Service Learning Projects - 1 Running Head: Service Learning Projects in Civic Education The Use of Service Learning Projects in Civic Education to Reduce Student Political Apathy Brittany Sizer Peabody College Capstone Experience March 5, 2008 Service Learning Projects - 2 Abstract According to the Center for Information and Research on Civic Learning and Engagement, since 1972 when 18-21 year old U.S. citizens were given the right to vote, political participation has declined (Youth, 2007, p. 1). Many researchers have found different reasons for this current apathetic state of affairs, but I would argue that although the current state of political engagement looks dreary when studying the 18-24 year olds, simple educational reform could solve many of the problems plaguing the political scene today. Research has shown consistently that although the youth of America are reluctant to get involved in politics, they still are extremely enthusiastic about volunteering and making a difference in their community. With that in mind, it is clear that the most effective means of teaching civic education to adolescents is by combining traditional civic education with service learning. By designing a program that concentrates on service learning and focuses on proven modern education best practices and concepts, I feel that students will be able to see real world application more clearly. Understanding how different types of people learn, and how to appeal to an individual’s strengths in order to build upon their weaknesses, is vital for student success. However, understanding learners and learning is not enough for students to be achieve, rather educators must also accompany this with a strong curriculum. The idea that “one teaching style fits all,” tends to reflect a teacher-centered instructional approach that does not work for all students due to their diverse needs and learning styles. A strong curriculum centered on real world application, discussion, higher order thinking skills, and preparation for college, reduces the conflicts between teaching styles and learning styles. A relaxed and supportive learning environment where students feel comfortable discussing their thoughts, feelings, ideas, and attitudes about public life and politics is also essential. When students feel comfortable to share, they take greater pride in the learning process and feel more invested in their learning. It is also essential to Service Learning Projects - 3 remember that these three components are most successful when teachers administer various authentic assessments that indicate students’ abilities to apply skills and knowledge to projects and activities. By providing a wide range of assessments, all students have the opportunity to showcase their strengths and build upon weaknesses. In short, combining these four areas of interest with current trends of student interest in volunteerism will serve not only to educate students about the importance of political participation, but also begin to reverse the trends of political apathy in our nations young people. Service Learning Projects - 4 - Looking back on the passage of the Twenty-sixth amendment in 1971, many hoped that allowing eighteen year olds the right to vote would encourage them to not only vote in vast numbers, but also begin to transform American politics. However, studies have illustrated that people age eighteen to twenty-four have actually had little or no real impact on the political system or elections over the past forty-years. For example, in 1994, “one in five eligible young voters (those young persons registered to vote) showed up for the midterm election,” and in the 2000 presidential election only 38% of young people ages eighteen to twenty-nine year olds voted (Bose & DiIulio, 2007, p.196). Many scholars have contributed this lack of participation to a rampant sense of apathy that plagues young adult views regarding politics and politicians themselves. What is striking, however, is that even while these young people exhibit political apathy, they also embrace community service much more than past generations—leading other Americans in overall civic duty (Bose & DiIulio, 2007, p. 198). Kevin Mattson (2003), a leading contemporary history professor from Ohio University, notes though that although “young citizens sense no civic connection between voting and volunteering or between political campaigns and community affairs,” they still feel (and display) a sense of civic responsibility in the form of volunteerism (p. 195). Thus, as teachers we must motivate our students and illustrate to them that there is a way to “move beyond this disconnect by reconnecting voluntary service and political education” (Bose & DiIulio, 2007, p. 195). The political disaffection of young people today poses a major political problem that must be changed, as American youth are the future of the nation. Thus, if young citizens continue to be apathetic and apolitical about public life, the Nation will continue to deteriorate. There are numerous approaches to civic education which make it difficult to achieve a consensus, however, Service Learning Projects - 5 during my literature review it became apparent that the best way to move beyond debate is to combine traditional civic education with an in schools through programs like Kids Voting and Youth Vote 2000. Using the school as the main venue is preferred over outside venues, which tend to focus on consumer culture—like MTV’s Rock the Vote, for example. In fact, statistics illustrate that one of the main problems with civic participation is that students do not get excited about political issues until right before the polls open. For example, according to Valerie Sulfaro, an associate professor in the political science department at James Madison University, “political interest usually starts to increase two weeks before an election,” thus people who procrastinate may find that it is too late to register or apply for an absentee ballot (Youth, 2007, p. 2). Students need to be constantly aware of politics around the country