Running head: RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A Title of research project set centered and double-spaced in uppercase and lowercase approximately 3-½ in. from the top of the page. Be sure to set the running head in ALL CAPS flush left in the header. Be sure the pagination (page number) is set flush right in the header. Use small Roman numerals for introductory matter (title page, contents page, etc.) and Arabic numerals for text pages. Only the first page contains the identifier “Running head:”. A Template for the Master of Education Option A Research Report Vince Aleccia Eastern Washington University Your name and institutional affiliation set centered and double-spaced in uppercase and lowercase directly below title of the research project. Presented to the Department of Education of Eastern Washington University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Master of Education June 10, 2016 Institutional details and date of submission set centered and double-spaced in uppercase and lowercase approximately 6-½ in. from the top of the page. i RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A Contents ii Please note that each Level 2 heading is indented the same. CHAPTER 1 ....................................................................................................................................1 Introduction ......................................................................................................................................1 Significance of the Study .......................................................................................................1 Statement of the Research Problem .......................................................................................2 Research Questions ................................................................................................................3 Limitations of the Study.........................................................................................................4 Definition of Terms................................................................................................................4 On the Importance of the Content Page(s) .............................................................................5 A Note on Option A ...............................................................................................................6 Some Formatting Pointers......................................................................................................6 CHAPTER 2 ....................................................................................................................................7 Literature Review.............................................................................................................................7 Your First Level 2 Heading ...................................................................................................8 This is a Level 3 heading ............................................................................................8 This is another Level 3 heading ..................................................................................8 Your Second Level 2 Heading ...............................................................................................9 Your Third Level 2 Heading ..................................................................................................9 Some Writing Strategies to Consider ...................................................................................10 Conclusion ...........................................................................................................................12 CHAPTER 3 ..................................................................................................................................13 Project Design ................................................................................................................................13 Type of Design and Underlying Assumptions .....................................................................13 Please note that each Level 3 heading is indented the same. RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A iii Qualifications and Assumptions of the Researcher .............................................................14 Participants and Site .............................................................................................................14 Concerning Level 3 headings.....................................................................................15 Description of site ......................................................................................................15 Data Collection ....................................................................................................................16 Data Analysis .......................................................................................................................16 A Final Note .........................................................................................................................17 CHAPTER 4 ..................................................................................................................................18 Project Implementation and Analysis ............................................................................................18 Description of the Project ....................................................................................................18 Changes Made ......................................................................................................................18 Data Collection ....................................................................................................................19 Data Analysis .......................................................................................................................20 Challenges Experienced .......................................................................................................21 Final Information on Tables and Figures .............................................................................21 CHAPTER 5 ..................................................................................................................................22 Conclusions and Reflections ..........................................................................................................22 What to Do Differently Next Time ......................................................................................22 Reflections on My Own Growth ..........................................................................................23 A Note on References ..........................................................................................................23 Suggested Length of the Research Report ...........................................................................23 REFERENCES ..............................................................................................................................24 APPENDICES ...............................................................................................................................25 RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A iv Appendix A—Letter to Parents ...........................................................................................26 Appendix B—Student Survey .............................................................................................27 Please note that the page numbers are aligned right. This can be easily done using the Tabs menu located under the Format pull-down menu. RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A v Tables Table 1—NBCT Responses to “I perform work that suits my values” .........................................20 RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A vi Abstract Immediately after the contents page (or list of tables and/or figures, if your research report requires them), you will insert an abstract. This is a passage of about 150 words that conveys what your research report addresses. In broad strokes, provide the reader with a summary of your study and your findings. You likely will reveal the type of research methodology (or methodologies) you used, whether qualitative, quantitative, or mixed. Use active voice, avoid technical jargon if at all possible, and be as parsimonious as possible with your words. Set the label centered 1 in. from the top of the page in bold. Be sure the text of your abstract is set double-space, like everything else in your research report. This is the last introductory component before you begin the first chapter. Because it appears before the text of your research report, the abstract is not listed on the contents page(s). RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A Please note that the chapter designator is set centered in all caps bold 2 inches from the top of the page. This is done for all chapters. CHAPTER 1 1 Please note that the title of the chapter (a Level 1 heading) is set centered in bold caps and lower case double-spaced under the chapter designator. This, too, is done for all chapters. Introduction The first chapter of your Option A research report for the MEd program provides an overview and framework of the project for your reader. It should consist of six sections: (a) introduction, (b) significance of the study, (c) statement of the research problem, (d) research questions, (e) limitations of the study, and (f) definitions of terms. As with the other chapters of your research project, the first section, which serves as an introduction, does not have a Level 2 heading. Hence, it begins as this paragraph does: indented but otherwise unadorned. Be sure to paginate in the upper-right corner with a running head in the upper-left. (The first chapter will normally begin with “1” for the pagination; the introductory pages such as the title page, contents page, and pages containing lists of tables or figures will be paginated using lower-case Roman numerals [i, ii, iii, etc.].) You may wish to cite specific sources that you’ve encountered in your research that will convey the essence of the background of your research project. When you have provided the appropriate overview and background for the reader, you will then need to provide the reader with an advance organizer. A listing of the sections as given in the second sentence of this paragraph will suffice. Use APA seriation for elements within a paragraph for this listing as discussed on page 64 of the Publication Manual. Once you’ve given your reader a sufficient introduction, you’re ready to continue with the rest of your first chapter. Significance of the Study Please note the use and format of this Level 2 heading. In this section, you should explain why this study is important. If, for example, you will focus on the importance of teaching study skills to incoming high school freshmen, you need to RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 2 ask yourself questions about the importance of this topic. Have student scores on standardized assessments lagged in a particular area? Do students need remediation in notetaking or other study skills? Do students need additional structure in working productively in cooperative groups? How could your research study improve the situation or condition of students, teachers, or education in general? You may wish to cite specific studies that you encounter in your review of literature that address the significance of your research project. As Glatthorn and Joyner (2005) suggested, a professionally significant study can contribute in one or more of these ways: test a theory, contribute to the development of theory, extend existing knowledge, change prevailing beliefs, suggest relationships between phenomena, extend a research methodology or instrument, or provide greater depth of knowledge about a previously studied phenomenon. (p. 114) In essence, this section answers the imperative question “So what?” that is crucial to understanding the significance of your research study. If you’re clear about the answer to “So what?”, then you’ll have a better understanding of why you’re conducting your study and, just as importantly, so will your reader. Statement of the Research Problem Please note the use and format of this long (40+ words) quote. The period appears after the last word of the quote, not after the parenthetical cite. Begin this section with a statement that starts “The purpose of this research project is to….” Because this statement encapsulates the essence of your research project, you should take great care in making it as complete as possible. As with the other sections of your first chapter, you may wish to cite specific sources that address some aspect of the purpose of your research project. An example of this is the long quote from Glatthorn and Joyner (2005) used in the previous section. Please note that with an indented long quote, quotation marks at the beginning RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 3 and end of the quote should not be used. The indentation of the quote serves as the typographical indicator that the passage is a quotation. Research Questions This section of your first chapter provides the reader with the specific questions your research project will address. You will need a sentence or two that introduces your research questions such as “To determine the effectiveness of teaching study skills to ninth-grade students during their first quarter of high school, I will examine the following questions….” When you list your research questions, be sure to number them with Arabic numerals followed by a period. (See pages 63-64 of the Publication Manual for a rationale and more detailed explanation.) Here is an example of this format: 1. What study skills do entering freshmen have? 2. To what extent does training in study skills improve the academic grades of students who are exposed to this training? 