Private and Public Higher Education Shares for 117 countries (2000-2009) *, **, ***, **** Last Update: November 2010 Country1 Private % of Total HE Enrolment Afghanistan3 12.0 (19,800/164,800) 23.9 (489,039/2,048,876) 26.6 (22,600/85,100) 3.5 (40,000/ N/A) Albania Argentina Armenia Australia Austria4 Azerbaijan Bangladesh Belarus Belgium4 4.4 14.4 (17,500/121,500) 14.4 (61,108/423,236) 15.2 (58,300/383,400) 55.4 (218,373/394,427) Year - Private % of Total HEIs Year Private % of Total Univ. Enrolment 2 Year Private % of Total Univ. Year - - - - - - - - 2005 54.6 (54/99) 2003 2003 16.5 (254,117/1,539,742) 2004 70.0 (28/40) 53.5 (1,327/2480) 77.3 (68/88) 2004 - - - - 2008 - - - - - - - - - 2003 - 2005/06 44.2 (91,648/207,577) 2005 35.7 (15/42) 48.6 (54/111) 21.8 (12/55) 33.3 (11/33) 2005 2006 - - 2005 2003 2003/04 Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) 2005/06 2005 71.6 (53/74) 2005 - - - - - - - - Page 1 Benin 20.0 2009 Bhutan 0 - Bolivia Bosnia & Herzegovina 27.8 2004 (N/A /12,200) 28.6 (6,000/21,000) 74.6 (3,639,413/4,880,381) 17.6 (58,380/332,654) 2006/07 58.0 (56,563/97,524) - Botswana Brazil Bulgaria Burundi Cambodia Chad Chile China Colombia Costa Rica Croatia (400/ N/A) 77.6 (584,722/753,543) 19.9 (4,013,010/20,210,249) 49.6 (600,731/1,212,035) 54.6 (93,730/171,792) 11.3 (16,000/141,000) 2007 2007 2008/09 2006 2003 2007 2008 2005 2004 2008 Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) 96.4 (27/28) 1999 - - - - - 2003 0 70.2 (40/57) - 2004 0 18.2 (56,764/312,769) 2005 2006 - - - - 2007 - 2008/09 (1/ N/A) 67.0 (203/303) 16.3 (7/43) 2007 2008/09 66.9 (2,224,824/3,325,125) 15.9 (39,107/246,523) (4/ N/A) 64.5 (40/62) 2002 - - 2006 - - (2/ N/A) 92.8 (205/221) 28.3 (640/2,263) 70.6 (197/279) 47.1 (57/121) 57.1 (28/49) 2003 66.9 (340,702/509,523) - 0 75.9 (1,530/2,015) 73.3 (22/30) 85.7 (6/7) 89.1 (2,032/2,281) 30.2 (16/53) 2007 2005 2008 2007 2007 2008 2004 0 56.2 (506,137/900,435) 53.4 (86,951/162,925) 2008 - 2007 69.2 (18/26) 73.8 (45/61) 2007 2008/09 2004 2007 2008 2004 0 67.8 (116/171) 92.6 (50/54) - - - 2005 2007 2004 Page 2 Cuba Cyprus Czech Republic Democratic Republic of Congo Denmark4 Dominican Republic Ecuador Egypt El Salvador Estonia Ethiopia Finland4 France4 Gabon 0.0 (0/908,588) 66.6 (13,712/20,587) 8.9 (29,201/327,955) 81.6 (82,173/100,724) 1.9 (4,367/228,893) 49.7 (160,603/323,439) 28.7 (90,278/314,496) 19.2 (447,000/2,325,000) 66.3 (82,812/124,956) 18.0 (12,315/68,399) 24.0 10.5 (32,393/308,966) 16.6 (364,783/2,201,201) 46.3 (25,000/54,000) 2007 2005/06 2004 80.6 (29/36) 40.1 (95/237) 2004 0.0 (0/4,861) 11.9 (40,939/344,180) 1997/98 (39/ N/A) - 2006 - 2005/06 2005 2004 2003 2006 2008/09 2003 88.4 (38/43) 58.7 (236/402) 62.6 (109/174) 83.3 (35/42) 52.2 (24/46) 60.0 - 2005/06 2007 0.0 (0/1) 60.0 (42/70) - - - - - 0.0 2007/08 0.0 2007/08 2005 50.1 (159,867/319,263) 2005 2004 2005 N/A 2.2 (39,000/1,766,000) 68.5 (79,299/115,715) 2005/06 2003 2006 2006 2006 0.0 4.2 (147/3,500) 2005/06 - - 0.0 (0/20) 15.5 (13/84) 2003 (3/ N/A) - - - - Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) - 93.9 (31/33) 56.9 (37/65) 46.4 (13/28) 96.2 (25/26) 0.0 (0/176,555) 2006 2004 2003 2007 2006 - 2007 2005 2004 2005 N/A 2006 2007/08 - Page 3 Georgia Germany Ghana Greece Guatemala Honduras Hong Kong, China Hungary Iceland4 India Indonesia Ireland4 Israel Italy Ivory Coast Japan 19.2 (29,400/153,300) 