Matakuliah Tahun : V0282 - Manajemen Akuntansi Hotel : 2009 - 2010 Revenue Management for Hotels Chapter 8 Chapter Outline • • • Establishing Room Rates Revenue Management Non-Room Revenue Learning Outcomes • • • Utilize alternative methods when establishing a hotel’s room rate structure. Apply revenue management and analysis techniques to the administration of a hotel’s room rate structure. Recognize the importance to a hotel of properly managing and controlling its non-room revenue. Establishing Room Rates • • • Any serious exploration of hotel room rates and their management must include basic information about room rate economics. Room rate economics recognizes that, when the supply of hotel rooms is held constant, an increase in demand for those rooms will result in an increase in their selling price. Conversely, when supply is held constant, a decrease in demand leads to a decreased selling price. Establishing Room Rates • • • Understanding the law of demand is critical because, unlike managers in other industries, hoteliers cannot increase their inventory levels of rooms (supply) in response to increases in demand. Hotel managers must also understand that their own inventory of rooms is highly perishable. If a hotel does not sell room 101 on Monday night, it will never again be able to sell that room on that night, and the potential revenue that would be generated from the sale is lost forever. Establishing Room Rates • • • • A rack rate is the price at which a hotel sells its rooms when no discounts of any kind are offered to the guests. In some cases, it makes sense for hoteliers to create special event rates. Sometimes referred to as “super” or “premium” rack, these rates are used when a hotel is assured of very high demand levels (e.g., Mardi Gras in New Orleans and New Year’s Eve in New York City). Hotels often negotiate special rates for selected guests. In most cases, these negotiated rates will vary by room type. In addition to rack and negotiated rates, hotels typically offer corporate rates, government rates, and group rates. Establishing Room Rates • • • Some hotels have great success “packaging” the guest rooms they sell with other hotel services or local area attractions. When a hotel creates a package, the package rate charged must be sufficient to ensure that all costs associated with the package have been considered. In addition, the use of one or more authorized fade rates, a reduced rate authorized for use when a guest seeking a reservation is hesitant to make the reservation because the price is perceived as too high, can result in even more room rates to be managed. Establishing Room Rates • • • A hotel’s revenue managers can also create discounts at various percentage or dollar levels for each rate type we have examined. The result is that a hotel, with multiple room types and multiple rate plans, may have literally hundreds of rates types programmed into its property management system. A property management system (PMS) is a computer system used to manage guest bookings, online reservations, check-in/check-out, and guest purchases of amenities offered by the hotel. The Hubbart Room Rate Formula • • • • • The Hubbart formula is used to determine what a hotel’s average daily rate (ADR) should be to reach the hotel owner’s financial goals. The Hubbart formula is a “bottom-up” approach as shown in Figure 8.2. To illustrate the Hubbart formula, the Blue Lagoon Water Park Resort’s Income Statement is shown in Figure 8.3. For a detailed analysis of the Hubbart formula, see Go Figure! following Figure 8.3. For a summary of the Hubbart formula calculations for the Blue Lagoon Water Park Resort, see Figure 8.4. Figure 8.2 Comparison of Normal and Bottom-Up Formats Normal Format for the Income Statement Bottom-Up Format for the Hubbart Formula Operated Department Income (Rooms) Net Income + Operated Departments Income (Excluding Rooms) + Taxes - Undistributed Operating Expenses + Nonoperating Expenses - Nonoperating Expenses + Undistributed Operating Expenses - Taxes - = Net Income = Operated Department Income (Rooms) Operated Departments Income (Excluding Rooms) Figure 8.3 Income Statement Blue Lagoon Water Park Resort Income Statement For the Period: January 1 through December 31, 2010 Net Revenue Operated Departments Rooms Food Beverage Telecommunications Other Operated Departments Rentals and Other Income Total Operated Departments ? 7,200,000 3,264,000 72,000 540,000 109,800 25,201,800 Cost of Sales ? 