and also when they need to act. Simply, “tuning in” to politics when it is convenient cannot be the only path for involvement. Teachers and educators can use volunteerism to demonstrate to students that through volunteering, it is easy to become involved politically. In fact, most campaigns view young people as some of the best potential volunteers and staffers, as they possess lots of enthusiasm and have ample free time when compared to working professionals (Youth, 2007, p. 3). In the beginning, I thought that the best way to teach what it means to be a responsible citizen of the United States and the value that that privilege holds was to use certain elements of Project Citizen, a portfolio based civic education program, to educate my students about the workings of government and the importance of political participation. This semester long program focuses on encouraging students to become active participants in both local and state governments by teaching them how to monitor and sway public policy. Following each semester, committee's composed of community members meet to decide if student work is capable of actual implementation. By simply tackling the weaknesses of this program and applying my knowledge in Service Learning Projects - 6 learners and learning, environment, curriculum, and assessment, I thought I could make Project Citizen more successful and further aid students by presenting the greatest learning experience possible. However, I soon realized that the program had significant problems, as even with my changes it required too many resources for most schools to implement. Additionally, other problems - like resistance from older teachers who are set in their teaching ways, lack of accountability, and students who lack the background knowledge to understand various issues stood as significant barriers to the likely success of my new program. Although there are ways that these problems could be minimized, I realized that I really needed to scrutinize the apathetic nature of young people towards politics from a different angle. Mattson (2003) notes that many colleges and universities have developed ‘service learning’ programs (p. 204), in which enrolled students perform service, but also discuss what they are doing in the classroom. For example, students in a specific class that focuses on housing policy might work at a homeless shelter with their classmates while enrolled in the course. This definition of “service learning” is far from what many high schools, like East Literature Magnet in East Nashville, TN, play out. In my experience, students that participate in service learning courses simply report to a sponsor (usually a teacher) during a specific period of the school day and help out with grading and room arrangement. Thus, in order for service learning based civic education to truly work, the words, “service learning” need to take on a new connotation within the high school realm. After all, I believe that if teachers can capitalize on student interest, students can connect what they do at their service site with policy efforts, their attitudes will change towards politics. This would not only have the effect of maximizing the effectiveness of civic education, it also greatly reduces the required resources by utilizing time already built in to the academic schedule. According to research, under this model, students’ leave with a clearer perspective on social issues Service Learning Projects - 7 and their forthcoming implications (Bose & DiIulio, 2007, p. 204). In order to begin to reverse the widespread political apathy of the American Youth, I believe that civic education must not be taken for granted, as I have seen during my experiences both as a student and student teacher. Educators must properly address and implement understanding in four key areas in order to ensure that students reap the maximum benefit of the social studies education and make a lasting impression in regard to the importance of community involvement and political participation of our youth. Every year, teachers are confronted with the seemingly impossible task of making one semester of a student’s senior year of high school so memorable that the lessons taught last a lifetime. In order to connect volunteerism with civic education, educators must be willing to “master the fine art” of connecting content knowledge with students, in addition to “doing what it takes to adapt their teaching so that what they teach takes hold in the lives and minds of students,” as the same formula does not work for every student (Tomlinson, 2006, p. 16). These key phrases truly embody the first of the vital key areas that must be addressed: learners and learning. Simply put, in order for students to maximize their learning opportunities, they must be able to directly relate to them. After studying Howard Gardner, I realize that students view themselves as gifted in multiple ways. Under his theory of multiple intelligences, teachers may describe students’ cognitive abilities in terms of numerous fairly “independent, but interacting cognitive capacities,” instead of in terms of one ‘general’ intelligence (Moran et al., 2006, p. 23). This simply means that students are really a combination of individual strengths and weaknesses, and that no two students are likely to have the same combination. As educators, it is important to understand not only the various intelligences but, also the ability to recognize them in a student’s profile. Without the knowledge of how specific students process information, it is difficult to maximize their strengths during the learning process. Thus, using a specific strength to support an area of weakness is helpful Service Learning Projects - 8 throughout the learning process for learners. Simply ignoring student weaknesses is not beneficial, as it does not help build up their weak areas. Instead, teachers need to aim to teach learners in a way that takes advantage of student power and breathes new life into learning (Tomlinson, 2006, p. 21). Additionally, intelligences are not single entities; rather