisa Pick, Amy Slatkin, Allan Stewart, Patsy Vasquez-Lockhart Yesenia Present Present Present Present Present Present Present Present Present Present Graham, Tiffany (proxy) Hyde-Augillard, Sharon (proxy) NORTHSHORE Guichard, Kenny Waguespack, Desiree Cantero, Linda Chavez, Gwen, Immediate Past Chair Eugene, Zina Griffith, Mike Keck, Jeanny Leonard, Angelica Loshbaugh, Alysia Mitchell, Scott Murphy, Louise O’Dwyer, Lisa Platner, Rob Richards, Whitney Robinson, LaShanda Smith, Lawrence Vega, Kimberly Weingart, Kady Present Mann, Forbes (proxy) Page, Karissa (proxy) Pierlus, David (proxy) Schneider, Louie (proxy) Schor, Meredith (proxy) Souquet, Jon (proxy) Sugarman, Meredith (proxy) Ussin, Nikita (proxy) Woodard, Cathy (proxy) INVITED GUESTS AND VISITORS President Scott Cowen * Via teleconference All Officers are serving the Staff Advisory Council term 2011 – 2012 Present TU Staff Advisory Council Meeting April 12, 2012 Page 2 Call to Order: The meeting was called to order at 3:30 pm in room 201 of the Lavin Bernick Center by Chris Lane. I. Review and Approval of the Minutes The February minutes have not been approved yet. The March 2012 minutes were approved, but a note was made that Jeanny Keck’s first name was misspelled within the body of the March 2012 minutes. II. Guest Speakers President Cowen and Anne Banos joined us to give us an update on the University. We received over 30,000 applications for 1,500 spots at the undergraduate level for fall 2012, and we are doing well at medical school. We expect to have another banner year. All of the graduate and professional schools should also do well. We are hoping for an incoming class of 1,550. The last few years we were oversubscribed. We hoped for 1,500 or 1,550 students, but ended up with over 1,600 students. Hopefully that doesn’t happen this year. The deposits are running way ahead of where we were last year at this time. The quality of the students that are interested in Tulane is extraordinary, and they are pleased with everything they are seeing. This also holds true with the medical school and he doesn’t see why it won’t be the same for all of the other schools. Financially, the University is tracking just as they had anticipated. We had a couple of dicey years after Katrina to work our way out of the damage. Things were better about three years ago, but then the recession happened. It has been a difficult three or four years for all colleges and universities around the country. We should all be glad (as Scott is) that we are not a public institution, because most of them haven’t had a raise in four years and had significant layoffs and furloughs. Fortunately, we haven’t had either of those here and continue to give raises and enhance benefits when possible. He sees us continuing to be able to do that. The environment for higher education is a tough environment. He hasn’t seen it as difficult as it has been the last three or four years than all of his life in the academy. All of our revenue sources, with the exception of tuition, are stable or going down and the costs are going up. We continue to hire and give raises, which makes up about 75% of our costs. The other 25% is made up of non-salary expenses, and even those costs such as insurance, utilities are all continuing to go up. That is also true for other colleges and universities. Given the fact that the enrollment is strong, overall we are doing alright, and he feels pretty good about the University when it comes to our financial position and our condition as an institution. We are going through a significant time of capital improvements. We have invested about five hundred million dollars in the last six years into new buildings and renovations to existing buildings. We will invest about another two hundred fifty million over the next three years. The money comes from a combination of sources. In some cases we go out and issue debt. When we built Weatherhead Hall, we had a bond issued to build it. It is self financing, because the revenue from the residents pays for the bond issue. In some cases, we build facilities with private philanthropy. The new football stadium will be built with donations from our friends around the country. We are also building some buildings with some FEMA money. The expansion of Howard Tilton Memorial Library will begin in a few months. It will be about a twenty million dollar project. Most of it will be funded by FEMA. Occasionally, we take money from operations as we did for Dinwiddie’s renovation. The Uptown campus is in pretty good shape. There are still some buildings that need work such as Stern and the Social Work Building. This is also true of the downtown campus and the Primate Center. TU Staff Advisory Council Meeting April 12, 2012 Page 3 We are in the midst of a very extensive and comprehensive strategic planning process. The last time we developed a plan was right after Katrina, which was the renewal plan. We have implemented