2,138,400 451,440 169,200 79,200 15,840 2,854,080 Undistributed Operating Expenses Administrative and General Information Systems Human Resources Security Franchise Fees Transportation Marketing Property Operations and Maintenance Utility Costs Total Undistributed Operating Expenses Gross Operating Profit 25,201,800 2,854,080 Payroll and Related Expenses Other Expenses Income (Loss) ? 2,188,800 534,960 54,000 180,000 48,960 5,973,120 ? 532,800 201,600 28,800 64,800 10,800 2,077,200 ? 2,340,000 2,076,000 -180,000 216,000 34,200 14,297,400 921,600 144,000 525,600 199,440 0 50,400 771,840 435,600 244,800 57,600 77,760 0 284,400 780,480 1,357,200 388,800 583,200 277,200 0 334,800 1,552,320 291,600 0 905,400 1,071,000 1,197,000 1,071,000 2,904,480 3,857,040 6,761,520 8,877,600 5,934,240 7,535,880 Rent, Property Taxes, and Insurance Depreciation and Amortization 1,760,400 1,260,000 Net Operating Income 4,515,480 Interest 1,272,000 Income Before Income Taxes 3,243,480 Income Taxes 1,297,390 Net Income 1,946,090 go figure! The steps required to compute the Hubbart formula in this example are: 1. Calculate the hotel’s target before-tax net income. Multiply the required rate of return (ROI) of the owner’s investment, and then adjust the answer for before-tax net income. Assume an investor considers paying $16,217,417 for the 240 room hotel at the Blue Lagoon and desires a 12% return on the investment. $16,217,417 x 0.12 = $1,946,090 ROI (hotel’s target net income) Calculate before-tax net income. Divide the after-tax net income (owner’s ROI) by 1.00 minus the tax rate. After-Tax Net Income (ROI) 1.00 – Tax Rate = Before-Tax Net Income or, assuming a tax rate of 40% $1,946,090 1.00 – 0.40 = $3,243,483.30 ~ $3,243,480 (rounded down) In order to be consistent with the Income Before Taxes number in Figure 8.3, we will round the before-tax net income down to $3,243,480. Normally, you wouldn’t round this number down (the IRS would not like that!), but in order for the Blue Lagoon statements to work nicely for the entire book, the rounded down number works better. (go figure! continued) 2. Calculate estimated nonoperating expenses. Calculate estimates of nonoperating expenses including rent, property taxes and insurance plus depreciation and amortization plus interest expense. In this example, the total nonoperating expenses are as follows: Rent, Property Taxes, and Insurance Depreciation and Amortization Interest Expense Total Nonoperating Expenses 1,760,400 1,260,000 1,272,000 $4,292,400 3. Calculate estimated undistributed operating expenses. Calculate estimates of undistributed operating expenses including administrative and general, information systems, human resources, security, franchise fees, transportation, marketing, property operations and maintenance, and utility costs. In this example, the total undistributed operating expenses are as follows: Administrative and General Information Systems Human Resources Security Franchise Fees Transportation Marketing Property Operations and Maintenance Utility Costs Total Undistributed Operating Expenses 1,357,200 388,800 583,200 277,200 0 334,800 1,552,320 1,197,000 1,071,000 $6,761,520 (go figure! continued) 4. Calculate estimated operated departments income excluding rooms. Calculate estimates of revenues minus expenses to determine estimated income for all non-rooms departments. These include income from food, beverage, telecommunications, other operated departments, and rentals and other income. In this example, estimated operating departments income excluding rooms is as follows: Food Beverage Telecommunications Other Operated Departments Rentals and Other Income Total Operated Departments Income Excluding Rooms 2,340,000 2,076,000 -180,000 216,000 34,200 $4,486,200 5. Calculate the operated department income for rooms. Using the results from steps 2 through 4: add the owner's desired ROI (adjusted for before-tax net income), add total nonoperating expenses, add total undistributed operating expenses, subtract total operated departments income excluding rooms (see Figure 8.2). In this example, estimated operated department income for rooms is as follows: Before-Tax Net Income Total Nonoperating Expenses Total Undistributed Operating Expenses Total Operated Departments Income Excluding Rooms Operated Department Income for Rooms $3,243,480 + 4,292,400 + 6,761,520 - 4,486,200 $9,811,200 (go figure! continued) 6. Calculate the estimated rooms department revenues based on estimated occupancy. Add estimated operated department income for rooms (from step 5) to estimated rooms expenses based on estimated occupancy to determine estimated rooms department revenues. From historical data, the rooms manager has calculated that payroll and related expenses and other expenses for rooms is $60 per room. Also, the manager has determined that the hotel