they interact with one another to produce various outcomes by working within and across students (Moran et al., 2003, p. 24). By partnering service learning with traditional civic education, I hope to not only allow students to work together and help one another develop their strengths, but I also strive to provide an opportunity that offers a multitude of rich learning experiences to students—activities that “engage with the material personally” instead of attempting to “absorb it in an abstract and de-contextualized way” (Moran et al., 2003, p. 25). By allowing students to learn using different intelligences at the same time, I feel that they will all have the opportunity to be successful, as each student will have the opportunity learn in his or her own way. When students demonstrate their learning in various ways, it not only keeps the energy in the classroom higher, but also allows the teacher to make sure that each and every student understands the concept. Simply, when teachers focus on student strengths and abilities rather than their deficits, research illustrates that student achievement levels climb (Tomlinson, 2006, p. 18). In addition to multiple intelligences, through my civic education program I hope to address the concept of natural learning—the idea that “every student is biologically equipped to learn from experience” (Caine & Caine, 2006, p. 50). Understanding this capacity is paramount for teachers, as it allows for them not to be as beleaguered by student differentiations and hopefully creates learning opportunities that make it easier to teach to students’ strengths. This is primarily done by stressing the idea that in nature, learning is simply making sense of experience and then using experience to survive to the best of one’s ability (Caine & Caine, 2006, p. 50). My program will respond to this Service Learning Projects - 9 idea by responding to student choices and integrating their interests into the course curriculum, while still teaching the required standards. I am confident that by providing a situation that tests one’s beliefs, and by tying new information to a purpose and decision making that leads to action, students will expand their minds (Caine & Caine, 2006, p. 50). Through the new service learning programs, students will be involved in a cycle of learning where they will be able to see a problem or issue first and then act. This enables students themselves to discover the power of their own minds and work in their own ways that they find most effective. The teacher in this situation fills the facilitator role and helps by guiding student comprehension and aiding in student understanding (Orozco & Sattin, 2007, p. 60). Additionally, it is essential for service learning programs to capitalize on student interests and curiosities, and assist their learning from a point of confidence. In many respects, this helps students develop a sense of ownership with the material and helps keep their attention throughout the unit. Through KWL charts and other graphic organizers, I hope students will be better able to link what they are required “to learn with what they already know, what they want to know, and what they have an enthusiasm for, as this builds not only on understanding, but also fosters an attraction for subject and/or topic investigation (Tomlinson, 2006, p. 20). Studies form the National Assessment of Educational Programs (NAEP) have demonstrated that civics students will likely be the most successful with a developmental model in which they start by learning content and then move forward by trying to make sense of it through civic practice (Wenglinsky, 2004, p. 34). Through the newly revamped service learning programs, students will be able to partner traditional learning in the classroom with a service learning opportunity outside of the classroom. For example, students interested in environmental protection could take part in a service learning activity that is based around the concept of reducing, reusing, and recycling. One way that Service Learning Projects - 10 this could be explored is by having learners become involved in activities such as the Glass Slipper Project, which provides a list of facilities that collect used proms dresses and formal wear so that young women who would otherwise not have the opportunity to participate in certain events may have the option. Environmentally, these projects are also beneficial because it cuts down on the two quadrillion pounds that Americans collectively discard each year (Mitchell, 2007, p. 1). By partnering the two methods of learning, students will not only learn the content, but also be able to make sense of it by applying it to the real world. First hand observation of how political policy affects the areas that they are interested in will enable students to gain a new interest in political activity. Additionally, allowing students to pick the service learning class that they are most interested in creates a sense of ownership with the material, the class, and the service learning organization even before the semester begins. Currently, educational political policy does not support this type of service learning opportunity for students, as NCLB has moved from being simply an accountability measure for student achievement results to also mandating that needed funds much be placed into the development of the basic skills approach (Wenglinsky, 2004, p. 35). Although basic skills are vital for learners, they must be balanced with higher-order thinking skills in order to ensure that the cognitive development of our students is not in danger. The service learning programs that I propose implementing tackle this current learning policy problem and embrace a certain sense of accountability. They are designed for learners to raise their achievement levels not through the simple knowledge of basic skills, but by “placing more emphasis on teaching for meaning” (Wenglinsky, 2004, p. 35). After all, that is the type of learning that learners will remember in the future, and as educators, that should be our