4.9 (94,285/1,920,102) 11.2 (8,000/71,600) 0.0 48.1 (105,082/218,466) 19.7 (22,018/111,766) 59.0 (127,256/215,637) 13.6 (56,590/416,348) 22.9 (3853/16,853) 30.7 (3,219,000/10,481,000) 71.0 (2,392,417/3,371,156) 7.0 13.1 (26,860/205,149) 7.2 (146,796/2,029,023) 31.0 77.4 2003 2008/09 2004 2005/06 2003 2002 2007/08 2006/07 2005 2005/06 2007 2004 2005/06 2006 2007 Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) 85.2 (150/176) 34.3 (122/356 ) 90.3 (28/31) 0.0 91.7 (11/12) 60.0 (9/15) 54.5 (12/22) 56.3 (40/71) 37.5 (3/8) 43.0 (7,720/17,973) 95.5 (2,766/2,897) 0.0 (0/20) 13.1 (8/61) 20.5 (17/83) (1/ N/A) 89.6 2003 2008/09 1.2 (15,760/1,339,274) 2008/09 2004 2005/06 0.0 2005/06 2009 - - 2002 - 2007/08 59.4 (95,238/ 160,295) 2006/07 19.3 (21/109) 2008/09 2005/06 2007/08 0.0 91.7 (11/12) 70.0 (7/10) 22.2 (2/9) - - - - 2006/07 - - - - 2005/06 - - - 2007 - - 89.0 (372/418) 2005/06 0.0 (0/123,010) 6.2 (110,624/1,780,743) 73.2 - 2005/06 2006/07 2007 2005/06 2006/07 2007 0.0 (0/7) 23.0 (17/74) 76.7 2009 2002 2007/08 2007 2005/06 2006/07 2007 Page 4 (2,924,022/3,776,623) Jordan5 Kazakhstan Kenya Kosovo Kyrgyzstan Lao People’s Democratic Republic Latvia Lesotho Lithuania The FYR of Macedonia Malaysia Maldives3 Mexico Moldova 46.5 (347,100/747,100) 17.9 (21,132/118,239) 50.7 (38,000/75,000) 7.2 (15,800/218,300) 32.4 (14,371/44,289) 31.9 (40,713/127,760) 8.5 (16,438/193,928) 17.9 (11,509/64,254) 50.9 (322,891/634,033) 33.4 (745,018/2,232,189) 24.0 (26,500/110,200) (4,199/4,689) 2004 2008 2004 2004/05 2007/08 2005/06 2007/08 2004 2007 2003 Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) 71.8 (130/181) 13.1 (17/130) 97.0 (32/33) 32.7 (16/49) 79.5 (31/39) 36.7 (22/60) 72.7 (16/22) 38.8 (19/49) 62.5 (5/8) 97.0 (559/576) 72.7 (1,175/1,617) 44.5 (48/108) (2,071,642/2,828,635) - - - 2004 - 2004 52.9 (91,541/173,032) - (580/756) 58.3 (14/24) 2006 2004/05 74.0 (17/23) 2004 - - - - 2004 - - - - 2005 29.7 (34,172/114,965) - - - 2007/08 0.0 (0/1) 33.3 (7/21) - 2007/08 2000 2005/06 3.5 (4,992/141,771) 2005/06 2004 - - 2004 - 7.5 - 2007 2003 - 2000 2005/06 2000 - 39.3 (11/28) - 2004 - 41.8 2003 72.7 2002 - - - - Page 5 Mongolia 26.0 2003 Montenegro (N/A /20,000) 32.1 (7,143/22,256) 0 (0/ N/A) 69.9 (361,177/516,769) 9.3 (23,763/256,468) 47.5 (65,000/136,960) 3.4 (37,636/1,108,199) 0 13.4 (28,434/211,559) - Mozambique Myanmar Nepal3 Netherlands4 New Zealand Nicaragua Nigeria North Korea Norway4 Oman6 Pakistan Panama Paraguay Peru 24.7 23.8 (103,466/435,130) 18.3 (24,187/132,167) 41.1 (44,722/108,812) 51.1 (463,801/908,315) 2003 8.3 2003 27.2 2003 - - - - - 2004 64.2 80.0 (4/5) 50.0 (6/12) 2004 - - - - 2005 - 0 - 2005 - 0 - 2005 - 0 - 2005 - 2002 2006/07 - - - - 2007 0 2007 2003 - - 2006 - - 2006/07 0 1.0 (883/87,562) 2006/07 2006 29.9 2006 2007/08 - - 2004 - 2003 0 90.9 (40/44) 30.7 (23/75) 0 8.3 (1/12) 75.0 (3/ N/A) 42.6 (40/94) 87.5 (28/32) 2007 2003 0.0 85.6 (172/201) 58.5 (69/118) 36.0 (32/89) 0 45.7 (32/70) 88.0 (22/25) 46.0 (57/124) 83.1 (59/71) 2003 - - - 2005 - - 50.3 (263,354/523,359) 2006 2005 2006 2006/07 2006 2007/08 Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) 2005 59.8 (49/82) 2003 2005 2006/07 2006 2007/08 2004 2005 Page 6 Philippines Poland Portugal Romania Russia Saudi Arabia7 65.2 (1,589,866/2,438,855) 34.1 (660,464/1,937,401) 25.9 (98,664/380,937) 33.8 (265,243/785,506) 14.9 (1,024,000/ 6,884,000) 2007 