has an average occupancy % of 80%, and the hotel has 240 rooms (see Chapter 1). Calculate the estimated number of rooms to be sold in the year: 240 rooms x 365 days in a year x 0.80 occupancy = 70,080 rooms Calculate the estimated rooms expenses based on $60 per room: 70,080 rooms x $60 = $4,204,800 Calculate the estimated rooms department revenues: Operated Department Income for Rooms Estimated Rooms Expenses Estimated Rooms Department Revenues 9,811,200 + 4,204,800 $14,016,000 (go figure! continued) 7. Calculate the hotel’s required ADR. Divide the estimated rooms department revenues (from step 6) by the estimated number of rooms to be sold (from step 6): Estimated Rooms Department Revenues Estimated Number of Rooms to be Sold = Hotel’s Required ADR or $14,016,000 70,080 = $200 Thus, the ADR that should be charged for the Blue Lagoon’s rooms in order to achieve the owner’s desired net income (ROI) is $200. Figure 8.4 Summary of Hubbart Formula Calculations for the Blue Lagoon Steps 1-5: Bottom-Up Format for the Hubbart Formula Calculations Before-Tax Net Income $ 3,243,480 + Nonoperating Expenses + 4,292,400 + Undistributed Operating Expenses + 6,761,520 - Operated Departments Income (Excluding Rooms) - 4,486,200 = Operated Department Income (Rooms) $9,811,200 Step 6: 240 rooms x 365 days in a year x 0.80 occupancy = 70,080 rooms 70,080 rooms x $60 expense per room = $4,204,800 estimated rooms expenses Operated Department Income for Rooms Estimated Rooms Expenses Estimated Rooms Department Revenues 9,811,200 + 4,204,800 $14,016,000 Step 7: $14,016,000 70,080 = $200 The Hubbart Room Rate Formula • • • The Hubbart formula is useful because it requires managerial accountants and hoteliers to consider the hotel owner's realistic investment goals and the costs of operating the hotel before determining the room rate. The formula has been criticized for relying on assumptions about the reasonableness of an owner’s desired ROI and the need to know expenses that are affected by the quality of the hotel’s management. Another criticism is that the formula requires the room rate to compensate for operating losses incurred by other areas (such as from telecommunications). The Hubbart Room Rate Formula • Despite its limitations, the Hubbart formula remains an important way to view the necessity of developing a room rate that: – – – – Provides an adequate return to the hotel’s owner(s) Recovers the hotel’s non-operating expenses Considers the hotel’s undistributed operating expenses Accounts for all the hotel’s non-room operated departments income (or loss) – Results in a definite and justifiable overall ADR goal The $1.00 per $1,000 Rule • • • One alternative way that hoteliers have historically determined room rate is the $1.00 per $1,000 rule. This rule states that, for every $1,000 invested in a hotel, the property should charge $1.00 in ADR. The dollar-per-thousand rule is most accurate for hotels that have high occupancies, high ADRs for their area of operation, and are newly built. The $1.00 per $1,000 Rule • • • Despite some limitations, the $1.00 per $1,000 rule does reflect the tendency for hotel buyers to discuss hotel selling prices in terms of a hotel’s cost per key (average cost per room), which is the average purchase price of a hotel’s guestroom expressed in thousands of dollars. It is important to recognize that the rate computed using the $1.00 per $1,000 rule does not become the hotel’s rack rate. Instead, it is the overall ADR that the hotel must achieve when its sells all of its various rooms at all of their respective rates. Alternative Room Rate Methodologies • Non-traditional, non-cost methods to establish rates: – Competitive Pricing. Charge what the competition charges. – Follow the Leader Pricing. Charge what the dominant hotel in the area charges. – Prestige Pricing. Charge the highest rate in the area and justify it with better product and/or service levels. – Discount Pricing. Reduce rates below that of the likely competitors. Web-Influenced Room Rate Methodologies • • • Today’s hotel room rate structures have been changed, and changed forever, by the advent of the Internet as the most popular method used for selling hotel rooms. As a result of the Internet, consumers can easily compare prices, but so can a hotel’s major competitors. While the call-around was standard practice as late as the early 2000s, consider modern hoteliers utilizing one of the many websites similar to http://www.Travelaxe.com and others that allow him/her to easily see other hotels’ rates. Web-Influenced Room Rate Methodologies • • • • • Guests care very little how much it “costs” a hotel to provide its