Faculty Senate Curriculum Committee Minutes from 10/26/06 June Deery Les Gerhardt David Hess Prabhat Hajela Chris McDermott Sharon Kunkel Lee Odell Ken Warriner Mike Wozny, chair Mark Steiner for Dick Smith Guest: Atsushi Akera 1) The minutes from the meeting of 10/11/06 were approved with the following changes noted: Item # 5: The draft report was distributed to department heads for approval. …..There was some discussion of the financial issues with the full time tuition policy. M. Wozny asked if the FSCC could review the report. L. Gerhardt will check with the Provost on the process. The 72 credit hour program would not change the requirement for the student to be fulltime and pay full tuition. Item # 4 bullet 2: David Hess asked what is being assessed, courses or programs. L. Odell responded saying it’s the degree granting program and the students’ performance in the program. Item # 4 bullet 8: “... the outcomes of a program can’t be measured with one culminating experience”. Item # 4 bullet 11: Add the statement- D. Hess noted that we could also assess our alumni. 2) Lester Gerhardt indicated that the draft report on the 72 credit hour PhD was provided to the FSCC and Jim Napolitano, president of the Faculty Senate. The Faculty Senate has forwarded the report to the FSCC for review and approval. 3) School of Humanities and Social Science- Atsushi Akera from the Science and Technology Studies Department provided an overview and background information on the packet of changes from his department. The department is proposing a number of changes: Change in Methods/Statistics Requirement Change in STS Concentration option Change in the STS Template Change in Advanced Options Change in requirements for the STS minor, Anthropology minor and the Ecological Economics, Values and Policy minor Proposal to change courses number for STSH and STSS courses Changes in course title or STSS/STSH designation Course additions and revisions Course deletions Deletion of Interschool Minor in Energy The Committee had a number of questions about the proposed changes. STSS 4330- Is the new title, 21st Century Risks too focused on the negative? It reflects a negative critique and the intention of the instructor. This should be the decision of the faculty member. Why is the department changing the designation of the history courses from STSS to STSH? This is something that probably should have been done long ago. S. Kunkel will check to see if this will affect the ROTC students. Advanced Placement and transfer credit procedures will also need to be revised to reflect this change. The following courses will be changed to the STSH designation: STSH 2510- Foundations of American History STSH 2520-History of the United States Since 1877 STSH 2530-World War II STSH 4200-China: Past and Present STSH 4510-History of American technology FSCC Minutes from 10/26/06 The department is dropping a number of courses from the catalog. The department is dropping many of the courses because they do not have an instructor to teach them. A. Akera was asked if the courses they offer are sustainable. The department is committed to developing and sustaining a core of courses that will be taught regularly. There are topical interests that change so they need to keep up with that too. The department is now reviewing the rotation of courses regularly to make sure they will be able to fully support the concentrations. New course proposals: STSS 2210 Design, Culture and Society STSS /STSH 4430 Drugs in History The syllabus for Drugs in History states that the course is Communication Intensive although the catalog description does not indicate that. A. Akera will check on the status of that course. Course deletions: STSH 2130 Intro to the Philosophy of Science STSH 2670 History of 19th Century Europe STST 2720 Masculine/Feminine STSH 4310 Scientific revolutions STSH 4850 Modern Latin America STSH 4710 Psychology, Culture and design STSH 4750 Troy, A 19th Century Industrial City STSH 4760 American Material Culture STSH 4780 Medieval Architecture and Art STSH 4900 STS Selected Topics STSH 4920 Topics in STS STSS 2500 Historical and Cultural perspectives STSS 2680 History of Contemporary Europe STSS 4110 Social Effects of Science and technology STSS 4250 Human Dimensions STSS 4260 Sociology of Medicine STSS 4310 Politics of Science and Technology STSS 4330 World Politics STSS 4540 Environment, Law and Culture STSS 4550 The Middle East STSS 4580 Latin America STSS 4610 20th Century Germany STSS 4620 History of Medicine STSS 4660 History of American Science STSS 4670 History Information Technology STSS 4900 STS Selected Topics STSS 4920 Topics in STS One of the courses to be deleted, STSH 2130, is cross listed with PHIL 2130. PHIL 2130 is one of the courses that has been certified as a Communication Intensive course. A. Akera will check on this. P. Hajela asked if this is the right time to drop the Energy minor when Energy is one of the Institute’s signature thrusts. The STS department needs someone to administer the minor. The courses are outdated and need to be updated. It is important to have someone in charge of the curriculum in the areas of the signature thrusts. The Committee did not think the minor should be dropped. A. Akera has reviewed the catalog for acceptable substitutions and he’ll talk to the other departments for appropriate courses and to see if he can find someone to administer it. S. Kunkel will check to see if we have any students who are pursuing this minor. The Committee decided not to vote on any of the items in the packet. M. Wozny suggested more time to review the changes and then finalizing the review and discussion at our next meeting. 4) School of Engineering-Mark Steiner presented course deletions from Civil Engineering. CIVL 6280-Infrastructure and Asset Mgmt Systems CIVL 4580- Infrastructure Engineering -2- FSCC Minutes from 10/26/06 K. Warriner asked how you can offer Civil Engineering without infrastructure and asked about the direction of the department. M. Steiner will take those questions back to the department. Two new courses were proposed: DSES 4210- Design and Analysis of Supply Chains DSES 4290- Simulation Modeling and Analysis The Committee suggested that there may be some overlap with courses offered by the School of Management and Technology (SoM&T). The department should discuss this with the faculty in SoM&T. DSES 4290- The Academic Integrity (AI) statement needs a penalty statement and the course outline should include specific readings. The Committee also thought there may be duplication with other course being offered. This course may be unique but the department needs to be more specific on the proposal form rather than indicate “no duplication” with other courses taught on campus. M. Wozny recommended tabling this proposal and requested additional information from the department. J. Deery noted that there are many recurring issues and questions, i.e. AI statements, what is for information and what must be voted on, etc. She suggested devoting some time at a future meeting so we can resolve the questions once and for all. -3-