School of Medicine Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences University of Nottingham Intervention Request for a Medical Student Student Name: (block capitals) Gender: Male Year of Study: Female State nature of concern (Please see guidance notes at end of this document) Knowledge, skills and performance Safety and quality Communication, partnership and teamwork Maintaining trust Tick Area(s) of Concern in the boxes above – see guidance for details Please write an account of why additional support is request, describing circumstances and any witnessed events – continue on next page if needed Position in relation to student (eg clinical teacher, personal tutor, administrator, student): Self-referral (please tick if request is for yourself) Your signature (If sent electronically a paper copy with signature should follow) Date: Your Details (block capitals) Reported by: Address: Telephone number: Email: If you believe that a concern may need a student to be suspended from contact with patients, because it may raise an immediate issue of patient safety, please contact the Dean for Medical Education directly ( Gillian.Doody@Nottingham.ac.uk Tel: 0115 82 30028) as soon as the concern is noted. Page 1 of 6 Document Control Intervention Request for a medical student Lead Author: Student Support and Professionalism Coordinator Version: 6 Date: November 2014 Review date; November 2015 (Continuation – account of concern) Please return to: The Student Support and Development Administrator, Medical Education Centre, B Floor, Medical School, QMC or email studentconcerns@nottingham.ac.uk For GEM students on the pre clinical course, please send these to the School Administrative Officer, Division of GEM & Health, The Medical School, Royal Derby Hospital, Derby. Student ID FOR OFFICE USE ONLY Record ID Year of Entry Series of Form Personal Tutor Page 2 of 6 Document Control Intervention Request for a medical student Lead Author: Student Support and Professionalism Coordinator Version: 6 Date: November 2014 Review date; November 2015 Guidance on use of the “Intervention Request Form” Introduction 1. The “Intervention Request for a Medical Student” procedure helps identify medical students experiencing professional, academic, personal or health problems enabling the school to secure the appropriate level of support. 2. Filling in an intervention request form is important as it is part of the systems in place to assess the developing professionalism of medical students. In most cases when a concern is received a student receives advice and support to address the area of concern. Unless a concern is known, remedial support and advice cannot be given. 3. The development and assessment of professional behaviour is part of the UG medical curriculum as specified in GMC Tomorrow’s Doctors (2009) including that related to students being aware of the importance of their own health. It is important that attitudes and behaviour are assessed so that students can be supported in developing professionalism and in rare serious cases that action is taken so that the safety and care of patients is not jeopardised. The GMC publication Medical Students Professional Values and Fitness to Practice gives further details. 4. The intervention request form is designed to provide an effective means of communicating concerns about medical students to the Medical School so that appropriate action may be taken to address such concerns and help a student in the domain of developing professionalism. All medical students sign a code of conduct on entry to the medical course which describes fully the attitudes and behaviour which are expected of them. Logbooks and study guides further specify areas around conduct and behaviour. Medical students are expected to follow local guidance in NHS premises related to conduct, dress, infection control, health and safety. 5. The GMC has revised its advice on Good Medical Practice and concerns about a student map onto this professional guidance as follows in the table on the next page 6. The form may be used by clinical staff responsible for supervising medical students, by other academic staff, by administrative staff, health professionals with whom the student might come in contact or by patients and members of the public. 7. The form may also be used by medical students who have concerns about a fellow medical student. Medical students have a responsibility to report any issues that may have a bearing upon the professionalism of others who may come into contact with patients. It may also be used for selfreferral. 8. This procedure accompanies the ‘Whistleblowing’ code of practice which gives guidance on how medical students should raise concerns about behaviour or practice in the University or the NHS which does not involve a medical student. The ‘Whistleblowing’ code of practice and the ‘Intervention Request Form” are designed to complement each other. 9. A concern usually results in the student having a meeting to address the issue through education and pastoral care. It is only very serious concerns that rarely might result in a disciplinary outcome. 10. This form will be kept on file permanently, unless negated and could be used as evidence in a Fitness to Practice investigation. Page 3 of 6 Document Control Intervention Request for a medical student Lead Author: Student Support and Professionalism Coordinator Version: 6 Date: November 2014 Review date; November 2015 Domain Knowledge, skills and performance Sub domain Develop and maintain your professional performance Apply knowledge and experience to practice Examples of concern * Not making good progress in developing clinical skills Failure to attend scheduled teaching sessions or tutor sessions Not attending appointments or meetings Lack of commitment Record your work clearly, accurately and legibly Not maintaining appropriate professional boundaries Inappropriate dress Failure to respond to the training environment despite support Working beyond specified limitations. Failure to follow guidelines or instructions. Poor record keeping in logbook or similar Illegible handwriting Failure to maintain confidentiality Safety and quality Contribute to and comply with systems to protect patients Respond to risks to safety Protect patients and colleagues from any risks posed by your health Communication, partnership and teamwork Maintaining trust Communicate effectively Work