PART I (OPEN TO THE PUBLIC) ITEM NO. REPORT OF: The Assistant Director (Procurement) TO: Lead Member Customer and Support Services ON: Monday 13 June 2005 TITLE : Procurement Co-ordination Team: Proposed Structure RECOMMENDATIONS : That the Lead Member approve the establishment of a Procurement Co-ordination Team in line with the proposed structure and the further actions required to allocate staff to the team either by the assimilation of staff from the existing Central Purchasing Team or, where necessary, by recruitment. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY : To support the modernisation and refocusing of procurement within Salford City Council, it is necessary to realign the structure of the centrally based purchasing staff to form a corporate unit capable of delivering the aims of the Procurement Strategy and to reinforce the advisory role now required of procurement functions. BACKGROUND DOCUMENTS : (available for public inspection) i. Structure Chart ii. Table of comparative costs iii. Job Descriptions ASSESSMENT OF RISK : 1. There is a high risk of a negative effect on the City Council’s CPA rating if an effective procurement strategy is not implemented. 2. There is a high risk of loss of benefits from a co-ordinated approach to procurement. 3. There is a risk that key policies (e.g., Small to Medium Enterprise and Third Sector Enterprise development) will suffer without an effective procurement team to support them. SOURCES OF FUNDING : Customer and Support Services Revenue Budget COMMENTS OF THE STRATEGIC DIRECTOR OF CUSTOMER AND SUPPORT SERVICES (or his representative) 1. LEGAL IMPLICATIONS Provided by : Alan R. Eastwood Deputy Director of Customer & Support Services and City Solicitor (0161) 793 3000) 2. FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS Provided by : John Spink, Head of Finance (0161) 793 3230 Geoff Topping, Assistant Director (Accountancy & Exchequer) (0161) 793 3240 PROPERTY (if applicable): N/A HUMAN RESOURCES (if applicable): CONTACT OFFICERs : Linda Bossons Senior Personnel Officer, Outstationed Teams (0161) 793 3968 Alan R. Eastwood Deputy Director of Customer & Support Services and City Solicitor (0161) 793 3000) Gary Amos, Assistant Director (Procurement) (0161) 793 3878 WARD(S) TO WHICH REPORT RELATE(S) : KEY COUNCIL POLICIES : All All DETAILS Current Situation: A corporate procurement strategy for 2005/2006 has been drafted and is in the process of ratification. However, a key element in the implementation of the strategy and the modernisation and refocusing of procurement will be the Procurement Coordination Team under the management of the Assistant Director (Procurement) and which is to be located within Law and Administration. The present central team is based around the central purchasing concept which, although originally effective, is inappropriate for the more modern approach advocated in the Byatt Report (2001) and the National Procurement Strategy (2003). However, the emphasis now is for a devolved approach to procurement, whereby Directorates are empowered to make their own procurement decisions and conduct their own procurement exercises, supported by a core procurement unit which would advise and guide them. This core function will be provided by the Procurement Co-ordination Team who will adopt a strategic role, having an overview of procurement activity across the City Council. As well as working closely with the City Council’s partner organisations, their scope would encompass the continued development of the procurement strategy and procurement policies as well as administering corporate procurement exercises. They would also be a key element in capacity building within the City Council and with local Small to Medium Enterprises and Voluntary Sector Organisations. Proposed Structure A significant aspect of local government procurement today is the way it reflects the evolutionary nature of the public sector. In order to support this new model, the revised structure allows for career development within the team and for team members to adopt more responsibility, essential in a consultancy role. They will also be required to display a greater level of initiative and independent action than in a traditional procurement organisation. The adoption of a career graded structure recognises this and is also important at a time when good procurement staff are becoming a sought after commodity. Retention of key staff is important to the success of the organisation and continuity of service performance. The aim is for mutually supporting elements within the team and there is deliberate overlap between job descriptions to encourage this. There should be sufficient resilience within the structure to respond to changing demands and enable the team to play an active role in supporting the City Council’s Seven Pledges. The new structure has been developed in consultation with the Deputy Director Customer and Support Services and City Solicitor, the Head of Finance, the Assistant Director (Accountancy & Exchequer) and the Senior Personnel Officer (Outstationed Teams). For information, both structures have been illustrated (see appendix 1). As regards recruitment to the Procurement Co-ordination team, it is intended that: The current Purchasing Manager (PO5) will be assimilated into the new post of Procurement Manager (PO5). The two new posts of Principal Procurement Officer (PO1/3) will, in the first instance, be ringfenced to the existing Purchasing team Leader (Contract Management) (SO2) and Team Leader (Processing) (SO2). If either or both of these people are unsuccessful in their applications, for the posts, they will be assimilated into Procurement Officer (SC3/SO2) posts or the F.S.G. Quality Controller (SO2) post and the Principal