3. Do entering freshmen who are not given training in study skills perform better than, as well as, or less well than students who are exposed to this training? The scope and sequence of these questions are crucial as they form the major focus of your research project. Be sure they’re in the most logical order. This is also important because your research questions will almost certainly be tied to the sections of your literature review in the second chapter. Also, be thinking about what type or types of data you will use to answer the questions. Creating research questions without thinking about the data sources to use in answering them is one of the most common mistakes beginning researchers make. In addition, you will examine how you answered these questions in your final chapter of your research study. Thus, they serve as structural bookends that mark the focus and results of your research project RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 4 in the first and last chapters. When you have finished listing your research questions, you’re ready to move on to the next section in your first chapter. Limitations of the Study This section should make clear exactly what your research project will address as well as what it won’t. If, for example, your research project will examine the impact of study skills on entering freshman students at a high school, then be sure to indicate that you will not look at the impact of study skills on other students in the school. If your research project will examine only two sections of students in an experimental-control group structure, be sure to indicate that the research project will not affect all freshman students. Other limitations may include factors that you have no direct control over such as a budget cut in the middle of the year that affects the planned outcome of your research project. It’s imperative that your reader knows exactly what you plan to address in your study and what you plan to leave out. As with so much else in life, accurate framing of what your study will and will not address is crucial. Definition of Terms One of the most important hallmarks of academic writing—or any writing for that matter—is precision. You may well use terms that you encounter in your review of the literature that are employed in specific ways in your research project. Thus, for the sake of clarity, be sure to define these terms precisely for your reader. After your Level 2 heading, and before you list your terms, be sure to indicate why you’re operationalizing these terms. For example, “It’s essential that the reader knows exactly what is meant by some specialized terms that appear in this research report. To give the reader that information, a list of terms follows with their specific definitions as they apply to this study.” When you define a term, please begin with a paragraph indentation and then list the term in boldface followed by a colon. End each definition with a RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 5 period. If you are using a term as defined by a researcher, be sure to cite the source at the end of your definition. Please follow this formatting precisely, and be sure to list your terms in alphabetical order. Here are three examples for you: National Board Certified Teacher: an accomplished teacher who has demonstrated professional mastery through certification by the National Board for Professional Teaching Standards. Such a teacher is referred to as an NBCT. National Board certified teachers receive certification in a specific subject are (for example, mathematics or art) and at a specific development level (for example, Early Adolescence [EA] or Adolescence and Young Adulthood [AYA]). Professional Development School: a school, usually an elementary school, with ties to a college or university teacher-training program that serves as a laboratory for training teachers and, often, teacher leaders. Role Conflict: the incompatibility or incongruency a teacher leader experiences in performing professional duties—especially as they pertain to tension between (a) the teacher leader’s internal standards or values and the defined role behavior; (b) the time or resources and the defined role behavior; (c) several roles the teacher leader must assume and the accompanying changes in behavior each role requires; and (d) institutional demands and requests from others, including co-workers and supervisors (Rizzo, House, & Lirtzman, 1970). On the Importance of the Contents Page(s) The contents page or pages of your research report are more than simply a list of the chapters and sections of your report. They serve as an integral structural device that provides the organizing principle for the entire report. In essence, a well-structured contents page or pages also doubles as an outline. The reader can readily consult it to determine the hierarchical RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 6 relationships between Level 2 headings within a chapter as well as any Level 3 headings (or, if necessary, Level 4 headings) and their relationship with the appropriate Level heading which they support. Please be sure your contents page or pages serve this purpose. Carefully check that the Level 2 headings and Level 3 headings are organized correctly. Please ensure that you format your headings correctly. (See pages 62-63 of the Publication Manual for more information.) A Note on Option A This option of the MEd research report should focus on a product such as a curriculum unit or other independent variable that can make a difference for students and your institution— whether classroom, school, or district. It should be a topic that you are passionate about. You will, of course, spend a good deal of time on the research and writing of the report as well as designing the project, collecting the data, and analyzing them. Therefore, choose your project carefully as you will be living with it for a year (or more). Some Formatting Pointers When you set up your formatting defaults, be sure you have no additional space inserted when you hit the Return key. To check this, first click on the Paragraph pull-down menu. Then under Spacing be sure that both Before and After are set at 0 pt. Line spacing should also be set as Double. If you make these settings your default, you’ll never have to worry about this while you’re writing your research report. In addition, remember that APA style requires the use of the Oxford comma in a list. Be sure, moreover, that your double quotation marks are “smart quotes” (“x”) instead