Course Year : S0825/Foundation Engineering : 2009 PILE FOUNDATION Session 17 – 26 PILE FOUNDATIONS SESSION 17 – 20 Topic: • Types of pile foundation • Point bearing capacity of single pile • Friction bearing capacity of single pile • Allowable bearing capacity of single pile Bina Nusantara INTRODUCTION Bina Nusantara TYPES OF PILE FOUNDATION STEEL PILE Bina Nusantara TYPES OF PILE FOUNDATION CONCRETE PILE Bina Nusantara TYPES OF PILE FOUNDATION CONCRETE PILE Bina Nusantara TYPES OF PILE FOUNDATION Bina Nusantara TYPES OF PILE FOUNDATION WOODEN PILE Bina Nusantara TYPES OF PILE FOUNDATION COMPOSITE PILE COMBINATION OF: - STEEL AND CONCRETE - WOODEN AND CONCRETE - ETC Bina Nusantara PILE CATEGORIES Classification of pile with respect to load transmission and functional behaviour: 1. END BEARING PILES These piles transfer their load on to a firm stratum located at a considerable depth below the base of the structure and they derive most of their carrying capacity from the penetration resistance of the soil at the toe of the pile 2. FRICTION PILES Carrying capacity is derived mainly from the adhesion or friction of the soil in contact with the shaft of the pile 3. COMPACTION PILES These piles transmit most of their load to the soil through skin friction. This process of driving such piles close to each other in groups greatly reduces the porosity and compressibility of the soil within and around the groups. Bina Nusantara PILE CATEGORIES END BEARING PILE Bina Nusantara PILE CATEGORIES FRICTION PILE Bina Nusantara PILE CATEGORIES Classification of pile with respect to effect on the soil - Driven Pile Driven piles are considered to be displacement piles. In the process of driving the pile into the ground, soil is moved radially as the pile shaft enters the ground. There may also be a component of movement of the soil in the vertical direction. Bina Nusantara PILE CATEGORIES Classification of pile with respect to effect on the soil - Bored Pile Bored piles(Replacement piles) are generally considered to be non-displacement piles a void is formed by boring or excavation before piles is produced. There are three non-displacement methods: bored cast- in - place piles, particularly pre-formed piles and grout or concrete intruded piles. Bina Nusantara PILE CATEGORIES Bina Nusantara DETERMINATION OF PILE LENGTH Bina Nusantara BEARING CAPACITY OF PILE Two components of pile bearing capacity: 1. Point bearing capacity (QP) 2. Friction bearing capacity (QS) QU QP QS Bina Nusantara BEARING CAPACITY OF PILE Bina Nusantara POINT BEARING CAPACITY For Shallow Foundation - TERZAGHI SQUARE FOUNDATION qu = 1,3.c.Nc + q.Nq + 0,4..B.N CIRCULAR FOUNDATION qu = 1,3.c.Nc + q.Nq + 0,3..B.N - GENERAL EQUATION qu c.Nc.Fcs.Fcd.Fci q.Nq.Fqs.Fqd.Fqi 0,5..B.N.Fs.Fd.Fi Deep Foundation qu = qP = c.Nc* + q.Nq* + .D.N* Where D is pile diameter, the 3rd term of equation is neglected due to its small contribution qu = qP = c.Nc* + q’.Nq* ; QP = Ap .qp = Ap (c.Nc* + q’.Nq*) Nc* & Nq* : bearing capacity factor by Meyerhof, Vesic and Janbu Bina Nusantara Ap : section area of pile POINT BEARING CAPACITY MEYERHOF PILE FOUNDATION AT UNIFORM SAND LAYER (c = 0) QP = Ap .qP = Ap.q’.Nq* Ap.ql ql = 50 . Nq* . tan (kN/m2) Base on the value of N-SPT : qP = 40NL/D 400N (kN/m2) Where: N = the average value of N-SPT near the pile point (about 10D above and 4D below the pile point) Bina Nusantara POINT BEARING CAPACITY MEYERHOF Bina Nusantara POINT BEARING CAPACITY MEYERHOF PILE FOUNDATION AT MULTIPLE SAND