all parts of the plan, and they have worked pretty well for us. Now it is time to think about the next ten years. They have been looking at the strengths and weaknesses of the University, where the higher education is going in the future and some of our opportunities. That work will be finished in about the next three months. Next year they will work with the individual schools and administrative units to develop their plans. That will all lead to another capital campaign for the University. We successfully completed a seven hundred million dollar campaign in June 2008. We actually raised about seven hundred and thirty million dollars. The new campaign will start in a couple of years and will be in excess of a billion dollars for endowment, operations and more buildings. We are already in the private phase of that. You really can’t do the campaign until you have a solid strategic plan for the future and know what you are raising money for. Scott spends a lot of time on the Medical School. We have some significant challenges with the Medical School in particular with the clinical platform. We have a joint venture with HCA since the mid 1990’s. For the most part it has been successful, but we wonder if it can continue to be successful in the future, especially since they will be building a new VA hospital that will open in 2015 and a new medical center downtown that will replace Charity that will open in 2016. We will have over two billion dollars worth of hospitals being built within one half mile of our hospital in the next three or four years, which will offer some interesting competition for us. The question is whether we will be able to weather that competition. The clinical part of the School of Medicine continues to be something that he focuses a lot of time and energy on. The issue of affordability and accessibility is another thing that they are looking at. We increase tuition every year by about 4%. They don’t think that is sustainable in the long run. If it is not sustainable, we have to figure out how we are going to finance ourselves. We are at capacity, so we can’t take any more students. The only way we can increase revenue is to increase tuition, because all of our other revenue sources are pretty flat. They will spend a lot of time at the June board meeting talking about that. About 52% of our undergraduates come from households with a net income greater than two hundred fifty thousand dollars. It is a very wealthy group, but we are pushing out the middle class and the lower socio economic class. They can’t afford the tuition. Even though we are increasing aid all the time, we can’t keep up with the amount that tuition is increasing. President Cowen could not be more proud of the faculty and staff at the University, and has been since he came here fourteen years ago. He is very optimistic about the future. He would like to believe that most of the people of New Orleans feel good about Tulane, but there are some exceptions to that. For the most part, people appreciate what the University has done for the city. We are probably doing more for our city than most universities are doing for their cities around the country. We are proud of that, and we will continue to help the city. Scott asked for questions. Jeanny Keck said that she would like to see the Liberal Arts Department – specifically the French Department - get a little more money, because they can’t afford supplies and the restrooms are in need of an update. Scott jokingly promised to send her some pens. Scott said that it this generally true around campus. She mentioned that some people are doing two jobs, but not being compensated for their work. She complimented the students at Tulane for being great ambassadors for the University. Resources have always been scarce. Part of the reason is that we don’t have an endowment the size of other Universities. Also, we live in a part of the country where there is not a lot of wealth. One of the great things is that we learn to do more with less, and it doesn’t seem to be changing. Newcomb Hall has had some improvements, and it is on their list to do more. TU Staff Advisory Council Meeting April 12, 2012 Page 4 Desiree told him about our CASA Christmas toy drive each year and asked him if he could possibly help us get the word out this year. We have about four thousand full time and three thousand part-time employees. He asked her to write Anne Banos in advance to remind her about our toy drive, and he will find a way to put it in his Tulane Talk, which is much more effective. It is normally prepared the day before it goes out. Jeanny asked if we will get the Computer Science major back. The School of Science and Engineering is putting a plan together to put a new program in place. They put a study group together and they are looking at their report. There is clearly a plan to add both an undergraduate major and master’s program in Computer Science. It is up to