of inch markers ("x") and that your single quotation marks or apostrophes are also true single quotation markers or apostrophes (‘x’) instead of foot markers ('x'). These details will enhance the professional appearance of your finished research report. RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 7 CHAPTER 2 Literature Review The second chapter of your Option A research report for the MEd program encompasses a synthesis of the pertinent research literature that you have examined. It should consist of several sections including the following: (a) an introduction, (b) several segments of the literature review, and (c) a set of conclusions. The number of segments of the literature review itself will depend on the number of research questions you have for your research project. Ideally, each research question should be correlated to one of the sections of the literature review itself. For example, if your research project focuses on study skills of incoming high school freshmen—the example used in the sample first chapter—then your sections of the literature review should be aligned with your research questions. If your first research question deals with the study skills preparation that incoming freshmen have, then the appropriately related section of the literature review should be devoted to studies that address this topic and be labeled with a fitting Level 2 heading such as Study-Skills Preparation of Incoming Freshmen (set, of course, in boldface flush left). As with the other chapters of your research project, your introductory section will be without a Level 2 heading. Thus, it should begin as the first two paragraphs in this sample: indented but otherwise unadorned. Likewise, be sure to have your running head and pagination in the header. (Your second chapter will begin with the pagination number following the last page number of the first chapter. For example, if your last page of the first chapter was page 6, the first pagination number in your second chapter would be “7” as in this sample paper.) You RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 8 should also provide your reader with an advance organizer for the structure of this chapter, just as you did in the first chapter. You might model this advance organizer on the second sentence of the first paragraph above. Once you’ve completed your introductory section, you’re ready to tackle the main part of your literature review. Please note the use and format of these Level 3 headings. Your First Level 2 Heading This section of your literature review should be tied to one (and, ideally, the first) of your research questions. Remember that a literature review should not be merely a collection of annotations about sources. Rather, each section of your literature review should flow coherently using sources to bolster your points in that particular section. Be sure to cite your studies (either in text or parenthetically) using APA format. (See chapter 6, “Crediting Sources,” especially sections 6.11 through 6.21 [pages 174-179] in the Publication Manual for guidance.) In addition, be sure to keep a Level 2 heading connected to at least the first two lines of text that the heading introduces. Separating a heading on one page and starting the text on the following page creates typographical widows (the headings) and orphans (the separated text). This is a Level 3 heading. Each section of your literature review may be subdivided into subsections. If you choose this method of organization, be sure each subsection uses a Level 3 heading. These subsections may be a single paragraph or a collection of paragraphs. And please remember that no paragraph should be longer than a single page. As with any other type of outlining mechanism, be sure to have at least two Level 3 headings under a Level 2 heading. This is another Level 3 heading. Each Level 3 heading is set in boldface just as Level 2 headings are. But unlike Level 2 headings, Level 3 headings are indented and have only the first letter of the first word (and any proper nouns or adjectives) capitalized. Further, they end with a period (or other end punctuation such as a question mark) to separate them from the rest of the RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 9 text in the paragraph. A word on structural simplicity here: There are Level 4 and Level 5 headings, but avoid them unless they’re absolutely necessary. If you must use them, then follow the formatting guide on pages 62-63 of the Publication Manual concerning level of headings. Your Second Level 2 Heading This section of your literature review should be tied to another (and, ideally, the second) of your research questions. Please be sure to cite your sources consistently using APA style. If you’re citing a study with three authors in your text, you would use the citation form of Brown, Smith, and Jones (2009). If, however, you give the citation within parentheses, you’ll need to replace the conjunction “and” with an ampersand (&). This form of citation would be thus: (Brown, Smith, & Jones, 2009). Observing these stylistic requirements will mark your paper as a professional effort. Please note, however, that on the second and subsequent citations of sources with three authors, you’ll need to list only the first author with “et al.” (meaning “and the rest” in Latin) following. Be sure to refer to the chapter titled “Reference Examples” (pages 193-224) in the Publication Manual. Pay special attention to the table on page 177 titled “Basic Citation Styles.” This resource will be invaluable as you write your research project, and you may wish to sleep with it under your pillow! Your Third Level 2 Heading As noted above, there is no set number of sections in the literature review. Some reviews may have only two sections while others may have three, four, or more. This will depend largely on the number of research questions you have guiding your research project. As a suggestion, you may wish to check your list of references to be sure that each piece of literature you mention in this chapter is listed alphabetically by author in the reference list. This list follows the last chapter and precedes any material in the Appendix. Doing this at the end of each draft of each RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 10 chapter will simplify the process of compiling your list of references at the end of the writing process (and, incidentally, prevent premature graying of your hair). Please remember, too, that Option A of the research report for the MEd program requires a minimum of 25 sources in your literature review. Some Writing Strategies to Consider Clear, readable writing is the currency in which scholars trade. Indeed, the three hallmarks of good writing are clarity, economy, and precision. One of the best ways to become an accomplished writer is