PLANNING AND TRANSPORTATION REGULATORY PANEL
20th October, 2011
Meeting commenced:
“
ended:
9:30 a.m.
10:20 a.m.
PRESENT: Councillor Clague – In the Chair
Councillors Antrobus, K. Garrido, Kean, Lea, McIntyre, Ord, Tope,
L. Turner and R. Wilson
Mr. J. Wheelton
88.
APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE
Apologies for absence were submitted on behalf of Councillors Heywood, Mold, Potter
and G. Wilson.
89.
DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST
There were no declarations of interest.
90.
MINUTES OF PROCEEDINGS
RESOLVED: THAT the minutes of the meeting of the Planning and Transportation
Regulatory Panel, held on 6th October, 2011, be approved as a correct record.
91.
APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING PERMISSION
(Full details of the matters referred to in this Minute are contained in the report of the
Strategic Director for Sustainable Regeneration, as amended, in the case of the
applications marked * in the supplementary report).
RESOLVED: (1) THAT it be noted that planning applications 11/60817/LBC and
11/60852/PRI, which both related to the Railway Bridge Over River Irwell To West Of
Wilburn Street/Trinity Way Salford, were both located in the Ordsall ward, and not in
different wards, as indicated in the above report.
(2) THAT it be noted that, following consideration by the Panel, the undermentioned applications for planning permission were determined, subject to the
conditions, as indicated below:Application
Number/Applicant
*11/60665/FUL
Mr. John Lloyd
D:\726869690.doc
Site
Development
Decision
139 Fir Street
Cadishead
M44 5AQ
Demolition of existing
outbuildings and
single storey lean-to.
Change of use of
existing house to two
apartments and
Granted. In
considering the
application it was
requested that the
Building Control
Division be
Planning & Transportation Regulatory Panel – 20th October 2011
Application
Number/Applicant
11/608171/LBC
Network Rail
Infrastructure Ltd
D:\726869690.doc
Site
Railway Bridge
over River Irwell to
West of Wilburn
Street/Trinity Way,
Salford
Development
Decision
construction of two
dwelling houses (Resub of 11/60204/FUL)
contacted to clarify
if any additional
soundproofing is
required between
the proposed
apartments and the
adjacent semi
detached house
Granted.
Listed Building
Consent for the
erection of one steel
portal structure to
bridge in connection
with electrification of
the railway
2
Planning & Transportation Regulatory Panel – 20th October 2011
Application
Number/Applicant
*11/60830/FUL
Salford Student
LLP
D:\726869690.doc
Site
Development
Decision
Former Riverside
House
1 St. Simon Street
Salford
M3 7ET
Erection of student
accommodation
comprising 242
bedrooms with
ancillary
accommodation
including 15 car
parking spaces
together with
associated creation of
new vehicular access
and alterations to
existing vehicular
access and
landscaping. Variation
of condition 12
amended elevations
and site layout on
planning permission
03/46609/FUL
Granted on the
basis that a material
start on the site has
occurred and
subject to the
addition of the
following
conditions:- (i) the
submission and
approval of an
appropriate crime
prevention plan and
(ii) ensuring the
development is not
vulnerable to
flooding, particularly
in relation to the
wall bordering the
site and adjacent to
the River Irwell and
whether any
improvements are
required to this.
In considering the
application,
reference was also
made to the
materials proposed
for the elevations of
the development,
which it was
suggested were too
dark and could give
the building an
austere
appearance. The
Strategic Director
for Sustainable
Regeneration was
asked to raise these
concerns with the
applicant when
agreeing the
materials to be
used.
3
Planning & Transportation Regulatory Panel – 20th October 2011
Application
Number/Applicant
11/60852/PRI
Network Rail
Infrastructure Ltd
92.
Site
Development
Decision
Railway Bridge
over River Irwell to
West of Wilburn
Street/Trinity Way,
Salford
Prior approval for the
erection of one steel
portal structure to
bridge in connection
with electrification of
the railway
Granted.
PLANNING APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY
The Strategic Director of Sustainable Regeneration submitted a report containing
details of planning applications which he had determined under delegated authority
during September and October, 2011, and were not, therefore, for consideration by the
Panel.
RESOLVED: (1) THAT it be noted that planning application 11/60547/HH (14 Bramley
Close, Swinton M27 0DR) had been included in the above report in error as the
application had been considered and approved by the Planning & Transportation
Regulatory Panel at the meeting held on 6th October, 2011.