them and the Provost. Meredith from the Financial Aid office asked if there is a plan to have student services housed closer together as other Universities and colleges do. This has been in the plan for several years. They are looking at using the School of Social Work building for this purpose for a one stop shop. We would have to figure out where to move the Social Work department and then expand and renovate the Social Work building. It is part of the ten year strategic plan. Laurie talked to Scott about the poor shape of McAlister Auditorium. They installed new seats on the side balconies of the auditorium, but the ceiling is falling, the walls are crumbling and the floor was not repaired before they put those seats in. She felt that they should have painted, and repaired the walls and floors before putting new seats in. Tony Lorino has an ongoing list of capital improvements and deferred maintenance issues, and McAlister is on that list. This is a five to ten million dollar repair. The roof is causing the problem. Tony and Scott just talked about this recently, and they are looking into doing at least some part of the repairs. We talked about the neighbors on Audubon Boulevard that are not happy about the stadium. Yvette and members of the senior staff have been meeting with the neighbors regularly. There will always be opposition, no matter what we do. He thinks the project will happen, but they are going to look at their concerns to see if there is something we could do to make them happy. She asked if they could do something to stop the project. Of course they could file a lawsuit or other things to slow the project down. Every project that we have ever been involved with has happened, and there have always been neighborhood issues. The group against the stadium is not very large. This is not a surprise to the University. The capacity of the new stadium is only about thirty thousand people where the old stadium held about eighty three thousand people. These residents knew they were buying a home next to a university. They benefit by having TUPD patrolling their streets, TEMS is available to them at all times and their property values have increased. It is a good deal living next to a University. The stadium will not be used every day. Tulane will be sensitive to parking and traffic during a game and have worked out the traffic flow. They believe every game will be sold out. Lisa asked why we think it will sell out based on their record. We average about nineteen thousand to twenty three thousand fans at the dome, so if the games are in the neighborhood on campus, they should sell out. He was also asked about operations after the stadium is built. There is a certain amount of money in the project for operations, but who will take care of it is still open. Chris Lane mentioned that it is getting increasingly difficult to schedule classes on the uptown campus. Most of the faculty uses technology, so he hopes that there is a plan to upgrade the classrooms. Chris also mentioned this to Dr. Bernstein. Charlie McMahon was asked for a list of all of the rooms that need technology or an upgrade. It will cost about one million dollars. Some of the rooms will be upgraded this summer and the rest should be done next summer. There are about thirty five rooms to be done. TU Staff Advisory Council Meeting April 12, 2012 Page 5 Chris told him about staff appreciation day. He explained that we are not able to do the same type of event as in previous years on a weekend, but we want to have a get together on the LBC quad on the Friday before Memorial Day. We are hoping that supervisors would let their employees take off to attend. Any suggestions or guidance would be appreciated. President Cowen said to think about that day since it is memorial weekend. Someone asked if there are plans for graduate student housing, but it is not in the plan right now. A new residence hall is set to be built on the Zimple quad for undergraduate housing next year. A large six hundred bed graduate student residence complex located where Rosen was located is being considered. They haven’t been able to figure out how to do it financially, because we would need parking and retail. III. Report of the Chair, Christopher Lane No Report IV. WFMO Liaison Denise O’Connell came to the meeting in place of Christina Wallace. We had a hiring proposal question from the previous meeting. We wanted to know when the verbal offer is extended to an applicant. The hiring proposal has to be approved before a verbal offer is extended. A member asked if we could get a breakdown of the whole hiring process. They provided a laminated step by step card a couple of years ago. Alicia remembers that the card said that you offer a verbal offer before the approval is received. Denise will check into that. We had asked about a commuter incentive program to have a carpool zone and offer carpool at a discounted parking rate. She said that