The Role of Extension in Community Resource and Economic Development as

advertisement

The Role of Extension in

Community Resource and Economic Development as

Perceived by Administrators and Directors of the

Cooperative Extension Service

Seth C. Urbanowitz

Dr. Michael D. Wilcox

Purpose of Study

• Ascertain the attitudes and perceptions of Extension administrators and directors in regard to the perceived role, function and direction of CRED

Extension activities as well as the socialenvironmental factors that could be affecting system resources.

Objectives of the Study

• Research objectives developed for the study:

– Gain insight into regional and national CRED

Extension efforts.

– Describe the political and social issues facing

CRED Extension program area and Extension as a whole.

– Examine perceptions and attitudes regarding research and programming priorities.

– Examine the perceived role of CRED professionals.

Methodology

• E-mailed all 115 administrators and associate administrators of the Extension System.

• Four e-mail reminders where sent dating from

May 13 to June 2. Two were from S-PLN colleagues and two from the graduate student, with personalized, regional or state focus.

• MANOVA/ANOVA and Chi-squared analyses conducted to test for regional variation or national consensus.

Response Rate

• 42 total responses. Thirty-five 1862 institutions and seven 1890 institutions responded.

• 36.5% overall response rate

– North Central (16.6%)

– Northeast (26.1%)

– South (40.4%)

– West (16.6%)

CRED and the Extension Mission

There is a clear role for community development in

Extension. However, there remains confusion on how best to achieve Extension’s community development objectives.

Dependent Variable

The Extension System at my institution has a significant role to play in CRED in my state.

CRED programming is essential in achieving the mission the Extension System at my institution.

'CRED Extension efforts can be accomplished through our family and consumer science, agriculture and natural resource and/or 4-H youth development programming.'

Mean

(strong disagree=1; strong agree=5)

4.43

4.38

3.31

Std. Deviation

.668

.854

1.316

Extension’s Current and Future

Involvement in CRED

Strengthening current priorities and identifying emerging opportunities will allow Extension to continue to provide effective programming that meets the needs of the public.

Programming % Yes

Leadership and Civic

Engagement

92.9%

Economic

Development

81.0%

Sustainable

Development

Natural

Resources and Env.

Mgmt.

Health and

Nutrition

71.4%

66.7%

59.5%

Research

Sustainable

Development

Ecnomic

Development

Natural

Resources and Env.

Mgmt.

Agriculture in

Transition

Health and

Nutrition

% Yes Emerging Issues % Yes

61.9%

Sustainable

Development

64.3%

61.9%

Workforce

Development

64.3%

59.5%

54.8%

Ecnomic

Development

Natural Resources and Env. Mgmt.

61.9%

57.1%

47.6%

Population

Change/Immigration

57.1%

Perceived Importance of Specializations

Consensus on specializations CRED Extension professionals should obtain to effectively work in community and economic development.

Dependent Variable

Leadership and Civic Engagement

Economic Development

Group Process and Facilitation

Organizational Development

Local Government

Public Issues Education

Workforce Development

Natural Resources

Mean

4.60

4.57

4.43

4.31

4.24

4.17

4.05

4.02

Std. Deviation

.544

.630

.590

.715

.759

.660

.825

.841

Threats

Failing to adequately serve all members of our nation’s communities or meet the needs of the public as the outreach service of the Land Grant System will negatively affect system resources and organizational image.

Dependent Variable

CRED Extension programming serves limited resource individuals adequately.

CRED Extension programming serves minority populations adequately.

Current programming done by CRED county-level professionals matches the needs of those counties.

Current research done by CRED university-based specialists matches your state’s needs.

Mean Std. Deviation

2.83 .294

2.88

2.48

2.36

.861

1.21

.95

Opportunities

Strengthening external partnerships and mass media use will improve political support and awareness of organizational purpose and make-up.

Dependent Variable

Increased external organizational linkages would improve political support for CRED

Extension efforts at my institution.

Mass media should be used more to build awareness of what Extension has to offer.

Mean

4.12

4.00

Std. Deviation

.504

.911

Variation in Regional CRED Efforts

Dependent Variable Region (I) Region (J)

Mean Difference

(I-J)

Region (I) Mean Significance

-.26

-1.35

*

South

Northeast

North Central

1.64 .767

.001

West

The number of funded

FTE's devoted to

CRED Extension programming is sufficient at your institution.

Northeast

North

Central

South

North Central

West

South

Northeast

West

South

West Northeast

North Central

*signifies significant regional variation.

.08

.26

-1.09

*

.34

1.35

*

1.09

*

1.43

*

-.08

-.34

-1.43

*

2.09

2.71

2.42

.995

.767

.013

.750

.001

.013

.003

.995

.750

.003

CRED Allocations as % of Total Budget

1%-5% Independent

Variable

Region South*

Total

Count

% within Region

Northeast

Adjusted Residual

Count

% within Region

Adjusted Residual

North Central Count

% within Region

West*

Adjusted Residual

Count

% within Region

Adjusted Residual

Count

% within Region

*Signifies significant regional variation.

10

58.8%

2.6

3

27.3%

-.7

2

28.6%

-.4

0

.0%

-2.2

15

35.7%

6% or more Total

7 17

41.2% 100.0%

-2.6

8 11

72.7% 100.0%

.7

5 7

71.4% 100.0%

.4

7 7

100.0% 100.0%

2.2

27 42

64.3% 100.0%

Recommendations

• Increase the capacity of CRED Extension to better serve multi-cultural, minority, and limited resource populations.

• Continue the use of consistent programmatic and research themes across state boundaries.

• Increase the use of various forms of mass media to communicate the appropriate image and build awareness.

• Strengthen external organizational linkages to improve effective programming and build political support.

Recommendations

• Consistently engage diverse audiences at the county-level to ensure awareness and effective programming that meets the needs of the public.

• Help to ensure relevant research and programming that meets the needs of the public through increased joint research-extension appointments.

• Develop a more unified voice across regions as to how best to achieve Extension’s community development objectives.

Download