to write frequently and edit carefully. As with most other endeavors, there is no substitute for practice. Bookstores and libraries carry dozens of writing guides; consider consulting several and buying at least one to reference regularly. One of the best and most venerable is Strunk and White’s The Elements of Style, which has gone through multiple revisions since its first appearance in 1959. Though slender, its 85 pages will provide reliable advice about improving your writing. Consider the passage under Rule 17, “Omit needless words”: Vigorous writing is concise. A sentence should contain no unnecessary words, a paragraph no unnecessary sentences, for the same reason that a drawing should have no unnecessary lines and a machine no unnecessary parts. This requires not that the writer make all his sentences short, or that he avoid all detail and treat his subjects only in outline, but that every word tell. (p. 23) In this 63-word passage, Strunk and White provide a solid principle about economy in writing. Cut ruthlessly as you edit: if a 2-word phrase can be replaced with a single strong word, do so. Rely on strong nouns and verbs that don’t require second-string adjectives and adverbs. Please note that indented quotes such as this do not have double quotation marks at the beginning or end. The indentation alerts the reader that this is a quote. RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 11 Another strategy to consider is to have a structure as you write. The structure, of course, may change as you move through the writing process, but it’s crucial to have a plan. At the least, be sure you know what your main idea or thesis is. Time spent clarifying this critical part of your document will pay handsome dividends. How will you develop your thesis? Will you use a chronological, spatial, or importance order as you write? One way to keep this in your mind is tape a copy of your thesis near your computer screen. As you finish each paragraph and save (a good habit to cultivate), be sure to ask yourself if the last bit you’ve written in some way relates to and develops your thesis. If it doesn’t, then there’s a good chance you should delete or at least rewrite the paragraph. This incremental process—though initially painstaking—will ensure a more coherent, unified document. One of the trickiest parts of writing a research report or thesis is to align the reference list with your in-text citations. If you don’t use a program such as RefWorks or EndNotes, consider using this process: as you read your draft, place a check next to the appropriate entry in your reference list. When you’ve finished reading the draft, each citation should be checked in the reference list. If not, then be sure to add it. If a source in your reference list is not checked, then be sure to delete it. Another strategy to help polish your writing is having someone whose judgment you trust read your draft. (Having two people is even better, provided they are careful readers.) Often, as we edit our work, we tend to overlook phrases and sentences that contain unnecessary words or words that have been unconsciously omitted. Another related problem is that of “eye skips.” This is when a reader’s eyes unconsciously pass over an entire line of text, a far-too-common occurrence. Having another pair of eyes to read your draft will lessen the chance of these events happening. RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 12 Finally, be sure that each paragraph in your research report is at least one sentence long but no more than one page. Your readers will appreciate not having to slog through excruciatingly long paragraphs. Not only that, but having an entire page of text without an typographical respite in the form of headings or other graphics such as tables or figures can be a terrific eyestrain. Conclusion When you have finished synthesizing your sources for the body of the literature review, you will need to present your findings in a final section. This may be a paragraph or two that recapitulates the major themes and findings of your literature review. It may, of course, be longer depending on the complexity of your literature review. RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 13 CHAPTER 3 Project Design Chapter 3 of your Option A research report for the MEd program should consist of six sections: (a) introduction, (b) type of design and the assumptions that underlie it, (c) the role of the researcher including qualifications and assumptions, (d) selection and description of the site and participants, (e) data-collection strategies, and (f) data-analysis strategies. As with the other chapters of your research project, the first section, which serves as a framework for what follows, does not have a Level 2 heading. Hence, it begins as this paragraph does: indented but otherwise unadorned. Be sure to continue the pagination in the upper-right corner. (This sample chapter begins with “13” for the pagination because of the relative brevity of this template, but in reality your third chapter will probably begin with “20” or thereabouts, taking into account the pagination for your first and second chapters.) When you have provided a framework for the reader that briefly recapitulates the first two chapters (a few sentences at most), you will then need to provide the reader with an advance organizer. A listing of the sections as given in the first sentence of this paragraph will suffice. Once you have given your reader a recapitulation of the first two chapters and an advance organizer for the rest of the third chapter, you’re ready to continue. Type of Design and Underlying Assumptions In this section, you should address what your specific design is. Indicate whether you will use a quantitative design, a qualitative design, or a mixed methodology design. You may wish to use one of the models given in the Leedy and Ormrod text used in EDUC 520 if your design RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 14 includes a quantitative component. You should also address the underlying assumptions by explaining why you chose the particular research design you did. (Why does your research project lend itself to the particular research design you chose?) You can use a quote, paraphrase, or summary from the Leedy and Ormrod text or any other research methods text to support your choice, if this seems to work. When you’ve provided your reader with a rationale for the particular design type you’ve chosen, you’re ready to move to the next section. Qualifications and Assumptions of the Researcher In this section, you have the opportunity (and the obligation) of giving the pertinent professional and philosophical background about yourself. Why exactly are your qualified to conduct this research project? What professional background (formal academic work as well as