TUPD would handle that and that we should send them a proposal. We also asked if a list of WFMO contacts for things such as tuition waivers, etc. could be put on their website. It would be helpful to know who does what within WFMO. We also want a list of constituents that each SAC member would report back to. If we get a list of the departments on campus and their location, we can determine which SAC members they should go to with questions. Chris doesn’t think that the idea was for WFMO to decide this, Suzanne thought that we used to get a list from Payroll, which included the locations of each employee. Once we know which departments are located near each other, we can group them together to determine who would represent that group. We mainly need the list of departments, their locations and a contact person from each department. Louise said that the list that Denise is talking about is the list of department heads similar to the list on the address stickers that we get from Payroll. They also have a list of the contacts that initiate everything for the department. Suzanne said that they used to try to get a SAC rep for each group of buildings so that each area is represented. Chris said that may also require us to know how many people are in each office. Laurie felt that it wouldn’t be necessary to know how many people are in a department as long as we have one contact person for each department. We would then list all of our SAC members on our website and list the departments/buildings that each member represents. If a department had an issue, they would know which member to go to with that issue. Denise will send that list to Chris. V. Officer Reports A. University Senate TU Staff Advisory Council Meeting April 12, 2012 Page 6 They attempted to have a short meeting, but a student from TEMS came in to give them a presentation on what they do and how many calls and types of calls that they respond to. They wanted to stress that they do provide a valuable service to people within a mile radius of the University and that their volume has increased since Katrina, so they are requesting another ambulance. Chris thought that this meeting was in March, but we didn’t get a report last month on this matter. B. Board of Administrators President Cowen reported on most of what Laurie had. They introduced people; they went over signature authority; passed resolutions and did an overview of commencement. Honorary degree recipients are Ruby Bridges, Lisa Jackson, who is also the speaker and head of the EPA and Peter Lax, a mathematician. The president’s Medal of Honor is going to Trombone Shorty. Other topics that were discussed: Student interest, quality and retention Impact and reputation for engagement We were given outstanding accolades for civic engagement. Research funding is in a financially constrained environment. Campus, physical plant expansions and improvements Stability, commitment and performance of faculty and staff Incoming medical school class is the best in history Challenges are crime and safety. John Barnwell, the new head of the police department, was introduced. Health care landscape will have an impact on the School of Medicine as Scott mentioned Largest disinvestment in public institutions ever – resulting in increased tuition College affordability and access is going to be the topic of Tulane board in New York in June Competing and aspiring to elevate Tulane’s quality and reputation with limited resources In three or four years they expect stability to break even and they will possibly raise tuition 60% - 80% of students receive financial aid The debt level of medical students continues to rise – it is about two hundred fifty thousand dollars on average, but ours is higher than that Issues with who will go into primary care, because salaries are so low Students come from homes with two hundred fifty thousand dollars or greater salaries per year John Barnwell, new head of TUPD, spoke. They used to have eighteen now have twelve officers. They patrol from Claiborne to St. Charles and Carrolton to Nashville Foot and bike patrols continue to monitor or safety and they work with the second district Rick Potts is the new chief uptown Increased lighting and lighting repair is a commitment from mayor Adding Broadway, Freret Street, Maple Street, Calhoun and Willow Street to the primary corridor for police to patrol Addition of half million dollars added to safety John Barnwell will speak to us in May President of Tulane Alumni Association gave the status of the association. We now have seventy eight active Tulane clubs around the world. There was 97% giving for Tulane alumni association board, but it is now 100%. Jobs, networking and employment are the most import topics that the Alumni Association will focus on. VI. University Senate Committee Reports TU Staff Advisory Council Meeting April 12, 2012 Page 7 1. Benefits No Report 2. Budget Review No Report 3. Information