Measurement To collect data, you need to have something to measure Measurement is the process of assigning numbers or scores to characteristics or attributes of the objects or people people of interest Variables • When we measure the attributes of an object, we obtain a value that varies between objects. • For example consider the people in this class as objects and their height as the attribute • The attribute height varies between objects, hence attributes are more collectively known as variables • Variables can be measured on four different scales Attitudes Expressions of inner feelings that reflect whether a person is favorably or unfavorably predisposed to some object -- a brand, a brand name, a service, a service provider, a retail store, a company, an advertisement, in essence, any marketing stimuli. Opinions A large amount of questions in marketing research are designed to measure attitudes Marketing managers want to understand consumers’ attitudes in order to influence their behavior Three Components of Attitudes The ABCs of attitudes: The Affective Component (based on feelings or overall evaluation) Feelings of like or dislike The Behavioral Component (likely action toward object; e.g. from a consumer behavior point of view, the consumer’s intention to buy a product) Intentions to behave The Cognitive Component (based on beliefs; what you think about a marketing stimulus) – Information possessed Nominal Scale Classifies data according to a category only. E.g., which color people select. Colors differ qualitatively not quantitatively. A number could be assigned to each color, but it would not have any value. The number serves only to identify the color. No assumptions are made that any color has more or less value than any other color. Nominal Scale Assign subjects to groups or categories – Mutually exclusive – Collectively exhaustive No order or distance relationship No arithmetic origin Only count numbers in categories Only present percentages of categories Chi-square most often used test of statistical significance Other Examples Sex Social status Marital status Days of the week (months) Geographic location Seasons Ethnic Group Types of restaurants Brand choice Religion Job Type: Executive, Technical, Clerical Coded as “1” Coded as “2” Nominal Scale Which of the following media influences your purchasing decisions the most? –1 Television –2 Radio –3 Newspapers –4 Magazines Ordinal Scale classifies nominal data according to some order or rank E.g. names ordered alphabetically With ordinal data, it is fair to say that one response is greater or less than another. E.g. if people were asked to rate the hotness of 3 chili peppers, a scale of "hot", "hotter" and "hottest" could be used. Values of "1" for "hot", "2" for "hotter" and "3" for "hottest" could be assigned. The gap between the items is unspecified. Ordinal Scale Can include opinion and preference scales Median but not mean No unique, arithmetic origin items cannot be added In marketing research practice, ordinal scale variables are often treated as interval scale variables Ordinal Scale Rank 1 Player Tiger Woods. Points 22.89 Examples 2 Jim Furyk, 8.70 3 Phil Mickelson, 8.31 4 Adam Scott, 7.26 5 Vijay Singh, 6.68 6 Retief Goosen, 6.35 7 Ernie Els, 6.25 Likert scales, rank on a scale of 1….5 your degree of satisfaction 8 Luke Donald, 5.55 Women’s dress sizes 9 Geoff Ogilvy, 5.42 10 Sergio Garcia, 5.42As at Oct 2006 GPA Small medium large Quality Please rank the news programs offered in the following four networks based on your preference.(1 for most preferred, 4 for least preferred). _____ CTV _____ Global _____ CITY TV _____ CBC Interval Scale assumes that the measurements are made in equal units. i.e. gaps between whole numbers on the scale are equal. e.g. Fahrenheit and Celsius temperature scales an interval scale does not have to have a true zero. e.g. A temperature of "zero" does not mean that there is no temperature...it is just an arbitrary zero point. Can’t perform full range of arithmetic equations. 