Religion Religion is Notoriuosly difficult to define. But we have no difficulty in deciding whether something is Religious or not Or do we A Luba diviner and her client, performing a divination ritual, jointly hold a friction oracle known as a kakishi on a woven mat on the ground between them.. (John Pemberton) Albrecht Durer 1504 What makes these religious? The Major Features of Religion • Texts • Belief in the supernatural • Symbolic • Moral code • Sacred vs. profane • Emotional Experience • Group membership/identity • A means of explanation • Stress/Anxiety Relief • Body of myth • Rituals • Magic and witchcraft • System • supernatural Beings and powers • A philosophy • Specially skilled individuals Defining Religion Religion can be defined as any set of attitudes, beliefs, and practices pertaining to supernatural power, whether that power be forces, gods, spirits, ghosts, or demons. What is considered the supernatural varies from one society to the next. Many societies don’t have a separate word for religion--it is so integrated into politics, or cultural identity Explanations for the Universality of Religion Functional Psychological Intellectual Interpretative Sociological Emotional Intellectual approach primitive E. B. Tylor man was a rationalist and a scientific philosopher the notion of spirits was not the outcome of irrational thinking preliterate religious beliefs and practices were not “ridiculous” or a “rubbish heap of miscellaneous folly” they were essentially consistent and logical, based on rational thinking and empirical knowledge. Animism the idea that the world and everything in it is filled with souls or spirits. These spirits can be communicated with. Spirits “feel” and therefore, can be harmed, flattered, offended and can also hurt or help. Psychological Approach Reduces anxiety provides comfort Gives meaning to life – Yes there is life after death a means for dealing with crises death and illness, famine, flood, failure helps people cope with reality. Tells them how to behave Removes burden of responsibility Participation in religious ceremonies provides reassurance security, and even ecstasy, closeness etc Sociological Approach religion stems from society and societal needs and provides for them religions validate the social: they posit controlling forces in the universe that sustain the moral and social order of a people sanction human conduct by providing notions of right and wrong setting precedents for acceptable behaviour, group norms provides moral sanctions for individual conduct education function through ritual used to learn oral traditions eg. puberty rites provide information about tribal lore. Interpretative Sees religion as a set of symbols and stresses the meaning of those symbols, as referents and creators of meaningful life. "a religion is a system of symbols which acts to establish powerful, pervasive and long-lasting moods and motivations by formulating conceptions of a general order of existence and clothing these conceptions with such an aura of factuality that the moods and motivations seem uniquely realistic." “Clifford Geertz” Claude Levi-Strauss structuralism -- Analysis of symbolic forms of mythic Through the work of Douglas and Victor Turner, as well as performance theory, a new emphasis on ritual was established. Concerned with the act Coping with Uncertainty Magic, divination, oracles, and witchcraft MAGIC Nature is understood to be controlled by forces which can be manipulated Magic is a way of controlling the natural elements. Magicians attempt to control the elements for the benefit of their society or for the detriment of their enemies. Contagious Magic Sympathetic Magic Cave art used for rituals of this sort? Standing Bison, Altamira (Spain) c. 15,000-10,000 B.C What is divination? " the practice of foreseeing future events or acquiring hidden knowledge through supernatural means" Examples? Ordeals Omens Oracles An Azande diviner uses a friction oracle (iwa), holding his foot against the lower part to keep the instrument in place and rubbing the upper part against it. Witchcraft ‘the inherent power to harm other persons by supernatural means’ Evans-Pritchard Bewitched Sabrina Charmed Worst witch ever Practical Magic The Sorcerer’s Apprentice shell currency is used to purchase the services of sorcerers © Dorothy and David Counts Rituals Bathing in the Ganges “a ritual is a stereotyped sequence of activities involving gestures, words, or objects, performed in a sequestered place and designed to influence preternatural [magical] entities or forces on behalf of the actor’s goals or interests” Victor Turner Rituals rites and ceremonies Sometimes ritual reenact myths and stories. sometimes involve particular kind of attire, or a specific location. They could be the reliving of an important event. a patterned form of behavior, generally communal and consisting of prescribed actions and words Carnival Ten characteristics of rituals 1. They are by definition religious –involve magic, the supernatural 2. They are highly formalized or structured patterns of behaviour 3. rituals are belief in action 4. Out of the ordinary actions i.e. sacred 5. usually performed in a sequestered place 6. They have a goal or aim 7. They serve a function for the people concerned 8. They serve to provide a sense of solidarity 9. symbolic 10. multivocalic Types of Rituals •Calendrical rites •concerned with the natural world •seasonal •should guarantee success and wealth •raindance •Rites of transition or passage, life cycle •concerned with the social world •changes in the individual’s status, role or position •Critical or life-crisis rites •Curing and magic •Concerned with the individual •Ritual For Group Welfare 1. Mass 2. Communion 3. Feast Days Role and Function of Rituals Contact the Ultimate Reality Communicate with the Ultimate Reality Communicate to others (public vs. private) Help to develop relationship with the Ultimate Reality Effect human transformation Rituals “(E)veryday religious activity and practice are significant because their primary purpose often to place individuals, families, and groups in ‘right relationships’ with gods, ancestors, other human beings, and nature.” Rituals are ways in which these relationships can be insured. What is a rite of passage? Solomon Grundy Solomon Grundy, Born on Monday, Christened on Tuesday, Married on Wednesday, Took ill on Thursday, Worse on Friday, Died on Saturday, Buried on Sunday: This is the end Of Solomon Grundy Rites of passage are the mileposts or landmarks that guide travelers through the life cycle. Quinceanera The Rites of Passage (1908) 1. separation 2. transition 3. incorporation Arnold van Gennep (1873 - 1957) Young boys from Numbulwar with small spears; they will try to hit the men, who will then have to dance for them at their circumcision ceremony. Photo by Ludo Kuipers © OzOutback Internet Services Young initiates are carried to their elders on the ceremonial ground and will stay with them during the all-night "Mandiwala" dance before their circumcision. Photo by Ludo Kuipers © OzOutback Internet Services Initiates during their ceremony in Borroloola; they are looking at a long line of dancers that will dance closely around them and take them to the ceremony ground. Photo by Ludo Kuipers © OzOutback Internet Services A boy is painted with red ochre for his "Mandiwala" initiation ceremony. He wears a belt of human hair that was put on him at the start of his initiation. Photo by Ludo Kuipers © OzOutback Internet Services Boys are painted up for their "Mandiwala" initiation cermony, where the whole night the men will dance for them; their circumcision takes place early in the morning. Photo by Ludo Kuipers © OzOutback Internet Services "Daru" initiates in Borroloola. They are carrying small bark boomerangs with which they try to hit men who should later dance for them in their "Mandiwala" ceremony. Photo by Ludo Kuipers © OzOutback Internet Services Young initiates during a "Djapi" circumcision ceremony in Numbulwar, south eastern Arnhem Land, in which the boys are painted with their clan totemic designs. Photo by Ludo Kuipers © OzOutback Internet Services An initiate during a southern Arnhem Land circumcision ceremony; the boy is decorated with white clay and strings of feathers. Photo by Ludo Kuipers © OzOutback Internet Services A man's dance during an initiation ceremony in the early morning in Beswick, in the southern part of Arnhem Land. Photo by Ludo Kuipers © OzOutback Internet Services