Research Training Programme Thesis Writing Getting into the habit of writing AIMS OF THE COURSE To start you thinking about the key elements of writing preparation, audience, drafting and editing. The course will also open up avenues for further support within the University. By the end of the course you will have: considered different writing styles and approaches reviewed your writing technique and looked to develop new techniques addressed how to keep writing and editing techniques separate developed knowledge of the range of writing development opportunities available to you at the University and elsewhere The Graduate School is a section within the University’s Research Innovation Services department. © The University of Nottingham Graduate School, June 16 1 Getting into the habit of writing THE SIMILARITIES AND DIFFERENCES BETWEEN SPOKEN AND WRITTEN COMMUNICATION In groups of 4 generate a list of similarities and differences between these two communication channels. List the all the things your group discusses here: SIMILARITIES 2 DIFFERENCES © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing WHAT WILL YOU BE WRITING DURING YOUR RESEARCH? In this exercise, you are going to identify your motivations and goals in writing during your time as a research student. Make a list of all the goals and motivations you can think of, relevant to writing during your research and (where appropriate) the different audiences. Think about why you are writing. What do you hope to gain from it? What will you be writing during your time as a research student? © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 What do you hope to gain from this writing? 3 Getting into the habit of writing HOW DO YOU WRITE? Use the space below to record how you approach a writing task such as producing an essay, a paper or your first year report. Which aspects or stages do you enjoy? Where do you have difficulty? One way of categorising approaches is along a spectrum from those who tend to start by producing text - ‘free-writers’ - to those who start by generating a plan or structure. Where would you place yourself on this spectrum? 4 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing FREEWRITING EXERCISE Freewriting is a technique developed by Peter Elbow1 in response to his own inability to write during the course of his PhD.2 The essential idea behind freewriting is that we must separate the writing and editing processes. Thus, freewriting is writing at full speed without the time to read or change what has just appeared on the paper. To be successful in developing you as a writer the technique should be used regularly; Elbow suggests every day over a three- to six-month period. Try this system for yourself: Use the prompt “Why am I interested in this research topic?” or “What excites / interests me most in my research area?” Write in complete sentences, not bullet points. However, don’t worry about grammar, spelling, punctuation, structure or even making sense. Write non-stop for five minutes. As you become comfortable with the technique you could increase this to ten minutes. The key is that you do NOT re-read what you have just written: you can do that after you finish. Why does Elbow think freewriting will help? Essentially, he believes that thinking of words and worrying whether they are the right (or best) ones are two complex tasks that compete with each if we let them. Freewriting breaks this link. Elbow studied many undergraduates and postgraduates learning to write in the academic context: students who used the technique over a prolonged period of time were able to write more (in the five minutes available) at the end of the programme and the quality of the pieces produced also increased. The following quotation sums up Elbow’s views: The most effective way I know to improve your writing is to do freewriting exercises regularly… It isn’t just therapeutic garbage. It is a way to produce bits of text that are better than usual: less random, more coherent, more highly organised. Professor of English and Director of the Writing Program, University of Massachusetts, Amherst (retired). 2 In fact Peter had to have two attempts at getting his PhD due to his problems with writing and it was this which led to his career-long interest in researching the writing process. 1 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 5 Getting into the habit of writing His views are endorsed by others in the field of teaching writing: Boice recommends a daily regime to be more productive. (Professors as Writers: A Self-Help Guide to Productive Writing. Stillwater, OK: New Forums) Emig suggests that writing is a mode of thinking and learning; i.e. we understand an idea by writing it. (Have you ever tried to explain something you thought you knew to someone and realised there is something in the explanation that you aren’t sure about?) (College Composition and Communication, 28: 122-8) Murray recommends that a writer needs a range of tools and strategies to remain productive. (Thesis Writing and Writing for Publication. Videos produced for the University of Glasgow) Torrance et al. recommends text generation strategies rather than learning about the technical aspects of writing or developing cognitive strategies to write. (British Journal of Educational Psychology, 63: 170-84) Stephen King, (the prolific horror novelist) says: ‘To be a successful writer I know of only two methods; read a lot and write a lot’. To learn more about the technique, try the following references: Murray, 2002, pp. 80-94 Elbow, 1973, 1981 6 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing Free writing exercise © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 7 Getting into the habit of writing Freewriting exercise, continued… 8 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing Freewriting exercise, continued… © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 9 Getting into the habit of writing Freewriting exercise, continued… 10 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing REVIEWING AND EDITING Elbow emphasises that reviewing and editing your work are separate processes from writing. Free writing is a technique which helps you to separate these stages. Take the piece of free-writing you produced earlier and working in pairs, read your partner’s passage (or your own, if you prefer) out loud. Then: Note down the key ideas you identified in your partner’s passage generate three questions about that writing that you would like to know more about Who can help you with reviewing and editing your work? Different people may be appropriate for different objectives, e.g. for grammar, structure, content, coherence, expression / style: © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 11 Getting into the habit of writing MINDMAPS – A TECHNIQUE FOR GATHERING AND ORGANISING IDEAS If you are finding it difficult to get your ideas down on paper… If you are having problems ‘unpacking’ your ideas, getting them down on paper, sorting out an appropriate order or grouping of ideas, findings, etc., then using the ‘mind map’ approach may help in structuring your writing. Mindmaps are an approach developed by Tony Buzan. Writing takes a linear structure, which means it seems logical to begin to write by developing a plan in the form of a list of points that will be covered. However, Buzan observed that our thoughts and ideas do not flow in that way. Often, our brain works in nonlinear ways - our thoughts can seem random and one idea can trigger a seemingly tangential connection. Mindmapping is a technique that takes account of this. A mindmap is a visual representation of how ideas interrelate. Start with the main idea in the centre of a blank page turned sideways. Use an image for the central idea if possible. From that idea add in other ideas radiating out from the central idea on curved lines, with one idea per line. It does not matter what order the thoughts occur in, the mind map allows one to connect them to related ideas, or to start a new branch, if needs be. Add in colour, pictures, dotted lines, arrows etc. to denote links between words. You can develop an approach that works best for you. Normally, when using mindmaps you would continue to add in ideas to each of the main branches until you were satisfied that you had exhausted your thoughts and the ideas in your mind on the topic. A strength of the technique is that you can always return to your mind map and add more as you read or think further. An example of a mind-map is reproduced on the next page. Advantages of this technique: the main idea is clearly identified the relative importance of each point is denoted by its proximity to the centre links between points are readily apparent recall and review are more rapid and effective with this method new information can easily be added it aids creativity in that new links and connections can be made more readily and it is easier to view the “whole picture” 12 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing The idea of mind-mapping follows on from Tony Buzan’s work (Use Your Head, BBC Books), Mind map example (technology) Discuss the factors of importance in the recycling of finite resources Produce Fuel Save Fuel Reduce No enforcement of recycling Cost of Disposal Prevent Pollution in Disposal Legal Save Money Economics EEC., encourage Government Action Increase Costs U.K. Recycling of Finite Resources Transport, sorting Facts + Figures - Example of Present Position potential Copper, Paper, etc. Encourage through sponsorship of Technology Improve prospects of recycling Source of map: Preparing for Living With Technology. Open University Press. 1988 p.40) © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 13 Getting into the habit of writing Use this page to start constructing a mind map for the next substantial piece of writing you think you’ll have to do. Develop the mind map as fully as possible for at least two of the main branches; the two you feel you know most about. 14 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing Write for 10 minutes on the two branches of your mind map that have been most fully developed: © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 15 Getting into the habit of writing Writing exercise continued… 16 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing Writing exercise continued… © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 17 Getting into the habit of writing Software for mind-mapping You can also develop a mind-map by using Mindmanager software available on the University network. You can find this on the NAL, by clicking on ‘start’ on your networked machine, then ‘run’. Select ‘nal’ (Novell Applications Launcher), open the folder ‘Software installation’ then click on ‘Mindmanager 6 Pro Install’. (There is also ‘Mindmanager 6 Pro Tutorial, at the same location, if you wish to follow that through.) 18 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing BULLET POINTS – ANOTHER TECHNIQUE FOR ORGANISING AND STRUCTURING IDEAS At the structurers end of the freewriting-structuring spectrum, one tool that is often used is constructing lists of priorities and bullet points. We are now going to try this approach. Think of something you have read recently and found interesting or useful. List everything you think is important about that piece of writing in the form of bullet points (this could include possible headings and subheadings). Then reorder each list so that the items are in a logical sequence or in order of importance with the most important item first. © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 19 Getting into the habit of writing Write from the prioritised bullet point list for ten minutes (see Appendix 1 on connecting words you might use in linking your ideas): 20 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing Continued.. © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 21 Getting into the habit of writing GETTING INTO THE WRITING HABIT Try setting aside five minutes for the next three days to practice free-writing. Generate three prompts to stimulate you to write: Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4: write 3 more prompts (based on your current work or the writing you’ve done in Days 1-3) 22 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing PERSONAL ACTION PLAN List three key things you have learnt about writing skills: 1. ________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________ 2. ________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________ 3. ________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________ Identify aspects of your writing you want to work on and how you will start on this: 1. ________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________ 2. ________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________ 3. ________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________ © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 23 Getting into the habit of writing Appendix 1 (from Academic Support Service) Connecting Words Words that connect ideas together fall into four main groups: the and relationship, which shows that additional information is given that is likely to add to your argument, or which give further illustration of your point; the but relationship, which shows that you wish to present information that will contrast with or contradict your previous point; the so relationship, which gives the idea of outcome or result… this is the case, so that must follow; and words that give a sense of time, words which mark each point in a series of points, or indicate that you are about to summarise or conclude. The following sheets give words and phrases that are frequently used to express these connections. Their use is sometimes subtle. Practice looking out for them in your reading and becoming aware of any slight differences in their meaning. 