Longwood University Guidance & Counseling Assessment Plan Longwood Educational Program: Guidance & Counseling Program Coordinator email Address: howefj@longwood.edu SPA Name: Virginia DOE Standards Date SPA Assessment Plan Submitted: 10/19/06 Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Program Coordinator: Frank Howe Program Coordinator Office Phone: 434-395-2338 SPA Website: http://www.pen.k12.va.us/VDOE/Compliance/TeacherED/nulicvr.pdf Date Plan Approved by AIR: Page 1 Frank Howe 6/28/2016 Chart 1: Alignment between Program Assessments and State Guidance and Counseling Standards Assessments VIRGINIA DEPARTMENT OF ECUCATION STANDARDS GUIDANCE & COUNSELING 1. The ability to support students by cooperatively working with parents/guardians and teachers. 2. Understanding of the principles and theories of human growth and development throughout the lifespan and their implications for school guidance and counseling. 3. Understanding of the social and cultural foundations of education and their implications for school guidance and counseling. 4. Understanding of lifespan career development. 5. Understanding of the skills and processes for counseling students to include: a. Individual and group counseling for academic development; b. Individual and group counseling for career development; and c. Individual and group counseling for personal/social development 6. Understanding of the knowledge, skills, and processes for providing developmental group guidance, including: a. Academic development; b. Career development; and 1 Community Resources Project EDUC 601 2 Parent Interview Project EDUC 613 X X Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling 3 Counseling Theory Paper EDUC 505 4 Life Span Paper EDUC 521 X X 5 SPED Services Provider Interview EDUC 613 6 Career Development Paper EDUC 610 7 G&C Program Plan EDUC 637 8 Counseling Role Play EDUC 545 X X 9 Ethical Concerns Presentation EDUC 637 10 Counseling Strategies Paper EDUC 555 X X X Page 2 Frank Howe 6/28/2016 Assessments VIRGINIA DEPARTMENT OF ECUCATION STANDARDS GUIDANCE & COUNSELING 1 Community Resources Project EDUC 601 2 Parent Interview Project EDUC 613 3 Counseling Theory Paper EDUC 505 4 Life Span Paper EDUC 521 5 SPED Services Provider Interview EDUC 613 6 Career Development Paper EDUC 610 7 G&C Program Plan EDUC 637 8 Counseling Role Play EDUC 545 9 Ethical Concerns Presentation EDUC 637 10 Counseling Strategies Paper EDUC 555 c. Personal/social development 7. Understanding of the skills and processes related to the school counseling program at the elementary, middle, and secondary levels, including: a. Characteristics of learners at the elementary, middle, and secondary levels; b. Program planning; c. Coordination; d. Consultation; and e. Staffing patterns 8. Understanding of the knowledge, skills, and processes of student appraisal and assessment relative to school guidance and counseling programs, including: a. Individual assessment; and b. Group assessment 9. Understanding of the counseling professional, including: a. Legal considerations; b. Ethical considerations; and c. Professional issues and standards 10. Understanding of the skills and processes of research and evaluation aimed at improving school guidance and counseling programs Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling X X X X Page 3 Frank Howe 6/28/2016 Chart 2: Program Assessment Descriptions and Delineation of Specific Rubric Items/Scores that Meet State Standards Assessments VIRGINIA DEPARTMENT OF ECUCATION STANDARDS GUIDANCE & COUNSELING 1. The ability to support students by cooperatively working with parents/guardians and teachers. 2. Understanding of the principles and theories of human growth and development throughout the lifespan and their implications for school guidance and counseling. 3. Understanding of the social and cultural foundations of education and their implications for school guidance and counseling. 4. Understanding of lifespan career development. 5. Understanding of the skills and processes for counseling students to include: a. Individual and group counseling for academic development; b. Individual and group counseling for career development; and c. Individual and group counseling for personal/social development 6. Understanding of the knowledge, skills, and processes for providing developmental group guidance, including: a. Academic development; b. Career development; and 1 Community Resources Project EDUC 601 2 Parent Interview Project EDUC 613 Overall Score Overall Score Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling 3 Counseling Theory Paper EDUC 505 4 Life Span Paper EDUC 521 Overall Score Overall Score 5 SPED Services Provider Interview EDUC 613 6 Career Development Paper EDUC 610 7 G&C Program Plan EDUC 637 8 Counseling Role Play EDUC 545 Section 35 Scores Overall Score 9 Ethical Concerns Presentation EDUC 637 10 Counseling Strategies Paper EDUC 555 Overall Score Overall Score Section 5 Score Page 4 Frank Howe 6/28/2016 Assessments VIRGINIA DEPARTMENT OF ECUCATION STANDARDS GUIDANCE & COUNSELING 1 Community Resources Project EDUC 601 2 Parent Interview Project EDUC 613 3 Counseling Theory Paper EDUC 505 4 Life Span Paper EDUC 521 5 SPED Services Provider Interview EDUC 613 6 Career Development Paper EDUC 610 7 G&C Program Plan EDUC 637 8 Counseling Role Play EDUC 545 9 Ethical Concerns Presentation EDUC 637 10 Counseling Strategies Paper EDUC 555 c. Personal/social development 7. Understanding of the skills and processes related to the school counseling program at the elementary, middle, and secondary levels, including: a. Characteristics of learners at the elementary, middle, and secondary levels; b. Program planning; c. Coordination; d. Consultation; and e. Staffing patterns 8. Understanding of the knowledge, skills, and