40 degrees is not twice as hot as 20 degrees Permissible statistics: count/frequencies, mode, median, mean, standard deviation Interval Scale How likely are you going to buy a new automobile within the next six months? (Please check the most appropriate category) Definitely will not buy Probably will not buy May or may not buy Probably will buy Definitely will buy ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ 1 2 3 4 5 Ratio Scale similar to interval scales except that the ratio scale has a true zero value. e.g. the time something takes allows you to compare differences between numbers. Permits full arithmetic operation. If a train journey takes 2 hr and 35 min, then this is half as long as a journey which takes 5 hr and 10 min. Ratio Scale • Indicates actual amount of variable – Shows magnitude of differences between points on scale – Shows proportions of differences • All statistical techniques useable • Most powerful with most meaningful answers • Allows comparisons of absolute magnitudes Examples height, weight, age, Length time Income 7 Market share 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1.What is your annual income before taxes? $ _______ 2. How far is your workplace from home? miles _______ Primary Scales of Measurement Nominal Ordinal Interval Ratio Numbers Assigned to Runners 4 81 9 Rank Order of Winners Performance Rating on a 0 to 10 Scale Time to Finish in Seconds Third Place Second Place First Place 8.2 9.1 9.6 15.2 14.1 13.4 Comparison of Measurement Scales Label Order Distance Origin Nominal scale Yes No No No Ordinal scale Yes Yes No No Interval scale Yes Yes Yes No Ratio scale Yes Yes Yes Yes Use of Measurement Scales • Nominal – Used to categorize objects • Ordinal – Used to define ordered relationships • Interval – Used to rank objects such that the magnitude of the difference between two objects can be determined • Ratio – Same as interval scale but has an absolute zero point Always use the most powerful scale possible Adding Sophistication To Scales • Concept: Desire to watch Star Wars movies – If a Star Wars movie is on television will you watch it? • Yes _____ No _____ – How likely are you to watch a Star Wars movie shown on television? • Very Likely ____ Likely ____ Indifferent ___ • Unlikely _____ Very Unlikely _____ Another way to describe variables • Qualitative variables: have a nominal scale of measurement. • Categorical variables: have a nominal or ordinal scale of measurement. • Quantitative variables: have an interval scale of measurement. • Continuous variables: have an Ordinal, interval, or ratio variables scale of measurement. Practice describing variables • Q: What kind of variable is educational attainment, and what scale is it measured in? •A: Education is measured in number of years of schooling, and is therefore a discrete quantitative variable measured on an interval scale. (Or is it?) •How could education be measure using… –A nominal scale –An ordinal scale A Classification of Scaling Techniques SCALING TECHNIQUES Comparative Scales Paired Comparison Rank Order Constant Sum Non-Comparative Scales Others Likert Continuous Rating Scales Semantic Differential Itemized Rating Scales Stapel Types of Scaling Techniques COMPARATIVE SCALES • Involve the respondent directly comparing stimulus objects. • e.g. How does Pepsi compare with Coke on sweetness NON-COMPARATIVE SCALES • Respondent scales each stimulus object independently of other objects •e.g. How would you rate the sweetness of Pepsi on a scale of 1 to 10 Paired Comparison Items If we have brands A, B, C and D, we would have respondents compare • A and B • A and C • A and D • B and C • B and D • C and D –Usually limited to N < 15 COMPARATIVE SCALES Paired Comparison Please indicate which of the following airlines you prefer by circling your more preferred airline in each pair: Air Canada Air Transat Zip WestJet Air Canada Zip WestJet Air Canada WestJet Air Transat Zip Air Transat COMPARATIVE SCALES Constant Sum Scales Allocate a total of 100 points among the following softdrinks depending on how favorable you feel toward each; the more highly you think of each soft-drink, the more points you should allocate to it. (Please check that the allocated points add to 100.) Coca-Cola _____ points 7-Up _____ points Dr. Pepper _____ points Tab _____ points Pepsi-Cola _____ points 100 points Constant Sum Scale Please divide 100 points among the following characteristics so the division reflects the relative importance of each characteristic to you in the selection of a bank Hours of service ________________ Friendliness _______________ Distance from home ________________ Investment vehicles ________________ Parking facilities __________________ COMPARATIVE SCALES Rank-Order Scales Rank the following soft-drinks from 1 (best) to 5 (worst) according to your taste preference: Coca-Cola _____ 7-Up _____ Dr. Pepper _____ Pepsi-Cola _____ Mountain Dew _____ –Top and bottom rank choices are ‘easy’ –Middle ranks are