Fighting against harmful social practices The case study of Mauritania Executive Summary FGM/C is a deep-rooted social norm in Mauritania. The average prevalence rate is 72.2. The most extreme forms are low (35%). Formerly used as a rite of passage for girls into adulthood, FGM/C are now most often performed some weeks after birth. There are strong negative sanctions for mothers who choose not to cut their daughters. Since 2009, the Ministry of Social Affairs of Social Affairs, Childhood and Family (MASEF) initiated a process of building a national child protection system to prevent and respond to the CP issues in a comprehensive and coordinated manner. UNICEF Actions against FGM/C are now part of this national initiative to protect children. Launched in 2007, they are mainly conducted by MASEF and Tostan, in 5 of 7 regions with the highest prevalence of FGM/C, in close partnership with UNFPA and in the context of a national coordination that brings together all key FGM/C international and national players under the authority of the department. UNICEF action’s includes 2 main components: the Tostan Education program for Human Rights and the program of voluntary abandonment of FGM/C implemented by MASEF and national NGOs that includes 4 subcomponents: i) awareness campaigns at national, provincial and department levels as well as community empowerment interventions in some municipalities; ii) support for national coordination of FGM/C actions, iii) training and mobilizing imams, professionals and opinion leaders, iv) empowerment of local organisations and leaders including FGM/C actors on child rights and child protection. The paradigm that guides actions for FGM/C abandonment in the country is based on the results of research conducted by Innocenti. Thus, implementation approach consists of massive and organized dissemination of positive messages promoting the voluntary abandonment and focused on human rights. Arguments used for combating FGM/C are built on 4 main elements: religious, health, legal and human rights. However, according to the social norm theory, any strategy proposed/used to tackle a social norm must take into consideration the concerned people’s expectations about themselves and about others. It is only when interventions are oriented to change people’s expectations that the behavior considered as inappropriate can change. According to some Mauritanian experts, beside religion the practice of FGM/C in Mauritania is related to the control of women sexuality. FGM/C is the shield that guarantees the preservation of virginity and marriageability. Virginity guarantees family honor. Prestige and social recognition depend on honor. Moreover, uncut young women are likely to remain spinster because cutting is one of the key criteria that determine the choice of men of their future wife. Moreover, according to the Mauritanian collective perception, mothers, as the guardian of moral values and the key family authority on FGM/C, must be exemplary both in society and in family. Cutting their daughters is an indication that guarantees that they have these suitable moral values. Guirlene Frederic Page 1 Consequently, it is crucial to confirm through research whether, from a practical point of view, mothers expect that every mother will cut her daughters (mothers’ empirical expectations), whatever her reasons may be, and whether the moral duties expected from them are really those they should completed to meet the expectations of the society and especially of their own community. It is obvious that these values and perception are in total opposition with those related to child/women rights to health, to human dignity, to freedom from physical or mental violence and injury and gender equality (see: F. Moneti’s presentation and UNICEF guidelines). However, Mauritanian mothers choose to do so for good reasons (see G. Mackie and C. Bicchieri’s presentations). So, we are clearly in two different worlds. Values confrontation will not end the practice. As highlighted by our colleague from Egypt, Sahar Hegazi, we need to use weapons of persuasion and convince mothers and the entire communities that they can ensure their girls’ happiness, preserve family honor and acquire social recognition in a better way: cutting is an unneeded practice. What will be the most effective way to change the practice as quickly as possible without hurting the Mauritanian values and beliefs? Based on some key concepts and tools studied, we will try to propose positive alternatives. We envision these lines of actions: I) Use some keys concepts and tools of social norms/social change theories to ensure effectiveness of the existing FGM/C programs in the context of the national coordination? Based on the new knowledge acquired there is a critical need to move our intuitive/empirical approach to a more scientific/effective one. This includes the following lines of action: re-categorize some specific elements of the script (see Christina Bicchieri’s presentation) by putting a specific attention on collecting/incorporating information on empirical and normative expectations and on developing a set of positive arguments to change communities’ expectations and therefore neutralize the existing sanctions against mothers and families who do not chose to cut their daughters; organize a participatory process of identification of the most powerful networks and individuals (see Ryan Muldoon’s presentation) and the targeted community inter-marrying linkages and strengthen the existing networks involved in the promotion of FGM/C by integrating the most influential individuals and groups and setting-up a common agenda of actions; reinforce the comprehensiveness of the package of actions and systematize the use of the nondirective approach for community empowerment II) Use concepts and tools of social norms/social change theories to go beyond the FGM/C national program and try to build national consensus in favour of policies/laws, institutions and structures that will ensure a protective environment and well-being for all Mauritanian children, in particular the most vulnerable and excluded. Guirlene Frederic Page 2 I. Context Violence, exploitation, abuse, discrimination and Regional variations of FGM/C prevalence neglect against children are frequent and multifaceted in (MICS 2007) Mauritania and affect a significant proportion of children. In regard to FGM/C, data available show an average prevalence rate of 72.2 of circumcision on young girls and women aged 15-49 years, with extreme rates ranging from 88% - to 98% mainly located in the southern half of the territory, in 7 regions. The practice of FGM is to remove from the genitals of the woman, the clitoris and sometimes the labia minora. The most extreme forms are low (3-5%). Formerly used as a rite of passage for girls into adulthood, FGM/C are now most often performed some weeks after birth. According to the MICS IV, the age limit does not generally exceed 2 years. Mauritanie 72.2 Tiris Zemmour 48.5 Dakhlet Nouadhibou 40.2 Adrar 61.8 Inchiri 30.4 Tagant 96.1 Nouakchott 54.8 Trarza 26.6 Brakna 88.1 Gorgol 94.7 El Hodh El Gharbi Assaba 97.6 98.1 El Hodh Ech Charghi 94.4 Guidimagha 97.3 Since 2009, the Mauritanian Government through the Ministry of Social Affairs of Social Affairs, Childhood and Family (MASEF) initiated a process of building a national child protection system to prevent and respond to the CP issues in a comprehensive and coordinated manner. II. Deciphering the script of FGM/C in Mauritania According to the results of anthropological research by Pr Abdoulaye Sow 1, anthropologist researcher and professor at the University of Nouakchott, religion and conjugal virtues are the main reasons listed to explain the practice. According to him, beside religion the practice of FGM in Mauritania is related to the control of women sexuality. As the culture of shame and modesty strongly influence Mauritanian’s behaviours, the young girl, from her childhood, is subject to a rigorous discipline to tame her feelings and natural desires and aims to inculcate a sense of shame of her body to prevent her from engaging in sex and in particular to get pregnant outside marriage that may dishonour her family. FGM/C are the shield against the carnal pleasures that guarantees the preservation of virginity and marriageability. As for the conjugal virtues, in line with the collective Mauritanian imagination, young girls cut will grow to be a faithful wife, loyal, submissive and strong enough to withstand the pain of childbirth. It is obvious that these values and perception are in total opposition with those related to child/women rights to health, to human dignity, to freedom from physical or mental violence and injury and gender equality (see: F. Moneti’s presentation and UNICEF guidelines). However, Mauritanian mothers choose to do so for good reason (see G. Mackie and C. Bicchieri’s presentations). We are clearly in two different worlds. The confrontation of values will not end the practice. As highlighted by our colleague from Egypt, we need to use weapons of persuasion and convince mothers that they can ensure their 1 His research on cultural factors underpinning FGM/C is part of his technical assistance to MASEF to develop, with the financial contribution of UNICEF together with UNIFPA, a harmonized training module for the national coordination against FGM/C. Guirlene Frederic Page 3 daughters’ happiness in a better way: the practice of excision is unneeded. What will be the most effective way to change the practice as quickly as possible without hurting the Mauritanian values and beliefs? Based on some key concepts and tools studied during the course, we will try to propose positive alternatives. a. Elements of empirical reasons of the key decision makers within the family Mothers have full authority to decide whether or not to circumcise their daughters. In some areas, grandmothers may also have a key role in the decision, in particular when their married daughters or daughters in law are too young to have a say in the family decisions. However, men have also a responsibility in the continuity of the practice because women think that they prefer circumcised women. Actually, this preference was confirmed by the research of Pr. Sow. According to the mothers’ point of view, any good mother will cut her daughter due to