2004/05 2007 2004 2005 2003 3.7 (20,654/563,062) 27.9 (67,157/241,054) 23.1 (50,576/218,860) 2004 9.9 2000 - - 2003 2005/06 2004/5 2005/06 - - - - - - - 2006 - - - - 2007/08 - - - 2003 - 2004/05 - 71.1 (86/121) 84.8 (145/171) 32.4 (24/74) 28.4 (21/74) Spain Sri Lanka3 9.6 - 2001 - 30.0 - 2003 - Sudan - - - - - Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) 2004/05 - 2006 2004 2005/06 2005/06 - South Korea 2006 2004/05 - - 78.4 (1,439,297/1,836,649) 9.0 (132,000/1,463,000) - South Africa - 2005/06 25.0 (6/24) 70.8 (46/65) 49.0 (52/107) 2000 2007/08 Slovenia 2003 - 37.1 12.5 (1/8) (N/A /239,000) 9.8 (20,098/ 204,082) 2.6 (3,552/136,990) 4.1 (30,000/730,000) 80.1 (2,565,888/3,204,036) Serbia Slovak Republic - 89.5 (1,431/1,599) 70.8 (315/445) 66.7 (110/165) 55.2 (37/67) 38.2 (409/1,071) 96.0 (48/50) 49.3 (33/67) 45.0 (9/20) 27.6 (8/29) (80.7 (96/119) 87.0 (280/322) Senegal 10.9 (4,140/38,040) 2005/06 2002 2004 2006 2001 2004 2006/07 2000 Page 7 Sweden4 Switzerland 7.3 (30,476/414,657) - 2003 - 2006/07 Thailand 71.9 19.4 (12,400/64,052) 9.9 (173,007/1,750,777) Turkey 5.8 2005/06 65.8 65.6 21/32 47.0 (70/149) 26.1 (30/115) UAE8 - - - Taiwan Tanzania Vietnam 15.1 (17,060/113,060) 10.5 (237,100/2,264,767) 0.0 (0/2,336,111) 26.1 (4,757,348/18,248,128) 11.7 (14,426/123,139) 41.6 10.4 (137,760/1,319,754) Yemen10 - Uganda Ukraine United Kingdom United States9 Uruguay Venezuela 2004 40.0 (24/60) - 2007 2003/04 2003 2006 85.2 (23/27) 17.6 (175/997) 2005 61.3 (2,667/4,352) 22.2 (14/63) 56.8 12.6 (29/230) - - 2007 2007 2004 Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) 2005 - - - 2004 66.8 2004 2006/07 - - 2007 16.8 2001 2005/06 5.8 2005/06 - - 2003/04 17.6 (3/17) 64.1 62.0 (13/21) 2006/07 2004 2006/07 2005/06 - 28.3 26.1 (30/115) 66.7 (6/9) - - - - 2003 - - - - - 2003 2005 38.4 (4,463,537/11,630,198) 15.0 (14,273/95,396) 21.7 0.7 (1/139) 75.6 (2,022/2,675) 73.3 (11/15) 55.1 2005 - - - - - 2007/08 2007 2007 2004 60.0 (3/5) 2003 2006 2006 2007/08 2003 2005 2006 Page 8 Zimbabwe 4.5 (1,797/39,797) Total***** 31.3 (34,943,443/111,773,28 4) Zambia 2003/04 41.7 (5/12) 55.7 - 0 2001 0 2001 2003/04 - - - - (30,555/54,866 ) * This global table derives mostly from PROPHE’s four regional tables: Africa, Asia, Europe, and Latin America. The major exception is inclusion of the United States here. There is also inclusion of five Middle Eastern countries not shown in Africa or any other regional table, but the data are sparse for Middle Eastern countries, many of which have just opened private institutions, and the region’s overall higher education numbers mostly remain small. The only countries we show here are Jordan, Oman, Saudi Arabia, UAE, and Yemen, and among them only Oman shows substantial data. ** Although the data come from the most reliable sources found—usually official sources—criteria and inclusiveness both vary greatly across countries and regions, so comparisons should be drawn only with caution. For example, the meaning of higher education, university, and tertiary education varies. In some databases, only accredited or at least licensed institutions are counted; in others, the figures are more broadly inclusive. There are also differences in how to count enrolments and in many other respects. Further details and caveats see PROPHE’s four regional tables. Attention to such matters is keener in PROPHE’s in-depth