Fifth Round PROJECT MONITORING, REPORTING, REVISION AND EXTENSION GUIDELINES For all reporting templates, please visit the UNDEF website: http://www.un.org/democracyfund/Grantees/grantees_R5.html This document outlines monitoring, reporting, extension and revision guidelines for UNDEFfunded 5th round projects. Reports submitted to UNDEF are considered to be part of the public domain (unless otherwise agreed) and as such may be shared with UNDEF’s Programme Consultative Group, Advisory Board, or may be posted on the UNDEF’s website. UNDEF will also use the reports submitted during the lifespan of the project to determine whether projects are making sufficient progress and to recommend adjustments to scope, implementation and funding as needed. All reports must be drafted in English or French, the two working languages of the UN Secretariat. 1. Project Management Arrangement UNDEF-funded projects fall into two categories: 1) CSO-Implemented projects without Executing Agency (CSOP) These are projects where the Civil Society Organization (CSO) is receiving the grant, is responsible for the overall management of the project and does not have an Executing Agency. The CSO under this arrangement bears all substantive, financial, monitoring and reporting responsibilities to UNDEF. 2) CSO-Implemented projects with Executing Agency (CSOP + EA) These are projects where the CSO partners with a UN Executing Agency. The CSO bears the responsibility to implement the project with oversight of the EA. Under this arrangement, the CSO or other applicant will bear substantive responsibility for achieving results in the project. The Executing Agency as responsible for the oversight of the project will bear all financial, monitoring, reporting and evaluation responsibilities to UNDEF. Note: Please refer to the signed cover page of the project document if you are unsure about which category pertains to your organization. 2. Project Monitoring UNDEF projects are monitored in several ways: A. All Implementing Agencies for all projects must monitor their own activities. The Implementing Agency (IA) (and the Executing Agency as relevant) should use the indicators set in the Result Based Framework of the Project Document (PD) to monitor the project throughout its duration. If the IA is required to collect additional baseline date, they are required to do so as soon as possible. Furthermore, the data for the indicators will be used in the final evaluation of the project. January 2012 1 Fifth Round B. For CSOP projects, UNDEF will appoint monitors to observe project milestones as detailed in the project document. C. For CSOP + EA projects, the Executing Agency is responsible for project monitoring and for reporting to UNDEF. D. In addition to the above, for all projects, UNDEF will monitor progress by way of review of midterm and progress reports and will conduct ad-hoc monitoring visits of the project as needed. 3. Project Reporting All projects (CSOP and CSOP + EA) are required to submit the following i) Mid-Term/Annual Report, ii) Final Narrative Report and iii) Financial Utilization Reports. For CSOP projects the Implementing Agency must submit the reports to UNDEF. For CSOP + EA projects the Executing Agency must submit the reports to UNDEF in consultation with the Implementing Agency. See Annex I for reporting timelines. Additionally, UNDEF may request ad hoc updates at any time throughout the duration of the project. 4. Monitoring and Reporting Requirements for CSOP Projects The following monitoring and reporting requirements apply to CSOP projects only. For information about reporting requirements for CSOP + EA projects please refer to section 5 of this document. Templates for financial and narrative reporting can be found on the UNDEF website. Reports that do not use the correct template will not be accepted. 4.1 Milestone Reports and Financial Utilization Reports A. UNDEF will appoint an observer to monitor project milestones 2 and 3. This person or entity will bear no responsibility for any aspect of implementation of the project. In order to arrange for monitoring of project milestones as detailed in the disbursement schedule in the project document, the Implementing Agency must provide UNDEF with the logistical details of the milestone activity two months prior to its occurrence. Logistical details include dates, location, contact names, agenda and any accompanying materials. UNDEF will designate a monitor to attend the activity. The UNDEF-appointed monitor will contact the Implementing Agency directly to make final arrangements. The monitor will attend the activity, will take notes and photos, and will collect materials. The Implementing Agency should provide the monitor with necessary documents, such as the event agenda, signed list of participants, publications, brochures etc. The monitor will then compile the details from the monitoring activity and will submit to UNDEF a “Milestone Verification Report” (MVR). In some cases, UNDEF may decide to conduct a desk review of the milestone activity in lieu of sending monitors. In these cases, the Implementing Agency will be required to submit an MVR, photos of the activity and any additional accompanying materials. B. When the milestone activity has been completed, the Implementing Agency should submit to UNDEF a Milestone Financial Utilization Report (FUR), certified by the independent and external auditor indicated in the project document. These financial reports should be in the required UNDEF format and reflect the amount spent to date. The purpose of the FURs is to compare January 2012 2 Fifth Round project expenditures against the project budget as agreed to in the signed project document. Please note that most of the previous tranche [e.g.:70%] must be spent before the next tranche is disbursed. Projects are required to attach a short explanation in cases where there has been a change in the funding schedule or budget allocation. UNDEF will review