processes of student appraisal and assessment relative to school guidance and counseling programs, including: a. Individual assessment; and b. Group assessment 9. Understanding of the counseling professional, including: a. Legal considerations; b. Ethical considerations; and c. Professional issues and standards 10. Understanding of the skills and processes of research and evaluation aimed at improving school guidance and counseling programs Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Section 67 Scores Overall Score Overall Score Section 8 Score Page 5 Frank Howe 6/28/2016 Chart 3: List of Assessments and Time of Administration Name of Assessment Type or Form of Assessment1 When the Assessment Is Administered2 1 Community Resources Project Project EDUC 601 2 Parent Interview Project Project EDUC 613 3 Counseling Theory Paper 4 Life Span Paper 5 SPED Services Provider Interview 6 Career Development Paper 7 G & C Program Plan 8 Counseling Role Play 9 Ethical Concerns Presentation 10 Counseling Strategies Paper Paper EDUC 505 Paper EDUC 521 Interview EDUC 613 Paper EDUC 610 Program Plan EDUC 637 Role Play EDUC 545 Presentation EDUC 637 Paper EDUC 555 1 Identify the type of assessment (e.g., essay, case study, project, comprehensive exam, reflection, state licensure test, portfolio). Indicate the point in the program when the assessment is administered (e.g., admission to the program, admission to student teaching/internship, required courses [specify course title and numbers], or completion of the program). 2 Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Page 6 Frank Howe 6/28/2016 APPENDIX: Standard Based Assessment Rubrics Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Page 7 EDUC 601 COMMUNITY RESOURCES PROJECT RUBRIC (Assessment #1) *A score of 11 is considered Acceptable. Rating Indicator Services provided to group by a selected organization Unclear as to sources of information about services Obtain a list of references relevant to group (e.g., magazines) Only one type of reference featured in list Partially Met (2) Information is provided about two characteristics of the group Clearly identified one to two input sources for determination Clearly identified one to two sources of information about services Two types of references featured in list Identify local and national resources (e.g., churches, television stations) that target group Total Score Only one type of resource featured in list Two types of resources featured in list Obtain social and demographic information about group (e.g., education rates) Determination of mental health services needs Unmet (1) Information is provided about one characteristic of the group Unclear as to input for services determination Three or more types of resources featured in list Score / 15 COMMENTS: Don Fleming, Ph.D. EDUC 601 Counseling in a Pluralistic Society Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Met (3) Information is provided about three or more characteristics of the group Clearly identified three or more input sources for determination Clearly identified three or more sources of information about services Three or more types of references featured in list Page 8 EDUC 613 PARENT INTERVIEW RUBRIC (Assessment #2) *A score of 18 is considered Acceptable. Rating Indicator Unmet (1) Describes subjects’ disability, family characteristics Is unable to clearly describe subject’s disability or family characteristics Skills needed for working with disability No evidence of probing interviewee to determine skills needed Counseling publications Does not present ways information learned affects the work of the school counselor Writing is not well organized and difficult to understand Writing organization Writing mechanics Technical requirements Paper submission Respects confidentiality of subject(s) Paper contains many (more than 5) spelling, syntax, or sentence construction errors Paper is less than 2 pages in length or is not double spaced or typed Paper is submitted more than one week late Confidential information is presented Partially Met (2) Describes family situation or subject’s characteristics but is unable to make connections between the two Some evidence of probing is evident but does not present a clear picture Presents at least 1-2 ways information learned affects the work of the school counselor Writing is organized but is difficult to follow and lacks cohesion Paper contains 3-5 spelling syntax, and sentence construction errors Paper is 2 pages in length, or is not double spaced or typed Paper is submitted no more than one week beyond deadline Some identifying information is presented Total Score Score Clearly describes family situation and how subject fits into family Evidence exists that probing interviewee occurred to determine relevant information on skills needed for working with subject in family Presents 3 or more ways the information affects the work of the school counselor Writing is well organized, logical and sequential Paper is well written. Spelling, syntax, and sentence construction are correct Paper is 3 or more pages in length, double spaced, and typed Paper is submitted by due date Identifying information is limited / 24 COMMENTS: Guidance and Counseling of Exceptional Students Educ 613 Don Fleming,Ph.D. Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Met (3) Page 9 EDUC 505 COUNSELING THEORY PAPER RUBRIC (Assessment #3) *A score of 29 is considered Acceptable. Rating Indicator Unmet (1) Introduction Little evidence of statement of topic or purpose Definition of Counseling Definition is inaccurate and difficult to understand Describes few (3 or less) aspects of view of human nature Key Concepts Counseling Role Does not define helper role and functions Therapeutic Goals and Process Is unable to describe goal and procedures for working with clients Relationship Issues No evidence of client/counselor relationship is presented Presents few (3 or less) counseling techniques Application & Counseling Techniques Evaluation of Approach Conclusion Ideas are illogical Writing Organization Writing is not well organized and difficult to understand Paper contains many (more than 5) spelling, syntax, or sentence construction errors Paper is less than 3 pages in length Writing Mechanics Technical Requirements Paper Submission Conclusions are illogical and do not fit data presented Paper not submitted within time required Partially Met (2) Statement of topic and/or purpose of paper are vaguely stated Definition is accurate yet difficult to understand Describes 4-5 aspects of view of human nature Helper role and functions are vaguely defined Describes 3 therapeutic goals and procedures for working with clients Client/counselor relationship is not clearly stated Presents 4-5 techniques that be applied with this approach Ideas are vaguely stated Conclusions contain 12 errors. Summarizations of data are weak Writing is organized but is difficult to follow and lacks cohesion Paper contains 3-5 spelling, syntax, and sentence construction errors Paper is 3 pages in length, or is not doublespaced or typed Paper submitted no more than one week beyond deadline Total Score Score Serves as a prologue and presents clear, concrete statement of topic and purpose of paper Definition is accurate and clear Clearly describes 6 aspects of view of human nature and articulates factors that account for changes in behavior Defines helper role and functions clearly Accurately describes 4 therapeutic goals and procedures for working with clients Discusses characteristics of client/counselor relationship Presents 6 techniques that might be applied with this approach Presents sound and logical ideas Draws accurate conclusions and summarizes data accurately Writing is well organized, logical and sequential Paper is well written. Spelling, syntax, and sentence construction are correct Paper is 4-5 pages in length, double-spaced, and typed Paper submitted by due date / 39 Comments: Don Fleming, PhD Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Met (3) Page 10 EDUC 505 Theories of Counseling and Psychotherapy Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Page 11 EDUC 521 LIFE SPAN PAPER RUBRIC (Assessment #4) *A score of 16 is considered Acceptable. Formerly Called: Rubric for Assessment of the Application of Knowledge Project 0 1 2 3 4 Organization Organization is unclear and missing two or more critical elements (time, location, method of data collection) Organization is unclear and missing one critical element (time, location, method of data collection) Organization is unclear or missing one critical element (time, location, method of data collection) Clear organization of the investigation (time, location, method of data collection) Data collection strategies Strategies are missing or grossly inappropriate Actual questions or rubric for observations is missing or poorly described Strategies are unclear and inappropriate Strategies are either unclear or inappropriate Strategies are clear and appropriate Actual questions or rubric for observations is described in general terms Actual questions or rubric for observations is described in some detail Data Summary No summary presented Analysis No analysis of the data in terms of the topic and class material is presented or one that contains serious or multiple errors or flaws Summary is incorrect or missing information A general analysis of the data in terms of the topic and class material contains some errors or flaws General Summary of data is presented A general analysis of the data in terms of the topic and class material is presented Actual questions or rubric for observations is clearly developed as a useable tool Clear and informative summary of data is presented A clear analysis of the data in terms of the topic and class material is presented Implications & Recommendation s A set of implications and recommendation s are not presented or a seriously in conflict with the project data or course material A set of implications and recommendation s are presented which are neither clear & cogent nor closely tied to the project and course material A set of implications and recommendation s are presented which are not clear & cogent or are not closely tied to the project and course material Assessment Tool - Interview - Observation - Questionnaire A clear and cogent set of implications and recommendation s are presented Total Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Scor e Clear organization of the investigation (time, location, method of data collection and other significant features) A clear analysis of the data in terms of the topic and class material is presented drawing specific connections and citing clear examples A clear and cogent set of implications and recommendation s are presented which are closely tied to the project and course material /21 Page 12 EDUC 613 SPECIAL EDUCATION SERVICES PROVIDER INTERVIEW ORAL PRESENTATION RUBRIC (Assessment #5) *A score of 15 is considered Acceptable. Rating Indicator Accuracy of information Implications for guidance counselors Interview Class activity Unmet (1-2) Inaccurate and incomplete information is presented Presented 1-2 ways information learned affects the work of the guidance counselor Presented 3 or less items of information learned from the interview Little involvement of class members Partially Met (3) Met (4-5) Information is accurate but not thorough Information is accurately presented and thorough Presented at least 3 ways information learned affects the work of the guidance counselor Presented 4-5 items of information gleaned from the interview Presented 4-5 ways the information affects the work of the guidance counselor Students showed interest Total Score Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Score Presented at least 6 items of information gleaned from the interview Students showed interest and participated with enthusiasm / 20 Page 13 EDUC 610 CAREER COUNSELING PROGRAM DESIGN RUBRIC (Assessment #6) *A score of 112 is considered Acceptable. Description of Target Population Needs Addressed Program Goals Program Objectives 0-5 Unclear description of target population, and or missing one or more of: demographics, developmental stage, and pertinent institutional information Missing or unclear on two or all of : description of assumptions made, specific needs assessed, and related rationale for the program Unclear or superficial description of program goals. 