data work on individual countries. See http://www.albany.edu/dept/eaps/prophe/data/national.html. *** Except for some pre-2000 data on several African countries. Also, in some cases no date is noted. For sources and comments on individual countries from Africa, Asia, Europe, and Latin America, see the pertinent regional tables. **** For the following countries, on which we have no other data, the World Bank, Accelerating Catch-up: Tertiary education for growth in Sub-Saharan Africa, Washington, D.C, 2009, gives the following figures for the number of private HEIs: Angola 7, Burkina Faso 4, Cape Verde 1, Central African Republic 4, Guinea 1, Liberia 3, Malawi 0, Mali 2, Mauritania 0, Namibia 1, Niger 0, Rwanda 12, and Togo 22. Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) Page 9 ***** If we sum all the enrolment data for Latin America, we get a private share of 48.2 %, but caution is required as national data range from 2002 to 2007 and we lack Bolivian enrolments. The private regional Latin America enrolment share was 46.6% in 2003; according to IESALC-UNESCO (2006), Informe sobre la Educación Superior en América Latina y El Caribe 2000-2005: La metamorfosis de la educación superior, Caracas. If we sum all the enrolment data for Asia, we get a private share of 36.4%, excluding countries and regions where either private enrolments or total enrolments are not available. If we sum all the enrolment data for Africa, we get a private share of 14.6%, excluding Benin, Chad, Ethiopia and Ivory Coast, countries and regions where either private enrolments or total enrolments are not available. If we sum all the enrolment data for Europe, we get a private share of 16.0%, excluding countries and regions where either private enrolments or total enrolments are not available, such as Austria, Ireland, Spain and Turkey. If we take the enrollment data drawn from the regional tables (48% for Latin America, 36.4% for Asia, 16.0% for Europe, and 14.6% for Africa), and if we weigh in the U.S.A. at 26.1%, we get a private share of total global higher education as 31.3%. If we sum all the institutional data for Latin America, we get a private share of 71.3 %, excluding countries and regions where either private institutions or total institutions are not available, such as Cuba and Peru. If we sum all the institutional data for Asia, we get a private share of 57.8 %, excluding countries and regions where either private institutions or total institutions are not available, such as Afghanistan, Maldives, and Nepal. If we sum all the institutional data for Africa, we get a private share of 59.2 %, excluding countries and regions where either private institutions or total institutions are not available, such as Sudan and Democratic Republic of Congo. If we sum all the institutional data for Europe, we get a private share of 25.7 %, excluding countries and regions where either private institutions or total institutions are not available, such as Austria and Belgium. If we take the institution data drawn from the regional tables (71.3% for Latin America, 57.8% for Asia, 25.7% for Europe, and 59.2% for Africa), and if we weigh in the U.S.A. at 61.3%, we get a private share of total global higher education institutions as 55.7%. 1 For the Latin American countries, data include undergraduate and graduate enrolment, except for Argentina, Bolivia, Uruguay, and Venezuela where only undergraduate is depicted. 