rooms. They care about the lodging value they receive. As a result, a hotel’s rates are heavily influenced by the laws of supply and demand. A guest can make a hotel reservation at a given rate, and, every day until the date of arrival, can go online to shop for an even lower price for the same room. If a lower rate were to be found, the guest could recontact the hotel, cancel the original reservation, and secure the new, lower rate. Revenue Management • • • Revenue management, also called yield management, is a set of techniques and procedures that use hotel specific data to manipulate occupancy, ADR, or both for the purpose of maximizing the revenue yield achieved by a hotel. Yield is a term used to describe the percentage of total potential revenue that is actually realized. Revenue managers are responsible for making decisions regarding the pricing and selling of guest rooms in order to maximize yield. go figure! For example, consider a property that has the potential of generating $50,000 with a fully booked hotel, but only generates revenues of $30,000 on a given Saturday. The hotel’s yield would be calculated as follows: Total Realized Revenue Total Potential Revenue = Yield or $30,000 $50,000 = 60% Revenue Management • • • • RevPAR is a combination of ADR and occupancy %. To increase yield simply means to increase the hotel’s RevPAR. Therefore, any change (decrease or increase) in either or both of the factors comprising RevPAR will change the yield of the hotel’s revenue. RevPAR is calculated using the following formula: ADR x Occupancy % = RevPAR Revenue Management • • Revenue management techniques are used during periods of low, as well as high, demand. Although the actual revenue management techniques used by hoteliers vary by property, in their simplest form, all these techniques are employed to: – – – – Forecast demand Eliminate discounts in high demand periods Increase discounts during low demand periods Implement “Special Event” rates during periods of extremely heavy demand Revenue Management • Using information gleaned from the hotel’s historical sales data, revenue management features in a property management system (PMS) can: – Recommend room rates that will optimize the number of rooms sold – Recommend room rates that will optimize sales revenue – Recommend special room restrictions that serve to optimize the total revenue generated by the hotel during a specific time period – Identify special high consumer demand dates that deserve special management attention to pricing Revenue Management • • • • In the hotel industry, a competitive set (comp set) consists of those hotels with whom a specific hotel competes and to which it compares its own operating performance. To fully evaluate RevPAR changes, hoteliers look to the relative performance of their comp set. They do so to better understand the room rate economics that affected their own property during a specific time period. To better understand the shortcomings of an overemphasis on RevPAR, it is important to take a closer look at its two fundamental components, occupancy % and ADR. Occupancy Percentage • • It might seem that the occupancy percentage for a hotel would be a straightforward calculation. A room revenue statistics report generated from the Blue Lagoon Water Park Resort’s property management system produced the information needed to calculate their occupancy percentage. Figure 8.6 The Blue Lagoon’s Room Statistics for Last Night Room Revenue Total Rooms in Hotel Out-of-Order (OOO) Rooms Complimentary (Comp) Rooms Occupied On-Change Rooms* Rooms Sold $38,400 240 5 3 7 192 *On-change rooms are rooms that are vacant but not yet cleaned. go figure! From the data in this report, it is clear that the hotel’s total room revenue for the day was $38,400, however, what is less clear is exactly how Paige should compute her occupancy percentage. Should she: 1. Include only sold rooms in her computation? If so, her formula would be: Rooms Sold Total Rooms in Hotel = Occupancy % or 192 240 = 80.0% 2. Include complimentary rooms as well as sold rooms in her computation? If so, her formula would be: Rooms Sold + Comp Rooms Occupied Total Rooms in Hotel = Occupancy % or 192 + 3 240 = 81.3% (go figure! continued) 3. Subtract non-sellable out-of-order rooms from her rooms available count? If so, her formula would be: Rooms Sold Total Rooms in Hotel – OOO Rooms = Occupancy % or 192 240 – 5 = 81.7% 4. Subtract non-sellable on change rooms from her rooms available count? If so, her formula would be: Rooms Sold Total Rooms in Hotel – On-Change Rooms or 192 240 – 7 = 82.4% = Occupancy % ADR • • Average daily rate (ADR) is also a critical