collaboratively with colleagues to maintain or improve patient care Teaching, training, supporting and assessing Continuity and coordination of care Establish and maintain partnerships with patients Show respect for patients Failure to comply with instructions around infection control Any action that might lead to patient safety being compromised Failure to report witnessed inappropriate attitude or conduct by another person A health issue (withdrawn, depressed, anxious) A health issue that may need a review by Occupational Health Alcohol or substance misuse Not responding to communications (emails, telephone calls, letters) Poor communication skills Poor interaction with colleagues or staff Being rude to staff or colleagues Inappropriate use of language Inappropriate conduct in teaching session Unable or unwilling to work as part of a team Poor interactions with patients Rudeness to patients or their relatives Treat patients and colleagues fairly and without discrimination Act with honesty and integrity Examination of patients without permission or consent Inappropriate discrimination. Bullying or harassment Dishonesty. Breach of codes or regulations. Criminal caution or conviction Falsifying attendance record Falsifying a logbook signoff Plagiarism or cheating *Some of these areas might be more appropriately dealt with through the “Support Request for a Medical Student” form Page 4 of 6 Document Control Intervention Request for a medical student Lead Author: Student Support and Professionalism Coordinator Version: 6 Date: November 2014 Review date; November 2015 Notes 1. Intervention forms raised anonymously will not normally be considered. 2. All concerns will be treated in confidence but we cannot guarantee that the identity of the person raising the concern will not be revealed. In the rare event of a concern about a student proceeding to the fitness to practise committee, only in exceptional circumstances will their identity not be disclosed. 3. Raising concerns maliciously, recklessly or irresponsibly will be considered to contravene the Nottingham University Code of Conduct for Medical Students and may result in a FTP referral in itself. What happens next? 1. Following receipt of an Intervention Request Form, the Student Support and Professionalism Coordinator, Medical Education Centre, will, as soon as possible, either refer the case to an appropriate Senior Tutor or Clinical Sub-Dean or in some cases directly to the Associate Dean for Medical Education for review. The student, about whom the concern has been expressed, may be required to attend a meeting to discuss the concern. 2. The Senior Tutor or Clinical Sub-Dean will decide on one the following: a) Recommend negation of the intervention request, if confirmed, all records destroyed (see point 4 below). b) Commence an educational approach, record to be held on student’s file. Progress monitored by Clinical Sub Dean or Senior Tutor. c) Refer for counselling/support: Academic Progress Committee Divert to “Support Request for a Medical Student” procedure Record held on student’s file. d) Verbal or written warning, record to be held on student’s file. e) Refer the case on to the Associate Dean for Medical Education for review (see below). The student will be informed of the outcome of the review of the concern within 10 working days of the referral except in exceptional circumstances 3. For more serious concerns, the Associate Dean for Medical Education will decide whether cases should be referred directly to an appropriate committee, procedure or agency for consideration. Depending on the nature of the concern and whether there have been previous expressions of concern, the student may be referred, for example to one or more of the following: The Academic Offences Committee The Senate Disciplinary Committee The Fitness to Practise procedure. Any other appropriate University procedure, for example to comply with the Dignity (harassment) Policy. An external body such as an NHS Trust or, if criminal activity is suspected, the police. 4. The Associate Dean for Medical Education will also consider all recommendations for an intervention request to be negated and will discuss each recommendation with either a Senior Tutor or Clinical SubDean different to the one making the initial review, or the Student Welfare Manager. Upon confirming such a recommendation this will be communicated to the Student Support and Professionalism Coordinator who will ensure that the intervention request form is removed from the student file. This will be in exceptional circumstances. The student will normally be informed of the outcome within 5 working days. 5. Unless the intervention request has been negated, upon closure of the review: The student’s Personal Tutor will be advised of their tutee’s involvement in an Intervention Request form, (with specific details being released only with the student’s agreement). The person who submitted the form will also receive notification that the matter has been dealt with and the manner of disposal. Page 5 of 6 Document Control Intervention Request for a medical student Lead Author: Student Support and Professionalism Coordinator Version: 6 Date: November 2014 Review date; November 2015 The request form will be kept on file permanently and could be used as evidence in a Fitness to Practice investigation. 6. Should a student be referred to the Fitness to Practice procedure, the student’s Personal Tutor will be informed of any stage by stage process (if appropriate) until the matter is closed. This guidance will be provided by the Faculty FTP Committee as well as the School of Medicine UG Curriculum Group to ensure consistency, fairness and proportionality. Support and Follow-Up Where appropriate, the Senior Tutor/Clinical Sub Dean or their nominee will agree a support plan to help the student which may involve the University Student Services Centre, a Senior Tutor or Clinical Sub-Dean and/or medical or other support. A student may be required to attend remediation. The staff member should ensure that follow-up continues until both the student and staff member agree that support is no longer needed. This decision will be documented and a record held in the student file. Page 6 of 6 Document Control Intervention Request for a medical student Lead Author: Student Support and Professionalism Coordinator Version: 6 Date: November 2014 Review date; November 2015