staff-development experiences) do you have that make you the right person to research your topic? What assumptions do you have? (You may want to mention the idea that in action research, the researcher has the dual identity of participant-observer. And you may want to explain the effect that this dual identity could have on your research project.) Once you’ve explained why you’re qualified and what your philosophical assumptions about the research project are, you’re ready to move to the next section. Participants and Site This section of your third chapter focuses on the participants and the location of the research project. Be as specific as possible when explaining how you chose your participants. Did you use students solely from your own class or classes? Did you use students from other classrooms in your building? From other buildings in your district? Was your population a true population or a sample? If you used a sample, was it random, cluster, or systematic? If you used a random sample, was it simple, stratified, or proportional? (Consult the Leedy and Ormrod text RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 15 or any reputable research methods text if the details are fuzzy.) Precision, which is always a good thing in writing, is particularly important when explaining your participant selection. Sometimes, a sample of convenience is necessary. If you use such a sample, please explain why. You should also indicate in this section how you addressed the issue of participant safety. This will include a discussion of your Institutional Review Board (IRB) application that you completed. It’s a good idea to include a copy of your approved IRB application in the appendix. If you’re using other teachers besides yourself, you’ll want to provide appropriate background information on them (for example, their academic qualifications, years of professional experience, etc.). Concerning Level 3 headings. In this section, a logical organizing principle would be to have two subsections: one for participants and one for location. If you choose to use this organizing principle, be sure to introduce each subsection with a Level 3 heading. This paragraph begins with such a heading. Please note the Level 3 heading is boldfaced like the Level 2, but it is indented and ends with a period. In addition, only the first letter of the first word and any proper nouns or adjectives are capitalized, unlike the Level 2 heading in which the first letter of all principal words is capitalized. Also please note that if you divide a section that begins with a Level 2 heading, you should have at least a sentence of text separating the Level 2 heading from the first Level 3 heading. Description of site. In this section, you will provide the reader with all of the pertinent particulars of the research project’s location. For example, if you’re using a specific classroom, be sure to describe the details that will affect aspects of your research project. The size, color, lighting, wall coverings, floors, and desk arrangement of the classroom might figure importantly in your project. If so, give the particulars for your reader. You may also wish to provide specific details about the school building if it’s germane. Of course, if your project involves using sites at RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 16 two or more schools, then you’ll need to adjust your description accordingly. The rule of thumb is to provide enough detail to the reader without overwhelming her. When you’ve provided sufficient detail, you’re ready to move to the next section. Data Collection This section requires you to explaining specifically what your data-collection plan is. If you’re using a quantitative instrument such as a survey with forced responses (for example, a 5point Likert scale), be sure to describe the instrument in detail. (How many items? Do they address attitude? Are there demographic items? How will the instrument be administered?) If you’re collecting qualitative data, which method(s) will you use? Don’t simply say you’re going to interview participants. Will your interviews use a structured, semistructured, or unstructured format? How many questions will you have for participants in your interview? You will need to include a sample of each instrument you use in your research project. These samples should appear in the Appendix, following the reference list. Once you have addressed your datacollection plan, you’re ready to move to the next section. Data Analysis This section deals with how you will extract meaning from the data you collected for your research project. If you’re going to create crosstabs, for instance, indicate the reason for them and how you will set them up. If you’re going to be gathering measures of central tendency such as mean, median, and mode, be sure to indicate why this is the most appropriate method of analysis for your data. The same holds true for measures of dispersion such as range and standard deviation. If you’re gathering information from participant interviews, be sure to explain the process you intend to use to decide on specific themes or nodes. How many times will you read the transcripts of your interviews to obtain “thick” results? RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 17 A Final Note When you first submit your third chapter, it will be part of your research proposal. As such, you will not have yet collected and analyzed your data for your research project. Thus, much of the third chapter will be written in the future tense. When you have completed data collection and analysis, you will need to revise your third chapter and cast it in the past tense. In addition, if you cite any additional references in your third chapter (such as the Leedy and Ormrod text), be sure to add them to your references list. RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 18 CHAPTER 4 Project Implementation The fourth chapter of your Option A research report for the MEd program will focus on describing what the outcomes of the project implementation were. It should consist of six sections: (a) introduction, (b) description of the project and what actually happened, (c) what changes were made and the factors that caused such changes, (d) data collection, (e) data analysis, and (f) challenges you experienced while implementing the project. The first section, as in the other chapters, provides a quick overview of the project and does not have a Level 2 heading. As with the other chapters, be sure to include the header. This chapter will need to be written in past tense as you are reporting how you implemented your research project. Once you have completed your introduction, you’re ready to move to the next section. Description of the Project This section describes in detail the research project you’ve carried out. You will likely want