Refugee Stories: Learning to
live in the UK
Being a Refugee. Learning and
Identity. A longitudinal study of
refugees in the UK
(Stoke on Trent, Trentham Books).
Published 2011
Linda Morrice, University of Sussex
28 June, 2016
Research aims
To capture the process of transition to living in the UK over a five year
period
- How individual biography shapes and informs the strategies
adopted by refugees
- What are the learning and identity processes at work
28 June, 2016
Advantages of life history and
longitudinal approach
• Contextualised framework for exploring refugee experience connections between past and present, here and there
• Refugee as a powerful and subsuming identity, displacing and
occluding others. Life history decentres ‘refugee’
• Temporal unfolding of events – opportunities and set backs
• Witness the contingent nature of the self. The ‘subject in process’ or
‘provisionality of identity work’ (Plumridge and Thomas (2003)
28 June, 2016
Methodological issues with longitudinal
research
• Scope for contradictions and changes in accounts – difficult to
achieve analytical closure
• Relationship with participants becomes more intimate over time ‘unthinking disclosures’
• Difficult to exit from the research and the participants
28 June, 2016
Working with refugees
• Prior experience of presenting and ‘storying’ themselves
• Potential harm to themselves, their current situation or family
remaining in the country they fled from
• Potential negative consequences to refugees themselves and
broader refugee community
• Mindful of the context in which producing research and the
purpose of research
• Experience of trauma
• Focus on practical aspects rather than emotional aspects
28 June, 2016
The power of the researcher
‘And the trouble is that when we write about others…they have
been brought (by us) to say it, and in saying of it their lives may
have been changed. To speak of traumas hitherto unnamed …is
to solidify and consolidate in words a kind of life. And for this – in
a way - the researcher becomes responsible’
(Plummer 2001: 225)
28 June, 2016
Ethical debates and dilemmas
• Ethical framework or ground rules – informed consent, right to
withdraw ….
• Day-to-day processes of knowledge production throw up moral,
ethical and practical dilemmas
• Constant tension between different responsibilities – ourselves
as researcher, participant/narrator, significant others
(family/community/friends), the research (sanitised version?)
28 June, 2016
Learning and identity
• Movements across social space are moments of non-continuity –
uncertainty, questioning of self, reflection and learning
• Transformative Learning Theory (Mezirow 1994, 2000)
‘…the process by which we transform our taken-for-granted
frames of reference to make them more inclusive,
discriminating, open, emotionally capable of change …
(2000: 8)
28 June, 2016
Learning and identity
‘A feeling of disharmony with the life-world - sense of disjuncture remains the greatest learning need that individuals have so that they
can return to the original state of harmony’ (Jarvis 2006: 78)
Assumptions
• learning builds on previous learning, offers a more suitable frame of
reference, generally positive leads to ‘superior perspective’ (Mezirow)
• Adaption to new culture is developmental – sense of identity,
confidence and self esteem develops over time
28 June, 2016
Enlarging the concept of learning
• Hidden curriculum (good learning)
- Beliefs, expectations, norms, tacit assumptions and behaviours
• Realising what and who you are not (bad learning)
- Illegitimate capital / little of no exchange value, expectations of habitus, loss
of professional identity - social, financial status, respect.
- ‘Unlearning’ and identity deconstruction
• Illegal working and refugee identity (ugly learning)
- Policy and public discourses: circumstantial law breakers, refugee label,
morally problematic and pathological
28 June, 2016
‘Yes it was illegal, it was illegal. That's what I'm saying I'm not sure whether they
didn't know that this was illegal because obviously they didn't even see my
passport, but they still gave me a job. … Every day you thank God after every
shift because you know because you've worked you’re going to be paid for it…I
didn't even have a bank account, I was using this lady, who I used to live with, I
was using her bank account. She gave me her card, so I was using her card at
the ATM…Not even anybody back home can ever imagine me or anyone doing
that. … There's no way you can actually make anyone understand what you
went through. There's no way. The lies that you tell, the anxiety, oh goodness,
it was really… its funny looking back now and you think ‘My goodness, how did I
do all that, how did I get away with that?’ It is a very long time to wait. You don't
want to go back there to being an illegal and having your boss there asking for
your passport every other week or every other day.’
Patricia
28 June, 2016
‘I think it was a big worry if people asked me ‘what are you doing
here?’ What can I say because, like I am a refugee but I have got
respect for myself, I don’t want to be down in front of people… So
I prefer not telling them why I am here and what for… They never
say this refugee did something good. Everything what they say
about refugees is bad.’
Savalan
28 June, 2016
‘As a refugee I felt you are living somewhere that you don’t belong to.
Especially English people; they are not very interested with
communicating with…I can’t say foreign people, it’s asylum seekers.
What can I say…there is not a good perception of refugees, the view is
not good of refugees. May be there is a definition of refugees as people
who come to this country for benefits and unfortunately the very, very
little cases it’s true, but we can’t expand it to everyone. When I speak to
English people the first question they ask me is ‘When do you intend to
go back?’ What can I say? I think English people trust the media. It
affects people.’
Farideh
28 June, 2016
Learning to be a refugee
• Interlocking messages from immigration policy, education
strategies and public discourses shaped the transformative and
learning experience
• Learning involves epistemological processes – changing how the
world is perceived, how they made sense of the world.
• Raises fundamental ontological issues about who and what they
could be in the world
• Recognition of potential negative outcomes of learning on identity
and conceptions of self.
28 June, 2016
References
Bloch, A. (2002) Refugee's Opportunities and Barriers in Employment and
Training. Report for Department for Work and Pensions. DWP, Leeds.
Jarvis, P. (2006) Towards a comprehensive theory of human learning, Lifelong
Learning and the Learning Society, Vol. 1 (Oxon, Routledge).
Mezirow, J. (1994) Understanding transformation theory. Adult Education
Quarterly, 44(4), 222-232
Mezirow, J. (2000) Learning as transformation, (San Francisco, Jossey-Bassey).
Morrice, L. (2011) Being a refugee: Learning and identity. A longitudinal study of
refugees in the UK, (Stoke on Trent, Trentham Books Ltd).
Plummer, K. (2001) Documents of Life 2. An invitation to a critical humanism.
London, Sage.
Plumridge, L., and Thomson, R. (2003) Longitudinal qualitative studies and the
reflexive self. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 6(3), 213222.
28 June, 2016