24 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing And Conjunctive adverbs: these join two clauses together after a semi-colon and must be followed by a comma. Example: There were many problems with the design of the rocket; moreover, Words to use within sentences changes in the crew also affected the launch. Some conjunctive adverbs can also begin sentences. In addition Also Furthermore That is Alternatively (note: not necessarily contrasting, but another point to consider) Besides Likewise Not only… but also Similarly In the same way Moreover © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 25 Getting into the habit of writing But Conjunctive adverbs: these join two clauses together after a semi-colon and must be followed by a comma. Example: There were many problems with the design of the rocket; however, the changes in the crew were more important regarding the crash. Words to use within sentences Some conjunctive adverbs can also begin sentences. Despite this Rather However Yet Nevertheless Instead On the other hand At the same time On the contrary In any case In either case 26 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing So Conjunctive adverbs: these join two clauses together after a semi-colon and must be followed by a comma. Example: There were many problems with the design of the rocket; moreover, Words to use within sentences changes in the crew also affected the launch. Some conjunctive adverbs can also begin sentences. Therefore Hence Consequently Because of this For this reason That being so On account of this Otherwise In consequence Arising out of this To this end In that case In such a case Under the circumstances With reference to this In other respects © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 27 Getting into the habit of writing Time Conjunctive adverbs: these join two clauses together after a semi-colon (or colon in a list) and must be followed by a comma. Example: Several factors affected the launch: firstly, there were problems with the design of the rocket; secondly, the crew were not prepared; and finally, the stormy weather affected the launch site. Some conjunctive adverbs can also begin sentences. First… then… next… finally Firstly… secondly… thirdly… finally At first… in the end After a time Previously On another occasion Up to now Meanwhile Hitherto To sum up Now In summary At this point Briefly After that In conclusion From now on 28 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing Conjunctive Adverbs These can fall in the middle of sentences, but they can also join together two closely related clauses with a semi-colon beforehand and a comma after them also anyway consequently finally furthermore hence however incidentally indeed instead likewise meanwhile moreover nevertheless next nonetheless otherwise still then therefore thus Subordinating Conjunctions (To subordinate implies that something is of less importance than something else or that something depends on something else.) If a subordinating conjunction falls in mid-sentence, there is usually no comma used. If it starts a sentence, there is a comma after this introductory phrase. Correct example: After eating dinner in front of the television all week, I decided to change locations. (The word "after" is a subordinating conjunction. Here it begins a sentence, leading to an introductory phrase. Notice that the comma falls right before the subject and verb.) Compare: I decided to change locations after eating dinner in front of the television all week. © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 29 Getting into the habit of writing (Notice that there is no comma before the "after" in the second example. Because it falls in mid-sentence, there is no introductory phrase which would require a comma.) 30 © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 Getting into the habit of writing after although as as [far/soon] as as if as though because before even if even though how if inasmuch as in case [that] in order that insofar as in that no matter how now that once provided [that] since so that supposing [that] than that though till unless until when, whenever where, wherever whether while why © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 31 Getting into the habit of writing Co-ordinating Conjunctions These are of EQUAL importance. Put a comma before a coordinating conjunction only if it joins two independent clauses (i.e., if there is a subject and a verb on either side of the conjunction). If a subject or a verb is lacking on either side of the conjunction, there is no comma. Correct example: I ate dinner in front of the television every night, and I finally got tired of it. Compare: I ate dinner in front of the television every night and finally got tired of it. (This sentence lacks a subject after the "and," so there is no comma. and yet or So but for nor Transitional Phrases These usually appear at the start of a sentence and are followed by a comma. You can also use transitional phrases between paragraphs to create a logical flow in your writing. after all as a result at any rate at the same time by the way even so for example in addition in fact in other words in the second place on the contrary on the other hand Getting into the habit of writing BOOK LIST Buzan, T 2003 (revised edition) Use your head London BBC Cutts, M. 1995 The Plain English Guide Oxford University Press Day, R. 1995ed How to Write and Publish a Scientific Paper Cambridge University Press Dunleavy, P. 2003 Authoring a PhD: How to Plan, Draft, Write and Finish a Doctoral Thesis or Dissertation Palgrave Macmillan Elbow, P. 1973 Writing Without Teachers Oxford University Press Elbow, P. 1981 Writing with Power Oxford University Press Murray, R. 2002 How to Write a Thesis Open University Press Murry, R. 2005 Writing for Academic Journals Open University Press Phillips, E.M. & Pugh, D.S. 2005, 4th Edition How to Get a PhD Open University Press Turabian, K.L. 1982 British Edition A Manual for Writers of Term Papers, Theses and Dissertations University of Chicago Press. Turk, C. & Kirkman, J. 1989 Effective Writing: Improving Scientific, Technical and Business Communication Chapman and Hall © The University of Nottingham Graduate School (June 16) Version 1.0 33