LAYER (c = 0) QP = Ap .qP qP ql l q q L l d ll 10 D b ql d Where: ql(l) : point bearing at loose sand layer (use loose sand parameter) ql(d) : point bearing at dense sand layer (use dense sand parameter) Lb = depth of penetration pile on dense sand layer ql(l) = ql(d) = 50 . Nq* . tan (kN/m2) Bina Nusantara POINT BEARING CAPACITY MEYERHOF PILE FOUNDATION AT SATURATED CLAY LAYER (c 0) QP = Ap (c.Nc* + q’.Nq*) For saturated clay ( = 0), from the curve we get: Nq* = 0.0 Nc* = 9.0 and QP = 9 . cu . Ap Bina Nusantara POINT BEARING CAPACITY VESIC • BASE ON THEORY OF VOID/SPACE EXPANSION • PARAMETER DESIGN IS EFFECTIVE CONDITION QP = Ap .qP = Ap (c.Nc* + o’.N*) Where: o’ = effective stress of soil at pile point 1 2Ko q' 3 o' Ko = soil lateral coefficient at rest = 1 – sin Nc*, N* = bearing capacity factors Nc* Nq * 1 cot Bina Nusantara N * 3 Nq * 1 2 K o POINT BEARING CAPACITY VESIC According to Vesic’s theory N* = f (Irr) where Irr = Reduced rigidity index for the soil I rr Ir 1 Ir Ir = Rigidity index Ir Es Gs 21 s c q ' tan c q ' tan Es = Modulus of elasticity of soil s = Poisson’s ratio of soil Gs = Shear modulus of soil = Average volumetric strain in the plastic zone below the pile point Bina Nusantara POINT BEARING CAPACITY VESIC For condition of no volume change (dense sand or saturated clay): = 0 Ir = Irr For undrained conditon, = 0 Nc* 4 ln I rr 1 1 3 2 The value of Ir could be estimated from laboratory tests i.e.: consolidation and triaxial Initial estimation for several type of soil as follow: Type of soil Sand 70 – 150 Silt and clay (drained) 50 – 100 Clay (undrained) Bina Nusantara Ir 100 – 200 POINT BEARING CAPACITY JANBU QP = Ap (c.Nc* + q’.Nq*) Nq* tan 1 tan Nc* Nq * 1 cot Bina Nusantara 2 .e 2 2 ' tan POINT BEARING CAPACITY BORED PILE QP = . Ap . Nc . Cp Where: = correction factor = 0.8 for D ≤ 1m = 0.75 for D > 1m Ap = section area of pile cp = undrained cohesion at pile point Nc = bearing capacity factor (Nc = 9) Bina Nusantara FRICTION RESISTANCE Where: Qs p.L. f p = pile perimeter L = incremental pile length over which p and f are taken constant f = unit friction resistance at any depth z Bina Nusantara FRICTION RESISTANCE SAND Qs p.L. f f K . v '. tan Where: K = effective earth coefficient = Ko = 1 – sin (bored pile) = Ko to 1.4Ko (low displacement driven pile) = Ko to 1.8Ko (high displacement driven pile) v’ = effective vertical stress at the depth under consideration = soil-pile friction angle = (0.5 – 0.8) Bina Nusantara FRICTION RESISTANCE CLAY Three of the presently accepted procedures are: 1. method This method was proposed by Vijayvergiya and Focht (1972), based on the assumption that the displacement of soil caused by pile driving results in a passive lateral pressure at any depth. 2. method (Tomlinson) Bina Nusantara 3. method FRICTION RESISTANCE CLAY - METHOD Qs p.L. f av f av v ' 2cu Where: v’= mean effective vertical stress for the entire embedment length cu = mean undrained shear strength ( = 0) VALID ONLY FOR ONE LAYER OF HOMOGEN CLAY Bina Nusantara FRICTION RESISTANCE CLAY - METHOD FOR LAYERED SOIL Bina Nusantara cu cu ,1.L1 cu , 2 .L2 ... L A1 A2 A3 ... v' L FRICTION RESISTANCE CLAY - METHOD Qs p.L. f f .cu For cu 50 kN/m2 =1 Bina Nusantara FRICTION RESISTANCE CLAY - METHOD Qs p.L. f f . v ' Where: v’= vertical effective stress = K.tanR R = drained friction angle of remolded clay K = earth pressure coefficient at rest = 1 – sin R (for normally consolidated clays) Bina Nusantara = (1 – sin R) . OCR (for overconsolidated