the following reasons: cutting ensures virginity on the wedding day. Virginity guarantees family honor and illustrates the extreme value of the bride and her mother. Prestige and social recognition depend on honor; uncut young women are likely to remain spinster because cutting is one of the key criteria that determine the choice of men of their future wife; It is unclear however whether these views are shared evenly among all the tribes and ethnic groups. Moreover, up to now, the trigger for change among mothers who chose not to circumcise their girls is still unknown. Thus, it remains to confirm whether, from a practical point of view, mothers expect that every mother will cut her daughters (mothers’ empirical expectations), whatever her reasons may be (see: C. Bicchieri’s presentation). b. Elements of normative expectations According to the collective perception described by Pr. Sow, Mauritanian women, as the guardian of moral values, must be exemplary both in society and in family. Thus, they must adopt the following behaviors: 1) Preserve the family’s honor; 2) Ensure purity of the blood pedigree of the ethnic group by strict observance of endogamous marriage strategies to guarantee the “bouclage consanguin”; 3) Ensure the glory of the descendants: The fate of a child is highly dependent on the moral qualities of his mother. It is a belief deeply rooted in the Mauritanian mentality; 4) Have the conjugal virtues required: in addition to her alleged moral qualities, a cut woman is more sexually attractive to men. In order to be consistent in applying the key concepts of expectations, it remains to examine whether these mothers believe that these duties are really those they should completed to meet the expectations of the society and especially of their own community. c. Common sanctions and incentives The most common sanctions associated with the choice of uncutting can be summarized as follow: Guirlene Frederic Page 4 Stigmatization, shame and rejection. Spinsterhood. Bad reputation. The fear of shame and dishonor is one of the most powerful incentives that explain persistence of the practice by Mauritanian mothers. III. UNICEF actions UNICEF Actions against FGM/C are part of the national initiative to protect children. Launched in 2007, they are mainly conducted by MASEF and Tostan, in 5 of 7 regions with the highest prevalence of FGM/C, in close partnership with UNFPA in the context of a national coordination that brings together all key FGM/C players under the authority of the department. This includes the following lines of action: 1. The Tostan Education program for Human Rights. Started in 2007, the first phase of the Tostan program in Mauritania was closed in May 2010 and allowed to educate and mobilise 30 core communities and 48 “adopted” communities in one of the most affected regions. A second phase program for a new core of 30 communities and a more limited support for the 78 initial ones is being designed. 2. The program of voluntary abandonment of FGM/C implemented by MASEF and National NGOs in four regions with high prevalence that includes these following subcomponents: Awareness campaigns that mobilize since 2007 authorities, professionals and other social actors, religious and community leaders, local NGOs, schools and media at national, provincial and department levels- in Nouakchott, the districts capitals and moughataas of four regions with high prevalence- as well as community empowerment interventions and support for some targeted municipalities. Support for national coordination of FGM/C actions This coordination bring together, under the leadership of MASEF, the key International agencies and key national NGOs to make operational a national mechanism to harmonize FGM/C approaches, methods and tools including harmonized monitoring and evaluation based on the prevalence of circumcision among girls of 0-five years which will be available in 2011. This component also includes studies, evaluation and research on Mauritanian FGM/C perception and practices. Training and mobilizing imams, professionals and opinion leaders This component aims at disseminating the national fatwa against FGM/C for the progressive education and involvement of imams, training and involvement of health personnel and other key opinion leaders in all areas with high prevalence. Empowerment of local organisations and leaders including FGM/C actors on child rights and child protection This component includes training and increasing involvement of local associations and FGM/C actors in the CP national efforts. In view of their crucial role at grassroots level, these local stakeholders will contribute to the protection responses by identifying, addressing directly community protection issues and referring the most difficult cases of children and families at risk or victims. IV. Main achievements FGM/C is no longer a taboo in the country and a growing proportion in the population tends to be in favour to its abandonment. Guirlene Frederic Page 5 Political authorities are increasingly committed to combating FGM/C. This also concerns the Parliament, which has public express his commitment to enact legislation to criminalize