component of RevPAR. Generally, hotel managers calculate ADR using rooms sold or rooms occupied. While both of these ADR formulas are commonly used, neither of these may accurately reflect ADR since they reveal different rates. go figure! To understand why, again consider the case of Paige Vincent. Utilizing her data in Figure 8.6 and the “rooms sold” approach to ADR computation, her ADR for the night would be: Total Rooms Revenue Total Number of Rooms Sold = ADR or $38,400 192 = $200.00 Utilizing the data in Figure 8.6 and the “rooms occupied” approach to ADR computation, which includes adds comp rooms to sold rooms, her ADR for the night would be: Total Rooms Revenue Total Number of Rooms Occupied or $38,400 192 + 3 = $196.92 = ADR Net ADR Yield • • • Despite the slight differences in these two ADR computations, neither is as useful to the hotel’s owners and managers as the computation of the net ADR yield. Net ADR Yield is the percentage of ADR actually received by a hotel after subtracting the cost of fees and assessments associated with the room’s sale. Today, most hotel guests already have a room reservation prior to arrival, and the reservation distribution channels (sources of reservations) used to make their reservations will charge the hotel widely varying fees for making them. Net ADR Yield • When a guest makes a reservation via the Internet, no less than three reservation-generation fees are typically charged to the hotel, including fees from: – Internet Travel Sites - websites for booking travel to end-users – Global Distribution System (GDS) - system that books and sells rooms for multiple companies – Central Reservation System (CRS) – system used by companies to centrally book reservations Net ADR Yield • • • With increased usage of high priced distribution channels, a room’s selling price (quoted) and the ADR the hotel actually receives can be radically different. Clearly, it is the ADR after the cost of reservation generation fees that should be most important to hoteliers and their attempts to increase RevPAR. If net ADR yield is not used, hotel owners and managers run the risk of significantly over inflated RevPARs accompanied by significantly reduced profits as well. go figure! Consider again, the case of the Blue Lagoon. Assuming that a guest paid $200 for a room night and total reservation fees of $80 were charged to the hotel. The net ADR yield for the room night is as follows: Room Rate - Reservation Generation Fees Room Rate Paid or $200 - $80 $200 = 60% = Net ADR Yield Flow-Through • • • Flow-through is a measure of the ability of a hotel to convert increased revenue dollars to increased gross operating profit dollars. Consider the simplified income statements detailing revenue and expenses for January 2010 and for the same month of the prior year for the Blue Lagoon Water Park Resort (see Figure 8.8). Gross operating profit (GOP) is, in effect, total hotel revenue less those expenses that are considered directly controllable by management. Figure 8.8 Vertical Income Statements Blue Lagoon Water Park Resort Vertical Income Statements For the Months Ended January 31, 2009 and 2010 Last Year (2009) % This Year (2010) % 1,105,000 847,850 1,952,850 56.6% 43.4% 100.0% 1,200,000 900,150 2,100,150 57.1% 42.9% 100.0% 335,890 537,034 872,924 17.2% 27.5% 44.7% 353,100 558,300 911,400 16.8% 26.6% 43.4% 1,079,926 55.3% 1,188,750 56.6% Total Undistributed Operating Expenses 559,986 28.7% 560,760 26.7% Gross Operating Profit 519,940 26.6% 627,990 29.9% Rent, Property Taxes, and Insurance Depreciation and Amortization 146,700 105,000 7.5% 5.4% 146,700 105,000 7.0% 5.0% Net Operating Income 268,240 13.7% 376,290 17.9% Interest 106,000 5.4% 106,000 5.0% Income Before Income Taxes 162,240 8.3% 270,290 12.9% Income Taxes 64,896 3.3% 108,116 5.1% Net Income 97,344 5.0% 162,174 7.7% Revenue Rooms Non Rooms Total Revenue Operated Department Expenses Rooms Non Rooms Total Operated Department Expenses Total Operated Department Income go figure! From Figure 8.8, the Blue Lagoon’s flow-through for January 2010 is calculated as the change in gross operating profit (GOP) from the prior year divided by the change in total revenues from the prior year as follows: GOP This Year- GOP Last Year Total Revenues This Year – Total Revenues Last Year or $627,990 – $519,940 $2,100,150 – $1,952,850 = 73.4% = Flow-Through Flow-Through • • • Flow-through was created by managerial accountants to measure the ability of a hotel to convert increases in revenue directly to increases in GOP. When flow-through is high (over 50%), it reflects efficiency on the part of management in converting additional revenues into additional