the FUR and will either approve the funding request or will revert to the project for further information or discussion. Any significant financial reallocation compared to the approved project budget requires prior UNDEF approval. Financial reallocations made without prior UNDEF’s approval will not be accepted, the implementing agency will be held responsible for over expenditures. *** The milestone activities chosen for the project as per the signed project document should correspond to when a new tranche of funds is needed. Therefore, the Implementing Agency is responsible for informing UNDEF as soon as possible of any changes in the milestone schedule, which in turn affects the disbursement of funds. *** 4.2 Mid-term Progress Report The Mid-term Progress Report must be submitted to UNDEF no later than 13 months from the project start date (as listed on the cover page of the signed project document). The report should include detailed information on the status of project implementation, including: the activities that have been completed and those in progress, an update on funds utilized, and the achievement of project outputs, outcomes and any unforeseen changes in the project as compared with the signed project document. The report should also justify any changes made to the implementation of the project as compared with the signed project document. UNDEF will use this report to determine whether the project is making sufficient progress and to gauge whether any adjustments in scope, activities or funding are warranted. The Mid-term Progress Report template is available on the UNDEF website. 4.3 Final Narrative Report The Implementing Agency is required to submit a Final Narrative Report one month after the completion of the project. The report must include detailed information on project implementation, describing the achievement of outputs and outcomes as agreed in the signed project document. The report should also justify any changes made to the implementation of the project as compared with the signed project document and should outline lessons learned and best practices. The Final Narrative Report template is available on the UNDEF website. 4.4 Final Financial Utilization Report A Final Financial Utilization Report, certified by the independent and external auditor identified in the project document, must be submitted no later than three months after the project end-date. This report must include all relevant financial details including expenditures and any income or interest earned. The Final Financial Utilization Report template is available on the UNDEF website. January 2012 3 Fifth Round 4.5 End of Project Evaluation UNDEF will inform the Implementing Agency if a project evaluation is to be conducted. Where evaluations are required, for CSOP projects, UNDEF will either directly commission a project evaluation or will request the Implementing Agency to organize an independent evaluation using the funds retained by UNDEF for this purpose. The Implementing Agency is required to take all necessary measures to facilitate evaluation as and when required by UNDEF or a third party on its behalf. The final evaluation report may be published on the UNDEF website. The Implementing Agency is required to feature UNDEF as a donor in all outreach materials including banners, signs, all written materials and publications associated with the UNDEF-funded project, as well as on the Implementing Agency’s website and publication resulting from the implementation of the UNDEF project. All presentation will include the UNDEF logo. Any acknowledgment should include the words ''The United Nations Democracy Fund'' 5. Monitoring and Reporting Requirements for CSOP +EA Projects Reports that do not use the correct template will not be accepted. Templates for financial and narrative reporting can be found on the UNDEF website. 5.1 Mid-term Progress Report The Mid-term Progress Report must be submitted to UNDEF no later than 13 months from the project start date (as listed on the cover page of the signed project document) OR when requesting the second disbursement of funds, whichever comes first. The report should include detailed information on the status of project implementation, including the activities that have been completed and those in progress, an update on funds utilized, and the achievement of project outputs, outcomes and any unforeseen changes in the project as compared with the signed project document. The report should also justify any changes made to the implementation of the project as compared with the signed project document. UNDEF will use this report to determine whether the project is making sufficient progress and to gauge whether any adjustments in scope, activities or funding are warranted. The Mid-term Progress Report template is available on the UNDEF website. . In the event that the second disbursement of funds is not needed until well after the submission of the Mid-term Report, the EA must submit a brief project status report to UNDEF. This report will provide an update on the status of implementation as well as on the current level of funding left after the first disbursement. No specific template is required for the status report. UNDEF may request additional information as needed. January 2012 4 Fifth Round 5.2 Final Narrative Report The Final Narrative Report should be submitted three months after the completion of the project. The report must include detailed information on project implementation, describing the achievement of outputs and outcomes as agreed in the signed project document. The report should also justify any changes made to the implementation of the project as compared with the signed project document and should outline lessons learned and best practices. The report should also justify any changes and should outline the lessons learned and best practices. The Final Narrative Report template is available on the UNDEF website. 