FGM/C, this year. The Fatwa recently issued by 33 among the most influential imams against FGM/C and their public stand for abandonment. At the end of 2009, the programmes conducted by MASEF and Tostan educated more than 3,000 local and religious leaders on human rights and/or FGM/C and other harmful practices. These leaders relayed the messages further to 172,072 women and men with 65% of those reached incline to abandon the practice. Representatives of 300 cooperatives of women accompanied Example of national harmonized by a national NGO, Union Rharma and from 78 communities tools: supported by Tostan publicly committed, respectively in February and May, 2010 to abandon female circumcision and early marriages. An operational coordination ensures better harmonization and monitoring of FGM/C actions at national level. A national logo, slogan and harmonized communication tools were developed and are used by all stakeholders. V. Strategy The paradigm that guides actions for FGM/C abandonment in the country is based on the results of research conducted by Innocenti. Thus, as promoted by Innocenti, implementation approach consists of massive and organized dissemination of positive messages promoting the voluntary abandonment and focused on human rights. Thus, in Mauritania, the messages built on health, religious, legal and human rights arguments are designed to create an environment conducive to the voluntary abandonment based on gradual disappearance of the practice due to lack of members. This approach aims primarily to bolster the position of non-members by promoting the gradual increase of number and their power, which would be accompanied by an increase in their inclination / common interest to fight against marginalization by their active involvement in actions to a steady increase their number. The 2 public declarations recently organized by Union Rharma and Tostan are part of this process. As for MASEF, its approach is focusing directly on the promotion of behaviour change in relation to the practice of FGM. To this end, actions continue to link public campaigns and community empowerment. With reference to the theory of Social Convention for collective change, MASEF uses a non-coercive approach to raise awareness of the damages caused by the practice and bring the decision to abandon as a collective decision. MASEF will also encourage public and explicit declaration of abandonment in order to promote the creation of a social and political environment that protects children. VI. Analysis of the strategy used for fighting against excision in Mauritania Arguments (religious, health, legal and human rights) used in Mauritania for combating FGM/C do not deeply differ from those reported in some experiments underway in the region or the UNICEF or UNFPA guidelines in the area. It is also not known yet how effective they are on the abandonment of excision but we know that they are likely to increase predisposition in favor of abandonment. Guirlene Frederic Page 6 However, the most important argument used to combat FGM/C in Mauritania is related to religion. It is based on the assumption that FGM/C is practiced because people believe that it is largely a recommendation or even a requirement of Islam. This fundamental motive gives rise to other sociocultural reasons that mixing ethnicities and interpretations of religious precepts at various degrees. Thus, the involvement of Imams and the Mauritanian fatwa against FGM/C are key factors for combating this practice in this country. Prevalence of FGM/C varies from one ethnic group to another2. The most observant is the Soninke ethnic group (more than 90%) and the least is the Wolof (28%). Can we assume that certain ethnicities are more religious than others? This explanation seems a bit pushy especially since everyone knows that the entire Mauritanian population is very religious and respectful of Islam recommendations. According to R. Muldoon, it is possible that different ethnicities have different interpretations of the requirements of Islam, what might imply different expectations vis-à-vis the practice of FGM/C. It is also widely accepted that health preservation is a key argument because Islam does not recommend any practices having adverse effects on health. This inconsistency (see Hugo Mercier’s presentation) between the justification of the practice as an Islam's recommendation and the obligation to respect human health, according to the Koran, was the clincher that helped secure the agreement of imams to tackle the practice. According to Gerry Mackie, the same inconsistency in the religious discourse in China contributed to ending the practice of foot binding. In this sense the religious argument in Mauritania is in line with that of human rights because it puts forward the need to respect the women and children right to health. These two key arguments (medical and religious) remain crucial in Mauritania and justify for a certain proportion of the populationincluding some influent religious leaders- the usefulness of law to prohibit and criminalize FGM/C. It is important to note that compliance with legal norms (see Antanas Mockus’ presentation) is very low