(2) That the decisions in respect of the under-mentioned applications be
noted:Application Number/
Applicant
11/60683/FUL
Mr. R. Warburton
Site
Development
Equip Tyre &
Autocare
223-227
Liverpool
Road, Eccles
M30 0QW
Erection of a rear
extension
11/60803/HH
Mr. B. Walsh
106 Standfield
Drive, Worsley
M28 1WB
Erection of a two
storey side/rear
extension and a single
storey rear extension
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60607/FUL
Asda
Netto Food
Store, Gt.
Cheetham
Street East,
Salford M7
4UF
Installation of a new
ATM and new plant
and enclosure
Approved
30 September
2011
D:\726869690.doc
Decision and Date
of Decision
Approved
27 September
2011
4
Planning & Transportation Regulatory Panel – 20th October 2011
Application Number/
Applicant
11/60608/ADV
Asda
Site
Development
Netto Food
Store, Great.
Cheetham
Street East,
Salford M7
4UF
Display of two
internally illuminated
fascia signs, once
ATM surround sign, 3
No. banners and 12
No. vinyl
advertisements to
inside of window
11/60732/COU
Mr. & Mrs. Patel
84 & 86
Devonshire
Street, Salford
M7 4AE
Change of use of part
of ground floor
residence (C3) to shop
(A1) re-sub of
11/59921/FUL
Approved
30 September
2011
11/60774/HH
Mr. Joseph Hershaft
6 St. Johns
Street
Salford
M7 2EA
Erection of a single
storey rear extension
(re-sub of
11/60375/HH)
Approved
7 October 2011
11/60860/DEMCON
Salford City Council
1-35 and 2-24
Cumberland
Street, Salford
M7 1GJ
Prior notification for
the demolition of 1-35
and 2-24 Cumberland
Street, Salford
No objections
5 October 2011
11/60863/DEMCON
Salford City Council
1-15
Fitzwilliam
Street, Salford
M7 1GL
Prior notification for
the demolition of 1-15
Fitzwilliam Street
No objections
5 October 2011
11/60764/HH
Mr. N. McPhee
21 Warwick
Road
Cadishead
M44 5HE
Demolition of existing
conservatory and
erection of single
storey side and rear
extension
Approved
3 October 2011
11/60815/HH
Mr. M. Davies
7 Rixtonleys
Drive, Irlam
M44 6RN
Erection of a two
storey side extension
and part single, part
two storey rear
extension
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60841/HH
Mr. A. Wood
56 Rose
Avenue, Irlam
M44 6AG
Erection of a rear
conservatory
Approved
5 October 2011
D:\726869690.doc
Decision and Date
of Decision
Approved
30 September
2011
5
Planning & Transportation Regulatory Panel – 20th October 2011
Application Number/
Applicant
11/60700/COU
Mr. Greg Beswick –
Onlyaman Limited
Site
Development
249 Bolton
Road, Salford
M6 7HP
Change of use from
D1 to A1 shop
11/60824/FUL
Mrs. L. Howard – Light
Oaks Junior School
Lights Oaks
Junior School,
Lancaster
Road, Salford
M6 8LU
Erection of a detached
shelter
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60394/FUL
Monton Village
Mr. J. Bagnall – Monton School,
Village School
Francis Street,
Eccles M30
9PR
11/60563/HH
21 Half Edge
Mr. Bernard Fanning
Lane, Eccles
M30 9AY
Remove existing
portacabin and
erection of a single
storey side extension
Approved
7 October 2011
Demolition of existing
front conservatory and
erection of a new front
conservatory
Approved
7 October 2011
11/60747/FUL
Mr. Daniel Schofield
259 Monton
Road, Eccles
M30 9PS
Erection of a 3 storey
side and rear
extension to provide
an office and
workshop extension
and facilitate the
creation of 3 self
contained flats
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60748/ADV
Mr. Daniel Schofield
259 Monton
Road, Eccles
M30 9PS
Display of an advert
hoarding on the new
gable wall
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60705/FUL
Mr. Nigel Sedman –
City West Housing
Trust
38 The De
Traffords,
Irlam
M44 6LP
Erection of a single
storey extension to
front elevation,
alterations to
elevations,
reconfiguration of
existing car parking
area and provision of
hardstanding to front
and rear
Approved
28 September
2011
D:\726869690.doc
Decision and Date
of Decision
Approved
27 September
2011
6
Planning & Transportation Regulatory Panel – 20th October 2011
Application Number/
Applicant
11/60889/DEMCON
Salford City Council –