6 - 10 Description of target population, but missing one of: demographics, developmental stage, and pertinent institutional information 11 - 15 Clear description of target population, including demographics, developmental stage, and pertinent institutional information 16 - 20 Clear and thorough description of target population, including demographics, developmental stage, and pertinent institutional information Missing or unclear on one of : description of assumptions made, specific needs assessed, and related rationale for the program Clear description of assumptions made, specific needs assessed, and related rationale for the program Clear and thorough description of assumptions made, specific needs assessed, and related rationale for the program Description of program goals which are developmentally appropriate. Clear and thorough description of program goals which are developmentally appropriate. Description of program objectives which are loosely tied to program goals, and are not observable, Description of program objectives which are loosely tied to program goals, or are not observable, and measurable. Clear description of program objectives which are tied to program goals, observable, and measurable. Clear and thorough description of program goals which are developmentally appropriate and tied to an identified career counseling theory Clear and thorough description of program objectives which are tied to program goals, observable, and Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Page 14 Total Interventions / Activities Program Promotion Program Evaluation References Cited and measurable. Description of activities and interventions but missing two or all of: content, plan for processing, and materials needed. Description of plan for program promotion but missing two or more of: including media. materials, method, and message Description of plan for program evaluation but missing two or all of: data/feedback sought, collection tools, and proposed use of collected information 0-2 References cited are missing all of : relevant, reliable, and presented in APA format measurable. Description of activities and interventions but missing one of: content, plan for processing, and materials needed. Description of activities and interventions including content, plan for processing, and materials needed. Description of plan for program promotion but missing one of: including media. materials, method, and message Description of plan for program promotion including media. materials, method, and message Description of plan for program evaluation but missing one of: data/feedback sought, collection tools, and proposed use of collected information Description of plan for program evaluation including data/feedback sought, collection tools, and proposed use of collected information 3-5 References cited are missing two of : relevant, reliable, and presented in APA format 6-8 References cited are missing one of : relevant, reliable, and presented in APA format Clear and specific description of activities and interventions including content, plan for processing, and materials needed. Clear and specific plan for program promotion including media. materials, method, and message Clear and specific description of plan for program evaluation including data/feedback sought, collection tools, and proposed use of collected information 9 - 10 References cited are relevant, reliable, and presented in APA format / 150 Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Page 15 EDUC 637 GUIDANCE AND COUNSELING PROGRAM PLAN RUBRIC (Assessment #7) *A score of 30 is considered Acceptable. Philosophical statement of counselor's role in school (4 pts) Job Description (2 pts) Individual Counseling (6pts): (issues likely to address, criteria for selection, criteria for referral out) Small Group (6 pts): (types considered, brief description & selection guidelines for one, brief sample of materials for one group meeting) Large Group (In Class) (6 pts): (types considered, brief description & selection guidelines for one, brief sample of materials for one group meeting) Consultation with other professional &/or parents (5 pts): (types of activities, counselor's role in each activity priority of various activities) Guidance Coordinator (5 pts): (types of activities counselor's role in each activity priority of various activities) Accountability (6 pts): (outline of five year accountability study, example of one data collection tool, example of use and interpretation of data) 1 2 Philosophical statement of counselor's role in school Missing significant elements of the professional and ethical elements of the school counselor’s roles and responsibilities General presentation of the professional and ethical elements of the school counselor’s roles and responsibilities Job Description Missing significant elements or improperly describes several elements Missing all or most of the following elements: clear description of issues likely