clays) FRICTION RESISTANCE BORED PILE Qs 0.45cu p L Where: cu = mean undrained shear strength p = pile perimeter L = incremental pile length over which p is taken constant Bina Nusantara ULTIMATE AND ALLOWABLE BEARING CAPACITY DRIVEN PILE QU QP QS Qall Qall QU FS FS= 2.5 - 4 Q QP S 3 1 .5 BORED PILE Bina Nusantara QU Qall 2 .5 D < 2 m and with expanded at pile point QU Qall 2 no expanded at pile point EXAMPLE A pile with 50 cm diameter is penetrated into clay soil as shown in the following figure: NC clay 5m GWL 5m = 18 kN/m3 cu = 30 kN/m2 R = 30o OC clay (OCR = 2) 20 m Bina Nusantara = 19.6 kN/m3 cu = 100 kN/m2 R = 30o Determine: 1. End bearing of pile 2. Friction resistance by , , and methods 3. Allowable bearing capacity of pile (use FS = 4) PILE FOUNDATIONS SESSION 21 – 22 Topic: • Settlement of Piles • Laterally Loaded Piles • Pull Out Resistance of Piles • Pile Driving Formula • Negative Skin Friction Bina Nusantara SETTLEMENT OF PILES S = S1 + S2 + S3 Where: S = total pile settlement S1 = elastic settlement of pile S2 = settlement of pile caused by the load at the pile tip S3 = settlement of pile caused by the load transmitted along the pile shaft Bina Nusantara SETTLEMENT OF PILES S1 Q wp .Qws L A p .E p Where: Qwp = load carried at the pile point under working load condition Qws = load carried by frictional (skin) resistance under working load condition Ap = area of pile cross section Ep = modulus of elasticity of the pile material L = length of pile = the magnitude which depend on the nature of unit friction (skin) resistance distribution along the pile shaft. Bina Nusantara SETTLEMENT OF PILES S2 qwp .D Es 1 .I 2 s wp Where: qwp = point load per unit area at the pile point = Qwp/Ap D = width or diameter of pile Es = modulus of elasticity of soil at or below the pile point s = poisson’s ratio of soil Iwp = influence factor = r Bina Nusantara SETTLEMENT OF PILES Qws D 2 S3 1 s .I ws pL Es Where: Qws = friction resistance of pile L = embedment length of pile p = perimeter of the pile Iws = influence factor I ws Bina Nusantara L 2 0.35 D EXAMPLE The allowable working load on a prestressed concrete pile 21 m long that has been driven into sand is 502 kN. The pile data are as follow: - Diameter (D) = 356 mm - The area of cross section (Ap) = 1045 cm2 - Perimeter (p) = 1.168 m Skin resistance carries 350 kN of the allowable load, and point bearing carries the rest. Use Ep = 21 x 106 kN/m2, Es = 25,000 kN/m2, s = 0.35 and = 0.62) Bina Nusantara Determine the settlement of the pile. EXAMPLE S1 Q wp .Q ws L 152 0.6235021 0.00353m 3.35mm S2 0.104521x106 A p .Ep qwp.D Es 0.356 2 1 2s .Iwp 0.152 1 0.35 0.85 0.0155m 15.5mm 1045 25,000 Iws L 21 2 0.35 2 0.35 4.69 D 0.356 Q D 350 0.356 2 4.69 0.00084m 0.84mm S3 ws 1 2s .Iws 1 0 . 35 1.16821 25,000 pL Es Bina Nusantara S = S1 + S2 + S3 = 3.35 + 15.5 + 0.84 = 19.69 mm LATERALLY LOADED PILE Bina Nusantara LATERALLY LOADED PILE ELASTIC SOLUTION – EMBEDDED IN GRANULAR SOIL Bina Nusantara LATERALLY LOADED PILE Bina Nusantara LATERALLY LOADED PILE For L/T 5 Bina Nusantara LATERALLY LOADED PILE Bina Nusantara LATERALLY LOADED PILE Bina Nusantara LATERALLY LOADED PILE ELASTIC SOLUTION – EMBEDDED IN COHESIVE SOIL Bina Nusantara LATERALLY LOADED PILE Bina Nusantara LATERALLY LOADED PILE ULTIMATE LOAD ANALYSIS – MEYERHOF – PILES IN SAND ULTIMATE LOAD RESISTANCE (Qu(g)) Bina Nusantara LATERALLY LOADED PILE MAXIMUM MOMENT, Mmax DUE TO THE LATERAL LOAD Qu(g) For long (flexible) piles in sand Bina Nusantara MAXIMUM