Procurement Officer vacancy(ies) advertised. The remaining new Procurement Officer (Sc3/SO2) posts will be ringfenced to the existing three Purchasing Officers (sc6) and four Purchasing Assistants (SC3) There will also be one Scale 6 and two Scale 3 posts available within the e-Trading Team which will adopt a broader role. This will involve: Administration of the purchase card programme and supplier liaison Requisitioner training Catalogue management System user support Master document maintenance The new post of F.S.G. Quality Controller (SO2) has been established to ensure the accurate processing of transactions by all F.S.G. teams by the development of and compliance with procedures, the implementation of audit recommendations and the provision of appropriate training. Selection Process Initially, the vacancies in Procurement Co-ordination will be ringfenced to members of Central Purchasing (including processing staff). The number of actual vacancies will be increased by the addition of three posts in the e-Trading Team. However, should any staff not be successful in securing a position in the Procurement Coordination or e-Trading teams, the conditions of the redeployment scheme will be applied. A meeting will be arranged to inform staff of the new staffing structure, at which copies of the new structure chart, job descriptions and person specifications will be circulated. The details of the new structure and the selection process will be presented to staff by the Assistant Director (Procurement) and the Assistant Director (Accountancy and Exchequer). Also present will be a representative from Human Resources and the appropriate trade union representative(s). Costs The financial summary (Appendix 2) shows the comparative costs of the two structures, which have been calculated at the maximum salary points as at 1 April 2005. For ease of reference, both the Procurement Co-ordination team and the eTrading team have been included. The total additional salary cost, calculated at the maximum of each grade, is £80,364 including oncost. However, based on the anticipated spinal column points at which staff will be appointed to the structure, the estimated additional salary cost for the first year will be in the region of £40,623 including oncost, rising incrementally each year as appropriate. These additional salary costs will be funded from procurement savings achieved by the Procurement Co-ordination team Appendix 1 Structure Charts Central Purchasing Team (Existing Structure) Purchasing Manager PO4 Purchasing Team Leader (Contract Management) SO2 Purchasing Officer SC6 Team Leader (Processing) SO2 Purchasing Officer SC6 Purchasing Assistant SC3 Purchasing Assistant SC3 Purchasing Officer SC6 Purchasing Assistant SC3 Purchasing Assistant SC3 Procurement Co-ordination Team (Proposed Structure ) Assistant Director (Procurement) Procurement Manager PO5 Principal Procurement Officer PO1/3 Procurement Officer SC3/SO2 Procurement Officer SC3/SO2 Principal Procurement Officer PO1/3 Procurement Officer SC3/SO2 Procurement Officer SC3/SO2 E-Trading Team (Proposed Structure ) e-Trading Manager PO5 Development Officer SO1 Purchase System Management Officer SC6 Admin Assistant SC3 Development Officer SO1 Admin Assistant SC3 FSG Quality Controller SO2 Admin Assistant SC3 Appendix 2 Costs CUSTOMER AND SUPPORT SERVICES DIRECTORATE PROCUREMENT TEAM CURRENT PROPOSED Post Title Grade No * Cost Car Allow Procurement (Law and Admin) Assistant Director (Procurement) FINANCIAL SUMMARY Post Title Car Allow Comments 46,128 Casual No Change 1 36,402 Casual 2 63,114 Casual 4 104,628 Casual New Post New Posts New Posts Grade No * Cost Procurement Coordination Team Band J 1 46,128 Casual Assistant Director (Procurement) Band J Procurement Manager PO5 Principal Procurement Officer PO1/3 Procurement Officer Sc3/SO2 1 Purchasing Team (FSG) Purchasing Manager Purchasing Team Leader PO5 SO2 1 2 36,402 52,314 Purchasing Officer Sc6 3 64,962 Purchasing Assistant Sc3 4 61,488 E-Trading Team (FSG) E-Trading Manager Development Officers Admin Assistant ) Postholders to be given ) opportunity to apply for above ) posts that will be ringfenced to ) these in the first instance E-Trading Team (FSG) PO5 SO1 Sc3 1 2 1 36,402 48,000 15,372 E-Trading Manager FSG Quality Controller Development Officers Purchase System Management Admin Assistant 15 361,068 * at grade max Increased cost at maximum of grades Oncost Total increased cost at maximun PO5 SO2 SO1 Sc6 Sc3 1 1 2 1 3 36,402 26,157 48,000 21,654 46,116 16 428,601 67,533 12,831 80,364 CUSTOMER AND SUPPORT SERVICES DIRECTORATE PROCUREMENT TEAM CURRENT PROPOSED Post Title Grade No * Cost Car Allow Procurement (Law and Admin) Assistant Director (Procurement) FINANCIAL SUMMARY - Based on Probable appointed grades Post Title Cost Car Allow Comments 1 46,128 Casual No Change 1 2 34,746 54,822 Casual Casual New Post New Posts 4 81,180 Casual New Posts Grade No Procurement Coordination Team Band J 1 46,128 Casual Assistant Director Band J (Procurement) Procurement Manager PO5 Principal Procurement PO1/3 Officer Procurement Officer Sc3/SO2 Purchasing Team (FSG) Purchasing Manager Purchasing Team Leader PO5 SO2 1 2 36,402 52,314 Purchasing Officer Sc6 3 64,962 Purchasing Assistant Sc3 4 61,488 E-Trading Team (FSG) E-Trading Manager Development Officers Admin Assistant ) Postholders to be given ) opportunity to apply for above ) posts that will be ringfenced to ) these in the first instance E-Trading Team (FSG) PO5 SO1 Sc3 1 2 1 36,402 48,000 15,372 E-Trading Manager FSG Quality Controller Development Officers Purchase System Management Admin Assistant 15 361,068 * at grade max Increased cost Oncost Total increased cost PO5 SO2 SO1 Sc6 1 1 2 1 36,402 26,157 48,000 21,654 Sc3 3 46,116 16 395,205 34,137 6,486 40,623