Mr. B. Enright
Site
Development
Recreation
Centre,
Holland Walk,
Salford M6
6FW
Prior notification for
the demolition of
Olivers Gym, Holland
Walk, Salford
11/60769/COU
SRC Transatlantic Ltd
38 Hankinson
Way, Salford
M6 5JA
Change of use from
(A1) retail to (A2)
financial and
professional
Approved
30 September
2011
11/60659/FUL
Mr. E. Burrows – Peel
Land & Property Ltd
3 Ohio Avenue
Salford
M50 2GT
Change of use from
office (B1) to day
nursery (D1) including
the conversion of part
of the existing car park
to play area and
erection of 2m high
fencing
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60673/FUL
Mr. Mark Spavin –
Bruntwood
Aldine House
New Bailey
Street, Salford
M3 5EU
Erection of a single
storey front extension
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60723/ADV
EH Booth & Co Ltd
Booths
Supermarket,
Media City,
Salford M50
2BS
Display of one
internally illuminated
totem pole, one
internally illuminated
fascia sign and
advertisements to
awnings
Approved
30 September
2011
D:\726869690.doc
Decision and Date
of Decision
No objections
5 October 2011
7
Planning & Transportation Regulatory Panel – 20th October 2011
Application Number/
Applicant
11/60708/LBC
Mr. David Cohen –
Adam Geoffrey
Management
Site
Development
Conavon
Court,
Blackfriars
Street, Salford
Extension of time limit
for implementation of
planning permission
04/49487/LBC. Listed
Building Consent for
internal and external
alterations to the
existing building,
cleaning of the interior
and exterior and the
erection of a part
single/part ten storey
rear extension and
four storey side
extension re-sub of
11/60328/LBC
11/60713/ADV
Flaircourt Properties
Riverside
House, Irwell
Street, Salford
M3 5EN
Display of a 1:1 shroud Approved
of the image of the
30 September
façade of the building
2011
and an externally
illuminated
advertisement
11/60743/ADV
Orbit Investments
(Salford) Ltd
Lowry
Designer
Outlet, The
Quays, Salford
Unit T2,
Residential
Tower Phase
1, Lowry
Designer
Outlet Mall,
Salford Quays,
Salford 5
Display of two
internally illuminated
fascia signs
Corner of
Chapel Street
& Blackfriars
Street, Salford
M3 7AA
Display of one
externally illuminated
hoarding sign and two
internally illuminated
hoarding signs
11/60742/COU
Orbit Investments
(Salford) Ltd
11/60805/ADV
Mr. S. Sweeney –
Primesight
D:\726869690.doc
Decision and Date
of Decision
Refused
30 September
2011
Approved
5 October 2011
Extension of time limit Approved
for the implementation 30 September
of planning permission 2011
08/56880/COU change
of use to office (B1)
and/or non-residential
institutions (D1)
Approved
7 October 2011
8
Planning & Transportation Regulatory Panel – 20th October 2011
Application Number/
Applicant
11/60519/HH
Mr. Motoshir Ali
Site
Development
4 Brierley
Road East
Swinton
M27 9TQ
Erection of a two
storey rear extension
Decision and Date
of Decision
Refused
11 October 2011
11/60719/COU
Mr. Filip Gryckiewicz
447 Chorley
Road, Swinton
M27 9LQ
Change of use from
retail to taxi booking
office
Approved
30 September
2011
11/60785/HH
Miss L Bowes
11 Harrowby
Road, Swinton
M27 5YR
Erection of a single
storey rear extension
Approved
30 September
2011
11/60691/HH
Mr. & Mrs. Payne
34 St. Georges
Crescent,
Salford M6
8JN
Demolition of existing
conservatory, partial
demolition of existing
single storey rear
element, erection of a
single storey side/rear
extension and
installation of solar
panels to side and rear
roofslopes
Approved
27 September
2011
11/60793/TPO
Mr. S. Charnock
2 Princeton
Close Salford
M6 8QL
Crown raise to provide
a 5m clearance from
the surrounding
ground level and 15%
crown thin two
sycamore trees (T1
and T2) and one silver
birch tree (T3)
Approved
28 September
2011
11/60770/FUL
Ms. Wendy Edge – The
Basic Charity
554 Eccles
New Road,
Salford M5
5AP
Installation of solar
panels to flat roof
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60828/HH
Mr. David Taylor – DKY
Developments Ltd
10 Verdun
Avenue,
Salford M6
8FS
Demolition of existing