profits. For most hotels, flow-throughs that are less than 50% indicate inefficiency in converting additional revenues into additional profits. GOPPAR • • • Gross operating profit per available room (GOPPAR) is defined as a hotel’s total revenue minus its management’s controllable expenses per available room. For example, the costs of a hotel’s lawn care services, utility bills, and even food and beverage expenses are considered when computing GOPPAR. These same expenses are not, of course, considered when computing RevPAR. go figure! Using the Blue Lagoon Water Park Resort January 2010 income statement in Figure 8.8, total rooms available to be sold are 7,440 (240 rooms x 31 days = 7,440) and GOP-PAR is calculated as follows: Gross Operating Profit Total Rooms Available to Be Sold or $627,990 7,440 = $84.41 = GOPPAR GOPPAR • • • RevPAR indicates the performance of a hotel in terms of rooms inventory sales and marketing, however, it provides no indication of how much money the hotel actually is, or should be, making. GOPPAR takes into consideration the cost containment and management control of the hotel and must be considered in any effective rooms pricing strategy. The difficulty is not that RevPAR is a poor measurement, but rather it is the fact that RevPAR should not be the only measurement of a hotel’s revenue manager’s effectiveness. Non-Room Revenue • • • Non-room revenue is important to the managers of both limited service and full-service hotels. It is common for limited service hotels to generate 520% of their total revenue from non-room sources. In full-service hotels, the non-rooms revenue generated may range from 20-50% of total revenue. Not every hotel will create revenues in every non-room revenue area. Non-Room Revenue • Non-room revenue on a hotel’s income statement is attributed to one of the following categories: – Food – Health Center – Beverage – Swimming Pool – Telecommunications – Tennis – Garage and Parking – Tennis Pro Shop – Golf Course – Other Operated Departments – Golf Pro Shop – Rentals and Other Income – Guest Laundry Food and Beverage Revenue • • • Food and beverage revenues typically make up the largest portion of a hotel’s non-room revenue. In a properly managed hotel food and beverage (F&B) department, the department head wants to financially support the hotel through sales. However, this may be more complicated than it first appears. Food and Beverage Revenue • • • For example, in many hotels, complementary breakfast is served to all overnight guests. The food and beverage department may be reimbursed for the “cost” of providing breakfast, but the actual “sales” value of the breakfast, including a profit, would not likely be transferred. Another example is a holiday weekend package plan that includes one night’s stay, dinner, and breakfast sold to guests for one price. Food and Beverage Revenue • • • Food service is often viewed as an amenity to attract guests and to provide food and beverage alternatives to increase the hotel’s revenues. The role of the F&B department is, appropriately, secondary to that of those departments that sell and service guest rooms. Experienced managerial accountants understand this and resist the temptation to aggressively and expensively seek to market the F&B operation to nonhotel guests living in the local area. Food and Beverage Revenue • Food and beverage in a hotel may include revenue and expense detail one or more of the following categories: – – – – – – – – – Room Service Banquets Breakfast Lunch Dinner Meeting room rental Meeting room set-up and décor Audio and Visual (A/V) equipment rental Service Charges Telecommunications Revenue • • • • In the not so distant past, in-room telephone toll charges contributed a significant amount of money to a hotel’s annual revenue. Today, however, the advent of cell telephones, and the reputation for excessive charges that has plagued hotels have lead to significant declines in this revenue source. Many hotel brands have had to reduce or even eliminate their local telephone charges. As a result, for most hoteliers, focus on the telephone department has shifted from a “pricing” concern to a “cost” accounting and management concern. Other Operated Departments Revenue • • • • • Pay-per-view movies Pay-per-play in-room games In-room safes Internet access charges Miscellaneous other income Review of Learning Outcomes • • • Utilize alternative methods when establishing a hotel’s room rate structure. Apply revenue management and analysis techniques to the administration of a hotel’s room rate structure. Recognize the importance to a hotel of properly managing and controlling its non-room revenue.