MOMENT, Mmax DUE TO THE LATERAL LOAD Qg LATERALLY LOADED PILE ULTIMATE LOAD ANALYSIS – MEYERHOF – PILES IN CLAY ULTIMATE LOAD RESISTANCE (Qu(g)) Bina Nusantara LATERALLY LOADED PILE MAXIMUM MOMENT, Mmax DUE TO THE LATERAL LOAD Qu(g) For long (flexible) piles Bina Nusantara MAXIMUM MOMENT, Mmax DUE TO THE LATERAL LOAD Qg PULL OUT RESISTANCE OF PILES Bina Nusantara PULL OUT RESISTANCE OF PILES Bina Nusantara PULL OUT RESISTANCE OF PILES EXAMPLE: A concrete pile 50 long is embedded in a saturated clay with cu = 850 lb/ft2. The pile is 12 in. x 12 in. in cross section. Use FS = 4 and determine the allowable pullout capacity of the pile Solution Given cu = 850 lb/ft2 40.73 kN/m2 ’ = 0.9 – 0.00625cu = 0.9 – (0.00625)(40.73) = 0.645 (50)( 4 x1)(0.645)(850) 109.7 kip 1000 T 109.7 un 27.4 kip FS 4 Tun L.p.'.c u Tun(all ) Bina Nusantara PULL OUT RESISTANCE OF PILES Bina Nusantara PULL OUT RESISTANCE OF PILES For dry soils, the equation simplifies to Tun 1 . p. .L2cr .K u . tan p. .Lcr .K u .L Lcr . tan 2 Determine the value of Ku and from figure 9.36b and 9.36c. Tun( all) Tun FS Where Tun(all) = allowable uplift capacity and FS is Factor of Safety (a value of 2 – 3 is recommended) Bina Nusantara PULL OUT RESISTANCE OF PILES EXAMPLE: a precast concrete pile with a cross section 350 mm x 350 mm is embedded in sand. The length of pile is 15 m. Assume that sand = 15.8 kN/m3, sand = 35o, and the relative density of sand = 70%. Estimate the allowable pullout capacity of the pile (FS = 4) Solution From figure 9.36, for = 35o and relative density = 70% L 14.5 ; Lcr (14.5)(0.35m) 5.08m D cr 1 ; 135 35o Ku 2 1 Tun . p. .L2cr .K u . tan p. .Lcr .K u .L Lcr . tan 2 Tun 1961 kN Bina Nusantara Tun( all) Tun 1961 490 kN FS 4 PILE DRIVING FORMULA Bina Nusantara NEGATIVE SKIN FRICTION Can occur under condition such as: - If a fill of clay soil is placed over a granular soil layer into which a pile is driven, the fill will gradually consolidate. This consolidation process will exert a downward drag force on the pile during a period of consolidation - If a fill of granular soil is placed over a layer of soft clay. It will induce the process of consolidation in the clay layer and thus exert a downward drag on the pile Bina Nusantara NEGATIVE SKIN FRICTION CLAY FILL OVER GRANULAR SOIL Bina Nusantara NEGATIVE SKIN FRICTION GRANULAR SOIL FILL OVER CLAY THE UNIT NEGATIVE SKIN FRICTION AT ANY DEPTH FROM z = 0 TO z = L1 Bina Nusantara NEGATIVE SKIN FRICTION Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES SESSION 23 – 24 Topic: • Bearing Capacity of Group Piles • Group Efficiency • Piles in Rock • Consolidation settlement of Group Piles Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES Lg = (n1 – 1)d + 2(D/2) Bg = (n2 – 1)d + 2(D/2) Where: D = pile diameter d = spacing of pile (center to center) Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES Bina Nusantara GROUP EFFICIENCY Qg ( u ) Q u Where: = group efficiency Qg(u) = ultimate load bearing capacity of the group pile Qu = ultimate load bearing capacity of each pile without the group effect Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES IN SAND 2n1 n2 2 d 4 D p.n1.n2 Qg ( u ) 2n1 n2 2 d 4 D . Qu p.n1.n2 If < 1 Qg(u) = .Qu If 1 Qg(u) = Qu Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES IN SAND Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES IN SAND Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES IN SAND Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES IN SAND Summary: 1. For driven group piles in sand with d 3D, Qu(g) may be taken to be Qu, which includes the frictional and the point bearing capacities of individual piles. 