usually most ‘difficult’ Comparative Scales Rank Order Scale Indicate your preferred type of music with a 1, your second favorite with a 2, and so on for each type of music: ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ Heavy Metal Alternative Urban Contemporary Classical Country Instructions Rank the various brands of toothpaste in order of preference. Begin by picking out the one brand that you like most and assign it a number 1. Then find the second most preferred- brand and assign it a number 2. Continue this procedure until you have ranked all the brands of toothpaste in order of preference. The least preferred brand should be assigned a rank of 10. No two brands should receive the same rank number. The criterion of preference is entirely up to you. There is no right or wrong answer. Just try to be consistent. Brand Rank Order 1. Crest 2. Colgate 3. Aim 4. Mentadent 5. Macleans 6. Ultra Brite 7. Close Up 8. Pepsodent 9. Plus White 10. Arm and Hammer COMPARATIVE SCALES Compared to Chevrolet, Ford is: less innovative 1 about the same 2 3 4 more innovative 5 6 7 Non comparative scale Continuous scale • How would you rate Marketing Research to other courses this term The worst X X 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 The Best Itemized Rating Scales Semantic Differential Scale The Likert scale Staple scale Non-Comparative Scales Non-Comparative Scales Semantic Differential Scale Here are a number of statements that could be used to describe WalMart. For each statement tick ( X ) the box that best describes your feelings about WalMart. Modern Store Old- fashioned store Low prices High prices Unfriendly staff Friendly staff Narrow product range Wide product range Sophisticated customers Unsophisticated customers Semantic Differential Scale Snake Diagram X Modern Store Old- fashioned store X Low prices X Friendly staff - High prices Unfriendly staff Wide product range X Narrow product range Sophisticated customers X Unsophisticated customers Key : Sears X WalMart Itemised Rating Scales Semantic differential Old X Fashioned 1 Modern 2 3 4 2 3 X 4 2 X 3 Cheap 1 Friendly service 1 4 5 Expensive 5 5 Unfriendly service Itemised Rating Scales Likert scale Cost is the most important consideration when buying a new car Strongly agree disagree Neither agree nor disagree agree Strongly agree 1 2 3 4 5 Itemised Rating Scales The Likert scale AGREEMENT •Strongly Agree •Agree •Undecided •Disagree •Strongly Disagree •Agree Very Strongly •Agree Strongly •Agree •Disagree •Disagree Strongly •Disagree Very Strongly •Agree Strongly •Agree Moderately •Agree Slightly •Disagree Slightly •Disagree Moderately •Disagree Strongly •Yes •No •Agree •Disagree •Agree •Undecided •Disagree •Completely Agree •Mostly Agree •Slightly Agree •Slightly Disagree •Mostly Disagree •Completely •Disagree •Disagree Strongly •Disagree •Tend to Disagree •Tend to Agree •Agree •Agree Strongly FREQUENCY •Very Frequently •Frequently •Occasionally •Rarely •Very Rarely •Never •Always •Very Frequently •Occasionally •Rarely •Very Rarely •Never •Always •Usually •About Half the Time •Seldom •Never •A Great Deal •Much •Somewhat •Little •Never •Often •Sometimes •Seldom •Never •Always •Very Often •Sometimes •Rarely •Never •Almost Always •To a Considerable Degree •Occasionally •Seldom IMPORTANCE •Very Important •Important •Moderately Important •Of Little Importance •Unimportant •Very Important •Moderately Important •Unimportant QUALITY •Very Good •Good •Barely Acceptable •Poor •Very Poor •Extremely Poor •Below Average •Average •Above Average •Excellent •Good •Fair •Poor LIKELIHOOD •Like Me •Unlike Me •To a Great Extent •Somewhat •Very Little •Not at All •True •False •Definitely •Very Probably •Probably •Possibly •Probably Not •Very Probably Not •Almost Always True •Usually True •Often True •Occasionally True •Sometimes But Infrequently True •Usually Not True •Almost Never True •True of Myself •Mostly True of Myself •About Halfway True of Myself •Slightly True Of Myself •Not at All True of Myself Itemised Rating Scales Staple scale +5 +5 +4 +4 +3 +3 +2 +2 +1 +1 High quality Poor service -1 -1 -2 -2 -3 -3 -4 -4 -5 -5 A Stapel Scale for Measuring a Store’s Image Select a plus number for words that you think describe the store accurately. The more accurately you think the work describes the store, the larger the plus number you should choose. Select a minus number for words you think do not describe the store accurately. The less accurately you think the word describes the store, the larger