garage and erection of
two storey side and
single storey rear
extension
Approved
7 October 2011
D:\726869690.doc
9
Planning & Transportation Regulatory Panel – 20th October 2011
Application Number/
Applicant
11/60714/HH
Mr. Ray Devine
Site
Development
15 Hastings
Road, Eccles
M30 8JR
Demolition of existing
single storey element
and erection of a two
storey side and rear
extension and a single
storey rear extension
11/60735/HH
Mr. & Mrs. G. McKevitt
9 Leamington
Road, Eccles
M30 8NE
Demolition of existing
conservatory and
erection of a single
storey side/rear
extension and
construction of access
ramp
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60649/CLUDP
Mr. Mark Thorpe
403 Moss
Lane, Worsley
M28 3NE
Permitted
development
4 October 2011
11/60731/HH
Mr. Sabry Shaaban
12 Brackley
Street,
Worsley
M28 3GU
Certificate of
lawfulness for erection
of outbuilding as
shown on the following
drawings 2947:05 Rev
A proposed
outbuilding, 2947:07
Rev A proposed site
and location plan
Erection of a single
storey side/rear
extension, erection of
car port to side and
front porch
11/60799/COU
Mrs. V. Scotton
66-68 Trafford
Drive
Little Hulton
M38 9QB
Change of use from
children’s home (C2)
to residential (C3)
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60677/HH
Mrs. Paula Preston
64 Houghton
Lane, Swinton
M27 0FB
Erection of an infill
extension between
existing kitchen and
garage, conversion of
garage to living and
construction of a new
pitched roof
Approved
5 October 2011
D:\726869690.doc
Decision and Date
of Decision
Approved
27 September
2011
Approved
30 September
2011
10
Planning & Transportation Regulatory Panel – 20th October 2011
Application Number/
Applicant
11/60698/HH
Miss Jacqui Hall
Site
Development
6 Lyon Grove
Worsley
M28 2RH
Demolition of existing
single storey outrigger
and erection of a part
single, part two storey
side/rear extension
11/60721/HH
Mr. Terry Wood
38 Poplar
Road, Swinton
M27 0HL
Erection of a single
storey side and rear
extension
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60722/HH
Mr. David Jones
1 Ryecroft
Lane
Worsley
M28 2PN
Installation of solar
panels to flat roof and
garden area
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60736/FUL
Esso Petroleum
Service Station
315 Walkden
Road, Worsley
M28 2RZ
Replacement of
existing fuelling
facilities including
storage tanks, vents,
lines and pump islands
Approved
30 September
2011
11/60745/HH
Mr. T. Worthington
37 Poplar
Road
Swinton
M27 0HL
Demolition of existing
utility room and
erection of a two
storey side/rear
extension
Approved
5 October 2011
11/60398/HH
Mr. A. Cobley
57 Hilton Lane
Worsley
M28 0SY
Erection of a two
storey side and single
storey rear extension
Approved
27 September
2011
11/60660/HH
Keith Carruthers
2 Mere Bank
Erection of a boundary
Close, Worsley fence
M28 0AS
Refused
30 September
2011
11/60765/HH
Mr & Mrs Carroll
1 Park Grove
Worsley
M28 7EB
Approved
3 October 2011
D:\726869690.doc
Demolition of existing
side extension and
erection of a tow
storey side extension
and a single storey
rear extension
Decision and Date
of Decision
Approved
28 September
2011
11
Planning & Transportation Regulatory Panel – 20th October 2011
93. PLANNING APPEALS
The Strategic Director for Sustainable Regeneration submitted a report providing
details of appeals that had been received and determined during September, 2011.
RESOLVED: THAT the report be noted
94.
SALFORD CITY COUNCIL TREE PRESERVATION ORDERS
The Strategic Director for Sustainable regeneration submitted reports seeking (a)
confirmation of Salford City Council Tree Preservation Order (TPO) (No. 458) 2011
(Ryecroft Lane, Worsley and Land to the Rear) and (b) a variation to Salford City
Council Tree Preservation Order (TPO) (No. 344) 2006 (Land Bounded by Eccles
New Road and Howard Street, Salford).
RESOLVED: THAT approval be given to the confirmation of and variation to, the
respective Salford City Council Tree Preservation Orders as detailed above.
D:\726869690.doc
12