in Mauritania. The country ratified the most key human rights conventions related to children and women and made great efforts to harmonize its legislation, but implementation remains insignificant. The human rights argument is the least accepted and it justifies all on-going work at community level regarding promotion of women and children rights. It is considered as an exogenous value but whose validity is more or less established. But, up to now, we do not know the precise influence of each of the arguments in relation to others. The dominance of the religious and health arguments is assumed but not proven. Education certainly plays a role but it is not radically critical given that the data showed that all those who know the harm of cutting do not necessarily abandon it. Research on social norms, in particular on MGFC, has already explained this. We assume that it is also valid for Mauritania. I think it could be useful to confirm this assumption. It has also been shown that the prevalence of FGM/C is higher in the country side than in the urban areas. The exact reasons for this are not explained either. Modernism seems a reason very general. According to G. Mackie, modernization is insufficient to end the practice, as well as the exclusive use of the religious argument. We do not know the exact inclination to abandonment or the exact prevalence itself compared to the most recent data available (2007) due to the limit of the indicator currently used (prevalence of cutting 2 There are 4 important ethnic groups in Mauritania. Guirlene Frederic Page 7 on 15-49 years women is a non-sensitive measure of trends in the short and medium term). This justifies the government's choice for another indicator of prevalence of circumcision on girls 0-5 years. It is important to also note that massive and organized actions for the abandonment of FGM/C are very recent. They started in 2007. So many questions and many others that UNICEF together with UNFPA are currently trying to support the Government to address through an evaluation of the first three years of the program implementation, an anthropo-sociological study of the key factors explaining MGFC in Mauritania and the choice of a more sensitive national indicator to report on changes in this norm. VII. How can we use the keys concepts and tools of social norms/social change theories to go further and ensure effectiveness of the existing FGM/C programs in the context of the national coordination? Based on the new knowledge acquired there is a critical need to move our intuitive/empirical approach to a more scientific/effective one. This includes the following lines of action: re-categorize the script (see Christina Bicchieri’s presentation) by putting a specific attention on collecting/incorporating information on empirical and normative expectations and on developing a set of positive arguments to change communities’ expectations and therefore neutralize the existing sanctions against mothers and families who do not chose to cut their daughters; organize a participatory process of identification of the most powerful networks and individuals (see Ryan Muldoon’s presentation) and the targeted community inter-marrying linkages and strengthen the existing networks involved in the promotion of FGM/C by integrating the most influential individuals and groups and setting-up a common agenda of actions; reinforce the comprehensiveness of the package of actions and systematize the use of the non-directive approach for community empowerment. Support the Mauritanian Government to re-categorize the script of honor in Mauritania and recentralize arguments against FGM/C on the empirical and normative expectations 2 important prerequisites have to be completed to achieve this: a. Take advantage of the national anthropo-sociological study which is being carried out to confirm/gather accurate information from mothers, men and community representatives’ expectations for each ethnic group b. Finalize the key cultural arguments (in development) that will address each of these expectations in order to neutralize the sanctions without a frontal attack on the values that support these expectations. Examples of counter-arguments proposed by Pr. Sow: (i): “girls may be protected from dishonor by means that are not harmful: Many societies that place also a high value on honor do not cut their girls but manage to protect them by using, for instance, sex education”. The Wolof ethnic group place high value on honor but do not cut their girls to preserve it. Reinforce/build common knowledge on social norms and common agreement/agenda on the way to adapt theories, concepts and tools in the Mauritania context Guirlene Frederic Page 8 Better structure/organize the diffusion of positive messages in favor of abandonment to reach this critical mass intended to bring the process to its tipping point: Share the new knowledge acquired on social norms/social change with UNFPA and the national coordination on FGM/C including MASEF in order to incorporate into the national FGM/C roadmap the key findings about empirical and normative expectations and to systematize the use of a non-directive approach based on