to address in individual counseling, criteria for selection, and criteria for referral out A clear and comprehensive job description Missing all or most of the following elements: clear description of the types of small groups considered, with a brief Individual Counseling Small Group Counseling 3 4 5 6 Clear and comprehensive description of issues likely to address in individual counseling, specific criteria for selection, and specific criteria for referral out Clear and comprehensive description of the types of small groups considered, Clear presentation of the professional and ethical elements of the school counselor’s roles and responsibilities Clear and thorough presentation of the professional and ethical elements of the school counselor’s roles and responsibilities Missing significant portions of the following elements: clear description of issues likely to address in individual counseling, criteria for selection, and criteria for referral out Missing one of the following elements: clear description of issues likely to address in individual counseling, criteria for selection, and criteria for referral out Clear description of issues likely to address in individual counseling, criteria for selection, and criteria for referral out Clear description of issues likely to address in individual counseling, specific criteria for selection, and specific criteria for referral out Missing significant portions of the following elements: clear description of the types of small Missing one of the following: clear description of the types of small groups considered, Clear description of the types of small groups considered, with a brief description & Clear description of the types of small groups considered, with a brief description Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Page 16 Scor e Frank Howe 6/28/2016 Large Group Guidance Consultation Guidance Coordination description & selection guidelines for one such group , and a clear outline of one session groups considered, with a brief description & selection guidelines for one such group , and a clear outline of one session with a brief description & selection guidelines for one such group , and a clear outline of one session selection guidelines for one such group , and a clear outline of one session & selection guidelines for one such group , and a clear outline of one session including sample of all materials for this group meeting with a brief description & selection guidelines for one such group , and a clear outline of one session including sample of all materials for this group meeting 1 2 3 4 5 6 Missing three of the following: description of a guidance program with description for one component, including brief sample of lesson plan and materials for one class meeting Missing two of the following: description of a guidance program with description for one component, including brief sample of lesson plan and materials for one class meeting Missing one of the following: description of a guidance program with description for one component, including brief sample of lesson plan and materials for one class meeting Description of a guidance program with description for one component, including brief sample of lesson plan and materials for one class meeting Clear description of a guidance program with clear description for one component, including brief sample of lesson plan and materials for one class meeting Clear and comprehensive description of a guidance program with clear and thorough description for one component, including brief sample of lesson plan and materials for one class meeting Missing all or most of the following elements: clear description of the types of activities, and counselor's role in each activity, and identification of the priority of each activity Missing one of the following elements: clear description of the types of activities, and counselor's role in each activity, and identification of the priority of each activity Clear description of the types of activities, and counselor's role in each activity, and identification of the priority of each activity Clear and thoughtful description of the types of activities, and counselor's role in each activity, and identification of the priority of each activity Missing all or most of the following elements: clear description of the types of activities, and counselor's role in each activity, and identification of the priority of each activity Missing one of the following elements: clear description of the types of activities, and counselor's role in each activity, and identification of the priority of each Clear description of the types of activities, and counselor's role in each activity, and identification of the priority of each activity Clear and thoughtful description of the types of activities, and counselor's role in each activity, and identification of the priority of each Clear and thoughtful description of the types of activities, and counselor's role in each activity, with specific examples and identification of the priority of each activity Clear and thoughtful description of the types of activities, and counselor's role in each activity, with specific examples Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Page 17 Scor e Frank Howe 6/28/2016 activity Accountabilit y Plan Missing all of the following elements: A outline of five year accountability study, with an example of one data collection tool, and an example of the use and interpretation of the data Missing two of the following elements: A outline of five year accountability study, with an example of one data collection tool, and an example of the use and interpretation of the data activity Missing one of the following elements: A outline of five year accountability study, with an example of one data collection tool, and