to focus on a brief recapitulation of the project design including participants and site(s) as well as other aspects that readers would be interested in. Changes Made Change—especially unplanned-for change—seems to be a constant in the research process. In this section, you will want to describe how your research project changed during the process and what the factors were which led to these changes. For example, you may have had to change the sample population you were working with because of a revision in your teaching schedule. This is definitely something that you should describe, as well as the impact such a RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 19 change had on your research project. Full disclosure of the results is not only ethical in research but absolutely essential. It is rare to find a research study that goes off exactly as planned; most studies have to address unplanned-for changes. There is no dishonor in doing so. Data Collection This section will chronicle the process of data collection you did while completing your research project. What was the process you used? How were your data organized? If you choose to present your data using tables and figures, be sure to follow APA style by consulting the Publication Manual (2010). See especially pages 128-150 for guidelines using tables and pages 150-167 for guidelines using figures. One general rule that might prove useful is found on page 137 of the 5th edition of the Publication Manual (2001): (a) if you have 3 or fewer numbers, use a sentence; (b) if you have from 4 to 20 numbers, use a table; and (c) if you have more than 20 numbers, consider using a graph or figure instead of a table. Just as a reminder, APA style requires that tables have only horizontal lines, not vertical ones. In addition, be sure to number tables and figures sequentially to avoid confusion. Thus if you had both tables and figures, the first of each would be Table 1 and Figure 1. Be sure, too, to double-space all parts of a word table including notes. (Tables using numbers should be doublespaced whenever possible for the sake of clarity.) Remember that notes should be set in 8-point type rather than 12-point type used for headings and the body. When you create tables and figures, please remember that these graphic representations of data should follow the three hallmarks of good writing: clarity, economy, and precision. Thus, headings and notes should contribute to the internal logic of the table or figure. You will also want to strive for simplicity in representing data in tables and figures. Cut relentlessly to avoid any possible misreading of your data. Please see Table 1, which appears on the following page, RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 20 as an example of how to organize data in an economical fashion. For the sake of convenience and uniformity, please use Table Simple 1 as your template. To access this, Click on the “Table” pull-down menu, then click on “Table AutoFormat.” Under the “Table styles” list, scroll to “Table Simple 1” and select. Table 1, found below, uses this table format and conforms to APA style requirements. Please note that the table designator is set in Roman caps and lower case. Table 1 Please note that the table title is set in italic caps and lower case. NBCT Responses to “I perform work that suits my values” Cumulative Descriptor Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent Disagree 4 4.7 4.8 4.8 Uncertain 8 9.4 9.5 14.3 Agree 46 54.1 54.8 69.0 Strongly Agree 84 98.8 100.0 Missing 1 1.2 Total 85 100.0 Note. The results for this particular survey item did not have any responses for the descriptor of Strongly Disagree. Data Analysis Please note that the table note is set in 8-point Times New Roman with “Note” italicized and followed by a period. In this section of the chapter, you will address the “Whys” and “Ahas!” that your data have provided. Look for patterns in both quantitative and qualitative data that lead you toward tentative conclusions. If, for example, your data suggest that students who have received a particular treatment as an independent variable score higher on a particular assessment instrument (which, of course, is the dependent variable), then you can discuss reasons why that RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 21 may be the case. Please remember that data can only suggest conclusions. It’s inappropriate to assume that your data prove anything. Humility is a virtue sometimes overlooked in scholarship. Challenges Experienced This final section of your fourth chapter will address what challenges you encountered while conducting your research project. These challenges may have to do with your sample used for the project, difficulties securing materials, or problems with colleagues or administrators. Rather than merely listing the challenges, however, you should address how you overcame the obstacles you encountered. Be as specific as you can. Remember: it is rare, indeed, for a researcher to have no challenges while implementing a research project. Final Information on Tables and Figures Be sure that every table and figure has a heading and that all vertical lines have been omitted. Further, be sure to refer to all tables in the text, ideally just before the table appears. Be sure that all tables are numbered sequentially using Arabic numerals. Figures, too, are numbered sequentially using Arabic numerals. RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 22 CHAPTER 5 Conclusions and Reflections The final chapter of your Option A research report for the MEd program will focus on describing what the project findings are and your thoughts about the process of conducting the project. It should consist of three sections: (a) summary of the entire project, (b) what to do differently next time, and (c) reflection on your own professional growth. The first section provides the reader with a summary of findings about the research project. It should also address how the project findings addressed the research questions posed in the first chapter. As in the other chapters, this introductory section does not have a Level 2 heading. Be sure to include a header with pagination. This chapter will need to be written in past tense as you are reporting the findings of your research project. Don’t forget to include the advance organizer. Once you have completed your introduction, you’re ready to move to the next section. What to Do Differently Next Time Hindsight, of course, is always 20/20. Having completed your research project, what would you change if you were to replicate your project or tweak it somewhat? Would you delete any parts or add something (or several things)? You might wish to consider your research preparations, literature review, project design, data collection, or data analysis procedures. For