positive arguments; Ask for cooperation of Tostan to expand and reinforce the existing group of national trainers of trainers’s skills on social norms, human rights approach, positive and non-directive approach and arguments to promote voluntary abandonment; In partnership with the key agencies working on FGM/C, develop and implement, at all geographic levels, in the 7 areas with high prevalence, a training program to increase the size of the core group of community leaders skilled and committed to disseminate positive messages particularly those related to expectations; Develop sound communication material (including powerful and innovative symbols and slogan: see the Saleema campain and A. Mockus’ presentations) and organize massive multimedia campaigns to disseminate/broadcast, at all levels, information based on positive arguments and data on the proportion of the population who do not cut their girls as well as on those who do not support the practice, but feel compelled to continue because of the fear of social sanctions; Minimize use of incentives (see Erte Xiao’s presentation) and find innovative manners to do it when it is necessary in order to stimulate self-commitment and determination about changing behaviors and norms that are divergent with human rights values and principles; Along with UNFPA and GTZ, implement a large program of sensitization of Imams (at least 500, from September-December 2010) on the National Fatwa in the 7 regions with high prevalence; Taking for example the presentations of Sylvio Waisbord and Sahar Hegazi, support the national coordination to develop and implement a set of relevant indicators to monitor progress on targeted communities’ expectations changes at national and provincial levels. Organize participatory processes at sub-national and local levels to identify the most powerful networks and individuals and the targeted communities inter-marrying linkages Use the core group of facilitators trained and the existing FGM/C/VGB structures at provincial, departmental and municipal level in place to organize focus-groups bringing together representatives of all segments of the targeted population. Up to now, the existing core groups of facilitators used to sensitize targeted communities about FGM/C were chosen based on the criteria of their administrative or technical authority or their position of leaders of local NGOs or CBOs. We just assumed that they have the power to convince people as Mauritanians are very respectful about hierarchy. But, as R. Muldoon pointed out, we have to take also into consideration the degree of trustful of the targeted communities vis-à-vis these “leaders”. This is why we are planning to carry out participatory research using the technique of focus-groups to identify the most trustful/natural leaders to reinforce these core-groups of facilitators credibility in promoting changing in people’s expectations. Guirlene Frederic Page 9 The purpose of these focus-groups is to organize participatory discussions (using appropriate tools like community participatory mapping exercises) to identify: 1) the most powerful/trustful leaders and groups; 2) the community inter-marrying networks. Information collected could be confirmed with those from previous studies and research, when available. Due to budgetary constraints, it would be quite unrealistic to plan surveys at all geographic levels to gather these information. However, it will be important to carefully think about the methodology and instruments that will be used to do so. The national group of trainers for trainers could be the implementing structure of these initiatives with the technical support of an expert on participatory approach. Reinforce the comprehensiveness of the package of actions and systematize the use of nondirective approach for community empowerment At present, although the implementation of holistic community empowerment programs is a recommendation of the National Coordination, this is taken into account systematically and comprehensively only by Tostan and GTZ. All other programs are specifically focused their action on promoting the abandonment of excision without addressing all the issues of children rights and wellbeing. The lack of financial resources largely explains this limit. Similarly, it is not clear that the approach non-directive and non-judgmental is well addressed and systematically implemented by all partners. Given the convincing results produced by Tostan and the power of social mobilization associated with this approach, we believe it is important to support the Ministry to strengthen its generalization. Now that the financial constraint was loosened a bit, we think to ask technical support from Tostan to strengthen the tools and interventions of the members of the coordination on 4 points (see Molly Melching’s presentation): 1. Empowering education for the people most affected by the practice; 2. The method, techniques and tools for identification inter-marrying links; 3. Organized diffusion of information by the participants themselves with special focus on the practice of adoption of bordering communities; 4. Public declaration by interconnected group to mark