5.3 Financial Reports In accordance with the requirements of UN Secretariat Accounts Division, all UN-Executed projects must submit the following: Annual Interim Financial Statement: to be submitted by 31st January of each project year, showing cumulative income and expenditure to date. The statement must be signed by the designated authorized representative at the UN Agency or Country Office (CO). Annual Certified Financial Statement: to be submitted by 31st May of each project year, showing cumulative income and expenditure to date. The statement must be signed by the UN Agency’s authorized representative at HQ. Final Interim Financial Statement: to be submitted three months after the project end date, or 27 months after the approved project start date. The statement should be signed by the designated authorized representative at the UN Agency or Country Office (CO). Final Certified Financial Statement: to be submitted no later than 30th June of the year following the financial closing of the project. The statement must be signed by the UN Agency’s authorized financial representative (e.g. Controller) at HQ. With the exception of the Final Certified Financial statement, all above mentioned reports must specify the unliquidated obligations (ULOs) (i.e. funds committed but yet not expended). All reports must report interest earned on the project funds. Any significant financial reallocation compared to the approved project budget requires prior UNDEF approval. Financial reallocations made prior UNDEF’s approval will not be accepted, the executive agency will be held responsible for any over expenditures. For more details, see section 6 below. January 2012 5 Fifth Round 5.4 Evaluation Report The Executing Agency is responsible for conducting an evaluation at the end of the project. The cost of the evaluation is covered by the Executing Agency fee. This evaluation should be carried out by an independent and external entity. Specific evaluation arrangements may have been documented in the respective project documents and in this case those arrangements should apply. UNDEF will also liaise with the EA, as necessary, to determine the best course for conducting evaluations. The final evaluation report may be published on the UNDEF website. 6. Project Revisions and Extensions 6.1 - Project Revisions A. Revisions that require prior approval from UNDEF: Changes to a project that affect its scope (outputs, outcomes and objectives), require a project substantive revision (see 6.2) approved by the UNDEF Office. Any significant financial reallocation compared to the approved project budget requires prior UNDEF approval. The request should be made using the Budget Revision Request Form which is available on the website. These changes should also be mentioned both in the mid-term and final narrative reports sent to UNDEF. Any financial reallocation where UNDEF prior agreement was not sought may be refused and the funds may have to be reimbursed to UNDEF. B. Revisions that do not require prior approval from UNDEF Changes to a project that do not affect the scope of the project do not require a project revision approved by the UNDEF Office. For example, changes in activities to ensure achievement of an output do not require a project revision. While no specific approval procedure is required, these changes should be mentioned both in the mid-term and final narrative reports sent to UNDEF. 6. 2 Substantive revisions Conditions A substantive revision involves a change either in the objective, outcomes or outputs of the project. Providing that the project remains relevant to the objectives of UNDEF and consistent with the project proposal, revisions can be made at any point during the project lifecycle under one of the following three circumstances: A) in response to changes in the national, regional or global context, B) to adjust the design and resource allocation to ensure the project operates effectively in a changing environment and/or January 2012 6 Fifth Round C) to improve project design and/or implementation by clarifying objectives, adjusting results, indicators, assumptions and/or conditions, and adding or curtailing activities. Procedure Substantive project revisions result from a participatory process involving the key stakeholders. They may be prompted by project team deliberations, by reports from beneficiaries or by monitoring, evaluation or review activities. Where a project is not proceeding as planned, the Implementing Agency, and where applicable the Executing Agency, should discuss with all partners ways to improve project implementation. A revision document should then be drafted and signed by all signatories to the original signed project document The revision document must describe changes made to relevant sections of the signed project document and must include: - a cover page with justification as to why the changes are wanted - a separate page which details changes in objectives, outputs, activities or inputs. by including new sections to replace old sections of the project document - a revised Results Framework and budget In case of projects implemented under the Executing Agency management arrangement (CSOP+EA), the Executing Agency will submit the project revision document to UNDEF. “Special situations”: project suspension and project revision A substantive revision may also be needed when a country faces an emergency or a “special situation.” In emergency situations, achievement of expected results may be jeopardized if ongoing activities are no longer appropriate. In such cases, projects may need to suspend ongoing project activities. In the case of a suspension in project implementation, the suspension needs to be explained formally to UNDEF including detailed information on the circumstances leading to the suspension of the project activities. Also, during the suspension, regular updates on the possibility for the project to restart should be sent to UNDEF. Once it becomes likely that the project will resume its implementation activities, UNDEF should be notified in writing of the upcoming resumption and it should be indicated whether a Project Revision or a Project Extension will be requested. 