paramount concern. Service Learning Projects - 11 Teachers who desire to be successful also must understand how their curriculum impacts learners and learning. Studies demonstrate that a large number of students who graduate from high school are not college ready, and thus are unsuccessful when they enter college. The difference in expectations between the two levels of education illustrates that there is a gap that needs to be closed. After all, when studying a college course, one finds that students are expected to be “independent, self-reliant learners who recognize when they are having problems with the course material and know how to request help from their professors and fellow classmates in order to complete numerous well-written and well-organized papers and projects (Conley, 2007, p. 24). High school students, on the other hand, are practically spoon-fed information and are asked rarely to use higher order thinking skills. Instead, secondary teachers typically ask them to complete prearranged tasks that do little to challenge their personal values, and as such, they view any challenge to their status quo way of thinking as “a personal attack” (Conley, 2007, p. 24). In order to begin to fix this troubling problem, teachers must advocate aligning school curriculum and instruction with college expectations. This process can be positive for both students and teachers. First, bringing teachers together to integrate course material and map out a way where each course fits in with other courses, both in and outside their departments, will help build camaraderie and understanding between educators. In addition, by doing this, students will have access to reviewing material in various classes and be better prepared for college expectations. The curriculum of the service-learning program itself addresses the college readiness problem in that it advocates for students to think outside the box and develop cognitively. If courses had to address material in other courses and fit together in a more cohesive manner, many of the benefits that students receive from being enrolled in the service learning course would transfer to other courses by encouraging the continued use of higher order thinking skills. Moreover, the Service Learning Projects - 12 service learning program’s curriculum would be set-up much like a senior seminar, as it would help create the college experience for students in high school without burdening students with college level texts too quickly. Instead of relying primarily on the textbook and allowing it to become the curriculum, research illustrates that the most helpful lessons have relied more heavily upon primary sources and other outside forms of reading (Olsen, 1995, p. 130). By allowing students to focus on specific topics and discuss meaning in depth, students are able to employ higher level thinking skills that will help them adjust to college more easily. Specifically, the service learning based senior seminars regarding government would employ a more rapid pace for learning than a typical high school level course, as well as place a focus on merging and intensifying the understanding of material to which students have already been shown, rather than focusing on introducing copious amounts of new material (Conley, 2007, p. 26). This is vital, as research demonstrates that the art of teaching currently dwells almost exclusively on providing learners with knowledge and then leaving them with few opportunities to unpack it (Olsen, 1995, p. 130). Thus, the whole philosophy of “less is more” seems to be the best method for “maximizing student learning” (Olsen, 1995, p. 130). During the seminars, teachers are trained to give students honest and sincere feedback regarding how well their work aligns with college level. This feedback is paramount for students, as it prepares them not only to understand constructive feedback, but also how to respond positively to criticism (Conley, 2007, p. 26). In addition, having this feedback “timely” and “ongoing” is vital, as it helps promote and keep student engagement and momentum (Orozco & Sattin, 2007, p. 60). Setting up a service learning type seminar for seniors will also help students to hone their interpretation, problem solving, critical reasoning, analytic research, and accuracy skills. For example, concept mapping, which could be used for brainstorming ideas, matrices to organize information on a particular issue, and using analogies and metaphors should all Service Learning Projects - 13 be encouraged. This ensures that students are thinking critically and also serve to heighten their comprehension (Olsen, 1995, p. 132). By aiding students in the development of their critical thinking, teachers not only aid students in becoming strong decision makers in other educational subjects, but also give them the opportunity to have the basic education required to participate in, as well as contribute to, society as a whole (Sears & Hughes, 1996, p. 130). Moreover, the curriculum of the senior service learning seminars would emphasize writing, a skill that many high school students lack, and as such are unprepared for college. By emphasizing writing skills, students will be more exposed to college level assessments and pedagogy, and as a result will be more equipped to tackle the transition into college. All in all, to respond to the current needs and interests of students today, secondary educators must work to align their teaching, material, and lessons with those of post-secondary institutions (Conley, 2007, p. 29). Lastly, the curriculum needs to emphasize embedding technological skills in programs outside of computer literacy. Student knowledge regarding technology is just as important today, as the skills of literacy and numeracy and their ability to work within in everyday will help better prepare them for the global scene (Orozco & Sattin, 2007, p. 60). Furthermore, educators must create a learning environment that is not only comfortable for students, but also open. Studies illustrate that when teachers maintain a class atmosphere of “relaxed alertness,” students feel knowledgeable, self-assured, and motivated (Caine & Caine, 2006, p. 53). As a result, students feel comfortable in asking questions, directing themselves, and pushing through even the most difficult portions of content. Having students feel relaxed enough to pose questions in a learning environment where standards are infused into the content is of great importance because it allows students to first “actively process” the information and then opens up the opportunity for the teacher to guide student understanding and study towards various skills Service Learning Projects - 14 without “depriving them of their voice” (Caine & Caine, 2006, p. 53). This type of environment allows for students to take part in “extensive authentic decision making,” which is one of the main goals of the senior service learning seminars (Caine & Caine, 2006, p.53). Additionally, in order to manage the classroom positively, senior service learning seminars will be designed to preserve a balance between teacher actions that provide clear, natural consequences for unacceptable student behavior and teacher actions that identify and reward acceptable behavior (Marzano & Marzano, 2003, p. 6). After all, recent studies have shown that the quality of teacher-student relationships is paramount and that a good foundation lays a successful groundwork for all other specifics of classroom management (Marzano & Marzano, 2003, p. 6). Thus, if teachers simply exhibit appropriate levels of dominance, cooperation, and awareness of high needs students, relationships can be extremely effective. This can primarily be done by establishing clear learning goals at the beginning of each unit, making expectations clear and visible through the usage of rubrics, providing summative feedback regarding those goals, using assertive behavior, tone of voice and body language and promptly confronting inappropriate behavior (Marzano & Marzano, 2003, p. 8). Additionally, viewing the relationship between teachers and students as a team may help foster a sense of cooperation, which conveys the message to students that the teacher cares about their wellbeing and success. The service learning environment also needs to be one in which scaffolding is one of the main methods for learners to learn. By scaffolding instruction, students move from being novices to becoming more advanced academically in a particular subject. As well, it is important to note that the same rules that apply to students should also apply to teachers, as through this type of teaching, teachers set the example and are essentially the model for learners to imitate. As a whole, the environment needs to foster collaboration, as today the challenge is dealing with and finding Service Learning Projects - 15 solutions for international problems that spill over national borders (Orozco & Sattin, 2007, p. 60). In the past, emphasis has been placed on student competition, but today the emphasis must be shifted towards collaboration between students, as that is how worldwide problems can be solved. In reaction to this change in emphasis, schools must restructure both their curriculum and pedagogy so that learning, the curriculum, and the environment place the students at the center. Global issues can be made local if educators work together to create meaningful assignments that take big issues, break them down into smaller, more manageable chunks of material and guide students to think about their implications (Orozco & Sattin, 2007, p. 60). Another way that a positive learning environment can be achieved is by encouraging interaction between students to help one another appreciate what citizenship means, what responsibilities are involved, and how to reflect on and infer rights and responsibilities. Senior service learning courses not only ask students to reflect, but also encourage the development of language skills and cultural awareness that students need to live in a “multicultural, multilingual, globally interconnected world” (Orozco & Sattin, 2007, p. 60). All in all, Orozco and Sattin (2007) are correct when they state “education for globalization should aim to educate the whole child for the whole world” (p. 62). A comprehensive civic education program must also place particular emphasis on how students will be assessed. Assessments for students should be multifaceted and allow students a choice in how they want to express their knowledge and understanding of a specific topic. The senior service learning seminars allow students to learn through the traditional sense, through reflective and guided class discussions, and through combining actions with knowledge to create real-world meaningful experiences. Students have the opportunity to visit each method of assessment weekly, which makes sure that all students are able to employ their strengths and weaknesses. For example, during the course of one week students might participate in peer- Service Learning Projects - 16 teaching, reflective journal writing about their hands-on experiences, and attend a political discussion regarding the implications of a specific policy or bill on society. Students in all situations have the opportunity to display their individual work and knowledge, as well as how they work collaboratively with their peers and parents in order to produce a final product. By administering various forms of assessment, teachers may find an answer to addressing student differences while still addressing high standards and capitalizing on student strengths (Caine & Caine, 2006, p. 54). Additionally, educators must be aware when assessing students that in all mainstream classrooms there are some students that may be classified as “at risk.” Not all students learn the same way, and as such, instructors must make an effort to expose their learners to a variety of learning modalities. With the usage of practical strategies and practices that are combined with patience and care, these students may become successful and may demonstrate high-quality work when solicited. Some strategies that promote higher