a change in expectations. VIII. How can we use concepts and tools of social norms/social change theories to go beyond the FGM/C national program and try to build national consensus in favour of policies/laws, institutions and structures that will ensure a protective environment and well being for all Mauritanian children, in particular the most vulnerable and excluded. In line with UNICEF efforts to set foundations of a protective environment for children in Mauritania, MASEF was assisted with the financial contribution of UNICEF including the UAE’s, to develop and validate the national strategy for child protection (NSPC) in order to establish Child Protection Structures (CPS) from community to policy levels at all geographic levels. At present, 6 CPS were established and are being made operational with UNICEF support in Nouakchott (the capital). This includes: (i) a inters-sectoral National Council for Childhood which is being revitalized at policy level under the Prime Minister's authority and the joint technical leadership of MASEF, the Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Justice; Guirlene Frederic Page 10 (ii) a central child protection table bringing together provincial basic public services, international and national child protection NGOs under the highest authority of the province, the Wali and the technical support of the provincial coordination of MASEF; 4 community child protection systems (CCPS) that were respectively established in 4 out of 9 municipalities of Nouakchott, under the authority of the mayor and accompanied in its operation by the provincial coordination of MASEF. These CCPS bring together the basic municipal services, representatives of municipal NGOs and community based organizations (CBOs) networks, key-religious and community leaders. (iii) In this context, we think this CP process will be an excellent opportunity to sensitize the key CP stakeholders at all levels of responsibility on concepts and tools of social norm/social theories in the prospect to build national consensus and a common agenda to change stakeholders behaviors and practices in favour of child rights fulfillment and child well being. We will particularly stress on the following actions: Brief the forum of international partners supporting the process of building CP systems and the high decision-making authorities on the key concepts and tools of social norm/social theories and their usefulness to address more effectively complex social issues based on unsuitable behaviors and to reach excluded populations; Collect information about family, community and even about the entire society behaviours regarding children with a special focus to the expectations related to child abuse, exploitation, discrimination and exclusion in order to develop positive arguments to change these expectations at all levels; Intensively advocate and provide support for law enforcement with a specific focus on setting-up mechanisms that take into account family and community expectations to ensure better implementation/respect of laws related to children rights as well as awareness of the entire population about these laws; Advocate at all levels for collective responsibility and moral obligation vis-à-vis children well-being and specifically at policy level on the need for adequate budget and inter-sectoral cooperation to ensure integrated and comprehensive programs for the most vulnerable; Use social networks concepts and tools, at provincial and community levels to identify the most trustful groups and individuals, including religious leaders, to be incorporated into the child protections structures in place to reinforce their credibility and efficiency; Use the community led/generated change approach to ensure comprehensive package of interventions for the most vulnerable children including empowering education in particular for the most vulnerable families, organized diffusion of information by the community members themselves on child rights and child protection and community based deliberation and pledge to protect the most vulnerable children; At all levels, minimize use of incentives and find innovative manners to do it when it is necessary in order to stimulate self-commitment and self determination to protect vulnerable children. IX. Constraints and challenges Serious budgetary constraint at national level in particular to support the national NGOs efforts to complete the package of interventions related to the Community-led development initiatives; Need for some practical guidelines or manual and technical assistance to help us relay on a soundly manner the key concepts and tools learned on social norms/social change; The Mauritanian Government very long process of decision making and its tendency to centralize which could slow all along the progress of actions; Guirlene Frederic Page 11 Lack of capacity of MASEF in particular at provincial levels to ensure consistent implementation and continuous monitoring of interventions; Lack of involvement of some authorities in the provinces; Resistance of the Imams in some regions to join the movement to promote the voluntary abandonment of FGM/C. Guirlene Frederic Page 12