example, would you expand or reduce your participant population or sample? Or would you extend or contract the time frame of your project? And just as important, why would you make any indicated changes? Try to envision your audience for this section as a beginning researcher who wishes to replicate your project. RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 23 Reflection on My Own Growth Every research project we participate in broadens our experience base. Often, it increases our knowledge base as well. It may even increase our wisdom. How have you grown as a professional educator because of your research project? How have you grown as a human being? What, for example, did you learn about human nature or the teaching and learning process because of conducting your project? Will you follow up this study with another? A Note on References As you compile your reference list, be sure to put each source in appropriate APA style and format. This includes using hanging indentation, which is a real convenience for the reader. Remember to order your sources alphabetically by author. Don’t forget to space between initials in author or editor names. Please check to be sure that text citations and reference list entries agree both in spelling and in date. In addition, be sure that inclusive page numbers are provided for each journal article or book chapter listed. This is one of the most common errors for novice researchers. Finally, check that each parenthetical or in-text citation is listed exactly the same way in the reference list. By extension, check that each entry in your reference list is cited in your text. This is common scholarly courtesy for your readers. Check that you have included the digital object identifier (doi) for sources that have them. Suggested Length of the Research Report If you choose Option A for the MEd research report, you should know there are no absolute length limits. That being said, most Option A research reports will probably encompass between 50 and 60 pages, including references. Remember that the second chapter literature review must contain a minimum of 25 sources. RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 24 References American Psychological Association. (2001). Publication manual of the American Psychological Association (5th ed.). Washington, DC: Author. American Psychological Association. (2010). Publication manual of the American Psychological Association (6th ed.). Washington, DC: Author. Glatthorn, A. A., & Joyner, R. L. (2005). Writing the winning thesis or dissertation: A step-bystep guide (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press. Leedy, P. D., & Ormrod, J. E. (2005). Practical research: Planning and design (8th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson. Rizzo, J. R., House, R. J., & Lirtzman, S. L. (1970). Role conflict and ambiguity in complex organizations. Administrative Science Quarterly, 15(2), 150-163. Strunk, Jr., W., & White, E. B. (1979). The elements of style (3rd ed.). New York, NY: Macmillan. Please note the use of hanging indentation when a reference listing exceeds a single line. RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 25 Please note that the appendices designator is set in caps and lowercase and is centered horizontally as well as vertically on the page. Appendices RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 26 Appendix A—Letter to Parents Dear Parents/Guardians, Over the next couple of months, in music class, I will be incorporating different methods to teach music concepts to your child. The methods that will be incorporated are: (a) using background music in class to observe any changes in behavior and academic performance, (b) using music therapy to aid music instruction, and (c) using Mozart music in the classroom. All three methods, I hope, will help your child learn, understand, and remember music concepts. I will be using the information collected from our class sessions to aid in my professional development as I work towards the Washington State requirement of completing my Professional Certification. As I teach your child music, I’ll be alternating different teaching methods and strategies to determine which method has the largest positive effect on music learning. I’m looking forward to trying out new methods which I hope will make me a better teacher for your child. I will be using video and photographs as part of my evidence. The information collected will only be used for my professional certification portfolio and will be destroyed once the portfolio is accepted. If you want your child to be included as evidence, either videotaped or photographed, please sign below and return this letter to me. I have been enjoying teaching your child and am excited with the growth I’ve seen over the year. Thank you, Mrs. Molly Bloom Discover Elementary Music Teacher I hereby allow ___________________________ to be included in the evidence, videotapes, or Child’s Name photographs that are collected in music class. ____________________________________ Parent/Guardian Signature RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 27 Appendix B—Student Survey This anonymous survey has been designed to gather demographic data as well as information about student attitudes toward the Canyon High School campus newspaper. Thank you for taking the time to respond to this survey. Part I—Attitudinal Items. Please respond candidly to each statement by circling the most appropriate number. The 5-point scale corresponds to the following values: 5 = Strongly Agree 4 = Agree 3 = Uncertain 2 = Disagree 1 = Strongly Disagree 1. The campus newspaper, which is published every two weeks, needs to be published more often. 5 4 3 2 1 2. The size of the issue, 8 pages, is large enough to accommodate the news around the campus community. 5 4 3 2 1 3. The design of the paper is, in general, visually pleasing. 5 4 3 2 1 4. The photographs that appear in the paper are, in general, clear and focused. 5 4 3 2 1 5. I generally receive a copy of the paper in my third-period class on publication days. 5 4 3 2 1 6. The headlines, in general, reflect the content of the stories. 5 4 3 2 1 7. News coverage is, in general, relevant to the campus community. 5 4 3 2 1 RESEARCH REPORT TEMPLATE—OPTION A 28 8. Sports coverage, in general, is balanced with all campus sports receiving notice in the paper. 5 4 3 2 1 9. Entertainment coverage, in general, addresses most popular venues such as movies, plays, and video games. 5 4 3 2 1 10. The ads in the paper are for services that I use or may use in the future. 5 4 3 2 1 Part II—Demographics. Please answer the following so we can compile a statistical crosssection of students who responded. 11. What is your gender? _____ Female _____ Male 12. What is your grade? _____ Freshman _____ Sophomore _____ Junior _____ Senior