2 University centers, university institutions or university institutes count within the university sector for Argentina, Brazil, Colombia, and Uruguay. Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) Page 10 3 Although some numbers are shown by sources, they are not solid enough to place in the table, particularly in regard to inconsistency about what is counted as higher education. 4 For several West European countries, there is great ambiguity on what is private. The OECD and Eurydice databases refer to public institutions and to independent private and also to government-dependent private institutions. The latter two types may be legally private, administered by nongovernment agencies such as churches, businesses, trade unions, or other bodies. Yet only the independent privates normally are seen as functionally private within the country. According to both databases, the difference between independent private institutions and government-dependent private institutions lies in the degree of core funding a private institution gets from government. If an institution receives 50% or more of its core funding from the government, it is considered government-dependent; in turn, if an institution receives less than 50% of its core funding from the government, it is counted as independent private institution. In each case we put the inclusive private figure into the table and then give the independent private figure in the note to that country. PROPHE’s general preference is to list and count as private whatever is legally private and to count as public whatever is legally public—and then explore empirically what these institutions are like in practice. Additionally, many government-dependent institutions are more autonomous (or “private”) in government than are public institutions, and, in any event, the 50% core funding mark is somewhat arbitrary. Still, in the interest of full information, we show separately both the total private figure (in the table) and the independent private share (in the notes). 5 AL-Omari, Aieman. and Obeidat, Osamha. University Missions/Goals in the Context of Globalization: Public and Private Institutions in the Middle East. International Journal of Private Higher Education 2006 (1): http://www.xaiu.edu.cn/xaiujournal/. 6 Sources: Ministry of Education, Oman www.moe.gov.om. For the number of the university, Al-Lamki, Salma M. and Qaboos, Sultan. The Development of Private Higher Education in the Sultanate of Oman: Perception and Analysis. International Journal of Private Higher Education 2006 (1), [online] available at http://www.xaiu.edu.cn/xaiujournal/. 7 Provided by Yussra Jamjoom. 8 AL-Omari, Aieman. and Obeidat, Osamha, 2006. 9 Source: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. Digest of Education Statistics: 2008. For enrollments: http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d08/tables/dt08_189.asp?referrer=list; For institutions: Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) Page 11 http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d08/tables/dt08_265.asp?referrer=list; Also see PROPHE’s U.S. case online at http://www.albany.edu/dept/eaps/prophe/data/countrydata.html. 10 AL-Omari, Aieman. and Obeidat, Osamha, 2006. Program for Research on Private Higher Education (PROPHE) Page 12