an example of the use and interpretation of the data A outline of five year accountability study, with an example of one data collection tool, and an example of the use and interpretation of the data and identification of the priority of each activity A clear outline of five year accountability study, with an example of one data collection tool, and an example of the use and interpretation of the data A clear, comprehensive outline of five year accountability study, with an example of one data collection tool, and clear example of the use and interpretation of the data / Total 40 Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Page 18 Frank Howe 6/28/2016 EDUC 545 ROLE PLAY RUBRIC (Assessment #8) *A score of 11 is considered Acceptable. Rating Indicator Attention to cognitive content issues in role play Not Met (0) No attempt is made to address cognitive content issues Partially Met (1) An attempt is made to address cognitive content issues Significantly Met (2) Efforts to address cognitive content issues feature implementation of a variety of strategies Attention to affective content issues in role play No attempt is made to address affective content issues An attempt is made to address affective content issues in role play Efforts to address affective content issues feature implementation of a variety of strategies Attention to nonverbal communication in role play No Acknowledgement Use of a variety of acknowledgement of nonverbal strategies to of nonverbal communications encourage client to communications explore significant nonverbal communications Use of counseling skills in role play One technique is used almost exclusively Attempt is made to implement a variety of counseling techniques Varied counseling techniques are consistently executed in a high quality manner Attention to focus in the role play No attempt is made to develop a focus Attempt is made to develop a focus Attempt is made to refine focus Total Score Score / 15 COMMENTS: Don Fleming, Ph.D. EDUC 545 Techniques of Counseling and Psychotherapy Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Fully Met (3) Efforts to address cognitive content issues feature implementation of a variety of strategies with appropriate timing of their use Efforts to address affective content issues feature implantation of a variety of strategies with appropriate timing Use of a variety of strategies to assist client in integrating nonverbal communications with verbalizations to establish a focus Varied counseling techniques are consistently executed in a high quality manner with appropriate timing of their use Attempt is made to refine and deepen focus Page 19 EDUC 637 ETHICAL CONCERNS PRESENTATION RUBRIC (Assessment #9) *A score of 11 is considered Acceptable. Each student will make an in-class presentation on a significant ethical concern related to the practice of school guidance and counseling. The presentation will cover the following points: Clear explanation of the problem situation - 5 pts Professional Ethical Concerns related to the situation - 5 pts Decision making process applied to this concern - 5 pts Explanation of the problem situation 0 Missing all or most of the following: clear explanation of the problem situation with relevant information on all involved Professional Ethical Concerns related to the situation Missing all or most of the following: clear explanation of the relevant ethical concerns with general information on the relevant code of ethics citations Decision making process applied to this concern Missing all or most of the following: leads a discussion on the decision 1 Missing significant portions of the following: clear explanation of the problem situation with relevant information on all involved Missing significant portions of the following: clear explanation of the relevant ethical concerns with general information on the relevant code of ethics citations Missing significant portions of the following: leads a discussion on the Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling 2 Missing one of the following elements: clear explanation of the problem situation with relevant information on all involved 3 Clear explanation of the problem situation with relevant information on all involved 4 Clear and thorough explanation of the problem situation with relevant information on all involved 5 Clear and thorough explanation of the problem situation with specific information on the roles and expectations of all involved Missing one of the following elements: clear explanation of the relevant ethical concerns with general information on the relevant code of ethics citations Clear explanation of the relevant ethical concerns with general information on the relevant code of ethics citations Clear and thorough explanation of the relevant ethical concerns with general information on the relevant code of ethics citations Clear and thorough explanation of the relevant ethical concerns with specific information on the relevant code of ethics citations Missing one of the following elements: leads a discussion on the decision Leads a discussion on the decision making process and ties it to the Leads a clear and thoughtful discussion on the decision making process Leads a clear and thoughtful discussion on the decision making process and Page 20 Score making process and ties it to the ethical concerns cited decision making process and ties it to the ethical concerns cited making process and ties it to the ethical concerns cited ethical concerns cited and ties it to the ethical concerns cited clearly ties it to the ethical concerns cited Total / 15 Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Page 21 EDUC 555 COUNSELING STRATEGIES PAPER RUBRIC (Assessment #10) IN DEVELOPMENT Longwood State Assessment Plan – Guidance & Counseling Page 22