the minus number you should choose, therefore, you can select any number from +3 for words that you think are very accurate all the way to -3 for words that you think are very inaccurate. WalMart +5 +5 +5 +4 +4 +4 +3 +3 +3 +2 +2 +2 +1 +1 +1 High Poor Wide Quality Service Variety -1 -1 -1 -2 -2 -2 -3 -3 -3 -4 -4 -4 -5 -5 -5 Staple Scale The following questions concern your ratings of several suppliers that provide products for use in your store. XYZ Poor Product Selection -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 1 2 3 4 5 Costly Products -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 1 2 3 4 5 Fast Service -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 1 2 3 4 5 High Quality Products -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 1 2 3 4 5 Innovative -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 1 2 3 4 5 Some Basic Considerations When Selecting a Scale Selecting a Rating, Ranking, Sorting, or Purchase Intent Scale Number of Categories Forced Versus Non-forced Choice Odd or Even Number of Scale Categories Balanced Versus Nonbalanced Alternatives Odd versus even if neutral responses likely, use odd number Odd Even Strongly Agree _____ Strongly Agree_____ Agree _____ Agree _____ Neutral _____ Disagree _____ Disagree _____ Strongly disagree___ Strongly disagree_____ Balanced vs. Unbalanced Balanced Unbalanced Very good ______ Excellent ______ Good ______ Very Good ______ Fair ______ Good ______ Poor ______ Fair ______ Very Poor ______ Poor ______ Balanced and Unbalanced Scales Balanced Scale Unbalanced Scale JOVAN MUSK FOR MEN IS JOVAN MUSK FOR MEN IS Extremely good Very good Good Bad Very bad Extremely bad Extremely good Very good Somewhat Good Good Bad Very bad Forced vs. Unforced Unforced Forced Extremely Reliable ___ Extremely Reliable ___ Very Reliable ___ Very Reliable ___ Somewhat Reliable ___ Somewhat Reliable ___ Somewhat Unreliable ___ Somewhat Unreliable ___ Very Unreliable ___ Very Unreliable ___ Extremely Unreliable ___ Extremely Unreliable ___ Don’t know ___ Labeled vs. End Anchored Labeled End Anchored Excellent _____ Very Good _____ _____ _____ Fair _____ _____ Poor _____ _____ Very Poor _____ Excellent Poor _____ Intervals May Not Reflect the Semantic Meaning of the Adjectives Excellent _____ Labeled Intervals Are Not Equal Excellent _____ Very Good _____ Very Good_____ Fair _____ Fair _____ Poor _____ Poor _____ Very Poor _____ Intervals Are Not Equal Very Poor _____ Number of Scale Points 5 Point Excellent 10 Point _____ Excellent _____________ _____________ _____ _____________ _____________ _____________ _____ _____________ _____________ _____ Poor _____ _____________ Poor _____________ _____________ Choosing the Appropriate Scale Attitude component Itemized category Rank Constant order sum Likert Semantic differential A Knowledge Awareness A Attribute beliefs A B B B Attribute importance A B A B Overall preferences A B A B B Specific attributes A B B B A A B A B Affect or Liking Action intentions A = Very appropriate, B = Sometimes appropriate Characteristics of Good Measurement Scales 1. Reliability • The degree to which a measure accurately captures a true outcome without error; Accuracy • synonymous with repetitive consistency 2. Validity • The degree to which a measure faithfully represents the underlying concept; Fidelity (it asks the right questions) 3. Sensitivity • The ability to discriminate meaningful differences between attitudes. The more categories the more sensitive (but less reliable) 4. Generalizability • How easy is scale to administer and interpret Validity and Reliability Reliability can be more easily determined than validity If it is reliable, it may or may not be valid If a measure is valid, it may or may not be reliable If it is not reliable, it cannot be valid If it is not valid, it may or may not be reliable Reliability and Validity Neither Reliable Nor Valid Reliable But Not Valid Reliable And Valid Example of low validity, high reliability • Scale is perfectly accurate, but is capturing the wrong thing; for example, it measures consumers’ interest in creative writing rather than preference for kinds of stationery. Example of modest validity, low reliability • Scale genuinely measures consumers’ interest in kinds of stationery, but poorly worded items, sloppy administration, data entry errors lead to random errors in data • Note that reliability sets an upper limit on validity -- a measure with a lot of errors is limited in how well it can capture a concept