Technology No Report 4. Equal Opportunity No Report 5. Physical Facilities No Report 6. Social Issues No Report VII. SAC Sub-Committees 1. Election Committee Elections will come up in the June meeting. If we have anyone that we want to nominate or if anyone wants to be an officer, we should keep this in mind. 2. Electronic Technology and Information No Report 3. Staff Appreciation Lawrence Smith, Alysia Loshbaugh, Jeanny Keck, Kathy Bourgeois, Sheri Bouyelas, Laurie Orgeron and Chris Lane have been working on the staff appreciation day. We found two bands that will give us a good price. The idea is to have an afternoon event where staff can get together for a couple of hours to relax. Students will be gone and things would be relatively slow. We have a jazz trio from the Music Department and Cajun band. We have $3,000 left in our budget. Another idea is to have a snowball stand with cups that would have a logo on them. We are looking at getting donations of food from Mr. Mudbugs and campuses will donate items. Facilities will donate chairs and tables, TUPD will donate three officers, Shuttles will donate a shuttle and one to north shore if they are interested. It will be a non alcohol event. We want the President’s Office to ask supervisors to let people attend. The President’s Council is meeting on May 27th. Our last meeting before elections is the May 10th. If we change it much, we have to have refined before President’s Council meeting. Chris asked if everyone likes this idea. Lisa thinks it will be appreciated but feels that people will take the Friday before a holiday off or will leave early. A suggestion was made to do it on Thursday from 3:00 – 5:00. Three years ago they had Ricky Graham during lunch and only about one hundred twenty people showed up. We hoped if the offices would let non essentials go, they would show up. Maybe we could incorporate it into standard lunch hour so they wouldn’t have to have permission from supervisors. Maybe we could have it from 11:00 – 2:00. North shore has a couple of events and they let them know in advance to let staff go and they don’t have any problem with supervisors letting them go. Law School deans usually let staff go around 3:00 if there is a holiday weekend. Downtown employees probably won’t come uptown and go back to work. They would rather come later and then leave from here. There is a half our trip each way to get TU Staff Advisory Council Meeting April 12, 2012 Page 8 from downtown to uptown and back. Graduation is the weekend before Memorial weekend. Business School starts summer school on May 14th. Someone asked if our resources would roll over to next year if they don’t get used. Chris believes that it does. Last year we had a good turnout, but the year before we didn’t due to bad weather. We ran into a timing issue another year, so they bought engraved key chains for everyone. That went over well. There is a baseball game on the Sunday after graduation, so parking will be limited. We discussed going back to having it on the weekend. We voted to move it to Thursday. We talked about the time. Chris will check the availability of the LBC. Scott Mitchell will coordinate getting prizes. Laurie said that snowballs are served in LBC hallway all the time, but Shirley said that we couldn’t have them in the room that we reserved. Alicia told Hansen that if it rains, we would set up in Pocket Park or something. Chris will talk to Shirley to see if the Kendal Cram is available that Thursday. We voted to keep in afternoon from 2:00 – 5:00. Small departments will have to rotate in order for everyone to attend. We need to check to see if the bands are available on that day and time. Chris said that he got an offer from Gal Holiday. Lisa didn’t think she would be good for our event. She plays rockabilly music. Chris will talk to Anne to see if that day and time will be acceptable and get it to the President’s Council. Chris asked for volunteers to do fundraising. People would get tickets at check in to win prizes. Lisa will take care of registration. Others offered to help set up or anything that needs to be done. Note: Anne sent Chris and email on April 27th, saying that they didn’t feel that the event could go on this year since we recently had the faculty/staff service day, and they didn’t feel that we had it developed well enough. 4. Staff Issues No report 5. Health and Wellness No report 6. Community Service No report VIII. Old Business No report IX. New Business Jeanny Keck wants to talk to the president of the student body, but they weren’t able to make the meeting. Jeanny is going to pursue it with or without Whitney. This falls under Student Relations, which is not on our agenda. Chris took it off, because they never met. We will discuss it at the next meeting. X. Adjournment TU Staff Advisory Council Meeting The meeting was adjourned at 4:50 pm. Respectfully submitted, Kathy Bourgeois Recording Secretary April 12, 2012 Page 9