6.3 - Extension of Project Duration UNDEF prefers projects to be implemented in accordance with the timetable in the project document and will only consider "no cost" extensions only in exceptional circumstances. In such cases, project extensions should be sought using the Project Extension Request Form which is available on the website. Such extensions do not entail changes in the overall budget. Please note January 2012 7 Fifth Round that salary and support costs should not exceed the amounts allocated in the approved project budget. Extensions will be considered for the shortest justifiable timeframe, and in no circumstances will they exceed 12 months. Procedure In normal circumstances, project extensions need to be requested by the Implementing Agency (or Executing Agency where applicable) after consultation with all project partners, at least two months before the initially foreseen project termination date. The form for requesting a project extension is available on the UNDEF website. In addition to the extension request form, an updated Results Framework should be enclosed clearly highlighting the activities already completed at the time of the request and the ones that will be implemented during the project extension. Depending on the duration of the extension, the reporting requirements to UNDEF might be affected and these new requirements will be notified upon approval of the extension request. For extensions of longer than 4 months, an extension status report should be provided to UNDEF half way through the extension period. This report should provide an update on the status of project implementation and disbursement of funds during the extension period, as per the revised Results Framework. This report should not exceed 3 pages. No specific template is required. January 2012 8 Fifth Round UNDEF REPORTING TIMETABLE These reporting requirements apply for projects under the following management arrangements: - CSO-Implemented projects without Executing Agency (CSOP) (TABLE 1) - CSO-Implemented projects with UN Executing Agency (CSOP + EA) (TABLE 2) Where applicable, templates for the reports mentioned below are available in the 5th Round section of the UNDEF website. All reports should be sent to the relevant UNDEF project officer, with a copy to democracyfund@un.org. In addition, all UN financial reports (CSOP+EA) should also be copied to trustfund@un.org indicating the type of report and the project number in the heading. TABLE 1 – CSOP Projects Report Title Prepared By Submitted By/To Deadline Milestone Verification Report UNDEF-appointed monitor By UNDEF-appointed monitor to UNDEF Following attendance of milestone activity Milestone Financial Utilization Report (FUR) CSO and certified by the designated external auditor By CSO to UNDEF Completion of each Milestone (#2 and #3) Mid-term Progress Report CSO By CSO to UNDEF 13 months after PSD (1) Final Narrative Report CSO By CSO to UNDEF 1 month after project end or 25 months after PSD (1) Final Financial Utilization Report (FFUR) CSO and certified by the designated external auditor By CSO to UNDEF 3 months after project end or 27 months after PSD (1) Evaluation Report Independent entity, or as decided by UNDEF in consultation with CSO By Independent entity to UNDEF, or as decided by UNDEF in consultation with CSO After submission of Final Narrative Report Extension Status Report CSO By CSO to UNDEF Halfway through extension period, for extensions longer than 4 months (if applicable) (1)The Project Start Date (PSD) is set by UNDEF according to the date of disbursement of 1 st tranche of funds to the CSO or the UN Agency and is indicated on the cover page of the finalized Project Document. January 2012 9 Fifth Round TABLE 2 – CSOP + EA Projects (2) Report Title Prepared By Submitted By/To Deadline Mid-term Progress Report UN Agency/CO in consultation with CSO By UN Agency/CO to UNDEF 13 months after PSD (1) OR when requesting the 2nd disbursement, whichever is first Annual Interim Financial Statement UN Agency/CO and certified by authorized UN Agency representative By UN Agency/CO to UNDEF By 31st January of each project year Annual Certified Financial Statement UN Agency/HQ and certified by authorized UN Agency representative at HQ By UN Agency/HQ to UNDEF By 31st May of each project year Final Narrative Report UN Agency/CO in consultation with CSO By UN Agency/CO to UNDEF 3 months after project end or 27 months after PSD (1) Final Interim Financial Statement UN Agency/CO and certified by authorized UN Agency representative By UN Agency/CO to UNDEF 3 months after project end or 27 months after PSD (1) Evaluation Report Independent Entity By UN Agency/CO to UNDEF 3 months after project end or 27 months after PSD (1) Final Certified Financial Statement UN Agency/HQ and certified by authorized UN Agency representative at HQ By UN Agency/HQ to UNDEF No later than 30th June of the year following the financial closing of the project UNDEF Evaluation Report UNDEF in consultation with UN Agency/CO and CSO By Evaluator to UNDEF After submission of Evaluation Report UN Agency/CO in consultation with CSO By UN Agency/CO to UNDEF Halfway through extension period, for extensions longer than 4 months (if applicable) Extension Status Report (if applicable) (1) The Project Start Date (PSD) is set by UNDEF according to the date of disbursement of 1st tranche of funds to the CSO or the Executing Agency and is indicated on the cover page of the finalized Project Document. (2) Additional requirements may apply for some UN executed projects and should be contained in an agreement signed between UNDEF and the UN agency/CO. For instance, UNDP executed projects will also refer to the agreement signed between UNDP and UNDEF January 2012 10