2. For bored group piles in sand at conventional spacings (d 3D), Qg(u) may be taken to be 2/3 to 3/4 times Qu (frictional and point bearing capacities of individual piles) Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES IN SATURATED CLAY Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES IN SATURATED CLAY Calculation steps: 1. Determine Qu = n1.n2 (Qp + Qs) where: QP = 9 . cu . Ap (ultimate end bearing capacity of single pile) QS = (.p.cu.L) (skin resistance of single pile) 2. Determine the ultimate capacity by assuming that the piles in the group act as a block with dimensional Lg x Bg x L as follow : - end bearing capacity of the block QP’ = Ap . qp = Ap . cu . Nc* with Ap = Lg . Bg - Skin resistance of the block QS’= (pg.cu.L) = 2.(Lg+Bg).cu.L - Ultimate bearing capacity o pile group Qu = QP’ + QS’ Qu = (Lg . Bg) . cu . Nc* + 2.(Lg+Bg).cu.L 3. Compare the values obtained in step 1 and 2 the lower of the two values is Qg(u) Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES IN SATURATED CLAY Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES IN SATURATED CLAY Problem: The section of a 3 x 4 group pile layered saturated clay. The piles are square in cross section (14 in. x 14 in.). The center to center spacing, d, of the piles is 35 in. Determine the allowable load bearing capacity of the pile group. USE FS = 4 Bina Nusantara GROUP PILES IN SATURATED CLAY Bina Nusantara PILES IN ROCK For point bearing piles resting on rock, most building codes specify that Qq(u) = Qu, provided that the minimum center to center spacing of piles is D + 300 mm. For H-Piles and piles with square cross sections, the magnitude of D is equal to the diagonal dimension of the pile cross section. Bina Nusantara CONSOLIDATION SETTLEMENT OF GROUP PILES The Terzaghi formula is valid with some rules: 1.The consolidation settlement is occurred from the depth of 2/3 of pile length. 2.The stress increase caused at the middle of each soil layer by using 2:1 method pi Bina Nusantara B Qg g zi Lg zi CONSOLIDATION SETTLEMENT OF GROUP PILES Problem: sat = 18 kN/m3 Cc = 0,3 eo = 0,82 sat = 18,9 kN/m3 Cc = 0,2 eo = 0,7 sat = 19 kN/m3 Cc = 0,25 eo = 0,75 Bina Nusantara A group pile with Lg = 3.3 m and Bg = 2.2 m as shown in the figure. Determine the consolidation settlement of the pile groups. All clays are normally consolidated. ELASTIC SETTLEMENT OF GROUP PILES • VESIC Bina Nusantara ELASTIC SETTLEMENT OF GROUP PILES • MEYERHOF (Pile groups in sand and gravel) Bina Nusantara ELASTIC SETTLEMENT OF GROUP PILES • PILE GROUP SETTLEMENT RELATED TO THE CONE PENETRATION RESISTANCE Bina Nusantara UPLIFT CAPACITY OF GROUP PILES Bina Nusantara UPLIFT CAPACITY OF GROUP PILES Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION AND LOADING TEST SESSION 25 – 26 Topic: • Installation Method of Driven Pile • Installation Method of Bored Pile • Loading Test by Static Method • Loading Test by Dynamic Method Bina Nusantara INSTALLATION METHOD Pile Installation Equipment The primary tools used in the actual driving (installing) of piles are : • • • • Impact Hammers, Vibrator Driver / Extractors Special Hydraulic Presses Supporting Equipment – power sources, hoisting & material handling equipment, etc. Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Types of Impact Hammers Impact Hammers are identified by their method of operation or the motive force employed. They are generally identified as : • Drop Hammers • Air or Steam Hammers • Diesel Hammers • Hydraulic Impact Hammers Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Drop Hammers Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Air (or Steam) Hammers Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Air (or Steam) Hammers Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Diesel Hammers Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Diesel Hammers Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Hydraulic Impact Hammers Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Hydraulic Impact Hammers Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Vibro Driver/Extractors Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Vibro Driver/Extractors Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Hydraulic Press Installer Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Hydraulic Press Installer Bina Nusantara PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Land Based Rigs Cantilever Fixed Lead Bina Nusantara (With Fixed Bottom Brace) (With Spotter) PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Land Based Rigs Under slung Swinging Lead Bina Nusantara (With Fixed Bottom Brace) (With stabbing points) PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Land Based Rigs European Style, Fixed Lead with Fixed Bottom Brace Bina Nusantara (Driving Aft Batter with Hydraulic Hammer) PILE INSTALLATION EQUIPMENTS Land Based Rigs European Style, Fixed Lead on Crawler Lower Bina Nusantara DRIVEN PILE INSTALLATION Bina Nusantara BORED PILE INSTALLATION Bina Nusantara PILE QUALITY Two aspects of final quality of pile: – Structural integrity of pile. – Pile ability to support external load, consist of strength of structure element and relationship load-settlement between pile and soil support Bina Nusantara STATIC LOADING TEST TEST METHODS – – – – – – Bina Nusantara Use Static Load The load is 200% of working load Preparation before testing Loading Measurement of pile movement Instrumentation STATIC LOADING TEST • Loading Methods – – – – Standard Method of Loading-SML, Monotonic Standard Method of Loading-SML, cyclic Quick Load Test (Quick ML) Constant Rate of Penetration Method (CRP) Bina Nusantara Sumber : Manual Pondasi Tiang, GEC Typical arrangements for axial compressive load test Anchor Pile Dead Load Bina Nusantara STATIC LOADING TEST Bina Nusantara STATIC LOADING TEST Test load arrangement using kentledge Bina Nusantara DYNAMIC LOADING TEST • PDA (Pile Driving Analyzer) • DLT (Dynamic Load Test), TNO • Theory of wave propagation Bina Nusantara Sumber : Manual Pondasi Tiang, GEC PDA computer Strain gauge and accelerometer Interpretation of PDA result Bina Nusantara PULL OUT TESTS Pullout load by using hydraulic jack between beam and reaction frame (ASTM D 3689-83, 1989) Bina Nusantara Sumber : Manual Pondasi Tiang, GEC PULL OUT TESTS Pullout load by using hydraulic jack, one at each end of the beam (ASTM D 3689-83, 1989) Bina Nusantara LATERAL LOADING TEST Bina Nusantara Sumber : Manual Pondasi Tiang, GEC LATERAL LOADING TEST Bina Nusantara PILE INTEGRITY TEST • This test is needed to check the integrity of bored pile or driven pile. • Some methods generally adopted is by using the principle of wave propagation. The test is carried out by applying vibration and evaluating its reflection. • Through this test, the defect on pile will be able to detect. Bina Nusantara Sumber : Manual Pondasi Tiang, GEC