order thinking, even among at risk students, include: preparing open-ended questions about the material being covered, increasing wait time for students to respond, placing challenging questions around the classroom with model responses, and routinely teaching question words like “analyze” “Interpret” “explain” “trace” (Bell, 2003, p. 33). Finally, teachers must continually review and re-teach material for all students through correcting incorrect portions of assignments, informal and formal checks for understanding, and employing daily reviews either at the beginning or end of each class as routine activities (Bell, 2003, p. 33). All in all, the most effective approach to confronting and working within student differences is to engage a universal student strength: “learning from life” (Caine & Caine, 2006, p. 54). There are certain aspects of basic civic education that all secondary students should have the opportunity to master while in high school. Although the current political trends illustrate that Service Learning Projects - 17 today’s youth are apathetic towards government, politics, and public life, through effort their attitudes can still be changed. By connecting civic education and volunteerism, many students will better connect their studies with present policies, political initiatives, and implications that affect the United States as a nation and to some extent the world as a whole. In addition to providing the best possible civic education for my students, I believe that this type of service learning based program will also serve to help me advance my own professional development and further my skills as an educator. I plan on continuing to develop lesson plans that not only engage students and promote political participation, but also help connect students learning experiences by teaching in a cross-curricular modality. This is paramount, as students need to understand that all of their courses are not isolated, but rather connect in a complex fashion and as such understanding in one course helps strengthen principles and knowledge in another course. Moreover, I will continue to plan and understand the connection between civic education and public policies to local service learning by exploring new possibilities and encouraging students to draw implications from those possibilities. I believe that this will further help my students see the many ways in which government affects their daily lives. Finally, I plan on continuing to challenge my students in the classroom and to have them question the status quo each day. By illustrating what current policies are and having learners brainstorm, I feel that students will realize that change is possible and can be accomplished successfully when there is a will. I also will continue to plan using the NCSS and state standards to structure discussions and learning. Thus, when bringing all conceptual ideas together, I realize that education can be energized and perhaps a new spin needs to be placed on civic education. Although I originally thought that implementing a school-wide, four-year version of Project Citizen would be most beneficial for students, I realize that perhaps that goal is unattainable. Such a program would not only be too time Service Learning Projects - 18 intensive for both teachers and students, but would also face barriers in the form of teacher resistance and lack of resources. As such, I think that the most practical way to energize students about becoming involved and engaged politically is to cater to what they enjoy doing. By bridging volunteerism with civic education, I feel that students will be given the opportunity to relate information that they learn inside the classroom to the real world and big issues. By employing a wide variety of learning techniques, creating a relaxed environment for the seminar, integrating the curriculum with other courses, evaluating with college level expectations, and having multiple assessments that test a variety of individual strengths, students will learn to become more politically active - as they will feel empowered, knowledgeable, and have experience with certain issues. I believe that only such a focused, concerted effort will provide the necessary change and stimulation to make a lasting impression of the importance of civic education and political participation to our youth. Service Learning Projects - 19 Bibliography Bell, L. (2003). Strategies that close the gap. Educational Leadership. 32-34. Bose, M. & DiIulio, J. (2007). Classic ideas and current issues in American Government. New York: Houghton Mifflin Company. Caine, R. & Caine, G. (2006). The way we learn. Educational Leadership. 50-54. Conley, D. (2007). The challenge of college readiness. Educational Leadership. 23-29. Marzano, R. & Marzano, J. (2003). The key to classroom. Educational Leadership. 6-13. Mattson, Kevin (2003). Engaging youth: Combating the apathy of young Americans towards politics. New York, NY: The Century Foundation Press. Mitchell, D. (2007). Environmental Protection Volunteer Opportunities. Retrieved February 18, 2007, from Charity Guide website: http://charityguide.org/volunteer/environmentalprotection.htm Moran, S., Kornhaber, M., & Gardner, H. (2006). Orchestrating multiple intelligences. Educational Leadership. 22-27. Olsen, D. (1995). Less can be more in the promotion of thinking. Social Education. 130-134. Scheurman, G. (1998). From behaviorist to constructivist Teaching. Social Education. 6-9. Sears, A., & Hughes, A. (1996). Citizenship education and current educational reform. Canadian Journal of Education, 21, 123-142. Retrieved September 12, 2007, from JSTOR database. Suarez-Orozoco, M. & Sattin, C. (2007). Wanted: Global citizens. Educational Leadership. 58-62. Tomlinson, C. & Jarvis, J. (2006). Teaching beyond the book. Educational Leadership. 16-21. Wenglinsky, H. (2004). Facts or critical thinking skills. Educational Leadership. 32-35. Youth Voting in America. The Young and the Restless. Retrieved September 7, 2007, from http://www.southmaineonline.com/youthvote/national.html.